SCOTUS DOMA Decison Disastrous Based on Logic as Well as Religion
The Supreme Court's 5-4 decision to invalidate the Defense of Marriage Act is regrettable but should be especially so for Jews. Contrary to the majority's assertion, DOMA was not about bigotry or rights. Homosexuals are respected as individuals and have the same constitutional rights as every other citizen including that of free association. But to call a homosexual partnership "marriage" is a categorical error as well as a moral one. Logic as well as the Torah affirm this. The Torah says normatively that a man leaves his father and mother and clings to his wife.
85 senators and 342 members of congress voted for DOMA including Schumer, Reid, Leahy and Biden. Clinton signed it. Were all these bigots? 38 states affirm marriage as the union of a man and a woman. In 31 of those states, citizens have had the opportunity to directly vote for state constitutional amendments defining marriage as the union of a man and a woman. Those constitutional amendments often passed by overwhelming majority of voter support. Conversely, in the three states that have voted to change their laws to include same-sex couples, a relatively small percentage of voters approved of the redefinition.
Leviticus 18, read in synagogues on the Jewish holy day of Yom Kippur, explains why the children of Israel were given the Promised Land. A major reason was that the former nations violated the Noahite law forbidding sexual immorality. The law as defined therein proscribes forbidden relationships such as incest, homosexuality and bestiality.
"Do not copy the practices of the land --- to which I take you. --- Do not defile yourselves through any of these abhorrent things, neither the citizen or the stranger who resides among you. For all these abominations were committed by the inhabitants who were there before you and the land became contaminated. So let not the land disgorge you for defiling it as it disgorged the nation that was before you. Any who do any of these abhorrent things - such persons shall be cut off from among their people."
Nothing could be plainer. Tragically, too many Jews ignore these teachings, including the three Jewish Supreme Court justices who helped form the five vote majority.
Tags
Who is online
104 visitors

"85 senators and 342 members of congress voted for DOMA including Schumer, Reid, Leahy and Biden. Clinton signed it. Were all these bigots? 38 states affirm marriage as the union of a man and a woman. In 31 of those states, citizens have had the opportunity to directly vote for state constitutional amendments defining marriage as the union of a man and a woman. Those constitutional amendments often passed by overwhelming majority of voter support. Conversely, in the three states that have voted to change their laws to include same-sex couples, a relatively small percentage of voters approved of the redefinition."
None of the senators or congressmen based their vote on religious reasons notwithstanding that all three major religions agree on the subject of homosexual relationships. The secular and religious views agree. The vast majority of states agree.
SCOTUS flies in the face of every institution but SCOTUS marginally, the president recently and NewsTalkers.
It was a free country last month before the SCOTUS decision.
It is not free for polygamists, yet, but what is to prevent that now? Not even the Bible which does not ban polygamy.
Arguably, the president and Scotus are on the way to violating the First Amendment and will be forcing church institutions to facilitate abortion and distribution of contraceptives all paid for by taxes.
hey if you really want more govt regulations why not just vote democrat & be done with it?
Religion, Len? Really?
Let's take a stroll through, uh, Leviticus? OK! And then we'll go from there.
And going forward, I insist you follow Biblical doctrine consistently and as literally as you have done in this discussion.
So
Leviticus 18:22
Do not have sexual relations with a man as one does with a woman; that is detestable."
So far, you're looking pretty convincing, Len. But wait there's more!
Well then, how about Exodus 35:2
"For six days, work is to be done, but the seventh day shall be your holy day, a day of sabbath rest to the LORD. Whoever does any work on it is to be put to death ."
Done any chores on Shabbos. Len?
Exodus 21:7
"And if a man sell his daughter to be a maidservant, she shall not go out as the menservants do."
Isn't that sanctioning slavery of women? Have any daughters, Len?
Hey football fans read Leviticus 11:7 since last season?
Jets or Giants fan, Len?
"And the pig, though it has a divided hoof, does not chew the cud; it is unclean for you."
Dirty f'n quarterbacks!
If my point is not evident, you may be a bit dense, I may be less of a communicator than I think I am, or, possibly you take the Bible literally -- in a selective way of course -- like religionists and politicians who pander to religious ideologues.
How much better off would we be in this world if we just went with "The Golden Rule" -- you know -- "Do Unto Others "
That's biblical!
But alas and tragically, those who genuflect to the marriage of religion and politics somehow can ignore the very dogmas they spout selectively when it suits there political agenda -- and live their disdain for those who see things differently from themselves.
And is there any act of human love or kindness that could not be extended IN THE TOTAL ABSENCE OF RELIGION -- AND WITHOUT THE INEVITABLE DOWNSIDES
Religionists will continue to listen to and elect the haters, haters who may or may not themselves, necessarily be haters, but nevertheless peddle their ugly wares to the willing dupes who, rather than deal rationally with reality, "validate" their bigotry with the Bible
but only those portions that suit them.
