Details Of "Classified" E-Mails revealed
I suggest everyone who is interested in this story read this article. I have bolded what i consider to be the most relevant points, de-politicized.
-
Top Secret Clinton Emails Include Drone Talk
The two emails on Hillary Rodham Clinton's private server that an auditor deemed "top secret" include a discussion of a news article detailing a U.S. drone operation and a separate conversation that could point back to highly classified material in an improper manner or merely reflect information collected independently, U.S. officials who have reviewed the correspondence told The Associated Press.
The sourcing of the information in the emails could have significant political implications as the 2016 presidential campaign heats up. Clinton, the front-runner for the Democratic nomination, agreed this week to turn over to the FBI the private server she used as secretary of state, and Republicans in Congress have seized on the involvement of federal law enforcement as a sign that she was either negligent with the nation's secrets or worse.
On Monday, the inspector general for the 17 spy agencies that make up what is known as the intelligence community told Congress that two of 40 emails in a random sample of the 30,000 emails Clinton gave the State Department for review contained information deemed "Top Secret/Sensitive Compartmented Information," one of the government's highest levels of classification.
The two emails were marked classified after consultations with the CIA, which is where the material originated, officials said.
The officials who spoke to the AP on condition of anonymity work in intelligence and other agencies. They wouldn't detail the contents of the emails because of ongoing questions about classification level. Clinton did not transmit the sensitive information herself, they said, and nothing in the emails she received makes clear reference to communications intercepts, confidential intelligence methods or any other form of sensitive sourcing.
The drone exchange, the officials said, begins with a copy of a news article that discusses the CIA drone program that targets terrorists in Pakistan and elsewhere. While a secret program, it is well-known and often reported on. The copy makes reference to classified information, and a Clinton adviser follows up by dancing around a top secret in a way that could possibly be inferred as confirmation, they said. Several officials, however, described this claim as tenuous.
But a second email reviewed by Charles McCullough, the intelligence community inspector general, appears more suspect. Nothing in the message is "lifted" from classified documents, the officials said, though they differed on where the information in it was sourced. Some said it improperly points back to highly classified material, while others countered that it was a classic case of what the government calls "parallel reporting" different people knowing the same thing through different means.
The emails came to light Tuesday after Sen. Chuck Grassley, R-Iowa, reported that McCullough found four "highly classified" emails on the unusual homebrew server that Clinton used while she was secretary of State. Two were sent back to the State Department for review, but Grassley said the other two were, in fact, classified at the closely guarded "Top Secret/SCI level."
In a four-page fact sheet that accompanied a letter to Clinton supporters, Clinton spokeswoman Jennifer Palmieri stressed that Clinton was permitted to use her own email account as a government employee and that the same process concerning classification reviews would still be taking place had she used the standard "state.gov" email account used by most department employees. The State Department, meanwhile, stressed that it wasn't clear if the material at issue ought to be considered classified at all.
Still, the developments suggested that the security of Clinton's email setup and how she guarded the nation's secrets will remain relevant campaign topics. Even if the emails highlighted by the intelligence community prove innocuous, she will still face questions about whether she set up the private server with the aim of avoiding scrutiny, whether emails she deleted because she said they were personal were actually work-related, and whether she appropriately shielded such emails from possible foreign spies and hackers.
Clinton says she exchanged about 60,000 emails in her four years as secretary of state. She turned over all but what she said were personal emails late last year. The department has been making those public as they are reviewed and scrubbed of any sensitive data.
The State Department advised employees not to use personal email accounts for work, but it wasn't prohibited. But Clinton's senior advisers at the State Department would have been briefed upon basic protocol for handling classified information and retaining government records. In Clinton's time, most officials saved their emails onto a separate file or printed them out when leaving office. Only recently has the department begun automatically archiving the records of dozens of senior officials, including Secretary of State John Kerry .
In the emails, Clinton's advisers appear cognizant of secrecy protections.
