╌>

Have you seen these amazing pictures of Obama--in Egypt?

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  the-irascible-harry-krishner  •  13 years ago  •  15 comments

Have you seen these amazing pictures of Obama--in Egypt?

Have you seen these amazing pictures of Obama-- in Egypt?

If not-- why not? 39.gif

anti-obama-signs-in-egypt-they-really-dont-li-L-ikZGCt.jpeg

EgyptObama2.jpg egypttwitterpicObamaNoUSPeopleYesJuly72013.jpg egypt.jpg?w=650 130703174035-lead-reza-sayah-egypt-morsy-coup-ouster-00020611-horizontal-gallery.jpg ( Link)


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    13 years ago
 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

Edifying. Eventually the truth will prevail.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

Thank you for this, Krishna.

Ok... I'm trying to make sure I have the correct 'picture' of what's been happening. First to address, the implications with the photos.

1. Morsi and the MB - are Sunni (similar to what the US refer to as the 'Right') ?

2. The photos here are implicating that Obama was financially supporting them to keep them in power? (can be done many ways - same ways as the US has done for years)

___

1. Now to address the larger issue - is this correct? ...who outed Morsi was the Egyptian Socialist Party (their 'Left' per se - their liberals) ?

2. They now have a massive 'sit-in' protest there of people who want the foundational 'right-leaning' Sunni leadership -- NOT 'liberal' leadership that will undermine Sunni objectives for their nation?

Just to note, it this also true? = essentially - the Sunni religious leadership would be closer to a 'Republic' which means that sovereignty lies with the individual, and the body of citizens would be 'advisory' and the individual 'can' go against group-think -- whereas, the ousters (their 'liberals') want a Democracy - *which means the individual and minority group have no say* - democracy is 'majority rule' and means sovereignty lies with the majority group, and the individual and minority are at the rule of the dictatorial 'majority' group ?

This is the exact same conflict we have in the US... we 'are' a Republic here, NOT a Democracy. Our leader is trying to force us into a Democracy-style of government. The difference has been, here, they're doing slowly - there, it happened too abruptly, and the people have formed a giant protest?

I want a Republic, not a mob-rule majority dictatorship -Democracy- for the US, too; so isn't Morsi a better deal for their country, Krishna, if they want a Republic - where the individual and minority have sovereignty ? (...Just trying to get a clear picture of the 'big' picture there.)

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

Are we in the fall of the Arab Spring now?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

Meanwhile, the US has not cut off that aid because Obama is calling the military action an "intervention" rather than a coup, thus still providing support

I don't think Obama has the sole power to remove foreign aid from a country . In fact I don't think he has any power in that regard .

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

So, you're suggesting that when Obama (thru Congress) was handing them 450 million after Benghazi, and then subsequent packages of millions, adding up to billions, that it was essentially to give strength to their military - not Morsi or whoever would be in charge at that time-frame ?

What do you suppose the end-goal of that would be? (objectively speaking)

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

odd hes recognized when not bowing to a king.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    13 years ago

Are we in the fall of the Arab Spring now?

Maybe.

Its actually starting to look like they are moving out of "Arab Autumn" & approaching the "Arab Winter".

The so-called "Arab Spring" has resulting in dictatorial governments being overthrown-- with even worse governments coming to power. (Except, in Egypt-- if the current gov't, with army support, can keep down the Muslim brotherhood (Morsi and his nasty associates) there's a chance things will improve for the average Egyptian.

And of course the main result of the so-called Arab Spring is even more bloodshed, widespread imprisonment & torture. (I believe in Syria alone the so-called "Arab Spring" has resulted in over 100,000 deaths-- most of them civilians. many are children )

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

Krishna, your reply statement to Six leaves me more confused. Here:

(Except, in Egypt-- if the current gov't, with army support, can keep down the Muslim brotherhood (Morsi and his nasty associates) there's a chance things will improve for the average Egyptian.

Who is the "the current govt"?

Are you saying that Morsi and the MB are a 'worse' option than the Egyptian Liberals ? If so, why do you think so...why is the Socialist group a better option with dictatorial Democracy ?

Just trying to understand ... Smile.gif

___

"

Yet if some liberal voices, such as ElBaradei, advocate for more dialogue and a go-slow approach against the sit-ins, they are being drowned out by calls for law and order made by other liberals and leftists many of the same people who decried the heavy-handedness of Morsi and his predecessor, Hosni Mubarak.

This is a violent and armed sit-in, and it is the right of every government to disperse it by law, and the people are saying that if the government does not disperse, we will do it ourselves, said Karima el-Hifnawy, a leader of the Egyptian Socialist Party. "

...

Yet, the Egyptian Socialist Party would equally "heavy-handed" in forcing mob-rule Democracy, yes ?? ... a bit of irony once again ?

