Pope blasts abortion after decrying focus on rules
" John Paul II and Benedict XVI were both intellectuals for whom doctrine was paramount, an orientation that guided the selection of a generation of bishops and cardinals who, in countries like the United States, have put themselves on the front lines in opposing abortion and gay marriage. They now find themselves being asked to preach more to those who have fallen away from the church and offer them a compassionate welcome home.
Greg Burke, the Vatican's senior communications adviser, insisted Friday that Francis was by no means calling into question the papacies and priorities of his predecessors.
"The pope is not condemning his predecessors," Burke told The Associated Press. "What he is saying is 'We've spent a lot of time talking about the boundaries. We've spent a lot of time talking about what is sin and what's not. Now let's move on. Let's talk about mercy. Let's talk about love.'"
Dublin Archbishop Diarmuid Martin, Ireland's most reform-minded Catholic leader, said Francis' comments will be tough for the church to put into action because there is a tendency to get "trapped" into the right and wrong, white and black of Catholic teaching.
"It's a way of thinking that will actually be very hard for the right and the left of the church, either of them, to accept," he told RTE radio. But he said Francis wasn't dismissing everything that has been taught to date.
"He's saying let's move in a different direction." "
http://hosted2.ap.org/APDEFAULT/3d281c11a96b4ad082fe88aa0db04305/Article_2013-09-20-EU-Vatican-Pope/id-ec5a0e6c566b4b10859cf06e8c2b1ea7
Tags
Who is online
77 visitors

" Mercy and Love" are great; I wholly promote them, but this Pope is treading a fine line, imo. Definitely, there's a "tendency to get 'trapped' into the right and wrong" of Catholic doctrine using his approach. You simply can't accept everyone, and then tell them they are wrong. It just doesn't work.
What do you think?
Probably, RW. That's where the politics of religion starts to get sticky .
I do believe this Pope has a strong altruistic nature, which is good, imo. Yet, I was skeptical of him at first in that I thought he saw the way to win people back [to which we don't really know why they left, for sure -- I can only speak for myself - but I think the ritualism, Latin et al - were good] was to lower the standards/foundations of the Church - just my interpretation of him; this article is saying that is 'not' correct, that he still holds the original values. My point is to suggest a dichotomy is present; he can't have his cake and eat it too; he can't favor a liberal approach in acceptance, while adhering to a value system that was meant to add stability and social order, give protection to those who can't protect themselves, and an institution that values the teachings and virtues of Christ and the apostles - in an effort to increase membership. ..If that's what he's doing.
At some point, the Catholic Church must realize that we, as a species, are pooping ourselves and the rest of all the species, out of a home. The more people, the more poop. Some day, the Catholic Church must realized that there are a finite source of resources on this planet, and the more we use them up, the less we have.
It would be nice, if it were recognized sooner, rather than later, when we're all on the brink...
Flame, on the issue of abortion, we agree, and for all of the same reasons.
My opinion was just that of the Church and the purpose of the institution, and the importance, in my view, of keeping the foundational 'values' in-tact.
Once 'any' institution allows liberal changes to seep in, its original purpose no longer makes any sense. If it's standards can be de-valued, then its values must have been 'worthless' to begin with.
My point is: don't join an organization on the premise that you're going to change it to work for 'you,' but rather, join it because you want to work to promote the morality and ethics that organization holds and represents.
____
I am pro-choice, yet I value life - I see priority. The Church does not. I wouldn't make an honest member, and I no longer practice the fellowship; but that doesn't mean that I can't still hold other values and principles of the Institution. Nor would I want to see the Church change it's stance on abortion; easy come, easy go, and before you know it, abortion might be viewed as a method of birth-control, which to me, would be a disgusting notion. Just my thoughts.
I agree, RW.
I thought views had relaxed on the use of birth control, but maybe I'm wrong. I agree with the government's viability views, allowing ending a life in progress up to a point. I don't judge anyone's decision in doing what they think is best.
What's the problem? Do we need to be the the nanny state for everything?
Last thing I heard girls of all ages can get the Plan B pill without prescription which covers them from becoming pregnant up to 72 hours after intercourse. With this new ruling as it is these days, there shouldn't be near as many abortions needed.
Obama Administration To End Age Restrictions On Plan B
By Igor Volsky on June 10, 2013 at 9:44 pm
The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) said in a statement that it has asked the manufacturer of Plan B One-Step to submit a supplemental application seeking approval of the one-pill product to be made available O.T.C. without any such restrictions and intends to approve it promptly. Generic versions may also be eventually approved. The morning after pill prevents conception if taken within 72 hours after sexual intercourse .
