╌>

Jonathan Kay: The real lessons of Munich

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  buzz-of-the-orient  •  13 years ago  •  2 comments

Jonathan Kay: The real lessons of Munich

Jonathan Kay: The real lessons of Munich

By Jonathan Kay for National Post, October 10, 2013

5658_discussions.jpg

Germans enter Czechoslovakia , 1938

On Oct. 10, 1938, 75 years ago today, Nazi Germany formally took control of the Sudetenland, the iron-rich portion of Czechoslovakia containing most of that countrys ethnic German population. Five months later, Hitler gobbled up the Czech rump. Six months after that came the invasion of Poland , and the beginning of the Second World War.

The Munich Pact represents one of the great hinge points in human history. Czechoslovakia was a militarily sophisticated nation that had assembled an extensive network of fortifications in the Sudeten region. France wasnt ready for war. But a Czechoslovak defensive campaign, supported explicitly by Britain and other powers, might have ended Nazi empire-building at an early stage.

Indeed, many German generals (especially Ludwig Beck, Chief of the General Staff) feared that a full-scale Czechoslovak invasion would end disastrously for Germany . Some even plotted to arrest the Fhrer if he declared war. But that proved unnecessary: At Munich, Hitler achieved his goals with the stroke of a pen.

Thus did the world get peace for our time (to cite Neville Chamberlains oft-misquoted phrase). Our time lasted a total of 11 months, while the industrial war of annihilation that followed it lasted six years and took more than 50 million lives. As Benjamin Netanyahu has repeatedly warned the world, this is the short-sighted arithmetic of appeasement.

But the Munich Pact was more than just a case study in pacifism and cowardice. It also was a symptom of the colonial mindset that still dominated the thinking of European leaders.

Click this link to read the rest of this article:

http://fullcomment.nationalpost.com/2013/10/10/jonathan-kay-the-real-lessons-of-munich/


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

(from the abovenoted article): In our own era, the Munich metaphor has become overused. Last month, for instance, during his failed effort to rouse the world to military action against Syria, U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry declared that This is our Munich moment. But thats a huge stretch. Munich, 1938, was a tragically squandered opportunity for world powers to stand up to an unmistakably fascistic and hegemonic regime. Bashar Al-Assad, on the other hand, is engaged in the opposite project: trying to keep Syria stitched together in the face of a rebellion that includes Al-Qaeda jihadis fighting under the banner of Sunni Islamofascism. The problem with comparing Syria 2013 to Czechoslovakia 1938 is that we have metaphorical Hitlers on both sides.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

(from the abovenoted article): One more difference between the Munich era and our own: Seven decades ago, it was widely understood that military aggression had consequences for the losers not just for the leaders and armies, but also for the peoples on whose behalf these wars were waged. Its a lesson that the Arab nations that declared war on Israel in 1948, most notably, still havent internalized.

Sudeten Germans were overjoyed to see Hitlers tanks roll into Czechoslovakia in 1938. But seven years later, when the war was over, they were thrown out of their homes along with millions of other Germans residing in parts of modern-day Hungary, Poland, Romania and the former Yugoslavia. As R.M. Douglas writes, it was the largest forced population transfer and perhaps the greatest single movement of peoples in human history.

These displaced Germans, perhaps as many as 14-million by Douglas count, became lifelong exiles. And yet very few of them defined themselves as refugees in the conventional political sense. Most found new jobs, and created new lives. They did not agglomerate in dead-end camps, become wards of the UN, manufacture a political identity based on suffering and displacement, or make violent political fetishes out of their desire to return to dimly remembered ancestral homes.

Perhaps that is why, 75 years later, Munich is a glittering tourist destination. Ramallah, not so much.

 
 

Who is online






100 visitors