U.S. border 'surge' would place agent every 1,000 feet
"
(Reuters) - The 2,000-mile (3,200-km) boundary between the United States and Mexico would have enough border patrol agents to station one guard every 1,000 feet, under a compromise measure being considered by the U.S. Senate as part of an effort to pass a comprehensive immigration reform bill.
It would also provide for the completion of 700 miles of fencing, observation towers, manned and unmanned aerial vehicles, radar and even seismic devices to prevent foreigners from illegally crossing the border, according to a description provided by a sponsor of the compromise.
The buildup of agents equipped with high-tech night-vision goggles, radar devices and electronic sensors was so reminiscent to some senators of past U.S. combat missions in Iraq that supporters openly boasted about the southwestern border "surge" - even as some civil liberties activists complained about border communities being turned into militarized zones.
The huge deployment is being proposed to try to assure Republicans that the border is secure under Senate legislation supported by President Barack Obama that would open a pathway to citizenship for up to 11 million undocumented immigrants in the United States.
Republicans have said repeatedly they would not support a comprehensive immigration bill unless it stopped foreigners from illegally crossing the U.S.-Mexico border.
The cost of the extra deployment is estimated to range between $40 billion and $50 billion, congressional aides said, at a time of budgetary retrenchment pushed primarily by Republicans in Congress. Whether the money is ever appropriated-and the new agents deployed would depend on future Congresses.
"I think it's overkill," said Democratic Senator Dick Durbin, who was one of the bipartisan group of senators who crafted the original bill. "This notion of doubling the number of people on the border and 700 more miles of fence is really trying to appease some Republicans who want a dramatic show of force on the border," he said.
According to a release by Senator Bob Corker of Tennessee, one of the authors of the amendment, the bill would add 20,000 border patrol agents along the southern border to the 18,500 already stationed there."
http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/06/21/us-usa-immigration-border-idUSBRE95K04520130621
Tags
Who is online
68 visitors

I don't know, do you think it's "over-kill" to double the people and have 700 more miles of fence?
That's a sad thought, BF. Too political and financial for business to get them to correct what needs to be done.
From what I've heard there is going to be a surge on the border to be in place to receive the benefits of an illegal immigrant. Being a citizen can be pretty costly if you decide to try and make something of yourself.
You have me thinking about how much of a reality that 'could' turn into!
I think we should move all the politicians in Washington including the President and Family to San Juan, Texas or right across the Mexican border from CIUDAD JUAREZ, Mexico.
Instead of building that fence or really getting serious about making the USA less desirable for illegal immigrants and others who want to cross the border into the USA, build houses for the politicians to live in during their term or terms in office and make it a requirement for them to have to spend 75% of there term living there unprotected by whatever just so happens to come across the border.
Now I think that would be a good start on improving our immigration policy, don't you?
I mean there are already people living there so the politicians won't be alone. And Janet Napolitano can open her front door and see Mexico less than 100 yards away.
Dick Durbin can be her next door neighbor.
Now I do believe things would start changing right away.
A link you don't want to miss.....
What a great speaker. Can't keep my leg still.
Oh yes... and so true for many other situations!
Here is a link that you'll find interesting. A little known group of American Indian trackers working the border.
The BP has already stated a 9% increase in Illegal Aliens in just 45 days - thanks to the immigration Super 8 Pack.
Good video...
I'm sure glad we have them, Kav. (Scalping them should be a good deterrent, too!
)
Kavika....thanks for the article. It was very interesting and enlightening and they have been scouting for generations. Nice to know someone is doing something.
I personally don't like the idea of a fence myself. I think there are other means that could act as deterrents and changing some of our laws could be beneficial. If we're using drones and surveillance equipment anyway then why not take more advantage of using it there? Just my opinion.
I just looked them up to see who they were (as if that would help me decide anything!)... a few must be wanting a freer border ? Is something more lenient now ?
Hmm.. you had me thinking about the cost vs. effectives using drones... just thought I'd link what I was reading and watching:
Border drone surveillancecarries a fatpricetag as is, for one thing. Should the Gang of Eight bill pass, droning the borderwould become that much more wildly expensive. An unarmed versionof the notorious Predator goes for$18 million a pop, and runs up an hourly operational tab of $3,000.In other words,it wouldcost at least $26 million to keep a single spy drone aloft for 24/7. As I've reported here in the past , CBP brass, despite grumbling from its rank-and-file,has been pushing to expand its fleet from 10 to 24 drones. By my math, that comes out,to $624,000,000.
