Neighborhood News and Views – Tax Code Reform
Taxes now that is a subject that comes up often in our group and the discussions are always long-winded, loud and full of assertions that this is what should be done to fix the tax code.
There are so many taxes to discuss income taxes (village, state and federal), excise taxes (state and federal), gasoline taxes (state and federal), sales tax, property tax, capital gains tax, estate taxes, gift taxes and on and on and on.
How much is too much and who should and should not be taxed more?
What deductions are really necessary and which are simply loopholes and gimmicks to game the process?
Should some industries get subsidies and others not receive them?
Who decides what is subsidized by the government?
Are taxes rates too high, too low, or just right?
Tax credits sound fiscal policy or simply another method to game the system at great expense to the U.S. taxpayers?
These are some of the many points, counterpoints and vague assertions that are a regular part of our discussions of the U.S. tax system and dont even get me started on the corporate tax code which is an entirely different discussion and article for another day.
The general view of our little group is that
1- All or virtually deductions and credits should be eliminated from the personal income tax code
2 A base amount of income should be non-taxable for citizens. The exact amount is debatable but our group thought it should be $25K for individuals and $40K for families, income above that amount would be taxable based on a progressive rate schedule from 1% to 25%.
3 State and municipal income taxes would be structured the same way with the tax rate decided on by the states.
4 All income, payroll, capital gains, inheritance, gift, et al would be taxed in this manner at a single rate.
We know it sounds too simple to be embraced by any politicians, but it would insure that everyone paid income tax in accordance with the rate assigned to their taxable income level, without adjustment, gimmick or loophole.
Tags
Who is online
122 visitors

Few subjects are as volatile to discuss currently than taxes, what should be done about revenue shortages, which taxes should be raised and which should be lowered, etc.
Some will opine that taxing the rich more will solve all the problems.
Some will opine that too many people get more out of the system than they pay into it.
Everyone agrees that the current system is broken but there is little agreement on how to fix the problems.
Well here is what he guys in the neighborhood think about tax reform.
John
If you think about it
There would be no deductions, no credits so all the tax paid in would actually go to the treasury
The top tax rate (say for incomes over $1M) would 25% and with no deductions people would actually pay 25% income tax (likewise on capital gains, inheritance etc) so the volume of tax revenue would increase greatly.
There would actually be more money to spend for the government to spend and the higher earners (actually everyone) would pay a true percentage of their incomes in taxes according to the rate schedule.
The current filing threshold for a married couple with 2 children is $27,800
The numbers could always be moved up or down a little - I am sure that there are self proclaimed and actual tax experts that will let us know what it should be
i am for either flat, or fair tax
caveat: remove ALL others.
of course this will never happen, certainly not while barry's henchmen are terrorizing conservatives
JoAnne
Thanks for your perspective in taxes in the first part of your comment
The last line of your comment is neither true, relevant or helpful to the discussion
Hi Robert,
I'm going to get to this as soon as I am back from my appt. Ironically, I have to do someone's taxes.
BadFish
Thanks for sharing your perspective
I think you will agree that it is fantasy so what real changes to the tax code do you think are possible and would be better than what we have now
Perrie
Thanks is somewhat ironic.
Always appreciate your perspective on my articles and comments
In my humble opinion we should move to a flat tax system, 15%-20% whatever it takes. The first 25K should be a tax free, living allowance everything after that is taxed. Think of the amount of money it would save the taxpayers, we would have less IRS employees, you could actually do your taxes yourself and not have to pay an accountant. You would know exactly how much money you owed in taxes, and not worry about whether you paid enough in or you are going to get hit with a tax bill at the end of the year.
As far as business taxes go, same deal, with the exception that they would be able to deduct direct expenses wages, costs of goods, etc. No loopholes or subsidies for oil companies, green energy, farms or any others.
Hi Robert,
First, there are really two different topics here; personal taxes and corporate taxes.
Let me first do the personal code.
The code is in desperate need of simplification. I used to think that the flat tax was the way to go. On the surface is seems fair, a set amount for everyone. In reality it's impact is the harshest on the working poor. Let me give you an example:
Let's set the tax rate at 20% Person A makes $25,000 and person B makes $250,000. So person A will pay $5,000 reducing their income to $20,000. Person B will pay $50,000, reducing their income to $200,000. The impact of this at the lower end of the income is far greater. $5,000 to them may be the difference between eating healthy or not. On the upper end of the scale, it might mean that they don't get to buy a car that year. No one will go hungry.
OK so now what?
A progressive scale isn't bad. What is, are all the loopholes. Most people think of deductions and credits in the same way, but they are not. There are 4 deductions individuals pay:
Of these 4, probably the one that should jump out at you is the gifts made by cash defined by the IRS as: Any transfer to an individual, either directly or indirectly, where full consideration (measured in money or money's worth) is not received in return.
Of this there are several classes of gifts:
All but number 2 should be go. They benefit the upper end of the income brackets. 2 usually affects the middle class the most, and as we have seen on many a chart, the middle class is drowning.
Now let's go to credits.
Let's start from the top. The Earned Income Credit , as defined by the IRS:
EITC, the Earned Income Tax Credit, sometimes called EIC is a tax credit to help you keep more of what you earned. It is a refundable federal income tax credit for low to moderate income working individuals and families. Congress originally approved the tax credit legislation in 1975 in part to offset the burden of social security taxes and to provide an incentive to work. When EITC exceeds the amount of taxes owed, it results in a tax refund to those who claim and qualify for the credit. To qualify, you must meet certain requirements and file a tax return, even if you do not owe any tax or are not required to file.
