╌>

ObamaCare Takes on Water --Peggy Noonan --It's not just a buggy website, it's a disaster of Titanic proportions.-WSJ -- Oct. 24, 2013

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  len  •  13 years ago  •  44 comments

ObamaCare Takes on Water --Peggy Noonan --It's not just a buggy website, it's a disaster of Titanic proportions.-WSJ -- Oct. 24, 2013

We should not lose The Headline in the day-to-day headlines. This is big history, not small. The ObamaCare rollout is a disaster for the White House, not a problem or a challenge or an embarrassment, not a gaffe or a bad few weeks. It is a political disaster, and the only question is whether it is partially recoverable, meaning the system can be made to work in a generally satisfactory way in the next few weeks. Butit has to be repeatedthey had 3 years after passage of the Affordable Care Act to make the program into something the American people could register for and feel they were benefiting from. Three and a half years! They had a long-declared start date: It would all go live Oct. 1, 2013, and everyone in the government, every contractor and consultant, knew it. The president put the meaning of his presidency into the programit informally carries his name, it is his brand. It was unveiled with great fanfare, and it didn't work. For almost anybody. Crashed systems, frozen screens, phone registration that prompted you back to the site that sent you to the 800 number, like a high-tech Mbius strip.

All this from the world's greatest, most technologically sophisticated nation, the one that invented the computer and the Internet. And from a government that is able to demand and channel a great deal of the people's wealth.

So you'd think it would sort of work. And it didn't. Which is a disaster.

Even though it's huge, and those who are reporting the story every day are, by and large, seasoned and have seen a few things, no one seems to know how it will end. Because it's new territory. Does anyone believe the whole technological side can be fixed quickly? No. The president may eventually accept a brief delay in implementationit is almost unbelievable that he will notbut does anyone think that the economics of the ACA, the content as set out and expressed on the sites, will flow smoothly, coherently, and fully satisfy the objectives of expanding health-insurance coverage while lowering its cost? You might believe that, but early reports of sticker shock, high deductibles and cancelled coverage are not promising. Does anyone think the president will back off and delay the program for enough time not only to get the technological side going but seriously improve the economics? No. So we're not only in the middle of a political disaster, we're in the middle of a mystery. What happens if this whole thing continues not to work? What do we do then?

It hardly matters if anyone is fired. That's the fifth paragraph in the Wikipedia history, or the 10th. Yes, a firing would be good democratic form, and it would acknowledge the idea of accountabilitysomeone or some persons failed on a historic level and were removed. It would take some heat off the White House"Look, we're doing something!"so it's surprising they haven't done it and odd the Republicans are clamoring for it. But who would want to be the new HHS secretary? Who would take that job?

It was Bill Daleyaccomplished political player, former mayor of Chicago and, most killingly, former chief of staff of President Obama, who Thursday, on "CBS This Morning," admitted the scale of the problem. Asked whether Kathleen Sebelius should be fired, he said: "To me that's kind of like firing Captain Smith on the Titanic after it hit the iceberg."

The Titanic. Some will see his comments as disloyal. Actually they were candid and realistic. Although in fairness, the Titanic at least had three good days, and Edward Smith chose to go down with the ship.

He didn't deny the waters were icy; he failed to slow his ship, failed to show heightened concern. Mrs. Sebelius did not show overwhelming confidence in the days before the debutthere was no "God himself couldn't sink this program." She repeated her lines in a way that seemed almost furtive, appearing not confident but confused, and almost guiltily stubborn. Her message was almost always the same: There are no icebergs ahead.

Norman Ornstein in National Journal this week reminds us of Democratic Sen. Max Baucus's iceberg warningactually "train wreck"at a hearing six months ago, in April. He warned implementation of ObamaCare could be a disaster. He told Mrs. Sebelius: "I understand you've hired a contractor. I'm just worried that that's going to be money down the drain because contractors like to make money more than they like to do anything else. That's their job." A lot of agencies are involved, he said, people are going to get confused, more simplicity is needed.

He was right. I happened to reread his warning while the House Energy and Commerce Committee questioned the four major contractors on the ObamaCare sites. The most pertinent query came from Rep. Marsha Blackburn, who asked the contractors to put on paper, and under oath, exactly how much money they had made from the federal government so far, and exactly how much they stand to make now, as they fix the sites, and in the future.

There are more questions on the failure to launch. Did Mrs. Sebelius and her top staffers know that the system was not ready and likely to fail? If they knew, did they not tell the White House? If they didn't know, how did it happen that they didn't? If the White House knew of the likelihood of a coming failure, why did they go full steam ahead? And if they didn't know, why?

Was there some degree of fabulism, or magical thinking, or reliance on blind luck within the White House and the greater administration? Many important people in the administration, and those contracting with it from the outside, would have had to ignore various signs of a coming failure. Did some of them know or have reason to know problems were both present and coming, and mislead or fail to inform their peers or superiors?

