The Hillary Clinton Email Saga: Still No There There
The Hillary Clinton Email Saga: Still No There There
By Kevin Drum
Is Hillary Clinton starting to get into serious trouble over the personal email account she maintained as Secretary of State? Hard to say. So far there's no evidence that she did anything wrong, just a beef between State and CIA over whether some of the emails she sent and received were classified
properly at the time. That may change, but for now that's all we've got.
So why is this getting so much attention? As Steve Benen points out, Clinton isn't the first Secretary of State to use a personal email account:
Politico published this report in March: "Like Hillary Clinton, former Secretary of State Colin Powell also used a personal email account during his tenure at the State Department, an aide confirmed in a statement."....MSNBCs Alex Seitz-Wald added at the time: "....Powell, who served from 2001-2005, apparently did not keep a record of personal emails, unlike Clinton."
As best as I can tell, no one ever cared about the Republican secretary of state using a personal email account. It was, to borrow a phrase, a non-story.
Jeb Bush also used a personal account when he was governor of Florida. And he held onto those emails for seven years before he finally made them public. What's more, it's clear that, like Clinton, he decided which emails to release and which to hold back. "Gov. Bush does not have a plan to release his personal e-mails not related to state business," an aide said in March. That sounds awfully similar to what Clinton has said about her email archive.
I'm not trying to be faux naive here. Nobody cares about Powell because he's not running for president. Nobody cares about Jeb Bush because....actually, I'm not sure why nobody cares about Bush. The governor of Florida doesn't handle classified intel, but if that were the big difference then Powell would be under scrutiny too.
It may turn out at some point that Clinton did something wrong. So far, her only real sin is looking guiltyand I'll confess I don't understand why she's acting that way. All it does is give Republicans ammunition and give the press corps an excuse to treat her the way they used to in the 90s. But as near as I can tell, there's just nothing here, which is why I haven't bothered writing about it. Aside from the obvious political motivations (for Republicans) and personal animus (among the press), is there any reason this is getting such big play? What am I missing?
Tags
Who is online
87 visitors

When the shoe was on the other foot
08/12/15 10:30 AMUpdated 08/12/15 10:40 AM
Steve Benen
"The story surrounding Hillary Clintons emails can get a little confusing, and some of the mistaken reporting from major news outlets hasnt helped. But officials are still in the process of examining how the State Department handled sensitive information.
With that in mind, the Washington Post reports that Clinton will provide the FBI with the private server she used for email during her tenure as secretary of state, as well as the thumb drive with emails Clinton already provided to the State Department.
Theres still nothing to suggest the Democratic presidential hopeful actually did anything wrong, but the Washington Posts Chris Cillizza is suspicious. Democrats, ask yourself this, Cillizza said this morning on Twitter. If this was a former [Republican Secretary of State] and his/her private e-mail server, would it be a non-story?
As a rule, I think thats a smart way for political observers to look at every story. If the situations were reversed, how would you react to a controversy?
The problem in this case is that Cillizza isnt necessarily pointing to a hypothetical. Politico published this report in March: Like Hillary Clinton, former Secretary of State Colin Powell also used a personal email account during his tenure at the State Department, an aide confirmed in a statement.
MSNBCs Alex Seitz-Wald added at the time:
Colin Powell, George W. Bushs first secretary of state, wrote in his memoir about how outdated technology infrastructure at the State Department led him to install a personal laptop in his office to use a personal email account to shoo[t] emails to my principal assistants, to individual ambassadors, and increasingly to my foreign-minister colleagues.
Powell, who served from 2001-2005, apparently did not keep a record of personal emails, unlike Clinton.
As best as I can tell, no one ever cared about the Republican secretary of state using a personal email account. It was, to borrow a phrase, a non-story.
Clearly, Republicans and some of Clintons media critics see an opportunity here. Louisiana Gov. Bobby Jindal (R), still hoping for some modicum of attention, has even begun telling people that Clinton might go to jail. I havent seen anything to suggest Clinton is guilty of any wrongdoing at all, but the probe is apparently still ongoing and well see if anything of interest turns up.
