What Does History Say About U.S. Success in Arming Rebel Movements?
Margaret Warner talks to former Reagan administration official Michael Pillsbury and The Nation's Robert Dreyfuss on what past endeavors by the United States to offer military aid to rebel movements can teach government officials today about providing weapons to the Syrian opposition . - http://www.pbs.org/newshour/bb/world/july-dec13/syria2_07-04.html
One of the reasons I used this specific article is show how low the journalistic standards at PBS have slid. In order to appease the Republican fanatics who want to cut funding to PBS and NPR, they've reduced themselves to asking biased right wing guests innocuous questions and reducing the air-time of important discussions like this so all the viewer gets is inaccurate soundbites.
In this case Michael Pillsbury, who was the assistant undersecretary of defense for policy planning during the Reagan administration (remember IranContra affair) gives the U.S. a weak " Well, it is a mixed record, to say the least " and the host, Margaret Warner, does not even challenge that statement. Poor journalism.
In regards to Syria, they completely and deliberately overlook the fact that the Obama administration has been covertly arming and training Syrian rebels. Another mark of declining journalistic integrity.
Let me put it in another way: We Arm The World .

On the campaign trail, Obama expressed openness to signing the global cluster munitions ban, but he has yet to speak about a global Arms Trade Treaty which would establish more rigorous conditions for weapons exports or about curbing weapons sales, in general.
I'm pretty sure that Obama is no different from former presidents [& most pres candidates] in that regard .
Obama's stated motive for getting us involved in arms to the Syrian rebels was to counter the use of poison gas by Assad . But what intelligence gives him the expectation of the rebels not doing the same once they get into power ? Maybe it is just a game of "whack-a-mole" for the flagrant violators of the Geneva convention by giving aid to their enemies .
I've noticed that most of the people in Internet discussion forms have strong political views-- usually this means either strongly liberal or strongly conservative.
So, in discussing U.S. politics, most have no problem deciding who they feel are the "good guys" and who they feel are "the bad guys". However, often in situations in other parts of the world tey don't know who to root for.
Of course, rather than looking into the facts, many merely blindly parrot whatever Fox News or Rachel Maddow tells them to believe (Which POV they adapt of course depends on their initial political bias).
So, re: the situation in Syria-- for most people , rather than trying to determine the actual facts, the job becomes trying to figure out which side is aligned with their own domestic political bias-- which side in Syria are the "conservatives"-- which side are "the liberals"?Who are "the good guys"? Like a sporting event-- who should I root for-- Assad or the rebels?
Of course most people don't realize that if democratic values and human rights are your criteria, often both sides are "the bad guys"-- as in the case in Syria and many other Arab conflicts. Speicifally in Syria-- which side do you want to "win"-- the side aligned with the Sunni terror group al Qaeda-- or the side aligned with the Shia terror group Hizb'Allah?
Of course most people don't realize that if democratic values and human rights are your criteria, often both sides are "the bad guys"
I suppose the correct approach would be to guesstimate which side has the better chance of adopting democratic values eventually . This is an extremely difficult process ! And there is always the possibility of creating conditions that bring on Armageddon . So maybe the strategy is attempting to avoid the "final battle" . That is also a very difficult process ...
which side do you want to "win"-- the side aligned with the Sunni terror group al Qaeda-- or the side aligned with the Shia terror group Hizb'Allah?
R U tryin' ta confuse me ?? :P
My opinion: neither side would adopt democracy if victorious.
(Heck, we already know Assad's actions-- he's been in power a while. And IMO the rebels will be dominated by their al Qaeda faction-- and al Qaeda's views are known).
IMO most Americans are making an assumption. And that is that one side is "better"-- than one side would institute democracy if they won. But people seem to forget--- this is an Arab country. All countries do not have the same values. And in the Arab world, democratic values clash with the dominent values. (While it might change some time in the distant future...)
There are some 20 or so Arab countries-- does anyone know what 5age of these are democratic? (Take a guess
)
Obama lost all integrity with me. He's not only a massive corporate tool, he's the biggest lying fraud that ever came out of the Democratic party, bar none.....so I don't believe a word he says.
I read an article about the REAL reason the U.S./Obama administration wants to escalate war in Syria;
are we talking about fast and furious?
kidding asside-as the article mentions iran-contra...do any posters know that congress would not ok the funds, so people in reagans admin did an end run, and went to the private sector to fund the operation?
yup, just like sebilius did with the pr push to promote obamacare.
difference: reagans people went to jail, the sebilius story????not even reported in the "news"
in so far as history, initially when the french helped us, many of the muskets didnt work, or the ammo was the wrong size, etc. but, eventually, it worked out.
My opinion: neither side would adopt democracy if victorious.
Given that stance it appears the best strategy would be to attempt to avoid "Armageddon" . Do you have any thoughts on what that would entail ?
There are some 20 or so Arab countries-- does anyone know what 5age of these are democratic? (Take a guess
I'm pretty sure that was supposed to be %age . And I'd guess it would be 0 . So the strategy would be to let each of them kill off the others . Arm the Syrian rebels enough to cause some real damage to Assad's forces .
This is about what was done in the past , for example : playing Iraq against Iran . Bush put an end to that however ...
I think fears of Armageddon are overblown. If there was any chance of all of that happening, it would be the result of a nucear war. And since israel is the only country in the immediate area with nukes, the chances of thatbhappening are close to nil.
What could happen are more local, conventional wars-- for example, as is now going on in Syria. (But that may not happen in Egypt as the army might prevent it. No group in Egypt is any match for the army-- so it probably won't escalate a lot).
Yup. No Arab democracies. There was one once-- but, not surprisingly, it was the only Arab country with a non-Muslim majority (Lebanon used to be a Christian majority country...but it isn't any more).
The Syrian rebels are slowly being armed, but still don't have a lot. Assad and Hezbollah are still more powerful. If the rebels get more arms, this thing could drag on for quite a while.
If one side is much more powerful, they finish off opposition sooner and the conflict de-escalates. However, the rebels are no being armed (by Saudi Arabia and some Gulf states-- so it can drag on for quite a while, and many more will die...
I don't think the U.S. is arming them yet(?)-- Obama is afraid the arms might fall into the al Qaeda faction of the rebel forces (the Saudis and The Gulf states don't seem to et that stop them). Or else he is already arming the more moderate factions of the rebels on the erroneous assumption that those weapons won't reach other rebel forces affiliated with al Qaeda.
What is the alleged reason?
BTW, that graphic doesn't state any reason for his doing that-- it merely show two things the U.S. "could do": Yes we could do: position carriers in the area (which is no big deal-- merely positioning them there is no big dealmif they are merely posioned and not used for combat)-- and we "could" enforce a no-fly zone (my guess is that we won't do that).
Sounds like an improvement! PBS has traditionally been public supported left-wing broadcasting.
The graphic was taken from a BBC article where the author was postulating as to why Obama is so eager to enter into this war on the side of the rebels.
It's quite obvious here that the author is suggesting it is being done for the defense of Israel.