Hey George … Let's Make a Deal!
TRAYVON MARTIN WAS PROSECUTED FOR MURDERING HIMSELF!
AND FOUND GUILTY BY SIX WHITE JURORS FROM A TOWN WITH A HISTORY OF RACISM.
I have a proposition for George Zimmerman.
I WILL PAY A PORTION OF YOUR LEGAL BILLS (if Fox News et al haven't already paid them in full), IF YOU WILL SUBJECT YOURSELF TO A POLYGRAPH TEST ON NATIONAL TELEVISION AND PASS!
You may contact me here on NT, Mr. Zimmerman.
Be a man and do this; take the test and, uh, stand your ground.

Have you heard the one about the black woman in Florida sentenced to 20 years in prison for firing a gun into HER CEILING?
Fla. woman Marissa Alexander gets 20 years for "warning shot": Did she stand her ground?
(CBS) - Last Friday, Jacksonville mother Marissa Alexander was sentenced by a Florida judge to 20 years in prison for firing what she says was a "warning shot" into the wall after a physical altercation with her husband, Rico Gray.
The case has set off yet another controversy involving the state's "stand your ground" law, which is under intense scrutiny after the shooting death of Trayvon Martin in February. Critics, including Congresswoman Corrine Brown (D-Fla.), are crying foul.
How, they ask, could a 31-year-old woman in a relationship with a man who had a history of domestic violence, and whose actions did not result in any physical injury, be sentenced to two decades in prison while George Zimmerman, the man who shot and killed Martin, is out on bail?
"The Florida criminal justice system has sent two clear messages today," Rep. Brown said in a statement on May 11. "One is that if women who are victims of domestic violence try to protect themselves, the "Stand Your Ground Law" will not apply to them...The second message is that if you are black, the system will treat you differently."
...
Black in Florida?
Innocent until Charged!
And I suppose you believe OJ was not guilty.
This has nothing to do with O.J. Simpson; it has to do with a bad law and disparate "justice."
You want a pissin' contest Len, start with Rodney King and go back in history to the racist injustices.
You raising O.J. Simpson as a kind of "balance/justification" for the Trayvon Marting sham decision, is analogous to me raising Meyer Lansky or Murder Incorporated as a justification for the Holocaust!
Injustice is injustice and each one fucks over whichever victim it affects.
This may be the straw that breaks the back of the inherently racist and radically religionist base to which the Republican/Tea Party plays. The "day in court" for the average American is through the ballot box AND THE TEA PARTY REPUBLICAN GOVERNORS, LEGISLATORS, ALEC AND KOCH BROTHERS' DIRTY DOLLARS ARE WORKING TO KILL THAT OPTION.
The peaceful shit storm among reasonable Americans began last night.
One has to be an ignorant, damn fool not to understand from where the anger over racist-executed, legislated and institutionalized injustice arises.
Fuck all who dare to blame the victims!
Perhaps in time you'll understand symbolic challenges that need be only that in order to advance an obvious reality.
I have spotted yet another, this one, not a "politically correct apologist", rather an enabler of and cheerleader for the system that has at least two standards for judging its citizens.
The polygraph is just a reference to an instrument that conjures up visions of the "handwriting on the wall."
Some of us have the conscience to read it aloud. Some of us revert to the name-calling of those who do.
No excuse for those assholes -- but let's address those that were peaceful, their numbers and their significance.
BUT SO WE'RE CLEAR -- just say one way or the other if you believe George Zimmerman could pass a ploygraph test.
YES or NO.
I insist.
Zimmerman is the racist thug -- he just got away with it. We'll see what comes out in Wrongful Death and Civil Rights proceedings.
Is it an insult that motivated Martin to kill Zimmerman?
And yes! Fuck all who dare to blame victims -- need examples of such mentality?
IMHO , I don't see a wrongful death suit coming , not based on the outcome of the trial. the self defense claim kind of nullifies that since it was used only after an assault was started .
as for a civil rights violation , I have to wonder what civil rights were violated , if we go with what the NAACP claimed last night , martins right to life , that's a double edged knife that will cut both ways , because martin also violated Z's civil rights when he started pummeling Z for whatever reason . and that will be , just in the case just decided , the crux , both individuals had legal rights to be where they were doing exactly what they were doing right up until the assault started , that's when the law was broken , like it or not .