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    13 years ago

Ok... I'm trying to make sure I have the correct 'picture' of what's been happening. First to address, the implications with the photos.

1. Morsi and the MB - are Sunni (similar to what the US refer to as the 'Right') ?

2. The photos here are implicating that Obama was financially supporting them to keep them in power? (can be done many ways - same ways as the US has done for years)

It can be a bit difficult to understand, as there are several different groups involved in the violence in the Arab world--sometimes their agendas overlap, sometimes they are different.

There are several "minor" conflicts in the area (Kurds seeking to gain the independent state they were promised from their land which is illegally occupied; "Palestinians" seeking to eliminate Israel; persecution of various minorities-- be they indigenous Christians or other religions or ethnicities, discrimination & persecution of gays, blacks, and women, etc).

However, there are basically two major conflicts going on throughout the area:

1. Religious sectarianism: Lots of bitterness, hatred & extreme violence between Sunni Muslims and Shia Muslims.

2. Religious "Moderates" vs religious "Extremists"

IMO, understanding that is the key towards understanding most of what's going on in the area.

(BTW, in the west {even the western part of NT!} so much of the political debate is about left vs right. However, in the Muslim world religion is so much more important than it is here-- as a result most of the conflicts are religious (the two types mentioned above).

Political "Liberals" vs Political Conservatives is not, IMO, a major factor in the mid-east).

Morsi and the MB - are Sunni (similar to what the US refer to as the 'Right') ?

Morsi & his MB henchmen are Sunni-- but so are the majority of their opponents. Egypt is overwhelmingly Sunni. So the conflict there is not Sunni v Shia, but rather that described in #2, above: Moderate" Sunnis {the current gov't; the army}--vs "extremist" Sunnis" {Morsi, Muslim Brotherhood}.

(Sunni Shiite-- I don't think as one as bring further left or right-- there are liberals & conservatives in both groups. In Egypt its about Sunni religious moderates v Sunni religious extremists.)

In Syria both conflicts are present. Unlike Egypt, there its mainly Sunni (opposition) vs. Shia (Assad's gov't). ..so its #1, above. However, in addition,--in Syria there is conflict amongst opposition groups--between Sunni Moderates & Sunni Extremists --#2, above.

The photos here are implicating that Obama was financially supporting them to keep them in power? (can be done many ways - same ways as the US has done for years)

Exactly!

Of course Republicans would be tempted to blame only Obama, but the fact is that U.S. Presidents of both parties having been supporting Egyptian totalitarian governments for years. The Islamist Morsi and the MB-- and before that the secular but widely hated dictator Mubarak.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

" Egypt is overwhelmingly Sunni. So the conflict there is not Sunni v Shia, but rather that described in #2, above: Moderate" Sunnis {the current gov't; the army}--vs "extremist" Sunnis" {Morsi, Muslim Brotherhood}. " ...

Ok..that explains a lot. Thank you. In the past, I had some of the Saudi Arabia culture presented to me with their foundational Sunnis (stating a comparison to our "Right") vs. their liberal/radical sector Sunnis that are opposing them--more than one group (?) (stating a comparison to our "Left" -- that's where I was getting the view I was just presenting), so I thought something similar was going on in Egypt.

___

" (Sunni Shiite-- I don't think as one as bring further left or right-- there are liberals & conservatives in both groups. " ....

As a quick aside with terminology for a moment - Iran is mostly Shiite (70%), yes ? Wouldn't you compare them politically to our liberal Left ?

Or would that just be for the extremist groups they
associate with (like the Hezbollah or Hamas)?

Does Iran have foundational Sunnis that live there, or primarily moderates?

I have been seeing Sunnis as 'more' to the 'Right' and Shiites more to the 'Left'----looks like that is a misconception, then... or maybe the view just depends on the territory involved (Ah.. must be--I just got to your comment re Syria).
___

" In Syria both conflicts are present. Unlike Egypt, there its mainly Sunni (opposition) vs. Shia (Assad's gov't). ..so its #1, above. However, in addition,--in Syria there is conflict amongst opposition groups--between Sunni Moderates & Sunni Extremists --#2, above. "

The conflict between Sunni Mods & Extremists similar to Egypt's conflict ? Just to note -- I see that similar to our political views [sort of:] ...we have Right-leaning religious extremists, then we have Right-leaning moderates that are Conservatives.

___

" Of course Republicans would be tempted to blame only Obama, but the fact is that U.S. Presidents of both parties having been supporting Egyptian totalitarian governments for years. " ..

I agree with that, Krishna, because I view 'our' politicians of 'both Parties' as end-goal equivalent---Totalitarian using the unethical principles of Democracy to get there. Frown.gif

Thank you for a nice reply.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    13 years ago

" Egypt is overwhelmingly Sunni. So the conflict there is not Sunni v Shia, but rather that described in #2, above: Moderate" Sunnis {the current gov't; the army}--vs "extremist" Sunnis" {Morsi, Muslim Brotherhood}. " ...

