╌>

Supreme Court Same-Sex Marriage Ruling: Justices Weigh In On DOMA, Prop 8

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  z  •  13 years ago  •  29 comments

Supreme Court Same-Sex Marriage Ruling: Justices Weigh In On DOMA, Prop 8

OPgQBqM.jpg The Supreme Court ruled on two major gay marriage cases Wednesday: Windsor v. U.S., addressing the Defense of Marriage Act , and Hollingsworth v. Perry, addressing California's Proposition 8 .

The court struck down DOMA by a vote of 5-4. The court dismissed the Proposition 8 case on the grounds that the defense lacked standing, making gay marriage legal again in California . - http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/06/26/supreme-court-same-sex-marriage-ruling_n_3455026.html?utm_hp_ref=politics

It turned out to be a good day after all...113.gif


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   Len    13 years ago

The California situation is very confusing and the outcome is not yet clear:

Not So Fast: Prop 8 is Still California Law

26 Jun 2013, 3:58 PM PDT

News reports that California's Prop 8 has been struck down as unconstitutional are completely false.

Proposition 8 is the amendment to the California Constitution that defines marriage as the union of one man and one woman. A federal trial judge--Vaughn Walker--held that Prop 8 violates the Fourteenth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution.

On Wednesday, the Supreme Court held that only the losing defendants in that case--the governor and attorney general of California--had standing to appeal that decision. When they refused to do so, Prop 8's official sponsors filed the appeal with the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, and pursued it all the way to the Supreme Court.

Since the official sponsors lacked standing to defend Prop 8, the Supreme Court refused to rule on the merits, and also vacated (i.e., threw out) the the Ninth Circuit's decision.

But that means Prop 8 is still the law in California. Section 3.5 of the California Constitution specifically commands:

An administrative agency ... has no power:

(a) To declare a statute unenforceable, or refuse to enforce a statute, on the basis of it being unconstitutional unless an appellate court has made a determination that such statute is unconstitutional;

(b) To declare a statute unconstitutional;

(c) To declare a statute unenforceable, or to refuse to enforce a statute on the basis that federal law or federal regulations prohibit the enforcement of such statute unless an appellate court has made a determination that the enforcement of such statute is prohibited by federal law or federal regulations.

As of today, there is no appellate opinion (meaning an opinion issued by a court of appeals) against Prop 8. The Supreme Court refused to issue one, and threw out the only other one (the Ninth Circuit's). There is only a trial court opinion. So every agency in California is legally bound to regard Prop 8 as binding law.

Since no one who wants to defend Prop 8 has standing to appeal rulings on it to the Ninth Circuit, there will never be such an opinion in the federal court system. So the only way to get an appellate opinion would be in the California state court system. So someone would have to file a lawsuit regarding Prop 8, and then appeal it to a California court of appeals and then maybe to the California Supreme Court. Only when one of those courts hold Prop 8 unconstitutional can the public officials in that state regard it as stricken from the books.

That litigation could take years. And in the meantime, supporters of traditional marriage can continue making the case for marriage.

And so the struggle continues.

Breitbart News legal columnist Ken Klukowski is a senior fellow for religious liberty at the Family Research Council and on faculty at Liberty University School of Law, and authored a brief in the Supreme Court's marriage litigation

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   Len    13 years ago

To add to the confusion here is the WSJ take:

By Geoffrey A. Fowler and Tamara Audi

Updated with comments from state officials and Prop 8s proponents

June 26, 2013, 11:16 AM

In California, the Supreme Courts ruling on Proposition 8 means that marriage for same-sex couples may resume in about a month, although there remain some legal avenues for those who oppose gay marriage to challenge whether it applies to all California residents.

The court avoided a ruling on the merits of Prop 8, saying that both the Supreme Court and a federal appeals court lacked jurisdiction to hear the case. That means a federal district courts ruling striking down Prop 8 stands.

But to whom does it apply?

In his original 2010 district court ruling on Prop 8, Judge Vaughn Walker said his ruling applied to all California counties and citizens, even though the lawsuit was filed by just two couples in two counties.

Could some counties that werent home to those couples attempt to challenge whether the ruling applied to them?

So far, no county clerks have said they will do that, but the original proponents of the Prop 8 ban have in the past said they will use available legal means to limit the scope of any ruling that wasnt in their favor.

