╌>

It's time for the United States to cease financial aid to Egypt.

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  dean-moriarty  •  13 years ago  •  47 comments

It's time for the United States to cease financial aid to Egypt.

Time to end aid.

Egypt is a disaster veering toward catastrophe. President Barack Obamas decision to ignore U.S. law by continuing financial aid will only exacerbate the situation. The administrations signal achievement is that almost everyone in Egypt now blames America, which has provided almost $75 billion in financial assistance to Cairo over the years.

Egypt became a top aid recipient after Anwar Sadat switched sides during the Cold War. His government was paid even more for making peace with Israel. Washington argued that the stability seemingly purchased was a good deal. No longer, however.

First, the law requires halting assistance. If the administration doesnt want to obey, it should urge Congress to amend the law. Only by applying a Clintonesque twist can what happened in Cairothe army arresting the president and top aides, prosecuting opponents, shutting television stations, detaining journalists, freezing assets, and shooting demonstratorsbe called something other than a coup. In fact, the Associated Press detailed how the military planned its takeover for months and aided the group Tamarrod in building opposition to former president Mohamed Morsi.

Washingtons best hope is to disengage, leaving Egyptians to decide their own future.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
AmericanDreamsShattered
Freshman Silent
link   AmericanDreamsShattered    13 years ago

I agree 100%, it is also time for this country to start calling in all of the "loans" it has made over the last 50 some odd years! Why is it that all you ever hear about is the amount of money this country "owes" to China? Yet conversely you never hear about what is "owed to the United States" by the World?

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    13 years ago

"Islamic democracy"

...along with "family vacation", "Soviet journalists" and "Lebanese government" are some of the more frequently used oxymorons in recent history.

It took more than 2 years, but the world has figured out that having elections does not make a country a democracy. Elections are part of the process in a democracy, but it is the freedoms that citizens have the other 364 days of the year that determine the type of government that rules.

Globally, the US has been made a fool of, for many reasons, spanning many decades. In particular, the UN has been a venue for ridicule of democracy in general, and the US and Israel specifically. There are countries that receive aid from the US every year to help run their countries, and yet, the voting record of these countries that rely upon US dollars votes against the US about 80% of the time. There are countries that these poor, despotic nations vote with all the time that can send them aid, but do not. The US need not send these countries anything. It's one thing when a country takes aid but does nothing to help you. It's another when they take aid and do things to hinder.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

But the vote is not the essential element in "freedom". The essential element is "rule of law".

That is not so simple . If the leader is not elected and/or cannot be thrown out what is to stop him from making his own laws ... and to exclude himself from the "rule of law" ? There has to be a system in place to remove him from office to prevent abuses . In Egypt the army provided that mechanism . In Turkey that is no longer possible [to my knowledge] .

What is likely to limit the powers of Erdogan ?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

I've learned a lot from this exchange . Thanks for your input .

I wonder about Iran . Are the courts subject to the control of the imams ?

Also how are the justices chosen for the European Court of Justice ?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

That's quite informative anyway . I suppose the critical factor is the combining of church and state . Giving political power to religious leaders presents problems which are essentially unavoidable . Its ancient Persia all over again .

And if what you say is accurate about the anti-Americanism there the resistance will not be receiving US aid anytime soon .

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

I used to think that doing that would be closing the proverbial 'gate,' to the middle-east, but I don't think so anymore. It goes to the wrong places/people anyway.

We gave a lot to Mubark and they had a 40% unemployment rate... look where that led - rioting. It seems to me, that if the leadership of a country wants to improve his own own welfare, then he would then need to first improve the welfare of the citizenry -- without causing them to be dependent on the government for their welfare.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

The world is a complicated place. Often it is better to support what we don't believe for the simple fact it would cost us much more somewhere else. But one thing for sure is when we do support others with our aid we should do with conditions, not because we just want to be good samaritans.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

we could have purchased all of their hearts and minds for a great deal less...

That is a good idea in theory but distributing $$ to a large population could be complicated . Usually the gatekeepers take most of it .

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    13 years ago

History tells a different story.

Those in power take any amount they want, but still foment hatred against us. It's not even a question of saying "thank you". They maintain an adversarial position, and make sure that their population maintains a hostile posture towards us.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

Nobody gets killed.

I kinda think everyone would be good with that...

