How Does President Obama's Economic Recovery Compare To Those Of Other Presidents?
President Obama and his paid spokespeople like to point out that the economy is doing better now than during the depths of the last recession, which ended in official records four years ago!
But economies always do better in recoveries than during recessions.
So that is a very low standard by which to judge Obamas record.
The real question is how President Obamas recovery compares to the other recoveries of other Presidents from other recessions.
Since the Great Depression, there have been 11 other recessions in America before this last one.In all those recessions, the economy recovered all jobs lost during the recession an average of 25 months after the recession began.
So the job effects of prior post Depression recessions lasted an average of about 2 years.
But here we are today, 5 years, or 67 months , after the recession started, and we still have not recovered all of the jobs lost during the recession.
As AEI President Arthur Brooks wrote in the Wall Street Journal last Thursday,
In 2008, the Bureau of Labor Statistics reported that total nonfarm seasonally adjusted employment was 138 million workers . Today, it is fewer than 136 million. Meanwhile, the number of Americans has grown by 12.8 million.In many areas of the country, more than one in five adults who want full time employment cant find it.
In sharp contrast, President Reagans recovery from the sharp 1981-1982 recession, which resulted from the monetary policy that broke the back of the roaring 1970s inflation, recovered all of the jobs lost during that recession within 36 months. At this point in the Reagan recovery, jobs had grown nearly 10% higher than when the recession started , representing an increase of more than 10 million more jobs.
Similarly, in the 11 post depression recessions before President Obama, the economy recovered the lost GDP during the recession within an average of 4.5 quarters after the recession started.But it took Obamas recovery 16 quarters , or 4 years , to reach that point. Today, 5 years, or 22 quarters , after the recession started, the economy (real GDP) has grown only about 3% above where it was when the recession started. By sharp contrast, at this point in the Reagan recovery, the economy had boomed by about 20%, or one fifth.
In addition, middle class incomes have continued to fall during Obamas recovery, losing even more ground than during the recession.
The number in poverty has also continued to soar during Obamas supposed recovery, to about 50 million, the most in the more than 50 years that Census has been tracking poverty, with the poverty rate up to 16.1%, higher than when the War on Poverty started in 1965.
Indeed, despite all of Obamas rhetoric, inequality has started rising during his Presidency.
These are the reasons why President Obamas recovery has been commonly characterized as the worst recovery from any recession since the Great Depression.
http://www.forbes.com/sites/peterferrara/2013/08/04/how-does-president-obamas-economic-recovery-compare-to-those-of-other-presidents/
Tags
Who is online
109 visitors

A perspective on the current recovery in comparison to economic recoveries after recessions in the past.
i refuse to believe in the lib mantra of this being the new normal
obama's "recovery" is anything but, normal.
JoAnne
Serious subject here requires serious discussion
Not meant to be a bash fest for liberals, conservatives, democrats, Republicans or anyone else
Whether it is the new normal will on what happens in the future not what has happened in the past
"<smiles, laughter> apparently, the shovel ready projects were not as shovel ready as we thought <looks around, laughs deeply>"
hey barry, where the ___________ is my 700 bill?
"The stimulus created millions of jobs. Per the CBO - 3.3 million jobs"
3.3 mill"saved or created", COSTING 700 bill "stimulus"= $212,000 PER JOB!
only in an abamanation is this a good return on investment.
what the low information voter is loath to admit:
barry and the redistributionist liberalsran all of the executive, the senate, and the house, entirely for the first two years of the false king's reign.
all of it. they shoved thru each and every socialist nonsense they had been salivating over for decades, but were unable to pass.
and now, people wonder why the obama "recovery" sucks?
like blaming the gop for detroit, the liberal just makes crap up.