ProtectMarriage.com , the group that defended Prop 8 at the Supreme Court and put it on the California ballot, vowed to keep fighting in the courts to limit the scope of the courts judgment. Our legal team is studying this closely and assessing what options we may have. We wont know for some time what those options might be, said ProtectMarriage general counsel Andy Pugno in a call with reporters.

But he suggested there were still legal avenues for Prop 8 to remain in effect in a conflict between California and federal law. In ruling the way the court did, the court has completely vacated and nullified the 9th Circuits decision in this case, said Mr. Pugno. But state law, he said, requires officials to enforce a law until there is an appellate court decision declaring it unconstitutional. Judge Vaughn Walkers original 2010 district court ruling may not be sufficient, he said.

California Attorney General Kamala Harris s office declined to comment on Mr. Pugnos statement. But earlier in the day, she said the Supreme Court ruling means that every county in the state of California must now recognize the right of same sex couples to legally marry.

Ms. Harris said that marriages will resume in the state as soon as the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals lifts its stay on an earlier ruling overturning the proposition that banned gay marriage. She issued a legal letter to Californias Gov. Jerry Brown saying the state can and should instruct county officials that when the district courts injunction goes into effect, they must resume issuing marriage licenses to and recording the marriages of same-sex couples.

Ms. Harris said she is urging the Ninth Circuit to lift the stay immediately, rather than wait its standard 25 days. The moment that happens, she said, Wedding bells will ring.

Before a group of reporters, Ms. Harris said today represents a great day for California, it represents a great day for the United States.Ms. Harris said if county clerks dont abide by the law her office will take legal action to make sure they perform same-sex weddings.

In the city and county of San Francisco, which has a history of pushing to perform gay marriage, city attorney Dennis Herrera said he would move to enforce gay marriage throughout California should another county dispute the rulings statewide application. Given arguments that Prop 8s proponents have consistently advanced, my office is prepared to litigate immediately against any effort to limit or delay the restoration of marriage equality for all Californians, Mr. Herrera said in a statement.

David Boies , one of the lawyers who argued the case against Prop 8, scoffed at the idea that there might be a legal way for the ban on marriage to remain in some parts of the state.

If some renegade clerk in some isolated county does something, there will be a quick remedy for that, he said. The law is absolutely clear: Prop 8 is dead, all across California.

While California Gov. Jerry Brown said the state would begin issuing marriage licenses as soon as possible, it will take at least 25 days for that to happen.

Following standard procedures, the Ninth Circuit Court of appeals issued a notice on Wednesday that it wouldnt issue its mandate until that period has passed, following a procedure called Rule 45

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

I've never agreed that the "equal protection clause" has anything to do with marriage. Laws are what is protected. There is no law dictating marriage 'behavior,' like a civil rights law is dictated/mandated to be humanely and fairly carried out, across the board under the guidelines of citizenship; and there is no law that states we have to be married in order to be a citizen.

The Equal Protection Clause of the 14th amendment of the U.S. Constitution prohibits states from denying any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws. See U.S. Const. amend. XIV . In other words, the laws of a state must treat an individual in the same manner as others in similar conditions and circumstances. A violation would occur, for example, if a state prohibited an individual from entering into an employment contract because he or she was a member of a particular race. The equal protection clause is not intended to provide "equality" among individuals or classes but only "equal application" of the laws. The result, therefore, of a law is not relevant so long as there is no discrimination in its application. By denying states the ability to discriminate, the equal protection clause of the Constitution is crucial to the protection of civil rights.

Ok, so I understand that they did this:

The court struck down Section 3 of DOMA, which limited the definition of marriage as between a man and a woman for the purposes of federal benefits

But my point is not DOMA, which it's purpose is to allow benefits, but rather, Law and marriage.

The only way Law impacts marriage that I can see in the "Marriage Law" is pertaining to what a society/culture determines marriage to be, and in our country that would seem to be a state's sole responsibility. From Wiki:

Marriage law refers to the legal requirements which determine the validity of a marriage , which vary considerably between countries.

..By establishing rights and obligations in societies...Therefore, marriage in and of itself is strictly a "societal construct" and is not a US Constitutional Protection.

A district court should not be able to override, as I see it, if we look at the origin of the issue itself---marriage as a societal construct---is not a Law to be a member of that society, and not a Federal Jurisdiction.

