The Black Hills Are Not For Sale - Honor Treaties
http://www.reelhouse.org/becker/honortreaties/honortreaties
14 minute video, just dealing with Pine Ridge Lakota Indian Reservation - the poorest land/people in the United States.
But, their status is, unfortunately, the status of many Indian tribes.
Reservations vary drastically in terms of their size, population, proximity to urban centers, and cultural beliefs and practices. Despite such variation, reservations share a similar history and face similar contemporary challenges. At the forefront of these challenges is poverty. In 2010, the poverty rate on reservations was 28.4 percent, compared with 22 percent among all American Indians (on and off reservations), and 15.3 percent among all Americans. In addition to poverty rates, reservations are hindered by low education levels, poor healthcare services, low employment, substandard housing, and deficient economic infrastructure.
The treaty era, from 1784 until 1871, resulted in 376 treaties that were ratified by the U. S. Congress. Numerous other treaties, such as the 93 for the California tribes in 1854, were never ratified by Congress - but the Indians didn't know that for 15 years when they were finally told by the California Governor. In 1854, the California Governor told Congress/the President not to worry about the Indians in California because he was going to kill them all - and almost did. The U. S. never stepped in to assist the tribes.
Per the U. S. Constitution, Article VI, " This Constitution, and the Laws of the United States which shall be made in Pursuance thereof; and all Treaties made, or which shall be made, under the Authority of the United States, shall be the supreme Law of the Land; and the Judges in every State shall be bound thereby, any Thing in the Constitution or Laws of any State to the Contrary notwithstanding. " - note - " shall be the supreme Law of the Land " - hmmmm - that means that no, I repeat, no law shall stand above them. Wonder what happened?
Cute note - the vast majority of the treaties carried the phrase that stated the treaty would be followed by the United States and the Indian tribes for "as long as the grass shall grow, the winds shall blow and the sun shall rise." Sadly, every treaty signed by the Indian tribes was broken by the United States government anywhere from minutes to months after they were signed/ratified by Congress - many even before they were ratified.
To many of us, these actions by the U. S. government have given us absolutely no reason to trust the government in any dealing - and people wonder why we're bitter.
Check this link out also. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reservation_poverty
Thank you for reading and for your honest and CoH responses.
Thank you Ambi for bringing this to our attention.

This thread is designed to bring to your attention an area of human dignity and poverty that doesn't get talked about. My question is - why not?
Why would the U. S. Government feel they had the "right" to break treaties without renegotiation?
We count when they discover valuable minerals on our lands.
Stephi - the use of your job would/will help educate others to understand what has happened so that maybe others, including your students, can help find ways to correct the attitudes that are prevalent towards Native Americans.
Isn't that always the way, 1st? Tell me one time in history anywhere on earth, where that is different?
I promise not to waste that opportunity, 1st Warrior! Thank you for teaching me so much!
It is so disturbing to me, that the original people of this land are treated with such little respect, even now. NA's are the invisible people of the US. Somehow, Indians were forgotten about during the civil rights movement. There needs still are not met. They are this nations throw away people. The secret is in the youth. Teaching them the truth of what happened and is still happening to Indians will light the way. Films like this IS the way to alert this generation so that there will be a people left for generations to come.
Here is a little hope:
Historians agree that both World Wars would have had a different outcome without the participation of the Code Talkers. Is it not ironic that there is no National Holiday to celebrate their saving the Allied Armies and the free world?
There are monuments all over DC to every war hero from the Revolution forward, including one to the modern day soldier called Three Soldiers, but not one monument depicting any of the Code Talkers. And the Three Soldiers are white, black and Hispanic.
The Indians were told the Hispanic soldier represented them, also.
It's difficult to educate other people about the depth of the complexity of Native American life and have them reach an understanding of it; I have no wish to turn this thread into another "us/them" article where whites feel they are being bashed for the sins of the fathers.
1stwarrior, I know you seek to educate, not fight the Indian wars again. I hope you receive full cooperation from the viewers and commenters.
You are teaching us what we need to know so that we can help bring about much-deserved change!!! And I thank you all.
"I have no wish to turn this thread into another "us/them" article where whites feel they are being bashed for the sins of the fathers...." I have not ever felt that way from any of you. You guys welcomed me into your very loving Anishinaabe Group/Family, and I am grateful....so very grateful. You could have turned me away because I am not of Native American heritage. Yet you have done just the opposite! You have brought me into the fold, taught me so much, and empowered me to help make changes within my sphere of influence. For me, that is with my First Graders. The little ones I teach understand poverty and so they take great interest when I share with them the truths of our Native Peoples.
Stephi, I was referring to the way these threads can sometimes get out of hand. Sometimes someone will take a comment out of context and run with it, and sometimes there are commenters who just like heated debates.
Many people think Native Americans just lay around living off government subsidies and they can be strident in their opinions. I am hoping that those who usually go "anti-Indian" on any article about NAs take the time to watch the video and think before they post.
Thank you for being the understanding person you are; it was indeed a gift to our Family when you became part of our community.
What I'd like to see/hear/read is some intelligent and meaningful discussion from the members of NT on why they think the breaking of treaties or taking of Indian lands is an OK action.
Remember to follow the CoH please.
1st.
It is very important to tag your articles. That is how they are found on searches. I have done this one for you.
BTW, 67 views mean that at least 40 people read this article without posting.
I can only speak for myself . I expect the issue of broken treaties etc had to do with the American Indians not being knowledgeable about the workings of the legal system . The same kind of abuses happen daily in the US today to people too poor to hire a competent attorney . The legal system is an adversarial process . That is NOT a nice thing .
Thank you Perrie - don't know why I always miss that little step.
I agree with what you're saying Petey. In fact, SCOTUS established rules for Congress to follow when dealing with the tribes in treaty making. When/if instances regarding treaties make it to courts, the judicial folks are to review the treaties from the same framework that the tribes would - using the same language or understanding of the language, what the actual intent of the treaty was and how the tribes understood what that intent was.
Unfortunately, not many of the laws/rules/regulations passed by Congress actually follows those guidelines - but they are still there.
I didn't know that . Its an interesting idea .
The wishes of the little guy or group are rarely [never ?] respected .
"Get over it" is a hostile, degrading phrase. It is not meant to promote healing but only to further abuse and devalue the person who is hurting. Those who use it are not worth listening to.
To your list, I would venture to add those who are emotionally overwhelmed and either don't know what to say or cannot find words to express what they feel. Quite often, when first confronted with something so horrific, we feel the need to run in self-preservation, then feel ashamed because we could not stand our ground in the face of the psychological onslaught.
When I first watched the video, I wanted to turn away, not because I do not care, but because it slammed my heart so hard I couldn't breathe. I didn't stop the film, but it stopped itself and would not finish. I had to reload to watch the rest. Nuisance in most cases. In this case, it gave me a bit of time to prepare myself for the rest.
The abject poverty is extreme cruelty, yet the little girl picking through the discarded clothing scattered on the ground is learning this is "normal" -- as are all the other children at Pine Ridge Rez. Heartbreaking.
Sorry, I can't add much 1stWarrior. I don't think it is okay that we still have "Reservations" as they should be called and honored as Sovereign Nations. I don't think it's okay for the US Government to break treaties because of resources they want out of greed. I don't think that it is okay for the First People to live in poverty and to be made invisible and forgotten. The First People are still here.
