Wal-Mart to DC: Force Us to Raise Wages? We'll Leave!
And why would they have a store within the district if they are not going to be treated in the same manner as other employers?
Anyone who thinks this is fair or a good idea has lost touch with equal treatment, with economic reality and with common sense.
Wal-Mart Stores is butting heads with Washington, D.C., over a city council vote that would require large box retailers to pay employees $12.50 an hour at minimum.
That's more than the local minimum wage of $8.25 an hour, but no matter. A day after Wal-Mart pushed back, threatening to drop plans to build three stores in the nation's capital and reconsider its commitment to three more, D.C. lawmakers approved the bill. If signed by the mayor, the bill would require retailers with more than $1 billion in U.S. annual sales and stores 75,000 square feet or larger to pay a higher minimum wage than that of the city.
Should the minimum wage be raised? Absolutely, should municipalities be able to discriminate against specific businesses to control who can and cannot do business in their confines? Absolutely not!
Why doesn't the District of Columbia raise the minimum wage for all employers to $12.50 if that is what they want the minimum wage to be?
Are they afraid that other businesses would also look elsewhere and relocate?
http://www.cnbc.com/id/100882170
I am fairly sure that Wal-Mart will survive with or without operations in the District of Columbia, the issue is whether these arbitrary, discriminatory and punitive regulations are fair to all businesses and in the best interests of the community

Most everyone hates Wal-Mart and that's okay
But arbitrary regulation that discriminates against individual businesses is neither fair nor prudent.
Wal-Mart pulling out of the District and opening their new stores elsewhere in Maryland and Virginia is the likely outcome of this situation.
I am sure that none of the citizens of the District will drive to the suburbs to shop at Wal-Mart and will faithfully patronize the small shops and stores instead
I dont live there but if I did? I got two words. C YA! And then if other states followed suit, not only would people get a decent wage that didnt land em on welfare to make ends meet, but it opens the door for all those businesses that walmart in all their greed has forced out of our communities because they cannot compete. I say its a win win.
Royal
What is the nature of the "ban"?
Whether you like or dislike WalMart, the act, by the city, council is simply a case of discrimination. How do you explain that they don't raise the minimum wage for a select section of businesses, while at them same time raising the minimum wage for another section of business.
They are simply grandstanding for their voters.
Well I liken it to what the republicans are doing with the womens reproductive movement across the nation. Who says its fair? When does fair have anything to do with anything? Its not fair that workers work for these greedy people and still end up on food stamps to exist either.
And other than that, I stand by my original comment.
But I do get your point.
Teko
Which goes to my point that if that is what the minimum wage should be then the minimum wage should be raised to $12.5o for all businesses not just Wal-Mart
flameaway
Are you saying that bums (people of very modest means) should be forced from our communities?
I'm in the DCarea, and the suburbs here already have plenty of Wal-Marts. DC is filled with long-existing establishments of varying size and scope that would allbe hurt by Wal-Mart. I'm sure they are allcheering Wal-Mart's threats to leave. Wal-Mart is like a disease, and DC is in effect trying to insulate themselves from it.
Gunny
Wal-Mart has indeed changed since Sam's death
But the point of the article is that a single employer should not be discriminate against or held to higher standards than other employers.
If the District of Columbia wants the minimum wage to be $12.50 then it should be $12.50 for all businesses in the district
flameaway
So you favor disparate treatment
Interesting
I live in a very small town, 1,000 population. We have a WalMart about 8 miles from our home. There is very little work in the area, and WalMart does employ a number of people. That is a plus. Wages here are low, so WalMart does pay more than many of the other businesses.
There are always two sides to a argument.
The next closest WalMart is in Branson, appx 25 miles away. The much shorter drive is a blessing for many. It may not seem like much, but driving to the local WalMart vs the one 25 miles away does save them fuel. That is very important when your struggling to stay afloat.