I don't think forcing California into a Gay marriage state is Constitutional.

(Just to note, I'm not against Gay unions, I just don't think 'forcing' value systems on societies (states) was how it was supposed to work, if that is what is happening in Cali or anywhere else in the US.)

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Aeonpax    13 years ago

No one is forcing Californians into same sex marriage, it's just that those in a same sex relationship, may marry.

As we are as a country, a republic, not a democracy, the US Constitution prevents the minority protection against the arbitrary and capricious whims of the majority. Government should not be intruding into the private affairs of citizens, and Prop 8 does that. In this case, if it is a state that does that, remedy can be sought for from the Federal courts.

The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals issued a 21 majority opinion affirming the judgment in Perry v. Schwarzenegger, which declared Proposition 8 unconstitutional.

In regards to that opinion, SCOTUS stated;

  • Chief Justice John Roberts , speaking for the 5-4 majority, said the private sponsors of Prop. 8 did not have legal standing to appeal after the ballot measure was struck down by a federal judge in San Francisco. - "We have never before upheld the standing of a private party to defend the constitutionality of a state statute when state officials have chosen not to," he said. "We decline to do so for the first time here."
 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

Semantics... :)

What I'm saying is that I don't agree that the District Court should be able to override an issue that should not be their Jurisdiction to do so...but just a minute, while I look closer to the issue of "private party...state statute...and state officials choosing not to."

Oh, but before I do, no, I didn't say that I thought anyone was being forced into Gay marriage---what I said was, "forcing value systems on societies"---meaning, that the majority of citizens don't want that value system as a part of their society... and a society, as a state, should have the final say on that---not a Federal District court, as I see it.

...As I pointed out, marriage is by definition, a "societal construct," not a state or Federal Law as a requirement for citizenship of state societies, so the societies involved should have the control. ...Ok, since I don't know what the state as a whole 'wants' or what their state Constitution says, I'm going to C/P the Wiki statement regarding Prop 8 (some overlap from iarnuocon's comment):

Proposition 8 was a California ballot proposition and a state constitutional amendment passed in the November 2008 state elections . The measure added a new provision, Section 7.5 of the Declaration of Rights, to the California Constitution , which provides that "only marriage between a man and a woman is valid or recognized in California." [ 2 ] [ 3 ] [ 4 ]

By restricting the recognition of marriage to opposite-sex couples , the proposition effectively overturned the California Supreme Court 's ruling of In re Marriage Cases that same-sex couples have a constitutional right to marry . The wording of Proposition 8 was precisely the same as that which had been found in Proposition 22 , which had passed in 2000 and, as an ordinary statute, had been invalidated by the State Supreme Court in 2008. California's State Constitution put Proposition 8 into immediate effect the day after the election. [ 5 ] The proposition did not affect domestic partnerships in California, [ 6 ] nor same-sex marriages performed before November 5, 2008. [ 7 ] [ 8 ] [ 9 ]

After the elections , demonstrations and protests occurred across the state and nation. Same-sex couples and government entities filed numerous lawsuits with the California Supreme Court challenging the proposition's validity and effect on previously administered same-sex marriages. In Strauss v. Horton , the California Supreme Court upheld Proposition 8, but allowed existing same-sex marriages to stand (under the grandfather clause principle).

United States District Court Judge Vaughn Walker overturned Proposition 8 on August 4, 2010 in Perry v. Schwarzenegger , ruling that it violated both the Due Process and Equal Protection clauses of the U.S. Constitution . [ 10 ] Walker issued an injunction against enforcing Proposition 8 and a stay to determine suspension of his ruling pending appeal. [ 11 ] [ 12 ] A Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals panel affirmed the federal district court's decision on February 7, 2012, [ 13 ] but the stay remained in place as appeals continued to the U.S. Supreme Court , [ 14 ] which heard oral arguments on March 26, 2013. [ 15 ]

On June 26, 2013, the Supreme Court ruled in Hollingsworth v. Perry that the proponents of Proposition 8 did not have legal standing to appeal the U.S. District Courts' ruling, since the state government refused to defend it. [ 16 ] Same sex marriage in California does not resume until the federal district court removes the stay of effect that prevents its ruling of unconstitutionality from reversing the amendment to the state constitution. [ 17 ] [ 18 ] [ 19

____

APax, I don't see that Prop 8 was originally "intruding in the private affairs" of citizens when it was a ballot meaure and Amendment that passed ! ..stated here:

Proposition 8 was a California ballot proposition and a state constitutional amendment passed in the November 2008 state elections . The measure added a new provision, Section 7.5 of the Declaration of Rights, to the California Constitution , which provides that "only marriage between a man and a woman is valid or recognized in California." [2] [3] [4]

Where's the "private" in that ?

