The other 911
The date 9/11 has another memorable event in history .
In the nation of Chile the Allende government was slipping into complete socialism . There was rampant extreme inflation which was destroying the economy . The government was nationalizing the copper industry and basically destroying capital formation and free trade .
But then an interesting thing happened . The parliament called for a military coup . That's right ... the people's elected representatives voted to stage a coup ! So , on 9/11/1973 General Augusto Pinochet launched an attack which removed President Salvador Allende .
There is no way to gloss over the violence and repression which followed . There was torture and disappearances as well . But somehow a democracy emerged from the wreckage of the old structure .
Here is a quote from Chile's President Piera :
http://world.time.com/2013/09/11/chiles-president-speaks-with-time-40-years-after-its-911/
Chile had been a very stable democracy. [But] in the late 60s President [Salvador] Allende, who was the leader of the leftist socialist Marxist coalition, won the election, with [just] 36 percent of the vote. Even though President Allende was elected democratically, my opinion is that he started by not respecting basic democratic principles. He didnt have any respect for the law. This was a very dramatic situation for Chile because the Chilean people did not agree with transforming Chile to a socialist Marxist Cuban model. The situation started to become very controversial and very violent. At the same time he started to arm groups. A lot of people came from Cuba and other Latin American countries, the situation became very controversial, very violent on both sides. There was no dialogue.
This is the same kind of thing that happened in Egypt with the Morsi government . The president is elected democratically but then violates the structure of government and the rule of law . And like in Egypt the military staged a coup to redress the problems caused by one man .
The Pinochet government ended when he stepped down and permitted free elections . The resulting democracy has been an outstanding example for the world and especially for Latin America . There is far less poverty in Chile than the rest of that region . This was a coup with very positive results ... eventually .
Tags
Who is online
122 visitors

This first comment space I am reserving for a set of rules about conduct in my article . Any comments you make should be made by starting a new comment thread . Thanks for your cooperation .
New rules ... hat tip to Bill Maher :
If your goal is to inform , teach or learn you are welcome here .
If your goal is to belittle or berate then you are not welcome here .
Win at all cost attitude will not be tolerated . If you do not demonstrate an interest in replying tothe points madein an argument , but only to perceived personal deficiencies you are in violation of this rule set . Likewise if you reply to a comment which had stated argument points by simple disparaging comments [eg . "That was stupid"] instead of making a factual provable counter argument then you are in violation of this rule set .
In general commenters mustnotfocus on each other as topics , only the facts covered in the article or related material oron points madein subsequent comments .
Responding to arguments by simply repeating your own arguments is just propagandizing . The first one to start a comment thread must be respected . His points need to be addressed before you can propagandize your own POV . If all you want to do is state your own POV , start your own comment thread .
Anyone violating the above principles may be banned from the article &/or have his offending comments removed .
Any situation not covered by the above new rules are to be subsumed under the standard CoC .
It is hard to argue with history . It worked quite well in Chile . It has been positive [so far] in Egypt .Most democracies begin with violent revolution including the US . One more thing : what happened in Chile was voted for by the parliament , the people's elected representatives .
OK , there is not a complete correspondence with the US revolution . But what is a fact is that most [maybe all ?]democracies are born in blood shed . In the case of Allende he was subverting the Chilean democracy and the rule of law . Without the rule of law there is no democracy . Likewise in Egypt with Morsi .
" This is the same kind of thing that happened in Egypt with the Morsi government . The president is elected democratically but then violates the structure of government and the rule of law . And like in Egypt the military staged a coup to redress the problems caused by one man . "
Good observation, Petey. It is the same type of situation isn't it.
I hope some type of stabilization can be found for them. If I understand the situation correctly, the majority of their population are Sunni or Salafist, and the army represents an opposition reform Party. That would seem to present a challenge for the people to get someone elected that the military won't oppose.
I wouldn't be surprised if you were right . So the question becomes what brings about a beneficial result . I would venture to guess it would be that the person the coup was launched against was subverting the rule of law . In other words they had the idea of restoring democracy in the coup . BUT if there was no history of democracy to begin with launching a coup would just result in more destruction and repression . My conclusion : real democracy is worth fighting for . If you have none it is tricky to first establish one . But if you already have one it is worth protecting even with violence .
Thanks for your insightful comments . You are bringing about focus on a tricky subject and forcing me to think !
One difference between Egypt and Chile was the powerful influence of the Nobel prize winning economist Milton Friedman . He actually visited Chile and consulted with the newly formed government . Eventually that turned into a focus on a conservative economics approach to government . Maybe something like that would help Egypt as well ... but there may be other factors .
