Want the Young and invincible to Buy into Obamacare? Answer these 3 questions
With enrollment for health insurance exchanges growing near, young Americans are about to get an earful.
The Obama administration expects that some 2.7 million healthy adults under 35 will need to enroll in insurance exchanges to make the premium prices work for everyone. To make that happen, its kicked off a reportedly $700 million educational campaign to recruit young people to the exchanges.
Im a member of the young, healthy and seemingly invincible demographic that the Obama administration is trying to reach. I rock climb on the weekends and ran my first marathon last month followed three days later by a hike up Mount Saint Helens. My employer does offer health insurance, but I choose to purchase my own individual plan, so Ive been through the insurance shopping process. Ive also been in the situation a lot of twenty-somethings are in today: underemployed and without insurance.
It makes sense why the administration has tapped its Hollywood network to join the campaign. But in the effort of convincing young people to buy insurance, celebs, social media and TV commercials will only go so far. There are some of the key questions I think Generation Y needs to see clearly addressed by this campaign.
How do I make the math work?
Yes, we know we could get sick or injured unexpectedly. But we also live in a world of instant gratification, and when youre pinching pennies, its hard to ignore the basic math: the penalty for not having insurance isnt nearly as costly as buying health insurance.
Its the same reason people skip renters insurance even though they know their home could be broken into, or pass on a roadside assistance plan knowing that their car could break down in the middle of the highway.
Thats why its important to tell young people that, or if , there are plans tailored for us. In Massachusettss exchange, young people gravitated to a high-deductible plan with lower monthly premiums. If a similar option will be available in every state, make sure they know about it.
Why should I pay more to help everyone else?
The fact that the administration says it needs healthy young people to make the exchanges work makes me feel, frankly, a little used. Millennials have already been scared into thinking that Social Security wont exist by the time we reach retirement now we need to buy health insurance so that the older people who use the healthcare system more can afford it?
What are the real penalties?
Ive had one real health scare in my life, and it came when I was just out of college, working part-time and newly dropped off of my parents health plan. I did price research before every diagnostic test and lab I had done. Although I havent crunched the numbers, I think not having insurance actually worked in my favor. With a small self-pay discount here and a little price cut for paying up front there, I probably saved money in the long run. The research and savings let me put what little money I had directly toward labs, diagnostic tests and medicines that likely would not have been fully covered under a plan I could afford anyway.
At the time I wasnt thinking about who was going to cover those additional costs, as Im sure most people relieved to save money on healthcare dont. If there are societal implications to being uninsured, my generation needs some education about what those are.
http://medcitynews.com/2013/07/want-the-young-and-invincibles-to-buy-into-obamacare-answer-these-3-questions/#ixzz2aelaXjcW
Tags
Who is online
122 visitors

A young professional explains why she is unconvinced as to why she should buy insurance as prescribed by Obamacare.
Interesting questions
When I was uninsured, I had the exact opposite experience. Doctors charge way more for services to those who don't have insurance.
There's no question that health insurance is freakishly expensive, many times prohibitively so, but the ultimate penalty for not having it can be a million dollar catastrophic injury resulting from doing something as mundane as crossing the street and getting tagged by a hit-and-run driver.
Hal
Good points and hard to argue with but as the author points out the challenge is convincing the "invincibles" that such things could really happen to them
I have seen the cost negotiating work for people paying cash in medical and especially in dental care but I am sure that in some instances it is as you describe
Thanks for the feedback
J F T
If you check around on the internet a little you will find that many of the "invincibles" that work at companies that provide health insurance opt not to enroll for the reasons cited by the author
J F T
The author acknowledges that in so many words but that fact does not deter from the reality of the feeling of being invincible and not needing insurance which is the point of the article - the importance of effective messaging to convince the "invincibles" that they really aren't.
Justice
I don't know where you reside but I think you and the insurance company got the shaft. Last year I had kidney stone surgery and paid for it myself, and the cost was $6,750.
