Canadian Assembly of First Nations Chief Objects to PM Imposing an “Assimilationist” Education System
Mark Kennedy: October, 7, 2013
[ LINK ]
"Harpers record on aboriginal issues is now under the international microscope, as a United Nations fact-finder began an eight-day trip through Canada to collect information about this countrys treatment of its indigenous peoples."
Stephen Harper, meets with Assembly of First Nations Chief Shawn Atleo on Parliament Hill in Ottawa
December 1, 2011 [Photo: REUTERS/Chris Wattie]
OTTAWA The Harper government is on the verge of potentially imposing an assimilationist education system on aboriginal children that repeats the mistakes of residential schools from past decades, says the head of Canadas largest aboriginal group.
In an interview with Postmedia News on Monday, Assembly of First Nations National Chief Shawn Atleo urged Prime Minister Stephen Harper to turn the page on more than a century of Canadas mistreatment of its indigenous peoples.
He called on the federal government to take substantive action in critical areas by recognizing native treaties and land claims, establishing a public inquiry into missing and murdered aboriginal women, and dropping its unilateral and top-down approach on how to bolster education for aboriginal children.
The calls came as aboriginals marked the 250th anniversary on Monday of the Royal Proclamation, the document which provided the basis for promises made to First Nations peoples by the British Crown.
Harpers record on aboriginal issues is now under the international microscope, as a United Nations fact-finder began an eight-day trip through Canada to collect information about this countrys treatment of its indigenous peoples.
The governments education plan will be the centerpiece of its aboriginal affairs agenda to be featured in next weeks throne speech, and then detailed later this year with the introduction of a First Nation Education Act.
But so far, said Atleo, the Conservative governments approach to working with First Nations on the forthcoming act has been reflective of how federal governments have always acted paternalistic at best and assimilationist at worst.
Read the entire story ;
Tags
Who is online
68 visitors

Anything less than full supports for language and culture would absolutely fit within a continued assimilationist effort that we still have to this very day, Atleo said.
Ive had residential school survivors who are now leaders in education say to me that the approach. now led by Affairs Minister Bernard Valcourt,feels like the experience of residential schools."
Near the 1920's the Canadian government startedto take actions towards "improving" The lives of the natives. They felt that by changing the natives' culture and lifestyles to be more like the typical Christian Canadian, all their problems would be solved. This was called assimilation. To assimilate the natives, they opened residential schools. Many schools were also run at churches.
Residential schools, which are the subject of the First Nations Truth and Reconciliation Commission [TRC] , were notorious for abuse and neglect of First Nations children. The children were forcibly sent to the schools, often hours away from their families, and were punished if they were caught practicing their religion, speaking their native language, among other reasons. [ Source ]
Seriously, religious teaching and education is a form of assimilationist education.
Isn't it hard to like one and not the other?
Seems the Canadian government hasn't learned anything from their own history regarding religious, education, and assimilation.
Harpers record on aboriginal issues is now under the international microscope, as a United Nations fact-finder began an eight-day trip through Canada to collect information about this countrys treatment of its indigenous peoples.
Hmm! I wonder just why, with the evidence so obvious, that the UN hasn't seen fit to put their host country under the microscope??
Excellent question Tsula.
Reflecting on my personal history of just why we left the res shortly after my birth in 1925, the people who are supposed to have our best interests at heart are constantly being found to have no hearts. DDSOS fits here perfectly, 88 years later, doesn't it?
Robert, you know this for a fact that your statement is true. Or is just more of you nonsense?
Robert - I know it's above your level, but "try" reading "The Rights of Indians and Tribes" by Stephen L. Pevar, Senior Staff Counsel for the ACLU, formerly from the Rosebud Sioux Reservation, and taught Federal Indian Law at the University of Denver School of Law for 20 years.
Oh, Indians are very much interested in maintaining and controlling their borders but this little thing called SCOTUS is trying to take that away from us with their rulings since 1986.
The First Nation's people had a much better relationship with it's government prior to Harper - he is, indeed, trying to eliminate First Nation's status regardless of treaties and laws - really very similar to SCOTUS.
Don't just throw out shit - if you don't know anything about a subject, say so.
LOL, are you serious John, that statement borders on comedy.
Are you not familiar with Reservations, Boarding Schools, and that little thing called Sovereign Nation.
''Psychological separation''....John from reality.
That is what "assimilation" is all about in the end.
No! "assimilation" is all about destroying the native cultures which the white people seem to feel sothreatened by! THIS is the original "final solution" and where we now stand in the governmental sanctioned genocide of an entire race. Makes you proud doesn't it to know that it has been going on almost unabated for 500 years?