___

After the elections , demonstrations and protests occurred across the state and nation. Same-sex couples and government entities filed numerous lawsuits with the California Supreme Court challenging the proposition's validity and effect on previously administered same-sex marriages. In Strauss v. Horton , the California Supreme Court upheld Proposition 8, but allowed existing same-sex marriages to stand (under the grandfather clause principle).

So, ok, a minority same-sex group wasn't happy---but still, the ballot passed! That's what matters---not what a minority want. And, they had their grandfathered clause, so the minority group affected would seem to be even smaller!

___

United States District Court Judge Vaughn Walker overturned Proposition 8 on August 4, 2010 in Perry v. Schwarzenegger , ruling that it violated both the Due Process and Equal Protection clauses of the U.S. Constitution . [10] Walker issued an injunction against enforcing Proposition 8 and a stay to determine suspension of his ruling pending appeal. [11] [12] A Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals panel affirmed the federal district court's decision on February 7, 2012, [13] but the stay remained in place as appeals continued to the U.S. Supreme Court , [14] which heard oral arguments on March 26, 2013.

Now, this is where I start to disagree---I do not agree that a Federal Court has jurisdiction to override a societal construct and state Constitution that was put in place with a balloted measure---that is not a law for citizenship-- it doesn't have anything to do with civil rights. Here's a definition of Civil Rights from Merriam Webster that infer citizenship and voting, not societal constructs such as marriage :

Definition of CIVIL RIGHTS

: the nonpolitical rights of a citizen; especially : the rights of personal liberty guaranteed to United States citizens by the 13th and 14th amendments to the Constitution and by acts of Congress
For Gays to infer marriage as part of civil rights, then I don't see how they can view discriminating mens and womens restrooms as much different --- that too is a societal construct...not a civil right..nor are due process or the equal protection clause violated by requiring a male and female to use different facilities---even tho they might 'identify' with the opposite gender. Sorry, but I think our Federal Government is seriously overstepping its jurisdiction...violating and interpreting for someone's else's benefit other than what the state's ballot determined.
___
We don't have to agree. And I know I can't get a Federal Government to do its job when it should, and keep its nose out of a state's (society) business when it shouldn't be there....but I CAN have an opinion ... and that's all that I am doing. Grin.gif
 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Aeonpax    13 years ago

Semantics IS the law which is why many key articles, phrases and concepts of law are in Latin, which is a dead language hence such words cannot have their meanings changed.

  • forcing value systems on societies

The US, in reality, is a society of many different culture systems and within it, many different values. Each has constitutional rights and under law, one is no greater than the other. Being gay is NOT a culture unto itself, by definition; it is an sexual orientation. Homosexual value systems are no different than heterosexual value systems and in almost all cases are the same. Their sexual preference is not a value system .

  • societal construct

This begs the question; what is a societal construct ? Such a phrase has no set definition and is often used to state a concept arising from the conditions set by society. To that extent, racism is clearly a societal construct meaning, whether or not humans are predisposed to prejudice. My point is, that phrase is pretty ambiguous and can mean many things.

In the case of marriage being a societal construct , that phrase is meaningless unless it is put in context. Ive seen it used most often in reference to ones belief in the morality of marriage. But morals themselves are not the domain of government. Therefore, a government body seeking to restrict a marriage (Prop 8) based on the implied immorality of same sexes entering into it is unconstitutional.

Prop 8 was a morality issue from the start. The matter of contention here is Perry v. Brown which spawned Hollingsworth v. Perry. You can find a good and fair analysis of the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals decision regarding Prop 8 here: Here .

Historically, marriage predates the Judeo-Christian concepts and (in the vernacular) were heathen or pagan rituals. Making matters worse, women in these marriages were considered property and as far back as Babylonia, were written into the laws as being taxable property. Even to this day, many married women are treated as property plus most of the worlds marriages are done well outside of the Judeo-Christian tradition which would include the US Justice of the Peace kind. No one faith or religion owns marriage regardless of tradition or custom.