>>And now that gay couples have the same rights as straight couples we are less free???
I did not know you ("we") are a homosexual. If so, I wish you well.
You were just as free before as you are now. DOMA was not about freedom but about money. It can be argued that non-married people are not free because they do not have benefits particular to married people. By your reasoning that is not fair.
Married people were granted special benefits because of the likelihood of children. Most children are likely accidental but are likely for a heterosexual marriage. Children of homosexuals are a relative rarity and so they are no more deserving of financial incentives than single roommates or siblings.
>>More=Less in bizarro world!
It is more bizarre than before.
Len>>Arguably, the president and Scotus are on the way to violating the First Amendment and will be forcing church institutions to facilitate abortion and distribution of contraceptives
>>Could you puleeeeeze explain how gay couples are going to have a need for abortions or contraceptives???????????
The "forcing" is obviously pertaining to straight people who are in the vast majority.
Hey, next time I speak to a woman who wants a vaginal probe, I'll remember that oh wait, that's Republican "less regulation."
Shall I go on?
Source? Verification? Specifics?
Charade Continues with Obamacares HHS Mandate
By Sarah Torre
July 2, 2013
In the Obama administrations latest Friday info-dump, the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) today released its final rule outlining a so-called accommodation for its coercive Obamacare mandate.
Like the administrations multiple previous attempts to fix the mandate, this final rule doesnt provide any workable or adequate solutions to the mandates trampling on Americans fundamental freedoms.
At the renewal of health-plan years, employers still will be forced to facilitate coverage of abortion-inducing drugs, contraception, and sterilization regardless of religious or moral objection to one or more of these practices.
Since it introduced the HHS mandate in 2011, the Obama administration repeatedly has brought out the best in bureaucratic theatrics. Through press conference promises, campaign absurdities, and hundreds of pages of complicated regulatory jargon, the administration has relied on a campaign of smoke and mirrors to hide the mandates assault on religious liberty.
Theres only one problem: Courts arent buying the act. Today, more than 200 plaintiffs are involved in more than 60 lawsuits over the Obamacare mandate. Of the 28 lawsuits in which rulings have touched on the merits of the cases, federal judges have awarded 21 temporary halts because of the rules serious burden on the free exercise of Americans first freedom.
The administrations latest regulatory antics to advance its anti-conscience mandate arent likely to get a standing ovation from federal judges either.
The so-called accommodation does not adequately address the mandates trampling on religious freedom and will still force religious non-profit organizations to abide by the mandate.
Only formal houses of worship and their integrated auxiliaries (a church-run soup kitchen, for example) are truly exempt. Countless religious employers among them charities, hospitals, and schools still will be forced to facilitate coverage of mandated drugs and services regardless of moral or religious objection.
These are the people who form the backbone of civil society. These are the people, motivated by deeply held beliefs, who get up every day to care for the sick, educate the next generation, and provide food, shelter and counseling for the most vulnerable Americans. Yet, these are the people whose religious liberty the administration refuses to adequately protect.
As a consolation prize for fitting the administrations narrow requirements to receive an inadequate accommodation, HHS also announced that some of these Good Samaritans will have until January 1, 2014 to figure out how to get over their beliefs and get in line with the mandate.
For everyone else? The Obama administration remains unrelenting in its assault on fundamental freedoms.
Family businesses are given no protection whatsoever from the coercive mandate. Why? Because the administration argues that families who build businesses, create jobs, and grow the economy lose their right to religious freedom when they walk in the doors of their workplaces.
The HHS mandate forces these employers into an impossible situation: Violate their beliefs, face crippling fines of up to $100 per employee per day, or drop health care coverage altogether harming their employees and risking an annual fine of roughly $2,000 per employee per year after 2014.
Practically speaking, by the administrations reasoning, faith is restricted to churches, synagogues, and mosques. Step outside the four walls of your home or place of worship and protection of your religious freedom ends.
Such picking and choosing of who gets to live out their faith in how they act and work isnt consistent with the protection of religious freedom enshrined in our founding and defended in laws such as the federal Religious Freedom Restoration Act.
Try as it might to masquerade the mandate with todays new rule, the Obama administration isnt likely to convince the courts that it is serious about protecting our freedoms.
It could take the Supreme Court to ring down the curtain on the show, but this charade is in its final act.
Sarah Torre is a policy analyst in the DeVos Center for Religion and Civil Society at the Heritage Foundation.
First appeared in National Review Online
You still listening to Mitt bullshit?
And by the way having religious dogma dictate what goes into a law is a violation of the beliefs of of any/all whose religious or non-sectarian convictions are contrary to said law.
