╌>

U.S. Intellectuals' Comfortable Self-Imposed Myopia

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  paul  •  13 years ago  •  20 comments

U.S. Intellectuals' Comfortable Self-Imposed Myopia

American Intellectuals' Widespread Failure to Stand Up to Billionaires and Authoritarian Power

Ideally, we pay intellectuals to help us deepen our understanding of how the world works, toward the goal of shaping a world more consistent with our moral and political principles, and our collective self-interest. What are the forces that keep people, especially relatively privileged people, mute in the face of such a clear need for critical intellectual work? The first, and easiest, answer is individual self-interestthe status and economic rewards that come to intellectuals who serve power. Upton Sinclair put it most succinctly: It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends upon his not understanding it.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Tex Stankley
Freshman Silent
link   Tex Stankley    13 years ago

Interesting article. No big surprises within though. Folks are apparently to lilly livered to bite the hand that feeds them.

6406_discussions.jpg?width=721

 
 
 
Paul
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Paul    13 years ago

Tex, welcome, and thank you for taking the time to read and comment on the excerpt/article.

No big surprises within though.

Chucklechortle...... I must agree. What I found interesting was how Jensen explains the process by which an unjust system is rationalized as natural, and therefore a "done deal".......

One of the most persuasive arguments for systems of domination and subordination is that they are natural.

So, oppressive systems work hard to make it appear that the hierarchy -- and the disparity in power and resources that flow from hierarchy -- is natural and, therefore, beyond modification. If white people are naturally smarter and more virtuous than people of color, then white supremacy is inevitable and justifiable. If men are naturally stronger and more capable of leadership than women, then patriarchy is inevitable and justifiable. If rich people are naturally clearer-thinking and harder-working than poor people, then economic inequality is inevitable and justifiable. If the strong are, well, stronger than the weak, then the strong will rule.

As John Stuart Mill noted in his argument for womens rights, [W]as there ever any domination which did not appear natural to those who possessed it? For unjust hierarchies, and the illegitimate authority that is exercised in them, maintaining their naturalness is essential. Not surprisingly, people in the dominant class exercising the power gravitate easily to such a view. And because of their power to control key intellectual institutions (especially education and mass communication), those in the dominant class can fashion a story about the world that leads some portion of the people in the subordinated class to internalize the ideology. A social order that violates almost everyones basic principles is transformed into a natural order that cannot be changed.

Natural? My Ass! Every unjust socio-economic construct is the result of not-so-deep thinkers who believe themselves to be deep thinkers playing their empty ego-drenched stupid little master of the universe games. 45.gif

One more thing.......Twain Rocks

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

For starters, one of the first thing the author does is tie "intellectualism" to schooling and wealth. Reality is that intellectuals come from all walks of life. The author frames his opinion around the canard that only rich and famous intellectuals alone, are the ones who can cause change.

Whatever.

 
 
 
Paul
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Paul    13 years ago

AeonPax, this from the excerpt might help you change your mind about condemning the entirety...

This analysis focuses on those doing intellectual work with the most privilege and the most autonomy.

 
 
 
Tex Stankley
Freshman Silent
link   Tex Stankley    13 years ago

"Natural" in the sense above is basically whatever the ruling class finds expedient to be so. Slavery was once promoted as the "natural" order of things just as wage slavery is in our Modern Stress Monkey Society today.

In my somewhat addled hipbilly opine, I do believe we are in the early stages of a serious class war that the poor cannot win. We shall see though. Things might get downright sporty here in the coming decades.

It seems to me that the intelligentsia that is suckled on the teat of unfettered capitalism find it in their best interest to extol and support that sumptuous teat.

As far as the auto didactics and non supported intellectuals, until they educate, organize and agitiate the herd, things will just keep on bum bum bumming along as they are.

Hey, but whadda I know? And, indeed, Twain Rocks. He is the spiritual Grand Pappy of Hunter S Thompson as far as I am concerned.

"If, in the present chaotic and shameful struggle for existence, when organized society offers a premium on greed, cruelty, and deceit, men can be found who stand aloof and almost alone in their determination to work for good rather than gold, who suffer want and persecution rather than desert principle, who can bravely walk to the scaffold for the good they can do humanity, what may we expect from men when freed from the grinding necessity of selling the better part of themselves for bread?" Lucy Parsons

 
 
 
Paul
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Paul    13 years ago

Hey, but whadda I know?

Tex, you can't pull the wool over my eyes.78.gif

 
 
 
Tex Stankley
Freshman Silent
link   Tex Stankley    13 years ago

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

This is a long article, and I hope to finish it. Thank you for the email.

I like the paragraph you highlighted, especially the last statement by Upton Sinclair. There would seem to be a lot of truth in that; there must have been/be a thread of ruthlessness that runs deep in the legacies of the Rothschild and Rockefeller families, self-interest being their motivation. Yet, as the next paragraph states:

I suspect that a desire to be accepted by peers is at least as powerful a motivation for intellectuals to accept the status quo. Humans are social animals who generally seek a safe and secure place in a social group, and theres no reason intellectuals would be different. Even when concentrated wealth and power do not threaten people with serious punishments, the desire to be a well-regarded member of an intellectual community is a powerful conformity-inducer. When ones professional cohort works within the worldview that the wealthy and powerful construct, the boundaries of that world seem appropriate. Curiosity about what lies beyond those boundaries tends to atrophy.