First of all you would have better luck ramming your head into a brick wall repeatedly, than trying to convince a 20 something year old that they should buy anything other than food, beer and vehicles. Unless they fine them $3,000 or $4,000 per year most are not going to purchase it they will pay the $100 fine for the year and be done with it. You can lead a horse to water but you can't make him drink.
The younger people will see the highest premium increases with the oldest seeing the lowest premium increases. Although the youngest will see the highest premium increases they will probably have the lowest income and therefore see 2/3 of their premium paid by the top 10% of income earners as subsidies.
So what you will like about Obamacare is the top 10% will be paying most of the premiums for everyone.
Now if you are young and make $45,000 as a single person you will get to see what it is like to be in the top 10%.
Approximately 50% of the people will not be paying fines or anything, so that leaves the other 50% to be considered as the 50% who will be paying something even if it is only 33% of their premium with the balance covered by subsidies paid by the top 10%.
This equates to the top 5% to 10% of income earners taking the biggest hit when the cost far exceeds the available funds to provide Obamacare for the nation except for the 30,000,000 who will still not have coverage.
CBO: Obamacare to Cover Millions Fewer Than Before Supreme Court Decision
Many states already facing deficits they are having a very difficult time of managing will not be able to handle the extra cost of Obamacare.
Obamacare....the last nail.
Jim
That is exactly the point and you are exactly right!!
Bravo
sixpick
Exactly what young people are thinking in my view
Thanks for the perspective
Their premiums will definitely be increasing the most, but the completion of the statement above as I posted it
will be the actual effect for most younger people since they will probably have lower incomes and the premiums will be based on income also. Even with the subsidies they will receive will be in effect a reduction of the real premium or out of pocket expense.
This is going to put a tremendous burden on the higher income earners because there will not be enough money to cover everyone covered unless the premium increases drastically with the top 10% of income earners in effect basically providing insurance for everyone else.
Everyone thinks they will be paying a lot of money for their insurance, but in my opinion this isn't going to be the case.
For example the millions of people that will have their hours cut back because of Obamacare will not be making as much money, so they will not be paying the full premium. The cost will be shifted to the top earners as planned (income redistribution).
Obamacare has nothing to do with health coverage. It's totally about income redistribution. The government will be forced to raise the premiums and the insurance will act as a drug to the majority of people because as we know when you get something for free, you kind of get use to it being that way and don't want it to change.
Obamacare will have the most demotivating effect on our society to grow and prosper than anything in my lifetime. Companies will prefer to grow, but will realize once they've grown and reach a certain level, they will take a big hit and be less inclined to shoot for the stars.
I have no faith in Obamacare whatsoever and think it is the last nail in the coffin for our country.
six
If someone is paying nothing because they do not have insurance at the present time then anything that they pay will be a lot to them whether it is a reasonable price for the product received or not since they do not believe they need the product.
I agree with some of the points you make abut the ACA and disagree with others - you are absolutely correct that the ACA is not about improving health care or making healthcare more affordable but rather about increasing access by taking from some to give to others.
A lot of people have seem lot of things over he years as the final nail in the coffin of the experiment called the U.S. and they have been wrong and I think you are wrong as well but time will tell.
Thanks for all the feedback
It may not be the last nail Robert, but it will be a drug to the majority of Americans which will have a tremendous withdrawal with the 10% paying and the 90% receiving which is a hard battle to fight if you are in the 10%.
It will not inspire growth, but will have the exact opposite effect in my opinion as it is already being proven even before it is fully implemented by many companies actually going out of business and many others cutting back on their employees hours to avoid having to tackle the tremendous cost to their companies once they reach a certain point in growth.
There will be many more people working two or more part time jobs to have enough money to live on, but still not enough to have to pay anywhere near the full premium for their coverage.
Then quite a few states aren't able to manage their present expenses and can not handle the additional expenses Obamacare will put on them, leaving 30 million or more people still without coverage.
The health care you receive will be based on the cost of providing it not the need for it and will become the most important issue from now on in this country.