And like it or not someone profiling another person is not yet illegal outside of being a member of a government agency and even then it still happens whenever a cop is given a BOLO or a description of a suspect. they even within government have people called profilers taught to based on evidence whom the LE officials should be looking at as a group looking for the suspect . used properly it can be very helpful , improperly and its down right dangerous hense the skepticism of its use.
I doubt z could pass a polygraph , but he never claimed he didn't kill martin , only that his actions were covered by the self defense statutes , which doesn't make him a murderer either since murder is the UNLAWFUL taking of a human life , there is such a thing in todays society as justified homicide , be we like it or not , its still there , and always will be , because some people on both sides , wont have the smarts of when to stop .
z was found not guilty of the charges he faced , that's all , and as I said he never claimed he didn't kill .
BF,
And Al Capone opened soup kitchens during the depression -- feeding with one hand and murdering with the other; people will do some good things and some of those same people will do bad things -- Don Corleone had an olive oil business -- but he only sold olive oil in the FRONT of the store.
Now, until you respond to my question
Our dialogue in this thread has ended.
But since there is no real evidence that Trayvon attacked George, I'm not sure why we are seriously discussing it.
Definition of real evidence = Evidence flame agrees with.
Trayon was just another young punk looking to administer a beatdown to the short creepy ass cracka who had the temerity to follow him. He was doing pretty good at just that, until his run-in with Mr. 9mm.
The Zimmerman haters can continue their circle-jerk as long as they wish, but the fact is justice was served.
Possibly, Bruce, that reckless endangerment and risking a catastrophe may applied, BUT HOW ABOUT YOUR FAVORITE, CASTLE DOCTRINE? And there were extenuating circumstances; her husband who had abused her was about to abuse her again -- it's my understanding that he was thus violating a court order, so, she was (allegedly) protecting herself from someone about to break at least two laws.
Trayvon Martin was walking home. And despite what Zimmerman claims, it was his word against the word of the person he murdered. White killer walks, black woman acting rationally or otherwise protecting herself -- 20 years.
Now Bruce, let's get back to my question you wrote
I say, if this scenario was presented to Zimmerman while taking a polygraph, and the question was "tell the examiner what really happened that night," -- we'd all have a different picture.
The only other eyewitness was killed by the guy who changed his story several times.
Egilman,
Legally it's irrelevant but it would be highly relevant to many who watched the trial and know the details and testimony AND ARE NOW FOCUSED ON ONLY WHAT IS KNOWN ABOUT THE EVENTS LEADING TO MARTIN'S DEATH -- ONLY THAT WHICH IS KNOWN.
Now, all those who are ducking my question -- let's push it a bit further
Would George Zimmerman pass a polygraph test starting with the question I asked Bruce?
Yes or no folks; relevant or not -- answer my question, own your opinions, stand your you know what.
How 'bout this question?
* "Mr. Zimmerman, did Trayvon Martin attempt to take your gun, if at all, at any time prior to your pointing it at his heart?"
No Egilman, it's relevant to at least one set of parents, reasonable human beings around the world, especially to those who have been victimized by institutionalized unfairness.
Stop ducking the question. I'm asking you to declare what you believe. The more people who evade the question, the more I see the answer.
Yes! It's hypothetical -- deal with it.
It wasn't a fight at all. Simply an attack. Martin sucker punched GZ in the nose causing him to fall on his back, mounted him and proceeded to beat him in the face and head. John Good was an eyewitness to the last part of this attack. Or he is not "real evidence" to you?
BF: Aww!!! give me a break!! Zimmerman would attach himself to any cause that would elevate him to been a COP!!!(police officer).
This is the real George Zimmerman:
Did George Zimmerman have help from his father, a retired judge, in clearing his name in three separate arrests?
George Zimmerman, Son of a Retired Judge, Has 3 Closed Arrests
Thats the question thats being asked now that more information on Trayvon Martins 28-year-old killer is being revealed. Robert Zimmerman, a former Orange County magistrate judge, recently wrote a letter to The Orlando Sentinel defending his son, whos been dragged through the mud for shooting the unarmed 17-year-old last month. In the letter, the senior Zimmerman asks people not to jump to conclusions and insists that his son didnt follow the young boy home as he walked through their gated community.
...