In fact, it's called the Canons of Construction in Indian Law.
Yup, us white people really suck.
The treaties were broken for two specific reasons. First was because of the mineral wealth found, i.e. gold/silver/uranium/oil, on the reservations, so the tribes had to be moved to allow the government to take control. Second was specifically to "make room for the whites". The Oklahoma Homestead Act busted the reservations and opened the territory to the Whites who wanted the land - period. Thousands of Indians were displaced, shoved off their lands and the Feds did nothing to curtail the advancement.
Of the total land base of the tribes in the 1500's, by 1930, there were 100M acres left for the tribes. Today, there are only 54.7M acres for the 274 reservation tribes. In 1898, 1903 and 1906, the Chickasaw tribe lost 12M acres, their government was disbanded and their constitution voided - all three treaty violations of the 1865 Cherokee/Chickasaw/U.S. Treaty.
btw,
The Black Hills has a very compelling energy about it. There is the grandeur of mountainous regions but a really old and cozy feeling to the place. One of my favorites places actually, we love it there.
Grump,
From discussions on other threads and from comments on The Forum, I have come to believe that the problem may be that Whites do not comprehend the full extent of the atrocities that were perpetrated upon Native Americans. The story of the "founding" of America has been glossed over and prettied up so that the depth of the betrayals, the genocide, and the racism directed toward Indians even today is not understood by the average citizen.
Most Americans think that Indians have it made. Live on land that can never be taken away, "draw a check" from the federal government financed by taxpayers, pay no taxes, do whatever they want... wow! what a life, wish I had it that easy!!
The government has shrouded the reality of Native American life in lies and half truths and most of the citizens who "hate" Indians in reality are envious of what they think is a free ride on the working taxpayer's back.
It's too bad there is such a wide chasm of misunderstanding; we all need each other if we are going to survive federal, or even state government. There are many, many white people who, upon hearing one kernel of the truth about NAs, express both horror and interest, and ask for more information.
What a powerful presentation huh?!
:~)
There is a percentage of white people - depending on what state you live in, it can be a large or non-existent.
His whole series is powerful.
I honestly can't figure what might right the wrongs. There are some debts that are truly too great to be able to repay. There are so many things to be taken into consideration, besides the fact that I'm not sure that enough Americans are ready to face the truth.
Education...,yeah. But more than that, at gut-check level, racism is the root of the problem. Even if we had the politicians with the ball's to do what is right, I can foresee that there needs to be a true cultural exchange of honest and circumspect, individual's input, from all sides.
In all honesty, there is no way to right the wrongs, and to even think there is, is a pipe dream. The best that could be hoped for is for an acknowledgement of the gross injustices and horrors that were visited on the First People... especially the children. That would be the first step.
The second would be a deep cleansing of the tainted history that has been whitewashed and fed to the citizens of this country about Native Americans, and then move forward to the truth about how Indians live today... what Reservation life is about, how Tribes are structured and how they REALLY come to get those "government checks" a lot of Americans are so envious of.
Then move forward by restoring land rights that have been taken by turning Reservation land into national forests that Indians can't hunt or log, but which the federal government can "lease" and receive revenue from; return land rights from which Indians can't fish the rivers any more (treaty violations); return to Tribes the right to call themselves "Tribes" along with lands stolen from them by the government when they declassified them (I'm not using the right terminology here.... 1stwarrior can explain it better.)
Don't know how to address the racism issue. There is a mysticism about Native Americans that just about terrify some Whites. Though some Indians are Christians, many hold to their ancient spiritual beliefs, and even the atheists among the crowds are more comfortable with Christians, Jews and even Muslims than they are with Shamans, Spirits and Manitous.
Robert Pirsig lays out a very interesting idea about the American Spirit, and what characterizes it's uniqueness. He makes the case that Americans were, and are, deeply influenced by Native American culture. That as one travels across the US from east to west, one can even witness the transformation from more European to more Native American influences in architecture and art. That things like modern film, reflect the American desire to promote itself as strong, silent, efficient of word and stoic in deed; traits that were picked up from Indians.
Indeed a mysticism, but one that is now also the shared experience of many Americans; there is much Indian blood that is mingled with European. While many Americans may not conscientiously admit it, they are both drawn to their very culture and excited by it's exotic nature. We are indeed a blended people in a lot of ways.
No, it isn't all whites but trying to isolate government from the people as if the people have no control is not productive. If enough people are willing to take action, the government responds. We saw that during the Civil Rights era. It is the racism of whites and the indifference of others (whites, blacks, etc) that allows those in the government to get away with what they do. That's true on every level and every issue.
It doesn't make any difference what color I am. The Indians were treated inhuman and if the white people that did it, it still doesn't make any difference what color I am. I am what I am and I had no control over it.
Atrocities have happened all over the world. Doesn't mean it was good but it has happened by all people. When I was in Taiwan the native people I met there were much like the Indians here. They were forced from their land and treated inhuman.
I hiked up into the mountains in Taiwan and stayed in a hut so to speak with a fire in the middle of the room and a hole in the ceiling. Everything was made out of wood. There were no conveniences. This sink had a hose coming in from up the hill from a stream and continually ran into the sink and out into a trough and on down the hill. The beds were wood benches and a friend of mine had married the girl he'd met. We were just visiting her family.
Her grandmother had a tattoo on her forehead the Japanese had put on it during WWII. The Chinese had taken all the land. These people lived a very simple life far back and up in the mountains.
The video "Ted" was overwhelming to me and very sad to know my forefathers could have had any part in this. I doubt they did as they have never had much power in governmental affairs and were just dirt farmers for as far back as I can research.
History certainly hasn't been taught in school the way it really was and I'm afraid it will not be taught in school in the future the way it really is. We can only hope we all come together as a nation today and right our wrongs the best way we can and understand we can't change history but we can change our present and future.
I've always believe I must look not for happiness but for harmony. That doesn't mean I have to agree with anyone just to make peace.
Many have died and suffered I see from this and the one I read from 1stwarrior about a month ago concerning the slaughter of whole villages in California.
It's hard to accept a person could be so cruel to scalp someone or this government could actually pay a price for that scalp.
I think too, sometimes, that what happens is kind of an extreme, opposite of what you were talking about. Folks that have some Native blood, have been raised in a strictly White culture, and would not admit to it out of pure racism.
One thing is for sure; peoples of whatever persuasion must be involved in the process of healing the relationship, or it will only fester more. Where there is room for learning, there is room for healing.
I'm not sure I understand what you mean by this statement.
At any rate, the article is about the government's lack of integrityin honoring any of the treaties signed with any of the Tribes in all of the history of its dealings with Native Americans.
One of the churches here in town collects coats, shoes, etc. for the Pine River Reservation. I take all of my gently used clothes, shoes, etc. there for donation, and help to collect at work, as well. Their situation is horrible!!!
I can't remember the name of the group that accepts a truckload of stuff from Louisville, but it also collects truckloads from around KY and runs the items up to the reservation. This is one charity that checks out, if you would like to help! I think the charity's name is Feather something... Anyway, the local Lutheran, Presbyterian, and Methodists churches collect the items until they have a semi-truckload, and it's a good thing to do.