Ok..that explains a lot. Thank you. In the past, I had some of the Saudi Arabia culture presented to me with their foundational Sunnis (stating a comparison to our "Right") vs. their liberal/radical sector Sunnis that are opposing them--more than one group (?) (stating a comparison to our "Left" -- that's where I was getting the view I was just presenting), so I thought something similar was going on in Egypt.

--> Both Egypt and Saudi Arabia are predominantly Sunni. In both places its religious extremists v moderates. Also those who want to move closer to democracy and those who want strict Islamic law (which can not be democratic).

Well, I suppose you could say that religious extremists are "conservative", and less rigid types whom interpret Islamic teacings less rigidly are more "liberal". But those terms aren't all that helpful in the middle east. Religious views rather than economic ones are the main factor here. I find it more helpful to differentiate between religious fundamentalists/religious extremists and religious moderates. (Even in the U.S.-- we have religious conservatives and economic conservatives.)

(Sunni Shiite-- I don't think as one as bring further left or right-- there are liberals & conservatives in both groups. " .

...As a quick aside with terminology for a moment - Iran is mostly Shiite (70%), yes ? Wouldn't you compare them politically to our liberal Left ?

--> NO!!! That's totally false and extremely misleading! And only confuses the discussion!

-->As long as you keep trying to impose western concepts on what's happening in the Muslim world you will stay confused! Neither the Shia nor the Sunni are more "left" or "right"-- just as neither Sunni nor Shiite perfer rock music to disco! Its irrelevant & misleading. These are not western style democracies Its all about religion there!

Or would that just be for the extremist groups they associate with (like the Hezbollah or Hamas)?

-->They are both extremist terror groups. Religious fundamentalist terrorists. The former is religious fundamentalist terrorist Shia, the latter fundamentalist religious terrorist Sunni. (And please don't ask which is liberal and which is conservative-- its irrelevant, confusing, and misleading.)

Does Iran have foundational Sunnis that live there, or primarily moderates?

-->Iranians are mostly Shia.Some very fundamentalist religious whack jobs. Some very moderate Muslims. Especially in the major cities, and the younger people, they are very moderate, tolerant, modern, etc-- a lot like kids of that age in NY, Paris, London. In rural areas, and amongst older people there, many are rigid extreme Muslims, strictly religious, and against democracy.

I have been seeing Sunnis as 'more' to the 'Right' and Shiites more to the 'Left'----looks like that is a misconception, then...

-->Yep.

or maybe the view just depends on the territory involved

-->Yes. If the "territorya involved is a western democrscy, "left" and right" are relevant. OTOH, if the territory is a non-democratic Muslim nation, its mainly all about religion, not "left" or "right". Using those terms is ony a way to confuse thinngs. These countries are not about democracy, they are about one's religious views. Most westerners have trouble conceiving about how Islam permeates every are of life there..(Even for those who are not religious-- what you say publically about religion might end up puttng you in jail or murdered (for alleged "blasphemy").
___

" In Syria both conflicts are present. Unlike Egypt, there its mainly Sunni (opposition) vs. Shia (Assad's gov't). ..so its #1, above. However, in addition,--in Syria there is conflict amongst opposition groups--between Sunni Moderates & Sunni Extremists --#2, above. "

The conflict between Sunni Mods & Extremists similar to Egypt's conflict ?

-->More than similar-- its what it is about!

-->Islam by its very nature is incompatible with democracy.J Devout Muslimms, religious extremists, are opposed to democracy. (In Egypt = Morsi, MB abd the Salafis). The current govt opposes them. They are opposed toislamic extremism. But while theey are moderates,many still believe in Islamic teachings, somtheir version of "democracy" is somewhat diluted..

just to note -- I see that similar to our political views [sort of:] ...we have Right-leaning religious extremists, then we have Right-leaning moderates that are Conservatives

--> For all our faults, we are a democracy. Thhey are not. Apples and Oranges. So comparisons are misleading.

___" Of course Republicans would be tempted to blame only Obama, but the fact is that U.S. Presidents of both parties having been supporting Egyptian totalitarian governments for years. " ..

I agree with that, Krishna, because I view 'our' politicians of 'both Parties' as end-goal equivalent---Totalitarian using the unethical principles of Democracy to get there. Frown.gif

--> Maybe. I think many of them aren't necessarily pro-totalitarian. Rather, they just want countries to be pro-U.S. So even if they are dictatorships, we court their fvaours because we want them as allies. Trying to meddle in the affairs of a dictatorship in order to try to create a democracy inn areas opposed to democracy doesn't work-- often the best we can do is have a freindly dictatorship rather then one that is hostile. (And other world powers are no more ethical than we are).