There is only one "interpretation" of this verdict. The prosecution failed. Nothing more, nothing less. If you think this proves anything else, you need to bone up on your 'Law an Order'. If the prosecution fails, the defendant walks, whether they committed the crime or not.
To answer your question AMac, "No". Zimmerman would not pass a polygraph. However, just for the record, the questions he would/should face would be the same as yours, "yes or no". Not 'What happened'? Much to broad and left to interpretation.
Apparently I'm not; I know what the jury decided. I also know that they didn't know what they didn't know and were content to rule "not guilty" despite what they did know which was quite incriminating. The LEGAL ASPECT OF THE EVENT IS DONE.
Now let's go for the truth.
I merely want to know what actually took place; are you going to duck the question? It costs nothing to Zimmerman for you and others to answer -- but I'm beginning to believe that the cost to those who answer, may be of some personal significance.
And I made a link to sweet George on Page #2 so innocent (sarc)
John Good's actual testimony doesn't match your version first Good said
And later Good said
Try this; have someone select two identical pieces of paper, each a different color, and have it done where you cannot see the papers. Darken a room have the person hold the papers at whatever distance you think Good was from Martin.
Try it and let me know how well you ID'd the colors.
So pokermik,
Are you gonna hold up and stop ducking my question, or fold up and keep trying to change dealers?
Oh, and Good also testified
Who had training in MMA? It wasn't Martin.
And finally
No answer to my question
No credibility.
So then you have nothing to fear by answering my question; or maybe I can put you on record as saying, "YES, I BELIEVE ZIMMERMAN COULD PASS A POLYGRAPH TEST!"
Can I record your thumbs up on that? You'll be the first to stand his ground and we'll all know where that ground is.
BF,
I responded to that article -- I gave you a specific answer even though you have not yet taken a position on that polygraph thingy question
Thanks for being the first (and only one to give a direct answer); and it's my polygraph test and my questions. Had Zimmerman taken the stand, he would have had to answer "my" questions and lied himself into prison. Regardless of the prosecution's "failures," the reality is, IF THE JURY HAD BASED ITS RULING JUST ON WHAT WAS KNOWN AND NOTHING THAT ZIMMERMAN CLAIMED THAT WAS NOT DOCUMENTED AND VERIFIABLE -- he'd have been convicted.
The jury took the easy way out albeit by way of the letter-of-the (Florida bullshit) law.
Frankly, when he chambered the round, he was guilty. Any gun safety advocate would agree, that a chambered round is the responsibility of the handler of the weapon.
This is a different thing all together. This was black on black crime. The woman is still innocent in my opinion.
I can tell you right now, this woman is going to get out of jail and should be out of jail already. From all I've read and I've read a lot, she should have never been in jail in the first place.
My problem here is why hasn't the media taken her case on like they did the Trayvon Martin case?
Here is a little information: I think you'll find both of these interesting. I have more but this should do it.
...
...
Also:
...
Physician's Assistant evaluation of Martin's (possibly self-inflicted "injuries").
See 1:23:00 to end
And Bruce, none of Zimmerman's Blood or DNA on Martin's hands. Did the rain wash it from Martin's hands but not Zimmerman's head and nose.
POLYGRAPH TEST OR NOT BRUCE? Until you answer my question, I'll regard any future comments as stalling/evasive.
BF wrote,
From YOUR LINK! Did you read the article, BF?
As I said previously BF, "my polygraph, my questions."
I'll see your Ohhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh and raise you
The test wasn't.
Nope read the information from your first link
Aside from which, I want MY questions asked and asked by a NEUTRAL THIRD PARTY TECHNICIAN/EXAMINER, NOT THE SANFORD (history of racism) POLICE DEPARTMENT.
NOTE: I do this from time-to-time with certain people; though we disagree, I do not intend anything in this dialogue as personal BF. We just disagree.
Let's continue you this tomorrow -- got other things to do for the rest of the evening.
Great observance AMac how many packets of Ketchup did they have to use to get that believable(not) photo? poor ole George, he had a boo, boo, so he killed someone..
"They" being the police ? Do you know how delusional you sound ?
Maybe Petey, its seems to be the season for it...its midnight where I live so I am getting a little tired...lol...
72 shot, 12 killed in Chicago over weekend, yet media obsesses on a plane crash in San Francisco where two die
by Ed Farnan on July 8, 2013
Print This Post
San Francisco International Airport was ground zero for national media attention as it focused on a jet crash which claimed the lives of two passengers.
