╌>

The Bankruptcy of Detroit: What can we do going forward?

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  perrie-halpern  •  13 years ago  •  18 comments

The Bankruptcy of Detroit: What can we do going forward?

By Einstein Insanity

Recently the City of Detroit declared bankruptcy, an event that to many, was really an anti-climactic event that begged the question Why did this not happen 30 years ago?.

Detroit has been the reliable kicking boy of all of those that have an axe to grind, whether it be political, social or racial, and has been such for quite a few generations. In some respects, the genesis of this decline can be seen as originating in 1958, when the Packard Automotive Plant on East Grand Boulevard closed down, to move to the former Briggs body plant, which previously made Packard car bodies (on a sidenote, the individual that came up with the brilliant idea that a factory that previously produced one component of a car could be retrofitted without expansion to produce the entire car deserved to lose his job), however Packards future, was probably previously already written with very short sighted decisions made by the company after the war, where the company was probably the healthiest of all the automakers in the United States, but took that position for granted, and basically let events unfold around it rather than controlling its own destiny.

To a certain extent, this can also be said for the city of Detroit itself, a city that in the 50s boasted the highest standard of living, the highest average income of any city in the United States. Detroit literally was the Mecca of what was the United States, an industrial powerhouse, albeit centered on the automobile industry. This same focus of power essentially also became its achillles heel, the focus of its downturn, leading to the bankruptcy that this once proud city is currently experiencing.

What doesnt seem apparent however, at least based on the commentary from people, and even slightly less so from the media, is that the problems that Detroit faces are not simple, and much of her problems are not even a problem related to Detroit itself, though some would make the statement that an inability to adapt to events that are happening around you is in itself the fault of the ones that refuse to adapt.

In particular, a shift that started in the 1950s, has created a long term structural problem that its unclear that anyone, at that time or today, could have ever thought would become as extreme as it has turned out. Look at today, one can listen to people say that we dont have enough long term investment (infrastructure or economic) and get the response we are the biggest economy the world, everything is fine. This is the exact same mentality that has befallen Detroit. It really doesnt matter what anyone says, your key industry that keeps your city economically alive, dropping from over million jobs to the less than 50,000 jobs today, is going to spell trouble, no matter how well managed the city is. Today, the city of Detroit is home to ONE, yup, that is correct ONE auto plant (Chrysler is the only big 3 company that still retains an assembly plant in Detroit. One might say that the Cadillac assembly plant is also in Detroit; however, most of that plant is actually in Hamtramck, and not in Detroit. It is also a plant that produces a limited number of vehicles, topping out at about 25,000 vehicles per year, which is infinitesimal in the auto industry, in the boutique category).

What does this mean for Detroit?

Well it means that while the changes in the auto industry, while they might be a cause for Detroits problems, the auto industry is not the solution for the City of Detroit. The bailout of the big 3 (yes, even if it was not part of the bailout, the bailout of the other two companies rescued Ford just as much as it rescued GM & Chrysler) had far more of an impact on the nations economy as a whole (and Canada as the big 3 are essentially integrated companies between the two nations) than it ever would have on the City of Detroit. Other than GMs head office, which is pretty much the most prominent building in downtown Detroit, there if very little presence financially for the city. The last remaining auto plant in the city provides about 12 million dollars in annual tax revenues, and most of its employees actually do not reside in Detroit, instead living in the suburbs, in the end, providing almost no economic benefit to the city. (for a city that has a current debt burden of 18 Billion dollars, the loss of 12 million dollars of tax revenue is minimal, and for all intents and purposes, a rounding error).

This is essentially Detroits current problem. There just isnt enough economic activity happening in the city. A past reliance on the auto industry, unthinkable that this cash cow would end, prevented the necessary mindset to make the necessary changes to effect economic renewal. Contrast this with another rust belt city, though smaller, but one that also had a reliance on one industry, Pittsburgh. Through the decline of the steel industry, another very proud industry for a city that was built on it, had the foresight to make changes back in the 50s, which laid the ground work to reinvent the city, and to create a city that is for the most part a healthy metropolis.