Whoever can convince the people they are the one to give them the most will be the winner in all elections even though as we've seen, promises don't mean a thing, only a means of winning elections.
sixpick
You may be right but I hope you are wrong
Thanks for all the feedback
jack c hill
Fairly close for sure but irrelevant to the topic being discussed which is the challenge in getting the millennials who feel they are invincible to buy insurance
cant obama just deem this part of the law postponed until another election is over?
why does obama want to shut down the government, and default over our obligations, destroying this tepid recovery, all over obamacare?
JoAnne
Irrelevant to the discussion of how to get millennials to decide to buy insurance
Not about whether you like Pres Obama or not
Do you have anything relevant to say about the topic?
young healthy people they want in there system so the system can either balance itself out with all the really sick people who are turned down by insurance companies, so Government isn't footing and loosing money for helping only the really sick people. Get fifty percent healthy it will help balance it all, have less then 50% and it becomes a pinch, Have over 50% and it is the people who are getting screwed.
That is insurance system summed up and the government got screwed accepting those that insurance companies won't allow.
Jim,
I used to work for Pru, and believe me, they never get the shaft and they still won't under Obamacare. And $6,750 is a fortune to have your stone removed. In fact, most stones can be exploded by a water table in 3 min. I had it done.
Shub
Valid points
To a large degree (so far) the millennials are not buying into being the balancing factor
Maybe they will
Six,
This is all supposition. I am not a fan of Obamacare, but for a different reason then how sound it is financially.
You asked bet you thought no one would answer.
What do you think cancer treatment might cost an uninsured person?
Because it lowers the cost of health insurance for everyone.
And
Perrie
I am not a particular fan of the ACA either, but since it is now the law of the land it must be dealt with and if the millennials do not participate then there are big problems and how to get them to participate is the debate I was trying to trigger with the article
Not sure I succeeded
Invincible only till they are not. Take me for instance. When I was working for Pru-Bache, I got a huge tumor on my neck that was invading my spinal cord. I was 25. At the same time my cousin got non-Hodgkins lymphoma. He was 22. My medical bills back in 1985 was over $30,000. If I didn't have insurance (I did since I worked for Pru), I would have had to rely on the public health care system. This guy in the article, says he is healthy, but his activities:
put superman at high risk of bodily harm. If he were to apply for insurance, that would count towards his premium, or without insurance, he would have to go to a public hospital, who will pass on the cost to their paying customers. Where is the win in that?
My issue with Obamacare is more subtle. There is a campaign right now going on, telling us what medical treatments we need and don't need. Here let me show you one:
Visit NBCNews.com for breaking news , world news , and news about the economy
I would like to know which of you guys are willing to take that 33% chance that you don't have prostrate cancer? My uncle's cancer, with a high PSA of over 100, didn't show on any screenings, yet the PSA was high enough for him to force his drs to take a much closer look. He was stage 4A when they found it. He is alive and one of the lucky ones. My own dr, who is a woman of 36, felt a lump in her breast and her oncologist said it was nothing. Not trusting the dr and because she herself is one, forced him into removing the lump. She had stage 2 cancer. Had she taken her dr's advice, who knows how it would have played out.
The issue here is not that Obamacare is bad because it forces some brat to pay $700, so he won't buy a new Iphone this year, but that they are going to brainwash the uniformed into not getting the test and care they need, to reduce costs. That I find really scary.
Perrie
Thanks for the perspective and all the points and anecdotal illustrations are n point
If the ACA is to remain the law of land and we are all to o as best we can with it then we must (collectively) figure out how to get the young and the healthy (almost sounds like a soap opera) involved and participating
The type of messaging contained may be just the thing needed to get the message across
A Mac
Your points and the data you provide is appreciated but it is the messaging that is the challenge
No one should really question that the participation of the young and the healthy is required to make the ACA work and whether one supports the ACA or does no support it as the right public policy it is what we have to work with right now.
