Head of Group Opposing Iran Accord Quits Post, Saying He Backs Deal
WASHINGTON When the bipartisan advocacy group United Against Nuclear Iran decided last week to mobilize opposition against the nuclear deal with Tehran, Gary Samore knew he could no longer serve as its president.
The reason: After long study, Mr. Samore, a former nuclear adviser to President Obama , had concluded that the accord was in the United States interest.
I think President Obamas strategy succeeded, said Mr. Samore, who left his post on Monday. He has created economic leverage and traded it away for Iranian nuclear concessions.
... it is Mr. Samores quiet departure as president of the organization that is resonating among the small community of experts who have pored over the agreement.
Mr. Samore helped establish the organization in 2008, well before serious nuclear talks were underway. The aim was to strengthen the international economic sanctions against Iran , which Mr. Samore was convinced had been mounting a clandestine effort to develop nuclear weapons .
Mr. Samore, who traveled to Iran in 2005, is well known to the Iranians. At a dinner that Mr. Samore attended during a meeting of the United Nations General Assembly in 2013, Mohammad Javad Zarif, Irans foreign minister, repeated assurances that Irans nuclear efforts were entirely peaceful.
We are all united against a nuclear Iran, he quipped, as he cast a glance at Mr. Samore.
Mr. Samore, who now runs the Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs at Harvard, initially said that the chances of a successful negotiation were dim. But after the framework of an accord was announced in Lausanne, Switzerland, in April, he praised it as a good first step.
...Though he backs the accord as the most that can be achieved diplomatically, Mr. Samore is skeptical that the agreement will open a new chapter in American-Iranian relations.
The best you can achieve with diplomacy is delay in the hope that at some point a new Iranian government emerges that is not committed to developing nuclear weapons, he said.
And if that leadership does not materialize, Mr. Samore acknowledges that Iran might vastly expand its nuclear enrichment program after core elements of the agreement expire in 15 years.
He is also not convinced that Iran will continue to adhere to the accord once economic sanctions are lifted. Even so, he argues, the accord will put the United States in a stronger position to respond than a congressional rejection would.
We will have bought a couple of years, and if Iran cheats or reneges we will be in an even better position to double down on sanctions or, if necessary, use military force, Mr. Samore said. If I knew for certain that in five years they would cheat or renege, Id still take the deal. "
http://www.nytimes.com/2015/08/12/world/middleeast/head-of-group-opposing-iran-accord-quits-post-saying-he-backs-deal.html
Tags
Who is online
87 visitors

We will have bought a couple of years, and if Iran cheats or reneges we will be in an even better position to double down on sanctions or, if necessary, use military force,
That's about the dumbest take possible. No one can possibly believe that. He's obviously lying.
We know Iran is strengthening its air defenses by the day, with help from Russia. Given the hundreds of billions of dollars we just gave Iran to play with, its inconceivable the Iranian milliraty will be weaker in in 5 years.
Second, the lifting of the sanctions opened Iran for business. Money and companies are already flowing into Iran. Even if the impossible happened and sanctions were reinstated, they wouldn't apply to all of the companies who enter Iran between now and their reinstatement per the terms of the capitulation, thus severely reducing their effectiveness.
The fact the the President and his minions continue to lie, blatantly, about this deal deals you how good it for America. But, as someone pointed out, Democrats no longer believe in having an American foreign policy.
That is the worst case.
A few dozen prominent U.S scientists came out if favor of the accord with a joint letter last weekend. 30 retired US generals and other military leaders released a statement yesterday supporting the deal. The support is coalescing.
Opponents have to convince every single Democratic Senator (who has yet to announce a position ) to vote against the deal in order to stop it in Congress. That's not going to happen.
Time to move the nation's business forward.