No John, it's not a yes or no question.Assimilation is all about destroying our culture/language/land/treaties.
Perhaps you might try to understand, if that's possible for you, Capt. Richard Henry Pratt, who stated the first ''Indian Boarding School'', or as I prefer to call them, ''Re-education camps''. Quote, ''Kill the Indian, save the man''..
''what does Harper have to do with Canada''.......LMAO, did you forget to goggle it Robert. He's the Prime Minister of Canada...
I don't know, but when you figure it out, break it down for the rest of us.
We were placed on reservations because the Europeans did not feel we were fit to be included in their society; we were not of their kind. When they over populated the areas they were in and needed to spread out, instead of trying to include us in their civilization, they had us "removed" to other locations so they could take the land we had been given. They did not want to "assimilate" us.
Now the government wants the land we were given by treaty "for as long as the sun shall shine and the grass shall grow" ..... or until we find natural resources that can benefit us and corporations who pay us such large sums under the table to run you off those lands... but we will call it "assimilation."
Suddenly it is in "our" best interest to assimilate.
Kiss my semi-white ass.... figuratively, of course... I'm partial as to who gets that close to it.
Sadly Badfish this is changing. For several years Brazilian Indians were protected but this new government is trying to change the rules and do to Brazilian Indians what was done to American Indians 200+ years ago and displace them. Ranchers and loggers are invading and killing the Indians that were up to recently uncontacted, they either die from disease or the ranchers/loggers just plain shoot them. The difference between Brazilian and American Indians today is that Brazilian Indians have the support and love of the population and Are not discriminated against, quite the contrary
They prefer to be of their own sovereignty - two citizenships are not what we asked for in the treaties, not what we asked for with the Snyder Act and not what we're asking for now. We prefer to be citizens of "OUR" Nation's - the ones that were here thousands of years before the Euro invasion.
LOL, no it's a knockout Robert.
Robert, face it you were KO'd. Plain and simple.
If what your saying is that sovereignty does not exist for Indians Tribes, when you are at odds with the U.S. Government.
As for heckling from the cheap seats, that is your forte' Robert. That, misdirection, derail and ''what if's''.
mimi, LMAO.
Did you "ask" for Obamacare? How 'bout SSec being taken out of your check? How 'bout filing taxes each year? No, you didn't ask for them - but you got them.
For me it's not hard, as long as they are kept separate.
IMO, religious teaching should conform with the religious beliefs of the students heritage and culture.
There's a difference between teaching FN and NA children about the religion and culture practiced by the non-natives they have to live and work with, and trying to convert those children from practicing the religion of their heritage and attempting to assimilate them, against their families wishes, into the Christian culture, as has been the practice in the past.
Very good question.
When the UN world wide human rights fact findinginitiative was announced, it raised a fire-storm among Americans, saying we are NOT going to have the UN telling us what to do.
Shouldn't they be? They have a completely different heritage and culture than the Euro-Christians that migrated to this continent 500 years ago. It could be argued that the immigrants should have converted to the ways of their native host.
Personally, I think it would have been a lot better if it had worked out that way.
I would certainly hope so.
Let it never again be said that you and I disagree on everything Badfish!
You would do a lot better with your comments if you would practice reading articles before you start commenting on them Robert.
Excerpt;
"In an interview with Postmedia News on Monday, Assembly of First Nations National Chief Shawn Atleo urged Prime Minister Stephen Harper to turn the page on more than a century of Canadas mistreatment of its indigenous peoples."
Robert, Robert, Robert,
Please quit making a fool out of yourself. Those are all covered under treaty obligations of the U.S. You know, the ''Supreme Law of the Land''. Your big on laws and abiding by them Robert, so why don't you take a little time and actually study the subject.
Have a great day.
8, 9, 10...Your out!!!!!
Like the U.S. protects and controlsit's borders Robert? Seems the US isn't much interested in protecting or controlling it's borders. The U.S. is a sovereign nation isn't it Robert? Ooooppppssss 12 to 20 million illegals roaming around the country side.
You stepped in it again Robert.
BF, palma did a whole article on it. It's on Anishinaabe.
Kinda like where Israel keeps telling them to head ain't it?
International law is the foundation for U. S. Federal and Canadian Federal laws, specifically when dealing with indigenous peoples. Under the "Doctrine of Discovery" power over Indians is the rule of international law that states that "discovery and conquest (gives) the conquerors sovereignty over and ownership of the lands thus obtained.
