╌>

Stop and Frisk coming to Detroit

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  dean-moriarty  •  13 years ago  •  3 comments

Stop and Frisk coming to Detroit

Link

frisk11n-1-web.jpg

City's version differs from stop-and-frisk used in NYC, police say

  • George Hunter
  • The Detroit News

Detroit The citys traffic cops are training to become more aggressive in trying to stop crime Detroits version of the controversial stop-and-frisk police tactic thats under scrutiny in the wake of a recent federal judges ruling.

The Manhattan Institute and Bratton Group, consultants hired to shape Detroit Police Department policy, pioneered the practice when they developed New Yorks stop-and-frisk program, which was ruled unconstitutional last week by U.S. District Judge Shira Scheindlin, who said police unfairly targeted blacks and Hispanics.

In Detroit, the consultants are implementing a stop-and-frisk initiative, laid out in their contract with the city, in which Traffic Unit officers are training to prevent street crime through the use of traffic stops.

The DPD Traffic Unit (will) evolve its mission from principally the issuance of tickets toward the prevention of crime, the contract says.

Detroit Police Assistant Chief Eric Ewing said the campaign is an extension of a longstanding practice.

Were already a stop-and-frisk agency; weve been doing it for years, he said. Thats just another way to say proactive policing.

Critics, including Scheindlin, say the practice leads to racial profiling, while advocates contend police cant target criminals in mostly-minority neighborhoods without arresting minorities.

Ewing said Detroit police dont specifically target minorities, but cant avoid stopping them in a city populated mostly by African-Americans. I can understand everyones concern about profiling, but Detroits population is mostly African-American, so of course were going to stop more black people, Ewing said. Thats not racial profiling; thats just good police work.

In her Aug. 12 ruling, Scheindlin said it was impermissible to subject all members of a racially defined group to heightened police enforcement because some members of that group are criminals, and ordered a federal monitor to oversee changes to New Yorks policy. New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg has appealed the decision, and contends stop-and-frisk tactics were instrumental in lowering the citys crime rate.

One New York mayoral candidate, Joe Lhota, chimed in. He said the judges decision was another step closer to making New York City like Detroit.

Manhattan Institute fellow Heather MacDonald, who decried the judges ruling, said it isnt likely to affect how Detroit officers do their jobs.

I think its a very big setback, MacDonald said. (Scheindlin) has embraced a flawed statistical model for determining when officers are racially profiling that uses a population benchmark rather than a crime benchmark that guarantees if officers are patrolling high-crime neighborhoods, which are primarily minority communities, theyre going to be vulnerable to racial profiling lawsuits.

Theres no way a police department can avoid generating racially disproportionate arrests, because the crime patterns are what they are, MacDonald said.

Ron Scott, director of the Detroit Coalition Against Police Brutality, said racial profiling isnt the only problem with stop-and-frisk policies.

It becomes a slippery slope where police feel they can stop people just because they think theyre about to do something, he said. You cant just indiscriminately stop people; thats not how a democracy works.

Ewing insisted officers dont stop people without reason. If we have reasonable suspicion someone is about to commit a crime, were allowed to stop that individual, he said. If we have a good reason to believe they may be armed say, if we see a holster, or a bulge that looks like a gun then were allowed to search them. Thats just being proactive.

Were not telling our officers they have to go out and stop X-number of people each day, Ewing said. But we are telling them to do police work.

East-side resident Cuban Williams said he was involved in a stop-and-frisk incident in April, when Detroit officers searched him and his car at a gas station on Van Dyke. He says he supports the stop-and-frisk policy.

Its sad it comes down to that, but realistically speaking, thats whats needed to prevent crime, said Williams, 34. Any effort is greatly appreciated. The police need to stop all these knuckleheads from shooting people and doing carjackings. Its all about how they approach you.

Ewing agreed police need to be proactive without violating citizens rights. He pointed out that Detroit is already under federal oversight and said officers are closely watched. Were in the business of constitutional policing, which means there are policies we have to adhere to, Ewing said. We understand that citizens have rights.

MacDonald said stop-and-frisk policies help minorities and the poor.

The reason police do proactive policing is to try to bring the same degree of public safety to poor communities as rich ones, she said. This is done to equalize peoples opportunities for success, and to make sure everyone has the same right to live in freedom from fear. Its actually a pro civil rights policy, I would argue.

ghunter@detroitnews.com
(313) 222-2134
The Associated Press contributed to this report



From The Detroit News: http://www.detroitnews.com/article/20130819/METRO01/308190024#ixzz2ckr1BMqy


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

I don't see any easy solution to this problem.

On one hand, it seems that "stop and frisk" does indeed lower violent crime-- significantly.

But OTOH, African-Americans and Hispanics are stopped much more than other people. (Even if the execution of this was truly "colour-blind, it would still happen. Because police would target high crimes areas-- and those areas are mostly heavily minority areas.)

Imagine if you were African-American. You might be stopped several times a moth-- possibly even more than once/wk. What a hassle! Plus, it just seems somehow unfair.

 
 
 
TTGA
Professor Silent
link   TTGA    13 years ago

I wouldn't go quite that far. It would give the police way too much power. Even in Detroit and Chicago, the vast majority of the people are honest folks who don't want those places to be like they are. Problem is that those people don't have the power to do anything about it.

 
 
 
TTGA
Professor Silent
link   TTGA    13 years ago

69.gif 69.gif 69.gif

 
 

Who is online


Gsquared
shona1


111 visitors