And there is the enduring mystery of why the president, who in his career has attempted to persuade the American people to have greater faith in and reliance on the federal government's ability to help, continues to go forward with an astounding lack of interest in the reputation of government.

He talks but he doesn't implement, never makes it work. He allows the IRS under his watch to be humiliated by scandal, waste, ill judgements prompted by ideological assumptions. He allows his signature program, the one that will make his name in the history books, to debut in failure. In response he says bland, rounded words that leave you wondering what just got said.

We're all reading of Jack Kennedy. He stayed up nights with self-recrimination after failure. "How could I have been so stupid?" he asked about the Bay of Pigs. A foreseeable mistake and he'd blown it, listened to the wrong people, made the wrong judgments. That man suffered over his missteps. He worried about his reputation, and the reputation of his government, and of America.

It is disorienting to not see this in a president. It is another thing about this story that feels not only historic, but historically strange.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     13 years ago

The question that I have is..Are the taxpayers going to have to pay for the repair of the system, or is it ''getting it right'', covered in the original contract?

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    13 years ago

Obamacare is a failure Barb. Even government sponsored NPR admits it.

 
 
 
brightstarone
Freshman Silent
link   brightstarone    13 years ago

ObamaCare Takes on Water --Peggy Noonan --It's not just a buggy website, it's a disaster of Titanic proportions.-WSJ -- Oct. 24, 2013

We should not lose The Headline in the day-to-day headlines. This is big history, not small. The ObamaCare rollout is a disaster for the White House, not a problem or a challenge or an embarrassment, not a gaffe or a bad few weeks. It is a political disaster,

Hey you know what else was a political disaster when it first came out ..... Medicare and Social Security, but history has proven that large complex programs like these start out with a few bugs and miss-steps that eventually are worked out and the programs end up doing their job and become very popular with the American people.

...and the only question is whether it is partially recoverable, meaning the system can be made to work in a generally satisfactory way in the next few weeks.

I can't say how much time it will take to work out the bugs but I have no doubt that it will work out in the end; and it will become more popular with the American People as the real benefits are revealed and the fear-mongering bullshit from the extremist rightfades away.

Butit has to be repeatedthey had 3 years after passage of the Affordable Care Act to make the program into something the American people could register for and feel they were benefiting from.

Along with that it should also be repeated that we have had 3 & 1/2 years of Republican Obstructionism and sabotage with many states controlled by Republicans sabotaging the implementation of the ACA.

three and a half years! They had a long-declared start date: It would all go live Oct. 1, 2013, and everyone in the government, every contractor and consultant, knew it. The president put the meaning of his presidency into the programit informally carries his name, it is his brand. It was unveiled with great fanfare, and it didn't work. For almost anybody. Crashed systems, frozen screens, phone registration that prompted you back to the site that sent you to the 800 number, like a high-tech Mbius strip.

OMG - this ACA will never ever get this straighten outor towork properly, we are doomed to failure:

THE SKY IS FALLING!!!

... (people screaming in horror and going crazy .. 43.gif 115.gif 116.gif 118.gif 35.gif 17.gif 12.gif 7.gif 40.gif 63.gif 47.gif 109.gif 102.gif

All this from the world's greatest, most technologically sophisticated nation, the one that invented the computer and the Internet. And from a government that is able to demand and channel a great deal of the people's wealth.

Just goes to show how much damage Republican Obstructionism and their scorched earth partisanpolitics of "make Obama fail" at all cost "make the ACA his waterloo" can sabotage the most technologically sophisticated nation, the one that invented the computer and the Internet.

So you'd think it would sort of work. And it didn't.

It would have if the Republican Extremist had behaved in an honorable non-partisan way for the good of the American people they are suppose to serve, instead of their special interest corporate masters that they do serve.

Which is a disaster.

I agree Republican Partisan Politics have been a disaster for our country, maybe that disaster will be straightened out in the next few election cycles beginning in 2014.Grin.gif

Even though it's huge, and those who are reporting the story every day are, by and large, seasoned and have seen a few things, no one seems to know how it will end.

Well going by past big government program roll outs that ended up working after a shaky start;I think that it is not a big a mystery as you make it out to be.

But then again the whole article is a phony fear-mongering anti Obama hit piece against the ACA. 44.gif

What else is new.106.gif

Because it's new territory. Does anyone believe the whole technological side can be fixed quickly? No.

I couldn't say when it will be fixed but I do know that it will be fixed and it will run as smoothly as Social Security does today. It is interesting that you said it won't be fixed soon, instead of saying it can't be fixed at all.39.gif

The president may eventually accept a brief delay in implementationit is almost unbelievable that he will not

I don't think he will delay implementation.68.gif

but does anyone think that the economics of the ACA, the content as set out and expressed on the sites, will flow smoothly, coherently, and fully satisfy the objectives of expanding health-insurance coverage while lowering its cost? You might believe that,

Yes I do believe that.101.gif

but early reports of sticker shock, high deductibles and cancelled coverage are not promising. Does anyone think the president will back off and delay the program for enough time not only to get the technological side going but seriously improve the economics? No. So we're not only in the middle of a political disaster, we're in the middle of a mystery. What happens if this whole thing continues not to work? What do we do then?

