What do you think?
Baby Veronica's biological mother suing government over adoption
By MEG KINNARD Associated Press on Jul 25, 2013, at 12:52 PMUpdated on 7/25/13 at 3:02 PM
COLUMBIA, S.C. The biological mother of a girl at the center of a South Carolina adoption dispute has sued the federal government, saying a law governing the placement of Indian children is unconstitutional.
In her lawsuit, filed Wednesday in federal court in South Carolina, Christy Maldonado asks U.S. Attorney General Eric Holder for a declaration that parts of the Indian Child Welfare Act are illegal. Those measures which include a preference for "other Indian families" over prospective non-Indian adoptive parents should be nixed because the law uses race in determining with whom a child should live and therefore violates equal protection provisions, Maldonado argues.
The act was passed in 1978 to reduce the number of Indian children being removed from their homes by public and private agencies and placed with non-Indian families. The law, Maldonado said in the lawsuit, was enacted with good intentions but ended up "sweeping within it children who do not have, and would not have but for ICWA any connection whatsoever to any Tribe other than biology ... and irrespective of whether their sole custodial birth mothers their only legal parents have even a trace of Indian blood."
Maldonado, who is Hispanic, was unmarried when she got pregnant and worked closely with a non-Indian couple hopeful of adopting her daughter. Her lawsuit includes 10 unnamed plaintiffs who are also unmarried mothers of children of Indian heritage who, because of the federal law, fear the adoptions of their children won't be finalized because the prospective parents are non-Indians, according to court documents.
Maldonado's lawsuit also names the Cherokee Nation as a defendant. Spokeswomen for both the nation and the federal government did not immediately comment on the lawsuit.
A Charleston-area couple has been trying to adopt Maldonado's now-3-year-old daughter since the girl's birth. Veronica lived with Matt and Melanie Capobianco for the first two years of her life but has been with her biological father since 2011, when the South Carolina Supreme Court ruled that, because of the federal law, Dusten Brown should have preference because of his Cherokee heritage.
The Capobiancos appealed that decision to the U.S. Supreme Court, which ruled this year that federal law did not actually require that Veronica who is about 2 percent Cherokee be given back to her Cherokee father.
But the ruling didn't directly award the girl to the Capobiancos, instead leaving it to South Carolina courts to decide where Veronica should end up. Last week, the state Supreme Court ordered a family court to finalize the Capobiancos' adoption of the girl, a decision that court upheld Wednesday.
No formal transition timetable has been set. Brown is also pursuing custody of her in Oklahoma, and his parents also are seeking guardianship through the Cherokee court system. Several American Indian groups have said they plan to file their own federal lawsuit to protect Veronica's interests.
The constitutionality of ICWA was tested in Choctaw Band of Indians v. Holyfield in 1989. The question dealt with Indians being treated separately from "other races". SCOTUS stated that ICWA is based on political status as Indian tribes, not on ethnicity or race.
"should be nixed because the law uses race in determining with whom a child should live and therefore violates equal protection provisions, Maldonado argues."
Maldonado loses.
So am I, Suz.
Me too.
Darn - I hate it when you guys make me get out my law books during the summer
OK, here we go. "Basic Indian law supports the constitutionality of the Indian Child Welfare Act. In several defining opinions, the Supreme Court had already rejected arguments that legislation favoring Indian tribal members violate the Fifth Amendment. In Morton v. Mancari , the Court upheld the Indian Reorganization Act providing an employment preference for qualified Indians in the Bureau of Indian Affairs. The legislation was defined by the court as political, not racial, in nature. If a preference " can be tied rationally to the fulfillment of Congress' unique obligation toward the Indians, such legislative judgments will not be disturbed ." The Court found the purpose of the preference was "to give Indians a greater participation in their own self-government; to further the Government's trust obligation toward the Indian tribes; and to reduce the negative effect of having non-Indians administer matters that affect Indian tribal life."
"The United States Supreme Court has consistently rejected claims that laws that treat Indians as a distinct class violate equal protection" The Court found that the Act was related to the political status of Indian individuals and tribes, not to their cultural or racial characteristics . The Court concluded that under a rational basis test, the Act was designed to provide protection to Indian families and to fulfill of Congress's unique guardianship obligations toward Indians and their plenary powers.
Maldonado loses.