In a series of August 2009 emails, Clinton aide Huma Abedin told Clinton that the U.S. point-man for Afghanistan, Richard Holbrooke, and another official wanted "to do a secure" conversation to discuss Afghan elections. Clinton said she could talk after she received a fax of a classified Holbrooke memo, also on a secure line. Later, Abedin wrote: "He can talk now. We can send secure fax now. And then connect call."
But other times, the line was blurred. Among Clinton's exchanges now censored as classified by the State Department was a brief exchange in October 2009 with Jeffrey Feltman, then the top U.S. diplomat for the Middle East . Both Clinton and Feltman's emails about an "Egyptian proposal" for a reconciliation ceremony with Hamas are marked B-1.4, classified for national security reasons, and completely blacked out from the email release.
A longer email the same day from Clinton to former Sen. George Mitchell, then Mideast peace envoy, is also censored. Mitchell responds tersely and carefully that "the Egyptian document has been received and is being translated. We'll review it tonight and tomorrow morning, will consult with the Pals (Palestinians) through our Consul General, and then I'll talk with Gen. S again. We'll keep you advised."
Associated Press writers Stephen Braun and Eric Tucker contributed to this report.

Taken objectively, this article points to the politicized nature of this inestigation, or more accurately, the reporting and interpretation of this investigation.
There is considerable information in this AP report that sounds favorable to Clinton, although not specifically characterized that way in the article.
linton was permitted to use her own email account as a government employee
Lie. She fired a Department of State employee for conducting government business using private email. Obama issued a rule prohibiting it. But we know rules don't apply to the Clintons, only to the little people. That's the perk of the cult of personality politics that dominate the democratic party.
SO now you are trying to argue that the emails shouldn't have been classified because you know damn well she is guilty? PRICELESS!
This Associated Press story, viewed objectively, clearly shows an ambiguous nature to the material in question, yet National Review columnists are calling for Clinton to be put in prison.
How political would you say this controversy is , Sean ?
It was also a lie when she said she was not issued a subpoena for them.
I am at a loss as to how to respond to such a confused and non-responsive comment.
Does it bother you, at all, to parrot her obvious lies?
She FIRED one of her employees for conducting work via private email. Yet you highlight her Campaign's spin that she was "permitted to use her own email account." I hope, for your sake, you feel at least a little dirty for enabling that sort of blatant hypocrisy.
But that's the Clintons' game. Once the blizzard of lies is pushed though, they dismiss their legal/ethical violations as non-important and part of some vast conspiracy. Never mind former State department employee Stephen Kim rots in the jail for information that "wasn't sensitive."
Little people like Stephen Kim go to jail for violating national security laws even over non-sensitive information. Hillary Clinton doesn't have to worry about that, the Democrat party protects the elite from those pesky consequences of their law breaking.
I don't know about that, but what about all the lies the right has spinning about her for 20 years.
If this wasn't a presidential campaign, this 'controversy' would probably just fade away into deserved nothingness. But , given everyday media hysteria in 2015, it may be the case that it has badly damaged her electabilty, so the witch hunters will have won.
In any case, we will find another candidate to beat Donald Trump or any of the other right wing nut cases that may get their nomination.
This article is an attempt to argue that the classified emails weren't real important and take your attention off the fact that she broke the law regardless.
You still can't explain why Petraeus was immediately charged for doing the exact same thing either.
Actually, the article specifically states that the classification of the emails is still under review. It says that in a couple different places.
That is laughable. So the BO admin will make sure the emails are declassified to keep her out of jail for breaking the law. You don't see anything wrong with that eh?
If she had broken the law as obviously as you seem to think, there would be a warrant out for her arrest.
But don't despair, there is a good chance the witch hunt is working.
I said it before and I'll say it again. She did EXACTLY the same thing Petraeus did and should have had the same charges brought against her as he did. You still can't explain, yet still defend the double standard.
No one in authority has said that, right wing media and some sensationalist mainstream media that would throw their own mother under the bus to create controversy have said that.
We don't arrest people in this country because Rush Limbaugh and Sean Hannity are out to get them.
