The Obamacare Exchange Scorecard: Around 100,000 Enrollees And Five Million Cancellations
Avik Roy ,Contributor
In the market for individually-purchased health insurance, more than 4.8 million Americans have received notices that their preexisting plans are soon to be illegal, and will be cancelled. Many more cancellation notices are imminent. But yesterday, the Wall Street Journal obtained information regarding the number of people who have signed up for new private health coverage under Obamacare: 40,000 to 50,000 for the federal exchange, and 49,000 for 12 of the 14 state-based exchanges.
White House falls short of target by around 80%
Last month, the Associated Press published details of an internal Obama administration memo, dated September 5, detailing the White Houses monthly targets as to how many people would sign up for private insurance under Obamacares exchanges. We expect enrollment in the initial months to be low, said the September 5 memo. Through October, the administration estimated that 494,620 would sign up. They only got about a fifth of the way toward that lowball estimate.
So far, private health plans have received enrollment data for 40,000 to 50,000 users of the federal marketplace, write Christopher Weaver, Timothy Martin, and Louise Radnofsky in the Journal . Separately, 12 of the 14 states that are running their own exchanges have tallied roughly 49,000 enrollees.
Believe it or not, the enrollment data from the federal government may actually exaggerate the number of people who have signed up. The number represents enrollment date sent to insurers from the marketplace, but counts data sent to insurers from the marketplace.
One official told Amy Goldstein and Sarah Kliff of the Washington Post that the official figure will include people who have paid for a plan and those who simply picked a plan and put it in their shopping cart. Most private companies arent allowed to count as sales people who put items in their electronic shopping carts, but havent yet paid. But politics triumphs economics. Goldstein and Kliff write that, according to one person with knowledge of the figures, slightly fewer than 40,000 people had selected a [federal exchange-based] health plan as of last week.
Website unlikely to be ready by Nov. 30
Last Friday, in a briefing conducted by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid services, officials walked back a previous commitment to get the website fixed by the end of November. Its a critical date, without question, said one. But dont think of it as an unveiling date. The goal is to make significant improvements that day.
These officials picked November 30 as their self-imposed deadline because, without it, many of the Americans seeing their preexisting plans cancelled before January 1 wont be able to find Obamacare-compliant plans to replace them.
Juliet Eilperin and Amy Goldstein of the Washington Post report that insurers may be looking for extra subsidies in order to help the government out. One idea circulated within the insurance industry would be for HHS to approave a method to estimate subsidies and give preliminary tax credits based on those estimateswith the accurate amount determined later, once the system works better. But insurance industry leaders have said that they would insist on a guarantee that they would be compensated for any underpaymentsand that they have asked to keep any overpayments.
Fixing the website may take six months
Based on what weve seen to date from the administration, it appears likely that the website will take four to six months to function properly. The Obama administration should take the advice of the Democratic chairman of the Senate Finance Committee, Max Baucus (D., Mont.) and shut the thing down until they can fix it.
But the administration appears hell-bent on keeping the exchange open, because they want to enroll as many people into Obamacare before the Presidents term is up. That way, the law will become harder to repeal, even if Republicans win in 2016.
I get the political logic. But Americans are facing significant disruptions in the quality and consistency of their health coverage. Its this very mentality that caused the Obama administration to force-launch a website that wasnt ready for prime time. Its important for them to get it right.
Tags
Who is online
129 visitors

More like 40-50,000 enrollees compared to an expected 500,000.
Interactive ObamaCare Enrollment Map: 45,865 Have Selected Plans In 19 States, .7% Of Total
Excerpts:
Clearly these early versions of the government website were designed to give desperate people with existing conditions a foretaste of the lousy service they can expect in the future ...
will we find out the age distribution of those actually enrolled, how many were for medicare, etc?
dont hold your breath, this being the most "transparent administration in history" and all!
so do the 15 lib senators who are terrified and went to obama pleading he do something now get to be called terrorists who strap bombs to their chests, haters who want people to not have affordable healthcare, etc now too?
In addition to Bennet, Udall and Begich, attendees included the other Senate Democrats up in 2014: Cory Booker of New Jersey, Chris Coons of Delaware, Richard J. Durbin of Illinois, Al Franken of Minnesota, Kay Hagan of North Carolina, Mary L. Landrieu of Louisiana, Jeff Merkley of Oregon, Mark Pryor of Arkansas, Jack Reed of Rhode Island, Jeanne Shaheen of New Hampshire, Brian Schatz of Hawaii, Tom Udall of New Mexico and Mark Warner of Virginia. Ed Markey of Massachusetts, who is also up in 2014, did not attend because he was chairing a hearing on USAID and Peace Corps nominations.
