╌>

How We Lost the Syrian Revolution

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  buzz-of-the-orient  •  13 years ago  •  12 comments

How We Lost the Syrian Revolution

How We Lost the Syrian Revolution

A Syrian activist in Aleppo laments the lost revolution as he reveals the sense of betrayal felt after rebels looted and ravaged his city.

By Edward Dark for Al-Monitor, translated by Sibel Utku Bila

@edwardedark . Edward Dark is a pseudonym for a Syrian currently residing in Aleppo. He tweets at @edwardedark .

5964_discussions.jpg

Forces loyal to Syria's President Bashar al-Assad carry their weapons as they move during what they said was an operation to push rebels from the road between Dahra Abd Rabbo village and Castello, in Aleppo, May 27, 2013. (photo by REUTERS/George Ourfalian)

So what went wrong? Or to be more accurate, where did we go wrong? How did a once inspirational and noble popular uprising calling for freedom and basic human rights degenerate into an orgy of bloodthirsty sectarian violence, with depravity unfit for even animals? Was it inevitable and wholly unavoidable, or did it not have to be this way?

The simple answer to the above question is the miscalculation (or was it planned?) of Syrians taking up arms against their regime, a ruthless military dictatorship held together by nepotism and clan and sectarian loyalties for 40 years of absolute power. Former US ambassador to Syria Robert Ford specifically warned about this in his infamous visit to Hama in the summer of 2011 just as the city was in the grip of massive anti-regime protests and before it was stormed by the Syrian army. That warning fell on deaf ears, whether by design or accident, and we have only ourselves to blame. Western and global inaction or not, we are solely responsible for our broken nation at the end of the day.

Nietzsche once said, "Whoever fights monsters should see to it that in the process he does not become a monster. That has proved to be very prophetic in the Syrian scenario. Away from all the agendas, whitewashing, propaganda, and outright lies of the global media stations, what we saw on the ground when the rebel fighters entered Aleppo was a far different reality. It hit home hard. It was a shock, especially to those of us who had supported and believed in the uprising all along. It was the ultimate betrayal.

To us, a rebel fighting against tyranny doesnt commit the same sort of crimes as the regime hes supposed to be fighting against. He doesnt loot the homes, businesses and communities of the people hes supposed to be fighting for. Yet, as the weeks went by in Aleppo, it became increasingly clear that this was exactly what was happening.

Click this link to read the whole article, it is heart-wrenching:

http://www.al-monitor.com/pulse/originals/2013/05/syria-revolution-aleppo-assad.html#ixzz2eRVoRvAg


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

This article has made me even sadder over what is happening in Syria as I was before. The truly sincere activists will lose this battle to the rebels or the regime. I see a similarity in what happened in Egypt when Mubarak was deposed - it was not the good people who won; it was just another evil result, perhaps even worse than what it replaced.

 
 
 
jennilee
Freshman Silent
link   jennilee    13 years ago
I think you are right, Buzz. We are used to good guys vs bad guys and trying to be on the side of good. But now, there is bad guys vs bad guys, and both sides are capable of, and have done, horrific deeds, the likes of which we in the US cannot even comprehend. So we have been asked to support one side over the other and we cannot. Whichever side wins, many people lose and we, as Americans, are not willing to commit our sons and daughters to that end. Democrat, Republican, or somewhere in between, most of us agree on that, as public opinion has shown
 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

Sorry Sixpick, I'm unable to open the video, or whatever it was you posted, so I cannot comment on it.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

Same with this one, Sixpick.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

Not an easy read. I don't know any answers to this, but can feel this man's pain and suffering.

I'm sad for all of them.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

What there is Buzz is just the crowd you see thru out the entire video chanting, nothing more in the one above.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

Buzz the one about Israel is a group of people expressing their solidarity with the Syrian people for the suffering they are experiencing. Different speakers speaking against the massacre in Syria.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

Syria conflict: from peaceful protest to civil war

Two years ago, no-one thought that Syrian citizens would take to the street, shouting out loud calling for freedom and change.

The heavy sense of dictatorship and memories of the 1980s made Syrians think the wave of change in the region would never come to their country.

But it did happen. At first, people were surprised, but above all shocked that their government would fire on peaceful protesters in Deraa. Every day, the death toll increased and in reaction more people took to the street.

The movement started as protests calling for more freedom and dignity. The way the government handled the events since those first days drove more and more people to oppose President Bashar al-Assad.

At first, no-one was calling for the regime to fall. Many people had hopes that the young president would respond to their calls and punish those of the security forces who killed innocent civilians.

But the wave of killings and arrests, torture and humiliation targeting people who were not even involved in the demonstrations drove many who steered clear of politics to join the protest movement.

Voices silenced

Today, government shelling has silenced the voices of peaceful protest. Demonstrators are no longer giving roses to soldiers and security men chanting: "One, one, one, the Syrian people are one."