The First Amendment ( Amendment I ) to the United States Constitution prohibits the making of any law respecting an establishment of religion , impeding the free exercise of religion ,
That makes it a wash in my book. Can't mandate nor prohibit based on religious belief. Something of a dilemma.
Meet the 18 For-Profit Companies Fighting Obamacare's Contraception...
Things aren't always what they seem.
I've read that three or four times now and still can't make sense of it. Well, it has been a long day ... are you saying that children of homosexuals are less deserving because they are a "relative rarity" ?
Now in Ohio rape counselors will lose funding if they discuss abortion with rape victims. Beyond disgusting !
Republicans don't like blow jobs so much because the vibrators keep chipping their teeth.
They do however enjoy "Oral Sex" where couples go to opposite corners of the bedroom and yell "fuck you" to one another.
Slavery existed before the Bible. Slavery in the Bible was not at all like slavery here before the Civil War. Rather than supporting slavery the Bible regulated it strictly.
The Hebrew for "slave," "eved," is identical to that for "servant." Abraham's eved, Eliezer, was so trusted that he was sent to (successfully) find a wife for his son, Isaac. Eveds got the Sabbath off and, as stated in the link. were freed on the sabbatical year. On the Jubilee year an eved who was forced toi sell his property had it returned to him.
The Liberty Bell's inscription is from the biblical chapter on the Jubilee year:
Not the children; sorry. Homosexual couples, since they rarely have children, are not deserving of marriage tax benefits as a class.
Tax benefits should be based on normative situations, not exceptional ones.
Homosexuals go to much effort and expense to have children, either by in vitro or by adoption. Such are usually at least moderately affluent and need child assistance much less than the average family.
DOMA is for the gay community, the life experience equivalent of "Bricks Without Straw", Len.
And there's a distinction between a servant and a slave.
SERVANT - a person who performs duties for others, esp. a person employed in a house on domestic duties or as a personal attendant.
SLAVE - a person who is the legal property of another and is forced to obey that person.
Leave it to Republicans and religionists to decide for everyone that which is "normative."
How wishing a homosexual good wishes bigoted? You are following the glbt activist phony strategy of calling anyone who does not subscribe to their agenda a bigot. Unfortunately that strategy has intimiidated many gullible people but you are barking up the wrong tree here.
Are you cognitively challenged? It is obvious that there is no difference in freedom before and after. The decision added no freedom; just more undeserving benefits.
America may not be free but it is cheap
It may not be free but it is as freer as some and better than most.
Those who follow their every whim are not free at all. In a Hebrew prayer we are requested not to follow the desires of our heart and eyes that lead us astray. The English poet, John Milton, wrote,
"License they mean when they cry Liberty; for who loves that must first be wise and good."
Licence, not liberty, is what SCOTUS endorsed.
ObamaCare's contraception mandate stands the First Amendment on its head.
By DONALD WUERL, CHARLES COLSON AND MEIR Y. SOLOVEICHIK
Stories involving a Catholic, a Protestant and a Jew typically end with a punch line. We wish that were the case here, but what brings us together is no laughing matter: the threat now posed by government policy to that basic human freedom, religious liberty.
Last month the federal Department of Health and Human Services announced that the Affordable Care Act requires employers to pay for insurance coverage for abortion-inducing drugs, sterilizations and contraception. What made the announcement especially troubling is that HHS specifically declined to exempt religious institutions that serve those outside their own faiths, such as hospitals and schools.
Coverage of this story has almost invariably been framed as a conflict between the federal government and the Catholic bishops. Zeroing in on the word "contraception," many commentators have taken delight in pointing to surveys about the use of contraceptives among Catholics, the message being that any infringement of religious freedom involves an idiosyncratic position that doesn't affect that many people.
Nothing could be further from the truth. The Catholic Church's teaching on contraception (not to mention abortion and surgical sterilization) has been clear, consistent and public. HHS Secretary Kathleen Sebelius's decision would force Catholic institutions either to violate the moral teachings of the Catholic Church or abandon the health-care, education and social services they provide the needy. This is intolerable.
And while most evangelicals take a more permissive view of contraception, they share with Catholics the moral conviction that the taking of human life in utero, whether surgically or by abortifacient drugs, violates the basic human right to life. Evangelical nonprofits such as Prison Fellowship would therefore also have to choose between violating their consciences or paying fines that would ultimately destroy their ability to help the people they are committed to helping.
Even worse than the financial impact is the breach of faith represented by Ms. Sebelius's decision. Her notion of an "appropriate balance" between religious freedom and "increasing access" to "important preventive services" stands the First Amendment on its head.