Gee I guess we're all doomed, hold me I'm so afraid. When will the FEMA concentration camps and grandmother killing begin???117.gif

It hardly matters if anyone is fired. That's the fifth paragraph in the Wikipedia history, or the 10th. Yes, a firing would be good democratic form, and it would acknowledge the idea of accountabilitysomeone or some persons failed on a historic level and were removed. It would take some heat off the White House"Look, we're doing something!"so it's surprising they haven't done it and odd the Republicans are clamoring for it. But who would want to be the new HHS secretary? Who would take that job?

I hope the Republican Tea Party Extremist Nut Jobs will be fired in the next few election cycles and then maybe the American people will get back a government that actually governs.69.gif

It was Bill Daleyaccomplished political player, former mayor of Chicago and, most killingly, former chief of staff of President Obama, who Thursday, on "CBS This Morning," admitted the scale of the problem. Asked whether Kathleen Sebelius should be fired, he said: "To me that's kind of like firing Captain Smith on the Titanic after it hit the iceberg."

The Titanic. Some will see his comments as disloyal. Actually they were candid and realistic. Although in fairness, the Titanic at least had three good days, and Edward Smith chose to go down with the ship.

He didn't deny the waters were icy; he failed to slow his ship, failed to show heightened concern. Mrs. Sebelius did not show overwhelming confidence in the days before the debutthere was no "God himself couldn't sink this program." She repeated her lines in a way that seemed almost furtive, appearing not confident but confused, and almost guiltily stubborn. Her message was almost always the same: There are no icebergs ahead.

Norman Ornstein in National Journal this week reminds us of Democratic Sen. Max Baucus's iceberg warningactually "train wreck"at a hearing six months ago, in April. He warned implementation of ObamaCare could be a disaster. He told Mrs. Sebelius: "I understand you've hired a contractor. I'm just worried that that's going to be money down the drain because contractors like to make money more than they like to do anything else. That's their job." A lot of agencies are involved, he said, people are going to get confused, more simplicity is needed.

He was right. I happened to reread his warning while the House Energy and Commerce Committee questioned the four major contractors on the ObamaCare sites. The most pertinent query came from Rep. Marsha Blackburn, who asked the contractors to put on paper, and under oath, exactly how much money they had made from the federal government so far, and exactly how much they stand to make now, as they fix the sites, and in the future.

There are more questions on the failure to launch. Did Mrs. Sebelius and her top staffers know that the system was not ready and likely to fail? If they knew, did they not tell the White House? If they didn't know, how did it happen that they didn't? If the White House knew of the likelihood of a coming failure, why did they go full steam ahead? And if they didn't know, why?

Was there some degree of fabulism, or magical thinking, or reliance on blind luck within the White House and the greater administration? Many important people in the administration, and those contracting with it from the outside, ..... blah ... blah ... blah .... blah 76.gif

Well you got all your talking point wordsand your exaggerated hyperbolic doom and gloom propaganda rant out, funny though I don't think all the propaganda bullshit from the Obama Hate Machine will succeed. I think in the end as always the Obama Presidency will succeed and the American People will be better off for it.

How sad for you.....115.gif

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

Patriotic Americans opposed Obama and his abortion of a socialistic, inoperable, so-called medical plan.

Is Peggy Noonan less patriotic than you???

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

More and more Democrats are admitting it as the other seed shows.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

Social security passed in Congress by a ten-to-one vote -- Medicare by three-to-one. Both were bipartisan.

Not a single Republican voted for ObamaCare and many Democrats were bribed to vote for it at a time when Congress should have been worrying about jobs.

The bill has over 2000 pages that Nancy Pelosi likely still has not read (let alone the president), the regulations are over 22,000 pages, and the computer program has over 50-million lines of code.

If the cost of passing and (non-)implementing it had instead been distributed to the 18 or 30-million uninsured everyone would be better off.

Don't even think of comparing those acts.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

The biggest bubble is the one the Democrats and their leader live in.

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   CM    13 years ago

This is what bugs the $h!t out of me. why do people who are receiving so called Govt. Medical Care, so opposed to others who are working taxpaying citizens, making too much $$$ to qualify for medicaid and too little to afford health insurance on their own, why are the ones receiving their medical care from those same poor taxpayers, so opposed to those people receiving some assistance in seeing a doctor??? Here is what I say, if Govt. Medical Care recipients had any pride, you would drop out of your Govt. Medical Care and go buy Private health insurance on your own, you like to receive but not to give, I think those people are the blood suckers, not the ones who are working and paying for those Govt. medical care recipients care...When I get to the age of qualification to receive Medicare and I find myself so indignant and disgusted of poor people and do not want to see them in my sight, I will not take that free medicare that I am relying on younger, healthier people to pay into to keep my benefits coming and go buy private health insurance on my own...This Obamacare was set up for all Americans, not just for some, all Americans needs to be healthy and productive, A healthy Nation makes a Healthy and Productive People...