Yes and the average lease on an apartment is $3,000 a month in NYC. Kind of like price fixing, don't you think?
In NYC you would have to have yourself and at least 5 or 6 other employees living in your apartment with you which is the case anyway in many instances these days in NYC. It's a big country and why anyone would think that is living is beyond me.
Now if you make a couple of hundred thousand a year and bring home less than half that after NYC and the Federal government gets through with you, I can see how some can do it.
I would just hate to think that $50 to $60 thousand dollars of my money was being spent on rent before taxes and fees. Oh, I'm sorry fees are taxes now or the other way around, depending on how you want to look at it.
Yes, it's tough down here in North Carolina, but in 4 or 5 years at that rate you could have a fully paid for house that would be a decent place to stay if you didn't live right in the city. And actually you could find the same in the city if you looked around a little.
Gunny
And if we decide where WalMart can be today, what business will we ostracize next?
I get your point just feeling a little sarcastic today
Kavika
YOU present a side of the debate that few people want to hear
Thanks as always for an insightful comment
BadFish
As always thanks for the on point input
BY the way it generated a chuckle
unions gave obama the election, and their power is revealed here as well.
union influence exceeds the influence and money backing of any other group or individual.
union shops dues, basically required in order to advance (or avoid a horsehead) are simply laundering opportunities for their puppets in congress to be re-elected.
unions were behind occupy wall street (remember the turd on the police car, the rapes) unions are no longer entities who wish to improve working conditions, they have not been for a very long time now.
hoffa indirectly called for the murder of people in the tea party when introducing obama during the re-election campaign, using the words "taken out".
unions are joined at the hip with liberal leaders, and the mob. the mob or mafiaare murderers, extortionists, and they profit from heroin peddling as well as human slavery and prostitution.
if we dont start realizing this, unions will destroy this nation.
Kavika....... Exactly. They already had stores in DC. They just made a financial decision. This is just another example of the entitlement society we have created over the last 20 to 30 years.
But over 2000 jobs would have been created. At least even at the minimum wage of $8.25 per hour $33,000,000 would have been paid out to employees by the end of the first year.
And we would hope some would have used Wal-Mart as a means to move up the ladder in society. Unfortunately too many would only work part time, do nothing to improve their lives and remained on government assistance.
That's not Wal-Marts fault or responsibility. It's the individuals responsibility to improve his/her life. There are too many programs to help them under these conditions they could if they would use them to improve their lives. Not Wal-Marts fault.
Hopefully, they wouldn't have to pay for them by the pound Fish.
Gunny,
Having 8 stores within a small area with a limited amount of dollars available shouldn't need to be addressed by government. It's such a bad business decision that the corporation should be able to figure out what will happen all by itself. If you put one store in a central location within that area, you're going to draw in all the available money in the area. If you add 7 more stores, you will be multiplying the fixed cost by a factor of 7, while still drawing in whatever money is available. The revenue will not go up, but the expenditures will.
Here's something for you flame. You have been through tough times in your life. You have come through it and have come out a better person. Now take the next step. Don't get caught up in the mentality of blaming anyone for your situation. You may not like this but it is meant to allow you to look at things a little different.
I also would like to see more American products made in the USA, but anywhere you go and I don't care where it is, look at where the product is made. So Wal-Mart isn't by far the only company selling products made elsewhere.
flameaway
There is a difference between making businesses comply with regulations and setting a minimum wage for some businesses and a different minimum wage for other businesses
That is unequal and unfair
Sixpixk
Very good message
Thanks for sharing
Gunny
There are four WalMarts within a circle of 50 miles and the closest is 22 miles away
Robert, this may be a bit off topic, but I feel compelled to make a couple of points.
First, WalMart products are mostly not manufactured in the U.S. If you go to any large store, K-Mart, Sears, J.C. Penny, Target you'll see that many of their products are made off shore. In fact many are made in the same plants that make WalMart products.