Although the crash was spectacular and captivated our attention.The very fact only 2 people lost their lives in the fiery mishap should have been enough to realize many other weighty events were happening around the country.
Miracles happened that morning that prevented a far larger loss of life and averted tragedy of mass proportions.
Yet 2,000 miles away, far more Americans were losing their lives in horrendous violence plaguing one of our largest cities.
The miracles in San Francisco that prevented far more death, were absent on the mean streets of Chicago and there are no breathless, glamorized national talking heads reporting on it.
Out of the headlines and buried on the back pages is the fact that over the 4th of July holiday, 72 American citizens were shot and 12 of them were killed in one violent city in America: Chicago, which is starting to be renamed Chiraq due to the violence.
President Obama said if only one childs life was saved due to his proposed gun control mandates, then his efforts would be worth it. But his hometown of Chicago is the poster child for strict gun control and has the same or worse statistics for violence as a war torn 3rd world country.
Chicago: The most difficult city in the US for a law abiding citizen to legally own a firearm. Yet criminals rule the streets having gunfights while innocent bystanders get shot in the crossfire.
Chicago: Under one party rule for decades and the epicenter of gun violence. Gun crime so horrendous it skews the nations violence statistics.
Yes the crash of the jet in San Francisco was a tragedy, but in the whole scheme of things, it was an extremely rare occurrence and the loss of life miniscule in comparison to the daily violent meat grinder of violence that the citizens of Chicago must suffer with.
It is time for the media to turn its priorities to what is at the core of this violence in one of our biggest cities. Because taking away guns from law abiding American citizens is not the solution.
Chicago was awash in illegal money and violence after the government declared a war on alcohol during the Prohibition era ..Perhaps it is time to examine who profits from the governments war on drugs and who/what is behind that violence.
Don't laugh at Robert G, BF, he only leaves his quips because he is either unwilling, unable or lacking the character, to answer direct questions that compromise his "thoughts."
By the way, if this discussion was a pond, it would be overrun with ducks - so let me rephrase the question that you boys won't answer:
QUESTION
Would George Zimmerman be able to pass my polygraph test, a test that would be comprised of all the questions that were not answered because
(1) Zimmerman did not take the witness stand, and
(2) Zimmerman had killed the only other eyewitness to the shooting
If you queepy quackers (good one, huh!) need help with this, I will begin posting MY polygraph questions, one-by-one and not the weak ass questions asked by the Sanford Police Department --
And, there's a distinction that isn't being acknowledged my ducky friends ... I'll post that information one more time
Now, I'm going to the gym for my training and later today when I return, I will look for all the answers to my question; I'll tally the results and possibly begin to post the individual questions I'd like Mr. Zimmerman to answer.
So we can get all your quips behind us, my offer to pay a portion of Mr. Zimmerman's legal expenses, be that offer symbolic or actual, is not at all relevant to the actual question and issue.
Trial outcomes and jury verdicts aside, many merely reflect DECISIONS --
AND MANY OF THOSE DECISIONS FAIL TO REFLECT THE TRUTH.
Robert G -- I know the decision -- NOW I WANT TO KNOW THE TRUTH.
There are only two mistakes one can make along the road to truth;
not going all the way, and not starting.
Buddha
A Mac ,
Coming from you that was an especially ironic quote ... based on the prevarications & distractions you have been commenting .
The question is not about whether or not there was blood from Zimmerman wounds, the question is
* If, as Zimmerman contended, his bloody nose was caused by Martin repeatedly punching him (MMA style according to one witness), how is it the blood remained on Zimmerman but somehow disappeared from Martin's hands?
More Questions
* Mr. Zimmerman; you claim that Trayvon Martin was banging your head on the concrete so, you grabbed your gun and shot him.
HOW IS IT THEN THAT MARTIN'S BODY WAS FOUND ON THE GRASS 25 FEET AWAY FROM THE CONCRETE SIDEWALK?
Here's a question for Len who early in this discussion asked me if I thought O.J. Simpson was guilty.
That's a disingenuous way of asking that question, Len. Your question actually is -- DO JURIES MAKE MISTAKES/BAD RULINGS? Now, Len, tell us that you believe the jury that acquitted Simpson did not make a mistake.
Still waiting for votes from the ducks.
You're calling me a liar!
