╌>

A September Evening

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  jonathan-p  •  13 years ago  •  15 comments

A September Evening

For a while, the eyes still seemed to see them there, perfect straight lines rising into the sky, an empty space on the horizon that your mind filled in without even thinking. You walked past, and thought, "Of course they're there. They're always there" and you saw them as they were, grey ghosts of steel rising above the rubble. You saw the city as it was and then you remembered that city is gone.

New York, the old grimy bustling city, has made way for two cities. The Bloombergian city of the yuppie toting a bag of organic groceries to her Citibike and the miniature Detroits of housing projects and endless grievances.
The old imaginary city still exists in the countless movies being filmed on every block where space aliens, monsters and superheroes regularly rampage past stereotypical cabbies with Brooklyn accents, but that city is fading away.
The tourists flock to see the shadow of that city which lingers on like the shadow of the towers.
On September 11, Ground Zero was New York. Today you can see Mexican and African vendors peddling commemorative patriotic knickknacks made in China and on a bad day the Truthers show up howling their contempt for the site. Tourists stop by and pose for snapshots with their families. Office workers walk by without thinking. The site, like the towers, is just something that's there.
Tonight and the night before as the towers of light cast blue beams across the sky, we remember but memory is a destructive medium. Each year the memories grow fainter. People ask each other where they were that day but the stories grow fainter each year and the memories of walking across the Brooklyn Bridge, stumbling through the ash or handing out sandwiches to rescue workers have dimmed.
To walk through the darkness toward the towers of light is to pass through a city of shadows. In a stray glimmer of light reflecting from a storefront or a puddle you can still see the old MISSING posters covering every face and dark trucks filled with grim men tearing apart the street asphalt. You can catch glimpses of a city reeling from the incomprehensible.
New York City is used to tragedy. Terrible things happen here all the time. The oldest photos of the city show the same stunned faces, legs lying in a puddle of blood, gawking children and stern cops frowning at something we cannot see. And relentlessly the blood is washed away, the tears are dried and the city moves on. September 11 left behind more blood, more legs and more frowning police... but the ashes have still been dumped in a landfill, the tears dried and the city moved on.
September 11 has become a tragedy and tragedy is an experience, not an explanation. It is a bonding experience that gives way to catharsis. The dead are mourned, the grief is expelled and the horror of it takes on the faint tinge of memory. It is no longer what is, but what was. It is not how we live now, but how we lived then. There is no longer a need for answers and that for many is also a relief.
"It is ridiculous to set a detective story in New York City. New York City is itself a detective story," Agatha Christie said.
missing-pics.jpg Most people who live here have given up on solving the city's detective stories. The weathered New Yorker is expected to meet the inexplicable with a shrug of the shoulders. Everything is strange, but the strangeness is the point. Everyone is living in a postmodern detective story with no solutions and no need for them.
In Murder on the Orient Express , Poirot arrives at the solution by realizing that only in America could such an unlikely collection of characters have met. By America, he means New York, and the city is still the ideal place to find unlikely collisions of characters.
There is still a murder to be solved and the suspects come and go in the streets below. The crime did not end with the murder of 3,000 people and the destruction of two towers. New schemes of mass murder are hatched every day across one river or the other. Maps are studied, charts are drawn up and the tools of the trade are gathered up by men who during the day sell papers or drive food trucks.
The murderers are still on the loose and what happened that terrible day was not an isolated incident, but part of a pattern of attacks taking place in a clash of civilizations. New York, the crossroads of civilizations, is a natural target for the attacks. New York is to the world what Mecca was to Arabia and the new Mohammeds are eager to do to it what Mohammed did to Mecca.
Bin Laden is dead, but the Muslim Oilsphere is full of other wealthy sons warring against the West. His backers are alive and the drone attacks that kill Al Qaeda leaders don't touch their money men in the Oilsphere. The clerics who teach young Muslim men about the glories of martyrdom can rest easy. They can even open up a mosque at Ground Zero.
This conflict of ideologies and collision of cultures is nothing less than the perpetuation of the great Islamic crusade against the Other. And where better to wage that war than in the places where others meet others every day? What better target than a World Trade Center for a violent ideology built on merchants turned robbers and robbers turned merchants?
In a city where everyone is different, it can be difficult for some to understand that the attackers were motivated by those differences. Their war against us is an attack on people who are fundamentally and incomprehensibly different than they are.
Islam is xenophobia written into unholy writ, a long chain of conquest, subjugation and cultural destruction by desert nomads who know how to drive a sharp bargain, but despite their claims of golden ages and scientific discoveries, have never been anything more than the jackals sniffing around the ruins of greater civilizations.
It is as natural for them to attack us as it is for us to wonder why we were attacked.
Americans hold the peculiar belief that life need not be a zero sum game. That we can learn from other people without turning them into our subjects. That we can make more of something instead of stealing from a finite amount that someone else has and then destroying them so that they can never get it back.
That is the great creative power of American Exceptionalism. It is a transcendent force that turned a land full of refugees into a world power brimming with technological wonders.
New York, that strange part-Dutch, part-English, part-Everything-else city, runs on the creativity of the impossible. Starving artists, aspiring actors, failed musicians, flailing poets, real estate mavens without a dime and brokers trading thin air gamble on the impossible. New York always seems on the verge of total anarchy and destruction and yet keeps going on in that strange half-mad creativity.

