A Letter to Chris Hayes
To Chris Hayes,
On your show, All In, you pointed out that climate change deniers deny because they know the necessary remedies are not acceptable within the scope of their ideology and world view. One of your guests said, (paraphrase) If the remedies offered by the left were more palatable to conservatives, then conservatives would find the problem more believable. No one, left or right, needs to say anything about remedies simply hearing of this problem carries with it a basic understanding of the necessary remedies. You dont have to be a scientist to know that if mankind is doing things that cause significant global ecosystem damage then mankind must make significant changes. People who tout liberty as their mantra dont want to hear they need to be limited in any way at all. So the only palatable remedy for those people is to refuse to believe there is a problem.
Actually, I feel most of us react in a similar way people on the left, like you and me, Chris even many of the same scientists who are telling us global climate change is a problem we too look for remedies within the scope of what we find palatable. What if the proper remedy lies outside the scope of what were willing to accept?
Im an engineer, not a climate scientist, so I am not qualified to address the specific changes necessary to remedy the mess weve created (and by the way, the mess covers much more than the climate). Even so, its clear to me that those of us who see and acknowledge the problems mankind has brought on our planetary ecosystem still only consider those solutions that let us keep the lifestyle we have. With only good intentions we tell our children, Dream big. The skys the limit. Go for it! Suggesting that we should live with less is heresy. Telling our children there must be limits on their aspirations is utterly ludicrous. So we search for solutions only within the realm of what WE find palatable quietly telling ourselves, we are clever enough to invent a better mousetrap. We shirk the notion that we may need to be content with fewer clever inventions.
You can have anything you want if you want it badly enough. You can be anything you want to be, do anything you set out to accomplish if you hold to that desire with singleness of purpose.
~ Abraham Lincoln
Thats a laudable assertion, but its fraught with problems. It was more appropriate in Abraham Lincolns day than it is now in the age of industry and technology. Mankind was doing plenty of damage to our environment even in Lincolns day, but todays technology enables us to do far more damage than the planet can sustainably repair.
If we are to operate with a singleness of purpose and survive, then it must be a group purpose. Not the group of people who think strictly the way I think, not the group comprised of the citizens of my country, not even the group of all human beings It must be the group that includes all creatures and all elements of the limited resource we call planet Earth.
Live Simply So Others May Simply Live,
~ Mohandas Gandhi

Thanks for taking the time to offer your thoughts on this, Raven Wing!
Excellent article Mal. The on going destruction of Mother Earth will reach a point that she is not able to repair herself.
That is when those that choose to partake in the damage will soon realize that you can't drink oil.
Mike, yes I have to agree with much of what you stated. The carbon credit thing is really nothing more than allowing the pollution to move between companies with really no decrease. It will become a ''traded item''.
Of course there are many that will make millions/billions from this, since the goal isn't to reduce the destruction of Mother Earth, but to make money. IMO, the politicians will line their own pockets, with the money flowing in from the groups you mentioned above.
When they start talking about ''government oversight'', I can't help but laughing in their faces. Government agencies can't ''oversee'' the toilet paper supply in their own buildings.
Mankind is very short sighted. They want instant gratification. People don't think about what they do that effects the the earth. Even if you don't believe in AGW, there is so much that we are doing that is damaging the earth. We are cutting down our forests, poisoning our earth and water with chemicals, over fishing our water. And all life comes from the ocean, so when they die, so do we.
Gandhi was spot on!
So you need "total" agreement, instead of the existing97%-98% of climate scientists agreement that humans are contributing to climate change? By the way, climate scientists are the only types of scientists who have a background worthy of consideration for such a complex topic, so please don't point to mathematics professors or biologists as legitimate deniers. You seriously need to ease up on the weed man. Here's a question - what if 98% of climate scientists believed that climate change was not impacted by humans? Would you then play devil's advocate because it wasn't a "total" consensus, and then take the position that humans are contributing toclimate change? It seems to me that you just like to find a conspiracy in everything. I bet if you quit smoking weed for a few months your head might clear up and allow reality to sink back in.
Perfect!!!
I gotta agree with that... BUT the big dollars in this argument are coming from the fossil fuel industry, and those dollars are "motivating" a handful of paid skeptics.
ABSOLUTELY!!! All one has to do is take a good look around...
As I said in this article, those who don't want to change will simply choose to adjust their beliefs... It's so easy to simply say, "I don't believe that." Even with the evidence staring you in the face.
[Mal chuckles...] Actually jcw, I think many (not all) of these folk are plenty smart enough... but they have succumbed to the seductive temptation to "believe" the world is what they wish it was rather than what it truly is. Belief is so mailable...
BINGO!!! It is so common for "these folks" to flip the story on its head.
Oh come on Mike... You know exactly what I meant... Pretending you don't just damages your credibility.
dear Chris,
congrats on suppressing the lisp, and toning down the purple colored glasses, but you may want to change the banner above your show. sometimes it reads: ALL IN, WITH CHRIS HAYES...LEAN FOWARD.
leading into madcow isnt really helping either..
yours,
j
Hi Raven Wing,
I have learned it is best to just ignore sophomoric comments such as the one denigrating Chris Hayes and his lisp. People who take pleasure in denigrating the difficulties of others are only trying assuage their own insecurity. I wouldn't bother giving them the time of day until they grow up.
I do appreciate your efforts to keep her on topic though... THANKS!!!
I completely agree JFT! How sad to be a member of such a shamelessly selfish generation. Addicted to the comforts technology has brought us.
Unfortunately, while this may have once been more-or-less a plausible scenario for (mostly white) Americans, politicians who are bought/owned by corporate profiteers, have made Lincoln's assertion, a platitude.
Hey there A Mac! Good to see you!
Perhaps so, but this "have, be, do" anything ideal is built into our culture, and thought of as a good aspiration... I'm not so sure it is.
Something like the Stupidest Generation....
We have the freedom to create a world where it is too hot to go outside and our kids can immigrate to Mars on a one way ticket.