╌>

Education on the Debt vs Deficit....a gift for the Tea Partiers and Cons

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  bluearcher  •  13 years ago  •  6 comments

Education on the Debt vs Deficit....a gift for the Tea Partiers and Cons

One of the recurring dialogues here, and probably elsewhere, goes more or less like this:

RABID Tea Partier: Obama is SPEEEENNNNNDDIIIIING US INTO OBLIVION! NOOOOoooooo!

INFORMED POSTER: Obama has actually REDUCED the deficit.

RABID Tea Partier: Oh yeah! (introduces link showing national debt in the Bush years vs. today). you sily libs dont know anything bout the economy do you?

INFORMED POSTER: That is debt, not deficit. Do you understand the difference?

RABID Tea Partier[crickets]

The problem is, Debt and Deficit are two different things. And it is astonishing how Teabaggers in particular do not understand what they're talking about.

DEBT
Debt is money you have borrowed. The US Government borrows money all the time, usually by selling Treasury bonds. These are some of the most reliably secure investments in the world, mostly because the US has never missed a payment. If we were to start playing fast and loose with our debt obligations our currency would rapidly start losing value, as investors around the world would start migrating to something safer. This is why threats to default on our debt are fundamentally treasonous to our economy. Our standing as a world power would virtually disappear overnight were we to stop making payments on our treasury bonds.

DEFICIT
Now, pay attention, because there are more letters in this word. I know they both start with DE and end with T, but they are not the same thing at all. When the US budget exceeds the amount of receipts in taxes for a given fiscal year, the overage is called the deficit. When this happens, the government borrows money to cover the shortfall. The accumulated deficits then become the debt.

HISTORY
This is where conservatives go haywire with the confusion and liberals have to patiently, over and over and over and over and over and over and over again, repeat the following indisputable facts:

Prior to 1980, every US President since World War II had reduced the ratio of overall debt to gdp. This was not difficult and most Americans believed paying taxes was accepted and part of their duty as Americans. But starting with Ronald Reagan, taxpayers were fooled into thinking that we could pay less in taxes and blow off the inevitable spending cuts we would have to make until another day. This was part of a strategy to force reductions or cancellations in social spending, known by the charming moniker of "Starve the Beast," but that's for another article. The important point here is, Reagan glibly and cheerfully sold Americans on the notion that they could have things both ways.

Reagan increased the US debt in his first term by 11 percent of GDP where every President before him going back to Roosevelt had reduced it some, except for Nixon/Ford who increased it by a tiny percentage point. He added another 9 percent GDP in his second term, for a record 20 percent of debt/gdp increase. This was exclusively due to Reagan's own financial recklessness and unwillingness to make difficult spending cut decisions because they would have been politically unpopular.
His successor, George H.W. Bush, was even worse, busting our national debt by 15% in four years alone.

In the 1990's, Bill Clinton got the problem under control, reducing the debt by .7% in his first term, and by an impressive 9% in his second term. He left the US budget with a surplus that would have given us the ability to pay down our Reagan-era debt within a few years.

However, Bush the Lesser, bent on completing the absurd game of chicken that Starve The Beast is, recklessly cut taxes for the least-needy Americans while giving a mere sop to the working class, and committed America to two fronts of an open-ended occupation. These two actions left the US with a STRUCTURAL deficit. Teabaggers shrieking about out-of-control spending don't seem to understand that the Bush contributions to our deficit are long-term obligations and changes to revenue that until redressed one way or the other will not go away just because a Republican House is elected. The structural items are so large that no matter how much discretionary spending we cut (and given how Congress works, cutitng discretionary spending is well-nigh impossible anyway) there is no way even a united party, GOP or Democrat, with perfect party discipline and a laser-sharp focus on debt reduction, could get rid of the structural faults in our treasury's revenue structure.

The other item is ending the tax cuts for the wealthy. There has been zero compelling evidence that these cuts ever had a damn thing to do with creating jobs or improving the economy. The justification for keeping them in place has been mostly infantile poutrage from the wealthy. As a percentage of income the wealthy pay less in taxes than the middle class do, which is inherently unfair.

Well, this has been entertaining. I look forward to the lack of comprehension from right-wing partisans on this issue, because Debt and Deficit still look an awful lot alike if you aren't reading too closely.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    13 years ago

So first Obama balloons the deficit then he lowers it slightly and people think this is good news. He is still driving us into the ground at a rate of about a trillion dollars a year.

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    13 years ago

I hate to break it to you Barb but the debt comes from the deficit and they are driving us into the ground at a rate of about a trillion dollars per year.

 
 
 
bluearcher
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  bluearcher    13 years ago

Let me put it simply since you seem to only parrot one understanding.

First of all, Obama has failed to convince Congress to enact some of his proposed policies such as higher taxes on the wealthy that likely would have reduced the deficit and thus kept the debt growing more slowly.

Spending began at the start of the recession that is the result of automatic stabilizers such as unemployment insurance kicking in. It is not such a simple answer to pin this all on Obamas policies.

While blame is often placed on the Bush tax cuts, the burst of spending under Bush is an often forgotten factor in the disappearance of the projected budget surplus.

Additionally, educate yourself @ Keynesian economics and methods of economic recovery.

Lastly, perhaps convince the Rethugs and TeaBaggers to embrace fiscal policy comprromise and something might get done.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

We went through this over a year and a half ago, and it was decided then that the term was unacceptable here on NT. I am going to change the title to teapartiers.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

Ya know what Bruce, I don't want either here. It brings down the level of discussion to nothing more than name calling, which is nothing more than what our government, if you want to call them that, is doing. Here is where we should be able to discuss issues without the tags. The CoC clearly states that. Both go.And for the record, when I see that term, I remove it.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    13 years ago

He (CLinton) left the US budget with a surplus

No he didn't. Clinton "balanced" the budget by raiding the social security trust fund and therefore raised the national debt each year he was in office. Clinton borrowed money from social security rather than the public, but he never made a dent in our national debt or truly balanced the budget.

 
 

Who is online






68 visitors