For Islam, the game is zero sum. If American civilization thrives, then their civilization is shadowed. If people are happy here, then they cannot be happy. If there are two towers in New York, that detracts from the glory of Islamic civilization. Islam is the bitter beggar forever looking to steal what it cannot have, worrying over the imaginary history of its own greatness and cursing the upstarts in the streets of a foreign city for taking the glory was rightfully theirs.
The American who shares his good fortune with the rest of the world cannot understand that there are some people who would rather steal than accept a gift, who would rather destroy than build and who would rather drown the world in darkness than accept someone else's light.
With some difficulty he might accept the existence of a small number of people who think this way, but an entire civilization built in this mold is too obscene an idea.
As with so many other strange things that wash up in the concrete streets of a strange city, it is easier to leave the mystery unsolved, to let the blanket fall back over the clash of civilizations and go on forward. It is the way that things have always been done in the city and as twin rays of light bisect the sky, they remind New Yorkers of their own fortitude, and not of the enemy waiting outside the light.
Outside a shadow war is waged with drones and hackers, spies and journalists, men in mosques speak quietly of terror and other men listen over the phone. There is little truth in this shadow war, but in some moments the light pierces the darkness and those who have forgotten why we are doing this, remember. And then they remember to forget.

http://sultanknish.blogspot.com/2013/09/a-september-evening.html


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    13 years ago

JR,

Melancholia often gives way to anger in many of our life experiences. If a loved one passes unnaturally, we look for answers. When murder is that unnatural event, and the perpetrator hasn't been apprehended, we can be susceptible to these types of feelings and emotions.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    13 years ago

The segue occurs when he visits the "murder mystery" motif. From there, he goes into who he believes to be responsible for the murders.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    13 years ago

The handling of this tragedy was all-American, with a New York flavor. Clean up the mess, care for those in mourning, and get things back to "normal" as quickly as possible. Try not to dwell too heavily on it, but shame on you if you ever forget.

As we reflect on this anniversary, we see that the world has not changed much. The risk of tragedy is ever present, and those responsible continue to proliferate in number. They are incapable of sharing joy with us. Our misery is their joy. I look forward to the day when we stop trying to understand this behavior.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

Jonathan,

I do not turn on the TV today. I do not listen to the list of names. I can't. Having witnessed the unthinkable, I have no need to relive the past. No one can write about this, who was not there. They can only imagine what it was like, like a person trying to imagine the loss of a child. It is impossible to do, unless you are among the unfortunate who have lost a child.

New Yorkers never forget. The gap in the skyline as you go over the Long Island Expressway to the Midtown tunnel, is a daily reminder for most. Matt looks out his window from Hoboken every day, and sees the whole in the sky, and remembers the day, that he didn't know if I was dead or alive. September 11, is the day that the rest of the US remembers, but we New Yorkers, remember everyday.

I have to agree that the article is a bit jarring. If you think that we are not totally vigilant, you must think again. We walk around with the mantra "If you see something, say something". Penn station has ever present National Guard. At any big event, more cops, more national guard and dogs.

We are aware of the dangers of radical Islam. You were not there for the protest of the 9/11 Mosque, but I was. The unions refused to build it. That was the end game. New Yorkers are aware that Mosques come in all flavors, and hence the surveillance program, which BTW has the help of the Muslim community. Good Muslims who don't want to be a part of 9/11.

I hate this day. I hate it because it is both fake and real. It is just symbolic to the rest of the US, of an ever present evil. It is real to every New Yorker. The day that part of New York's soul died.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

This was so very well expressed. Thank you.

I particularly like these:

Americans hold the peculiar belief that life need not be a zero sum game. That we can learn from other people without turning them into our subjects. That we can make more of something instead of stealing from a finite amount that someone else has and then destroying them so that they can never get it back. That is the great creative power of American Exceptionalism. It is a transcendent force that turned a land full of refugees into a world power brimming with technological wonders.