barb
I do not dispute your number of jobs created nor do I doubt he numbers in the article which showfewer people employed now than in 2008
Typical that people refuse to look at the total economic recovery and simply chant the mantras = stimulus good trickle down bad
People unable to see that all is not well in the recovery make me sad more than they make me gag
Thanks for your perspective
barb
Again no sane person denies that progress has been made
The point, which seems to be escaping you, is that the recovery (so far as jobs are concerned) is proceeding at a slower pace than any other recovery in history
Remember forget about politics for a moment and simply look at the facts of the big picture
JoAnne
Play nice and try to talk about the article and not about "the people" who you disagree with/
I have a question - if infrastructure is crumbling (which it is), and the only solution to keep it from falling apart completely and utterly paralyzing the economy, is to fix it - then what is the solution that involves a trickle down approach? Are you suggesting that privatization of infrastructure is somehow the answer to fixing the economy? Are you out of your mind? That would just be the final nail into the coffin for the middle class. That's theultimate moveserving to make the rich richer and the poor poorer.
Hal
I suggested no such thing about infrastructure
No reasonable person denies that we need to rebuild old infrastructure and replace some with new
I think a combination of private/public sector effort will be the answer to rebuilding the infrastructure - perhaps some variation of the infrastructure bank that some have suggested
My sanity is just fine and yours?
Lol - any combination of private/public sector infrastructure improvements results in some sort of toll for the private side, usually where one did not exist to begin with. Once that toll is in place, don't believe for a second the promises ofit's limited existence. What private sector entity out there is looking to give away some free money with no guarantee of a return on their investment? Especially for something as pricey as infrastructure.
What we need to do is get back to the business of building a country, instead of budgeting zillions of dollars for defense to squander on programsfor spying on the tax payers.
Hal
Glad you are LOL, laughter is a healthy thing
Hard to argue with the fact that the DoD budget needs to be trimmed though the reaction the DoD sequester cuts seem o indicate that many disagree with cutting the spending drastically at the pentagon.
Perhaps I misunderstand the infrastructure bank concept, I thought it would provide capital ad loan guarantees for private companies to bid on and get contracts from the government for infrastructure projects.
So that is a very low standard by which to judge Obamas record.
hence, the new normal nonsense. it is fairly typical of the left to lower the bar, and thus be able to later claim any minor gain as being monumental.
case in point: all the obama apologists on networks touting the huge decrease in the deficit. when only a decade ago we would consider the dollar amount of the reduction to be an astounding figure, let alone the total deficit in the trillion category.
another example: rather than pursuing excellence, we are instead moving towards rewarding mediocrity in schools, where everyone gets a trophy.
finally, and most historically obvious: the "fairness" of redistribution does nothing but make the great majority poor, and eliminate any chance of individual accomplishment being rewarded.
iarnuocon
Thanks for sharing your perspectives
You presented some facts but do not forget these facts which are just as important
iarnuocon
The play nice request goes for you too please!
iarnuocon
Well of course you are right, the democrats (and liberals) played no part and have no responsibility for the poor state of the U.S. economy
Thanks for sharing your perspective
iarnuocon
I get it now, the only facts that are relevant are those that support and praise actions of the administration.
I suppose that should have been obvious
iarnuocon
You are the one who is interested only in the facts that support your side of the argument so the steaming pile is yours
I readily admit that progress has been made and that there are areas and achievements for which the administration deserves credit and even praise but there is also the cold hard facts about the rising number of unemployed, the rising number of part-time and low wage jobs that were created etc.
I accept the good things that have been accomplished and also recognize areas where efforts have fallen shot.
Is that too difficult for you or too much to ask?
iarnuocon
I agree
Thanks for the back and forth - that we do not agree is obvious but we both presented our views in an aggressive yet civil manner
See ya on other threads
iarnuocon
In the future I will try and use less controversial (with an agenda) articles to highlight the points I want to make
iarnuocon
I agree that the 80's recovery is not a benchmark but there is also nothing absurdly inaccurate in comparing that recovery to the current one so long as one realizes that the comparative progress while relative is not directly correlative since the conditions that cause the recessions and the details of the recoveries are distinctly different.