You apparently don't understand classification, John. Classified means BY DEFINITION that its release would be harmful. Hillary had no right to decide otherwise without being an official classification officer, which she wasn't. She is guilty as hell.
Look, the AP story clearly states the classification of the documents under discussion is still under review.
It is not my problem if you people have your minds made up to the point where you forget how to read.
The only reason they are under review is so they can be declassified to keep Hillary in the race. The point is that if she downloaded files marked classified she broke the law. Reviewing them after the fact and De-classifying them is horseshit and akin to a Presidential pardon.
If you took what you just said, and then wrote the exact opposite of it, you would be closer to the truth.
What part of "it is against the law to download documents marked as classified on a private server" Don't you understand?
AP Story Demonstrates Weak Claims Against Hillary On E-mails
by Armando Follow
Let's review this again - (1) Clinton did not transmit the sensitive information herself and (2) nothing in the emails she received makes clear reference to communications intercepts, confidential intelligence methods or any other form of sensitive sourcing.
Frankly, this puts Clinton completely in the clear. This story SHOULD be over as far as Hillary is concerned. IS that true for other State personnel? I think so. But there can be no doubt as to Clinton.
The AP story continues:
This passage is unclear in this phrase - "The copy makes reference to classified information." This could mean, as I think it does, the copy from the news article. In which case, huh? A news article can be TOP SECRET? Just ludicrous. If "copy" means something else, I have no idea what it could be.The story continues:
This seems to be a part of the interagency food fight where the IC thinks everything is classified, even though everyone knows from various sources and normal reasonable people say that's nonsense. And again, none of this implicates Hillary.The rest of the article is a basic retelling of the controversy.
If this AP story is accurate, it's pretty clear there is no there there in this story.
I don't necessarily 100% agree with this daily Kos take ( I think mine is better), but we see people awakening to the fact that this controversy is proceeding as a witch hunt in the media, including the mainstream media.
Again you are arguing that they should not have been marked classified and ignoring that they WERE marked classified. Let me say it a different way you might (i don't have high hopes) understand. It is against the law to download a document MARKED AS classified to a private server. It doesn't matter who thinks they should not have been marked that way.
Is that better?
No one can really believe that this face would lie about classified material or anything else, could they?
...
No, you are just hoping that this will be seen as a witch hunt. Twisting the facts to make it seem like what she did was ethical and legal may make some people believe it, after all, if a lie is repeated often and loudly enough, even those who are speaking it will begin to believe it. But the rest of us know better. She is the dem front runner and if she is taken out of the race, then who will be the dems best hope? I heard today that they are dusting off Al Gore, but I just don't think he can bring any excitement to the race.
What facts? No one in authority has ever said she did anything wrong. It is all speculation at this point, which is kind of the definition of a witch hunt.
You can tell just by looking at her? Neat trick! I don't know if she did or did not lie (no one here does yet either), but I also don't know anyone who is psychic and can tell just by looking at her! Maybe you should call the FBI and tell them you know?
BULLSHIT!
...
I don't know why I bother. You constantly ignore facts and offer your BS opinion as facts.
It is hard to know which comment is being referred to on this forum.
In any case, the classification of the four e-mails is still under review.
The issue at hand is if they were marked classified WHEN SHE DOWNLOADED THEM simple as that. This is the way the law is written John.
This is why no on e looked into if there was "actually classified info" in the emails Petraeus downloaded. There is no reason for it because they were MARKED classified. He broke the law and he was charged as he should have been.
96WS6, your own link to the Post story tries to explain to you that, so far, none of the emails on Clinton's server were marked as "Classified".
To date there is no " Criminal Investigation" of Mrs. Clinton but there is a proper investigation into how & why some documents were classified as they were by the different departments that handle such things.
A completely different scenariothan the one you're trying to push.
So far it looks like another Benghazi/IRS meme but I'm willing to wait and see how things turn out.
AH, unfortunately there are a number of people here who are not careful when they read news stories. I have tried to tell him, more than once, that the e-mails were mot marked classified, according to news reports, but it has been futile.