Re-member.org
I think their plight is utterly disgraceful, a blot on the US, and a complete and total debacle. I do what I can to help, which isn't much, but better than nothing.
When vacationing in Wyoming, years ago, the owner of the "dude" ranch that we were visiting told my mother and I that he didn't like southerners, because of their attitudes towards blacks. His wife emphatically nodded her head.
While I understand what they meant, and yes, hate it myself, that's not the way it is here at home in Kentucky-- even back then. There are individuals that I feel to be beyond the pale, but as a whole group, everyone gets along. We know little of the Native Americans, as we have few in the state.
Not 5 minutes later, he made the comment that the only good Indian was a dead Indian. How could he not see the hypocrisy of his statements?
I'd say that prejudice is alive and well, pretty much no matter where you go. In one form or another, someone is busy hating someone else. The trouble is, with both groups, (and others), the prejudice is not only government sanctioned, but encouraged.
It makes me very angry and very sad!!!
Robert, obviously, you don't know many Yugoslavians. Perhaps it is time you educated yourself! I have a lovely beaded purse, handmade in Yugoslavia in the 1920s, that contains a handwritten message, carefully block printed in the cryptic alphabet. I have yet to find anyone that can translate it for me! I hope that it wasn't a cry for help!
It is unlike you to profess your ignorance so willingly!Perhaps you can use this as a fine opportunity to learn something from others.
Nor are you, Robert. You're not being nice, helpful, but likely very honest. Sometimes, saying nothing is the best approach of all.
You know this is a sore subject with many of us. Why would you purposefully bait anyone? If the subject annoys you, ignore it.
If you can't say something nice, don't say anything... Have an absolutely wonderful evening!
The sovereignty of the Tribes is nota choice for them to make; it is at the whim of the government. With the stroke of a pen Congress can take it away. It is a tightrope walked without a safety net, as the only one available is whatever treaty was signed... and as is being discussed, not one treaty has ever been honored.
Whenever it is convenient or expedient the government changes or ignores it at their whim.
If I am wrong about this, 1stwarrior, please correct me.
SCOTUS Chief Justice John Marshall, in one of the Marshall Trilogy cases, agreed that the tribes have had sovereignty since before the coming of the Euros and that sovereignty can't be taken away. However, he also said that the tribes are dependent Indian Nations under tutelage to the U. S. and are to be treated as "wards" and should be "protected" against outside aggressors.
In a nut-shell, Congress can and does change the requirements of a treaty anytime they feel like it. But, they can not change the fact that the tribes are sovereign, independentnations and have been long before the Euros got out of their reed boats.
And your statement about Kentucky makes the point - depending on the state, there can be "some" or a "lot" (as in Wyoming).
POW camps would be more appropriate in many cases.
Sadly sixpick, you are correct. It is and has happened in more countries than can be imagined. Read up on the Boar's Wars and what the Brits did to the Indigenous people back in the 17/1800's - the same that they did to the Native Americans. Look at what the French did to the Vietnamese or, believe it or not, what the Japanese did to the Chinese.
Dominant society, no matter what the predominant color is, does not care for the peoples of the lands they take. They are only interested in establishing their life style - one that ALL must adhere to.
There once were 382 Indian reservations - now there are 264 because Congress decided, during the Termination period, over 100 tribes didn't need to be Indian anymore - they were now white and would assimilate.
How disdainful can you get?
And it's that "dependent wards" that make us have to toe the line, right? As dependents, the government doles out the goodies and punishments as they see fit?
And even though proclaimed sovereign, the Tribes cannot enter into any trade agreements or anything of that nature independent of the US government? And they cannot actually the US government from encroaching on their land if the government feels to do so is in the best interests of the rest of the country.... whatever that interest may be?
I mean, a protracted and costly court battle may ensue but in the end, since SCOTUS will probably be the final say, it is usually inevitable that the Indians will probably be the loser?
Pre-zackly
Well stated Mimi!
Well said, Mimi. But in the meantime, the lawsuits will bring the issue before the public and, hopefully, that is a teaching moment - if it is done correctly and with grace.
That's so true. The Christian churches teach people to be afraid of all other systems of belief. Look at their constant harping against Wiccans as devil worshippers, witches, evil, etc. The Christian churches are all about exclusivity and fear of others.
However, those interested in so-called "New Age" beliefs (which is such a silly term because most of "New Age" writings are about ancient beliefs) are very interested in the NA mysticism. It would be a good step for NA speakers and writers to reach out to the New Age community.
One of the beliefs about the NA is that all men are warriors. That's not true in other cultures, and yet they believe it about the NA. That might be part of what terrifies them. That the man they are looking at might be powerful enough to kill them and would given half the chance.
There is also the continuing degradation of NA women, built on the false belief that they were treated as little more than slaves by their men. The fear of the men is probably part of why NA women are targeted sexual violence by whites. Men have always used the rape of women as a way to "punish" the men in a culture they believe is their enemy. It's been used as a war strategy since before the Biblical era. Fortunately, now its been declared as a war crime, but that hasn't stopped armies from raping the women of the conquered countries.
For many whites, it seems like they think the white war against NAs is still current, just like so many whites in the South seem to still be fighting the Civil War. Ironically, these seem to be the same whites that tell NAs to "just get over it."
Great post, Raven Wing. So much information and insight contained within it.
Actually, they can, Robert. That's the law. They are both citizens of the US and citizens of the First Nations. Having a dual citizenship isn't unique to them. There are many from other nations that also have dual citizenships. It isn't a hard concept to understand. If the concept eludes you, however, then do a google search and you'll find a lot of resources that explain it.
That's your perspective, but it isn't the perspective of our laws and the treaties signed into law by many representing our government.
Actually, its not "irreconcilable" at all. Most people do not have a problem understanding more than one aspect of anything. I'm surprised you do. If it makes no sense to you, then you should study it until it does make sense to you.
It is a luxury of whites to be able to say that because their culture is the dominant culture in the US. No other race has that privilege. That's why it is important to them to preserve their culture even as they are forced to live amid the dominant white culture. That's why other ethnicities do the same.
There are many whites who are panicking at the prospect of changing demographics of our nation and are already screaming the white culture will be lost because whites are about to become a minority race. Google "white culture dying" and you'll find a lot of sites discussing those fears, especially white supremacist sites but even sites that are not white supremacist.
Those fears are behind the militia and secessionist movement, the build up of arsenals, the support for the Ted Nugents of the nation, the attempts to stop blacks from voting, the attempts to stop immigration, and the abuse of NAs.
What you are saying to the NAs is: stop protecting your culture. Are you willing to say it to these whites too?
Glad to see they are aware of the need. I wish everyone was.
Loretta - you make entirely too much sense - and I love your horses too.
Speaking of flailing about, you didn't answer my question. It's a simple yes or no. Are you willing to tell whites not to protect their culture now that the white race is about to become a minority race in the US?
You also didn't look up any of the concepts I mentioned. I don't admire willful ignorance. In fact, I don't have much patience with it. If you don't care about your level of knowledge, then no one else should either. That means they should not value your opinion at all.
As to whites panicking, if you haven't noticed it, you haven't been paying attention. Even Lindsey Graham has remarked upon it in regards to the GOP not being able to generate enough angry white guys to stay in power. Almost everything the GOP is doing nowadays is related to white racial panic, including their obsession with forcing women to have more babies. White women who don't want a slew of babies are considered white traitors because the white birth rate is too low, per the white supremacists.
