╌>

How the liberals ruined Detroit.

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  dean-moriarty  •  13 years ago  •  35 comments

How the liberals ruined Detroit.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   seeder  Dean Moriarty    13 years ago
 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

Urban "reblewal" ?

 
 
 
Chucky Stuart
Freshman Silent
link   Chucky Stuart    13 years ago

Yes, I know liberals and conservatives exist for the sole purpose of blaming each other for all of ourproblems, but the reason for Detroit's failure is obvious, and remarkably non-ideological; you cannot maintain an infrastructure built for 1.8 million people with a tax base of 700,000 no matter what your politics.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

the reason for Detroit's failure is obvious, and remarkably non-ideological

You do know that your "reason" is what followed the failure , not what caused the failure , right ?

 
 
 
One Miscreant
Professor Silent
link   One Miscreant    13 years ago

30.gif Increditble liberal discussion Mr. Moriarity! 30.gif

Jack Kerouac introduced the phrase "Beat Generation" in 1948 to characterize a perceived underground, anti-conformist youth movement in New York.

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   seeder  Dean Moriarty    13 years ago

Kerouac was a conservative hated being called a liberal and was a friend of Buckleys.

"Despite the 'beatnik' stereotype, Kerouac was a political conservative, especially when under the influence of his Catholic mother. As the beatniks of the 1950's began to yield their spotlight to the hippies of the 1960's, Jack took pleasure in standing against everything the hippies stood for. He supported the Vietnam War and became friendly with William F. Buckley."

 
 
 
One Miscreant
Professor Silent
link   One Miscreant    13 years ago

You knew Kerouac?

hated being called a liberal

Yet he basked in the glow of a generation of liberal adulations only to sell books I suppose. Like Ginsberg and Borroughs?

 
 
 
One Miscreant
Professor Silent
link   One Miscreant    13 years ago

*yawn*

The two republican mayors before 1962 were connected to Detroits financial "problems" before 1933.

*pppffffttt* (spd)

Frye? ... Frye? ...Frye?

It ain't about republican or democrats when they both are the cornestone ofa governmentinstitution sething in corruption. If they want to do what is right, help the people of Detroit quit bending to corrupt business masters.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

Well that video isn't completely true............ I'd say it's only 99% true. The 1% voted with their feet. Actually about 50% of them voted with their feet. The auto companies we bailed out voted with their feet also.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

At first I thought I was watching a comedy. Well, perhaps it isa tragic comedy. The tragedy here is that someone is going to take this garbage seriously.

  • First off, this report is so blatantly biased and clich ridden that it really does not merit any intellectual consideration. Im not saying liberals are not to blame. What I am saying is that this video takes Occam's razor to an all new stupefying low. It is pap for the simple minded. Its basically a union bashing short they show at tea party meetings
  • Background scenery This crafty piece of ideological propaganda starts and ends with showing nothing but run down, half demolished homes, attempting to give the dull minded viewer the idea that this was all somehow indicative to all of Detroit and was the result of liberal policy.
  • Teachers unions Youll hear the same old, tired conservative talking points implying that the teachers union is at fault for Detroits educational problems. No facts, just rehearsed babble.
  • Unproven statements A good propaganda piece starts with the assumption that whatever they say is true so there is no need for them to back it up with sourceable facts or you to question it.
  • Green cars This is a great slight of hand trick. By telling you green cars failed, they imply that such technology is unneeded nor desired. Never said is that the economic and manufacturing logistics behind energy efficient and alternative fuel cars is so new, the start-up costs will be higher. In the dumbed down world of the poorly educated, these things never cross their minds, if youll excuse the pun.
  • Distortions - This video from start to finish, is the quintessential definition of distortion.
  • Auto Union - Like I said, this is partly a union bashing piece and while Ill admit the UAW is not blameless, for video completely ignored the auto manufacturers poor management other than to say it might have, has the fetid ring to it.
  • Urban Farms This I will say was a bad idea from the get go. The #1 problem with urban gardens? Theft.

**********************


My advice, avoid PJTV for anything. They make Fox news sound like actual journalists.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

So ... that stuff about LBJ and the model cities program was false ?
And teacher's unions seem to be a problem no matter what city they are in . They are opposed to a merit system of any kind . Call it tired but it is near impossible to bust the influence of teacher's unions .

From my POV the Detroit automakers got arrogant . They made it pretty much inevitable they would lose market share to countries like Japan . Was it the unions or management that was at fault ? I suspect both . But it wouldn't surprise me if the unions pressured management . They did establish "job banks" where union members who were displaced were paid for doing nothing . That only happens when a lot of pressure is applied .