The decision comes after a federal judge in April ordered the FDA to lift restrictions on the morning-after pill. The administration responded to the ruling by lowering the age restriction from 17 to 15 , sparking the ire of health groups and district Judge Edward Korman, who, in a series of contemptuous opinions, called the administrations defiance an i nsult to the intelligence of women and a charade meant to stall his original order. Last week, the Second Circuit Court of Appeals ordered the administration to make two-pill versions of emergency contraception immediately available over the counter to women of all ages.
Womens health groups embraced the administrations decision on Monday, calling it a huge breakthrough for access to birth control and a historic moment for womens health and equity. The FDAs decision will make emergency contraception available on store shelves, just like condoms, and women of all ages will be able to get it quickly in order to prevent unintended pregnancy, Planned Parenthood Federation of America president Cecile Richards said in a statement.
Medical experts have consistently argued that the administrations arbitrary age limits have no basis in scientific research, as multiple studies have found Plan B to be safer than aspirin for all ages . In December 2011, the FDA approved Plan B for over the counter use for all women, but amended its policy after Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius overruled the agency, claiming that the manufacturer had failed to study whether the drug was safe for girls as young as 11.
It may be different. I don't know.
Just to note re your statement:
I tend to agree with this, but I want 100% agreement, not top down (rule by oligarchy), nor consensus (majority rule=mob rule) - I think a change should be all or nothing in agreement, within an organization or small group. I think that's the most considerate and fair.
Six, by nanny state in this context, are you implying that Obamacare wants to pay for it[Plan B]? I'm not questioning it, I'm just wanting to make sure I got your point.
Additionally, I have my own opinions on abortion, but to make sure I understand correctly 'their' terminology and use in your report, Plan B would be like an abortion - not birth control [which means prevention of conception]. In other words, I disagree with those that say 'conception' doesn't take place until implantation in the uterus. I see conception taking place the moment the sperm meets the egg, forming a zygote, and I believe the Church believes it's at that moment that a soul is given, so it is seen as a person at that time, which is different from how science views it. So, Plan B would effectively be an abortion, if conception took place. As an aside, I tend not to agree with it for two reasons - I think it creates a different attitude in women, using abortion as birth control, and I don't trust the safety of it, particularly at any age].
Considering the human predilection for war and other self harming practices, (not to mention natural disasters beyond human control) a Malthusian catastrophe at this point seems rather remote.
As I see it, Francis made his announcement to calm down the reactionary Catholics, whom are pretty well stuck in the anti-abortion mode to the exclusion of all other evils that exist in this world.
In some ways, it helps to know theological reasons as to the Catholic doctrine particularly related to abortion and birth control.and homosexuality.
To summarize, in Catholic theology, sex is a gift from God in order to procreate. Life begins at the moment of conception. Now this is where most Catholics and many Christians stop. Abortion is murder and that is that. Murder is a sin against humankind. However, Catholic theological precepts go beyond that.
Also at the moment of conception, the entity is spiritually endowed with a soul. It is the Catholic belief that God wants our souls, not our corporeal forms, when we die. To deny God a soul is an affront to God her/his self. The greater sin is to offend God, not humankind. This is to say that birth control which prevents a human from being formed also prevents a soul from being gestated.
The dichotomy here is that while many Catholics are against abortion, they practice birth control, which is as I pointed out, is a greater sin than abortion.theologically speaking. This was explained in the papal encyclical letter, Humanae Vitae, by his Popeness; Paul 6 (VI) in 1968.
Humanae Vitae went over like a rock with Catholics, many who rejected it for various reasons and is still, quite controversial. Small wonder Francis did not bring it up.
As for homosexuality, being homosexual itself is not a sin. However having sex without the possibility of a life and soul (which is what God wants) coming into being (kind of hard between like genders) is also a sin equal to that of using birth control.
If anyone has been taught the Maslow's hierarchy of needs, one has to minister first to the basic components of mundane or human existence before you can tend to the spiritual needs and to that extent, I agree with Francis. The social evils that are being forced upon humankind by the corporations/banks and ideological extremists, need to be addressed first.
No, they are not! But they are part of the problem, too!!!
I had to look that up!
