National Service - Good for the U.S. or Not?
I have heard and read many opinions on national service and the as on most issues in the country today there is a huge ideological chasm between the supporters and those against the concept.
National service does not mean the military, it could and should include a Conservation Corps, the Peace Corps, and participation in othermanners government service and support to the people (such as national parks, infrastructure projects, public schools, public hospitals) at the federal and state level
America has had its share of traumas lately the shooting in Newtown, Conn., the bombing in Boston, and disasters in West, Texas, and Norman, Okla.
After letters and donations overwhelmed Newtown, its postmaster remarked: This is just the proof of the love thats in this country.
The citizens of Boston emerged from their homes to spontaneously cheer their law enforcement personnel and first responders, honoring public service and sacrifice.
Contributions poured in to help the people of Texas and Oklahoma.
In each case, Americans suffered together and overcame together. At least for a time, they felt we all felt like a single country.
That has been an exception in recent years. Our politics have little sense of common purpose. Americans are ideologically polarized.
Perhaps one reason Americans cheer for service and sacrifice and respond so strongly in times of crisis is because they miss these values and the hope they represent for uniting the country.
So how do we encourage a generation of Americans to take seriously the responsibilities of citizenship? How can we help connect the rising generation to one another and the country? How can we foster more leaders who, regardless of their political beliefs, work together to solve Americas problems again?
Exhortation is not enough.
What we truly value, we institutionalize.
To educate, we build universities. To cure, we build hospitals.
To make citizens, we must facilitate the shared experiences that cultivate civic pride and responsibility.
This should mean a period of full-time national service as a rite of passage for every young American, ages 18 to 28. Such service could be military or civilian.
Young adults could choose the Army or Peace Corps, Marine Corps or AmeriCorps, the Navy or VISTA. National service would be optional, but expected.
Every college admissions officer or employer must start to ask, Where did you serve?
http://www.politico.com/story/2013/06/national-service-is-key-to-national-strength-93069.html
Tags
Who is online
69 visitors

This should mean a period of full-time national service as a rite of passage for every young American, ages 18 to 28. Such service could be military or civilian.
All citizens, no exceptions!! A means to bring people from all parts and strata of the society together focused on common goals and learning from each others
And yet we have men (and soon young women likely too) register for selective service when they reach the age of 18
"A couple years out of a lifetime never hurt anyone serving some one else instead of them selves." Tell that to my uncle that was forced into slavery in Vietnam and came back missing one eye.
Gunny
I could not agree more
The young people participating in civilian service programs or the military (their choice) would learn about themselves, about the world they live in and about what they want to do with their lives.
The country would benefit as well and this national service would be the balancing weight to every young person be eligible for four years of college at a public university at no expense.
not likely
Gunny
I agree the four years of college is tuition only
badfish
Not registering for the selective service is breaking the law, don't know about you but I respect the rule of law in this country
If national service was something everyone participated in then the benefits they received at its completion would not be coercion
Dean
Not sure I see the relevance of your contribution based on the topic of the article
Care to explain the relevance
I love it!
The perfect example of Libertarian hypocrisy!
They want the right to be free as citizens in every sense of the aforementioned words, but they don't want the obligation to lift a finger towards securing that citizenship or those freedoms.
Priceless!
Gotta admit, I'm torn on this one Robert. I think a stint of national service sounds like a great idea for those who have no problem with it (I sure as heck don't). I start to balk at the idea when it becomes mandatory. I could support it if it was all carrots and no sticks.
So much for citizenship....
Then we will stay with the status quo.... All volunteer, and take our lumps along the way.
We are in this country as one we should protect it as one.
Spot on target Gunny. Our country asks very little of it's citizens. The bitch is trying to convince them of that case.
Involuntary servitude is slavery. You guys need to talk to my friend Ernst he was forced into involuntary servitude by both Mussolini and Hitler as a youth. After a few years he escaped and joined the French foreign legion so he could shoot back at those that enslaved him.
"It's partisan troll bait/feed" That could be true that theLibertarianparty is the only party left that defends freedom from slavery.
It comes down to a matter of choice. I chose to serve, not for 2 years buy for 8, and I get the benefits of that choice I made as did the country. But when you start to take away a persons right to choose, for whatever reason, that can have effects beyond the single topic of national service. A person must be free to decide what choices they make and live with the benefits or the consequences. Right of choice must always be protected. A free society, a free community can only be comprised of free individuals, not compelled by force.
Chucky
Maybe those who serve get the Pell Grants and those that don't get student loans for college
E I
Not actually
The PELL Grant program would be ended
The national service programs would be established and an education grant (four years of college tuition at a public school) would be established and given to those that volunteered to serve.
I fail to see the constitutional issue, since everyone would have the same opportunity to serve and receive the grant for a college education
Those freely choosing to not serve, would be exercising their freedom of choice
Dean
Your input still lacks relevance to the topic but thanks for stopping by
badfish
The article offers it as a possible solution so I guess that is suggestive, but if it were established as voluntary and tied to receiving a free college education I think we would see more people willing to serve which in the end would benefit the nation and give deserving people an education without the burden of student loans
It is relevant if you are suggesting mandatory service. I got that impression from this.
"This should mean a period of full-time national service as a rite of passage for every young American, ages 18 to 28. Such service could be military or civilian."
Used to be the draft. You knew you were gonna get drafted for service in the military at a certain age. I think many of the problems began in our society after they did away with it.
People got lazy, disrespectful, started experiencing low self worth and symptoms of depression, hanging on the corner with drugs.
I think the draft was good fo all these reasons and people actually had respect for themselves and honored the country they served. Geesh, im old! lol
Let me re phrase that. By going into the military, it seemed to make men out of boys. They many times went in as a trouble maker and came out someone who was proud of themselves, confident with good self esteem. Yes, in ways it did prevent those things. I think they should re instate something of this nature and call it whatever they want to call it. It doesnt have to be war related.
Hmmm.. I don't know, Robert, I'm not sure that I agree that "service" should be a requirement, and it certainly doesn't seem to be a part of what we define as a "citizen." I agree with BadFish that forcing us to be a part of Service seems to be removing our concept of being a "free" man.
I know President Obama is trying to legislate a forced program of either military or community service, and I don't agree with that, either.
___
From Dictionary.com:
citizen
[ sit - uh -z uhchloe
Thanks for the feedback and perhaps you are right that compulsory service is a step too far
I opined above that perhaps it is voluntary and participants get four years of college paid for and the Pell Grant programs are otherwise eliminated.
Since you brought up the definition of a citizen, one could also interpret .....
....as serving when needed rather than when we want to serve which would allow for compulsory service
But that is a debate for another time
Again thanks for the feedback
flameaway
No worries and thanks for the feedback
Dean
The price we "should" pay for the freedoms and gifts we receive from our country but you obviously do not feel you owe your country anything
Ok I accept that
Thanks for the feedback and your perspective
Mickey
Absolutely correct in my view as well!
National service sounds like a great idea. However, those with power and money will easily avoid it, so to that extent, it doesn't seem fair.
I wish you were right about this but history says otherwise. George Bush in the Texas Air National Guard comes to mind.
E I
National service military or non military for everyone that is physically able