In 1823, the SCOTUS held that by virtue of the "discovery" of North America by the Europeans and the "conquest" of its inhabitants, the federal government (as the Europeans' successor) is entitled to enforce its laws over all persons and propertywithin the United States. As the nation in control of this territory, the United States may exercise all powers "necessarily inherent" in any sovereign nation, including the authority to regulate Indians and their property.
Canada also uses this "guise" to "regulate" the First Nation's peoples.
Interestingly, Robert, the Indian tribes are not asking the U. S. for anything.
The doctrine of trust responsibility was cited in early SCOTUS cases as an additional source of federal power over Indians. Many treaties between the U. S. and the tribes contain a guarantee that the federal government will "protect" the treaty tribe. This promise, the Court has held, gives the federal government both the power and the duty to regulate Indians for their protection - as "a dependent ward".
With some of these folks, it's like you are fighting an unarmed man.
Robert, we can go on and on. As I suggested before, it would do you in good stead, to at least have some comprehension of what you talking about.
I posted a link for you, that may, just may, help you understand the complete picture. If you chose to babble on about something that, by your statements, don't know anything about, that is your choice.
I'm going to have dinner now, and I thank you for paying your taxes, so I can keep getting all my free stuff.
Robert, do you not understand that the choice is not ours? The US government has total control over the Indian Nations. To try and proclaim complete sovereignty would be an act of war; the government does not even allow the Tribes total control over their own money.
Do you know of any other group of people in this country that has a "Bureau of__ Affairs" in the government? Bureau of Black Affairs? Bureau of White Affairs?
This government lost billions of dollars of Indian money and the freaking Supreme Court said, "So what?" Yes, the sovereignty is false, and it is fragile, and is subject to the whim of the son of a bitch bastards in congress, and of whomever is on the Supreme Court when the complaints get that far.
If I am wrong, Kavika and 1stwarrior will correct me.
So Robert - you're saying that the U. S. Constitution is incorrect and the courts have been finding improperly???
The source of an Indian tribe's power is its people. Indian tribes have the inherent right to govern themselves, a right they have possessed "from time immemorial" (Worcester v. Georgia). As a federal appellate court stated in 2002, "Indian tribes are neither states, nor part of the federal government, nor subdivisions of either. Rather, they are sovereign political entities possessed of sovereign authority not derived from the U. S, which they predate. Indian tribes are qualified to exercise powers of self-government . . . by reason of their original tribal sovereignty" (National Labor Relations Board v. Pueblo of San Juan).
Robert - go to the previous page, below mimi's comment, and you'll see you have been answered.
I would agree with that Tsula, if the UN Human Rights agency were as biased and prejudiced against MUCH more deserving nations for their criticism as they are against Israel almost exclusively.
I absolutely support that Canada should be assimilationist with respect to the Native and Non-Native populations. A goodly portion of every Canadian child's education should be devoted to learning about aboriginal history, customs and traditions (which it is NOT). If this were done in Canada AND the USA, perhaps the people there would become more peaceful, respectful of their environment and sensitive to the feelings of persons different from themselves.
Such assimilationist education as I described would lead to these things never or almost never happening:
Robert - quite simply, the U. S. controls Indian tribes because it has the military power to do so. The ultimate source of the federal government's power over Indians is its military strength. Other justifications are given besides this one, but the fact is that if the U. S. were no militarily more powerful, Indian tribes today would exercise the same sovereignty they did prior to the arrival of the Euros.
The feds take the position that Congress has plenary power over all Indian tribes, their governments, their members, and their property. As SCOTUS stated in 2011, citing its earlier decisions: "The United States retains plenary authority to divest tribes of any attributes in all matters, including their form of government."(United States v. Jicarilla Apache Tribe,131 S. Ct., 2313, 2323-2324 (2011)) Congress, in other words, may assist or destroy a tribal government as it sees fit, and at various times it has assisted tribes while at others it has attempted to destroy them.
And we're gonna tell them to LEAVE ME ALONE????? 5.2M people v. 308M??? Kinda big odds, eh?
just refer to Oglala, 1970s
I think you should do some reading before posting comments like this. Even the dead you got wrong
Who said anything about removing NA children from their original culture? There is no reason for NA children that wish to get a traditional education to completely abandon their native culture.
I wasn't trying to get "credit" for anything.
I was trying to point out a habit you seem to have when you jump into discussions. ie;
"You would do a lot better with your comments if you would practice reading articles before you start commenting on them Robert."
Not just regardingthis article, but you seem to do it with many discussions you jump into.