The connection between union contributions and the Dems is well established . The bailout of GM did not happen in a vacuum . After all someone [the taxpayers ] have to make good on all of those pensions for UAW workers .

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

Question? "Raising my hand)

Where did the money go when we bailed out GM?

Sorry..... too late..... I found the answer.

The Story No One Tells About One of America's Biggest Bankruptcies

The GM situation is a microcosm of what's gone wrong in our country.
In the June issue of my Investment Advisory , I argued that the bankruptcy process resolved none of GM's core problems. The process was subverted by the political establishment, which sought to protect one class of citizen at the expense of the regional economy, GM's bondholders, and its customers.
If we can't apply the rule of law and sound economics to fixing one of the world's most important manufacturing concerns... it doesn't bode well for anyone else being afforded these privileges, either.
That's why it's so important for you to understand what happened.
Most people simply don't realize that the bailout of GM wasn't a bailout of the company. It wasn't a bailout of its shareholders, who lost everything... or its bondholders, who lost almost everything. Where did the money go? To the union. The United Auto Workers (UAW) ended up with all the money.
There's more: Read the whole article
Just a sample....
It could have received a mixture of cash and equity in the new GM just like any other unsecured creditor. But there wasn't really a bankruptcy court. Instead, there was Steve Rattner "the Rat," as we call him the crooked Democratic political operative under investigation for bribing New York State pension officials. Obama made him the "car czar."
His job wasn't to fix GM. It was to deliver billions to the union and, thus, deliver Michigan for Obama in the next election.
There's more....Read the whole article. I feel sorry for the people for putting their faith in the leaders of their city and our country. Just a bunch of crooks.
The Whole Article:
...
I never cared for Bush, but it is a shame he couldn't take full responsibility for this.
.
 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

1) So ... that stuff about LBJ and the model cities program was false ?

2) And teacher's unions seem to be a problem no matter what city they are in. They are opposed to a merit system of any kind . Call it tired but it is near impossible to bust the influence of teacher's unions .

3) From my POV the Detroit automakers got arrogant . They made it pretty much inevitable they would lose market share to countries like Japan . Was it the unions or management that was at fault ? I suspect both . But it wouldn't surprise me if the unions pressured management . They did establish "job banks" where union members who were displaced were paid for doing nothing . That only happens when a lot of pressure is applied .

4) The connection between union contributions and the Dems is well established . The bailout of GM did not happen in a vacuum . After all someone [the taxpayers ] have to make good on all of those pensions for UAW workers.

*****************

1) Misrepresented is the key word here. Generally, it failed though. However, heres the kicker.those homes that were shown in the video? That my friend was the result of the Republicans once Johnson left office. Under Nixon, the priorities were shifted to bricks and motor: aka; building houses.

2) This right wing obsession with teachers unions is a massive canard. If the merit system of pay is your only objection, then you are under informed about educational problems. I had on-going fights with WEAC (Wisconsin Education Association Council) or the Wisconsin teachers union, but never over pay. Those teachers that can maintain the minimum standards until they retire deserve every cent they earnand then some.

3) The UAW and the automakers were in bed together (a symbiotic relationship) but they were also mortal enemies. The automakers had absolutely no incentive, especially from the government, in producing energy efficient clean or green cars. Behind that, you can thank the US oil cartels.

4) Yes, the Unions over all contributed heavy into Democratic coffers but that was more than offset by the heavy contributions from the corporations, especially those who want to make all public services, for-profit ventures.

I am against bailouts, period. Not to the automakers and certainly not to the banks and financial institutions.

To a certain extent, Detroit became what is now, one giant slum, because of the negligence, criminality and lack of foresight by their elected officials which were/are predominantly Democrats. The laughable PJTV report just barely touched on that, choosing instead to make this an irrational spew for conservative ideologues against unions.

Far from being educational and informative, this video should have been billed as comedic satire.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

Let's cut thru the crap here.

Detroit was like California's gold rush for the city earlier in the last century.

Like the gold rush in California the gold became scarce.

The crooked politicians, unions and auto companies took the money and ran, leaving behind a bunch of suckers who put their faith in all three of these entities.

Obama bailed out the unions, leaving the investors and stock holders empty-handed in order to get elected. The city was the least important in all these decisions.

The people have to take some of the blame as well for taking advantage of the opportunities without considering the risks involved.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

2] Those teachers that can maintain the minimum standards until they retire deserve every cent they earnand then some.

Maintain minimum standards ... is that what you want for public education ? How about promoting excellence ? Detroit has been a complete failure in that regard .