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   CM    13 years ago

Not a single Republican voted for ObamaCare and many Democrats were bribed to vote for it at a time when Congress should have been worrying about jobs.

That's because the obstructionist Republican party did what they always do, Obstruct, and the bribing, did you mean just like Mitch McConnell's bride of $3Billion to re-open the Govt. that the Republicans shut down?? Is that the kind of bribe you are speaking of??McConnell should be ashamed, taking $$$$ to do his duty and taking charge of his party, shameful!!! See, people who live in glass houses, shouldn't throw stones..

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   CM    13 years ago

Hi Mike, not at all, but since 2008, there has been Zero (~0~ )corporation in any legislation brought up by the Democrats, The Republicans have not done anything to move the country forward in any shape or fashion, there has been a standstill in Washington DC and obvious resentment, that type of obstruction has to end on both sides..This is the thing, if Republicans do not like Obamacare, they have had three years to write their own health plan and present it, instead, they have voted to repeal 42 times and not once made a bill to replace with something they deemed better, they just want to get rid of it, not considering there are approximately 50,000,000 uninsured Americans who needs to get medical care...

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    13 years ago
Noonan is great. Just a masterful eviceration of an indifferent president and a dysfunctional adminstration. This sums up the adminstration about as well as can be done in two paragraphs:"And there is the enduring mystery of why the president, who in his career has attempted to persuade the American people to have greater faith in and reliance on the federal government's ability to help, continues to go forward with an astounding lack of interest in the reputation of government.He talks but he doesn't implement, never makes it work. He allows the IRS under his watch to be humiliated by scandal, waste, ill judgements prompted by ideological assumptions. He allows his signature program, the one that will make his name in the history books, to debut in failure. In response he says bland, rounded words that leave you wondering what just got said."
 
 
 
brightstarone
Freshman Silent
link   brightstarone    13 years ago

Len regarding reply:

Social security passed in Congress by a ten-to-one vote -- Medicare by three-to-one. Both were bipartisan.

It has been well established that the Republicans political strategy has been to answer every non-partisan attempt from President Obama to work with them; with Vitriolic Partisan Obstruction.

What does that have to do with what I said and how does that equate with what happened 78 years ago, with the social security vote in the 1930's during the FDR Presidency.

Not a single Republican voted for ObamaCare ....

Uh yeah .... that is that Republican Obstruction thingy that I was talking about.

...and many Democrats were bribed to vote for it at a time when Congress should have been worrying about jobs.

So many Democrats were bribed to vote for the ACA?........ this is news to me.... so how many is many? and since when have Republicans been worried about jobs?

The Republicans have been workingto stop millions of un-insured Americans from getting affordable health-insurance, and they have been working to suppress the vote so that their unpopular party and un-American polices have a better chance of winning elections, and they have been working to Obstruct everything Obama, and they have been working to take away a women's right to have control and say so over her own body....... etc... etc...etc..

But they most certainly have not been working to create good American jobs.

That they have ignored completely, while at the same time claiming that they care about job's, job's, job's.

The bill has over 2000 pages that Nancy Pelosi likely still has not read (let alone the president), the regulations are over 22,000 pages, and the computer program has over 50-million lines of code.

Wow ... that is amazing, a complicated government bill ...... that has never ever happened before in the entirehistory of the American Political System, that must mean that this bill is bad.

If the cost of passing and (non-)implementing it had instead been distributed to the 18 or 30-million uninsured everyone would be better off.

And what does that irrelevant supposition have to do with the discussion?

Don't even think of comparing those acts.

First off Len, ...

....don't tell me what to do or think.

I will compare what ever I deem appropriate to compare.

You don't control that.

Second, ...

I will compare it again word for word:

Hey you know what else was a political disaster when it first came out ..... Medicare and Social Security, but history has proven that large complex programs like these start out with a few bugs and miss-steps that eventually are worked out and the programs end up doing their job and become very popular with the American people.

For good measure I will give you another comparison Len:

When Buffoon Bush's Medicare part D was rolled out it was a disaster with a lot of glitch's and mistakes, and many Republicans defended it saying that it was expected and a historical precedent that large complex government programs have problems in the beginning that straighten out and become better as it continues to be implemented and corrections are made until it runs smoothly.

Those same republicans who said all this back in 2006 are now in their partisan hypocrisy screaming that the sky is fallinglike chicken little and complainingaboutwhat a horrible irreversible train wreck this ACA roll out is.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

The Obama cabal really screwed this online sign-up thing, most royally. Idiots or were they? Suppose they deliberately screwed up. Considering the underhandedness of this administration, anything is possible.

Still, I find it disingenuous (or insincere, dishonest, untruthful, false, deceitful) that the republicans would be so concerned about the technological problems for Americans to sign-up online for Obamacare; the one thing they hate more than minorities, that they would make a public issue of it.