One should not the timeline however. Detroit cant change itself overnight, nor should it even try. A community doesnt thrive on short term, and often short sighted decisions. Turning the city around is going to take a very long time, generations even. Its taken generations to get to this point, it will take the same amount of time to reverse this trend and correct the problem.

What is actually ironic about much of the commentary about Detroit though is that the most vociferous about Detroit and mismanagement comes from the libertarian crowd, or the crowd that believes in the power of the free market or the wisdom of the individual, yet Detroits problems are in a very strong sense reliant on that exact same behavior. Detroits past economic power is based on an industry, the auto industry, and its that same industry that has led to Detroits downfall. It is going to take a very large social investment in order to rescue the city, an investment that is going to take decades to bring to fruition, though it remains to be seen if the people of the country have the patience to see it through. Only time will tell

So What Can be Done with Detroit?

One thing that this bankruptcy declaration has done, is provided an opportunity for this discussion, and also potentially provided the shock event that will allow for the changes that need to be made, to be made. For years, the city has essentially been frozen in time, unable to really do anything to change structurally, not enough money to invest in the city to make it more desirable (one only needs to look at the state of the old Packard factory, for the most part, abandoned since it closed in 1958, to see how long this has existed), but also prevented legally and logistically from reducing its structural costs, with the only real option available to them, outsourcing of services, ironically while making the short term fiscal picture slightly better, at the same time, makes the longer term picture much worse. Now is the time for Detroit to make those changes.

All of this is assuming that the nation wants to Save Detroit, because just letting Detroit go is also an option. Allowing the city to turn into an even larger post industrial wasteland is as valid an option as any.

What should NOT be done

The biggest thing that should NOT happen is that cultural assets of the city should NOT be sold off. In addition to basically extracting what little value the city currently has in terms of assets, making the City even more bereft of desirable reasons for people to gravitate to the city, selling off the first Rembrandt in a North American Art Museum wont do much to address the extreme debt burden that the city has. Its unclear how much money selling these assets off would raise, but its pretty clear that just putting everything onto the market in an everything must go manner is only going to reduce that eventual total. At most, I would estimate that the sale of those assets would result in less than a billion dollars. Considering that the total debt of the city is around 18 Billion dollars, it just isnt enough. The sale of these assets does NOTHING to resolve the structural problems that the city faces, it in fact, as noted, makes some of those problems even worse, by reducing even more of the citys attractiveness.

Additionally, much of the assets in question (the classic automobile collection is an example) have FAR more value as a complete collection for the city than they ever would parted off out to individual collectors. Again, it would destroy much of the positive heritage of the city, and bring absolutely nothing back in return.
This is ignoring the legal question of whether or not the city is even able to sell those assets, as most of them were given to the city in trust, and the sale of those assets may result in the proceeds being given not to the debtors of the city, but to the heirs of those that donated those works to the city.

With that comes the question, what should be done about the debt. Well that can be dealt with in two parts, the portion of the debt that is owed to pension funds, and the portion that is owed to outside creditors. These are two very distinct liabilities, and for the most part, have to be handled differently by a bankruptcy court.

The debt to the pension funds will more than likely be lost, but only on paper, and will end up being paid for by the nations taxpayers of the country, specifically because a pension fund is a federally insured entity, and once it becomes insolvent, then the pension guarantor will end up paying for the majority of those costs. In the case of the unfunded health care benefits, those costs will more than likely end up on the bankroll of Medicare (let those that think that this one town in Texas opting out of Medicare and Social Security provides any form of guarantee, THIS is a perfect example of this gone awry, and not just in a small way, but in a VERY big way, a 7 billion dollar way).
More than anything however, this creates the opportunity to open up the question of the integrity of retirement obligations of companies, and public sector entities. Many (well ok, those on the right and libertarian persuasions) state very clearly that all of these debts should just be written off, but ethically, this is a very dubious position. These pension obligations are essentially salary, and if there is one thing that is pretty clear in employment law in the United States, is that employees do not, as a position of employment, take a risk position in the success or failure of the company or entity in question. So if a company goes bankrupt, making employment financial obligations full is at the top of the list when it comes to dissolution. As creditors, they are at the top of the list.