Regardless of yours or my definition of what constitutes Civil Rights, partisan rhetoric aside, I will respectfully agree to disagree with you on this issue.

 
 
 
Neetu2
Freshman Silent
link   Neetu2    13 years ago

CL, I don't think the Constitution is "forcing" gay unions or marriages; it merely states they do not violate the definition of marriage. Marriage is a societal construct, sure, and it should be up to the parties concerned to choose who they marry and not be obstructed by laws or out-dated definitions of marriage.

 
 
 
Neetu2
Freshman Silent
link   Neetu2    13 years ago

Scalia is just a cranky old man!Smile.gif

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Aeonpax    13 years ago
  • It legally invalidates the 9th Circuit decision, not the District Court decision,

Maybe I'm reading something wrong here but according to this article;

  • "We have never before upheld the standing of a private party to defend the constitutionality of a state statute when state officials have chosen not to. We decline to do so for the first time here," the majority Court statement (which broke along the typical 5-4 line) said. That means there is no specific decision from the Court regarding Prop 8, and the previous ruling, by Judge Vaughan Walker and upheld by the Ninth Circuit Court, that invalidated Prop 8 as discriminatory, stands" . - ...

I am to gather then that Judge Vaughan Walker's ruling stands as is but how does the SCOTUS ruling "invalidate" what the Ninth said in upholding Walkers decision? The justices were referring to the Supreme Court and not any of the Appellate courts.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

Marriage is a societal construct---not a Federal law as a condition to be a citizen, and that is why it is up to the the state (as a society) to define their own definition of marriage.

You are right a Constitution of the US does not force same-sex marriage onto states---Gay judges that are "interpreting" Amendments in their own favor are!!

Smile.gif

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

Prop 8 should not be a Federal matter, and DOMA is only to make sure Gays get the Fed benefits to which they are entitled under state jurisdiction.

 
 
 
evilone
Professor Guide
link   evilone    13 years ago

The Loving ruling made marriage a right. The Constitution grants equal protection.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

I'm not forcing a view of "marriage" - that is up to a state to define their definition of marriage. If it was up to a Federal Government, then marriage would be a law for citizenship to which the Feds could 'force' and tax every citizen accordingly -- due to a citizens' compliance or non-compliance of a Federal marriage law. That currently fictitious scenario is not how it was supposed to work. That isn't why people broke away from the Kings and started anew here. They wanted control of their commonalities (society) as a body of people, that we call "states." As a majority, they wanted to have a value system and is why they have a State Constitution. A Federal government's jurisdiction should be to 'assist' a state's Constitution, as the desire of the majority, not strike it down, by aiding an individual's protections afforded them by that State Constitution.

I have never agreed that case law should ever be used to override a state Constitution..It was a case and cases vary in the details/circumstances. So because my neighbor killed their spouse and it was found to be self-defense, should become a precedent for the legality of people killing their spouses? I have never agreed that interracial marriage should have any Federal ties to it. That also should be up to a state's majority value system, just as Gay marriage should be. It's the 'state' that should determine their definition of marriage--the Federal Government is out of their jurisdiction in mandating it as a Federal law to determine who can and can't get married.

Please don't misinterpret me; I'm not passing judgment on who should or shouldn't get married---I'm just saying that it isn't a Natural Law as self-evident---it's a societal construct, therefore subject to a state law. Marriage has nothing to do with being inhumane (e.g. raping, beating, murdering and other such forms of inhumanity that certain other cultures don't see as 'harm'), which IS part of our legal system and LAW, and civil rights as a citizen.. I can't stress the citizen relevance enough---in regards to marriage of any kind! It's not a requirement to be married to be a citizen--the Feds should be out of it. Period!

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

As I've said, it is "clear" that equal protection refers to what is already National Law and guaranteeing that citizens rights to those laws are met. Same with civil liberties-- Internet definition of civil liberties:

civil liberties

Web definitions
(civil liberty) one's freedom to exercise one's rights as guaranteed under the laws of the country.

