Bereft Of Any New Policy Ideas Since Vietnam, America's Liberal Left Is Intellectually Bankrupt
If you were offered 50 percent more income than you now earn, would you be willing to go work in a coal mine? Would you give up 15 IQ points for 50 percent more income? Would you give up 10 years of life expectancy?
If you are willing to accept these offers, then money is probably the most important thing in your life. At least it ranks very near the top. For most of us, money is nowhere near the most important thing, however.
Why do we need to reflect on this? Because the topic du jour on the left these days is inequality. By inequality they mean inequality of income. And they want government to do something about it.
Yet, as I wrote recently , people seem to care a lot more about physical and mental health, living longer, social status and a host of other things than they care about money. And for the most part, money cant buy the things that people care most about.
So why are intellectuals on the left so obsessed with money inequality instead of the inequality of lifes blessings that people value much more? Certainly in their own lives they dont act as though money is the most important value. Theyre all writers and professors when they could have earned a lot more by getting a law degree or an MBA.
I believe the answer is that they are reactionaries. Theyre living in the past.
When Karl Marx was writing about inequality 150 years ago, most people were struggling to meet basic needs. To obtain lifes necessities, you needed money. So it was only natural that money income and wealth were the focus of Marxs attention. Not surprisingly, redistribution of income was the primary goal of 19 th century socialists.
Today things are different. Nature produces all kinds of inequalities that seem a lot more unfair than differences in income. Women for example, live as much as ten years longer than men. Some people are born with genius IQs; others are not as lucky. Some are born with the Huntingtons disease gene; others are not.
If the left wants to redress lifes unfairness, why dont they advocate redistribution from women to men, from people with healthy genes to unhealthy genes, from high to low IQs? And if Tom Wolfe is right, just about everybody cares about status more than income. Social status is distributed far more unequally than income. So why isnt the left advocating redistribution from high status to low status individuals?
Why, in other words, are they focused on a 19 th century socialist view of the world instead of a 21 st century view?
I have believed for some time that the left is intellectually bankrupt . I cant think of a single new idea from the left of the political spectrum since the end of the Vietnam War. Just about all the national debates since then have been over proposals that have come from the right. Try watching left-wing talk shows on television. I believe you will find that they spend almost all their time talking about people on the right and their ideas.
In education, were arguing about charter schools and vouchers. To reform the tax system, its the flat tax. For Social Security, its private retirement accounts. For Medicare and Medicaid, its private health insurance. For welfare, its tough love. To promote economic growth, lower taxes on capital. All these ideas come from the political right.
Even programs that you may not even think of as conservative have come from the right. The earned income tax credit (EITC), for example, is Milton Friedmans negative income tax. Its the rights alternative to the welfare state. The common currency of the European Union was the brainchild of the Wall Street Journals favorite economist: Robert Mundell. Both Hillary Clintons and Barack Obamas health reform plans were based on the model of managed competition which relies on artificial markets, not government, to allocate health care resources. Although Im not a fan of this approach, the idea came from Stanford University professor Alain Enthoven and was promoted by the Heritage Foundation both strong critics of the British National Health Service and the Canadian health care system.
Heres the brutal truth. The left has no idea what to do about our failing public schools. It has no solution to the problem of entitlement spending. It has no earthly idea what to do about all the problems in our health care system. There is no coherent proposal on the left to reform the tax system. I think it is no exaggeration to say that the left has no ideas. Period.
In some ways this is understandable. The 20 th century was one long experiment in left-wing ideas. By left-wing I am including the national socialism of Nazi Germany and fascist Italy. I am also including early 20 th century progressivism , including the desire to re-make public education and purify the gene pool. I am also including everything on the left that the left refers to as left.
So what was the result of all that? Failure. The left all over the world was wrong about everything. They were wrong about communism. They were wrong about socialism. They were wrong about progressivism. They were wrong about the welfare state.