Read more:
Sixpick, I'm not sold on the fence idea. It just sounds like another boondoggle to me.
The neo cons will ACT like they want to secure the border ,but wont really do it, they will just underfund like they always do. Illegals cheapen the labor force. Like before the first amnesty law,landscapers were typically paid $ 10.00+ an hour.Now its betwee
n7 and 8 dollars an hour.
Lol, there's a lot of truth there, too!
___
You're giving me visions of a line in the sand with militants equipped as above on either side of the line - staring at each other ....while illegals from both sides are vaulting the wall in-between manned stations. (j/k!! - I hope)
Me either Kavika. Not sold on fence.
Major changes in the laws in this country and in some cases just enforcing the ones on the books.
Obama basically has been taking laws on the books ever since he came into office and making a change in them and claiming them as his own, when in reality the laws ware already on the books.
Like the one he likes to brag about giving women equal pay. It was already on the books, he just increased the time lawyers could have to make their money and make more as well with that extra time. I think about 30 out of 300,000,00 have taken advantage of it. Namef it after that lady. Can't remember her name at the moment.
Gave everyone the impression he got us out o Iraq, but that time limit was already set when he come into office but his minions still think Obama got us out of Iraq.
I think if you remove the sugar from the table you will find less ant climbing the legs of the table.
Don't think much of a fence as a fence will eventually not only keep you don't want in, it will also keep you from gong out.
The vast majority of Mexican's who come into the the US illegally, is because of crime or more specifically, drug related crime . From bottom to top, Mexico has become a cesspool corruption in which the drug cartels, whom are funded to the tune of billions of dollars per year by Americans buying illegal drugs, particularly marijuana.
Aside from the cost of harboring all these illegals is the additional cost of this wasteful and useless "war on drugs" which we are not winning and is only making the corporations rich, for example: War On Drugs Biggest Corporate Welfare Program In History: Obama Wa... , which of course is supported by our corporate puppet of a president.
From the Mexican perspective, life in the US as an illegal is by far safer and more economically productive than at home. Make no mistake, Mexicans love their country and would sooner continue to live there than in "el norte."
The answer to this problem is so simple - Legalize marijuana. It will cut into the illegal revenue the cartels are making by at least 2/3rds, if not more. That would also cut the money we spend on this fake war by the same amount.
This will not totally solve the Mexican corruption problem, but it will cut deeply into the bribes and pay offs that fund it.
I think its over kill to the tune of 30 mil bucks, yes I do. Especially at a time when we cannot afford meals on wheels for our seniors. So.....how come the ones squalling about cutting the deficit and debt are not constrained by their own rules again? So much for all that smaller government. Waste of money? absolutely, its a buy off for votes is all.
I ask.......do we even know what they are voting for? Voting for, doing something, moving forward is not necessarily the right thing to do by voting for something you don't even know anything about.
There were several who said they were for the immigration bill, even before it was written. Just being for something and voting for it doesn't mean it is the right thing to do. How many of us even know what is contained in the immigration law?
They changed it last Thursday by adding 300 amendments and Harry Reid says we're going to vote on it today Monday June 24, 2013.
Take a look at it and see if you would vote for it. I guess it depends on what party you are affiliated with will determine your answer as it seems whatever the leaders of the Democrats come up with the Democrats are ready to vote for even before they have even come up with a bill.
The difference is the Republicans, some will vote for it and some will not. They aren't voting like robots.
Has anyone read the bill? I bet I've read more of it than 95% of Congress. Just last Thursday theu added nealy 300 amendments and Harry said they were going to vote on it Monday which is today. June 24,2013.
United States Senate Committee on Judiciary Click on Sponsors1-(MDM13313) -to read the new version.
I say give everyone a cutoff date to report and receive a work card and permission to have a visa to work here that is renewable. If they decide they want citizenship, then do it the proper way and make the legal immigrants happy all their effort wasn't in vain.
After the cutoff date anyone without a work card giving them permission to be here and work gets deported. Anyone employing people with no work card gets Any who employs someone without a work card or proof they aren't American citizens receives a very heavy fine. No benefits. Right now they would have to make $46,000 per individual and we know that is a crock. That's fair.
Believe it or not there are many that don't want to be American Citizens, but only want to improve their lives. Why the rush? After all it has been 25 years this has been going on and as far as the American people this doesn't even rate on the top 10 most important things they are concerned with, but you wouldn't believe that with the government media and White House promoting it like they have.
They just run you guys around like little electric robots.