A lot of millennialsmust be convinced that it is in their best interest to participate
Then maybe the PSA should be about all those healthy self absorbed youth, getting sick. Like rates of cancer, auto immune diseases (happens mostly to young people), auto accidents (which they lead in). Nothing like a dose of reality that I got to make you see the value of paying in. Also maybe making the penalty a bit more painful.
Perrie
I think you are correct
My boys are in their thirties and subtle does work with them and I assume not with the group younger than them so I think the messaging needs to be in your face if it is tobe effective
This whole thing is a forest. It's almost ridiculous to think that one congress that lasted for 6 months and behind closed doors has passed on to the whole country through unscrupulous means a law that over half the public didn't want and now we're stuck with this monster which really has nothing to do with health coverage, but income redistribution.
Before I even get involved in Obamacare, I note that 50% of Americans weren't paying anything for their health coverage before and will not be paying anything after Obamacare is implemented. 13% to 17% gave Obama their votes and if included in any poll would have been in favor of anything that Obama had anything to do with. Then you had the die hard liberals who felt a racial guilt and gave their support when they along with the others mentioned above didn't know crap about what they were doing or getting into. All they knew was Obama said it was good and if he said it was good it must be.
So if you take all the tax paying citizens of this country and only the the tax paying citizens of this country you would probably find 85% or more of these people didn't want Obamacare for a number of reasons, one being they were perfectly happy with what they had and didn't want their health treatments to be guided by cost as it will be in Obamacare and not need as it is now.
Don't continue to fool yourself. Obamacare and the cost of it will become a bigger issue than anything else in this country. It will be the main focus in every election from here on out. There will become a time when cost will be the most important thing to consider before maybe allowing you to have that treatment to save your life.
Someone is going to have to pay the cost of the coverage and it isn't going to be the people who receive free health coverage already, the people who make less that $45,000 a year for the most part or the many exceptions including the people who work in Washington who will get 75% of their premiums paid by the taxpayer who makes more than $45,000 as a single person. And this doesn't even touch on all the exceptions granted by the Obama Administration.
Take for example here's a young guy who hasn't paid anything but the penalty, excuse me, tax for not taking out the policy and finds out he does have cancer. Now what do you think we are going to do? Let me tell you. We're going to treat his cancer whether he has paid or not and if he is disabled from the cancer and isn't making that $45,000 at the current rate set, then we are going to pay for his treatment without any money coming from him at all. This all will depend on his income. If he is still working at McDonald's he will not pay anything. In fact everyone at McDonald's that aren't upper management will get free coverage anyway.
They say we had 160,000 something jobs created last month and unemployment had come down two tenths of a point. Chris Matthews was bragging about it. I mean how long will it take or is it even possible for the people to realize that is no recovery and it's all bogus. I would go into it more, but it's a waste of time. This all may seem off topic, but it isn't really. I have a reason for all of this. First you're not going to get the young man to pay the insurance premium. I know you want to brainwash him enough to make him want to do his part, but it isn't going to work.
Even that little video Perrie put up is subtle, I agree. I don't know if it is of the same reason, but my reason is very clear to me. It's the psychology that is being used to brainwash you some more to start making you think different about things. Sometimes I think our whole language has been taken over by some alien or something. The idea behind that video is to manipulate the way you look at things, so you will accept it when you doctor tells you "we just need to keep a close look at it."
It's no different than the Boston Bomber day when martial law was thrust into you face all day long. I keep saying this and it's true. A good track dog could have tracked the younger bomber the night before right to where he ended up, but they used the opportunity to practice martial law and condition you a little all day long. They really think we have been dumb down quite a bit and it is pretty obvious we have to me. It's not an overnight thing, but a generational thing. We are falling off the tree so to speak, we're so ripe for it today.
So take HR 3590. Service Members Home Ownership Tax Act of 2009 was introduced in the House of Representatives on September 17, 2009. It was sponsored by Rep. Charles Rangel from NY.
The text of HR 3590 stated that the bills purpose was:
To amend the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 to modify the first-time home buyers credit in the case of members of the Armed Forces and certain other Federal employees, and for other purposes.