But we must realize that the Arab world and democracy are incompatible-- and trying to make them democratic has disasterous consequences.iraq is a perfect example.

An old saying:

Never try to teach a pig to sing. You'll only end up frustrated-- and it annoys the pig!Grin.gif

Thank you for a nice reply.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

Krishna, thank you, again!

First, if I may clarify my usage of the terms "Right vs Left" -- that wasn't to say Republican platform values vs. Democratic platform values--in other words, my intent was comparative in emotionalism -- not politics... 'Right' to mean fundamental or foundational & 'Left' to mean progressive/getting away from traditional thought.

I'm sorry if I sounded confused or didn't understand the difference between their religion and politics, but I do understand. (I just 'look' confused. Smile.gif ..just joking)

___

I also understand why Democracy would 'never' work there due to the basic premise of Islam - it doesn't teach the 'majority' rules everyone - it teaches only Allah rules everyone, and it teaches that can't 'ever' change, or will be considered Blasphemy for anyone that tries to change it, with severe consequences. ...as I understand it.

___

Thank you, too, for discussing Iran for a moment. I appreciated that for the fact that here our nation has seemingly a lot of indirect involvement with them, yet we or many of us, have little knowledge as to why -and- how they are significant in our dealings with some of the other nations in the ME - like Egypt. Understanding their religious imperatives can help us understand how they affect Egypt's actions--which 'can' affect us. ..For me, it's always the big picture forest fire I'm looking for, not so much the brush fires here and there.

___

Thank you for commenting on some of the other things like: Hamas being Sunni, and Hezbollah being Shia; religion is a way of life - yes - with westerners not always realizing that; on "territory" - I just meant which religious group had control of the area--not politics.

___

An old saying:

Never try to teach a pig to sing. You'll only end up frustrated-- and it annoys the pig!Grin.gif

LOL...

And to joke with you a second...

I'm sure glad I'm a wabbit ! 18.gif

Hope you have a good night!

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    13 years ago

clarify my usage of the terms "Right vs Left" -- that wasn't to say Republican platform values vs. Democratic platform values--in other words, my intent was comparative in emotionalism -- not politics... 'Right' to mean fundamental or foundational & 'Left' to mean progressive/getting away from traditional thought.

Ok-- in that sense its appliciable. But the Sunni and Shia both have both those sorts of liberals and conservatives amongst them.

Thank you, too, for discussing Iran for a moment. I appreciated that for the fact that here our nation has seemingly a lot of indirect involvement with them, yet we or many of us, have little knowledge as to why -and- how they are significant in our dealings with some of the other nations in the ME - like Egypt. Understanding their religious imperatives can help us understand how they affect Egypt's actions--which 'can' affect us. ..For me, it's always the big picture forest fire I'm looking for, not so much the brush fires here and there.

The situation with Iran is a bit complicated. There's another factor at play-- they are not Arabs. They are descendents of the ancient Persians. (And they are very proud of that). They are Shia. Its a big country, with a wide variety of ethnic groups. (Most of whom are persecuted, in addition to the gov'ts recationary attitude towards gays and women and other religions such as Bahai'i).

Ianians range from very modern, progressive types to very traditional (culturally "conservative") types. The current government is Islamist, and a big abuser of the rights of their own people.

The current government hates Israel, the west, and Sunni countries--particularly those close by (Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states). They have threatened to annihilate Israel, but the Sunni Arab countries are also afraid of what they might do to them do once they get nukes.

Iran, being Shiite, has sent troops into Syria to support their Shia dictator (Assad). Iran also supports the Shia Lebanese terror group Hezb'Allah. H. is also fighting alongside Iran and Assad's troops to defeat the rebels. (All those groups are so busy killing each other of that they really aren't involved much with Egypt-- which in any event is rather far from Iran.

Although some outside powers are trying to meddle in Egypt (including the U.S.!) there's much less foreign involvement in Egypt then in Syria, where there are numerous foreign fighters, of many different types.-- including al Qaeda, Hizb'Allah, Iranians, possibly some extremist volunteers from the Gulf & N Africa ,and recently even some Pakistani Taliban fighters have shown up in Syria.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

But the Sunni and Shia both have both those sorts of liberals and conservatives amongst them.

Ok.. That adjusts my original view. Thank you.

Thank you for your thoughts and info on Iran and their relationships with their people and H.

Interesting too, imo, that there's less foreign involvement in Egypt than Syria; I suppose because Egypt always seems like a hub to me - a gateway to many different directions and influences. Syria sure has a lot of variety of fighters there!

___

Back to Egypt - did you have a statement on what's up with the propaganda - the photos in the article and Obama? Is there any implication that they don't want our money anymore?

 
 

Who is online


Snuffy


104 visitors