The stench of insincerity by the GOP reeks of flatulent ammonia.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

Its an amazing list of pork and bribes to pass Obamacare, even for an old pro like Reid:

The multimillion-dollar deals cut with Sen. Ben Nelson (D-Neb.) and others to win the 60 votes needed for the historic health care reform bill gave President Barack Obama the margin he needed to fulfill a central campaign promise but may also have upped the ante for future presidential horse trading.

With the bill hanging in the balance, Nelson won a provision exempting his state from paying the usual share of costs for new Medicaid patients. The deal critics have dubbed the Cornhusker Kickback is expected to cost the federal government $100 million over 10 years.

Before a close vote last month, Sen. Mary Landrieu (D-La.) won an even larger break for her state an estimated $300 million in extra federal spending, in a move opponents derided as the Louisiana Purchase.

Some critics branded the special deals as functionally equivalent to the kind of earmarks Obama crusaded against as a senator and a quantum leap from eleventh-hour deals Obamas predecessors have cut.

Lets take a look at the list itself, which goes far beyond Nelson and Landrieu, the pair that IBD Editorials calls the Louisiana Purchase and Omaha Stakes:

The bill contains unfunded mandates to states through the expansion of Medicaid but this time with new special treatment for the states of Nebraska , Vermont, and Massachusetts . These states will receive Federal Matching Assistance Percentages (FMAP) bonuses such that:

  1. Nebraska will receive 100% FMAP for newly eligibles indefinitely , making it the only state where the federal government will pay for all new enrollees. CBO estimated the cost to the federal government (additional funds to Nebraska) would be $100 million, which may look small compared to the other deals negotiated, yet over the long-term will cost far more, since funding continues indefinitely.
  2. Vermont will receive a 2.2% FMAP increase for 6 years for their entire program, thus receiving an additional $600 million over ten years.
  3. Massachusetts will receive a 0.5% FMAP increase for three years for the entire program, thus receiving an additional $500 million over ten years.
  • Despite $120 billion in Medicare Advantage cuts, the Managers Amendment found a way for Florida residents, as well as some individuals in Pennsylvania and New York, and potentially Oregon , to be grandfathered out of receiving the cuts.
  • Dorgan and Conrads protections for frontier states provision would, starting in 2011, establish a 1.0 hospital wage index and geographic practice expense floors for hospitals and physicians located in states where at least 50% of the counties in the state are frontier. Not surprisingly, states that qualify and benefit from the provision are Montana , South Dakota, North Dakota, Utah, and Wyoming.

Of the many problems with these sweetheart deals, is the door it leaves wide open for more federal involvement and financing of state-based entitlement programs. Sen. Harkin said it best when he stated In 2017, as you know, when we have to start phasing back from 100%, and going down to 98%, they are going to say, Wait, there is one state that stays at 100? And every governor in the country is going to say, Why doesnt our state stay there?When you look at it, I thought well, god, good, it is going to be the impetus for all the states to stay at 100%. So he [Nelson] might have done all of us a favor.

Changes for Sen. Ben Nelson (Nebraska)

  • Nelson secured more than just 100% federal funding for Nebraskas Medicaid expansion, the list of sweeteners (also called the Cornhusker kickback by Senate Republicans) includes:
    • An exemption from the insurance tax for Nebraska non-profit insurers, with language written in a way that only applies to Mutual of Omaha Insurance Company and Blue Cross Blue Shield Plans (BCBS) of Nebraska (and Michigan). According to news reports , Nelsons office states that BCBS would pay between $15 million and $20 million less in fees under the Senate bill than it would have without a change.
    • An exemption from taxes for Medicare supplemental (Medigap) insurance providers. Specifically, Mutual of Omaha, will not have to pay taxes on Medigap insurance, while reports also indicate that this tax break will be extended to other companies.
    • Some changes requested by Nelson would benefit people across the country, such as the inflation adjustment to the $2,500 cap on tax-exempt contributions to Flexible Savings Accounts (FSAs) and exemptions for nearly 55 physician-owned hospitals that have a provider agreement to participate in Medicare by August 1, 2010 (pushed back from February 1, 2010).

Changes for Sen. Levin (Michigan)

  • According to reports, Like Nelson, Levin sought an exemption from the $6 billion annual fee for non-profits, as non-profit insurers make up 76% of industry profits, but drew opposition from liberals. Ultimately, Levin got an exemption from the insurance tax for Michigan non-profit insurers, with language written in a way that applies to Blue Cross Blue Shield Plans (BCBS) of Michigan (and Nebraska).
  • Furthermore, the amendment changes the extension of section 508 hospital provisions so that hospitals in Michigan (as well as Connecticut) have the option to benefit under them if it means higher payments.