I've heard many who have come here legally aren't interested in making entry into this country so easy. You won't hear any of their voices unless you change channels and look them up.
A Legal Immigrant's Take on Illegal Immigration
Our president today makes his way to the southern border. Over the past few months, various states have followed, to a greater or less extent, the path blazed last year by Arizona, when it took legislative steps to deal with a problem of illegal immigration that the federal government has consistently failed to solve.
The law in question in Arizona was SB 1070. When it passed, I was an immigrant resident of that state.
When I received my greencard two years ago, I was sent a letter from the Department of Homeland Security -- the same letter that is sent to thousands of new immigrants every week -- from which I quote:
Pretty clear.
While a permanent resident, I am here as a guest, and my carrying my "greencard" is a reasonable step on the path to becoming a proud American -- "reasonable" because any nation needs to know whom it lets in, as part of its responsibility to the security of its citizens.
My rights here depend on the rule and enforcement of law, applied equally to all, regardless of background or color. For that reason, the backlash against new state immigration laws is not in any true sense "liberal" or "progressive". A liberal should support the rule of law that protects the security and the rights of its individual citizens.
Not only is SB 1070 blind to color and ethnicity: it protects immigrants from being asked for documents without reasonable suspicion of a violation of the law of which I was notified when I became an immigrant. Therefore, Arizona's law offered immigrants a protection that is not offered to them in the "Welcome to America" letter I quoted at the top of this article.
The true racism around such laws lies in the idea that we should not seek to enforce established law equally because we want to give a particular ethnic group -- singled out only because we assume rightly or wrongly, that group tends more than any other to violate that particular law (!) -- a pass on their legal obligations.
Shouting "racism" where there is none seeks to promote division to the benefit of the group that makes the claim. Evils can only be eliminated when honestly identified. For that reason, I hope that any law officer that implements SB 1070 or any other law with a bias for or against one race or community suffers the full force of the laws that already protect us all against that evil. But that does not speak against recent attempts by states to protect themselves from the increasingly violent consequences of illegal immigration.
The logic of the position of much of the Left on State crackdowns on illegal immigration seems to be, "the laws are unfair because they support discrimination against a particular group that is much more likely to be breaking that law -- even though the same law states that not even basic checks of identity (let alone arrest etc.) can be made until there is reasonable suspicion that the relevant law is being broken". What is meant is that as long as the group that violates a law has a racial identity, we should have no such law. That is to argue from race.
America's immigration system needs radical reform to allow more good, hard-working people of whatever origin to contribute to the USA.
Those who really want to help immigrants should first learn about the current "legal" immigration system that incentivizes illegal immigration.
It is my fantasy to sit one day as a witness in a Congressional Committee on immigration, and to tell of the 700 pages I had to compile each time I renewed my visa; the $200 I had to pay for a photocopy of one sheet of paper from the Department of Homeland Security; the fact that even after I paid, the DHS didn't send me that document for 200 days, until someone who knew someone made a call to a "special number" etc..
I would tell the Committee that the immigration problem is not so difficult to solve. Secure the border simply because security is the first duty of government, and then do the following.
First, prohibit anyone who has committed a visa/immigration violation from ever becoming a permanent resident (and therefore citizen) of the country. A violator who has American family here may remain only under rolling sponsorship of their American spouse.
This will change the incentive calculus for illegal immigrants, and will deal with one of the most important immigration statistics that you have never heard: from 2000 to 2007, two thirds of all legal Mexican immigrants (who represented 35% of all immigrants to the USA) were once here illegally! Those immigrants are making completely rational choices given the system we have, and for commendable reasons. The fault is not with them. It is with us as Americans. This two-thirds compares with the mere 9% of all immigrants who become immigrants legally through work. (Yes, 9%.)
Second, limit family-based immigration to immediate family only. Allow a new citizen to sponsor only his spouse and children into the country - and perhaps, if he can prove the means to support them, elderly parents when they need care. No more uncles, aunties, cousins, grandmothers etc..
Third, send a test case to the supreme court regarding the 14th amendment, which states,
All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside.
This amendment was passed in 1868 to ensure that all persons, including slaves and their progeny, could be citizens of the nation. Children of diplomats, foreign visitors or similar aliens are not included. Nor was the amendment intended to extend to children of illegal immigrants who perhaps more than any, are not subject to the jurisdiction of this country.
It goes without saying, I hope, that we have a moral and civic responsibility to those whom were brought here "illegally' as minors to let them settle as American citizens.
