╌>

Court to Review Plan for Baby Veronica's Transition back to South Carolina

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  jsbach  •  13 years ago  •  41 comments

Court to Review Plan for Baby Veronica's Transition back to South Carolina

Court to Review Plan for Baby Veronica's Transition back to South Carolina

By JARREL WADE World Staff Writer on Jul 31, 2013, at 2:23 AMUpdated on 7/31/13 at 2:39 AM

Jarrel Wade 918-581-8367
jarrel.wade@tulsaworld.com

A transition plan set for a South Carolina family court to review on Wednesday outlines suggestions for a process to return Baby Veronica to her adoptive parents, including encouragement for her father to throw Veronica a going-away party before a seven-day transition in Oklahoma.

The plan - provided to the World by Cherokee Nation officials who are working with Veronica's biological father, Dusten Brown - is the basis for a family court hearing in South Carolina scheduled for Wednesday afternoon, when a judge will decide the details of the transition.

Cherokee Nation spokeswoman Amanda Clinton said the proposed plan is callous toward Veronica and developed by social workers who have never seen or talked to the almost 4-year-old girl.

However, Lori Alvino McGill, an attorney for the birth mother, said Brown, who has had custody of Veronica for the past 19 months, never allowed the social workers who wrote the plan - nor the adoptive parents, Matt and Melanie Capobianco - to have any access to Veronica.

Soon after she was born, Brown agreed to give custody to the birth mother, who - unbeknownst to him, he maintains - had put Veronica up for adoption.

The Capobiancos raised Veronica from birth but lost custody when she was 2 years old.

With help from the Cherokee Nation, Brown won custody in December 2011. But the U.S. Supreme Court overturned that decision last month, sending the case back to South Carolina.

A1veronica0731.jpg
IN THE MIDDLE
Veronica: Social workers drafted a proposal for how both sides should handle her transition back to South Carolina.

"Developed by experts in the field, that (transition) plan seeks to make it as easy as possible for Veronica to be reunited with her family, and has Veronica's interests as its controlling consideration, as the (South Carolina) Supreme Court recognized," McGill said.

The plan calls for a transition period of a week, when Veronica will be weaned away from Brown slowly - starting with play dates for the adoptive couple before phasing toward play dates with Brown and then the adoptive parents returning with Veronica to South Carolina.

"The bottom line is that Matt and Melanie have pledged to abide by whatever terms the family court believes are necessary to ensure that Veronica's interests are protected during this sensitive time," McGill said.

"That stands in sharp contrast to the way Veronica was treated 18 months ago, when she was loaded into a pickup truck, driven 22 straight hours to Oklahoma, and then never allowed to see or speak to her parents (the Capobiancos) again.

"Throughout this period, and even to this day, the Brown family has repeatedly refused simple requests for any type of visitation."

Deena McMahon, a licensed individual clinical social worker in Minnesota, prepared the plan along with Catherine O'Reilly Chalmers, a licensed family therapist in Tulsa, according to South Carolina court records.

Chalmers did not return phone calls on Tuesday.

According to the transition plan, Brown is encouraged to do things to make Veronica feel comfortable with the Capobiancos, who are asked to send photos.

"He can plan a farewell celebration with his community, which should be done prior to the transition period. He can gather photos and memorabilia of his life with Veronica and of his own family and community and have them organized to send with Veronica," according to the plan's preparation section.

"Dusten (Brown) should be encouraged to find and use support to help him manage this grief-filled experience. This person may be his proxy, a mental health provider or community member," according to the plan.

The plan encourages Brown to appear outwardly supportive and positive about the transition back to the Capobiancos for Veronica's sake.

"If the parties mutually agree, visits with Dusten (Brown) should not occur for at least two months, to allow Veronica time to settle in. Routine phone calls, such as once or twice a week for the first few weeks, are suggested, but they should not last more than a few minutes," according to the transition plan.

In a section labeled "What to tell the Child," the five-page plan suggests distractions such as "She can have a cookie at her adoptive parents' house. Talk about games she can play when she gets there. Tell her she can watch her favorite video or cartoon when she returns to the adoptive parents' home."

"In language Veronica can understand, help her realize she will be returning to the family she lived with when she was a little girl, to help take care of her, to keep her safe, to play with her, and to love her. This is the hardest part.

"Veronica must not believe she is being abandoned or rejected. She needs to feel she is gaining something and being welcomed. Tell her repeatedly that Dusten loves her very much. At this stage, children can understand the idea of two fathers."

Cherokee Nation Assistant Attorney General Chrissi Nimmo said attorneys for Brown intend to file an objection Wednesday to halt the family court hearing, "though we don't think it will have any effect."

Brown has filed a request with the U.S. Supreme Court to stay the South Carolina Supreme Court order, Nimmo said.

The Supreme Court ordered that the adoptive couple respond to the motion by 2 p.m. Friday.