Changes for Sen. Landrieu (Louisiana):

  • Landrieu was one of the first Senators to secure a sweetheart deal, aptly nicknamed the Louisiana Purchase; she traded her support for bringing the bill to the floor for a $300 million increase in Medicaid funding for Louisiana . The underlying bill was cryptically written to increase federal Medicaid subsidies for certain states recovering from a major disaster during the past 7 years that have been declared a major disaster area and is meant to replenish the decrease in federal money resulting from an abnormally inflated per capita income in Louisiana following Hurricane Katrina. This was due to an influx of insurance dollars, federal grants and increased labor wages.

Changes for Sen. Sanders (Vermont) :

  • In addition the Vermont FMAP increase, the amendment includes a provision pushed by Sanders to provide an additional $10 billion in funding for community health centers and the National Health Services Corps which he argues would provide primary care to 25 million more people.

Changes for Sen. Bill Nelson (Florida)

As noted above, Nelson was able to secure a deal to keep Medicare Advantage plans enrollees in Florida grandfathered in. Notably, when McCain tried to offer an amendment to allow all enrollees to be grandfathered in, 57 Democrats voted against it.

Changes for Hawaii: The Managers Amendment singles out Hawaii as the only state to receive a Disproportionate Share Hospital (DSH) extension.

Changes for Sen. Lieberman (Connecticut): It amends the extension of section 508 hospital provisions so that hospitals in Connecticut (as well as Michigan) have the option to benefit under them if it means higher payments.

Changes for Sen. Dodd (Connecticut): It was a mystery until just revealed that Chris Dodds state will benefit from a cryptically awarded $100 million for a Health Care Facility at a public research university that contains a states sole public academic medical and dental schoolcriteria designed to apply to the University of Connecticut.

Changes for Sen. Baucus (Montana):

Baucus secured a pilot program in the amendment to provide innovative approaches to furnishing comprehensive, coordinated, and cost-effective care to certain qualified individuals. A qualified individual is an environmental exposure affected individualwho resides in or around the geographic area subject to an emergency declaration made as of June 17, 2009. And who might these select few individuals be? Well, according to EPA , On June 17, 2009, EPA Administrator Lisa Jackson issued a Public Health Emergency (PHE) finding at the Libby Asbestos Superfund site in northwest Montana. This provision would help residents of Libby by allowing them to sign up for Medicare benefits.

 
 
 
brightstarone
Freshman Silent
link   brightstarone    13 years ago

Len, regarding reply:

What does any of that have to do with what we were discussing?

We were discussing the initial glitch's and problems with the roll out of the ACA.

You're trying to sell the latest talking point propaganda against Obama-care.

Which is that the ACA is a total failure because the roll out has problems and is not going smoothly, so because of the shaky roll out of Obama-care then, according to your logic Health-care reform itself is no good.

That is a bogus argument and the typical propaganda talking pointdistortion that has no merit or truth to it because as I pointed out; the roll out of Obama-care is separate from Obama-care itself and all large complex government programs historically have had problems in the beginning when they were first rolled out,which eventuallywere corrected and ended up working just fine and becoming very popular and well liked by the majority of American People.

And I sighted examples of this:

Social Security, Medicare, The Perscription Drug Program part D.

Your latest reply is a re-hash of the anti Obama-care talking point arguments that have been heard many times before and have nothing to do with our discussion regarding the complexity of large government programs and the inevitable glitch's that come when large programs like these are first rolled out.

You can keep repeating the same arguments against the Affordable Care Act, but guess what, it is the LAW and it is CONSTITUTIONAL.

Willard ~the liar~ Romney ran on a platform to defund Obama-care and the American People rejected him and re-elected President Obama.

The Affordable Care Act is here to stay, and all the right wing propaganda bullshit will not make it go away.

The glitch's of the Obama-care roll out will be corrected and the program will continue forward and eventually become very popular just like Social Security and Medicare and the prescription drug program did.

 
 
 
brightstarone
Freshman Silent
link   brightstarone    13 years ago

Mike in Ga, regarding comment:

Last time I looked it was Lens article. I'd say that gives him the right to talk about anything he wants. Right?

Show me where I said Len had no right to talk about anything he wants.

What I did say and mean, was that Len went off topic after I exposed his bullshit argument about Obama-care.

Since he could not prove me wrong he changed the subject and went off topic, I was just calling him out on it.

And a fair reading of the post shows that.

You understand how that works. Right?Grin.gif

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

JfT, have YOU registered yet?

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

BS,

Didn't you ask me this?

So many Democrats were bribed to vote for the ACA?........ this is news to me.... so how many is many?

When I respond, if I am off topic, it is to suit you.

It is not Republican obstruction but Democrat revival of Tammany Hall political domination by any means, fair or foul -- but mostly foul -- ,in the cause of socialism and humongous government control of all private enterprise, one step at a time. We are on the road to dictatorship.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

Since you have no response to the message you try to skewer the messenger.

You do this over and over. It is your well known debating style.

 
 
 
brightstarone
Freshman Silent
link   brightstarone    13 years ago

Len, regarding reply:

BS,

Didn't you ask me this?