If you're distracted it's because you don't want to address reasonable question to which you know you will not like the answer. Rebut away but call me a liar or imply again that I am one, I will ask you to leave this discussion.
In that case I will need to call you out on each example of BS & distraction when it happens . That is nearly a full time job ... BTW calling you a liar is not the same as saying you lied .
After I turn out the lights, you'll be even more blind.
So, does this mean you still haven't the balls to answer the question?
By the way
Doubling down and playing with words; either point out the lies specifically or don't comment further in this thread.
Get started pointing or get going.
Your style of attacking-the-messenger without giving specifics to justify your attack, then, declaring victory in the debate is what drives members away. It's frustrating to have to respond to a generic allegation that is mostly character assassination or mockery or a quip -- anything but a point-counter-point rebuttal.
Followed by a heartfelt message from Wayne LaPierre and the gutless House Tea Party members who make it possible for those illegally obtained guns to assail the 10,000.
The purveyors of the disease weep for its victims and deposit the blood money into their accounts.
And the religionists, the bigots and those compassionate conservatives enable all those "pro-life" legislators-hypocrites to kill legislation that could save the lives of children (of all races and ethnicities).
There's no hypocrite like a pro-life, pro-gun hypocrite.
Good one, BF!
Communist! You know full well stand your ground only applies to white people!
The outcome of this trial endorses a number of self destructive lessons for society:
- When the police tell you not to do something, go ahead and do it anyways - even if it gets someone killed for no legitimate reason.
- When you take a voluntary position in neighborhood watch for your community, don't worry about the rules of the position, just do it however you want to do it - even if it gets someone killed for no legitimate reason.
- If you are planning on standing your ground, don't make idle threats, make sure that the bulletforever silences the threat, and pray that nobody is watching too closely.
- If a 17 year old boy can kick your grown ass so hard that your only option is to resort to a gun, then you are wasting your time and money on those self defense classes.
- The legal system is not intended to deliver justice, it is simply a game with tons of rules. It's a lot like tax laws,where whoever makes best use of the rules wins the game.
- Most importantly - it's only lying if you get caught. Therefore, feel free to believe and propagate your own stories, since nobody was there to say for sure that you version of events is not accurate.
Frankly , I'm tired of your attempts at producing guilt . You're constantly saying that you are the offended party . You have accused me of talking down to you [when you were in fact being illogical ] and now you refuse to distinguish between being called a liar and being called out on lies . So I'll tell ya what . I've got no particular need for this crap . I am leaving this thread and will not partake of anymore of your bullshit threads in the future . They are a waste of my valuable time .
See ya'.
And as you leave, I remind you once again of your non-specific character assassinations. If you make an allegation, you should be able to satisfy the burden-of-proof that goes with allegations -- you should cite the particulars -- you know -- the same thing you believe the prosecution failed to do in the Zimmerman trial.
Ironic.
Once again, Robert G calls out his straw men, projecting that, like himself, they have no real sympathy or concern for the victims of gun violence, while he, Robert G, cries crocodile tears and lauds the legislator whore/pimps for the NRA -- the enabler of killers of children, the contributors to the right-wing elected shits that foment the unemployment, poverty and despair in the inner cities THAT THEY CREATE AND INSTITUTIONALIZE.
He jests at scars that never felt a wound
And he feigns concern for thousands of dead black men but can't shed a single one for a kid who was just trying to get home but never got there because a man with a loaded gun, a man who had made 46 9-1-1 calls, all to report black kids who he deemed "assholes who always get away" and "fuckin' punks" -- needed to make sure "asshole/fuckin' punk number 47 didn't.
ANSWER MY QUESTION ROBERT G -- I've read your spiel a dozen or more times -- I know your position - YES or NO on the LEGITIMATE POLYGRAPH TEST.
Until you answer
Why should he? First, he's been found not guilty by 4 white women and two Hispanic women. It's only Zimmerman who is called a "White Hispanic". Until this mess, they were called "Hispanic", "Latino" or, collectively, "Brown. Only racists consider this about color.
Oh, now he's a "young MAN" -- although legally he's actually a "child." So look, you wanna' fuck around with words or will you answer the questions?
Are you going to ANSWER MY QUESTIONS OR NOT?
AGAIN: Could Zimmerman get past these questions?