It's not so much the food/number of human mouths, as it is the poop. Most of the world has NO sewage treatment, no proper way to dispose of our waste products, and we are busy polluting, (via poop, chemicals, and general activities), our water supplies.
Clean water supplies are dwindling very fast-- and while some of them are renewable, thanks to rain, many of them are not, due to limited recharge. We are currently mining groundwater supplies that have taken millions of years to form, and can't be recharged. To me, that's a big problem.
As our population grows, we have greater demands for clean water, produce more poop, and ruin more potential sources of clean water.
I don't think that is remote, at all, nor does The Water Channel, nor do most scientists...
Well.... probably should have left the Nanny out of my comment, but I kind of get tired of everyone depending on the government to make every decision in our lives for us. So...
The drug mainly prevents pregnancy by stopping the release of an egg from the ovary, and by preventing the fertilization of an egg, Dr. Christopher Estes, assistant professor of obstetrics and gynecology at the University of Miami Miller School of Medicine, told MyHealthNewsDaily in a 2011 interview.
Full Information How Plan B Works
If this is true then there is never a fertilized egg, so in that case it wouldn't be an abortion, would it? Taken within 72 hours it is suppose to be very effective.
Maybe they can sell them in the women's restroom like they do condoms in the men's restroom. From what I understand and I don't know if it is true the age limit has been removed.
If you plan on having sex, stop by a convenience store or carry one in your pocketbook or design a little pill container on the bottom of your Iphone case if you're too young and don't carry a pocketbook.
And for that special moment when there's no turning back, you've got the rest of the night and more to get up take a wiz, a pill and a glass of water.
Pop the pill, have the sex or have the sex and then pop the pill. Better than a condom. No more pregnancies or abortions. Problem solved.
Hey.... you've been given the solution to the problem of facing an abortion so take a little responsibility yourselves.
Give them to your friends or children as a Christmas present. It's a whole new world. Draw a line through the part in the Bible that says sex before marriage is a sin. The population of Heaven will go up and there won't be as many souls in Hell to burn so maybe the fire will be a little cooler and eternity won't seem as long.
Wish they had these Plan B pills when I was growing up.
Oh yes separate that church and state as Flame has reminded us and we're home free. The Pope will have more time to spend on other things as well.
APax, Just my thoughts, but I think it makes more sense to let disease and circumstance take its natural course [natural population control], and allow natural birth to happen. That doesn't mean I'm favoring age, it just makes more sense to me. Oh, but that doesn't make money for the Cartels letting things take their natural course, does it. I don't believe that medical/pharma advancements were ever about actual health care - it was about making industries multi-billionaires. If we let life take its natural course, we wouldn't be concerned with over-population and pollution.
On the other hand, here's a thought I've read from others - the birth rate has dramatically decreased in the US, but not in other countries, necessarily. We risk becoming a minority in the grand scheme (anglos are already a minority in new births in the US according to what I read). Many fear from a religious perspective, that Islam will supersede Christianity as a result. If that happened here, they could become a majority in Congress, and could try to change laws and possibly amend the Constitution (if ratified). I thought that was interesting to consider.
Thanks for the clarification, Six.
When there were pharmacists refusing to sell plan B pills due to religious convictions [but agreed to sell contraceptives/condoms, IUD's and such], I thought it was because the pill stopped the blastocyst during cell division, essentially killing it. My liberal state governor got involved and passed legislation to prevent Pharmacists' from making their own decisions.
Took me down the wrong track... sorry.
I think you're right, AP.
APax, just to note, some of what you said is not how I was taught [but is viewed as propaganda against the Church] re the Church's beliefs, especially re homosexuality. They respect a person's sexual orientation outside of the Church, as they value life overall [and the current Pope respects a priest's orientation, as well as others as part of natural attraction, but I think he's saying he still wants to hold traditional foundations--that's where I find him not making sense]. What I was taught as the reason homosexuality is not to be a part of the organization was simply to protect the foundational principles, and to protect the sacrament of Matrimony[different from marriage], I never learned it as you said it--against God and his lust for souls--no... In fact, Catholicism is in many ways, as I pointed out in my Karma article, similar to Buddhism in that it seeks perfection, in the image, but Catholics believe it's to be done here, not in subsequent lives.
While I can understand the concern of water being contaminated by human feces, personally, I'm not too apprehensive about over population...at this point.
China's draconian "one child" only policy which was started in 1979, is a good study as far as how people react to and undermine, government attempts to limit population growth.