So many Democrats were bribed to vote for the ACA?........ this is news to me.... so how many is many?

When I respond, if I am off topic, it is to suit you.

Yes I did ask you that, I miss-understood. I thought you were talking about money bribes not the political deals that have always happened in Washington DC since the Congress was established 200 plus years ago.

You went off your own articles topic before I asked you that question with your dissertation on the votes for Social Security 70 years ago and the lack of Republican Votes (because of obstructionism) for the ACA.

I simply called you out on it.

Remember your article was about the failure of Obama-care because of the glitch's of its initial roll out.

I correctly pointed out that historically that has happened with every major and complex government program, like Social Security, Medicare, Prescription Drug Plan Part D.

The glitch's when such programs are initially rolled out; are not extra ordinary or unusual.

The initial Glitch's of a roll out of a new program is separate from the viability of the program itself.

Eventually when we get past the glitch's the programs work well and become very popular with the American people,

You know programs like Social Security, Medicare ...etc

It is not Republican obstruction but Democrat revival of Tammany Hall political domination by any means, fair or foul -- but mostly foul -- ,in the cause of socialism and humongous government control of all private enterprise, one step at a time. We are on the road to dictatorship

You see this is why Obama Haters always lose and President Obama eventually wins, even with determined hate driven obstructionism the Republicans have never been able to defeat him.

Your over the top exaggerations and hyperbolic partisan rhetoric is to obvious and does not sell to main stream America, it only sounds good to the crazy minority of government hating right wing mal-contented extremist; Tea Party Nuts, who do not represent the majority of the electorate.

Words like Socialist and dictatorship in an argument against a plan to make health-care affordable to tens of millions of Americans that can't afford it; is only going to appeal to the crazy Tea Baggers, and that is why President Obama beat the crap out of:

Willard ~ the liar~ Rom ney winning with the popular vote, even though the liar promised that he would defund Obama-care if he were elected and he LOST.

But please do go on with your talking point rhetoric if it makes you feel better, I will just smile as I shake my head in amusement.Grin.gif

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

The biggest liar of all is the president -- and you swear to his lies.

Like, "Everyone can keep their health insurance."

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

I have it too and recall zero glitches.

It worked right out of the box.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

Name them, and compare the severity, if any, with what is going on today.

You are just making it up which is what is done when facts are missing and you need a lame argument.

The main problem withy Medicare, as with all insurance, is that it makes prices go up and invites cheating.

 
 
 
brightstarone
Freshman Silent
link   brightstarone    13 years ago

dennis smith, regarding comment:

Obamacare has not been proven to be affordable. see Mike in GA comment above.

Oh! ... well that's it then, if Mike in GA sez so then it must not be affordable, I'm sure mikes points are objective and non-partisan above reproach.

Mike in GA has honored us with:

The absolute perfect light of Truth and Knowledge.77.gif

No need for further questions or discussion it is over, it is a slam dunk for the Obama Hating Nation.

There is only one thing left to do, .......

DEFUND ........... Obama-care.

NOT!!! 68.gif

Please do go on with your talking point rhetoric if it makes you feel better, I will just smile as I shake my head in amusement.Grin.gif

 
 
 
brightstarone
Freshman Silent
link   brightstarone    13 years ago

dennis smith, regarding comment:

It is only somes opinion that Obamacare will become as accepted as Medicare and Medicaid have. No proof just speculation.

Here's the thing dennis, there are opinions and speculations and then there are opinions and speculations.

Not all opinions and speculations are equal.

For Example:

If one basis her/his opinion or makes speculations based on partisan political prejudice or blind propaganda, then the conclusive product of such speculation or opinionwould be highly suspect and very different from one who bases his/her speculation and opinions on proven historical precedent and previous known experience.

You can see the difference can't you dennis ?Grin.gif

 
 
 
brightstarone
Freshman Silent
link   brightstarone    13 years ago

dennis smith, regarding reply:

Brightstar - I used Mikes comment as one reference.

So what are you saying that you didn't necessarily agree with Mikes comment so that is why you mentioned it?

Some analysts say it will save money overlong term and short term.Some analysts say it will cost money over the long and short term.

Looks like the two sides of the issue ...... hey isn't that the case with every issue, you know isn't that axiomatic and obvious; enough so that it is well known and it doesn't need to be pointed out?

But thanks for pointing it out anyway dennis101.gif

There are two sides t everything bt you only choose oe side.

Really dennis.... isn't that always the case with issues, you knowtwosides and one has to form an opinion which is correct, I think your trying very hard to show off your ability to state the obvious.

OK I'll give you props for your amazing ability113.gif

Your Obama hating comment is nonsense.

Oh not at all dennis, it is not nonsense.

It is the truth, their are America Hating Mal-contented extremist (Tea Party Nut Bags & the right wing media complex) who absolutely hate President Obama, so much so that they would rather work to make the country go down just to see President Obama fail.

I have agreed with Obama for many things and disagreed with him on many things.

Same as me dennis.