Robert - read my response below - will clarify what you're trying to say - I think.
No, SCOTUS ruled that the Choctaw Nation had priority and was correct in taking over the case. However, the Choctaw Nation reviewed all the information/evidence and decided that it would be in the "best interests of the child(ren)" for the family in Biloxi to adopt them.
You ought to read the case - really interesting turn-a-bout.
Robert, I totally agree, which is further reason why should stay with her father.
I have to say that there have been many cases like this, including non-Indian, where the child is treated as chattel. This is the biggest crime of all.
Suz,
The difference here is that Indians have no choice in allowing guardianship of the government; the government insists upon it. It's written into the Constitution.
So no one can fault Indians for using that guardianship to their advantage when the opportunity arises, when the government has used it to strip land, wealth, children, sovereignty, legal protections, economic progress, sanitary improvements, educational and medical infrastructure advancements, and a host of other things taken for granted by other American citizens, from them. I don't think they can even make improvements on their home or land without the express consent/permission of the federal government.... could be wrong about that, of course.
1stwarrior, am I misquoting here, or is it something like 20+ different rules/laws that Indians have to follow when they step off the rez that are not imposed on other citizens? Did I dream that up or misunderstand something I read?
mimi - there are 26 distinct laws specifically for Native Americans and not for the rest of the U. S. population. 25 Code of Federal Regulations is a compilation of regulations/laws specifically for Native Americans. Native Americans have their own separate Bill of Rights - there are 13 of them - and they are different from the general U. S. population.
My response Robert has been given to you. ICWA was passed in 1978 specifically for Native Americans to allow the tribe to control the adoption process of its children, to keep the Indian community together, to keep the children with their Indian culture, to maintain and develop the Indian population within its traditional cultural boundaries.
Emotional issues are very overbearing at times. Unfortunately, the courts don't care. They are going to follow the laws as written (except for SCOTUS) and personal feelings have no bearing on the law. This link will give you a fuller understanding of what the case is about -
I know, Suz. Sorry if it sounded like I was coming down on you. I was really clarifying for those who were reading the comments and maybe didn't understand what you were saying.
My apologies.
It's the Cherokee Nation. The Choctaw Band of Mississippi Indians was the case previously ruled on by SCOTUS.
Here ya go Robert - just for you - straight from the SCOTUS decision - Please, in the future, research your answer before bringing it on:
"2. Section 1915(a)'s adoption-placement preferences are inapplicable in cases where no alternative party has formally sought to adopt the child. No party other than Adoptive Couple sought to adopt Baby Girl in the Family Court or the South Carolina Supreme court. Biological Father is not covered by 1915(a) because he did not seek to adopt Baby Girl; instead, he argued that his parental rights should not be terminated in the first place. And custody was never sought by Baby Girl's paternal grandparents, other members of the Cherokee Nation, or other Indian families. Reversed and remanded."
Please note also that as of today - this very minute - NO ADOPTION REQUEST HAS BEEN FILED BY ANYONE in this case. Why???? Quite simply, the birth father still has custody and is Baby Veronica's biological child - SCOTUS can't change that. SCOTUS remanded the case back to the SC Supreme Court, but DID NOT CHANGE the South Carolina Family Court's decision, which is still a valid decision.
If you take away the issue of the father being Cherokee, and look at it as if he were any other citizen of the US, he would be granted custody of the child even if she had already been adopted by the SC couple and had lived with them until the age of six or seven. The adoption would be voided and set aside.
We have seen and read of cases in the news before. Mothers giving up newborn babies for adoption, never having any contact with them for years then changing their minds. Fathers never having been told they were even the parent of a child finding out years later and winning custodial rights.
I knew a girl years ago who had a child and named the father on the birth certificate. The father left town and no one knew how to find him. She wanted an aunt and uncle to adopt the child and they prevented from doing so because, as the man was named on the birth certificate, he had to sign documents to relinquish his parental rights before any adoption could take place.
Why is this situation different if this father did not give up all parental rights?
There are other reasons to seal a military record. Sometimes sniper records are sealed, or if someone belonged to a special unit.
The only group I know of who has more sealed records than the military is the Coca Cola Company, from whom the Israeli Mossad could probably take lessons in security.
I wasn't implying he was a sniper. I was giving a "for instance" of different types of military records that are sealed.