Next, to address Joann statement about ''unions will destroy this nation''..
I worked for 50 years, and was on both sides, union and management, for both small and very large companies. I was a member of Teamsters local 357 and 208 in LA CA.
What I found is, that either side that get's too powerful is a detriment to the other. Both can and will take advantage of the other, and push their agenda no matter the cost.
I don't believe that ''unions will destroy this nation''...It's not the union, it's generally the leadership. The same can be said of the Companies.
The single largest area of conflict when I was in management with the union were the ''work rules''. Wages and benefits did not raise to the top. Work rules did, it seem that no one in favor of unions want to address this. We were required, because of work rules, to have employees that we did not need, simply because union workers were exempt from doing their complete job.
Balance is key, for both labor and the companies.
You are overlooking the probability that 2000+ jobs would have been decimated throughout the impact area due to Wal-Mart's edge in competition. I don't blame DC for resisting the crushing power of such a massive corporation - particularly one that openly and purposely manipulates their policies to avoid having to provide insurance benefits. That is bad news for everyone involved, all for the sake of selling tons of cheap crap made offshore.
Thank you Robert for listening to it. Sadly in our society today with the motivation being "You didn't build that" sort of attitude accepted by so many this will not be viewed by the ones that need to hear it the most. And after so many years of brainwashing (which many are unaware) it will anger them instead of my objective. Sadly true.
I don't think you appreciate the motivation for the Walmart model . It is consumer demand for cheap prices .If Walmart is forced out that doesn't mean there won't be other venues which will appeal to that demand ... small stores which sell cheap Asian imports for example .
You wanna know how easy it isto provethat that speech is bullshit? Just imagine if everyone were to suddenly do as suggested, and allow ourselves to "become what we think about". Nothing - that's what. Nobody would think about working the floor at Wal-Mart,thus ifsuch a simple plan were to actually work then nobody would be working the floor at Wal-Mart- and Wal-Mart would fail, including all the rich Wal-Mart executives. That is no better advice than the hokus pokus crap you can find in the Secret.If you let that garbage influence you too much you might find yourself dying of heatstroke in sweat lodge, under the command of some shyster.
Hal
Good point for not having a Wal Mart at all rather than arbitrarily imposing a minimum wage on Wal Mart that other businesses are not subject to
Mickey, I have to agree with EI on Marina Del Rey.
I lived in Huntington Beach for a number of years. Walmart wanted to build a store there. Of course there was opposition, but in the end it was built, it wasn't a super store. Huntington Beach is an wealthy city, yet the store is doing quite well, andpeople donot to have a problem with it.
Perhaps the ''Peoples Republic of Santa Monica'' should take a second look at it. There are no smiley to insert. So consider I've added a smiley
E I
A little class and civility if you please!!!
A lot of people have explained clearly why they hate Wal Mart and I accept that
A lot of people have simply pouted nonsense and I accept that
But only a couple of actually addressed the issue which is that an arbitrary minimum wage being set for one company and not others is discriminatory and flat out wrong
I try to remain civil on threads that I comment on (though I can be quite sarcastic at times) and ask that everyone remain civil and disagree without being disagreeable
Although there maybe a lot that can be said about Wallmarts practices, there are a lot of people who depend on Wallmart, K-mart and the such. Many families simply have no other place that they can afford to feed their families or clothe them for school. As a kid, I never owned anything but K-mart tennies and jeans and we were thankful for it.
That is very true Larry. Not all can afford to shop at Macys or the like.
Mickey, it didn't destroy any neighborhoods in HB.
BTW, is the Boa man still in Venice? How about Muscle Beach?
Agreed Robert.
Regrettably, I believe you are right about that. I am NOT saying that those presenting arguments here in this discussion believe that, as I am not privy to their thoughts; however, I DO believe that they unwittingly promote that elitism.