* If, as Zimmerman contended, his bloody nose was caused by Martin repeatedly punching him (MMA style according to one witness), how is it the blood remained on Zimmerman but somehow disappeared from Martin's hands?
More Questions
* Mr. Zimmerman; you claim that Trayvon Martin was banging your head on the concrete so, you grabbed your gun and shot him.
HOW IS IT THEN THAT MARTIN'S BODY WAS FOUND ON THE GRASS 25 FEET AWAY FROM THE CONCRETE SIDEWALK?
Here's a question for Len who early in this discussion asked me if I thought O.J. Simpson was guilty.
That's a disingenuous way of asking that question, Len. Your question actually is -- DO JURIES MAKE MISTAKES/BAD RULINGS? Now, Len, tell us that you believe the jury that acquitted Simpson did not make a mistake.
Still waiting for votes from the ducks.
No one's disputing that. And the only reason Zimmerman's Hispanic "ID" was mentioned was to create an impression, namely that "Zimmerman couldn't be a racist because he's part Hispanic." That's neither accurate nor relevant.
ANSWER THE QUESTIONS -- STOP DUCKING MY QUESTIONS
The TRIAL and THE TRUTH are separate entities. From the only LIVING eyewitness, I want answers.
I believe we got the truth. Two men (yes, 17 is a man in my book) made mistakes. It is sad. it is NOT race related as far as I can tell. I believe the testimony given by the ONLY eyewitness as to the extent of the pounding Zimmerman got. I believe the forensic expert who said the presence of Zimmerman's DNA on Martin would have proven the assault, but the lack of DNA does not disprove the assault. Shot people do not fly back 25 feet upon impact, Hollywood to the contrary, but the can STAGGER 25 feet before falling. And last but not least, being beaten IS grounds for pulling your gun and firing. I guarantee I would have. I ALSO guarantee that if I was 300 yards from my Dad's house and a scary person was following me back when I was 17 and full of piss and vinegar, I would have gone home. Then brought Pop and gone "stalker hunting". Not spent 4 minutes doing whatever, then jumping the stalker.
I think two men made mistakes. I think one paid with his life, and the other will pay for the rest of his life. It's sad. But neither one is guilty of anything but stupidity. Sadly, sometimes stupidity is fatal.
"But let's just ignore that little fact, and concentrate on her race."
Yeah she was sentenced to prison for shooting a warning shot and killing no one, she is black.
And Zimmerman shot an unarmed black teenage boy to death, who btw was minding his own business and committing no crime.
Zimmerman got away with murder, he is white.
Let's see, one white man who had a record of conflicts with the lawn (not admissible in court so the jury never got that info) shoots a black teenager to death and is not convicted of a crime.
And one black woman shoots a warning shot to protect herself from a husband with a record of abusive behaviour; killing no one, and she gets sentenced to twenty years in prison.
Yep you're right race has absolutely nothing to do with any of it.
Racism andwhite supremacy don't exsist in America that's all in the past we are bett..
SURE ... I believe that ..... wink ... wink.
But Zimmerman told the police that Martin said "you got me," "that at first I wasn't sure I hit him," "that he (Zimmerman) spread Martin's arms out to see if he had a weapon - although Martin was found on his stomach with his hands under him," - it's not about whether anyone "believes we got the truth." It's about what exactly IS the truth.
I'm asking if Zimmerman could pass a ploygraph test given the questions I posed -- NONE OF WHICH WERE ANSWERED DURING THE TRIAL BECAUSE
1) Zimmerman did not take the stand and
2) Zimmerman killed the only other eyewitness
THERE'S A REASON I'M GETTING EVERYTHING BUT ANSWERS TO MY QUESTIONS -- and the reason is becoming more and more obvious; most people know that had we answers to the questions I've asked, the verdict may well have been different.
Are you seriously going with (paraphrasing) THE ABSENCE OF EVIDENCE DOES NOT DISPROVE? Really?
Let me rephrase; "The ABSENCE OF EVIDENCE MEANS THERE IS NO PROOF."
Trayvon Martin was tried and convicted of his own murder in part because he was not able to tell the court why there was AN ABSENCE OF EVIDENCE.
Neale, I can't prove you ever committed a crime because I have AN ABSENCE OF EVIDENCE. What if said, "I still think your a criminal BECAUSE "THE ABSENCE OF EVIDENCE DOES NOT DISPROVE" finishing the sentence, it looks like this
Well it's not supposed to work that way but that's the shit deal Trayvon Martin got because of and after the fact that he was killed.