It isobvious friom your posts that your agree with whatever he does.

You cannot make absolute conclusive generally sweeping conclusions about my opinions and thoughts on whether I agree with everything President Obama does from reading a couple of my postings.

Not only is that simplistic and lazy but it is also absolutely wrong.

Take your partisan blinders off and you will see this.

Just because I believe that the ACA will eventually get past its initial glitch's; and run smoothly and become very popular with the American people, doesn't mean that I wear metaphorical blinders.

It means that I have formed a valid conclusion based on the evidence and facts of the matter.Grin.gif

 
 
 
brightstarone
Freshman Silent
link   brightstarone    13 years ago

Thanks justice.Smile.gif

I liked you other avatar better, the one with zimmermans fat ugly face in the cross hairs.

 
 
 
brightstarone
Freshman Silent
link   brightstarone    13 years ago

Brightstar - There was no place to reply to youur comments below so will reply here.

Sounds good to me dennisGrin.gif

When someonepoints out that their side is the gospel, they are looking at the issue through ro colored glasses.

Yeah, I expressed my opinion. I never said it was gospel, I don't even believe in organized religionGrin.gif

There is both good and bad in the current Obamacare which you fail to accept based on your comments.

Of course there is good and bad in many things, complex programs like ACA or Social Security or what ever else; are never 100% absolutely perfect.

How could they be? They were made up by human-beings and human-beings are not perfect, far from it.

All we can ever hope to do is to strivefor that more perfect health-care or union.

Your Obama hating comment is nonsense.

Oh not at all dennis, it is not nonsense.

It is the truth, their are America Hating Mal-contented extremist (Tea Party Nut Bags & the right wing media complex) who absolutely hate President Obama, so much so that they would rather work to make the country go down just to see President Obama fail.

Your opinion only that people want to see the country ruined.

No offense intended dennis, but your syntax is a little off. Is English your native tounge?

Just wondering.

As for your comment:

"Your opinion only that people want to see the country ruined"

My exact point was that Obama Haters, Hate the man so much that they don't care about anything else but to hurt him even if they have to take the country down to do it, like obstructing the normal and expected functions of government, like rejecting all of President Obama's proposal's, even ones that they were for in the past, Shutting down the government and holding the country hostage if they don't get their way on everything, commenting with personal attacks and exaggerated partisan name calling instead of policy points ... etc

Claming that people absolutely hate Obama when they disagree with some of his policies is an example of hate itself.

I did not claim that all people that have honest disagreements with President Obama hate him.

That is a ridiculous distortion that miss-represents what I meant.

I was talking about the mal-contented right wing fanatics that are stuck in an ideological rut and they cannot see past their hatred of the man those are the extremist that make personal attacks with racial overtones and threats against his and his families lives.

None of that has anything to do with legitimate political discourse, but it has everything to do with a psychotic ideological hate fetish against President Obama.

The right wing hate machine is dedicated tonothing more then attacking President Obama24/7/365.

Pointing out the truth about the Obama Haters is not the same as hating.

It is talking about something that you see happening and calling it out, sorry you find truth telling so hateful dennisGrin.gif

 
 
 
brightstarone
Freshman Silent
link   brightstarone    13 years ago

dennis smith, regarding reply:

Brightstar - You state that all opinions and speculation are not equal. They in fact are all equal until proven otherwise and your comments offfer no proof.

I dis-agree.

BTW - There is nothing wrong with agreeing to disagree unless you find something "unequal" with that.

I dis-agree.

Itis you who cannot see the difference.

It is you who has said that it is all equal, meaning the same, no difference.

I'm the one that said not all opinions and speculations are equal and the same that there are differences.

And now you're telling me that I can't see the differences?

You're not making sense dennis.

When you can back up your comments with proof perhaps my views will change butnot until then. Are you open to the same?

I alreadybacked up my comments and you've ignored my arguments.

So here it is again:

If one basis her/his opinion or makes speculations based on partisan political prejudice or blind propaganda, then the conclusive product of such speculation or opinionwould be highly suspect and very different from one who bases his/her speculation and opinions on proven historical precedent and previous known experience.

You can see the difference can't you dennis ?

As for your changing views, well we are just expressing our point of views and in the end whether you come to agree or not is not a major issue in my life.

Your dis-agreement has no emotional resonance with me, I usually forget most of what I post and move on, it's just blogging after all.Grin.gif

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

"if you like your doctor, you can keep your doctor, period"

"if you like your healthcare plan, you can keep your healthcare plan, period"

This evening I let my emotions get the best of me when listening to the President's remarks regarding the coverage of illegal immigrants in the health care bill. While I disagree with the President's statement, my comments were inappropriate and regrettable. I extend sincere apologies to the President for this lack of civility

~Rep. Joe Wilson

obama is a bold faced liar, period.

~TEA

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

they elected him, twice

they knew he was lying all along

they called anyone apposed terrorists.

now they can choke on it.

 
 

Who is online




82 visitors