Sorry but this view assumes western values . The middle east is not like that . Blood seems to be the currency of choice there .

BTW , what would you pay people to do [or not do ] . And how would you get reimbursed if they did not perform ?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

I don't understand how you expect that an example from SE Asia compares to Afghanistan

I'm pretty sure that dollars would be appreciated...

Maybe in the cities where there is an actual banking system . But in the rural areas staying physically alive is the challenge . There are warlords who will take any property that can be carried off . Money does not work in lawless places unless you have the firepower to protect it . What good is cash if your family can be kidnapped and held for ransom ?

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    13 years ago

Iran and NK don't send us aid.

Hardball power politics is practiced with carrot and stick. Where is the stick in the equation for these countries who receive annual benefit?

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

Correct me if I'm wrong here but isn't the reason the US is giving money to Egypt, is that it goes back to the Camp David Accords where the US, under Carter, pays Egypt NOT to act as a belligerent or an aggressor towards Israel..meaning, if you don't attack them (Israel), we will pay you "X" millions of dollars per year....or something like that?

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

The deal wasn't that frank, but basically that was it. And the deal has held for thirty years.

It is probably important that a large part of the aid goes to Egypt's military, which therefore does not want war with Israel... and which, by the same occasion, has the firepower to "influence" the general political situation.

Yup.

Israelis a U.S. ally-- in fact one of the more reliable ones. And Egypt under Mubarak was considered a U.S. ally-- and Egypt sort of still is...maybe. Naturally it would be counter to U.S. interests to have allies fighting each other.

The Egyptian army has occasionally committed atrocities. But what's the alternative? If not for the army, the Musli Brother might still be in power. And I beieve a large number of Egyptian would like to abrogate the Treaty with Israel and attack Israel-- if not for the army, tat probably would've happened again.

IMO we should definitely continue aid to Egypt.

Though not the main reasons, it has other benefits as well-- military aid helps the U.S. economy, and both the stockholders as well as the (unionized) workers at defense plants benefit! And, interestingly, Israel is cooperating with Egypt in their efforts to keep the terror group Hamas in check...

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

APax, I think there's a lot to be said in speculation towards your view.

Conditions of the Peace Treaty from Wiki as a refresher:

" The peace treaty between Egypt and Israel was signed sixteen months after Egyptian President Anwar El Sadat's visit to Israel in 1977 after intense negotiation. The main features of the treaty were mutual recognition, cessation of the state of war that had existed since the 1948 ArabIsraeli War , normalization of relations and the complete withdrawal by Israel of its armed forces and civilians from the Sinai Peninsula which Israel had captured during the Six-Day War in 1967. Egypt agreed to leave the area demilitarized. The agreement also provided for the free passage of Israeli ships through the Suez Canal , and recognition of the Strait of Tiran and the Gulf of Aqaba as international waterways.

The agreement notably made Egypt the first Arab state to officially recognize Israel. [ 1 ]

Compliance

Normalization

The normalization of relations between Israel and Egypt went into effect in January 1980. Ambassadors were exchanged in February. The boycott laws were repealed by Egypt's parliament the same month, and some trade began to develop, albeit less than Israel had hoped for. In March 1980 regular airline flights were inaugurated. Egypt also began supplying Israel with crude oil. [ 2

___

So, are you suggesting that we were essentially bribing paying Egypt to honor their end of the deal ? Was paying them a condition of the Treaty?

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

Bob,

I'm sorry that I missed your comment!

I like your thoughts on "right and wrong" - I see what you mean: Not the right people for peace, equal treatment and justice; but our leadership could find 'reasons' (and uses) for their leadership to make things 'right' elsewhere...as I interpret.

Yes, it would seem impossible to guarantee where funds get allocated in foreign aid...and I don't know if we even try. Although, it was speculated the banks do. I recall a report on aid to Yemen. A million dollar aid package was given to Farmers, that instead of growing crops for their people, they were growing drug crops for the drug cartels. If true, I guess the leadership of their country would be considered the 'right' people for some. Grin.gif

I agree that the Hierarchy running the country would seem to have the same objectives here or there.

Last year, I calculated that America had spent in Afghanistan, the equivalent of more than thirty thousand dollars per inhabitant. I'm pretty sure that we could have purchased all of their hearts and minds for a great deal less...