You all know fuckin' well why you've done everything but answer the questions.
I understand your point, really I do. But YOU said the absence of Zimmerman DNA proved martin hadn't hit him. I simply said that while the presence of it would have proven it, the lack of DNA does not disprove it. If this had been an assault case, Marin would not have gotten off for beating Zimmerman solely on no DNA on his hands. That is all I said.
I believe, as I said above, that both men made mistakes that led to the shooting. HOWEVER IT GOT TO THAT POINT, the shooting is not a crime if, as Zimmerman says, he feared for his life or great bodily harm. I honestly believe that if it had been two whites, or two blacks, no one would have given a damn about this case.
I firmly believe that the primary reason ANYONE cares about it is because the media made it into a racist attack. Given Zimmerman's history, I don't see it on his part, Given martin's "Creepy Assed Cracker" comment, I actually do see it on his side. But it's really irrelevant. The media pushed this for two reasons- racism sells, and it had the added effect of being a backdoor way to attack the Florida Stand Your Ground law and CCW in general. Taking it just from the evidence presented, and the testimony given by the one person who saw part of the attack, it actually supports CCW, and has nothing to really do with Stand Your Ground if Martin did, in fact, jump Zimmerman. And yes, I believe he did.
It was and is a sad case. I think that race had almost nothing to do with it (other than Martin's comment) either way. I feel bad for Martin's parents. I feel bad for Zimmerman's family. And the jury acted correctly. There exists reasonable doubt as to the actual events leading up to the shooting. Zimmerman HAD to be acquitted. And the federal government, if it brings up the false civil rights aspect and tries Zimmerman based on it, will lose. Agree with me or not, that's the way I see it.
On a side note- despite the fact I obviously disagree with you, again you are doing your usual excellent job of remaining polite in a tense discussion. My respect will ALWAYS go to you even if my agreement doesn't.
Neale, this case had a fascinating twist; had Martin lived, he'd have been in the legal position to claim "stand your ground status"! And although it is the prosecution that has to satisfy a "burden-of-proof," the trial could have been stood on its head if Martin had been alive to testify that HE WAS DEFENDING HIMSELF UNDER THE FLORIDA "STAND-YOUR-GROUND" Statute.
Zimmerman would claim Martin bloodied his nose and Martin would have claimed, "there was (literally) no blood on my hands."
What I believe I said (I'll check back) was that there was only Zimmerman's word that Martin bloodied his nose and that there was no blood on Martin's hands to evidence that claim. Again, the trial turned upside down.
So, I posit the question because Martin's prosecutors could not prove or disprove how Zimmerman's nose got broken and bloodied. Nor could Zimmerman's defense. The photos show the injuries BUT NOT HOW THEY GOT THERE. The question as to whether or not Zimmerman may have inflicted his own injuries is a valid one because of the absence of "evidence" other than Zimmerman's word.
We'll never know so I ask the question to show that doubts are plausible. And no one answers my question because they know damned well that if they answer, either yes or no, they'll either have made my argument or looked disingenuous.
Had you not written that, I would have; it's good to be able to have a heated debate with a friend and know that it in no way harms the friendship!
Well, I DO have friends who are liberals, don'tcha know?
The burden of proof is on the prosecution, as we both know. They have to prove "beyond a reasonable doubt" the guilt of an defendant. They failed to do so.
On your interesting thesis (Trayvon was standing his ground) I would have to disagree to an extent. Stand your ground does not allow you to attack another man first. If Zimmerman is right that Martin jumped him, then as the aggressor, Marin had no SMG rights. That would be like saying "I was mugging this woman, and she hit me with her purse. So I stood my ground and beat her to the ground." SMG means you do not have to flee an attacker. It does not say you can jump a person you believe MAY attack you. Now, if Zimmerman flashed his gun at Martin before Martin jumped him, and Marin felt he had no choice but to jump him to live, I'd agree with you, But no one I read of said the gun was flashed before the physical altercation took place. and to be honest, if someone flashed a gun at me and I got out of his sight for a second, he'd never see me again. I'd be the one on the phone to 911. Assuming, for the sake of argument, I wasn't armed myself.
But there's no evidence as to who attacked whom first -- only the word of Zimmerman (we've exhausted this).