But to suggest Democrats would pounce if the shoe were on the other foot doesnt appear to be true. We already know how Dems would respond to a Republican secretary of state using a private email account: with indifference."
he governor of Florida doesn't handle classified intel,
You think that's important? Good lord.
Explaining away felonies by making a completely insane comparison. You can't make this shit up.
IS there any evidence that Colin Powell mishandled Top Secret material?
Until there is, the comparison is meaningless.
You imbibe too much right wing nonsense. It is your total downfall.
As you post from Kevin Drum and Rachael Maddow....
People who are interested in this topic REALLY need to read this
Media are exploiting news that two emails Democratic presidential candidate Hillary Clinton turned over to the State Department from her time as secretary of state may be retroactively classified as "top secret" to push myths about Clinton's handling of government information and scandalize her email use. Here are the facts.
FACT: None Of The Emails Sent To Clinton Were Labeled As "Classifie... "
FACT: Emails Originated In State Dept. System, And Questions About ...
FACT: Experts Have Debunked Any Comparison Between Clinton's Email ...
FACT: IG Referral To Justice Department Was Not Criminal, And FBI I...
Intelligence Community IG Says Two Emails From Clinton's Server Should Be Marked "Top Secret"
Intelligence Community Inspector General Says Two Emails From Clinton's Server Contain "Top Secret" Information . The inspector general for the Intelligence Community (ICIG), I. Charles McCullough, reportedly informed leaders of key congressional oversight committees that two classified emails previously discovered on Clinton's server contain top secret information. As McClatchy reported:
State Department: It Remains Unclear Whether Material In Two Emails Should Be Retroactively Classified. NBC noted that the State Department is still working with the intelligence community to determine whether the information in the two emails should in fact be labeled as classified:
MYTH: Clinton Received Emails Marked As "Top Secret"
Fox Anchor Bret Baier: "'Top Secret' Was Marked On The Emails" Sent To Clinton. During the August 11 edition of Special Report , host Bret Baier claimed that "'top secret' was marked on the emails" that Clinton received during her time as secretary of state:
NBC's Andrea Mitchell: ICIG "Contradicted Clinton's Repeated Claim That Nothing On Those Private Emails Was Classified." On the August 12 edition of NBC's Today , Andrea Mitchell argued that the ICIG's statement "contradicted" Clinton's "repeated past denials":
FACT: None Of The Emails Sent To Clinton Were Labeled As "Classified" Or "Top Secret"
Government Officials: None Of The Emails Were Marked As "Classified"When They Were Sent. The Washington Post reported that when the ICIG first "found information that should have been designated as classified" in four emails from Clinton's server -- two of which he now says contain "top secret" information -- government officials acknowledged that the emails were not marked as classified when they were sent (emphasis added):
IG Memo On Classified Information In Emails: "None Of The Emails ... Had Classification Or Dissemination Markings." A memo from the ICIG clearly stated that "none of the emails we reviewed had classification or dissemination markings":
MYTH: Emails Weren't Marked As "Classified"Because Clinton Used A Private Server Instead Of State Dept. Email
Fox & Friends ' Steve Doocy: Emails "Were Never Classified" Because Clinton Used A Private Server Rather Than The State Department's Email System. Throughout the August 12 edition of Fox & Friends , co-host Steve Doocy repeatedly blamed the lack of classification on Clinton's use of a private server instead of "the State Department email system," arguing the emails "were never classified because she never submitted it" (emphasis added):
FACT: Emails Originated In State Dept. System And Questions About Retroactive Classification Would Have Occurred Regardless Of Clinton's Server Use
Emails Originated With State Department Employees And Were Forwarded To Clinton. The State Department's statement on the retroactive "top secret" designation made clear that the emails at issue originated with State Department employees, not Clinton herself:
Clinton Campaign: Emails Originated From "Unclassified .Gov Email System." A fact sheet released by the presidential campaign for the former secretary of state explains that the emails at issue originated on "the unclassified .gov email system":
Vox: Whether Or Not Emails Should Have Been Marked Classified Is Part Of "Bureaucratic Turf War." Vox pointed out how the intra-agency disagreement over whether the emails were appropriately categorized "is a bureaucratic fight about how the State Department has handled the emails, not about Hillary Clinton" (emphasis added):