The American who shares his good fortune with the rest of the world cannot understand that there are some people who would rather steal than accept a gift, who would rather destroy than build and who would rather drown the world in darkness than accept someone else's light.

I do agree that we are exceptional - at least, we once were. We didbuild that. Being exceptional isn't magic; it takes work, patience and dedication. We can try to show someone else the light, but we can't 'force' them to take it - that's something we still have yet to learn.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    13 years ago

Last month, I visited the 9/11 Memorial for the first time. I worked in 2 WTC, 56th Floor, for a few years. I find myself in NYC a few times a year, but this was the first time I made the trip downtown. When you say you don't want to watch or listen, I get it.

The Freedom Tower is a beautiful structure, to be sure. Personally, I feel the need to feel encouraged and hopeful when beholding it. It is a symbol of the rebuilding that we Americans will do if you try to knock us down. We will come back and build again. It's like one big extended middle finger pointing across the water. "Think ya beat us? Fuck you, assholes". That's the NYC response.

The author is driving home the point that we cannot regain footing unless we do a number of things, and the first thing is to acknowledge that we cannot reason with those who wish to destroy us. We have to stop analyzing, placating, equivocating and most of all, trying to make friends. These are not our friends. These are people that we must stop associating with. We must stop sending aid. We must stop purchasing their products and commodities. We need to go our own way.

It's not a fake day, Perrie. It's real. But it's only a part of our memory now. And we must never forget. And that which does not kill you, makes you stronger. We've got a scar on our soul, but that's just where we took the blow. We didn't lose any of our soul. It's just a little more coarse; a little tougher.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

I imagine that the relatives of those innocentswhohappen to beblown apart by American drone strikes have very similar feelings of unjustifiable loss.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    13 years ago

I think we are starting to learn. We've been talking about energy independence for a little over 40 years, but only recently have we begun to take concrete measures. "Drill, drill, drill" has finally resulted in the US becoming a net exporter of petroleum. This obviates the need to deal with OPEC in any manner. As we continue to become more stingy in our use, we will have an effect on the price of energy, further driving down the influence of those countries who do nothing other than produce oil and foment hatred.

We don't need to pretend to care about these countries anymore. We only did business with them, and got embroiled in far more than we ever bargained for. When we can stop doing business, we don't need to play the charade of friendship.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    13 years ago

Most of those "innocents" died because they allowed the targets in their homes. It's a crime to embed yourself in a populated civilian area. The victims only have their countrymen to blame. Perhaps they should not harbor them in this manner. Maybe they'd live a little longer.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

Americans hold the peculiar belief that life need not be a zero sum game.

Yes .

For Islam, the game is zero sum.

A religion that has attached itself to piracy and extortion is not involved with zero sum pursuits . Its founder got his start by robbing caravans . That often involved killing . That is a negative sum game .

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago
It's a crime to embed yourself in a populated civilian area.

It's just as much of a strategy as a crime. When it works, thetargetsstay alive, when it doesn't work, the range of deaths still salvagea purpose. Regardless, I'm sure there are many innocent pawns in dictatorships who know the feeling of losing a loved one to such violence. Imagine never being able to go to or send your child to a supermarket without the risk of suicide bombers taking their life. In the US this is a rarity far more extreme than a lightening strike, in some countries it's every week.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

We don't need to pretend to care about these countries anymore. We only did business with them, and got embroiled in far more than we ever bargained for. When we can stop doing business, we don't need to play the charade of friendship.

I agree with your thoughts. The best diplomacy, imo, is to stop aid and trade, not dropping bombs on them, hoping to force our 'will' on others, to get them to change.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

I might not have been physically present in NY that day, but I remember everything I saw that was televised by both journalists and citizen-reporting [hoping it wasn't propagandized/altered in any way], as if it happened yesterday; and if true, I might have seen more than if I was standing blocks away. I saw footage of explosions going off in a symmetrical pattern on the opposite side of the building from the plane's impact. It was obviously a very detailed plan of events in making sure the buildings went down the way they did. If I let my mind go there, I can still see and hear the people jumping from the building and the noise of them making impact. The reporter confirmed that's what the noise was, looking down away from the camera, holding back emotion. I will never forget that thought that crossed my mind that morning of how I would have handled that decision - being burned alive or to jump out the window, hoping for a chance of survival.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

Very good explanation of the difference between zero sum and negative sum, Petey.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

Related topic : the other 911 , an important event in the previous century :

 
 

Who is online




122 visitors