"Laws of the country" -- but we also have laws of a state--therefore, a civil right and a civil liberty would be (or should be) only dictating that which is self-evident and determined by the Nation as a national value system (e.g. re: rape, murder, physical abuse, mental abuse, embezzlement and whatever the national value system upholds). Marriage is NOT a national requirement of our rule of law. It should not have ties to a Federal Government mandate of who can and cannot marry...It IS strictly a societal construct whether you want to admit it or not. Grin.gif

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

I will respectfully agree to disagree with you on this issue.

Agreed. Smile.gif

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

A "right" can be a national law or a state law---there is a reason why there needs to be both---one is to protect what the nation views as self-evident as a Natural Law that evolved into what we call Legal Law. Yes, the US Constitution grants "equal protection" of what we as a "Nation" consider self-evident---marriage of any kind does not (or should not be misinterpreted) fall under the dictates of a National rule that one must be married, or in any way/shape/or form dictate what should constitute a marriage. That's what a state law is for....everything 'else' that is 'not' under Federal mandate to be a legal citizen.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

was FORCE the states to recognize one and only one definition of marriage, by creating a WHOLE set of laws,

That's been my point all along, but not in agreement.

The Feds should not have ANY jurisdiction in determining what constitutes a marriage, who can and cannot get married and what the rights and responsibilities in a marriage ARE!!! DOMA's primary purpose was to 'aid' the rights, responsibilities and benefits of marriage in a state...any authority they have taken upon themselves to define what a marriage is, who can and cannot marry, is unethical and immoral, as I see it...I tend to see it as a violation of our BoR.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

Yes, the US Constitution applies to all Americans, so to be moral, ethical, democratic and as fair as possible---- Judicial Review should be a process of the body of citizens, not a group of 9 that are just as human as the rest of us, that tend to interpret rather than send it back to "the people" for clarification of Constitutionality.

Again, a Federal Government is to 'assist' the states in maintaining US Constitutional protections and aid them in upholding their state Constitutions (at least should be) and should only strike down if a Federal/National Law is violated. "Interpretation" of a law should be left to the jurisdiction that should logically hold the authority---and Marriage should obviously be one of them.

___

P.S. to anyone here---if I did not reply to a comment of yours, it's probably due to my not seeing it. My email format consolidates the users, not necessarily showing each comment, and I sometimes forget to scroll down the email page for subsequent comments.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

To all,

You know, we can all quibble back and forth on this issue (and others) over why we think what the Federal Government's involvement in issues should be, but it all boils down to one thing:

..The more states' rights and choices we let them remove, forcing a Federal compliance/mandate, the more social unrest will escalate; and we all know that eventually leads to a revolution.

The hard-core Libs say, to the effect, "Oh just let everyone do whatever they want" (other than harm), and their dissenters say, to the effect, "But what you do around my children affects an immature, naive and vulnerable mind (and yes, kids do mimic rather than rationally 'decide' on things), so I want to protect them from you until they are older and better equipped to decide for themselves."

I personally think there should be a place for both mindsets in our Nation, and neither one should be forced to live by the standards of the other. I just don't know how a diverse nation can reasonably accomplish that. Sexual orientation is 'naturally' a choice, but experimentation still happens...and kids do experiment with what is happening in their environments.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

The Civil War was an 'economic war' that included 'physical,' social change, but that doesn't mean that it precluded the ethics of states' rights (the will of the people in societies).

If you were correct in your statement, that a notion of states' rights never existed, then you must 'not' -also- acknowledge the 1st and other Amendments that are meant to 'restrict' the power of Congress in areas other than their specified enumerations---delineations that separate the Federal Government from the unspecified rights of "the people" - and because the people reside in states, that would logically conclude "states' rights."

AND---I did not say that anything will "cause" kids to be Gay...you read into that something that I was not implicating. And, pretending to be Gay does/can happen because they can think it is 'cool' to be so among their friends, but I was not implicating that causes them to be Gay---I was implicating everything else.

If you think "conversations" is all it takes for common-sense and intelligence---then you are just as naive as they are!

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Aeonpax    13 years ago

Too bad you did NOT address the question in regards to your statement;

  • "It legally invalidates the 9th Circuit decision, not the District Court decision" - "how does the SCOTUS ruling "invalidate" what the Ninth said in upholding Walkers decision?'