After the meeting, the presidents trip to Texas was delayed about an hour. He is scheduled to give a speech on Obamacare and attend two high-dollar fund-raisers for the DSCC. Bennet boarded Marine One with him on the South Lawn and will make the trip.
The White House meeting came as Senate Democrats have grown increasingly concerned about the rollout, with Sen. Barbara A. Mikulski, D-Md., saying Tuesday that the early problems had created a crisis of confidence.
would obama have gotten this mess passed, and gotten re-elected if he had told people tens of thousands would loose their healthcare?
of course not.
transparency my ass
That includes me . Please enlighten us idiots ... we learn fast !
How many thousands have registered?
what, no directaccusations of hating ill people? (expecially poor minority females)
Wow ... such profanity . I'm shocked ...
That was an interesting reading link . As a statistician I would suggest that the projection of a single factor model into regions outside of the mass of data points is a dangerous practice . There is really no reason to assume the simple linear dependence on per capita GDP . In other words the US is in a class by itself . Linear regression cannot be depended on in such a situation . I'll need to read the rest of his links to get a concept of his explanation ...
I know we are all adults here, and profanity is part of life, but you really don't add anything to the point you are trying to make by lacing it with profane language.
Forbes' Dishonesty: An Avik Roy Hatchet-Job on the Affordable Care Act
Forbes published an article by Avik Roy about the Affordable Care Act (ACA) leading to healthcare premiums being more expensive for young Americans than they otherwise were. Avik Roy has been on CNBC slinging his bull-pucky to the Wall St. crowd, and the article has been circulating social media, scaring young-folks like myself into fearing the big-bad socialist takeover demon that is Obamacare. Like so many attacks on the ACA, this one is blatantly dishonest to anyone who knows anything about the main components about the law.
Roy's article compares barebones policies that were available pre-ACA. The coverage in any healthcare plan that would've been affordable to me pre-ACA was laughable. In the event of a legitimate health emergency, these plans would have left a millennial like myself bankrupt, regardless of if I had the insurance or not.
Compared to the exchange plans, these policies that would get me out of a legitimate health emergency without bankrupting me. The plans also include prescription coverage, preventative care, and copay plans. Roy's article is like comparing a scooter to a Mercedes-Benz and seething with righteous indignation because the big bad guv'ment made the CLK pricier than the Vespa.
In addition to the dishonesty of comparison, the article is dishonest about the actual cost to young Americans. It intentionally focuses on young americans premium costs without tabulating
a) premium support
b) state Medicaid eligibility, or
c) the costs saved on average by having 18-26 year olds on their parents' plans.
These are gigantic factors affecting the affordability of healthcare. Medicaid plans usually don't require any premium payment at all, as with parental plans. Premium support, of course, means that the government, now allegedly raising the cost of premiums, would mitigate the overall cost of the plan, up to 100% in some cases.
This isn't the only Obamacare hatchet-job that Forbes has run. Their objective, like the rest of the right-wing punditocracy dominating the core of the GOP at the moment, is to scare young people into not participating, and convince them that its against their interests. Its the only real way that the GOP can obstruct Obamacare before 2016.
Forbes shows us with this latest journalistic abortion how important media politics is. This is a continuation of the Chuck Todd media culture that doesn't feel the need to challenge weasel words, misleading statements, and outright lies that come out of politicians and other media outlets alike.
# Obamacare Success! Non-Fed Site Signups: 373,169 Exchange Applications/Enrollments 588,948 Medicaid
Fri Nov 08, 2013 at 09:13 AM PST
Official ACA Numbers: Expect between 40K - 400K Actual Enrollments
This is about Obama advisers, not hatchet wielders:
You swear like a sailor . What do you do when you make port ?
Jenni ,
You're right PERIOD !
the monarchy today declared that ins companies will be allowed to continue existing policies until after the election.
it appears the insurance industry just stopped getting a lubricant application before getting _________.
will be interesting to see how much faster carriers now drop out of the market (the lefts goal, all along)
Careful what you wish for!
The Real Story Behind the Phony Canceled Health Insurance Scandal
Go to the link and see what the Republicans and Blue Dog Democrats have assured for those not likely to have read their junk policies!
Max Baucus is a Republican thru and thru. He votes republican lies Republican and is a Repuglican. The only thing Democratic about Mix Bucus is the money he used to run for office and the monicer he uses to get elected.
Maybe . Or maybe it was designed to fail ...
I am eager to read details , especially if they include photographic support ...
i enjoyed newts 2 cents on crossfire:
in less time than it took the administration to launch obamacare...we were able to defeat the nazi's, the japanese, free europe and the pacific!