Let's finally get to the question of the constitutionality of states' legal efforts to protect themselves from illegal immigration: if such laws are unconstitutional, they must be struck down for that reason alone. But it is the height of hypocrisy by the Federal government, which fails every day in hundreds of ways to act within the confines of the Constitution, to bring suit. So once the suits against the States are done, I hope that every state in the Union should take at face value the Federal government's newly found interest in the Constitution, and sue it to force it to meet its own obligations.
They passed it after they took all the pork out of it that didn't have anything to do with Sandy. You can't trust them. They'll sneak a big bill that goes way beyond the purpose of the bill and only later do you find out all the crap included in the bill.
JW...why don't you read the bill and see what you think? You know I did put it above. Or are you one of those that just vote for anything as long as it's along party lines?
I just hope they don't pass such a watered down version that its a name only bill and nothing changes. I don't agree with the extra spent on border security tho and the reason that I don't is that under this administration border patrol has been ramped up like at no other time and illegals have been deported in large numbers as well. Im just not seeing where it is necessary if you know what I mean. It seems more of a buy off to get votes than anything else in order to get it passed. And no, my view is not party related at all but more from the research I have done on what has and has not changed in the last several years. Its overkill to me.
Enforce the laws and change some of the laws.
The laws are set up like a sugar cube sitting in the middle of this country and the illegal immigrants are like ants. The Democrat want illegal immigrants for votes. I say change the law to eliminate that and see how much interest the Democrats show for the illegals.
There are quite a few who could care less about becoming citizens. They are just running away from a bad situation from a corrupt country. If we want to help someone, help Mexico become more of a place people want to stay instead of making the USA a place they want to run to.
Our next door neighbor isn't getting any help and it really is our biggest threat while we're somewhere on the other side of the world spending $50,000,000 a day to prolong a war that isn't going to help us either way.
No six, I dont think it is the dems that want the votes at all, they already have them and it is the republicans that need to do something to gain their trust and thereby, by passing immigration it can only help them. Same with us women. And this is the ONLY reason the pubs will pass the legislation, because it will benefit them in the long run and without it?
I wish politics were not a part of it, but listen to this.
Ronald Reagan gave them amnesty and received mid 30% of their votes. Bush pushed for amnesty and got 30%. Romney got even less.
The border was promised to be secured by the Democrats with Reagan by the Democrat Congress and never happened.
So it is the votes unfortunately that makes the different in interest in the illegals. Take away the votes and see how much support you get from the Democrats.
These are the facts no matter what they want you to believe. You'd see what I mean by this.
By the way have you read the bill? Neither has Congress. I posted it above. They added 300 amendment to the original last Thursday and expect to vote on it today Monday 24, 2013.
I've already found things in there that present problems and it's not a piece of cake to read when it refers you to look at all the other (ii) (3) (a) (A) that replaces this that and the other.
We've dealt with this for 25 years. What's the rush. I'll tell you. They know it isn't gong to pass the House and it will be just another make believe war on someone to feed to the public and dealing with this will take the attention off the other major problems the administration is facing.
Look up the top ten things that matter to US citizens and you won't find this in it. It's the media and the White House that has made it important.
Wonder why the don't just do that EI? I know and I know you know. That would definitely be the most effective means in combating illegal immigration. I don't think you agree we can help Mexico, but I think it is our biggest threat in many many ways as you say, "I don't know which is scarier, stalemate parties or a one party system."
who cares, like all govt backed programs, there is absolutely no requirment to guage progress/outcome.
how long until after this wreck is passed with libs start claiming parallels to when the democrats called slaves 2/3 human, in order to increase representation in the house?
can see shumer and the liars now, almost crying about the inhumanity!
So that's what they mean by "fences make good neighbors" --- you never see them!
I agree, APax... legalization of marijuana would sure put a dent in that revenue by the cartels. I've read local reports that Mexican Officials are thrilled with the two states here that have legalized it, hoping that it will help many of their own problems.
Who knows the truth, but the report is saying that the Dems want to spend a lot of money on immigration reform, and the Repubs are saying they won't support the expense without a secure border...but to have a secure border...you have to spend money! Oh wait, is there really any such thing as "secure" ? Is there really any such thing as immigration reform--or is it just 'more' of the same, except now they would have a different label ? In other words, our problems don't get better---we would just have more of them?
We've dealt with this for 25 years. What's the rush.
And you would think that after handling it for that long, it would be more clearcut at this point? But I do agree. After all, what IS the rush?