Though he was "only" with the National Guard, you must remember that National Guard units have been deployed to Iraq and Afghanistan since the Iraq war due to the low numbers of regular military personnel. So I have no idea what they have been called upon to do while in active duty... but I do know that too many have not come home, and too many have come home maimed and broken in body an spirit.
I don't know if dishonorable discharges are sealed now; that used to not be the case.
Evidently she didn't want the responsibility either. She also wanted her jollies, took no precautions against pregnancy, had no intentions of marriage, or of keeping the baby.
He has Veronica now, is stepping up as a father, taking responsibility, while the mother, who still does not want the responsibility, is doing everything in her power to prevent father and daughter from having a life together.
She is out of it; she needs to stay out of it, as she has let go of all rights attached to the child.
When a case is reversed, that's it; the Supreme Court has invalidated the lower courts decision, and it's over. When it is reversed and remanded, they'll will cite their issue for reversal, and send it back down to the lower court for them to "fix" their own error. It's a Court's way of saying the case is partially correct, but needs some clarification and editing (so to speak).
Two issues were cited - now the lower courts have to determine if they are going to follow ICWA or SCOTUS. If they follow SCOTUS, they'll be back at SCOTUS. If they follow ICWA, they'll be back at SCOTUS.
Yes, it would be difficult to talk about my grandchildren as often as I do had I not been.
I will take time away from the true subject of this article to say that I don't understand your reasoning of this statement. It would be difficult for a child to understand why a birth mother wouldn't love her enough as much as she did the siblings she kept with her.
Upon reaching adulthood, raised with careful and intelligent adoptive parents who could teach her about the basics of economics and single parenting, she could perhaps reconcile with it. In the teens, with all the emotional ups and downs, being the one who wasn't "good enough to keep" will be a thorn in her side until she develops maturity.
Which is what I stated - remanded and reversed means they have to address the two issues. Ordering the adoption process to continue is further violation of the law and not adhering to SCOTUS instructions.
Rescue - the mother did not stay in contact with Veronica.
Rescue, I have understanding and compassion for the situation. I can't believe you are not exhibiting the same.
The little girl has now lived with her father for the last two years (or almost two years) and while it must have been traumatic for her to be removed from the adoptive parents, it will be even more so to be removed from her father now.
She is older and the memories of living with her father and the relatives who have surrounded her are more embedded within her than those of her earlier years as a much younger baby.
I repeat.... children have been removed from parents who have adopted them straight from the delivery room and raised them for several years. Their hysterical and pathetic cries and those of the adoptive parents, character references from friends, clergy, teachers, doctors, neighbors... none of that made a difference when the birth mother or father decided they wanted their blood child back. The judge slammed his gavel and gave away all the love and security that had been lavished on the child without a twitch of his/her eyebrow and went home to a good meal and a sound sleep.
So what the fricking hell makes a difference here except that (a) the SC couple haven't actually adopted Veronica yet; (b) the father is Native American.
He was not dishonorably discharged. His file is closed for now until the trial and mess is over so the "mother's" attorney's can't gain access to information they don't need.
Rescue - I could be wrong, but a lot of your "information" appears to be coming from some very, very unreliable sources. Your bitterness towards Dusten is misplaced. If you want to be bitter at someone, try the court system, starting with SCOTUS 'cause they have botched this one from word go.
He did not refuse financial support - she refused it. He wanted the marriage so he could place her and the child on the military benefits program to reduce the expenses "he offered" to pay that she refused.
Way to much misinformation. Please list some links so I can compare them with the court documents.
Thank you, 1stwarrior. I was wondering where Rescue was getting this information as it was not consistent with what I had been familiar with from other sources.
If Rescue posts links, and after comparing them with court documents, you find the discrepancies to fit Rescue's version of events, please educate us here on this thread.
One thing this case does not need is misinformation - the adoptive parent's attorneys have made dammmm sure of that.
Actually, no Robert - I'm just rehashing discussions held in my Indian Child Welfare Act law class. The whole class has voiced its opinion toward the SCOTUS decision and the actions by the SC Supreme's decision - it is contrary to what SCOTUS directed them to do - but, that is just our opinion, something we all are entitled to.
Thanks, seriously, for voicing yours.
@ Rescue
Sometimes these articles get heated and opinionated. If we lived in the same town and met two or three times a week as friends do chances are we would occasionally squabble over something and make up over coffee or a Coke.