In 1790, George Washington exchanged letters with Moses Seixas, the warden of the Hebrew Congregation of Newport, R.I. Seixas praised the newly formed United States for "affording to All liberty of conscience, and immunities of citizenship." People who knew all too well what it meant to be deprived of the "invaluable rights of free Citizens" held religious liberty and freedom of conscience most dear.
In reply, Washington wrote that U.S. citizens had a "right to applaud themselves" for setting an example of "an enlarged and liberal policy" that enshrined freedom of conscience. He added that the ability of members of one faith to seek the benefit of all Americans is the foundation of America's civic strength.
We see evidence of that strength all around us: If a working mother's child needs to visit the emergency room, there's a good chance the hospital is a Catholic one. If an ex-offender needs help readjusting to life outside of prison, there's a good chance help will come from a Christian ministry like Prison Fellowship.
Yet instead of encouraging the different faith communities to continue their vital work for the good of all, the Obama administration is forcing them to make a choice: serving God and their neighbors according to the dictates of their respective faithsor bending the knee to the dictates of the state.
For Jews, George Washington's letter has always been cherished. It embodies the promise extended by America not only to them, but to all citizens. That is why many in the Jewish community are alarmed to see the very religious freedom Washington praised centuries ago endangered by Washington's successor. "May the children of the stock of Abraham who dwell in this land," Washington wrote, "continue to merit and enjoy the good will of the other inhabitants."
At this critical moment, Americans of every faith, as guardians of their own freedom, must, in the words of the First Amendment, "petition the government for the redress of grievances." That's why over the past two years more than 500,000 people have signed the "Manhattan Declaration" in defense of religious liberty. They believe, as do we, that under no circumstances should people of faith violate their consciences and discard their most cherished religious beliefs in order to comply with a gravely unjust law.
That's something that this Catholic, this Protestant and this Jew are in perfect agreement about.
Cardinal Wuerl is the archbishop of Washington, D.C. Mr. Colson is the founder of Prison Fellowship and the Colson Center for Christian Worldview. Rabbi Soloveichik is director of the Straus Center for Torah and Western Thought at Yeshiva University and associate rabbi at Congregation Kehilath Jeshurun
We hold these truths to be self-evident: that all men are created equal; that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable rights; that among these are life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.
Jefferson
Sorry I don't have a list for you but you asked for verification and I provided it. Obama's "negotiating" with the Church is like the PA's negotiating with Israel. "Gim'me, gim'me gim'me."
pat, Just noting my interpretation of:
Children of homosexuals are a relative rarity and so they are no more deserving of financial incentives than single roommates or siblings.
I interpreted his "they" as who he was referring to throughout-- homosexuals---not the children.
I'm commenting on this only because I know I have been guilty of using words like "they, his, hers, theirs, this, that, etc." as many of us, which can cause confusion; yet, to give the context to the 'children' wouldn't really make sense.
I can't support Len from a Jewish perspective, as I know little about it.
I do agree if someone wants same-sex marriage, polygamy, polyamory, etc., or even wants to marry their car, cat, or favorite tree---that's their prerogative.
I just want all of the different types of unions to have their own Institution and designated benefits---which could be the same benefits as heterosexual unions...if it makes sense with that particular type of union to do so.
I see that as a very fair solution and would eliminate the forcing of one group to conform to the demands of the others'.
Also, the legal benefits, needs and demands would seem very complicated with some of these other unions, like polyamory, such that a group marriage might want to blend a homosexual marriage into their group union...and then if there were children from different mothers and fathers, then if divorce occurred---it could get really messy. So, if different institutions were formed, different legalities and rules could be made to aid the complications surrounding children, as well as 'community property' when it belongs to a commune instead of just a couple.
Who are the 200 plaintiffs?
I'll bet that they are all or mostly Tea Party/Republican-connected.
This information is on-the-record;
You are changing the subject, merely demonstrating that a little learning is a dangerous thing. But I am only too happy to bite.
The death penalty was applicable only while the Sanhedrin was extent over 2000 years ago. Moreover, the Talmud says that a Sanhedrin that executed a single person in over 90 years was a murdering court. The laws of jurisprudence make execution almost impossible. Such verses were included to show the seriousness of the offence. As the Psalms say, "God is merciful.. He forgives sin and does not destroy. Repeatedly He suppresses His anger, not arousing His full wrath." (Psalms 78, 20)
No! It says "servant," not slave. The father was providing his daughter to be the secondary wife, or concubine, for a man or his son. In an age of polygamy such was not degradation. Her offspring had equal inheritance rights with children of the first wife. (Deut. 21:15-17)
The dense one is evidently you. That verse is not about football, or shoes, but about eating as is the much of Lev. 11. While Jesus said that what goes into your mouth cannot defile as what comes out of your mouth may, Jews consider both important.