" Maybe something like that would help Egypt as well .. "
You might very well be onto something there, because I've read their economy is in shambles, somewhat, so a strong economic leader as well as meeting their other needs, would seem to be their answer.
I am not an economist and I know almost nothing about the economy of Egypt . So I am not going to venture unsubstantiated guesses about how that would apply to Egypt .
That goes to show how a nation's 'politics' are basically about its economics.
To me, that also points to why not just having knowledgeable advisors is critical, but I think an effective leader should also be well-versed in national economics.
(I do understand your point, tho - it was having the 'different' philosophy that caused the problem for the opposing view.)
Lefties are the opposite excuse for taking our money unethically for themselves - programs and taxes that don't work.
The other group use national loans and interest to make money for themselves.
It all works out the same in the end, tho, why they are essentially no different.
I want government, I just want it more under the peoples' control for transparency and accountability. There will still be corruption - but do we want it controlled by the Feds or the people?
I know you are a historian, Bob, so I believe you. Interesting. Always appreciate your knowledge.
I was just opining to Petey that I saw a similarity, as he did, with the existence of a military coup. I don't think either one of us was declaring historical knowledge as to what was 'behind' it, motivated the action.
Not for 'us' the citizens, you're right.
I meant for 'them' - I do believe it 'does' all work out the same for them.
Sure the rich were upset with him . So was the common man . That came about because of his incompetence in economic issues . His policies brought runaway inflation . The desperation that causes upsets all . In this case the popularly elected parliament decided to oust him by force . His gifts of weapons to several violent groups made that the only practical approach .
Also :
He didnt have any respect for the law.
[quote from president Piera ]
You can repeat it endlessly . That doesn't make it true . Here is a quote from the current president Piera :
That combined with the runaway inflation his impractical policies brought about made his downfall inevitable .
So does runaway inflation . Anyone as economically incompetent as Allende was bound to fall for that reason alone .
The fact that the ignorant lower classes believed that socialism would put a stop to that inflation was what happens when ignorance reigns supreme . Fortunately more educated heads prevailed ; people who understood basic economics got involved . That included Nobel prize winning economist Milton Friedman .
Yes . It was approved by the popularly elected parliament of Chile . It was NOT an act of a rogue military .
That is working out reeeally well in Norway ./sarc Students from all over the world go there to get free education .That puts an economic strain on the tax base .
Runaway inflation happened in Chile . It is not possible to finance many social programs out of thin air . You need a financial base to produce reliable taxes .
This is fantasy you are preaching . Runaway inflation means that one has to make purchases immediately before prices go up again . And if you are a wage employee you suffer greatly because your wage does not keep pace with the costs . Even an ignorant engineer knows that much ... your slick lies notwithstanding . [Ordinarily I would call such a statement merely inaccurate but since you are so knowledgeable about financial matters I'm going to call it a lie . ]
I never thought of that event as the first 9/11. I guess that was because the outcome was good. Hopefully that will be the way it goes in Egypt.
Bob,
In a perfect world, we would all have democracy. But we don't live in a perfect world. Proof of that is Russia. Poor Gorbi. The people complained about him all the time. But they love Putin. This is an odd phenom of oppressed people. They don't or can't transition into democracy. I am not fond of dictators, but in some cases, they do work.The Pinochet government was a necessary evil, that eventually gave the people of Chile a democracy.
Clearly you know nothing about being poor . Your confident assertion about how poor people live is arrogant and unsympathetic to human suffering .
Pinochet did that at the specific request of the popularly elected parliament . That was a direct order from the government to rein in the malfunctioning executive branch . It is an even more legal action than what happened in Egypt to the Morsi government . Violating the rule of law has consequences in a democracy . And that was what Allende did , not Pinochet .
Saying that the rich are the ones hit worst by high inflation is a generalization with little backup . As long as the wealthy can purchase gold or US T bonds they can protect their wealth . And I haven't even mentioned real estate holdings . The poor do not have those options . Even an ignorant engineer knows that much . And yes you do bluff ...
T-bonds are not denominated in foreign currency . They are in US currency and therefore subject only to US inflation rates . Gold is not subject to diminished value due to inflation . Those arguments are 100 % wrong .
Savings denominated in the local currency are another matter ...
Not in any actual school , only in your twilight zone head . But feel free to prove me wrong by linking to actual evidence ... In fact , since these arguments have been repeated I am going to insist on actual evidence if you want to continue this back & forth .
You certainly have't convinced me of that.
Perhapsyou could explain to us all, justwhat"engendered multipliers" and money distributed to lower income people, or "the poor" as you call them, has to do with inflation? We are discussing inflation are we not?