Right-Wing Groups Use Decline of White Birthrates to Stoke Fear of Homosexuality, Feminism and Abortion
Here's a page where they're discussing the low white birth rate.
Why the White race is dying...a personal story
Here's a page with lots of videos discussing this white racial panic.
White race is dying!! Stand up NOW! before its to late!!
WhiteAryan Resistance's position on abortion
There. I've made it easy for you to pay attention and educate yourself.
As to your rant that NAs don't have the right to be a sovereign nation, yawn. No relevance whatsoever. It's their legal right, whether you approve or not.
As to their unhappiness with the US government: sounds like they're the same as everyone else who criticizes the government. You seem to think they do not have the same rights to criticize the rest of us do. That's beyond silly.
If you can spare 16 minutes, this is a good storyabout my people...
Maybe it will give you some insight and context to the history.
I love all three of those images. Thanks for posting them. They give me a lot to think about.
One of the amazing things that I have learned about the culture of my own people is that there were women Warriors who were as fierce in battle as any of the males.
Unless I am mistaken, Crazy Horse had a sister who was every bit as feared on the battlefield as Crazy Horse himself. These types of things are never mentioned in history books or movies and definitely was never talked about among the early cavalry. Wouldn't do to have the early white women know they were capable of anything but having babies and keeping house... unless it were prostitution.
Oh, gosh, thanks. I love it when people love my horses.
All those happy yellow smurfy things for me? Why, thank you, ma'am. Much appreciated.
So ... that was a simple yes or no ? What a surprise . What exactly is "white culture " ? Since US history is composed of wave after wave of immigrants from different "white cultures" arriving at these shores , which ones are THE "white culture" ? Please tell me 'cause I have no idea .
Reading the White Aryan Resistance website does NOT reflect the position of most whites or even of George Zimmerman even though he is now officially the most hated "white" in the US at the moment .
The question is simple. I'm not sure why you're confused. For those whites who are claiming the white culture (however they define it) must be preserved, would you tell them the same thing that the NA are being told by Robert?
Trying to say white culture is not all one culture, therefore the question is invalid is making Robert's assertions invalid too because the same can be said about NA culture.
BTW, I didn't just quote the WAR website. I quoted several. I can quote you hundreds more, including on most forums like Yahoo.
Well said, Raven Wing. I suspect many do not know their heritage no matter what it is. That would include whites who have Black, Mexican, NA or other racial heritages.
Mimmi, most people do not know Custer was slain by a woman warrior and that his body was desecrated by women because of his cowardice and using NA women as a shield between the army and the NA warriors. Custer mutilated the women killed and took the rest as sex slaves for his army. So the NA women, after he'd been slain, put awls in his ears, to help him hear them better in the afterlife, and an arrow up his penis.
NA women were the inspiration behind a lot of the suffragette movement. The elevated status of the Native American women was discussed by the Suffragettes.
The Seneca are one of the Six Nations of the Iroquois nation. Lucretia Mott and Elizabeth Cady Stanton spent time living among the Seneca. Mott stayed through the summer of 1848, leaving only for the convention in Stantons hometown, Seneca Falls, New York. The Iroquois adopted Matilda Joslyn Gage into their Wolf clan. She noted they gave her a voice and representation in political affairsa right she was denied under U.S. laws.
Stanton, Gage and Mott used this discrepancy in social systems in their speeches at the First Womens Rights Convention held on July 19, 1848
Stanton noted clan mothers held the authority to nominate, elect and depose tribal chiefs. "The Indian women endure fatigue and carry burdens that some of our fair faced, soft handed, mustachoed, young gentlemen would consider it quite impossible for them to sustainthe women were the great power among the clan," and "the original nomination of the chiefs also always rested with the women."
Gage spoke of the Iroquois government and culture. "Division of power between the sexes in this Indian republic was nearly equal. Although the principal chief of the confederacy was a man, descent ran through the female line, the sister of the chief possessing the power of nominating his successor."
Gage pointed out the U.S. form of government was borrowed from the Six Nations, and thus "the modern world [is] indebted for its first conception of inherent rights, natural equality of condition, and the establishment of a civilized government upon this basis" to the Iroquois.
Stanton contrasted the status of the Iroquois women with the oppression of white women. While "civilized" women pledged to obey their husbands upon marriage, among Haudenosaunee women "usually the females ruled the house," Stanton wrote. "The stores were in common; but woe to the luckless husband or lover who was too shiftless to do his share of the providing. No matter how many children, or whatever goods he might have in the house, he might at any time be ordered to pick up his blanket and budge; and after such an order it would not be healthful for him to attempt to disobey . . . and unless saved by the intercession of some aunt or grandmother, he must retreat to his own clan, or go and start a new matrimonial alliance in some other [clan]."
Stanton railed against the idea women were physically incapable, therefore must be "protected" by patriarchal oppression. "We cannot say what the woman might be physically, if the girl were allowed all the freedom of the boy in romping, climbing, swimming, playing hoop and ball. Among some of the Tarter tribes of the present day the women manage a horse, hurl a javelin, hunt wild animals, and fight an enemy as well as the men. The Indian women endure fatigue and carry burdens that some of our fair faced, soft handed, mustachoed, young gentlemen would consider it quite impossible for them to sustain."
IDK . I'm not Robert . I guess you can't tell us whites apart ...
So ... now you want me to go back & read the entire interaction between you 2 ....
That's the thing about the internet . They let everyone in ... including the mentally disturbed . I don't read that stuff . Why do you ?
So you think that my references to Robert as the third person in this discussion means I think you're Robert? Interesting.
BTW, I'm white, so the attempt to insult me as NA fell kind of flat. Of course, I wonder why you would want to insult an NA and why you don't seem to have enough reading comprehension to understand what I wrote.
Actually, I assumed you informed yourself about the discussion before you posted your comment so that your comment would be valid and have relevance. Guess I was wrong. I'll try not to make that assumption again.
So you think those in charge of the GOP are "mentally disturbed"? Or didn't you read the part about them? How about the other sites I quoted? Bother to read them at all? Or do you think that focusing on the one site you want to demonize makes the entire comment invalid? Go back and reread the entire comment. The WAR people are not saying anything the GOP and the other sites I quoted aren't also saying, so if you want to demonize one, you have to demonize them all.
As to why I read them: because I value knowledge. As I said to Robert, in the comment you replied to, I am not a fan of willful ignorance. When a person is not well informed on a subject, that person should not be making comments because it makes that person look silly and wastes the time of everyone else.
Thank you. I've never understood why some people prefer to remain ignorant on a subject they profess to be interested in.
Ahhhh - someone's been reading Political Leaders and Peacemakers by Victoria Sherrow - or Peace, Power, Righteousness - an indigenous manifesto by Taiaiake Alfred - or Apache Women Warriors by Kimberly Moore Buchanan or Indian Lives, Essays on Nineteenth- and Twentieth-Century Native American Leaders by Moses and Wilson.
Something in them we can all learn - very profoundreading.
I looked at your list again and still did not see anything from the GOP . Is this GOP ?
Me, too!