On Wednesday "there will likely be an order of a physical transfer of custody, and the adoption will likely be finalized, barring any unforeseen circumstances," Nimmo said. "The mechanism then to enforce that order is to register it with an Oklahoma court and seek enforcement."

Brown will then have 20 days to request a hearing, unless he voluntarily agrees to go forward with the transition, Nimmo said.

"We are still very, very hopeful the United States Supreme Court will stay the South Carolina Supreme Court decision," Nimmo said.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    13 years ago

"That" family never adopted Veronica - they have merely put in an application for adoption - hence the name "adoptive parents".

The seven Native American organizations who are preparing the suit in favor of Dusten will be able to slam McGill to the mat for her total lack of knowledge of ICWA.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    13 years ago

This entire "plan" is callous and disgusting.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    13 years ago

If this were the mother wanting her child back there wouldn't even be a controversy. Forget about the fact that this father is Native American, and concentrate on the word "father." That alone should settle the matter.

Mothers who have signed away their babies from the delivery room, had nothing to do with them for years then changed their minds, have been able to have adoptions set aside and their children returned to them. Judges have ignored the screams of the children and the heartbroken sobs of the adoptive parents as they were torn from each other's arms, citing "birth parents" as if it were a sacred right.

So exactly what is the problem here? Come on out and say it. What is the problem here? This is the child's birth parent, her father, a decent person with a support system to help care for her and he loves her and wants her. Come on. Come on out with it. What's the real problem here? Is it because he is a man? Is it because he is an Indian? What's the real problem?

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

Bravo! Mimi!

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    13 years ago

The "plan" is "supposed" to be made up by the tribe, not the state. The tribe is/has provided "expert witnesses" in strict accordance with ICWA. "Deena McMahon, a licensed individual clinical social worker in Minnesota, prepared the plan along with Catherine O'Reilly Chalmers, a licensed family therapist in Tulsa, according to South Carolina court records." Based on the information provided in this sentence, neither of the "planners" are Indian and are not qualified, per ICWA, to write a plan or to be "expert witnesses".

The "plan", by law, is supposed to be rehabilitative and remedial - to make things right for the family to stay together. This "plan" they are writing has absolutely nothing to do with ICWA.

The "family"'s attorneys have been pushing this since the beginning - they're looking for bigbucks at the sake of a child and her father. The "family" was going to concede to the State Family Court's decision but the attorney's wouldn't let them, and to the State Supreme Court's decision, but, again,the attorneys told them they "needed" to take it to SCOTUS.

Simply put, by law, as I've said in two other threads, Dusten Brown and Veronica are father and daughter, by blood, and that trumps the wishes of the "family".

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    13 years ago

You just so good - mmmuuuuwwwwaaaaahhhhhhhhh9.gif 41.gif 9.gif 41.gif 9.gif 41.gif

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    13 years ago

Indian child - Indian father - what part of ICWA does that not fit?

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    13 years ago

Asking the father to throw her a party as a kiss off, that's what. It's callous to ask the father to do that, and when she is older she could very well think of it as her father being so happy to get rid of her that he celebrated it with a party.

And I'm back to asking the question... what's the real beef here? He's her birth father, so what the heck is the real problem here? These other people have not even actually adopted her, so why do you keep referring to them as her adoptive parents? So far they are simply foster parents, technically speaking. The adoption has not been finalized... and should never be.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    13 years ago

Perhaps the term "those people" was merely was used to designate the foster parents (they are not the adoptive parents as they have never adopted Veronica as yet) and not as a slur, Bullwinkle.

Please, let's give each other a benefit of the doubt.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    13 years ago

To help many of you to understand what plans are allowed under ICWA -

1. "Remedial and rehabilitative services: Remedial and rehabilitative services are services provided by the state to give support to families to help them become safe placements for a child. These services are required in the Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA). The intention of these services is to provide supports to a family to prevent the removal of a child by rehabilitating or strengthening the family in their parenting and other related skills, and/or to provide support that assists in remediating or correcting the situation in a home that led to the removal of a child. These services can include family group conferencing, parent counseling, substance abuse counseling, job-skill training, and many other types of services."

2. "Service plan: A service plan is an arrangement of services identified by a social worker and family to meet the needs of the child and/or parents. Services for the child can include counseling, cultural practices for healing, medical treatment, protective day care, and out-of-home placement. Services for both the parents and the child can include concurrent planning, family group conferencing, counseling, cultural practices for healing, and other rehabilitative and remedial services. The service plan may include informal sources of support, like extended family, church, and the tribe. Social workers will have a certain number of face-to-face contacts and home visits with the family, but the level of service varies by family needs, the proximity of services, and the services provided by other agencies. The service plan is time-limited, meaning that goals and objectives must be met within a limited time or the social worker will look at other permanent placements."

3. "Concurrent planning: Concurrent planning is a practice technique used by social workers that takes place when the worker and the family simultaneously plan for reunification and an alternate permanent placement if reunification is not possible."