MYTH: Hillary Clinton's Email Use Is Comparable To David Petraeus' Crimes
Doocy: Clinton's Email Use Is "The Same Thing That David Petraeus Pleaded Guilty To." On the August 12 edition of Fox News' Fox & Friends , Doocy hyped the debunked claim that Clinton's email use was similar to Gen. David Petraeus' illegal mishandling of confidential information:
Fox Judicial Analyst Implies Clinton's Email Use Is Worse Than Petraeus' Crimes. Appearing on the August 12 edition of Fox & Friends , senior judicial analyst Andrew Napolitano claimed "it's a grave situation" for Hillary Clinton, arguing that Gen. Petraeus only had "the lowest level materials in a desk drawer" while Clinton "had top secret materials in the server in her barn":
FACT: Experts Have Debunked The Comparison -- Petraeus Knowingly Mishandled Classified Documents, Whereas Clinton Had Authorization To Use Private Email, And There's No Evidence She Knowingly Emailed Classified Information
Petraeus Pled Guilty To Violating 18 U.S.C. 1924, "Unlawfully And Knowingly" Moving Classified Materials "With Intent To Retain Such Documents ... At Unauthorized Locations." Petraeus pled guilty to one count of violating Title 18, United States Code, Section 1924:
NY Times : "There Has Never Been Any Legal Prohibition Against" Using Personal Email Accounts. Despite having previously scandalized Clinton's use of private emails as "alarming," the Times later clarified that "there has never been any legal prohibition" against the practice and that "[m]embers of President Obama's cabinet" use a "wide variety of strategies" to handle their emails:
State Dept: Clinton Preserved And Provided Emails In Line With 2009 Regulation And How We Handled Records At The Time. At theMarch 3daily press briefing, State Department deputy spokesperson Marie Harf explained that Clinton turned over 55,000 pages of documents as part of the State Department's "process of updating our records management" and emphasized that Clinton is the only former secretary of state to have done so. From Harf's briefing:
Clinton: "I Am Confident That I Never Sent Or Received Any Information That Was Classified At The Time." Clinton told reporters on July 26 that she never sent or received information that she knew was classified at the time:
Director Of Project On Government Secrecy: "There's No Comparison Between The Clinton Email Issue And The Petraeus Case." Steven Aftergood told The Washington Times that "[e]veryone agrees that there was no information in the Clinton emails that was marked as classified," and therefore Clinton's actions bear no resemblance to Petraeus's:
Government Secrecy Expert: "There's No Case" Against Clinton If She Didn't Knowingly Misuse Classified Information. William Jeffress, an attorney who has handled government secrecy cases, told Time :
MYTH: Clinton Is The Subject Of A Federal Criminal Investigation
Fox's Chris Stirewalt: Clinton Might Be "The Subject Of A Federal Criminal Investigation." On the August 12 edition of Fox News' America's Newsroom , digital editor Chris Stirewalt claimed that Clinton might become "the first major party nominee that is the subject of a federal criminalinvestigation." [Fox News, America's Newsroom , 8/12/15 ]
FACT: IG Referral To Justice Department Was Not Criminal, And FBI Isn't Targeting Clinton Herself
Reuters: Inspector General Referral Is Not Criminal. Reuters reported on July 24 that there was "no criminal referral over [the] Clinton emails":
AP: U.S. Official Said That Request Of DOJ "Doesn't Suggest Wrongdoing By Clinton Herself." The Associated Press quoted an anonymous U.S. official who noted that the referral did not implicate Clinton in any wrongdoing:
Wash. Post : Officials Say Clinton "Is Not A Target" Of FBI Probe. The Washington Post reported that government officials said Clinton is "not a target" of the FBI's investigation:
This material makes it pretty clear that the media is being very irresponsible in their reporting of this story, particularly Fox News, of course.
The emails do not appear to have been classified Top Secret when Mrs. Clinton received them. If she forwarded them, it was under the belief they were not classified material.
That appears to be the bottom line. The Media Matters article is a revelation to those who have only casually followed this story.
"Two Inspectors General have confirmed that the material in the four e-mails found in a sample of 40 they were allowed to inspect was classified at the time it was transmitted through Hillary Clintons e-mail system . The datawas classified when they were sent and are classified now , according to their referral, and now they have confirmed that at least two of the four contained data that was classified TS/compartmented at that time."