So the first article, where they discussed the GOPs use of fear concerning white majority wasn't about the GOP? Interesting interpretation. But if you want it more direct than that, h ere's racism and white supremacy in the GOP:
RandPauls team has anotherwhitesupremacist- Salon.com
WhiteSupremacists Rally AroundRonPaul's Racist Newsletter Scandal...
Paul Jenkins: TheGOP'sWhiteSupremacy- Breaking News and ...
UPenn professor: RacistGOPopposes abortion to protectwhite major...
The GOP welcomed known White supremacists to CPAC
RickPerry's Newest Problem: His Fond Memories of "Niggerhead"
RickPerry: ExtremistWhiteAmerica's Evangelical Hope - MWC
Republican Racism Example #22:Rick SantorumAnd TheWhiteSupremacist
WhiteSupremacists Showcased At CPAC Conservative
There are thousands more examples if you care to do a search.
But this is straying from the topic of broken treaties, except that white racism is the reason behind the broken treaties and the lack of public outcry.
Consider this - in the treaty, the U. S. states that they will maintain the infrastructure of the reservation, maintain schools for educating the young, provide medical care, and provide police protection, among other things.
60% of the reservation has no electricity, running water, sewer or communications. 70% of the youth are dropping out of school that they have to be bused to, 75 miles away. The medical/clinics have been shut down. The police duties have been turned over to the Tribe with no funding. The unemployment on the reservation is 92% because the nearest town in 75 miles away and there is no public transportation systemavailable for the residents to go to work AND, remember, this is South Dakota - the racist state in the Union against Indians, so there are no job opportunities. The "adoption" rate, by forcefully taking the children from their homes, is 48% - 3/4's of adoptions in SD are of Indian children forcefully taken from their homes.
Yeah - honor the treaties.
If you return to our discussion, my posts most certainly address what you said. You claimed I was being an armchair psychologist when I spoke of how racism is affecting our nation. I've proved what I said with these links, so your attempt to discredit my post is complete.
However, you still haven't answered my question. It's a simple yes or no. Are you willing to tell whites not to protect their culture now that the white race is about to become a minority race in the US?
If you choose not to answer it again, I'm going to assume the answer is no, you would not tell whites to stop trying to protect their culture. That would mean you know telling NAs not to try to protect their culture is wrong too.
Cultures need preservation because of the inherent values found within them. Telling someone their culture is worthless is meant to create psychological pain. Why anyone would want to do that is beyond me.
Those are shameful statistics. I'm glad you posted them because the more they are exposed, the better the chance of informing enough of the public to build pressure on the government to fulfill their obligations.
As to the racism in SD, there isn't much the government can do about that except enforce anti-discrimination laws. However that won't change the decisions of individuals that limit the future of Indian youth or job seekers.
In the feminist community, we have had some success with putting together Internet co-ops where individuals sell their crafts or other products in order to build a business of their own. Women in Africa, India and other locations have reported success. These women suffer from the same problems of poverty, isolation and discrimination found at Pine Ridge. I wonder if something along the same lines would help the Pine Ridge people.
You'd probably be amazed at how aware feminists are of the values of NAs, especially as regards women. There are many discussions about the basis of indigenous culture vs the dominant culture. Women have an inherent interest in overturning and/or changing the dominant culture just like Indians do, so we are natural allies.
I should take the time to find links to some of these discussions and post them in an article. They might be of interest to this community.
The same problems existed for the women who benefited from the co-ops. I would have do to research to see how they resolved them. The initial programs were privately funded through donations. They proved successful enough to get the UN and other public bodies to step in and help with the funding. The latter would probably not happen here, so the success would have to depend upon private donations until the success was great enough to sustain itself. That would be one of the hardest parts.
Another attempt to comment in an area where you are ill-informed? The link you provided has nothing at all to do with the overall oppression of white women via the dominant patriarchal culture of white men. Here's a better link to educate yourself:
The Cult of True Womanhood - Pinzler.com
That was life for women in the East. Women in the West took a different path. It is not an accident that Wyoming and Utah were the first states to grant women the right to vote. Women were already a viable force in the running of their towns when the question of suffrage arose.
Western women were well aware of the respect for and prominence of women in other cultures, like the Indian and Mexican social structure. so freedom and equality for women spread from the West to the East.
Parker, in The Cult of True Womanhood and the Western Movement (1992), noted white men classified white women as Sunbonnet Sue and Goodhearted Sal. The first represented respectable women; the latter represented fallen women living in sin. White men ignored what white women couldnt help but notice: these women enjoyed greater freedom and respect in their culture. Sunbonnet Sue could only look with wishful eyes at the Californio women... Mexican and Native American women were neither bound by the rigid morality of the New England-Eastern society nor seeped in the innate wickedness envisioned by Anglo-American men.
Susan B. Anthony advised women to move en masse to Wyoming because the state enfranchised women fifty-one years before the U.S. Congress granted women the right to vote. D uring 1870,women served on a jury in Laramie. Laramie also hired the first female court bailiff, Mary Atkinson. South Pass City huired the first female justice of the peace, Esther Hobart Morris.
In 1888, national suffragists hung convention banners declaring "the vote of women transformed Wyoming from barbarism to civilization." Harper's Magazine featured Cheyenne women going door to door registering voters.
When Wyoming applied for statehood, the U.S. Congress still opposed womens suffrage. They threatened to strip Wyomings women of their right to vote. Wyomings men and women balked. The official telegram from Cheyenne stated theyd rather remain out of the Union 100 years than join under the condition women lost the vote. Faced with a standoff, Congress relented.
A Los Angeles Times article, How Susan B. Anthony and Others Struggled Against Many Obstacles, First Victory in West, Wyoming Led off in 1869 and Other States Were Won Over Slowly (1920), remarked upon Wyomings progressive stance concerning womens rights: it was not until 1869 that the first American woman acquired the legal right to cast a ballot. Then the right to vote was given to women, not because of the agitation of [suffragette] Mrs. [Lucretia] Mott, but because of the hardy pioneers of a Western Territory thought that women who shared the dangers and hardships of the trek across the prairies ought also to have an equal voice in the government of the new lands.
It did transform Wyoming . The state budget went out the window as soon as women got the vote . That applies to more than just this one state .
If I were an early white woman I would have been bitter and probably driven insane or into prostitution or suicide... or maybe into life as a highwaywoman.
Ever learned anything about life as a woman then? If you had wealthy parents who died and left you a fortune, the entire thing, money and estates, went to whomever you were MARRIED to, not to you. Not one farthing, not one blade of grass was legally yours. If the husband chose to gamble it all away or to set you aside in a dingy country cottage, he could take your children from you and leaveyou destitute with no recourse.
If he died owing gambling debts, you paid them or could be sold into bondage to "work off" his debts... which never seemed to get paid off. If you had children, they were sold into bondage as well.
Hell, yes... insanity and bitterness, no choice but prostitution or a quick marriage to another man who owned your body and if you were lucky, was kind with your soul.
I know they would be.
All that and more. A woman who was not a virgin could be raped with impunity unless she was married and then the crime was against her husband's property rights, not her rights in any way. A prostitute's body was considered public property so any man could rape her at any time. Women who enjoyed sex were considered mentally ill and placed in asylums and/or divorced. There are divorce records where men asserted they felt shamed and abused because their wives enjoyed sex.