Ghaith Matar, the activist who initiated the practice of handing a rose and a bottle of water to troops, was found murdered in Daryya in mid-2011.

The BBC's Lina Sinjab: "Under the surface, many lives have been torn apart"

No more men and women are dancing in public squares to the sound of freedom songs made popular by Ibrahim al-Qashoush, who composed "Go, Go Bashar" in Hama.

He too was killed and dumped in a river, his throat cut and his vocal cords removed.

No protesters in Damascus throw rubber balls with the word "freedom" written on them to bounce about outside the president's home.

No more jokes about the plot to implant aubergines from Homs with bombs or sticks symbolising the Kalashnikovs that protesters were, according to the reports on government TV, meant to be carrying.

There are real Kalashnikovs and bombs now. What started as a peaceful call for freedom soon turned into violence, armed confrontation and eventually civil war.

More than 70,000 civilians have been killed. The cost of destruction exceeds $80bn and the fighting is far from done.

Opposition forces are gaining ground across the country and the types of weapons being used by the army - shelling, Scud missiles and air strikes - are ever heavier. And mainly the victims are civilians.

Exhaustion

Two years into the revolution, society is polarised and the Syrian flag is abandoned. Revolutionaries wave a green flag and government supporters a red one.

But with the country now in the grip of death and destruction, everyone is above all fearful and tired.

Towns and families have been divided. Moving between a city and surrounding areas can be impossible.

Syrian uprising

  • March 2011 : Protests erupt in Deraa after youths are arrested for painting revolutionary slogans. Security forces shoot a number of people in Deraa, triggering more unrest
  • May: Tanks enter Deraa, Homs and suburbs of Damascus
  • July : Hundreds of thousands of people across the country protest
  • Oct : Opposition Syrian National Council formed
  • Dec : Damascus agrees to allow Arab League observers into the country
  • May 2012: Some 108 killed in Houla, near Homs - UN later blames Syrian troops and militia
  • Aug: Hundreds killed as troops storm Damascus suburb of Darayya
  • Nov : Opposition groups unite in National Coalition for Syrian Revolutionary and Opposition Forces
  • Dec : US recognises coalition as "legitimate representative" of Syrian people
  • Jan 2013: At least 100 people killed and burned in their homes in Haswiya, near Homs
  • Feb : UN estimates up to 70,000 have been killed

Checkpoints and road blocks are almost everywhere as the government tries to cut off suburbs, which are often the main areas of revolts, from city centres, which are mostly under government control.

Even among the president's loyalists, people are exhausted.

Hassan Raya has lost one of his four children. His son Bassel, a national basketball player, was killed by rebels last May. He was said to have been part of a pro-government militia.

Hassan now says he sees supports dialogue and reconciliation, though he sees those who killed his son as mad and irresponsible.

But Hassan lives in Mezzeh 86 district in Damascus, a predominantly Alawite stronghold of Assad loyalists. For people here, a political solution means keeping their president in power.

The government has set up a ministry of reconciliation led by Ali Haidar, who has himself lost a son in the conflict.

"Tomorrow the number of victims will increase," he says, "But a rapid political solution would end the bloodshed and destruction."

But hardly anyone now believes what the government says, or that a political settlement is possible.

Zaidoun al-Zobi, an activists who was jailed for three weeks and freed after mediation by international envoy Lakhdar Brahimi, doubts the government is serious about negotiations.

"If they are honest, let them at least release all the prisoners inside the jails to start with," he says.

Looking to future

Um Osama, who is in her late 60s, has lost two sons. She and her husband are now in charge of raising the grandchildren. She doesn't believe in a political solution.

"They killed my two sons, destroyed my house, burnt out the area. Who will we talk to?" she asks.

But amid the violence, there is a great sense of hope. Among civilians, there is an unprecedented sense of solidarity.

People are sharing homes, clothes and food - notably with the hundreds of thousands displaced by the fighting.

The sense of freedom is palpable, with opposition voices speaking out. More than new 30 online publications are promoting democracy, despite the crackdown.

In some opposition-controlled areas, civilians and rebels are establishing local councils to get the services working.

And as people start to look past the civil war, some are protesting against rebel groups that have committed abuses or which, like the Nusra Front, are seeking to Islamise society.

Syria has risen against tyranny and will never be the same again.

To see this article and also a video click here: Link

As you can see this article starts where we and the other nations should have started to make a difference if we were going to do anything, but now we only have two choices and both of them are bad choices to choose from. We could have made a difference when this all started, I believe, along with the rest of the world. At this time it has turned into a bunch of rabid animals and the people of Syria are all victims.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

To us, a rebel fighting against tyranny doesnt commit the same sort of crimes as the regime hes supposed to be fighting against. He doesnt loot the homes, businesses and communities of the people hes supposed to be fighting for. Yet, as the weeks went by in Aleppo, it became increasingly clear that this was exactly what was happening.

It's apparent that Human Nature isn't selective, isn't it..

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

Syrian civil war

 
 

Who is online






117 visitors