Not too many people would argue with helping out the members of our armed services, so the bill was passed by the House of Representatives on October 8, 2009 by a "call of roll" which resulted in a vote of 416-0 (with 16 not voting).
The truth is that Charles Rangel never introduced HR 3590 with the purpose of seeing it become law under its originally stated purpose.
Instead, Congressman Rangel introduced HR 3590 as a means to create a bill that absolutely no representative in their right mind would be against all for the purpose of getting the House bill to the US Senate so that it could be gutted and replaced with the Health Care bill as an amendment. Rep. Rangel used our brave service members as a decoy to get the bill to the Senate. To cut thru the cheese, Harry Reid struck out the original bill and replaced it with the Healthcare Bill. It was finally passed as a reconciliation bill when over 60% of the citizens of this country didn't even want it.
Anyway you look at it, what this monster is designed to do is give the IRS more power over you, make the people that make over $92,000 as a family pay almost all the premium to cover the entire population of the USA, except the 30 million that will not have coverage. (Oh did I mention that half the jobs created last month were part time?) Well they won't pay anything.
And all this talk about immigration. Now what do you think we're going to do with the illegal immigrant (sorry, I'm using the old dictionary) when he/she or one of the children get sick? Do you think we're going to say screw you? I don't think so, we don't now and we won't after Obamacare is fully implemented. We'll add that to the overall cost and the top 5 to 10% of income earners will cover that as well.
That fact is most people families don't make $100,000 or $92,000 per year so they will be subsidized up to 2/3 of their premium paid for them. You can bet the ones that haven't and aren't going to be paying anything love that. The Democrats have convinced them the Republicans are the rich dogs. Well they're not, they only donate more of their money than the Democrats to social programs, that's all. And the ones I know don't have time to protest because they are too busy trying to support their families and get ahead while they don't even realize they are fixing to really get screwed again.
No..... I wouldn't encourage a young person to pay anything but the penalty. Why? It's to their benefit. When they get sick enough that they need the insurance but not sick enough to be disabled and don't make the $45,000 they will get a big discount anyway or they can just build up a big bill under big brother IRS, but they will still be treated. We're not going to turn people away from treatment of course the Democrats may if they can find a way to blame it on the Republicans
Let me tell you there are only a handful of Republicans that are worth a crap and none of them have been in Washington for very long. But as far as what I've seen with the Democrats it's about the same.
By the way if you haven't noticed almost all jobs being created are part time jobs since Obama has taken control (and I mean that) and the economy has been growing at about 1/5 to 1/3 of what it needs to be growing, more people than in recorded history are going on disability, 8 million jobs have vanished, almost 50 million people are on food stamps (sorry the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program) which they are selling by the truck loads, companies are working with less employees, rates for next year for health insurance are increasing drastically in most cases and rebates for your insurance premiums are insurance protection the insurance companies are using as they don't know before hand what it is going to cost them to pay the claims. They have actuaries who project the cost but they put a buffer in there in case it cost more, so you're not getting money back in the sense you made money. They just have to cover their butts so they charge more than what they predict the actual cost to be to protect themselves from a catastrophic loss. If anything is left over they give it back. You just let them hold more of your money and when they finalized the year you get it back. Nothing special about that. The way it is written makes you think you actually made some money, doesn't it?
Most of you will not have to worry anyway, because most of your premiums will be paid by someone else until their motivation for success has been taken from them as well and as the field becomes more level there will be a smaller percentage paying for your insurance unless they just decide to quit carrying the whole cart and see where you end up then.
So, just hold your arm out and stick the needle in slowly. You don't want to overdose the first shot.
Egilman
The efforts of the Congress and their staff members to be exempt from the provisions of the PPACA which they have enacted for "the common people" is to say the least a little disturbing.
Looks like Ms. Pelosi read what was in the law and didn't like all that much
Sixpick
Thanks for sharing your perspective and providing a detailed explanation of the points of concern about the ACA