Being accused of nymphomania was a serious charge. A woman could be institutionalized as mentally disordered, where any interest in sex would have been used as proof she needed to remain confined, as would any act of rebellion against the demands of her captors. A common remedy was either a clitoridectomy or an ovariectomy, the removal of one or both ovaries. Removal of the clitoris would no doubt cure a womans sexual desires because it is the only organ in the human body with no purpose other than to provide sexual pleasure.
Carol Groneman, in Nymphomania: A History (2000), cited a case published in the Boston Medical and Surgical Journal in 1841. Miss T was thought to suffer from nymphomania because she uttered the most disgusting obscenities and her body movements expressed libidinous feelings. She also exhibited sadness and a paroxysm of hysteria. The doctors examined her and decided her uterus was too large, her vagina too moist and her clitoris too long and tumid. To treat this terrible condition, they applied caustic substances to her genitals and congratulated themselves that after weeks of these applications she had not a symptom remaining referable to nymphomania After this torture, she displayed every appearance of modesty. Her offending clitoris was determined to be properly retracted and very diminutive.
In his Ladies' Guide in Health and Disease (1889), Dr. John Harvey Kellogg, of Kelloggs Corn Flakes fame, recommendations for nymphomania included cool sitz baths; the cool enema; a spare diet; the application of blisters and other irritants to the sensitive parts of the sexual organs, the removal of the clitoris and nymphae (the folds of the vulva surrounding the vaginal opening, aka labia minora)
Even little girls were not immune to caustic substances. Kellogg railed against the dangers of childhood masturbation. Corn Flakes and granola were part of his cure for self-abuse. In Plain Facts for Old and Young (1881), under his chapter Secret Vice (Solitary Vice or Self-Abuse), he wrote: A remedy which is almost always successful in small boys is circumcision...The operation should be performed by a surgeon without administering an anesthetic, as the brief pain attending the operation will have a salutary effect upon the mind...In females, the author has found the application of pure carbolic acid to the clitoris an excellent means of allaying the abnormal excitement.
That's a common misogynistic claim with no foundation in reality. Very boring when someone feels the need to insert the same discredited falsehoods into a legitimate discussion. Do you have anything knowledgeable and informative to contribute, or should I just ignore all further posts by you?
Yeah , if your only defense is to label what you disagree with as misogynistic then put me on ignore . Hiding from the facts will serve you well ... NOT .
You have not presented any facts. You've simply repeated the falsehoods of misogynists on the far right. But since you want to pretend they are facts, you'll need to present links to resources validating your claim that women in Wyoming destroyed Wyoming's budget after they got the vote. I'll be waiting.
But in the meantime, here's a few sites that thoroughly agrees with you -- and you claimed you do not read extremists sites like this, remember?
How Female Suffrage Destroyed Western Civilization
How the feminist lesbian bitches destroyed America ! - The
19th Amendment: Celebrating 90 Years of Feminism Destroying ...
Muslims Warn Giving Women Rights Could Destroy Society
Egypt's Islamists warn giving women some rights could destroy ...
Fox News Contributor: Allowing Women To Vote A 'Mistake'
I could do that but it will require some work on my part . What kind of evidence will you actually accept as fact instead of rejecting as misogyny ?
Works written in that era addressing that issue would be your best resource. Failing that, then valid sites dedicated to history, like universities, etc. Sites dedicated to the history of Wyoming might address it if it actually happened.
Those written by today's misogynists in an attempt to degrade and devalue women will not be acceptable.
I had a feeling we would not speak the same language . From my POV the best evidence would be numerical data which show a correlation . But that is apparently not your forte . Finding historical political tracts is likely to prove very difficult and time consuming . Take care .
PS : Just noticed your links . That is not what I had in mind . I doubt any of them present hard numerical data . Rants are not something I take seriously .
Apparently not my forte? I"m an accountant who specialized in salvaging corporations from their own disastrous financial mistakes.
I'm also a journalist who has written many investigative reports on city and state budgeting.
So if you want to discuss the Wyoming state budgets before women got the vote and after they got the vote, go for it. I'd be interested in seeing your sources and the proof any changes can be correlated to the women's vote.
OK , fair enough . I was judging by the usual links and arguments you post . I've never seen you make a numerical one . Maybe because it reminds you too much of work ?
BTW do you know the diff between correlation and causation ?
Most people's eyes glaze over when the discussion turns to numbers, especially those with a social context, so I focus my posts on our social systems and their fallibility. especially when they inflict harm. Providing historical information and correlating it to today's issues seems to interest more people.
Yes, I know the difference between correlation and causation. In this case, I doubt you'll be able to prove either.
Ladies - ditto what Dead Man Talking said - please get back on track and leave the soap at home.
Thanks.
It is ironic that the US government can sit at the table with a straight face as the moral head of negotiations with world leaders to discuss treaties for human rights and boundaries for lands their failure to honor both for the Native Americans in their own country has resulted in poverty, illness, lack of education, joblessness, poor sanitation, poor housing, no infrastructure, poor to no medical or emergency services, lack of adequate fresh water supply, racism, bigotry and prejudice among a large number of the rest of the populace, and, to paraphrase the current president, a deep pain from the history of abuses and genocide of the Native American people that has not gone away....
because the government insists they still live it.
I understand that each Tribe is unto itself, sovereign.
It is, however, unfortunate, that just once, the total Indian nations could not come together as One and form a million NA march on DC to demand that the government honor the treaties signed three hundred years ago, and at the least assist in providing medical, educational and sanitary facilities for the reservations....
to return to them the logging rights taken from them by turning their reservation lands into national forests then leased to private corporations....
to return to them fishing and hunting rights taken from them.....
and to demand that they be allowed to have the right to say who enters reservation land with the same absolute control that the US government controls who enters this country (excluding the Southern border).
We have the Amish and the Mennonites living in this country as protected communities inhabited by people who have societies outside that considered "normal" by the rest of us. They pay no taxes as they claim everything they own, all revenue they make from the farms they cultivate and the products made and the animals raised/slaughtered/processed are owned by the church.
Even during the time of the draft their men and boys were exempt. Their children are exempt from being required to attend school after the eighth grade, whereas our children are considered delinquent, sent to kiddie prison and parents sent to jail and fined if the children don't attend school. Religion is taught in their schools.
A completely protected class of people, living outside the rules of the rest of us, yet receiving no condemnation of special privilege; but let someone mention Native Americans and the accusations of them being treated special are vicious and mean. Is it racism?
Hmmm - that's not what they taught us in officer leadership school.
If what you say is true John - why did you just comment as it has no bearing on the thread?
Stick to the topic of the thread please.
Yeah, pretty much, Mimi. Much of it is opportunism at it's finest. Easy targets, and the opportunity to be "somebody" by somehow being "better" then someone else. But, I believe that rubbing the term racism in someone's face only serves to change the subject and put everyone on the defense. Is it racism? Yeah, probably, but that changes the issue from what we can accomplish to make things better to "you are a fuck wad racist". Just how much of this article is devoted to making life better on the Pine Ridge rez and how much of it is devoted to name calling? Just a little different perspective. You know already that I am compassionate toward the plight of the NA's so don't manage to take me wrong here.
And you ask me for clarification?
My apologies Grump. You are right, the word "racist" is thrown around so much lately it has lost its meaning.