Yep.... It's a 'huge' contradiction...isn't it?
I wonder if the pressure is because they make more money when the status is "illegal" -- legal would mean they might have to pay union wages--- Oh...the horror!
I just love this statement because it points to the biggest crime of all that I see, too - "there are many that prefer that exact situation" = job security for them, in a way...keep people voting for them because we think they are 'helping' us. And of course, bitching does make them look like they are 'working.' (before they all go play golf together
)
Interesting thought, JoAnne... maybe.
I'm thinking they both might want it... but for reasons that only benefit them with increased tax revenue. I don't see why decreasing deficits or National debt would matter to them in the long run, and they have the power to change Budget Acts, extensions et al, that they themselves have placed... But anyway, the CBO reports that the Immigration Bill could go either way... despite that, it's still tax revenue, and I think that's all they really care about.
___
The Senates pending immigration bill will pave the way for the arrival of 46 million legal immigrants
over the next 20 years, increase the federal debt in the same time period and shrink Americans average wage, according Alabama Republican Sen. Jeff Sessions critical reading of two new reports on the pending immigration reform bill provided by the Congressional Budget Office.
But Florida Republican Sen. Marco Rubio, the most prominent GOP advocate for the immigration reform bill, says the CBO reports are good news for Americans.
The CBO has further confirmed what most conservative economists have found: reforming our immigration system is a net benefit
for our economy, American workers and taxpayers, Rubio said in a statement on Tuesday. The report offers encouraging evidence that the [bill could] reduce the deficit over the next 20 years.
Read more:
Chloe, perhaps you can explain something to me. Nothing in the CBO report to me makes any sense when compared to reality. Two different units of my company deal with employment; Temp (unskilled and semi-skilled) and skilled/professional. Both divisions are maxed out when it comes to finding employment. The jobs just are not there and those that are, for both skilled and non-skilled, are short term.
Our own forecasts see an upswing in temp staff, both skilled and unskilled however, none of these jobs save a few, will pay the kind of wages (minus and benefits) to allow for the purchase of goods and services as the CBO report suggests it will. Employers are looking for staff that whereby there is no lawful guarantee of hours and wages, and where staff can be increased and cut on a moments notice. They don't want to hire their own full or part-time staff. Temps fill that bill.
I'm not impressed with economic double-speak especially when the formula the CBO is using appears to be flawed or in my vernacular; isn't following reality.
While I applaud the influx of new citizens (well over the 11 million that keeps on getting repeated) as cultural enhancement, I just don't see the jobs they are supposed to be filling. The CBO paints a rosy picture that doesn't square with the reality I'm seeing.
APax, I'm sorry to be so slow in replying, but something wouldn't let me back into this site! I tried for over an hour and kept getting a "500 unexpected error" - something I've never seen before.
Well, now that I've completely forgotten what I was going to type...lol - I don't have any professional forecasts handy; but, like you, I do not see how we could assume that there will be work for this influx over the expected eleven million... about 46 million total over the next twenty years. Considering the existing population will make babies and some of the 46 million will as well, that's going to be a lot of positions to fill in twenty plus years.
Session's stated there will be an increase in unemployment over five years after the Bill is implemented, and then there was another statement that said they don't expect much of an increase in unemployment over the long term. ..I don't see how they can suggest that. Technology is rapidly displacing (and removing) the workforce, and many of the immigrants are unskilled...then they won't even have a chance at the jobs that 'are' available for operating the technology. Yes, some can become skilled...but I just don't see why technology will mean we need an 'increased' workforce...most cos I read are boasting at the cutbacks they are able to make.
..(as an aside, I've read that 'expectations' for the future, due to tech advancements, will mean most of the future jobs will be either low-paid or specialty high-paid--essentially the middle grade will disappear--so, if that is going to happen naturally, then adding massive people to the system would seem to add expediency to that outcome). Just to note, I had to shake my head when they said, to the effect, "but a bright side would be that productivity would be marginally increased." ..Oh...low pay with increased productivity..how nice. ./s
...for those few, low-paid individuals that are working. But, if you are correct, that it will be a lot of temporary work...then business and the Gov will make out like robbers. Business will save on paying wages and benefits, and the Gov will need to print up more to meet the massive unemployment and other welfare needs...such a deal !
Also, I thought that whole discussion about SS was disturbing...to think they were including SS payments from the immigrants in that 197 (mil ?) estimate reduction ! That's poor accounting to me---although, that's getting into what EI was talking about -sort of- that one night that several of us frustrated him...lol.. Yes, it needs to be invested, but it needs to be there for them, too.