Keep peddling lies Media Matters, it's what you do best.
This is a big deal. Unlike previous republicanfaux scandals like Benghazi, this is an actual thingie. Just like republican lies repeated over and over again do not make something true, democrat denials over and over again do not make something false. There is a there there (typing that sentence strained my spleen). Unless all the major media (including those not named FOX) are part of some vast right-wing conspiracy, Hillary better be worried.
GO BERNIE!
People who are interested in this topic REALLY need to read this
...
Media are exploiting news that two emails Democratic presidential candidate Hillary Clinton turned over to the State Department from her time as secretary of state may be retroactively classified as "top secret" to push myths about Clinton's handling of government information and scandalize her email use. Here are the facts.
FACT: None Of The Emails Sent To Clinton Were Labeled As "Classifie... "
FACT: Emails Originated In State Dept. System, And Questions About ...
FACT: Experts Have Debunked Any Comparison Between Clinton's Email ...
FACT: IG Referral To Justice Department Was Not Criminal, And FBI I...
What he said! There really is no there, there and there never was.
Sean, get a grip on yourself.
This is from your linked Hot Air story
"The datawas classified when they were sent and are classified now , according to their referral, and now they have confirmed that at least two of the four contained data that was classified TS/compartmented at that time. If it wasnt marked, it clearly should have been."
Number one, if the material was not marked as classified WHEN it was sent to Clinton, from the State Dept. e-mail system, what did SHE do wrong ?
Number two, the Media Matters material makes it clear that the "classified" nature of the material has been in dispute between the State Dept. and the intelligence community. That being the case, it is simple to see why the State Dept. did not consider the sent material classified Top Secret.
The clowns at Fox blew the thing all out of proportion yesterday and today, as is their usual procedure.
Bernie's going to strike out and Biden's warming up in the bullpen.
I read all the Media Matter material (somewhat lengthy), and frankly, it explains a lot of the confusion and misrepresentations we have seen in the media.
Glenn Greenwald points out her hypocrisy:
"When it comes to low-level government employees with no power, the Obama administration has purposely prosecuted them as harshly as possibleto the point of vindictiveness: It has notoriously prosecuted more individuals under the Espionage Act of 1917 for improperly handling classified information than all previous administrations combined.
NSA whistleblower Tom Drake, for instance, faced years in prison, and ultimately had his career destroyed, based on the Obama DOJs claims that he mishandled classified information (it included information that was not formally classified at the time but was retroactively decreed to be such). Less than two weeks ago, a Naval reservist was convicted and sentenced for mishandling classified military materials despite no evidence he intended to distribute them. Last year, a Naval officer was convicted of mishandling classified information also in the absence of any intent to distribute it.
In the light of these newClinton revelations, the very same people who spent years justifying this obsessive assault are now scampering for reasons why a huge exception should be made for the Democratic Party front-runner. Fascinatingly, one of the most vocal defenders of this Obama DOJ record of persecution has been Hillary Clinton herself.
Manning was convicted and sentenced to 35 years in prison. At the time, the only thing Hillary Clinton had to say about that was to issue a sermon about how classified information deserves to be protected and we will continue to take necessary steps to do so because it affect[s] the security of individuals and relationships."
Two inspector generals confirm that the material was classified at the time it was sent. The independently operating inspector generals don't work for Fox, much as you wish it were true.
To quote Hot Air:"Security clearances put the burden of verifying classification status on those transmitting and receiving it. As the highest ranking official at State, Hillary Clinton was responsible for ensuring the security and proper handling of that data. The reason it got transmitted in an unsecured manner is because she and her team set up a covert system to subvert Congressional oversight and thwart the Federal Records Act, which purposefully or not resulted in the unauthorized retention of classified material at her home, an unauthorized and improperly secured location for TS/compartmented data."
She set up a system to avoid proper classification of documents. She'd be going to jail if she wasn't a Democrat leader/
Doesn't do a thing to make the case that Clinton knew at the time that she handled these e-mails that they were supposed to be classified or classified top secret.
The media and particularly the right wing media seems to be witch hunting this woman because of her last name.