Money distribute by the government to lower income people is in fact spentimmediately, more likely for things they need,not want, and have not been able to purchase. Which means that money goes immediately back into the economy, which has a tendency to stimulate the economy, and has little to with inflation.
Inflation occurs when the cost of goods and services rises causing the consumer to be able to buy fewer of those goods and services, which results in a reduction of the purchasing power of each unit of currency.
As PC saidelsewherein this thread, the wealthy are hurt much less by inflationbecausethey have the means to protect their wealth by diverting their investments.
Reverting to that loaf of bread you mentioned, when the economy isexperiencingarapidrate of inflation, the wealthy can purchase 10 loaves of bread when the price is 2pesosper loaf, offsetting theinflationrate, but the poor guy that can't afford to by even one loafbecausehe only has 1 peso, has to wait until he can save up another peso to make his purchase, but because inflation has reduced the purchasing power of the peso, by the time he has 2 pesos that loaf of bread now cost 2 1/2 pesos.
This is not Economy 101, it's simple common sense.
When our guy gets fed up with not being able to get ahead of, or even keeping up with the inflation rate, it sometimes results in the overthrow of governments. After all, many of those that live in "peso country" are relatively short tempered.
So give it up B,everyonce in a while someone comes along that actually does know what their talking about and delivers an "intellectual sucker punch."(not a term I would normally use, but it is a term youcertainly should not be using)
There are 2 important points here :
1] B will not be back . He knows when he hasn't got a leg to stand on .
2] His point about the multipliers actually works against him . Social programs to the poor actually provide a large input towards increasing inflation since "the highest multiplier is for money distributed (through whatever process) to the poor, precisely because they are almost certain to spend it immediately"
So the result is that inflation tends to go even faster because of those multipliers . This is why socialism in combination with high inflation is the worst possible combination . It ruins the economy in the shortest possible time .
Probably doesn't have anything to do with the topic but I remember this interview of Milton Friedman by Phil Donahue:
Everyone ? There are 6 BILLION people in the world . Get real . Why doesn't everyone deserve a Harvard education ? Who cares how much that costs to provide ... not you !
Much of the world is having kids at a much higher rate than the west . Isn't that greedy as well ?Are we responsible for all of their brats ?
Should we help those who are opposed to our cultural values ? Many middle eastern Arabs try to kill the rest of the world . Should we teach them western chemistry so they can build bombs to blow us up ?
Great interview Six . I doubt that PhilDonohueaccepted any of that excellent info . Hewas a hopeless case ...
Being a little melodramatic are we Flame ? Indians still exist in the US . Their culture may not have survived but they have . Indian culture may be a noble and beautiful concept but it does not support vast numbers of people . Our culture does .
If you would do the work to count stuff and you studied more history you would agree with Friedman too .
What does any of that have to do with economics or Milton Friedman ?
Flame ,
Yes , by all means lets use thousands of acres of valuable land to let buffalo roam on . Where are you gonna live then ? Are you willing to move to another country to give up your space to some buffalo ? I'm callingBS [Buffalo Shit ] .
People who live in the real world .
We in the west have invented many concepts . One of them is the principle of law called self defense . If someone attacks you , you are permitted to defend yourself . Do you think that is a bad idea ?
Perhaps if you knew anything about this subject you wouldn't ask such an uninformed question . The middle eastern Arabs have attacked many countries besides the US . They include Thailand , China , India , the Phillipines and Nigeria . That should give you pause so as to not try so hard to justify the actions of bomb throwing religious crazies .
And you are not from middle eastern Arab countries .
Why have they attacked many Asian countries ? Is it the same reason ?
You can't even read my entire comment but you accuse me of being unobjective . TRY REREADING MY COMMENT .
I will just as soon as you reread my comment and reply to what I actually said . If you don't do that you are violating my rules for conduct . They are posted in the reply to the 1st comment on page 1 . DO NOT VIOLATE THEM AGAIN OR YOU WILL BE EJECTED FROM THIS ARTICLE . Here is a link
Right now Islamists are attacking a shopping mall in Kenya . Why are they doing that ?
Again you are missing my point . I brought up the East because the argument you used for the attacks against the west don't work there . I am not acknowledging your point because it is based on the ridiculous claims that :
1] terrorists need reasons [that we would understand] and 2] that they would actually state those reasons in English .
If you can't explain the terrorist attacks in the east with the same arguments used in the west then they are wrong . Find another argument . Here's mine :
Your entire stance is to get behind the underdog . You don't question what he is doing nor what he says . You accept it all as fait accompli . I don't . It is all needlessly destructive . If terrorists want death then let's give them their own death .