A Forgivable Genocide (Part 2 - Jordan)
By Bob Nelson
After the creation of the Emirate of Transjordan in the early 1920s as a British satellite alongside the "Palestine Mandate", things were fairly quiet all th e way to the Second World War. The British slowly granted more and more authority to Emir Abdullah's administration, ultimately keeping only foreign and military affairs.
A steady influx of Jewish immigrants into Palestine (they were forbidden entry to Tra nsjordan) led to rising Arab resentment, and ultimately to a revolt 1936-1939, with thousands dead. To calm Arab anger, the British put relatively tight limits on Jewish immigration to Palestine.
On the diplomatic front, it was clear that Transjordan would be excluded from any new Jewish state to be created in Palestine, east of the Jordan. It was not at all clear, however, what the relationship would be between the Emirate and the Muslim portion of Palestine. There were several possibilities:
- The Emira te might be expanded to include Muslim portions of Palestine.
- A new Muslim state might englobe Muslim portions of Palestine and the Emirate.
- There might be two separate states: an unchanged Transjordan and a new Muslim Palestinian state.
- All Mu slim Palestinians might be moved to Transjordan, leaving all land west of the Jordan for the Jews.
There were partisans for each of these solutions, and each was possible, even the last one, which seems outlandish today. The breakup of the defeated Austro -Hungarian Empire after the Great War created a number of small, ethnically (almost) homogeneous countries. Hundreds of thousands of people were displaced in (failed) efforts to make those new counties completely homogeneous.
Diplomats tried to improve the chances of their preferred solution, but none really dominated. In general, the British avoided getting sucked into any actual realization of a Jewish state. Why? Perhaps from loyalty to their Arab allies. Perhaps they feared that a Jewish state would bri ng conflict and that they would get caught in the crossfire. Perhaps from anti-Semitism. Perhaps from a bit of all of those...
The Emirate of Transjordan became the Hashemite Kingdom of Transjordan in May 1946.
World War Two... and the Holocaust... had cha nged everything. The creation of a Jewish state became inevitable and urgent.
The British made a quick effort at finding a universally acceptable solution, saw that there was none... and threw in the towel. They asked to be relieved of the mandate, and ann ounced that they would pull out.
The UN looked at several solutions, and in 1947 decided that partition was the least bad. The UN plan was a compromise. Like all compromises it can be seen as good or bad for each stakeholder, depending on the criteria appl ied.
The UN plan was accepted by the Jews and refused by surrounding Arab nations. The opinion of the local Arabs is unknown, because no one asked them. Violence broke out even before Britain's mandate ended. Israel declared its independence, on the basis of the UN partition. War ensued.
The Arabs lost. ... But not all the Arabs... King Abdullah's British-trained Arab Legion occupied what was to become known as the West Bank. Abdullah's domain was renamed the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan, and the West Bank was annexed.
Tags
Who is online
140 visitors

Hummm 8 views yet lots of opinions about this issue. Shocker!
And that issue has not been settled to any degree even today . The fact that there is still much bloodshed between the West Bank Arabs and the residents of the Gaza strip apparently will not be settled any time soon .
I personally find it hopeful that there is a lack of unity . It seems that the desire for a winner-take-all approach prevents unity & also prevents a country from forming there . Even if the Jews disappeared from the region there would still be those 2 factions fighting & killing each other .
Which brings up some interesting points:
1. Israel has totally withdrawn from Gaza-- there's not a Jew in the entire place! And all those settlements in Gaza? You know-- the ones that were supposedly "a permanent obstacle to peace"? Well, they no longer exist!!!
However, what people often miss when discussing the total Israeli withdrawal from Gaza (2005) -is this: The "Palestinians now have total self rule -- in Gaza.
2. You mentioned conflict between the Gazans and the West Bank Palestinians. But the fact is, the dominant cultural values in the Arab world today see violence as the preferred method of resolving disputes. (If the Arabs didn't haveJews to attack, they would attack Christians. if there are no nearby kuffar ("Infidels") to attack, they attack other Muslims. The Arab world is a violent place...
These events were the decisive factors that forced Britain to announce their desire to terminate the Palestine Mandate and place the Question of Palestine before the United Nations, the successor to the League of Nations . The UN created UNSCOP (the UN Special Committee on Palestine) on 15 May 1947, with representatives from 11 countries. UNSCOP conducted hearings and made a general survey of the situation in Palestine, and issued its report on 31 August. Seven members (Canada, Czechoslovakia , Guatemala, Netherlands, Peru , Sweden, and Uruguay ) recommended the creation of independent Arab and Jewish states, with Jerusalem to be placed under international administration . Three members (India, Iran , and Yugoslavia ) supported the creation of a single federal state containing both Jewish and Arab constituent states. Australia abstained.
On 29 November, the UN General Assembly, voting 33 to 13, with 10 abstentions, adopted a resolution recommending the adoption and implementation of the Plan of Partition with Economic Union as Resolution 181 (II) ., [38] while making some adjustments to the boundaries between the two states proposed by it. The division was to take effect on the date of British withdrawal. The partition plan required that the proposed states grant full civil rights to all people within their borders, regardless of race, religion or gender. It is important to note that the UN General Assembly is only granted the power to make recommendations, therefore, UNGAR 181 was not legally binding. [39] Both the U.S. and the Soviet Union supported the resolution. Haiti , Liberia, and the Philippines changed their votes at the last moment after concerted pressure from the U.S. and from Zionist organisations. [40] [41] [42] The five members of the Arab League , who were voting members at the time, voted against the Plan.
The Jewish Agency, which was the Jewish state-in-formation, accepted the plan, and nearly all the Jews in Palestine rejoiced at the news. Israeli history books mention 29 November as the most important date in the creation of Israel as it refers to UNGA 181 of 1947 Partition of the Mandate of Palestine into two states and whereof Israel's Proclamation of Independence refers to UNGA 181 as its source of sovereignty in Ph's 9 & 15. [ citation needed ]
The partition plan was rejected out of hand by Palestinian Arab leadership and by most of the Arab population. [qt 1] [qt 2] Meeting in Cairo on November and December 1947, the Arab League then adopted a series of resolutions aimed at a military solution to the conflict.
Britain announced that it would accept the partition plan, but refused to enforce it, arguing it was not accepted by the Arabs. Britain also refused to share the administration of Palestine with the UN Palestine Commission during the transitional period. In September 1947, the British government announced that the Mandate for Palestine would end at midnight on 14 May 1948. [43] [44] [45]
Looking forward to the next edition......