You know how kids can be at times, and everybody in school knows poor kids by what they wear. When I was a wee school lad, though we were aware of that stigmatic nasty attitude, we were still happier than punch to get a new pair of Keds from the K-mart...it only happened once a year!
:~)
I have to agree that there might be a level of elitism in this, but I have mixed feelings. This ruling would also affect Costco and the likes, which regular folks shop in. And big lot stores tend to put out of business mom and pop stores.
When I worked in Brooklyn, the neighborhood was poor. The shops catered to their clientele by selling close outs and seconds. It was a win/win for both.
But that would also include Target, Kmart, Costco, Best Buy, Lowes, Home Depot and BJ's, so I don't see this as just going after Walmart. And all these stores do kill mom and pop stores, that actually do become part of a neighborhood and are actually service oriented.
No.
Merely unwitting.
:~)
you've never been in one of those ''places'', you just heard about it, right!!...LMAO
jwc2blue
Only since you want to pick nits,
for one type of business which is still discriminatory and unfair
If a fair, living wage for people working at WalMart is $12.50 then a fair, living wage for someone working at Mary's flower shop is also $12.50
Perrie
Then raise the minimum wage for everyone not selectively
If people cannot see that this is unfair they are just not looking
E I
So ignore her and interact with everyone else who appreciate your commentary
Have to agree with Robert on this. Look at the other end of this stick....If you can say that a business that makes X amount has to pay X amount, what about a business that makes very little at all? Should that business be excused from minimum wage requirements?
By all appearances, you have just instituted a sliding scale forminimum wage.
Hal.... you have provided the example I'm talking about. I don't even have to see or know you to know you.
How true Robert.
Well Mickey, we all grow old. What used to be fun, simply isn't anymore. Old age isn't for wimps.
Some people see the glass half empty and some people see the same glass half full.
Some people see Wal-Mart keeping people on assistance. Some people see Wal-Mart as a stepping stone to a better life.
Some people see Wal-Mart putting other businesses out of business. Some people see other businesses opening all around Wal-Mart because they know the traffic it will bring.
Some people want the tag in the back of their shirts to say lacoste and some are just happy to have a shirt.
Some people will not shop at Wal-Mart because they have a high a opinion of themselves and others aren't concerned with the opinion of others.
Some people see the advantages of having a Wal-Mart close by and some people don't see the advantages of having a Wal-Mart close by.
Some people see the disadvantages of having a Wal-Mart close by and some people don't see the disadvantages of having a Wal-Mart close by.
Some people don't see the revenue and property taxes Wal-Mart pays to the county and some have no idea of what you're talking about.
Some people think Wal-Mart is the only store that sells products that are made in other countries and some people realize almost all products from all stores are made in other countries, including food products.
Some people can afford the best of everything and some people can not. Now I ask you.... Some people are always saying they are for the little man, the poor man and I ask you who are the people here in favor of making sure the little man, the poor man can clothe his family? Isn't it ironic?
Some people can't be satisfied no matter what.
My point [which you seemed to have missed ] is that discriminating against Walmart will not change the underlying reality . There is a demand for cheap goods . There will always be such demand and there will be someone who will satisfy that demand .
Mickey, my doctor told me that I have a bad case of CRS...perhaps you do as well....CRS (can't remember shit)
Time To Be A Bad Liberal Again
The DC City Council is currently debating a living wage bill . Well, sort of. Not the debating part. The living wage bill part. Because the law would only apply to companies with corporate sales over $1 billion and operating spaces over 75,000 square feet. Oh, and a host of companies (Home Depot, Costco, Macys, etc.) will be grandfathered in while those that employ unionized workers will be exempted. Which basically means this bill applies to Wal-Mart and Wal-Mart only. And I really hate that.
So I guess JoAnne's comment wasn't so off topic. Agreed?
I read somewhere on here Costco paid over $20 per hr. I'm sure they do but from the horse's mouth....
In his statement, Jelinek said Costcos starting pay is $11.50 an hour in the United States .