Interesting thought. I wonder how much they actually received. It's too bad that there isn't some integrity behind it all, even with charity in our nation. There should be a way to bypass the government and donate directly to where it 'should' go - but then that would mean having to bypass our own Government, wouldn't it. No win?

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

And I beieve a large number of Egyptian would like to abrogate the Treaty with Israel and attack Israel...

In a country of eighty million, a "large number" may yet be a very small minority.

Good point.

And of course its impossible to know the percent with that opinion.

However, from everything I've read from a variety of sources, as well as some of the conversations I've had with Egyptians while in Egypt (admittedly a relatively small number) there is a widespread hatred of Israel, and a surprisingly high number of Egyptians who would actually like to see another war with Israel.

I hope that the vociferous "death to the Jews" extremist warmongers are just that. The massive popular turnout in favor of the army's overthrow of Morsi, is to me a very hopeful sign.

I think its a hopeful sign re: moves toward democracy in Egypt.

But a lot of people didn't want the Morsi out because they were opposed to an Islamist gov't. Not because they favoured peaceful relations with Israel. Rather. a major factor was the increasing economic deterioration under Morsi, which had a terrible impact on many Egyptians.

And also two oter factors: increasing fear of terrorism (mainly from Hamas), as well as Morsi's seizing increasing pwoer.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

APax, I think there's a lot to be said in speculation towards your view.

Actually I thinks its more than just her view. I think most people who are well informed on the matter (and who are also being honest) would agree with her: U.S. aid to Egypt is basically a bribe to "play nice".

Sounds negative? Maybe, but given the current realities, I think its a good move to continue this aid bribe.

Conditions of the Peace Treaty from Wiki as a refresher:

" The peace treaty between Egypt and Israel was signed sixteen months after Egyptian President Anwar El Sadat's visit to Israel in 1977 after intense negotiation. The main features of the treaty were mutual recognition, cessation of the state of war that had existed since the 1948 ArabIsraeli War , normalization of relations and the complete withdrawal by Israel of its armed forces and civilians from the Sinai Peninsula which Israel had captured during the Six-Day War in 1967. Egypt agreed to leave the area demilitarized. The agreement also provided for the free passage of Israeli ships through the Suez Canal , and recognition of the Strait of Tiran and the Gulf of Aqaba as international waterways.

The agreement notably made Egypt the first Arab state to officially recognize Israel. [ 1 ]

An important addition to the above: as a result of that war, Israel gained possession of the Egyptian Sinai. A huge area (I believe it was > 2X as large as the entire country of Israel! It borders the Red Sea which is a popular tourist destination-- especially for diving. Oil had just been discovered there. Obviously Egypt wanted it back.

In giving it back, Israel had everything to lose-- and nothing to gain (except for peace and an end to Egyptian belligerency). Seemed like a deal would benefit the Egyptians more than Israel.

The Egyptians knew this, and refused to make peace with Israel- - even if it would have meant getting the area back. They tried to get the USSR (at that time Egypt was allied with the Communist bloc) to pressure Israel to hand it over, without getting anything (i.e. peace) in return.

This might have worked, but at the time the USSR had other major problems which required its attention.

The article seems to imply that it was negotiations that created peace. But there was no way Egypt would've made peace with Israel-- they only did it after it became clear that not only couldn't they retake the Sinai by force, but that the USSR couldn't help them. So, reluctantly, they began to realize that the only way to get the Sinai back was to make peace with the hated ""Zionists"! (To this day, of the 22 or so Arab countries, only two have agreed to recognize Israel. A few are still technically at war with Israel...and have been since 1948!)

Compliance

Normalization

The normalization of relations between Israel and Egypt went into effect in January 1980. Ambassadors were exchanged in February. The boycott laws were repealed by Egypt's parliament the same month, and some trade began to develop, albeit less than Israel had hoped for. In March 1980 regular airline flights were inaugurated. Egypt also began supplying Israel with crude oil. [ 2

___

So, are you suggesting that we were essentially bribing paying Egypt to honor their end of the deal ? Was paying them a condition of the Treaty?

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    13 years ago

This is SO important to understand.

Nearly all the "aid" we give is a payment towards stability. Figuring where the payoff, pays-off, and where to cut losses, is the tricky part.

 
 
 
Kim Lyvang2
Freshman Silent
link   Kim Lyvang2    13 years ago

Isn't it about time that the US takes care of its own and not other countries?

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

This is SO important to understand.