It's extremely frustrating to try and find the trigger that will click with people so they will say, "Wow! I never thought of it that way. Maybe I ought to give this situation more consideration and look at it from another angle."
The only thing that will make life better on the Pine Ridge rez is an infusion of real interest in doing so, accompanied by the funds to make it happen and people knowledgeable of the NA culture and sensitive to both the pride and needs of the people there. The funds should come from the federal government as a step toward meeting its obligation in honoring terms of treaty; the rest would follow from that one first positive step.
Thank you for putting me back on track, Grump.
There is no need to apologize, Mimi. I have been reading the comments after stepping back from the argument. I have been watching the processes involved rather than the the comments and words themselves. (If that makes any sense.)
Those who do not wish to know what is going on at Pine Ridge, or who don't want to be faced with the chilling video, can easily change the subject and get the truly concerned off on a tangent about race, "you white people", blah blah blah, and the exploration of what is presented in the video vanishes.
What does this video mean, how can the people of the United States bring about a better life for those boys in gangs, do other Indian tribes offer anything to Pine Ridge? There are a hundred questions brought up by the video and few of them have been answered or even addressed - the diversions generated by a few (both sides of the fence) have been successful and way easier to do than work toward a solution to the problems faced by the folks at Pine Ridge.
To me, simple minded old fool that I am, the fact that the folks at Pine Ridge happen to be Indians doesn't matter as much as the fact that they are folks just like you and me who are suffering and living in deplorable conditions.
And, sadly, it is not racism. The laws and the courts have made it a political issue - treaties, sovereignty, trust lands, "dependent nations" - has absolutely nothing to do with race.
Another striking fact that not many remember is in 1994, Pres. Clinton went to the Pine Ridge Rez and "Promised" to direct industry to begin working with the tribe to increase their economic structure - amazingly, no one showed and nothing was done to change that flow - that is politics.
I think you are right. It is not racism (I don't know about the "sadly" part of your comment, though). Industry to increase the economy of Pine Ridge would have to be "profitable" to "corporate America" and I don't see the corporate part of America being very compassionate with anybody - Indian or not. The approach would have to be different, not based on profit but based on compassion. Compassion now and profits later (but only maybe), but that is not the American corporate way. Yes, it's politics and our politicians are bought and paid for by the highest lobbyist / bidder. That is not racism directed at NA's because corporations - through our elected politicians - are targeting each and every one of us no matter what color we are.
I see what you guys are saying, Grump and 1stwarrior. To my shame, I had gone off topic and was referring to the way people have a tendency to get their hackles up whenever Native Americans are discussed.
They immediately get defensive and call them a "protected race" and seem to resent it, throwing in all the misconceptions such as "free land, no taxes, lifetime welfare checks" things of that nature.
As Grump said, I was out of line, stirring up resentment, and offering no solutions, only becoming another part of the problem, the very thing I said at the beginning of this thread I hoped would not happen. (Mimi hanging her head in shame.)
I know this sounds crass and out of line with the dignity and pride associated with NAs, but as Pine Ridge is so out of the mainstream as far as attracting industry.... what's the chance of it transforming itself into a tourist attraction, a living view into how Indians lived and worked in the pastin the waythe Connecticut village that made itself famous for its view into the Colonial past?
Draw enough tourists there and in time small businesses can thrive on the reservation. Schools can plan educational class trips there; perhaps they could develop a small dude ranch, things of that nature. I realize that leaders would have to step forward to badger Washington to upgrade facilities to accommodate improvements for such things.... and I'd lead the committee straight to Clinton's front door and tell the bastard he had been elected as head of it and front man to approach the right people to get it off the ground, based on his promises that never materialized.
Just throwing out suggestions here. Shoot them down, I'll try to come up with more.
The BIA has a section dealing specifically with economic development. The tribes have to compete for it and the documentation for the grants are horrendous. Since "Daddy" put the BIA in charge of ensuring treaty rights, for the most part, have been adhered to, I'm kinda curious as to why this has gone on for so long.
And your discussion will be welcome.
This is so blasted frustrating and confusing, trying to get to the bottom of why nothing has been done to help Pine Ridge and how to go about helping them now.
It just brings me right back to the idea of marching on Washington by all the Nations getting together en mass, an Indian uprising protesting the failure of the government to honor the terms of the treaties.
Anything else is like watching a hamster in a cage running on one of those exercise wheels.... running its little heart out, in place, racing 90mph, going nowhere.
DMT~ We are going to have to keep educating and keep pushing the government. They boast of "accountability" with everything else. It is their turn to be held accountable.
We have to focus on the positive in every heritage. We must. I think some people misconstrue efforts of those of race and culture (other than their own) for fairness and equality as trying to say they are more important or deserving/entitled. That is not the case at all! People of every walk of life, every color, shape, size, belief, economic situation......deserve respect and acceptance. (
For those who are about to attack me on this, I'm saying respect , not that you must agree with them, but respect them and accept their right to be who and what they are, even if it is different than what you prefer.)
This is not about Native Americans vs. Whites. That is silly. This is about people. Humans. Rights. And the Golden Rule: Would any of us want to live in the ways depicted in this video?
So what value do each of us place on each other? It is a question for each human being to ask of their own hearts. And if ever the answer comes up with a lower value for any person of any color other than our own, we really need to do some serious soul-searching.
I really, really do.
I was thinking along those lines, DMT, but it seemed such a long range plan and I didn't know if anyone in the government had the intelligence to plan that far ahead.
Of course we are talking about the initial intelligence of the founding fathers who certainly had it all over the current crop, so all these guys have to do is follow the blueprint.
As I said on our page - step by step - one foot in front of the other - one by one - that's all it takes - persistency.
Thanks Stephi.
Realize this is a little late in responding to you Robert - but - Chief Justice John Marshall in Cherokee Nation v. Georgia (1831) stated "Indian tribes are not foreign nations, but distinct political entities, governing themselves, and making treaties with the United States. Their relationship to the United States Government is that of domestic, dependent nations - the relationship is similar to that between wards and their guardians." In Worcester v. Georgia (1832), he further stated "Indian Nations had always been considered distinct, independent political communities, retaining their original natural rights, as the undisputed possessors of the soil ... The very term "nation" so generally applied to them means "people distinct from others"."
The important point of sovereignty is that tribes are independent nations. Some characteristics of sovereignty are:
Tribes were not granted sovereignty - they always had it.
Indian tribal governments have always maintained sole responsibility to perpetuate their status as sovereign nations and to exercise their rights as defined by treaty or other statute.
Depending upon the legal document establishing a tribe's legal status and recognition, there may be certain rights that only Congress can alter.
Sovereignty is a status rigorously guarded and maintained by tribal governing bodies - Indian Nations do not delegate sovereignty to other entities.
So stated.
This is another reason I wish the Nations could come together just for the purpose of addressing Washington on subject of honoring Treaties.There are members of Tribes who have been quite successful in becoming attorneys and politicians and if a an accord were formed among all the Nations could advocate for the poorer ones on subject of honoring Treaties.
Just focusing on schools, medical and sanitary facilities, and minimal housing improvement would provide immediate employment and when completed would extend thatemployment for the residents of the reservations. Another improvement needed for them would be a tower so they could receive basic Internet service, something everyone on this board takes for granted.