3] The automakers had absolutely no incentive, especially from the government, in producing energy efficient clean or green cars. Behind that, you can thank the US oil cartels.

I don't see how the oil cartels could accomplish that . Automakers should have had a desire to keep their jobs .But instead they produced clunkers which lacked both fuel economy and longevity . The US public stopped buying and the foreign market continued to ignore GM .

4] To a certain extent, Detroit became what is now, one giant slum, because of the negligence, criminality and lack of foresight by their elected officials which were/are predominantly Democrats. The laughable PJTV report just barely touched on that, choosing instead to make this an irrational spew for conservative ideologues against unions.

If I'm not mistaken that was 1 of the 1st issues brought up ... that Dems were responsible since 1962 .

BTW , although the bailout was a bad idea , the error has been compounded by leaving the ownership in private hands . Let the UAW take over ownership . Then when they run it into the ground again they will earn their own failure all by themselves .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

Very interesting article . I think this makes the case for honestly transferring ownership out of private hands & into UAW hands . Let the union fail on its own instead of having management to blame . Either that or they will be forced to actually cut costs to succeed .

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   seeder  Dean Moriarty    13 years ago

If we all could be as smart as those that reelected Kwame the hip hop mayor.Tongue.gif

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

Well it was Bush for the longest kind of time. Now I guess now they're stuck on the videos. LOL

 
 
 
jack c hill
Freshman Silent
link   jack c hill    13 years ago

76.gif If only the conservative were in charge.24.gif Its a proven fact when you lower peoples wages the economy skyrockets.35.gif Trickle down works35.gif

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

I read an entirely different story here General Motors Chapter 11 reorganization that paints an almost opposite picture that Mr. " stansberryresearch " presented. Too bad he didn't mention that the UAW is a " Major Shareholder " in GM and as such, had a legal right by GM's own corporate rules, for payment.

Furthermore, the UAW has a vested interest in keeping GM alive and competitive.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

I got to minute 2:52 of that video, and I couldn't listen to one more second more of the bullshit.

I think with far too much logic than to even be able to breath in that asinine bubble where the Right Wingnuts live their daily lives.

Outside the bubble;

Note - Almost every city in America is predominantly Democrat and under a Democratic Administration.

Note - Detroit used to be the world leader in Auto manufacturing.

Note - Many Americans started buying foreign cars. Because a) they were cheaper, and b) they were better.

Note - The Detroit auto manufacturers dropped the ball not the politicians.

Note - This article is one big pile of Right Wing propaganda bullshit.

Note - I'm done. Gonna go find something productive to comment on.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

Is there any doubt in anyone's mind that both those guys are republicans?

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

perceived?

Did does anyone still that it didn't exist-- that that was only a false perception?

That there was no anti-conformist youth movement in that era-- it was only (falsely) perceived to have existed?

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

I never thought I'd live to see the day the most powerful city in the country at one time would eventually end up looking like Beirut or Somalia, in my lifetime.

Well, if you lived in ancientt Greece or Rome you would have seen it-- probably a lot of other great cities as well, great cities (and even entire great empire) rise ...and fall..over time.

But Detroit is just one, I wonder if we will this happen to other places in the near future? (probably none as bad as Detroit-- but then, a few decades ago no ne believed this could happen to Detroit).

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

This video from start to finish, is the quintessential definition of distortion.

True. We should probably avoid such biased sites in the future. Stick to 100% honest sites like Press TV . A l-Jazeer a. Russia Today . R ens e, A merican Free Press , Ve terans Tod ay. D avid Duk e. Chossudovsky 's " Global Research , Stormfront.

You probably are unaware of these sites, but check them out. (A good starting point would be their material about the truth behind 911-- a topic upon which they all seem to be in agreement! Smile.gif ).

And for something completely different:

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

Before and after to make it simple without all the jargon..... If you look at the information for the old GM and then the new GM you will see who the owners were and now are. Also, in fact the stock needs to double for the American people to break even. The unions didn't own anything before but now they do. The shareholders did have ownership, but now they don't. The whole thing bailed the unions out for one thing and left the shareholder empty handed. Look at "Ownership". During the 2012 election it was claimed by Romney Jeeps were going to be built in China and Obama laughed and made fun of it. I still have the article that proves Obama laughed and the fools believed him. If you still believe him go to factcheck.org and you will see the real facts. Also my information which was told as a lie to the American people about the jeeps came from a local newspaper in Italy, I believe it was. I still have that article. If you want to see it, I will be glad to look it up and post it. We were the fools.

