╌>

Would Switzerland's "Income for All" Proposal Work in the United States?

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  peter-loves-the-real-tea-party  •  13 years ago  •  9 comments

Would Switzerland's "Income for All" Proposal Work in the United States?

link

By Joshua M. Patton, Wed, November 13, 2013

With the troubled state of American entitlements, could the solution be to abolish them and replace it with a monthly stipend from the government for every citizen? Its a question examined by Annie Lowrey in The New York Times in an essay about how a new Swiss proposal to pay each citizen a monthly income regardless of their age or level of income might be applied in America. Lowrey says that these incomes are whispered about in the United States, where certain wonks on the libertarian right and liberal left have come to a strange convergence around the idea some prefer an unconditional basic income that would go out to everyone, no strings attached.

Lowrey also highlights the downsides of this proposal, which include the cost of the incomes and that it would be a massive disincentive to work for many. However some, like John Rawlsa political philosopher that might be labeled as liberal, although he assuredly sees himself as more middle-of-the-roadhave raised the reciprocity argument, suggesting that there will be a moral objection to giving people money with no guarantee that they will actually contribute to the economy in a meaningful way.

Lowreys article also cites the work of Evelyn Forget of the University of Manitoba whom she calls a health economist. Forgets research has shown that while poverty was reduced, [h]igh-school completion rates went up; hospitalization rates went down. Her argument being that basic community values would be positively affected by a social program like this.

It is undeniable that over the past few decades wages have been stagnant and the income gap between the wealthiest Americans and the middle-class has been widening with no signs of stoppage. This proposal might address that problem, but the claims have yet to be vetted by a number-crunching group like the Congressional Budget Office.

Discuss.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    13 years ago

Not agreeing with the idea, just trying to figure out how it would even work. Economically, who foots the bill when more people stop working and paying taxes?

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  Pedro    13 years ago

I tend to think people wont stop working. Some will, but they were going to stop working anyway most likely. It definitely puts people in a better position to care for themselves. Personally, I'd love to see a real return on my tax dollars....something that I can control and use for the betterment of my family and friends rather than rely on the government to tell me (or not even bother to tell me as the is really the case) how my tax dollars are being applied.

That said, I really havent researched it enough yet to have a real opinion, but on the surface, I like the concept.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    13 years ago

Personally, I'd love to see a real return on my tax dollars....something that I can control and use for the betterment of my family and friends rather than rely on the government to tell me (or not even bother to tell me as the is really the case) how my tax dollars are being applied.

Yeah, I could go for that.

For sure, this is social engineering on a grand scale. While I wonder what it would do to the communal work ethic (not really sure thatI agree or disagree with your analysis, I'll have to think on it some), I can see that it may also free-up would be artisans, allowing for greater freedom to pursue their endeavors.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

If that ambition is attaining wealth and this wealth is practically unattainable; then what ambition exists that will replace attaining wealth?

Isn't it obvious ?

5467_discussions.jpg

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  Pedro    13 years ago

Everybody turns into indestructible sponges who are afraid of everything?

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    13 years ago

The plain and simple reality is that we don't have enough jobs for everyone that wants one, and that isn't going to change for at least a generation given current trends.

Worse yet, we have many taking jobs that are well beneath them, thus we are under utilizing the available workforce's capability. (a form of waste)

Worse than that.... We have a good chunk of our population that does not have the necessary education level to participate in other than minimum wage jobs, and that chunk is growing. This is by design as it has always been cheaper to keep people on welfare than it is to train them for jobs that aren't there anyway as welfare is where they will end up in the long run.

Lastly.... minimum wage is not a living wage. Expect crime levels to increase.

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  Pedro    13 years ago

Minimum wage is not a living wage for a single provider. That is true. However, I feel some other aspects of your post are a little off. Here is what I'm thinking:

we don't have enough jobs for everyone that wants one

I disagree. There are actually a lot of jobs out there. This however ties somewhat into this next piece

we have many taking jobs that are well beneath them, thus we are under utilizing the available workforce's capability. (a form of waste)

I disagree with this also. There is no such thing as a job that is beneath you. It is all about need. We have more need for what would be considered untrained labor than any other thing. That is the same regardless of economic or social concerns. What happens though is that people thinkn jobs are beneath them, and so rather than take those jobs, people would rather get onto gov't dole and accept handouts funded by the workforce. This is further exacerbated by the fact that, since people wont take jobs that are beneath them in many cases, illegal/immigrant workers end up taking those jobs, and at a much lower wage than the people spurning such jobs would accept thus devaluing the entire workforce to the point where employers lower the expected wage for any such jobs. It is a vicious circle, economically speaking.

We have a good chunk of our population that does not have the necessary education level to participate in other than minimum wage jobs

The majority of jobs are jobs that can be filled by unskilled labor. More to the point though, unskilled labor is actually the backbone of any workforce. This has always been the way of things from the inception of societies until now, and will continue to be the same throughout the future of humanity. not everybody can be a doctor, and we tend to need far more ditch diggers than doctors, at least if we want things to at least maintain if not exceed expectations in a societal sense.

this is by design as it has always been cheaper to keep people on welfare than it is to train them for jobs that aren't there anyway as welfare is where they will end up in the long run.

Not really. It is always more affordable to train people for jobs. People end up on welfare mostly because they share the same defeatist attitude represented in the italicized post. Welfare ideally is only there to pick people back up when the worst happens. However, people tend to create the worst scenarios to justify giving up and ending up on welfare. While this isnt always the case, it is all too often the case.

What we really need to do is empower people, and in my opinion, boosting the income of all citizens provides a scenario wherein the day to day struggle is eased, thus making it easier to actually put forth a hard days work without the worry that doing so wont amount to much, thereby increasing the average workers daily output and productivity. A happy worker is a productive worker, as the old adage goes.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    13 years ago

There are study after study that says you are wrong about training people. Common sense should tell you the same.

And I think you are wrong headed about many things Pedro. I've finishing up being on business here in China for the last two weeks. In the China Daily this week, the government admits that only 6% of the people here are in jobs that are rewarding and challenging to them. The United States leads the rest of the world in that field at a rate of 27%. I worked as a carpenter to get me into college, done time as a roughneck in the oil fields, signed my life over to Uncle Sam for eight years, all with an eye of getting to be an engineer. Are you telling me that even with being an engineer that I should be happy cleaning toilets, and handing out fries?

There is much in your response that tells me that you really don't understand how the real world works. Your statement that is the real kicker "boosting the income of all citizens provides a scenario wherein the day to day struggle is eased" speaks volumes as to what you don't have a handle on. How many members of congress do you think you can convince of that statement, and more importantly, what is your plan to do just such cause I'm up for ideas.

Regards....

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  Pedro    13 years ago

I'm saying you have an obligation to do what you must, and if you need to clean toilets, you shouldnt feel superior to the task.

 
 

Who is online




124 visitors