And it's grandfathered in DC and union stores are exempt. But Wal-Mart is expected to jump to $12.50 per hour right away.
...
Joann usually is on topic , this being no exception . Many people don't follow her arguments because of the way she makes connections .
Six, that is the correct starting pay. My brother in law has worked for them for 15 years and is making in the $26 per hour range. That is in the Richmond VA. area. It could be different by region.
Well I have to say I agree with Robert. If it is voted to raise the minimum rate to $12.50 by the state then it should be $12.50 for everyone and that means every business in that state who has employees, not excepts.
To Everyone
Thanks to all for a lively and informative discussion which has touched on the real issue of this "law" as well as a number of other issues, which were interesting and informative for the mostpart
It's the mostpart that I'm thinking about Robert
Thanks for posting a good article.
jwc2blue
No one forces anyone to work at WalMart for shit wages
Your point about "need and desire" and the amount of credit card deb resulting from the latter is an excellent point and the reason that some people get into debt so deep.
Sixpick
Your examples seem to highlight that people make choices and that those choices are different for different people and that people have different perceptions of what is right and wrong, good and bad, important and not important.
Very true
yup and is it costco that already pays 12.50 per hour and offers healthcare package to boot. If they can do it? And according to them? Things work much much better that way and their bottom line has not been effected. Nor do they have a huge turnover in the workforce as a result.
jwc2blue
I stand by the point that no one is forced to work at or shop at Wal Mart
They make choices
Wal Mart exists where it exists because people sho at and work at the stores and as long it is meeting a consumer demand it will continue to exist
I love small mom and pop shops as much as anyone (I livein a small village and patronize many of them) but when I want a power tool I go to Sears, when I want a flat screen I go to Wal Mart or HH Gregg or Best Buy, when I want lumber I go to Home Depot etc etc
The reason best value for my money
And if that makes me a bad person then I guess I am a bad person
By the way, I often see the shop owners form our village at the mall or at the big box stores as well. Curious
flameaway
I do not think your comment is humorous nor do I think it is correct
Low prices have nothing to do with the American Dream and on one (except you) has even made that point
And also the topic (lest we forget) is the unfair treatment of Wal Mart by the District in establishing one minimum wage for some companies and one minimum wage for other companies.
Whether people like or dislike, shop or do not shop at Wal Mart is immaterial to whether it is fair to make disparate treatment under the law the norm in the District.
flameaway
If you support discrimination against individuals or individual companies as being just legislation then I recognize the enemy and it is you
(winks back at fa)
jwc2blue
Have you ever considered that the reason
is because that is what the consumer wants and that the purpose of a business is to supply what the consumer wants
And by the way
most of the jobs in mom and pop shops are paying at or slightly above minimum wage and lots of them do not offer insurance of any kind
I always that that labeling Pres Obama regards food stamps was pretty stupid and I also think that when the consumer no longer demands the products that WalMart sells that WalMart will change its business model or it will go away
flameaway
I understand a lot of things and one of them is that some people make flip, obscureand empty comments with a view more towards humor than an understanding of the issue
And you do at times have a unique perspective but in this case I am not sure that you have made any point at all.
The question, the only question is whether the minimum wage should be the same for all employers?
All the rest of the pro or anti WalMart commentary is deflection from that issue
flameaway
Good that you understand that you are on the wrong side of the issue but a shame that such a cute avatar must be the enemy
Perhaps frenemy is a better choice
flameaway
So you think that the "right side" of the issue is discriminatory wage laws meant to affect only certain employers
Y0u have a strange set of values
Your ability to educate me is highly in doubt, nut your ability to humorously entertain is unquestioned
Folks here is an update on the story with the thoughts of the Deputy Mayor of Washington D.C.
It sounds like reason is being inserted into the process and this bad decision will not become law.
Economists have demonstrated that raising the minimum wage increases unemployment among minorities and teens.