Nearly all the "aid" we give is a payment towards stability. Figuring where they payoff, paysoff, and where to cut losses, is the tricky part.

I think there re people who feel we should cut id to any country that isn't 100% democratic (in their opinion). Well-- maybe 99%--even 97% democratic might be OK.All well and good-- in theory.

But usually there are many other factors at play.So then it becomes a judgement call-- a bit more in depth thinking and analysis needs to be made in many cases.

I am quite aware of some of the abuses recently carries out by their army. But there are many factors. (if US/EU pressure could get their army to stop that sort of thing BTW (this may already be happening) great. But all things considered, IMO, we should continue aid to Egypt.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

Krishna, Thank you for the additional info.

Also from the same Wiki source are these statements:

" The Deputy chief of Egypt's largest party, the Muslim Brotherhood, said that they would not recognize Israel's right to exist, the treaty is non-binding, and would be put to a referendum. [ 23 ] The Egyptian president, Mohammed Morsi , vowed to respect Egypt-Israel peace treaty. [ 24 ]" "

1) If the MB openly admit they have no obligation in their minds to honor the treaty; they see Israel as non-existent, then why does it make any sense to keep paying them? Aren't they going to do whatever they want with or without US aid ?

2) Sounds like Morsi was a better deal.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

Figuring where they payoff, paysoff, and where to cut losses, is the tricky part.

It surely seems so.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

1) If the MB openly admit they have no obligation in their minds to honor the treaty; they see Israel as non-existent, then why does it make any sense to keep paying them? Aren't they going to do whatever they want with or without US aid ?

That is a perfect example of the effectiveness of US aid to Egypt!

The MB expressed their true feels (important--realize Morsi was the MB candidate). So why did Morsi express a view seemingly at odds with the MB (of which he is a member?).

Morsi knew if he wanted to keep US aid flowing, he had best tone it down a bit.(Interestingly, a lot of observers were surprised at first at how "moderate" Morsi had become (at least in his policies towards Israel). When a member of the MB (Morsi) was elected, at first many Israelis were somewhat upset. But they later realized that (due to the influence of the US!) just as it was under Mubarak, Morsi actually represented no threat to Israel.

Due to US influence (due to our aid bribes to Egypt), as to Israel, its "business as usual"-- which means no Egyptian/Israeli war. In fact for many years now the Egyptian-Israeli border has been relatively quiet-- certainly much more peaceful than what's going on with Syria, Iraq, Yemen, Bahrain, Libya, within Egypt, and within many other Arab countries..

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

Isn't it about time that the US takes care of its own and not other countries?

Aiding our allies is taking care of U.S. interests. (For starters-- the US still imports oil-- and some of oulr friends are much more dependent on Arab oil.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

But one thing for sure is when we do support others with our aid we should do with conditions, not because we just want to be good samaritans.

The track record of the U.S. foreign policies over the years has been horrendous. We have supported so many horrible dictators-- and have also occasionally supported the overthrow of a fairly democratic gov't by people who installed a dictator.

Although it in no way justifies it, often the policies of other major powers has been pretty bad as well

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

Maybe the MB are all talk when it comes to not honoring the Treaty as a scare tactic.

Another war would certainly not be my first choice, yet, realizing another country is essentially holding us hostage for funding, feels really creepy - doesn't it?

Looking at what is entailed in the Treaty, I can see what Israel would lose. I find myself wondering if we could reverse the situation, put ourselves in the driver's seat, and stop the aid. If war is imminent at some point -- between Israel and the US, shouldn't we be able to establish that bullying won't be tolerated ?

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

Another war would certainly not be my first choice,

Perhaps war would be your second choice?

yet, realizing another country is essentially holding us hostage for funding, feels really creepy - doesn't it?

Yes and no. This sort of thing has gone on for centuries (bribing other countries to obtain their friendship). And they don't "have us over a barrel" (as they would if we were bribing them not to attack us-- now that would be real blackmail). We are not being held hostage-- we could stop the aid. (Then, in all probability, Egypt would once again join the Russian sphere of influence.

There are several countries in the world we give aid to so they remain pro-American. And of course other powers, for example the Chinese and the Russians do the same thing. (Why do you think Russia is giving Syria's Assad so much aid-- which allows him to keep the rebels at bay?)

Looking at what is entailed in the Treaty, I can see what Israel would lose.