I do not think that we should expect the same recovery that we saw in the 80's (if there was a recovery then I guess) but I do think that what we are seeing in our recovery or fax recovery or economic stagnation (depending who you ask) is inadequate and that questioning that situation and pointing out shortcomings and failures (as well as successes) is the right thing to do
Sorry to jump in the middle of you and Egilman but just want to insert those thoughts into the discussion
I would never call you "Richard" or any diminutive of that since you are Iarnuocon obviously
I think the president's Cloward-Piven strategy is working fine.
iarnuocon
Not a road map for sure but a point of comparison absolutely
Neither Reagan nor Obama was/is a economic messiah and anyone that thinks that either was/is such a savior of the economy and country is sadly mistaken
A double bold harrumph is sure to get your message across.
Sixpick
A little of an overreach don't you think?
President Obama is more a European social democrat than a socialist don't you think?
BadFish
Now that is a fact that few will argue with these days
unfortunate the only way we seem to be able to question our dear leader is by watching him with another comedian.
fitting, as his economic, like other policies, are a joke.
Was Congress fighting jobs development in those two chosen recessions. Was the federal government giving tax deferments to companies sendong jobs over seas? If so Possibly Regan. Currentlyat least three times bills have been attempted to end tax deferments to reward companies moving jobs to China, Cambodia and 150+ more countries was filibustered or I believe once voted down by the House majority which is the Republicans party. Republican Tea Party who are theextremest Republicans as there is no such thing as the TEA PARTY clearly want to shut the Government down. This is treasonou an open sttempt to overthrow the government. So if you want to blame someone for the job deficit blame the Republican Party. Stock market is at an all time high. The rich and big business are doing great while your taxes pay for food stamps and medicaid for Wal Mart employees who work for the Walton family one of the richest families in the world.
Count all the jobs sent to foreign countries and you will understand why GDP is down. Go to Wal-Mart once again and find a product made in the USA.
speaking of obamanomics, aetna just pulled out of maryland.
super job!
r m e R
Thanks for your perspective
Actually was in a WalMart yesterday and among other things picked up a couple of jars of Smuckers jelly and jam made right here in Ohio
Too early to say what will happen long term. With so much extremism on both sides it has made recovery sluggishly slow
Why not just hand 3.2 million people $212,000? In Greenland they punished the people responsible for the housing bubble and gave the stimulus to the homeowners instead of the banks in the way of lowered interest rates. Their recession was over shortly after. What happened here merely REWARDED banks and set us up for round 2. Yea that's right, no one got burnt here, WTF wouldn't they do it again?
Shub
The truest statement that anyone has made in quite a while
Thanks for sharing your perspective
Right....what was I thinking!
They wouldn't be guaranteed huge campaign donations if they did it that way!
Good point!
well, now that he has answered questions from lenno on our relationship with russia, perhaps barry will go on letterman and we can learn more about his economic goals.
JoAnne
Gotta admit that on made me smile
Egilman
It has been suggested to me (and it makes some sense) that the most recent recession (which some consider to be a depression) was much worse than any other recession and comparisons might be better made to the recovery from the depression rather than to those recessions "since WWII)
Something to consider
Obama's Economic Recovery
Egilman
Thanks for your thoughts and perspective
I think that overall tax code reform (all aspects is needed)
One thing I would like to see is all income (payroll, capital gains, inheritance) all taxed at a single rate; we need a spurt of high growth for a period of time and then steady growth to get the economy back and going
I think you are overly optimistic when you say
Within six months this economy would be roaring like a freight train again
NO matter what is done the economy will not be "roaring" in six months in my view
JoAnne
Still looking for relevant input
iarnuocon
Excellent points
The only possible issue here, in my view, is that if enough other carriers were to follow Aetna over time the remaining insures could raise rates artificially
egilman
Thanks for the feedback
Good friend of mine here on NT calls it stagnation and I think you described the same situation
egilman
If history is an indicator not any time soon