The decision by the Ninth Curcuit agreed with Judge Vaugh's decision that Proposition 8 is unconstitutional under both the Due Process and Equal Protection Clauses. This prohibits "anyone" (since the state California is NOT going to challenge it) from using that same venue to redress this same issue.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

And misinterpreting what I say doesn't improve your position any, either... I have no idea why you would say to me "your shitty kids"---you obviously must be erroneously thinking 'religion' when you said that--and there was no religious context to my words--please stop stereotyping and assuming my intentions.

My point is simply that I see a state vote as the peoples' representatives saying "this is what we want as a majority body of citizens" which is correct since we use democratic procedure (majority rule)...2) I view DOMA as a Federal agency that should not be dictating 'who' can and cannot marry as that should be a state jurisdiction; if that were true that they can, then there wouldn't still be over thirty ? states that don't have or want same-sex marriage as part of their value system; however I do think that makes sense that they should do as they currently have done which is to rule on Federal benefits.

My statement on highschoolers was something I witnessed, so I know it happens; and yes you are naive about kids if you think you can have conversations and necessarily get your way...but that's digressing and distracting the point, so please stop using fallacies to divert the point at hand which is simply----that state law when put to a vote, should rule, imo...and I do not agree that marriage is a 'right'---a right is a protection in the Constitution that is meant for 'everyone' not select citizens---and marriage is a societal construct and has nothing to do with civil rights.

I agree people should form unions and that they should have their benefits---I just want a different institution to be involved. Have marriage be to a pet, a plant, a building, a car as some dude wanted to do--whatever-- but don't expect to incorporate into a foundational system that has nothing to do with their 'value system.' Have new institutions---instead of forcing someone else to redefine theirs'.

You'll never concede your arrogance and expectations that only your way goes and no one else is entitled to a different point of view, Iarnuocon, especially when my point is not bigotry or hatred for Gays or anyone else; if someone wants a different lifestyle, fine, do it--but don't expect it to be a part of state law if the majority doesn't want it--go find or create a majority that does. That's my only point and always was--it's not about prejudice, it's about ethics, majority value systems and living in peace, like-mindedness. ..So this is pointless redundancy. We've both had our 'say' and all you have left is fallacy tactics and misinterpreted ridicule. The End

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

Apparently you aren't understanding me, EI. All I have ever been defending is that what a majority body of people say is the value system they want for their state (a societal value system) is what the final decision should be. The people should be the Judicial Review-- not a potential Gay Judge, re: 'this' issue--but I do think that Judicial Review of what Congress has approved on 'any' issue, should be up to a Nation, a body of citizens, not a group of 9 potentially biased individuals.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

I'd love to see you forced to live in the world you envision. I'm pretty sure it wouldn't work out the way you think it would.

Hey, in case you haven't bothered to look around lately instead of wallowing in righteous arrogance --- Your liberal, free-for-all isn't working out so well, either, now is it!

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

Iarnuocon, if dictating the concepts/precepts of Marriage is going to be a Federal Jurisdiction, then they had better handle it like they appear to do with so many other things that they want to control:

Make marriage a law to be followed as a rule for citizenship--you know, kinda like forcing everyone to pay for insurance--so that they can impose taxes or fees, make money from it, both from those that do comply and from those that don't.

Or, we could use common-sense, and see Marriage as the 'given societal value system that it is' and let those individuals of that particular value system, mandate their own rules for their society.

Oh wait, but that doesn't make money for the Hierarchy, nor does it give them control of our lives---- scratch that idea. Although, I wouldn't scratch it for too long, because even though you refuse to see it, taking away our democratic principles in favor of Federal control, is not going to fly in the long run.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

As an additional point :

Here's an excerpt from a very astute ex-viner's comment that shows how History is in the process of repeating itself and the ignorant here totally won't get it:

" Much ink has been spilt of latein an attempt todraw parallels between todays United States and Ancient Rome. Who could have predicted how closelya Supreme Court metaphor picked on a whim ended up reflecting reality? "

Until 300 BC only patricians could become augures. Plebeian assemblies were forbidden to take augury and hence had no input as to whether a certain law, war or festival should occur. Cicero, an augur himself, accounts how the monopoly of the patricians created a useful barrier to the encroachment of the populares . [10] However in 300 BC a new law Lex Ogulnia, increased the number of augures from four to nine and required that five of the nine be plebeians, granting, for the first time, the ability to interpret the will of the Gods to lower classes. With this new power, it was not only possible for plebeians to determine the gods will in their favor but it was also now possible for plebeians to critique unfair interpretations by patricians.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

Ohhhh....EI, I can only love you for your unique and ubiquitous approach to points being made. Grin.gif

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

Yes, you do misinterpret me (and others). Your own preconceptions, narcissistic prejudice of others, and desire to view me and others as second-class citizens, due to your support of Liberal and Federal control, seems to always stand in the way of our communicating without you resorting to tactics and ridicule. You refuse to acknowledge majority rule (as a valid point) - democratic procedure (I know we are not a Democracy...and a good thing we aren't).