The following table is a comparison (estimates) of the new GM and the old GM
Old GM (before July 10, 2009) New GM (after July 10, 2009)
Brands
5,900 US Dealerships 5,000
Common shareholders, bondholders and secured creditors Ownership The United States Treasury , the Canada Development Investment Corporation , Government of Ontario , Old GM bondholders, and UAW and CAW unions
47 US Plants 34
US $94.7 B Debt [ 16 ] US $17 B
91,000 US employees 68,500
 
 
 
Jimster
Freshman Silent
link   Jimster    13 years ago
So maybe you can explain why the poorest States in the country are Republican strongholds?Debtor states are Red by a very wide margin.
 
 
 
One Miscreant
Professor Silent
link   One Miscreant    13 years ago

Really? Red and Blue, us and them, we now describe theft of the peoples money and trust is republican and democrat centered? They both steal from us all. Only the uber-stupid would think a political party, they choose to align with, would actually reward this loyalty. Donations to a political party is always throwing good money after bad. Donating time or money to the political cause only sends the wrong message, so they will keep screwing everyone they can. There is no politician in our country who is not beholding to the big money. The citizens are an after thought, at best. The ultimate in divide and conquer strategy. Uber-stupid.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

Quite interesting from another article I see up at the time concerning Detroit.

It is not a surprise the federal government wont bail out Detroit. The citys emergency manager told CNN this month he didnt ask Washington for help before filing for bankruptcy.

But it could rub some Detroit residents the wrong way. While city workers are likely to see their pensions slashed, auto industry workers there are still receiving full benefits, thanks to the 2008 bailout of General Motors and Chrysler.

The $80 billion in assistance to those firms came in early 2009 after executives begged for federal help, and since the funds came from the Troubled Asset Relief Program, the package didnt require congressional approval.

...

Keep in mind the final deal was not made until after Bush was long gone.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

Below are the 10 states that are projecting the largest shortfalls for FY 2012.

StateProjected FY 2012 shortfall
(in millions of dollars)
California$21,300
Illinois17,000
New Jersey10,500
Texas10,000
New York8,200
Connecticut3,800
Minnesota3,800
North Carolina3,000
Ohio3,000
Florida (tie)2,500
Oregon (tie)2,500
 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

Jimster!

I didn't know you were here, (apparently they let anyone join this site) where have you been hanging out? I hadn't seen you around the Vine for almost a year, and I've been here since February and this is the first time I've come across you.

I'm glad to see you pointed out the fact that the country's poorest States are GOP strongholds, but I doubt very much you will see these guys make any attempt to explain why that is.

It would be great if you would join the Police Brutality & Misconduct and Public Office Abuse & Misconduct groups, I would really like to have your input. You may also want to join the newly formed N ewsTalkers Community group.

Anyway, it's good to see you, FR sent.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

2) Do you know what minimum standards for teachers are? If you dont know that, you certainly will not understand the concept of excellence in education.

There are many different standards for teachers. For example those of the National Board for Professional Teaching Standards (NBPTS), Council of Chief State School Officers (CCSCO) and their InTASC or "I nterstate Teacher Assessment and Support Consortium " standards, then there are each states standards as setup by their departments of Public Instruction (not to mention the licensing tests) and lastly the School Board and community standards.

Then, almost every single solitary urban school in the US, with a high or disproportionate amount of socio-economically disadvantaged minorities, has exactly the same problems with instructing students, regardless of ideology, union membership (or lack thereof) and political party.

Oh, and don't forget Bush's dreaded "No Child Left Behind" which tied federal assistance to test scores and practically has destroyed the concept of education.

By the way, MPS (Milwaukee Public Schools) is worse than Detroit as far as graduating minority students.

3) There are two issues with this, a) Hydrocarbon emissions and b) ending the dependency on oil, in lieu of renewable energy resources. I'm dealing with the latter, b). Read - Big Oil's Stranglehold on America and Who Killed the Electric Car?

4) That's my point. The article should have stuck with that and presented an intelligent expose on how Democrat/liberal policies failed Detroit instead of making the article an anti-union diatribe full of cheap talking points.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

Bankrupt Cities, Municipalities List and Map

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

You know I don't care for any of those SOB and B's LOL up there in Washington. The way I figure it ......... it's a war against us from them and quite a few of us aren't aware of that.

 
 
 
One Miscreant
Professor Silent
link   One Miscreant    13 years ago

My cynicism comes from having actually believed in our system as a lad. Now we should all know what our forefathers meant by "taxation without representation".

 
 

Who is online





113 visitors