As Raven said, friends don't ditch each other over a difference of opinion. Life would be so, so dull if we all thought alike on every issue.
Hugs,
mimi
OK - the discussion is getting out of line. This thread is for the legal discussion on the constitutionality of the Baby Veronica court case.
I understand your frustrations Rescue, but your "personal" feelings are not going to change the Court's decisions which were made on the supposed basis of ICWA. As a family therapist, you have read and are aware of the requirements of ICWA.
On this discussion, you can't let your heart jump in and dictate your reasoning ability when dissecting a court's decisions, specifically the why's and wherefores.
My opinion is still that you are talking apples and oranges. I don't know where you're getting your information on what Dusten did or didn't do, but I strongly urge you to review this link -
; or this one - (contains seven articles - please read each one).
Oh, say it isn't so
Rescue - as you know, the tribes make up the enrollment criteria. Some require 5/8ths and some just require the individual be related to someone who was on the original rolls at the establishment of the rez, whenever that was. The Cherokee just require relationship, so it really doesn't matter what the blood quantum is - as long as they have the relationship, they are "eligible" for enrollment. It is not an automatic enrollment. The tribal enrollment clerk ascertains the qualifications are met and then the tribal Council has to approve it. Yes, Dusten Brown is a valid member of the Cherokee Nation of Oklahoma, so Veronica is automatically covered by ICWA. BUT - she has to become enrolled by the tribal process- it is not automatic.
First - the adoption process as not complete - she had not been adopted - the state Family Court and the state Supreme court ruled she had to be returned to her biological/birth father, so she was. There was no adoption.
If we had many pages, I could "quote" the regs to you and give some examples of how the law is actually utilized. There are many, many steps that are required to be followed that involve, not just the tribe, but also the state, in establishing and certifying that all the steps have been taken. It depends on the type of case - adoption, placement,foster care and foster home. This court case was based on Section 1912(a) - (g) and 1915. 1912 establishes the criteria for notice of proceedings, appointment of counsel, examination of reports, remedial and rehabilitative programs, foster care placement and parental rights termination orders. Specifically, the court ruled on the 1912(e), which states "No foster care placement may be ordered in such proceeding in the absence of a determination, supported by clear and convincing evidence, including testimony of qualified expert witnesses, that the continued custody of the child by the parent or Indian custodian is likely to result in serious emotional or physical damage to the child."
The court erred - "foster care placement shall mean any action removing an Indian child from its parents or Indian custodian for temporary placement in a foster home or institution or the home of a guardian or conservator where the parent or Indian cannot have the child returned upon demand, but where parental rights have not been terminated." There was no "temporary placement" nor "guardian or conservator" and the "parental rights" had not been terminated.
The continued means the now and future - Alito just stuck with the "now" and didn't look at Veronica's future. Sotomayer ate him a new one in her dissent (beautiful document)
The court didn't even rule on the "adoptive placement" which wasn't even brought before the court which is what the adoptive couple wanted - the have Veronica placed with them through adoption.
Lastly, and I gotta go eat after this - 1915(a) requires - REQUIRES - placement of an Indian child with a member of the child's extended family, other members of the Indian child's tribe or other Indian families. Didn't see the court do that one right either. To not follow that precedence requires the court to prove, beyond a reasonable doubt, that there is "good cause to the contrary" to avoid the preferences. Didn't see the court do that one either.
A side note - of the 24 months you are pushing that Veronica was with the "Adoptive Parents" - no, Dusten was in Iraq for 13 of those months and his family was constantly checking on Veronica, so, no, he was not "ignoring" her - Uncle Sam had greater control.
AND - "In any voluntary proceeding for termination of parental rights to, or adoptive placement of an Indian child, the consent of the parent MAY BE WITHDRAWN FOR ANY REASON AT ANY TIME PRIOR TO THE ENTRY OF A FINAL DEGREE OF TERMINATION OR ADOPTION, AS THE CASE MAY BE, AND THE CHILD SHALL BE RETURNED TO THE PARENT." (caps my emphasis). Dusten is/was well within his rights.
OK, gonna go eat catfish and salad.
Robert - as best as I've been able to determine, there have only been two court decisions - SCOTUS and the SC Supremes. Are you saying there are others since the SCOTUS decision?