Actually Israel lost most of what they could loose when they signed the peace treaty with Egypt-- oil wells, a lucrative tourist area, etc. Now the main thing they could lose is peace with Egypt.

But with the Brotherhood out of power, and ever increasing economic woes, they are in no shape to attack Israel. And-- due to recent attacks on Egypt by Hamas from Gaza-- both countries now have a common interest in keeping the Egyptian Sinai free of terrorists.

I find myself wondering if we could reverse the situation, put ourselves in the driver's seat, and stop the aid.

We could-- but why do something self-destructive like that? Especially since is on the verge of developing nuclear weapons (which Obama adamantly opposes), why would we want to weaken Israel-- the major counter-weight to Iran? And a powerful (and stabile) Egypt is also in our interests-- for several reasons).

P>S: In addition to other ways giving aid to Egypt helps the U.S., giving all that aid to Egypt helps our economy. If it stopped, some factories would shut down-- or at least cut the hours/numbers of people employed there. Why would you want to increase unempolyment?

If war is imminent at some point -- between Israel and the US, shouldn't we be able to establish that bullying won't be tolerated ?

Why on earth would you think war between the US and Israel would happen? They are one of our best allies-- and we have common interests in the area.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

Isn't it about time that the US takes care of its own and not other countries?

Why would you want to increase U.S. unempolyment?

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

Krishna,

Here is what typed,

If war is imminent at some point -- between Israel and the US, shouldn't we be able to establish that bullying won't be tolerated ?

"If war is imminent at some point" = meaning with Egypt.

"between Israel and the Us" = meaning working together (the -- was to indicate a new thought)

"shouldn't we be able to establish that bullying won't be tolerated ? = "we" meaning the US and Israel together. Smile.gif

* * *

I would have no reason to think the US would be against Israel.

* * *

You did an excellent job of laying out all the good reasons why we should continue funding Egypt. You have helped move me from undecided to decided! Thank you!

I think the biggest point you made that caused me to take a position was the competition aspect. While I knew Russia funded Syria, I had not thought about the other Super Powers funding various other countries hoping for favors.

Nice discussion, and now it's pretty late here. Nite!

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

Here is what typed,

If war is imminent at some point -- between Israel and the US, shouldn't we be able to establish that bullying won't be tolerated ?

"If war is imminent at some point" = meaning with Egypt.

"between Israel and the Us" = meaning working together (the -- was to indicate a new thought)

"shouldn't we be able to establish that bullying won't be tolerated ? = "we" meaning the US and Israel together.

Whoops-- I read it too quickly! Sorry about that Smile.gif )

I think I missed the punctuation-- and punctuation can change the entire meaning of a sentence:

1592402038.jpg

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

Good insight, Bob. It's something I've sensed from the little exposure I've had with their culture, and this is the first I've read anyone to comment on it.

Their culture promotes dramatic language -- the more over the top, the better!

This might seem like a silly analogy -- but you know how they say we can scare an animal that's larger and more powerful than us just by acting scarier or tougher ? I sense the Arabs try to do that with their language. I also attribute some of their esoteric speech as part of that - intentionally making language difficult to understand - keeping others in the dark, never knowing for sure what their plans are...lol

(I'm tempted to draw a parallel with some folks in America... but I'd be getting off-topic...Grin.gif )

LOL ... That's perfect!

Occidentals tend to value nuance in their conversation -- diametrically opposite!

That's interesting, isn't it?! No wonder we can't communicate with them! lol

___

Off-topic, but I'm slowly, sort of, understanding the convoluted aspect of how their ethnicity, different languages, different customs and different religions or sects - are all part of a *singular* label..i.e., Arab, Muslim, Hebrew, Seminite? (never understood that word).

I'm not sure if I'm making my point clear. I don't usually think of a label applying to a whole bunch of things---do you know what I mean? For example---If I speak English---that doesn't have to imply my race, religion, culture (way of life)--or anything more than the fact that I *speak* the English language.

I think what I'm trying to say is what makes the middle east so difficult for me to understand. Plus, I don't know the history of all of those different peoples such as the Assyrians and other terms; although, I have read some, but it's too involved for me without having the background.

This brief statement by someone did help me a bit in understanding that not all Arabs are Muslim (Krishna might have commented on that once before as well). ...

Please excuse my off-topic.

 
 

Who is online





113 visitors