4. "Active efforts: Active efforts is an action that is required of the state in caring for an Indian child, mandated under the Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA). While active efforts is undefined in ICWA, it refers to an effort more intense than the legal term reasonable efforts. Active efforts applies to providing remedial and rehabilitative services to the family prior to the removal of an Indian child from his or her parent or Indian custodian, and/or an intensive effort to reunify an Indian child with his or her parent or Indian custodian."

Note - all of the above (and all of ICWA) deal with the reunification of the family - the Indian family. Nowhere in the threads storylineis any of this discussed. So, what type of "planning" are they doing other than raping the Indians through faulty interpretation of the law????

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    13 years ago

So, not following the law is OK? Tearing apart a father and daughter is OK? Tearing apart an Indian family is OK?

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    13 years ago

You know, Bullwinkle, I was trying to impart some sort of feeling of friendship into this discussion and meant no personal insult to you or to foster parents or to adoptive parents, just as I meant to personal insult to Rescue.

If you choose to take it as such and embrace hard feelings, that is on you. I have mentioned at least four times that mothers are allowed to set aside adoptions years after giving away babies straight from the delivery room and never having had any further relationship with them... neither did they reimburse the adoptive parents for any prenatal care, cost of delivery, or parenting care they had given the child.

That is the basis of my questioning why this father is being treated differently. I have never, once, said that I think adoptive parents aren't real parents; I have never once made a blanket assumption that blood parents are better caretakers for children than loving adoptive parents, and I do not think so.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    13 years ago

Again - this "may" sound like it's really emotional (and it is to some), but this is a serious legal precedence that needs to be brought to a full stop because it is making a mockery of the law.

ICWA gives tribal governments a strong voice concerning child custody proceedings that involve Indian children, by allocating tribes exclusive jurisdiction over the case when the child resides on, or is domiciled on, the reservation, or when the child is a ward of the tribe; and concurrent, but presumptive, jurisdiction over non-reservation Native Americans foster care placement proceedings.

That is the law - has nothing to do with emotionalism.

Rescue, you need to open your eyes and head when discussing this topic because your heartcontinues to advocate the non-legal standing and practice taking place. Can't do that. Have to follow the law.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    13 years ago

Serious court time coming up - get your iced tea and peanut butter and jelly sandwiches ready.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    13 years ago

Just posted the new article - go gett'm.

This is gonna get good.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    13 years ago

I can see that you can't separate the two things.

What you can't see is my point of view, and I am having difficulty seeing yours on this subject.

We are both merely guessing as to what the child will think about it all in the future IF she ends up with her adoptive parents.

there is a thing called sacrificial love.

Yes, there is. And it is only the father you seem to be accusing of lacking in this area. She is now with him and appears to be happy and thriving. The foster parents could show some sacrificial love and leave Veronica with her birth father instead of once again filling her life with the trauma of removing her from the family life she has come to know.

Regardless of whatever transition plan is put in place it WILL be a trauma for her, and Separation Anxiety Disorder will no doubt be a part of Veronica's psychological makeup if this "transition" takes place.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    13 years ago

Depends on many things. First and foremost - Choctaw Indian Band of Mississippi v. Holyfield - Indian parents, on the rez, went 200 miles away to have their twins and placed them in an adoption. The State of Miss said - you can do it; the state Supreme Court said you can do it; the SCOTUS said - Tribe, what do you think???? Wow. Well, the tribe said they could adopt the children out since they had been away from the rez for over four years, didn't even know the birth parents, nor knew anything of their culture or heritage. Good ruling by SCOTUS and by the tribe.

This case is totally the opposite.

There is no such thing as a "Transition Plan". ICWA does not allow for one - as you've seen on the other post listing the four types of plans allowed under ICWA. This is an ICWA case, pure and simple. Contrary to what someone said earlier, SCOTUS did not say this wasn't an ICWA case - the SC Supremes said that - and they don't have that right or latitude.

ICWA/tribes/Indians, in the hypothetical you listed, would "probably" allow the family who adopted her to keep her - just as in Holyfield - she doesn't know her birth parents, knows nothing of her heritage/culture/traditions or her tribe, because the law is designed to keep Indian families together if "it is the child's best interests." In your hypothetical, the child would probably stay.

Your hypothetical doesn't match the case - even by the wildest of imaginations.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    13 years ago

Luv ya flame - mean it.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    13 years ago

It's not totally separate from this situation when someone has made the comment that the father has made no effort to reimbursethe couple in SC or the birth mother for the money they have spent so far on the birth and care of Veronica... so I addressed that comment.

If you have not heard of children being returned to birth mothers years after being given up, I am surprised. It was in the news several times, and in some of the articles about Americans seeking adoptions out of the country it was listed as one of the reasons along with the faster adoption times.

 
 

Who is online





122 visitors