I do not agree that Marriage is a "right," in the same sense that our other Constitutional protections are, as civil liberties as I have already explained, and I do not acknowledge DOMA exercising any authority in dictating a definition of marriage, also already covered, and justified by the electoral.

I have also presented a solution (as another valid point) that instead of forcing an Institution to redefine itself, an opposing value system should create a new Institution engaging the benefits that other groups are entitled.

If you do not understand or accept my points as valid--then that's your problem, not mine.

__

Come on, admit it. You support the Government because you work for the Government...you're just doing what every other selfish Liberal does--watching out for your own self-interests and benefits at the expense of loss of choice for the rest of us.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

iar, we are a Republic that uses representative democratic procedure that offers protections to the individual that is 'legally' oppressed by the majority using substantive due process. I agree with that in some cases. Please don't continue to misinterpret me. I was NOT suggesting mob rule in the sense of allowing the majority to circumvent legal systems---and that means that the MINORITY also should not be allowed to circumvent legal systems using the Federal Government to override state laws, use Gay Judges (can't remember his name), or use the Judiciary to 'interpret' language, using the 14th, to favor a minority Group (of any type).

That is my point, and I'm sure you know it; you just continue to misconstrue my points because you don't like me. So be it.

I don't agree with using Case Law as precedence. I don't see it as ethical. Cases vary in circumstances and detail, and while portions might be similar to another, that shouldn't make them a determinate for a different set of circumstances.

I will continue to stand behind *marriage is not a US Constitutional 'right,'* despite the Feds putting their nose where it doesn't belong.

A state should 'define' their value system behind marriage. A Federal government can assist an individual that for some reason is oppressed by 'that' definition. If you're for an 'anything goes' approach to government, then that's your opinion, but I doubt you'd be happy with that---just like you think I wouldn't be happy with a public Judicial Review.

___

EI, ...No, I didn't say that I think interracial relationships should be illegal. Here's my nutshell: There is a reason, as I see it, that we have a Federal Government value system AND a state Government value system; yes, a Fed should step in, if a state is being unfair or not honoring their law for some reason, but the larger view should simply be that their primary job should be to uphold what every state in the union values as moral and ethical-- Natural Law, to not harm as we view it, what is 'self-evident.' "Everything else" that doesn't fall under that Heading (all of the social issues, regulations (and imo, commerce), etc. should be up to the state. That means that not every personal whim is going to be acceptable, or shouldn't be. So, who should decide what is acceptable and what shouldn't be acceptable if not the majority ? We do allow a lot of leeway as a majority, functioning from a 'harm' criteria, allowing individuality, but again, who is going to decide what constitutes 'harm' if not the majority?

No, I'm not saying "that the only judge who could have presided over that trial should have been a radical religious blowhard." I was thinking about a Judge that would have a reason to be prejudice in this topic, but there was an article that involved that scenario; I don't remember his name or what year that was.

The simple fact is that if that judges argument was incorrect, then that judge would have had his decision overturned, but nope, he had a VERY reasoned argument for his decision. The reasoning was in itself VERY valid.

The private party issue?

Only proposition 9 wasn't devised or passed by a legislature. I am not sure why something has to be repeated 10 billion times, but in California, a law doesn't have to go through the legislature to become a law. All you need is enough signatures on a piece of paper and it goes up for a vote in the next election cycle.

LOL...are you sure it wasn't only 5 billion instead of 10 billion..:)

What you might not realize is that seems irrelevant to me as to 'how' something gets on the ballot...I mean, we can write-in names for President on a ballot!! The point that is pertinent is what gets voted on by the majority and passed...not who put it on the ballot.

 
 

Who is online






73 visitors