Very good! Too bad you do not know that these verses were paraphrased from Rabbi Hillel who, in response to a potential convert who asked him to explain Judaism while standing on one foot, replied as is quoted in the Talmud: "What is hateful to you, do not do to your neighbor: this is the whole Torah. The rest is commentary. Now go and learn."
Lifted from:
Leviticus 19:18 - Thou shalt not avenge, nor bear any grudge against the children of thy people, but thou shalt love thy neighbour as thyself: I [am] the LORD.
So why are we arguing? Look at the donut, not at the hole.
Lifted from Hosea 14:3.
Good quote! Unfortunately we live in a world where people decide for themselves what is true, honest, just and pure, The NY Times Sunday review had an article entitled, "The Gospel According to Me." That is "Meism;" neither Judaism or Christianity. If everything is holy, then nothing is holy. While you rail against selective spouting, you do it as well as anyone; deciding for yourself what is just and pure while ignoring what is uncomfortable.
Sure; but it is like the "cut flowers" analogy. If you cut flowers from a plant, you may deceive yourself into thinking that the flowers do not need the original plant or soil to survive. The positive commandments about goodness, love and kindness come from the Bible just as do the negative commandments that people prefer to ignore. That is "Meism."
God is so mad at Americans over the SCOTUS decision to declare DOMA unconstitutional that he is going to punish us -by continuing to ignore us and hide for eternity, just like He has donesince the beginning of time. Whoa is us.
I believe in God and the Bible. But my outlook on this is one based on how we run the country. The country must be either run by religious rule or by the constitution and when we mingle the two, chaos abounds as we have seen multitudes of times. Americans need to decide if they want a religious ruler or one run by what we call the constitution. Same with the abortion topic. Not everyone believes in abortion, but they do believe in an individual right to choose and I think this is similar to marriage.
When the country recognized the gays as an alternative lifestyle, the gave recognition and as such, under the constitution they cannot be discriminated against. The problem we have caused in this latest action of DOMA is leave it for now in the hands of the states, which ultimately will not work for the economic woes alone that this creates. There will have to be another decision to make it mandatory to not discriminate on a national basis, and I do foresee this happening eventually.
I believe in my god and my bible, but that does not give me the right imo to tell the people living down the street that because of my beliefs they must act accordingly to them. God is their judge, not me.
Under the constitution, the country will make those decisions accordingly or we will need to change how we want to rule the country. I do not believe that God will punish me because of something you may or may not do.
There are countries who rule by their religion and dole out punishment accordingly. Do we really want to do that in America and how will that work in a nation that has so many different beliefs, whose do we enforce?
"Forced?"
Arguably any employed person is forced to obey his boss; not physical force but if he knows what is good for him.
You are just spinning to make something more than it is.
I was not there but, for the culture of those times, Hebrew "slavery" was clearly the most benevolent that existed because of Torah regulation.
The chances that the biblical god is real are exactly equal to the chances thatthe one that hundreds of millions of Hindus believe in is real -which also happensto be a manifestation of hundreds ofindividual gods. This is what is so perplexing about religion - one's religion is above all else a function determined solely on their location on the surface of this planet. If we find intelligence elsewhere in the cosmos, and that intelligence happens to have religious beliefs, it will be just as random, free of evidence, and nonconforming to any of the thousands of conflicting religions on this planet. I don't understand why atheists can see this but believers refuse to acknowledge it. Taking it to the extreme of convincing yourself just how such an unknown entity is going to react to anything is pathologically unhealthy ... to us atheistsanyways.
Yep, no denying that. He could be a study in good debate skills.
Len on the other hand...
Don't tell a Hindu that - they will insist that those many gods are just the manifestations of the monotheistic god that is at the center of Hinduism. I've been through this argument before - it makes no sense to me but that's how they see it.
Personally I think the biggest damage being done to christianity are those who profess to be believers going around and beating people over the head with the bible. This is NOT what a believer is supposed to be doing or saying. And to dare speak for God based on a limited knowledge of what one thinks the bible says to them is doing much much damage to God and keeping more and more people from wanting to experience him.
That my friends, is the exact opposite of what God wants to happen, so I wish for Gods sake, people would quit using the bible to thump other people over the head. In Gods eyes every sin is equal be it a little white lie or murder. sin is sin
Self rightousness is as well, people denying gods existance will be on the heads of those so called religious that put themselves above everyone else. We are all the same.
Now Im not talking about the bible anymore, everyone can read it themselves but that is my take which is just my take. And we all have a take dont we.
I tell ya what. If you believe that, that is your right to do so. Me? I am a believer and Hal,,you will not convince me he doesnt exist, anymore than I will convince you that he does. Besides. That is not my job, that is your option. You have a free will and so do I. Im not getting into a debate of why I believe the way I do or why you believe the way you do. In the end, we will ALL find out, until then? That is your business. And your right to think anyway you choose.