A $15 minimum wage is a terrible idea
By Dylan Matthews, Published: June 22
Excerpts:
David Neumark at UC Irvine and William Wascher of the Federal Reserve Board of Governors concluded in a 2007 review of the literature that a solid majority of studies find that minimum wage increases reduce employment, while very few, if any, provide convincing evidence that it increases employment.
And there are studies from other researchers backing up both Neumark/Wascher and Dube. A recent study from economists at the London School of Economics and the central bank of Turkey found higher minimum wages increased unemployment, while Berkeleys Laura Giuliano found no effects, as does the Center for Economic and Policy Researchs John Schmitt. Its fair to say that this is an empirical question on which labor economists are divided, though Neumark and Waschers literature review suggests that the bulk of the research on the topic points to negative effects on employment.
flameaway
I have offered no logical rebuttals because I likely did not view the "barbed comment" as deserving of a logical response
If you make a logical, relevant comment, I will provide the same in response
It seems that you are more interested in being cool rather than engaging in back and forth relevant debate of a point
It has nothing to do with my learning curve but your lack of ability to teach anyone anything other than how to make comments veiled in innuendo rather than simply debating a point with relevant and cogent comments
As to values, I see that you rather talk about the other person in a debate thread than about the subject of the debate which is sadly typical
I think the time has come to end my participation in this off topic exchange and hope you will do the same but if you must have the last word please go ahead
Len
Good points
I am all for raising the minimum wage so long as it is raised for all employers.
That is inflationary but it might get us to 2% and end quantitative easing.
Intuitively ... as far as I can tell . How about you ?
Don't let the door hit you in the ass on the way out.
Oh, okay - that sounds reasonable. Everyone can have exactly what they want out of like ..... provided that that there are a certain (significant) number of people who want to be a janitor, or who want to work in fast food, or who want to work in a sweatshop. What, you say? Nobody wants those shitty jobs? Well then, it's pretty obvious that a world that doesn't have those occupations is not the wonderful world that we live in today - it would be a world where there is no such thing as clean facilities, or fast food restaurants, oraffordable clothing. Therefore, your philosophy is pure bullshit, since by definition if everyone were to adopt it, then the world would not be clean, convenient or affordable. Clearly you don't know shit. Keep gobbling up that bullshit - the charlatans who push it are depending on your support.
Well ... to be fair I have been accused of linear thinking . I don't think that criticism applies to Joann . ; )
As much as I hate Walmart the targeting of them for special treatment seems wrong to me. Maybe, since Walmart contends that their employees are there of their own free will, we should cut off all government aid to their employees. We'll see how many decide to quit their jobs. This, of course, would apply to all employers as there are others who exploit these loopholes but Walmart is the worst offender by far.
So, instead of targeting Wal-Mart, target the employees of Wal-Mart? I'm sure corporations would love that mentality.
Hal
Or the minimum wage is raised to whatever level that the electorate an their representatives support for all employers rather than targeting a single employer for disparate treatment
M M
It seems the Deputy Mayor disagrees with you
StevieGee
You hit the point and the only reason I posted this article in the first place
All employers should be treated the same
The problem with minimum wage is that the cost of living varies wildly with location, yet all locations have jobs that pay by minimum wage. A coupleminimum wage employeescould afford the share the rentfor an apartment in some Podunk town, but rent in DC is going to be 2-3 times higher than Podunk. Public assistance ends up making up the balance, and Wal-Mart makes tremendous profit by located in densely packed, high rent areas.
Excellent point Hal!!!
Libertarians have this notion that they will personally be better off in an "everybody for themselves" society. Sadly, the only way for them to find out how badly mistaken they are is for the rest of us to go down in flames with them. The more we overwhelm our planet with our numbers and abuse of resources, the more personal self-interest will prevail over compassion.
Hal
Sounds like what is needed is rent control in the district
And that all employers who make a profitin the district should be forced to pay the higher wage if it is to be the law