Since a pension is for all intents and purposes, a portion of an employees compensation, morally it must be made full (one of the reasons why there is the pension insurance fund run by the federal government).

This doesnt get into the very real question of why the city and the unions continued to negotiate deferred compensation (which is what the pension and retirement health care benefits are) long past the point that the city knew it was unable to meet those obligations. This matter cant reside on the shoulders of one city administration however, as this is a very long standing problem that both sides of the table has refused to address.

The private debt, while simpler legally, is much more complicated financially.
Legally, any and all the private debt can just be written off. This is the risk one takes when investing in bonds, in particular investing in bonds in a city that has been in financial and economic distress for as long as Detroit has been. People buying Detroit Municipal bonds have been investing in those bonds assuming that some public entity will back up those bonds in the event that Detroit declared bankruptcy.
The other side of that however is that if this were to happen, then it would pretty much mean that for the next generation, any debt that Detroit may want to sell, would have to be purchased by a government entity, such as the State or the Federal Government. Detroit would no longer be able to sell debt on its own.
So even though legally, the city can just technically wipe that debt of its plate, logistically, this will most likely create more problems than it solves, longer term problems. This will impact the city long term, because what the city needs most of all is a massive infusion of cash, which would best be had by a public-private partnership, coordinated by the city, the state and the federal government, and wiping this debt off the books would essentially remove the private portion of this, making it a public bailout that will last several generations.

Another problem which is extremely difficult to gauge is the question of, how much of that private debt is backed by Municipal LDOs Yup, the dragon of derivatives may strike again. The problem here however isnt the LDO, but the impact of the LDOs on creditor negotiations. To understand this, we need to go back to the big 3 bankruptcy and the impact of the LDOs on bondholders.

Because of the way that many of the LDO contracts were structured, the dependence on LDOs was based on a total loss, meaning that a bondholder would not get their insurance amount unless the bond was a total loss (so getting pennies on the dollar would invalidate the LDO/Insurance claim). When the big 3 bankruptcy was ongoing, there was a significant number of bondholders that were actually pushing for a chapter 7 (liquidation) bankruptcy, because that was the only way they could cash in their insurance derivatives (the LDO), and the rest of the bond holders were pushing for a chapter 11. (those that push the Unions got everything, and the bondholders got nothing dont realize how complex the situation actually was, where you had a group of bondholders that WANTED liquidation, because they would get more money out of it). Unfortunately, we dont know how much of Detroits private liabilities are backed by derivatives, so it is extremely difficult to gauge how much of an impact this would have.
Another oft suggested topic includes shrinking the city, would essentially just juggle the books rather than fix anything structurally. In the United States, all land is attached to some form of county or region. While the terminology may change from State to State, the concept is the same.

So if the City of Detroit were to carve off a portion of the city, say the northern portion where many of the companies that once made Detroit an industrial powerhouse were located, but is now for the most part, just an industrial desert today, creating a cost base for the city, but not providing much revenue. What would this do for Detroit. Well it would certainly reduce its costs, but that region would then need to be assigned to a new regional allocation, so a new city of north detroit would need to be created. This would just move the cost from Detroit, to this new city, which in the end doesnt really fix anything. We still have a section of a metropolitan area that still needs to be serviced with police, fire, ambulatory, and school services, and a new city administration that needs to raise the funds to pay for those services. It may make Detroits books look better, but it certainly doesnt fix any of the core problems. This is yet another example of you cant really fix things just by cutting.

So what should be done?

