Blaming high gas prices on oil speculators is a fantasy
The need to have a boogeyman to blame things on is part of the political mindset . What the rest of us need is solid info about what does cause the high prices . Fortunately I have identified 2 such causes as follows ...
1) simple supply and demand
The supply has reached 'peak oil" . That started in 2005 when China [especially] began to import increasing amounts of petroleum . This brought about the condition economists call "supply inelasticity" . For more details see this article from last year :
http://thenewstalkers.com/forum/topics/an-issue-that-trancends-politics
2) Badly designed EPA ethnol blending policies ... the so-called RINs or Renewable Identification Numbers .
""As a result of the 2005 Clean Air Act, refiners need to blend a certain amount of ethanol into gasoline every year, and every year the amount they blend in goes higher and higher," Lutz says in the attached video.
He says as long as U.S. gasoline consumption is going up, the 10% ethanol blend mandate "is not a problem." However, he points out that American gasoline usage is currently down and has been falling for the past four years, and recently touched a 13-year low.
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-05-23/u-s-april-gasoline-use-fell-from-year-earlier-api-says.html
As a result, Lutz says refiners have hit "the Blend Wall."
"It has created a situation where refiners have to mix 10% ethanol into the gasoline they make even though the market can't consume it all," he says, noting that most vehicles on the road today can't handle any more than E-10, as the mixed gasoline is known.
Now here's the tricky part. In order to adhere to this federal mandate, Lutz says, refiners have been buying ethanol credits, known as RINs (Renewable Identification Numbers), to offset their obligations. Predictably, this surge in demand for RINs has pushed the price to record highs."
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-07-16/ethanol-climbs-against-gasoline-on-stockpiles-and-record-rins.html
Source :
http://finance.yahoo.com/blogs/breakout/blame-ethanol-spike-gasoline-prices-lutz-125424933.html
Yup , it is the government's demand that ethanol be used to replace some of the gasoline . And it is not just the replacement itself but the inflexible rule by which they set the demand . The rule wasn't just to control the oxygenation of gasoline . It was to provide pork barrel spending for the midwest corn belt . That is clear because the rule demanded a certain total amount of ethanol to be used , not a certain %age of gasoline .
However , the RIN situation is about to change for the better .
"Here's the good part: Lutz sees the price of RINs falling, a sign that the EPA is finally getting around to modifying their absurd policy. Once RINs are out of the equation, Lutz says the price per gallon is going to fall lower.
"I'm not going to be stunned if we see gas prices going below $3 by the end of the year," Lutz says. "That's going to be a heck of a tailwind going into the holiday shopping season."
Source :
http://finance.yahoo.com/blogs/breakout/gas-prices-could-dip-below-3-end-lutz-112631980.html
There you have it . It is not just the oil supply inflexibility . It was a badly constructed EPA policy designed to shovel money to the midwestern corn farmers . I suppose this is what Obama would call "shovel ready " .
This is government sponsored crony capitalism at it "finest" . Your tax dollars and gas money being wasted ...
Tags
Who is online
100 visitors

The good news is that gas prices are likely to drop below $3 per gallon for the 1st time in about 5 years . The bad news is that Obama will probably claim credit for this drop even though his policies had a lot to do with these high prices .
Good article Petey,
Gas is $3.09 as of today, and has been on a steady decline for the last month or so.
Don't even get me started on the ethanol con job done on the American people.
Thanks Kavika ,
Gas has def been dropping of late . The interesting thing is the explanation . There were 2 major factors , not the lone one I discussed last year . Its good to stay up on a subject !
From the Bloomberg article you linked:
Which agrees with my point that Congress needs to act to prevent higher concentrations of Ethanol from becoming required by law.
The Renewable Fuel Standards Mess - 9/15/2013
Renewable fuel standard: Are we nearing a compromise on ethanol? - October 14, 2013
(my bold)
does anyone now a chemists that has an alternate fuel source?
When you say $3 dollars are you talking the price at the pump or the total per barrel. Isn't half payed through taxes to equal the price per barrel?
Was that point made in this recent article ...
And thanks for the other links ...
Yes, specifically in response to this .
On the RFS issue, the EPA's hands are tied, although they are tasked with implementing it.
Cletus ,
The following link addresses that issue :
As you can see there , the president can override the EPA mandate .
Yes . That is what Lutz was referring to .
I'm not sure what you mean here . Are you saying that the pump price is 50 % taxes ?
Petey, here is a link to the taxes on gas and diesel. No where near 50%.
thanks for clearing it up Kavika
What I found interesting, is that the states taxes, for the vast majority of states, is much higher than the federal tax levied.
As the EPA is part of a President's administration, the President can change EPA rules.
But he can't override a law passed. He can reduce the priority of implementing it.
Just found:
EPA Considers U.S. Ethanol Mandate Cut Amid Complaints Oct 10, 2013
Industry group threatens lawsuit over 2014 renewable fuel quotas -
- October 17, 2013
i thought sop was to blame it on bush
Good link Cletus . And based on this excerpt :
it is what I expected . It is under Obama's control . He assumes full responsibility if something goes wrong .
JoAnne ,
Here is the start of the very first sentence in my article :
Now you see the need for an article like this to clear up the misconceptions .
In my article I examined 2 factors in determining gas prices . Here is a third :
Again , nothing to do with speculators ...
Petey, I read an article by Lundberg a couple of years ago, where they said speculators added about $10 per barrel of oil.
Feel free to post a link to it . But be prepared for me to debunk it ...
If I could find the link, I'd post it Petey. I have no problem with you trying to debunk it. My comment was for information only.
My suggestion is to read this old thread :
This issue was brought up there along with links . As far as the issue of speculators today : why are gas prices dropping now ? The speculators are still speculating ... right ?