I gave up on trying to convince anyone of a religious persuasion that they are not looking at the whole picture long ago. Either you see it or you don't. However, I will always bring this fact up when a discussion veers into mixing politics and religion. The two topics need to be forever separate, since endorsing one religion in a political arena over another is like saying that the metric system is false means to measurement.
Religion and politics should stay out of each others way? I absolutely agree with that!
An "employed person" is compensated for his/her employment, can resign, is protected by law from crimes that might be perpetrated by the employer (i.e. requiring the performance of sexual favors cannot be a condition of employment, nor can race, religion or gender).
LOL! Unfortunately, that too! Love that play on words!
__
Our Admin has declared 'Time and eternity' unconstitutional, as well. Time no longer exists and is inconsequential, as nothing matters anymore. We are an 'anything goes' society, no matter what 'time' it is (clock or era:), so throw those clocks out the window...and eternity ? Forget it---everything is temporary---so why even bother trying, right? ..Live for today; do whatever you want...because it "really doesn't matter."
...And, marriage ? Less than half of us want it, apparently, and the Millenials will make it non-existent, eventually.
...(just joking!!...I hope)
The Bible was cobbled together" over 3000 years ago. The Dead Sea Scrolls attests to the Bible's existence well before the First Century and historical data places it much farther. The Oral Law (Talmud) was set to writing around the Fourth Century because of fear of loss.
Ok! Most of the sabbatical, Jubilee and other related laws deal with Hebrew slaves but the laws of benevolent treatment apply to all. The Hebrew "eved" applies to both. So can we take the matter of Hebrew slaves off the table now?
It does not say "buy." The Bible makes absolutely no mention of slave markets or auctions and slavery, while addressed, was evidently not so common. Here is the correct translation:
"Acquire" from an existing slave could be family coming to join them; an unlikely event if the slave was treated harshly. In the Code of Hammurabi a master was penalized for destroying the tooth or eye of another man's slave but not of his own slave. It ordered that a slave's ear be cut off if he asked for freedom. If there were too many slaves in Greece they conducted an extermination. Roman slaves were mutilated and crucified. Sick ones were starved to death. Tacitus records that 400 slaves in one residence were killed following their master's murder.
Among the Hebrews kidnapping a person or selling him as a slave was a capital offence. If a master injured a slave's organ the slave was freed. (Exod. 21:26f) If a slave escaped he must not be returned. (Deut. 23:16f) The pre-Civil War South was nowheree as benevolent as the 3000-year-old Hebrew society.
I have answered every question and comment; even from those I said I would no longer respond to. I am not here to write a treatise. I am not ashamed of the Bible and sweep nothing under the rug. Times and the economy has changed greatly, to say the least, but slavery among the Hebrews was far more humane than anywhere else.
That is only a logical consequence for the illogical.
But in this comment, you make the following assertion:
So the REAL question is, do you even really truly understand the material that you try to make people believe, OR do you make the same mistake as so many in the radical Islamic communities (the ones that commit the acts of terror) and completely take out of context the texts that you are interpreting.
I understand it but you are cognitively challenged. It was pointed out that, in English, the words have different meanings but, in Hebrew, the meaning of the single word depends on context. Icorrected your context error.
It is liberals who are fundamentalists and who cling to their dogma.
Tell me why. It is all right to support me from a non-Jewish one.
Why should single people be discriminated against; or siblings, or roommates? Don't they have equal rights?
Why get married at all? Shouldn't common-law partners have rights too?
Your ideas are Chloeism, not Judaism.
Au contraire! Normative is simple; the way it was BO.
You are a bigot against tea party folks. There are lots more of them than homosexuals.
Our Government is not based on Religion and you brought forth a prime example. No one book, call it a bible or something else covers all relogions. Its the very reason our for fathers said we had freedom of religion and so be it if your belief is there is no logic to any religion then also freedom from Religion. Reading a verse from your book means nothing to many other religions. So if you want a Jewish religion and its rules and laws then go somewhere and start a government based on Judaism.Just notmy countrynor utilize any other religion for that matter..
Hey Len 95% of the people want background checks for gun buyers and ammunition buyers. So whats your point. No one is asking you to marry another man or even sleep with one. But it is a free country isn't it. Or does that difference vary based on a religious book, A family belief, the largest religion or the first religion or just your religion general concensus what is your decision point because I'm sure your logic does no prevail as the only logical answer. In fact it doesn't work for me.
The Pilgrims came here to freely exercise their religion. The First Amendment is about freedom FOR religion. Government must not interfere; which they are doing in spades.
Israel is a secular nation that preserves and protects all; forms of worship. Muslims have more freedom there than in Muslim nations.