Throughout the entire 20 th century, what did the left consider its intellectual rival? Classical liberalism . That was the political philosophy of our founding fathers. It was classical liberalism that eliminated slavery from the civilized world, gave us womens suffrage, and extended economic and political freedom to people all over the globe.
The contrast between these two worldviews could not be more stark. The classical liberals believed the state should be the servant of free men. The 20 th century left believed that men should serve the state. The results are in. The 20 th century was the century of economic instability, depression and war. The 19 th century was the century of price stability, economic growth and relative international peace. The 20 th century was the century of dictatorship and genocide on an unimaginable scale with 125 million people killed by their own governments! The 19 th century was a century of liberation and increasing personal freedom.
By the last quarter of the 20 th century, people all over the world realized that a huge mistake had been made. Communism was dismantled almost everywhere. Countries began instituting the flat tax, private social security accounts and even school vouchers. They began privatizing, deregulating and freeing up markets.
There are still some intellectual holdouts, however. Inevitably, they are reactionaries seeking a return to the failed policies of the past.
New York Times columnist Paul Krugman writes longingly about the post-World War II years when the highest marginal tax rate was 91 percent, when far more workers were in labor unions and when government regulation was pervasive. (Did you know that in those years the government would not allow a bank to pay you interest on your checking account balance, dictated what interest rate they could pay on your savings account and prohibited the average citizen from even buying a Treasury bill?) Krugman also pines wistfully about the Roosevelt years, when the federal government tried to immitate Italian fascism by forcing every industry and trade to form cartels and set prices and output in virtually every market just like the medieval guilds.
Sorry, this is not serious thinking in anyones book.
http://www.forbes.com/sites/johngoodman/2013/07/02/bereft-of-any-new-policy-ideas-since-vietnam-americas-liberal-left-is-intellectually-bankrupt/

Pretty much says it all.
Combine that with their failure to change the Chinese currency peg & you've got the 2 most significant factors affecting the US employment picture . Very weak ...
Open borders and illegals affect each one of those, and is the reason why each of those aren't working for us.
Great article. I agree with all of it.
This is one of the worst opinion articles Ive ever read in a long time. It is one long bloviated whine, broken up in paragraphs; completely devoid of facts and written at a 5th grade level. Maybe this kind of literary slop works well for the American Thinker (which is an oxymoron) but for Forbes to allow such tripe to be published shows a major plunge in their journalistic standards.
The authors harangue on Marxism is a joke, chuck full of incomplete logic, unprovable suppositions and outright fantasy.
To that extent, I might say the right has become morally bankrupt and, for example, has produced a constant flow of pro-corporation, anti-liberty idea that have reduced American education (among other things) to the laughing stock of the world.
Lastly, John C. Goodman, the author of this garbage, is the founder, President and CEO of the National Center for Policy Analysis (NCPA).
The National Center for Policy Analysis (NCPA) is a free market think tank primarily funded by private foundations established by wealthy conservative business families and billionaires, including Charles and David Koch.
National Socialism
National Socialism , German Nationalsozialismus , also called Nazism or Naziism , totalitarian movement led by Adolf Hitler as head of the Nazi Party in Germany . In its intense nationalism , mass appeal, and dictatorial rule, National Socialism shared many elements with Italian fascism . However, Nazism was far more extreme both in its ideas and in its practice. In almost every respect it was an anti-intellectual and atheoretical movement, emphasizing the will of the charismatic dictator as the sole source of inspiration of a people and a nation, as well as a vision of annihilation of all enemies of the Aryan Volk as the one and only goal of Nazi policy.
You have to have a little knowledge about history to understand this and put it into perspective.
Otherwise you will be fooled like the Germans were.
I'm curious, did he rejoice in delivering the death letters to the Jews as George Soros did?
Obama is a laughing stock: Column
Obama's efforts to do something about Syria invite only criticism and push back.
Remember that dumb cowboy George W. Bush, who alienated all our allies and dragged us into wars of choice in the Mideast? And remember that goofball Mitt Romney, whom Joe Biden a year ago accused of wanting to go to war in Syria?