In fact, everything I mentioned here is something we alltake for granted.
IfIam not mistaken, the only timethe Tribes came together against an enemy was when Crazy Horseand Sitting Bulltalked them into joining against the invaders trying to take their land. It was suchaberrant behavior it rattled Washington to its core.
Is this why the Sioux, particularly, have been neglected and trampled upon? Isthe government afraid of the Sioux mystique... afraidthe spirit of Crazy Horse will be rebornin another man or woman who will make it into politics or become successful enough to be able to pull together enough of the leaders of the other Nations to form one Indian Nation strong enough to assail Washington andforce enough publicity so that the rest of the country finally looks at the reality of the Indian situation?
Russell Means must have scared the hell out of the government. And, WTH, they weren't looking in the right direction and the Anishinaabe Dennis Banks, that silver tongued devil, started all the trouble.
United We Stand... Divided We Fall... and there are so many people in this country who will stand with us if they know what it is all about, and that is what concernsWashington the most. Because most of the people in America are still standing for what'sright and decent as long as it isn't something that takes anything away from them.
But, I'm an Aquarius, a dreamer, and a conspiracy theorist.
Honemana,
This is the kind of information that so many of us don't know. Although it's available to us we just don't know to look for it and it can be confusing when we find it.
Good grief, if I were financially secure enough to do it, I would form a group to tour cities and towns across the US just to address citizens of this country as an information source to educate them about the realities of the relationships between the Nations and state and federal governments.
It's an ungodly triangle... both the state and federal government have ropes tied to the Indian... one with ropes tied the hands, the other tied to the feet, they are seated on four wheelers with the motors revved and are trying to see which can pull the Indian apart and leave with the most amount of the body parts.
I wish others had the courage to comment on it.
OH my Goodness, Raven Wing! Thank you! What you said is an honor I do not take lightly.
1st Warrior~
We're building bridges, my friend! It just takes time....and like you said, persistence. Like we say in our home, "Thanks for thankin' me"
there are so many people in this country who will stand with us if they know what it is all about
Yes there are, Mimi! We just need to connect. Like you guys did with me in your Anishinaabe Group. You took a chance accepting me and I am so grateful because I treasure the friendships we have made, and the knowledge you have imparted to me. There is so much we just didn't/don't know about. And the more you teach us, the more people you will have standing with you. I just know it. I guess we are dreamers together!
And one of the things that really bothers me is that, unless the Indian Gaming law allows it, the states can't do it. Taxing is one thing they can't do. This needs to go to court above the 2nd Circuit -, i.e. SCOTUS.
States only have the rights Congress gives them and, under Indian law, that ain't much. I've looked at the cases in the various states where it is states v. tribes and have found that, not only are the states telling the Feds they can do what they want within their boundaries, they are attempting to attack the tribes in a new front. Sadly for them, the tribes are winning 92% of the cases due to treaty rights and Constitutionality. Maybe that's why they're trying harder.
It will only get worse in the days to come as federal money gets tighter. The states are cutting funds to programs for its non Native citizens and will be going after every wooden nickel they can squeeze, legally or illegally, from the reservations.
Unfortunately, in doing so, politicians will be pitting slyly pitting the citizens of the two neighborhoods against each other, inciting animosity. I sincerely hope the reservations have some good public relations people in the wings.
The states have always been up in arms about the Tribes being un-touchable until the PL-280 and only then could six specific states have "minor" say-so over tribal/individual activities. Other states were allowed to opt in, but none took the offer.
'Course, no one has mentioned the number of tribes who have successful casino operations who have manned and outfitted the city and county law enforcement officers because the city/county/state can't afford to. Not to mention the hospitals, schools, industry, roads and other equipment freely furnished by those tribes to the communities to off-set the traffic to the casinos and wear and tear on the highways.
Congress didn't want the tribes to have more law enforcement authority over non-Indians - that was the issue. I mean, heaven forbid that an Indian should be able to arrest a non-Indian for violation of a law on the reservation - what would happen to this world if that were to be allowed???? After all, according to Judge Rhenquist in theSuquamish case, the Indians don't have the "mental capacity" to deal with the intracies of the law.
Ssssssshhhhhhh........ you guys are going to destroy the image of Indians taking, never giving, to the local communities....
I would like to personally thank all of you for your discussion on this subject. Yes, it is a very sore subject for the Native peoples because they've had to live it - not so with dominant, non-Indian society.
I will be happy to discuss any portion of this thread if you wish - just let me know.
Oh - you don't have to quit these discussions either - keep it up.
Whenever you post an article, 1stwarrior, I learn something... heck, I learn a lot. Having been raised in the shadows and never versed in the tangled web of legalities that defines reservation life, the duplicity of both federal and state governments shocks and angers me. It is difficult to reign in the anger at times and word these comments so that they don't seem to be directed at the white population en mass, but at the government specifically.
Honor the treaties as they pertain to housing, schools, educational, medical and sanitary facilities... that alone would take care of employment opportunities to start, would sustain employment for many in the long run. Just do that much. Then the US government wouldn't look like two faced fools when at the negotiation tables with other countries when talking about human rights.
Most countries do refuse to enter into treaties with the U. S. Now they enter into Memorandums of Agreement or Cooperative Agreements. 'Course, the U. S. still breaks those too.
How do youtype that lip thing that is called a "raspberry"?????
Guny, I had to read comments and links on the other article about baby Veronica to understand what you meant by this.
"Justice" Roberts? Oh, yeah.....
Yeah, but it's usually for the business side of the world. Think I'm gonna havfta do some research on his Indian rulings - how many in favor of or against - could be very interesting.
I am quite interested in your results.
Since his tenure on SCOTUS from 2003, he has been involved with 572 cases. Just in the past two years, six Indian cases came to the court and he was against all six.
The write-ups on him from scholarly documents have him listed as being very non-supportive of the tribes and very supportive of Business.
I've got a friend who is doing more research for me.
Not a good looking picture - kinda a clone of Rehnquist.
Well, between he, Alito, Scalia and Thomas, the Indian community is dead.
Time yet for a "Million First People's March" of all Tribes on Washington? Mrs D and I have both committed to be there if it occurs in our lifetime. Is it not time for the Nations to come together and demand honor from the seat of power in this country?
To deny this father the right to raise his child strikes at the heart of ICWA, doesn't it? Is ICWA another one to bite the dust?
Mimi, I sure pray it happens in our lifetime.
My aunt, now in her 70s, tells of how as a teen she was dancing around the kitchen while my Grandmother was preparing dinner... to the song "Cherokee Nation" by Paul Revere and the Raiders.
She said, "Mama, you look like you are a Cherokee Indian Princess," and my Grandmother slapped her so hard she fell across the room into the wall. Her mother then stalked (her word) to her as she lay on the floor and leaned down and very quietly said, "We are Black Dutch. Don't you ever say we are Indian."
It was on her death bed that my Grandmother admitted that she was Cherokee anything proving that had been destroyed.
Mrs D, I so hope it occurs in our lifetime, too. I think even the Nations would be surprised at the number of people who would respond to show support.
The next president of this country could very well be the first politician who stands publicly with them. They are so busy counting illegals they have never bothered to count the number of those who are "trace" Native Americans and proud of it, and the White sisters and brothers of the heart who support restoring honor to at least one level of the government.