There is even a Gay Pride parade. That is not Jewish.
You mean they changed your Torah regulation? Well then no problem change it again.
If someone wrote in the bible that a marriage is between a man and a woman that tells me they felt they had to call it out as there were already people who felt otherwise.
Len Abortion has been legal for years not only in this country but many countries. The President has not changed anything the President can only sign a bill or Veto it. Guess he can start a war as the law now stands but must be approved afterwards by Congress. Are you one of those low life racist. Bet there is no minority blood in your family wait a minute dam you are the minority.
Mickey I believe that was an anal exreaction by Len. We have a live biggot in Len who only likes children from a family like his. Glad he doesn't write the laws.
Then why do we not declare a jubilee year we are due one since we never had one and erase all housing debt? Why are we not obeying the biblical law forbidding the charging of interest on loans? You cant cherry pick what Gods law we want to obey. The bible says that I can sell my daughter, In in need of some money so what Is a good asking price for her ??
Now I understand why the indians thought we were crazy. In Lens case it appearsthey were right.
I can't support a doctrine that I have no knowledge of or experience in to form an opinion.
To which I do...(and the others, too). Why? Because you are reacting to the issue no differently than a liberal or person of another value system; everyone functions based on one of two things: 1) what they have been taught ancestrally-(and/or could be passed on through an allele, skipping a generation, possibly); or 2) what they have experienced. And, for some, their perceptions of how things 'are' can be a result of 'both.'
Are you referring to social status or financially ?
1) Socially, "single" shouldn't be discriminated against--it's a shame that it appears to carry a prejudice or stigma, as many employers claim an emotional stability with marriage, prejudicing those that aren't married. I've read instances of people getting married for the wrong reasons--to be viewed differently in the community (as 'better'). So while they actually do have 'equal' rights, the prejudice prevents them.
However, financially re taxes, that's about the practicality of the economics - an attempt to create fairness between the two groups (married vs. single) by charging married a higher tax premium, or should.
I'm not sure how siblings and roommates fit into the context of the conversation, Len.
..And, common law marriage does exist in some states.
Dam had friends that had a child thru a surrigate his wife could not conceive. So guess that baby would be in the same situation dam sure not the norm. I don't think I would like Lens country.
Oh before there were gays in the military no wait they were already serving their country. They just couldnot admit then they were ok. Those good closet gays like beforeright Len. I think you duth protest to much Len. Have you had a gay fling Len is this a guilt tantrum.
Dang Einstein Insanity you had to stir the pot some more.
As an aside, but relevant pragmatically in that other areas of society functioned similarly, e.g. Economics - people were of either "Austrian" mindset or the other, with the point being that Authoritarianism, better judgment or intelligence would be the prevailing doctrine...or what have you.
The death penalty was applicable only while the Sanhedrin was extent over 2000 years ago.
Don't thank me for your own nonsense.
Note also that there is such a thing as Halakha, Jewish Law, that you are ignorant of notwithstanding your attempt to sound like a scholar. Teaching a scorner even the little I know, admittedly being far from expert myself, is a lost cause. Let me just tell you that the Bible was written for a theological state containing the Temple that was destroyed in 70 CE. Absent the Temple, many commandments are not applicable including those of sacrifice and a capital Sanhedrin.
the Talmud says that a Sanhedrin that executed a single person in over 90 years was a murdering court. The laws of jurisprudence make execution almost impossible. Such verses were included to show the seriousness of the offence.
You are speaking from ignorance once again. The reason is that the trial procedures and rules of evidence and witnesses are far stricter than exist here today. If you want a taste browse here while remembering that a little learning is dangerous.
No nation had more humane restrictions on rape then, and most not even now. Compare to Muslims 3000+ years later. Today the Israeli rules are of course stricter, not looser. So you cannot fault greater strictness. OTOH this nation is moving to greater looseness with moral codes.
Again, today's rabbinic law is stricter, not easier.
Just sons; but again even then the law made conviction virtually impossible.
Read the Talmudic details in above reference on pages 68b-71a
My counsel would be what God advised Cain (unsuccessfully): "Surely if you do right there is uplift. But if you do not do right, sin lurks at your door. Its urge is towards you. Yet you CAN be its master." (Gen. 4:7)
"You who love the lord hate evil." (Ps. 97) Is hating evil hateful? Justice is about preventing justifiably hateful things. What used to be just is changing. As Sen. Moynihyan said, "We are defining deviancy downwards."
Not at all! Your premise is that Hillel would not block a sin he would want to do himself. Your logic, such as it is, fails at the starting gate.
We have a Written and Oral Law that form Halakha. We also have customs that vary with sect and ethnicity. Other than customs the combination, as applicable today, is normative and holy.