I think what I bolded, the need to be highly regarded and respected, would be the biggest motivation to those individuals in not standing up for the better ideals that fly in the face of disparity and social injustice. Their probable associations with the Skull and Bones, Freemasons, Bilderbergers, Trilateral Commission, etc. would seem to dictate their behavior as well as use of their intellectualism in their privileged status; "the boundaries of that world seem appropriate" for them, as well as 'thinking' outside of those boundaries would likely land them outside of that realm. In that light, they would be expected to stay within their Global elite network that serves their goals of continued power and immortal legacies.

That's my immediate thought from what I've read so far.

 
 
 
Paul
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Paul    13 years ago

But now the struggle for wealth has fewer frontiers; you have to be an enormous player to even sit at the real table; so wealth is doing away with that bit of bakeesh they offered to the 'middle' class. They can't afford it anymore; the game is too tight.

Alas, it does appear to be as you have pointed out. Things are getting a tad (understatement) compressed.

 
 
 
Paul
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Paul    13 years ago

Good insight, Chloe. I would extrapolate your insight to claim that if an intellectual, who once proffered new and sharp thinking, settles into a pattern of paraphrasing, parroting and rehashing the same old, unseemly and discredited rationalizations of domination and subordination, he/she forfeits their standing as an intellectual.

In my opinion, social, political and economic intellectualism cannot stand alone, as an abstraction, separate from the humanity it should serve. An intellectual who diverges from serving the common good is but a empty talking head.

 
 
 
Tex Stankley
Freshman Silent
link   Tex Stankley    13 years ago

I agree with you totally.

Though we have indeed been engaged in class war from our countries birth, the last 40 years has been an assault from the top down. The working class has done little but bear up to our bewildered best and politely lean over for the boning. The last deadly serious fight came about with the turn of the 19th century labor movement.

What I am saying is that we are on the cusp of perhaps looking like Greece or Egypt in the coming decades. It is starting to get bad enough for the bottom to push back. We shall see though. Americans are not prone to resistance, or even getting up off the couch, while engaged in the watching of their whale sized TV sets as long as there is another cold one in the fridge.

I'm not holding my breathe, so's to speak, but it is not beyond imagination for such a future to unfold. It's what we need.

6407_discussions.gif

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

It's easy to see how the Hierarchy justifies its lack of compassion to improve social conditions when they have so much support from their own groups and organizations, and more significantly, pressure to conform in their own world.

They would seem to possess what the article views as necessary for a society - dignity, solidarity and commitment - but for themselves in their own society. I don't think it's ethical, especially when we consider how they achieved their legacies; so, no I don't justify or excuse their intellectualism, but I do understand it - why they do what they do. "General welfare" to them - means for their own general welfare, not that of nations.

(Just to note, I have spent a lot of time reading authors on the vine that have cynicism for the Hierarchy, so my attitude is biased as a result-lol-not out of jealousy, but out of principle. It looks like most of us here have similar views.)

The problem appears to be that they use those principles to further their own investments, maintaining their control and hierarchical status, with too many of us only seeing the 'need' for those changes, but might refuse to see who is actually benefiting from those changes, while continuing on with the destruction. I'm referring to issues such as Climate Change and Carbon Tax; Sustainability - plans financed and planned by Globalists for profit; Data Centers - in the name of "security" (which is said to have helped), but might actually be a very lucrative enterprise of selling sensitive political/government/leader secrets to the right bidder. And now, technological advancements in industry/manufacturing that will continue to decrease the needs for human labor, unions, lowering wages - even at the top with demand being high, but fewer positions being available. But, the Hierarchy will not only gain wealth from it all...more importantly, they will gain further control of our lives.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

It doesn't change my mind but prove that the report is flawed.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

Maybe I took a wrong interpretation of the article, but I thought they were referring to the hierarchical Intellectuals, rather than say those in general society, government leaders, the technocrats, et al.

 
 
 
Steve Ott
Professor Silent
link   Steve Ott    13 years ago

For starters, tell me why it is we leave the thinking to people paid to do it?

 
 
 
Paul
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Paul    13 years ago

We're not leavin' it to 'em, not by any stretch, but some of 'em get paid to do it, and Jensen is callin' 'em out for bein' conformist chicken-shits.

 
 
 
Steve Ott
Professor Silent
link   Steve Ott    13 years ago

Yes, the question was at least half rhetorical. For as long as I can remember, I have told people that I don't want to know something, I want to know everything.

Now I know that is impossible. One person cannot know everything. However,I do believe a person can know enough about many things to be able to make informed decisions. I simply am unable to understand why "people" in general are willing to let others do the thinking, be it Fox News, NBC or David Letterman.

 
 
 
Paul
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Paul    13 years ago

I simply am unable to understand why "people" in general are willing to let others do the thinking

Steve, in a general sense, give me information, and I'll do the thinking.....on it. 39.gif

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

If the article does indeed only include a narrow grouping of of certain Americans, then it cannot be applied to ALL Americans. In that respect, it would be flawed.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

APax, You're right!! The title says "US Intellectuals" -- standing up to Billionaires.

I went down the Global Elite path, rather than just Americans, in my own mind, discussing why they don't stand up to those that control their groups/organizations. My mistake. Thanks for getting me to see that. Smile.gif

 
 

Who is online







102 visitors