╌>

Analysis: Israeli-Palestinian riddle won't answer Middle East's wider woes

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  the-irascible-harry-krishner  •  13 years ago  •  9 comments

Analysis: Israeli-Palestinian riddle won't answer Middle East's wider woes

Egypt Independent -On Sun, 04/08/2013 - 16:19

News that the two sides had resumed peace talks last week after a three-year halt was largely overshadowed by turmoil in Egypt and the Syrian civil war, which has set Sunni and Shia Muslims against one another.

U.S. officials still hope that resolving the decades-old confrontation will help to unlock the region's wider problems, but analysts say it no longer lies at the strategic heart of a troubled Middle East.

"That was probably the case before the Arab uprisings, but a number of other struggles have now joined it, such as the Sunni-Shia struggle and an intra-Sunni conflict," said Salman Shaikh, director of the Brookings Doha Centre think tank.

None of these crises will come any closer to being settled should, by some miracle, Israel and the Palestinians finally agree to divide the land where they live.

( Read it all)


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    13 years ago

The Sunni Arab states & Iran:

Despite Iranian denials, Western experts think Shia Iran is trying to develop nuclear weapons. This alarms many Sunni Arab leaders as much as the Israelis.

A review of thousands of U.S. classified documents posted on the WikiLeaks website suggests that in private, Sunni officials were indeed more interested in discussing Iran and other topics than the fate of the occupied Palestinian Territories.

And that's a key point: "WikiLeaks website suggests that in private, Sunni officials were indeed more interested in discussing Iran and other topics than the fate of the occupied Palestinian Territories".

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    13 years ago

Arab rulers can no longer get away with deflecting their peoples' anger by using Israel as a scapegoat:

In public, Muslim leaders have traditionally railed against Israel, happy to fan ordinary Arabs' sincere anger about the plight of the Palestinians - and perhaps deflect criticism of their own failure to make badly needed reforms.

Arab leaders can no longer get away with this. The uprisings of the last 2-1/2 years have shown that domestic problems cannot be swept under the carpet. These include a deep economic malaise that a peace deal would do nothing to heal.

In a 2011 newspaper interview, President Bashar al-Assad said Syria was immune to unrest partly because he had united it in common cause against Israel. It was a hollow claim; just weeks later, violence erupted among Syrians that still rages.

Aware of its battered reputation and the fact that the Arab world is not focused on Israel, Hezbollah leader Sayyed Hassan Nasrallah wrapped himself in the cloak of Palestinian resistance on Friday, issuing a rallying cry for fellow Muslims.

"The elimination of Israel is not only a Palestinian interest. It is the interest of the entire Muslim world and the entire Arab world," he said in a rare appearance in Beirut.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

Wider woes ?

6207_discussions.jpg

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    13 years ago

Exactly.

In microcosm, the I/P equation is usually only evoked by Arabs when it suits their immediate need to manipulate a situation, either domestically or otherwise. In reality, Arabs have treated the Palestinians like shit for forever.

In macrocosm, the I/P equation coulda been solved a long time ago, right off the bat in '48. The conflict raging in the muslim world has nothing to do with Israel at all, and everything to do with a religion and political ideology that refuses to enter into the 21st century.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    13 years ago

BTW, this is one of the best analyses on this subject that I've read-- very astute observations...I highly recommend reading the whole thing.

(P.S. The link originally posted was broken--- should be ok now.)

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

Thanks for repairing the link .

violence has flared again in Iraq, with over 1,000 killed there in July alone, many at the hands of Al-Qaeda.

I see this as a positive development . If Al-Qaeda is focused on Iraq they will devote less attention to the US .Call me provincial or worse ...

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    13 years ago

If Al-Qaeda is focused on Iraq they will devote less attention to the US .

al Qaeda is very focused on Northe Africa and points south. There's been a huge resurgence in Iraq. They have now joined the rebel coalition trying to overthrow Assad.

That struggle is Shai )Assad and allies) vs the rebels who are Sunni.

In addition, the Sunni opposition is also split-- between extremists such as al Qaeda and moderates.

Al Qaeda is being its usual violent self in both Iraq nd Syria.

Call me provincial or worse ...

Well, you know the old saying:

Calme anything you want-- just donn't call me late for dinner! Smile.gif

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    13 years ago

I admit I'm nave about Shia and Sunni relationship other than know the difference between the two; I would not have realized Shia could possible use nuclear weapons on the other.

Its basically a case of two different groups clashing over interpretations of the Koran, etc. Not really important to understand the various theological differences. Basically all we need to know is that they are two different branches of Islam, and the extremists of both hate each other. And there are a lot of extremists!).

Almost of the clashes between Arabs today are due to mutual hatreds between these groups. The terrorism in Iraq and the current bloody Syrian civil war (both sides routinely rape, torture and murder civilians-- including children) is a clash between these two groups.

The two sides in Syria:

1. Shia & supporters: (These Muslim fighters are Shia):

-Assad & Syrian Shia.

-Supported by Iran and their proxy, the Lebanese terror group Hezb'Allah.

-Russia.

-Both Iran and Hezb'Allah have troops who are actually fighting inside Syria supporting the Assad gov't. Russia does not have Russians fighting there, but sends lots of advanced weapons.

2. Sunni & supporters - The opposition trying to overthrow Assad:

-Syrian Sunni.

-A broad coalition, Sunni Moslems from different countries. They range from a few who actually want a democratic secular state through to those who want a Sunni Islamist state. Includes extremist al Qaeda and recently the arrival of Pakistani Taliban! Some Sunni volunteers from various countries...

-The Arab Gulf states (Sunnis) are sending weapons-- but not nearly the quantity or for the most part the quality that Assad gets from Russia and Iran. Some of them go, as individuals, th fight against the Shia.

-The U.S. & EU favour the rebels, but are hesitate to send heavy weapons to the opposition forces because they fear they will fall into the Hands of violent jihadis & not the moderates.

_________________________________________________________

MISC:

-The conflict in Iraq is also about Sunni-Shia mutual hatreds.

-Turkey is Sunni, so they are supporting the rebels.

-Israel: Actually neutral-- they feel that whoever wins will result in dangerous conditions. No support of either side, no weapons to either. They did have something like 2-4 airstrikes, but the goal was not to support either side. Rather, advanced weapons were being transferred to the Lebanese terror group Hizb'Allah, and it was deemed a threat to Israel's security.

-Egypt is not a Sunni-Shia conflict-- more on that later.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

It's sort of Orwellian (Animal Farm) when humans start to look more and more like pigs.

 
 

Who is online

goose is back


117 visitors