..And they also have gender-related [aborting girls] selective abortions, to limit population even further. That should really throw-off natural selection!
Wow! There was an article on the vine once, pointing to a lot of implicated outcomes--political especially, relating to the personality of leaders--as a result of selective gender breeding. Scary..
The truth is the white ethnic groups here and abroad have already reached the point where they haven't produced enough children and will become extinct. Wonder if racism will become extinct?
I'm not saying I'm right, I'm just relating what I understand to be true.
Chloe,
I deliberately did not get deep into the ecclesiastical Catholic dogma here, mainly because it doesnt make sense to me and I dont understand it. These are points that require having a living faith in a particular religion, which I lack. So what I did was summarize things.
I do know however that Catholic catechism which is taught to the Catholic faithful is less complex than Catholic theology which gets into the philosophical explanations behind eternal salvation, original sin, the sacraments, etc.
While I may understand the reasons behind their objections to same sex marriage, I obviously dont accept them. However I will stand by my statement that the Catholic belief in God wanting souls is at the crux of the matter. That explanation was started by Augustine and later, gone into detail in Aquinass Summa Theologica .
I took Catholic theology 101 in college for one reason; so I could argue with Catholics about gay rights, et al. To me, it was time well spent.
Is the Pope, Catholic?
Nice comment and pensive, RW. I hadn't thought to question a belief in God, before, but that could be! I have questioned their honesty in Catholic principles before [due to the obvious], but that also represents a relatively small number.
I think your point about family or societal pressure holds merit.
There's also blatant hypocrisy in the membership; not necessarily in Catholicism, but in protestant church-goers as well. Religion offers a safety net in many communities - a place for some to find help and support as a last resort; they aren't there because they believe in God or the tenets of that Faith, but because they need someone to care.
Chloe,
Flames question is rhetorical gibberish hence my trite reply. One can argue whether belief in God is a prerequisite for belonging to any judeo-christian sect but that accomplishes about as much as discussing the sound of one hand clapping.
To those whom have a sincere belief in God, via the various different religions and find comfort and solace in it, I say good for them. Live and let live.
I believe in a supreme divinity but far apart from the judeo-christian concepts of what such an entity is and such an abstraction to me, represents a spiritual "good."
I 'get it,' AP...at least my interpretation of your point.
I like quotes that express my thoughts about spirituality and 'Faith' - which to me are very personal. I never think of going to church as an expression of Faith, but more of a social event in fellowship and humanity...that has its place, too. Here are couple quotes that say it as I would like to:
By Emerson:
Make your own Bible. Select and collect all the words and sentences that in all your readings have been to you like the blast of a trumpet.
By John Lennon:
I believe in God, but not as one thing, not as an old man in the sky. I believe that what people call God is something in all of us. I believe that what Jesus and Mohammed and Buddha and all the rest said was right. It's just that the translations have gone wrong.
I agree with that, too, Raven. I've thought that exact same thing with some extended family members. For them, it's about climbing a social ladder in their network -- has absolutely nothing to do with their congregation and other people--only themselves and what's in it for them.
Thank you for your story, Raven. There's a lot of humility to be learned in that lesson.
I'm filled with emotion to read that about you and your brother, Raven. There's some of that "hope" that Neetu often talks about, that I too, often think about. You've shown us that sometimes the surprising or unexpected, does happen.
I'll explain flame,
My first and most honest answer is I don't know. My second is; I don't care. My interest in Pope Francis is pretty much limited to his genuine concern for social issues which I champion. To my knowledge, he is the only world leader with enough renown, that is addressing the concerns of the poor and working class. There are no others.
Today, for example, "Pope Francis made one of his strongest attacks on the global economic system on Sunday, saying it could no longer be based on a "god called money" and urged the unemployed to fight for work. - ...
Our interests here are diametric. You see religion as nonessential, if not drag, on the community of humankind. Me, on the other hand, see a sincere belief on a god, God or any anthropomorphic celestial abstraction that is omniscience (infinite knowledge), omnipotence (unlimited power), omnipresence (present everywhere) and omnibenevolent (perfect goodness) as a positive force.
Rhetoric is basically the art of discourse, to what end however, is up to the participants. To engage me in discourse, however well intentioned, about something I cannot know nor have an interest in knowing, such as a popes belief in God, is irrelevant to me...at this point. I will support any person who can advocate for the poor and working class, a Pope notwithstanding.