Both of them must be having a big laugh over the way things are going for Obama now. When I wrote last week on our bumbling Syria diplomacy, it seemed that things couldn't possibly go further downhill. Boy, was I wrong.
Last week, it seemed our only ally was France. But now the French are having second thoughts . Obama's efforts to get support at the G20 conference came to nothing. Even the pope is undercutting him.
Meanwhile, at home, polls show Americans are against a strike, and Obama is facing double-digit defections among Democrats in the Senate. The outlook for passage in the House, meanwhile, looks so bad that a resolution to authorize war may not even make it to a vote . If it's sure to fail, why force members -- Republicans and Democrats alike -- to go on record? You can bet they don't appreciate Obama putting them in this position. The Pentagon isn't happy, and even The Atlantic' s Ta-Nehisi Coates , a reliable Obama supporter, calls his policy "dumb."
Some critics are even comparing the collapse of American influence under Obama to the end of the Soviet Union . Well, that may be an exaggeration -- but Obama promised a " fundamental transformation, " after all.
At least Hollywood is still behind the president -- or, anyway, is mostly keeping quiet about its opposition because, as old-line Hollywood liberal Ed Asner reports , they "don't want to feel anti-black." So it's come to this -- while George W. Bush was savaged for " bombing brown people ," now if you're against bombing brown people you're "anti-black."
As I said, if I were George W. Bush or Romney, I'd be sorely tempted to laugh, because Obama's chickens are coming home to roost. Obama was elected after he and his party sowed distrust of U.S. military endeavors, mocked "intelligence estimates" about "weapons of mass destruction," and suggested that anything the United States did in the region was probably somehow a scheme to benefit oil companies. Now Obama and his administration are shocked to find that when they go on about intelligence estimates and weapons of mass destruction, people don't take them seriously.
Likewise, Obama has repeatedly shown his disdain for Congress and his willingness to act without congressional approval in all sorts of areas, from ObamaCare implementation to gun control. So it's not surprising that members of Congress seem to be a bit . . . distant now that Obama suddenly wants them to bail him out of his unfortunate " red line " remark.
But I'd bet that Bush and Romney aren't actually laughing. That's because they're both serious men who understand international politics and who care for the future of the country. They no doubt understand that, as fun as it is to watch a political opponent twist in the wind due to his own ineptitude, the price will ultimately be paid not by Obama, but by the people of America.
Our diplomacy is a joke, our president is a laughing stock, our enemies are emboldened, and we've still got over three years of this to go. Nothing funny there at all, alas.
Cool, you can cut 'n' paste; here's your award.
Now here's the difficult part, can you clearly articulate, in your own words, what (if anything) this has to do with the thread?
A Pax ,
How about this one :
Apparently you are A Pax now ...
Your "plan" is not the left's plan . No one major would support such extreme measures . But more importantly those proposals are not a reform of the tax code . No matter how large you make those caps , there are corporations which can avoid them by utilizing IRS loopholes . And like others on the left you fail to even comprehend what actual tax code problems are . I understand that you are not in the 1 % and are therefore not able to take advantage of those loopholes but ignorance of them is no excuse . They exist . They are abusive . They need reforming . But Obama won't . Neither will Hillary of Liz Warren .
OK , don't read my comment . I won't read yours either ... bye .
What we have here is a failure to communicate ...
How about this one;
history tends to repeat itself. the dem party used to be the party of slavery, now infiltrated by radical liberals, they enslave instead with dependancy. recently, its fantastic to watch how they embrace a controlled press, and wall street financed presidents.
pretty amaizing, the bra burners are now running the senate!
careful, the mere mention of friedman may get you "krugman-ed"
I'd eat both of them ... one with syrup , one without .
Ho Hum
I'm a moderate, and I don't feel intellectually bankrupt. I am quite sure there are those that would gladly dispute that, but I'm not morally OR intellectually bankrupt.
Most of us here on NTaren't.