Jobs Report Underestimates Underemployed - Growth is Happening in the Wrong Places
The markets upbeat reaction to Fridays tiny improvement in unemployment suggests that this is an economy on the mend.
The reality is far less sunny.
In fact, low-paying jobs that are being created will keep the recovery moving at a snails pace and will be a drag on wages for some time to come.
Quality matters as much if not more than quantity, and the quality of jobs we are generating is abysmal , says Diane Swonk, chief economist at Mesirow Financial.
In June, the Labor Dept. reported that nonfarm payrolls rose by 195,000, ahead of expectations. The unemployment rate held steady at 7.6%, failing to dip a hair as economists had predicted to 7.5%.
People working part time, referred to as involuntary part-time workers because their hours had been cut or they were unable to find full-time work, rose by 322,000 to 8.2 million .
That reflects a disturbing trend in this recovery that the recent job growth has come in sectors that tend to be low-paying, such as leisure, retail and hospitality, and in temporary work.
At 7.6%, the rate of joblessness is a striking improvement from the 10% rate of four years ago, but it is still uncomfortably higher than the average 6% unemployment rate for the 24 years before the recession started .
However, those numbers dont tell the real story of what the government refers to as labor underutilization. That measures unemployment at a jaw-dropping unadjusted 14.6%, which includes people jobless for 15 weeks or longer as well as those considered discouraged because they cant find jobs and have given up and those working part-time jobs because thats all they could find, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics.
Temporary work has accounted for roughly 25% of net employment gains since the recession ended, and is approaching a new record.
Lets not kid ourselves, says Gary Burtless, a senior fellow of economic studies at the Brooking Institute, all these indicators of labor market hardship suggest the job market is slowly recovering(and) were still a long way from full employment.
Of course, none of these indicators tells us the number of full-time or part-time workers who hold jobs in occupations that are far below their occupational and educational qualifications levels, he adds.
Certainly, the pace of recovery in employment has improved, but its important to look at the types of jobs that are being created because those jobs will directly affect the fortunes and challenges of households and neighborhoods as well as the course of the recovery, she added.
Also worrisome is that this drop in wages will not be recovered and could lead to a bevy of social issues that hamper economic growth for generations to come.
http://www.marketwatch.com/story/jobs-report-underestimates-underemployed-2013-07-05?pagenumber=1
Tags
Who is online
102 visitors

The jobs report was certainly a bit of good news and the markets, the media and many citizen reacted enthusiastically.
But, .....
As my friend Einsteinian Insanity has told us many times things are stagnant and will not get better until we start to see some real, sustainable growth in the economy.
Judging by where the many of the jobs of late are being created, the number of them that are temporary positions and the number of them that are "low paying" jobs perhaps we should temper our enthusiasm.
E I
Agreed but that is pretty much true of the majority of the "statistics" that are used to portray the employment and unemployment situation in the country which is why month after month not only are they questionably accurate but the previous month's and quarter's are continually revised up or down for no real apparent reason
E I
I am not sure that "over employed" is a realistic thing to measure
I know a lot of folks (especially in sales) that have made north of $200K total compensation on an annual basis without the benefit of a college degree and earned and were worth every penny.
A college degree is not a measurement of what one's salary should be, but rather the value an employee adds to an enterprise and how hard it would be to replace the employee's contribution should be the measure of the salary he/she receives
E I
Thanks for the feedback
IN my view the difference between underemployment and overemployment (if either really exist) is that underemployment is normally contrary to the desires, qualifications and needs of the individual while over employment is more normally an individual who has achieved a position through experience and innate skills rather simply based on education.
I still say (and you did not refute) that
offshoring jobs increases a company's flexibility
In what way ? Please expand on that ...
E I
I m not sure I totally agree with
If you were to say "outsourcing" rather than offshoring then I would agree 100% as I think outsourcing can be beneficial to the flexibility of the larger company without taking jobs out of the country and it allows for smaller, specialty companies to provide services or goods (and jobs)
E I
You and I agree on the "Walmart" issue and you stated it very clearly so that anyone should be able to understand
E I
As to "growth in the wrong places", I took that to mean that the author felt that if the majority of jobs were created as low paying jobs, temporary positions or in the fast food or other low paying service industry positions that real economic growth would not result.
At least that is what I gleaned from the article
E I
Absolutely agree and I think you will agree that a "new" middle class production base in the U.S. utilizing all technological advantages is how that will be done because the "blue collar factory jobs that have faded away are not likely to come back in large numbers
Again I agree and in addition to steadily increasing income more stable and only gradually decreasing labor participation rate is also important in supporting the social support network in the U.S.
I agree that Europe is in worse shape than the U.S in this regard but that is small comfort when considering the problems we must overcome
As always thanks for the feedback
I can't offshore to my own company in China, because I can't actually own a company in China
Good information . Not to be a pest but that would be an example of less flexibility [even if the other factors increase flexibility ] .
E I
What you say is true but I still contend that the most flexible solution for companies, that best serves the company, the American work force and the U.S. economy is outsourcing rather than offshoring.
You are correct that changes to labor laws, as well as corporate taxes and regulations, need to be made to make this the option that companies choose.
The U.S> economy has and in my view always will be best when it is producing goods rather than being mainly a service economy.
E I
True is some cases I am sure
But in my view if all things were equal (from a financial standpoint) most companies would prefer to have their production in Texas or Illinois than in Thailand or China.
E I
Well you have clearly explained and stated the obvious
I said "if" to make the point that we need to do those things to make all things equal enabling the companies o choose to outsource but not offshore
E I
But to not consider and talk about those options is to give up and I am not ready to give up
OK , your knowledgeable focus on bottom line considerations is clearing the fog of confusion ...
Well things AREN'T equal, that is again the problem. The tax system in the US right now is skewed a certain way, the economic structure is skewed a certain way, and if your competitor is offshoring, then guess what, you are more than likely also going to have to offshore in order to survive.
....
but nobody seems interested in listening, or more importantly, acting on it.
Hmmm ... thinking back to the election last year it seems to me that those were the issues Romney was bringing up .
OK , I'll give you the capital gains issue but he was talking about reforming the rest of the tax code especially in Re to China .
Let me know if I'm off topic here but as far as the Temp situations goes, these is a journalistic investigation that was done on an aspect the temporary staffing industry, by Pro Publica . The article is worth a read, titled: The Expendables: How the Temps Who Power Corporate Giants Are Getti... .
Once again, the Corporations are attacking the middle class and working poor. In corporation eyes, a temp (actually any human) is a disposable commodity . Corporations claim the way an employee gets treated, " is just business ".
The corporations, by law, are amoral constructs. Perhaps, but what they do is immoral .
It wasn't so much the structure, but in his numbers
Trying to be numerically precise about what is essentially a political process is likely to be an exercise in futility .
Romney may have been willing to leave the powerful 1 %ers a benefit with the capital gains so that he could effect badly needed reforms in the tax code . It would not require much to revert to a higher capital gains rate later .
The complexity of the tax code really doesn't hurt companies.
It does hurt workers however and that is the point .
Romney didn't care about that. he made his money from taking advantage of this part of the tax code, capital gains, and he equates profits to economic health.
So you are saying that you didn't trust Romney to start thinking like a President instead of continuing to think like a capitalist CEO . That is why he didn't get elected . No one trusted him to change his mind set . But is the current lack of leadership on the tax code any worse than risking that he would change ?