Now, why go through all of this. Well pretty simple, its to say that things are FAR more complex than, the city should live within its means or sell of its art collection or sell off its car collection, or sell off grosse point park to a bunch of libertarians who will create a libertarian paradise (I may say this in jest, but it actually was a suggestion) and all of Detroits problems will be solved. The solutions are FAR more complicated, because the causes are far more complicated, and unless one actually starts addressing those causes, which you cannot do just by wiping it off the books, then you can never actually start creating solutions.

It is a problem that goes beyond the oft repeated live within your means mantra. What is needed to resurrect Detroit will require a MASSIVE infusion of financial capital, along with human capital. One cannot grow by cutting, no matter how many fiscal regressionists make this assertion. Detroit cannot raise this capital, it must come from outside the city itself, it needs to be a national investment project. In a way though, this shouldnt just be a national investment project for Detroit, but for ANY city in the nation that needs to reinvent itself. Detroit may be the poster child, but it is not the only city in the nation that needs it. This isnt even unprecedented, as cities that have had military base closures do receive money from State and Federal governments for redevelopment.

Now for some specifics of what I think should be done:

  1. All debt shall be made whole, the pension liabilities should be funded, and all private debt paid off through a new debenture, at a fixed interest rate, to be paid off over the next 20 years. Existing debt will be cancelled. (This will go to terminate any of the derivatives attached to the private debt)
  2. Any and ALL contracts the city has should be terminated and renegotiated. As part of this renegotiation, because of the future uncertainty of the economic future of the city, no negotiations should allow for future liabilities. This includes the defined benefit pension plan, retirement health care benefits etc should be capped This means that those who are eligible to receive benefits will continue to receive them, however those that are currently working will receive benefits prorated to their employment contribution.
  3. The city of Detroit, the state of Michigan and the Federal government should set up a Public/Private partnership which will section off unused land, parcel it out by region to various entities (whether it be for residential development, industrial development or commercial or a combination thereof). This parceling out would be at no cost to the private entity with the requirement that economic development will commence within a reasonable period of time, otherwise the land reverts back to the public/private partnership trust. The main purpose of this is not to make short term income for the city, but to redevelop an economic and residential base for the city, which will create longer term revenue potential for the city, through economic and commercial activity.
  4. The city should embark on a radical redevelopment of the citys educational system. More than half the citys residents are functionally illiterate, a status that is not only shameful, but is one of the factors that makes Detroit the economic basket case that it is. The future economies require that its workers are better educated, and not from a historical standard, but from todays standard. In order for Detroit to pull out of this, its schools need to become centers of excellence, not just for her citizens, but for the people that the city needs to attract to ensure its future success.
  5. A Capital investment fund should be created, which will provide loans to companies that desire to locate in a Distressed Community. These loans will be at a reduced interest rate, however, they will also have a management from the Trust entity that is issuing these loans (a loan from a bank is not without strings, therefore a loan from a public trust should also not be without strings). The interest rate set would be based on prevailing rates, but would be lower than what one would normally expect as a business loan rate. These loans would ONLY be acceptable for use in Capital investment within the distressed region, in this case Detroit, and would only be available for industrial/commercial purposes that seek to develop the economy of the region (nope, setting up a warehouse in Detroit is not acceptable).

Now, these are just a few ideas, but the one thing that is a given is that turning Detroit around is going to take a LOT of capital, over a long period of time. Turning Detroit around is going to take a strong commitment. It remains to be seen if America and Americans have the patience for this. Long after the headlines have gone away, the problem that is Detroit will remain. Will the current focus on Detroit disappear as the headline value of the Bankruptcy declaration is gone? Will the birth of the next heir to the British Throne take the problems of Detroit out of mind, who knows? But if that does happen, its America that will lose, lose to yet another example of a society that has turned to short term solutions to long term problems. This most of all is what needs to change.

Jonathan Walters


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

Holy mkrl ! Is this a guest submission ? Is he blogging elsewhere ?