On the other hand, if Zimmerman stalked Martin and drew his gun without any provocation, then it was Martin entitled to SYG defense.
Or, if he continued to pursue Martin (in the dark of night without probable cause, with no crime in progress and in view of his recorded words in which he ASSUMED the things he assumed about Martin -- "SUSPECT", "ASSHOLE WHO ALWAYS GETS AWAY", FUCKIN' PUNK" --
And if Zimmerman was the aggressor and was thus the attacker?
The only other person who would know that was Martin. Witness John Good changed his testimony.
(Plaxico Burris, NFL player, black man -- shot himself in the leg and was sentenced to two years in prison; Zimmerman walked).
all thats missing is a few lacrosse players!
Yes, there are bad, improper prosecutions, JoAnne. So, is your quip an implication that we should have more in order to balance the injustices from bad facts and bad laws?
Did daddy tell you to chamber the round before the fight and be careful not to shoot yourself in the process?
The problem is that "progressives" like you and Al Sharpton, prejudge any black a victim ipso facto. I suspect you did so before the trial began.
In all fairness many rightists likely judged Zimmerman not guilty before the trial began.
Both sides are wrong. The polarization of our society is shameful and regretful.
But the trial is over and, according to OJ Simpson liberal defense attorney, Prof. Alan Dershowitz (see new seed), bringing the case at all constituted prosecutor malfeasance and a violation of Zimmerman's civil rights.
DOJ cannot bring a case against Zimmerman as that would constitute double jeopardy.
No, actually it isn't double jeopardy. civil rights prosecution is used to get around state laws that don't work. The problem is there IS no civil rights component to this, as the FBI determined over a year ago. Federal charges and state charges for the same crime are not actually double jeopardy according to law. A false law, in my opinion, but law nonetheless.
AGREE!
Not if it's a civil rights case (or a wrongful death civil case).
Oh let's stick around; this case will be "re-tried" in every law school in America and in many other countries as well. So also will the "Stand Your Ground Law" that made the jury's instructions a possible one-way road to acquittal.
We've had the trial, now let's go for the truth and the answers to the questions that, had Martin lived, might have changed everything. Give the dead kid a chance to be vindicated for all those who enabled and/or cheered for him to be convicted of his own murder.
Head wounds tend to bleed profusely, but you knew that. When he went to the doctor to get a release to return to work the medical assistant that treated him said that his wounds were superficial and required little if any treatment. Nice try.
Husband a Lawyer, book deal, do you think Juror #B37 knew the way she had to vote even before she started serving?
The reason for so many "IFs" is directly attributable to the killing by Zimmerman of the only other eyewitness beside Zimmerman himself; and the reason for that is the "Stand Your Ground" statute which encourages "shoot first," "no need to retreat nor try and defuse a tense situation WHICH THE LAW ALMOST ENCOURAGES THE AGGRESSOR TO BE AN AGGRESSOR!"
SYG is an NRA PIECE OF SHIT that has become the sanctioned "religion" of assholes with guns, harbored and overt aggression and hatred. The Zimmerman trial produced a "landmark verdict" one that will likely cause the SYG law to be placed "on trial" -- in principle and in the courts.
Of course those who revere SYG and hate the "hoodies" want the Zimmerman trial to now just fade into the past for fear that BEYOND THE VERDICT WILL EMERGE THE TRUTH! We have in America, the "birthers", the "deathers", the "haters" and now, more than ever, if you haven't met one, you're about to encounter the "truthers."
I'm guessing that Mr. Zimmerman will get a book deal (I believe, because he was found "not guilty", he can profit monetarily from the case), TV/Fox-type time and, that he will embellish and glorify "God's Plan" as he called his killing of Trayvon Martin (Hannity interview). His delusions of faux-law-man grandeur may well cause him to speak the truth in spite of himself, and, if that happens, honest reasonable folk will know with even greater certainty, the system is not only broken, but that it's a cancer that is killing the concept called "America."
Florida Blackscomprise 30% ofthe Stand your ground defense users in Florida. Yet they make up approx. 17% of Florida's population. And that defense is successful 78% of the time. Whites comprise a larger share of uses, but a smaller percentage of SUCCESSFUL uses at 48% successful. The Stand Your Ground defense seems to benefit black Americans more than whites as a percentage. And that is NOT a bad thing, since black-on-black violent crime is, sadly, quite high.