Practice what you preach.
Next decade SCOTUS will outlaw the Bible as a hate document and force clergy to perform homosexual marriage, bisexual marriage (of three) and transgender marriage.
Can marriage to a pet be far behind?
Who would have thought we would be where we are a decade ago?
I really do think that legalizing same-sex marriage will lead to the other forms of union to start rallying for their share of the economic pie.
I see a slew of nightmares arising from that, as I mentioned with a possible incorporated polyamory scenario, requiring benefits that we all pay for (Federal)--giving more benefits to one group than another group would qualify for just because their situation is less complicated. That leads to feelings of inequality (as now) and belligerence. Again, I don't think various lifestyles should be lumped under one heading when they are essentially all 'different.'
Give each group their own definition, their own name, and their own set of rules qualifying their entitlements...then we can each be on our merry way, not being bothered by someone else's value system trying to re-define ours.
I was envisioning something similar to religious denominations---their commonality is that they are all a Faith---yet, each one has a variation of the doctrine. Why couldn't marriage be treated similarly?
The more I think about it, I see a huge correlation between religion and marriage - in principle. Our nation is tolerant in both venues - to be married or not be married, just as having Faith or to not have Faith...as well as agreeing with diversity in each.
I agree with your statement Mickey. I wasn't suggesting a correlation between the two Institutions in the context of the article topic.
I was just using religion as an example - the different sects have a common premise, but allow for diversity in definition to establish each one as its own.
LOL... Oh, Ok...thanks.
When Scalia forecast the end of doma three years ago everyone called it hyperbole.
I am sure you know there was no USA or Constitution when the Pilgrims came and you are just pulling my leg. In any eve3nt, here is their motive:
Pilgrims: The Escape of Courageous People
The Pilgrims were English Separatists who founded Plymouth Colony in 1620. The Pilgrims, fleeing religious persecution, broke away from the Church of England because they felt the Church violated biblical principles of true Christians. Due to persecution and economic distress, they believed they had to break away from the Church of England to form congregations which were more in keeping with divine requirements. Coming out of the recent Reformation, the pilgrims believed the Church of England had not come far enough. The Church was under strict rule of the State so their actions were considered treasonous and these Separatists had to flee their homeland.
Determined and very courageous men and women committed themselves (in all aspects of their lives) to life based on the Bible and a relationship with God. They brought their only known culture and spiritual values to the New World and attempted to establish an improved foundation of English society on an unfamiliar new continent. - See more at:
Hal.Denying your child access to modern medicine for something as easy to cure as kidney stones, in lieu of mindless prayer, pretty much is human sacrifice
I think this is more misinterpretation of what the word says. This is ignorance in its finest form. Could it be that the knowledge of doctors and medicine may have been given by God? I believe so. Prayer is good, so is doctors and the medical knowledge they have been blessed with for our good. You cannot dump everyone who believes into one large group. The so called religious right has done more to damage what christianity is and what it stands for then the evil forces than oppose it. My opinion is, they are the evil forces spreading lies and deceit in the name of god. If this continues I see an entity coming that will restrict ones right to their religion. This too is not good but is predicted to happen. I see the beginning of it on forums like these all over the place.
Wow! That's a leap of no-faith!
What should be outlawed is religionist-delusion.
'Course, that be tantamount to outlawing the current Republican/Tea Party and its base.
Hmmmmmmmmm! I like it!
Separate but equal was a legal doctrine in United States constitutional law that justified systems of segregation . Under this doctrine, services, facilities and public accommodations were allowed to be separated by race, on the condition that the quality of each group's public facilities was to remain equal. The phrase was derived from a Louisiana law of 1890, although the law actually used the phrase "equal but separate." [ 1 ]
____
tHAT PHRASE PERTAINS TO rACE....nOT MARRIAGE.
sORRY FOR THE ODD CAPS AND SCRIPT. i MUST HAVE A KEYLOGGER.
The point I was making that "sailed over" 'your' head is that the court may have 'interpreted' a right to marry different races in reference to that phrase ... but that is not what we are talking about here!!!!
Defining what constitutes a marriage is! That phrase is pertinent to a 'right' to marry---not pertinent to a definition of marriage! You might want to take a moment to check yourself before accusing others of misinterpretation or incomprehension.
Just because you don't get something is not and should not be an excuse for arrogance and condescension!
No, it does not. Why? ..Because if that were true, religious organizations would not allow 'denominations.' They are equal in the regard of each being considered a legitimate Faith, but are all a part of the Institution of Religion. The same could hold true for marriage--they could be separate in definition (as beliefs/values, same as religion), but would be equal in that have a legal union. In other words, the 'Institution' would be 'legal union with the same benefits' - but each 'denomination' so to speak, would have a different label.