I bolded the part of the code that is a problem. This means that you can actually get back more money than you earned. Now I am all for letting the lower income brackets keep everything that they earn, since this would reduce public assistance, but it's not fair that they should get money back, while the middle and upper class has to pay.
Education Credit :
Tax credits, deductions and savings plans can help taxpayerswiththeir expenses for higher education.
Fair enough. It helps families send their kids through college. Lower income brackets have benefits from income based scholarships, that middle class families don't. There should be a cut off for this for the ultra wealthy, since they don't need it. I'm being generous here, but no to $500,000 a year.
Child and Dependent care credit. This is a tricky one. The IRS defines this as:
Expenses are paid for the care of a qualifying individual if the primary function is to assure the individual's well-being and protection. In general, amounts paid for services outside your household qualify for the credit if the care is provided for (i) a qualifying individual who is your qualifying child under age 13 or (ii) a qualifying individual who regularly spends at least 8 hours each day in your household.
This credit helps people work, which is good. But there should be a point where there is a cut off. Define that at the upper limit of middle class. After that you can afford to pay for such help.
The Adoption Credit I am on the fence about. My gut says that we shouldn't allow it at all. Most public adoptions of unwanted children, arebasicallyfree. The few fees involved should be covered by the code. But this is for adoptions that are private and or out of this country. Well if they are private, that is your choice to make. If they are out of this country, again, your choice to make. I don't see why the American people should have to support these choices. And for the record, my niece is one of these adoptions.
Health Coverage Tax Credit:This credit will no longer be available after 2014, when Obamacare kicks in.
Savers Credit. The savers credit helps offset part of the first $2,000 workers voluntarily contribute to IRAs and to 401(k) plans and similar workplace retirement programs. Also known as the retirement savings contributions credit, the savers credit is available in addition to any other tax savings that apply.
The savers credit can be claimed by:
This one gets a resounding keep. This is a huge encouragement for people to plan for their retirement, which in return will reduce the burden on the government.
OK that's a start.
Hi Robert!
I'm going to throw my two cents in...not that mine or anyone else's is going to make a bit of difference...but here goes
I'm not going to go into nearly as much detail as Perrie has...very good, Perrie!!!!
I really believe that capital gains should be addressed. Most capital gains taxes are paid on investment 'income', not real estate (when the middle class pay capital gains taxes, it's usually from real estate). It's an unfair use of our tax system that those that earn their living from investments, don't pay 'earned income taxes.'
Leona,
I totally agree! Just hadn't gotten there yet, but now you saved me the work, LOL!
Jim,
I could live with the flat tax, but then your cut off is too low. See comment below. To have a flat tax work, and you are doing away with all other deductions, then you have to raise the limit to at least $75,000. The take home would be $60,000. That $60,000 would now have to pay for Tuition or medical expenses, child care, retirement,mortgage or rent, state and local taxes,transportation, clothing, food...
There are not many places in the US that can do that even on $60,000 a year shopping at Walmart.
Perrie
Thank you for a very thoughtful, well thought out and detailed perspective and for the excellent feedback on a complicated subject.
There are arguments to be made by individuals and groups for keeping an and all of the deductions and credits in the tax code and that is the reason that it is the unmanageable mess that it is today and why it is manipulated and misused by so many and bottom line it does not work.
I appreciate and respect your passion for the deductions that you consider favorable and useful but in my view the best idea might befrom your comment - raise the nontaxable income amountand eliminate all the tax deductions ad credits. In my view having a non-taxable amount and deductions and credits isa non starter.
Thanks again for the excellentfeedback
leonahardware
Howdy and thanks for the feedback
I addressed that issue in the article saying that all income should be taxed in the same way so I obviously agree with you
Robert,
You are a very nice host to your articles. I like that!
I also realize that while detailed, my post is a huge bore. The fact that I am a CPA, I usually hide, since it does make me the bane of dull jokes.
I am not sure I understand this:
So are you saying, that you are for a flat tax but say raising up the base income to a say somewhere between $50K-$65K before the tax would kick in? I guess that is doable. I am not sure if those who advocate for a flat tax would agree with the bottom amount though.
Perrie
I am saying that I d not know what the non-taxable base income should be but feel hat a tax code without deductions or credits would be simpler, less manipulated and better for everyone (citizens ad government)
Accountants are great people and usually have a lot of interesting and illuminating things to say, I started my career in accounting, bookkeeping and finance but made the shift to Human Resources for the last 15 years before I retired.
I found that my accounting education and background was very helpful in my HR career as I partnered with General Managers and Directors and advocated for employees at the same time
Finding the Goldilocks method are we?
You should also remember what will the behavioral effect be to the people. Raise prices on gas and people will car pool or public transportation, lower the price and you'll see more vehicles out on the road with more crashes.
a large gap why not 5% to 10%
Do municipal's have a decision on tax rate ro do the states decide for the municipal's?
Tax Roth IRA's and over shore accounts also? What if the amount of the gift is $10,000 isn't that written off in the tax code under the IRS now? You want to tax that to?
BTW Robert this article would have been perfect for the economics forum
Shub
I try to post an short article on a regular basis about the things my friends (of various political persuasions) talk about
I do not suggest that I have the final answers or that what we think is the best solution
The specific questions you ask are good ones - the schedule of tax rates could be 5% to 10% I suppose but I think 25% on incomes over $1M is fair what the lowest rate is debatable in my view. Of course states and municipalities would set their own tax rates and in the article I said all income would be taxed the same.
Feel free to put the article (or any other article) I write in the forum as I have no idea how to do so
As always thanks for the feedback
It is the same way only you go to the group page and click article/seed underneath the other articles
Your welcome.
Shub
And the article still shows up for he whole site to see and comment on and not just the selected group?