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

I miss Einsteinian Insanity (Jonathan) - his articles his commentary and the intellectual dressing downs and scoldings that he can so expertly give me while simultaneously making me laugh and pointing out wrong I am.

Ah the good old days

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

OK , I read this piece . He is talking mostly in generalities here which is OK . But to actually solve the problems specifics must be addressed . IMO the 1st specific would be to examine what Detroit still has going for it .
I am no expert on that but I expect it has access to freight transportation infrastructure . That could be applied to some future endeavors .

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

This will be part of a longer piece for a mag. He asked me to submit it here for him.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

Maybe he'll be back. I miss him, too.

 
 
 
Nigel Dogberry
Freshman Silent
link   Nigel Dogberry    13 years ago

Some good, general ideas are to be found here. This failure of Detroit will take years and years to overcome. This has been approaching for years and it amazing that it just now is fixing to explode in Detroit's face. There is no easy solution.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

I have been following this Petey and indeed the city has billions in assets, some of them priceless. They are trying to solve the issue without having to give those up to auction.

Infrastructure they do have, but one needs a reason to go there in the first place, which at present there doesn't seem to be. But maybe a huge part of the puzzle lies across the Canadian border. Windsor, Ontario used to be a big part of Detroit's economics. Then infrastructure comes into the picture.

 
 
 
Shub Orinuj
Freshman Silent
link   Shub Orinuj    13 years ago

Let it go to waste I say same with Cleveland what is the purpose of holding onto them anyhow other then to boost population growth?

 
 
 
One Miscreant
Professor Silent
link   One Miscreant    13 years ago

It was supposed to take years, had the 'reigning emergency manager' Kevyn Orr actually followed precedent. The Michigan Emergency Manager law is rarely used to go straight to bankruptcy, they are mostly used to avoid it. Deals are made with creditors and that takes time to litigate. Orr took the easy way and dismissed all debt indicating it would be too hard. ( Source )

BTW-this law was repealed by Michigan voters and back-doored into law as 'Public Act 436' , in spite of the obvious objectionof the people of Michigan. Bankruptcy is one of the last things mention in the opening paragraph.

I'm no bankruptcy lawyer, but any resolution should consider the wishes of people of Michigan/Detroit first and foremost.

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    13 years ago

" what is the purpose of holding onto them anyhow other then to boost population growth?"

Democrats need the votes.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

He's just warming up ...

 
 
 
Shub Orinuj
Freshman Silent
link   Shub Orinuj    13 years ago

Both parties can change where they get their votes

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

Bikes in motor city ... how ironic .

 
 
 
One Miscreant
Professor Silent
link   One Miscreant    13 years ago

I used to ride 3 miles each time i went to the Detroit Zoos as a teen

 
 
 
One Miscreant
Professor Silent
link   One Miscreant    13 years ago

Education is never a wasted expense. Children need all the help they can get, when the grownups are so lazy, self-absorbed greedy and uncaring.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

Any and ALL contracts the city has should be terminated and renegotiated.

If Detroit breaks a contract, it would send a message-- loud and clear!

When parties enter into a contract, they are pledging to keep their word-- to uphold their part of the contract.

If Detroit starts breaking contracts, going back on its promises, it would soon becomes obvious that they are not to be trusted-- that their promises (contracts) are worthless.

It shows that when they made the contract (a promise to hold to the provisions of the contract) essentially they lied-- their promise to uphold the provisions of the contract was a lie.

This would show that they are not to be trusted (if they agreed to something and then backed down, wouldn't they possibly do that again? That shows that they can't be trusted-- their word is meaningless. A ( that they would make promises (signing new contracts or "re-negotiating" new ones) in the future that are also lies?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

George W. Bush and .... just might be examples of minds it would have been better to waste...

In that case I'm sure you would be interested in this development

 
 
 
leonahardware
Freshman Silent
link   leonahardware    13 years ago

Robert,

Here's where you can find EI...

 
 

Who is online


CB


113 visitors