All in all, I agree with the opposition to this Bill - it's "amnesty/increased welfare/and lower wages" for America.
Thanks for the reply (I got the 500 note too) Unless I miss my guess here, this will completely undo what once was considered the middle class.
That's what it looks like... they're only going to need so many specialty jobs. I believe that NBC report from a while back suggested 70% low-paid and 30% high-paid... and then... how many of those jobs will be available to support that huge influx of people.
Oh, it was billion, not 197 mil... thought that didn't look right.
Personally, I think that the borders should be open and we should welcome immigrants with open arms. So, yes, I think that it is over-kill.
The government =
.... Us =
EI,
I agree that the CBO reports are an important and significant gauge that we should be aware of, and in your implication that there was 'something' that I didn't understand, you didn't indicate what you thought that was.
Also, I did not suggest that I was taking an annual view of the immigration situation. I commented on the statements made in the report, and 'any' personal opinions or conclusions drawn by me, would always be projectory, not a dim, short-term view.
I agree that a view of the situation needs to be based on the generation arriving, but that still would have to be averaged over decades, so again, I would not be looking at the short-term (just to note, that's the difference between my way of thinking and 'many' Libs---they are subjective, demanding and want results right now; I try to be objective, waiting for 'timing' to balance results, and realize that 'conditions' are the determinate for what's 'right,' and that isn't always right now).
EI,
Yes, I did see how misleading and 'biased' that view was---that's why I 'also' included the opposite view, and is why I stated that it could go either way (but I also speculated which view seems the most likely to me).
The report is two-fold: 1) cost of the Bill; 2) economic impact.
The 46 million "legal" statement is 'not' misleading in my view:
The CBO impact report says the bill would increase the U.S. population by 10.4 million above current forecasts for 2023, and by 16 million in 2033 .
The current forecasts predict an inflow of roughly 11 million per decade , or 22 million by 2033.
The CBO report also assumes that eight million illegal immigrants of the estimated 11 million illegals will be allowed to stay, but does not include them in the population-growth forecast because theyre already living in the United States.
Together, the current 22 million inflow , plus the new 16 million and the eight million illegals , add up to 46 million new or legalized people for the nation in 20 years.
The nations current population is 314 million, so the bill would ensure the arrival of one new immigrant for every six Americans. "
___
So, they are still including projectories and forecasts---so again, no, I don't think the inclusive with implied variables figure of 46 million is misleading, AND I think the final statement of "ensured" arrival of 1 immigrant for every 6 Americans is VERY significant!
But, also to note and agree with you, that I agree on their use of language (and methods of Neuro-linguistic Programming that I commented on in the Google article) to control the context of their communication to create a desired meaning that can 'sway' or direct the outcome of their opinions--essentially, bias on steroids.
EI,
In other words, it's the "legal" status that's the game-changer that will impact us all in every sector---and that's why I don't think the statement is misleading; the significance of impact is based more on legal status percentage, tho overall population still needs to be a consideration in determining welfare needs.
EI,
I agree with both of those 'points' and I also see what the CBO is measuring, both subjectively and objectively---and yes, I see there are "pieces" involved, but I also see they're pointing to a larger picture: that regardless of all the variables, we can be assured that there will be 'at least' one new American for every six Americans with this Bill over the next twenty years.
Yes, and I intentionally didn't go into areas that I felt they didn't address for the very reason you mentioned - the politics of it - and also, the nature of speculation regarding the demographics, education, work ethic, ancestoral ethics/values, and human nature... all are necessary in factoring the results.
I will bring up one other factor that I saw they left out, that is also speculation, but I think is worthy of mention - that would be inflation/deflation - the value of the dollar.
We see that number "46 million" people and we can only relate their 'worth' (and everyone else's worth) in terms of the value of today's dollar and that of today's minimum wage.
If we 'assume' that a large portion of that 46 million, plus increased populations that were not factored in, will not find work due to skill or technology, then increasing unemployment expenses going to the reduced tax-payer base (Business will have less responsibility to contribute to unemployment insurance if the hired was not a full-time employee, but was contracted, yes? ..I'm ignorant in their responsibility, the extent of it) along with increases generated by the Government will be necessary.
This influx of continual money flow into the system without the balance of a larger tax base to fund it, would cause hyperinflation. The hyperinflation causes our dollar to lose value. So if this scenario is reasonable, our idea of what kind of economic impact 46 million plus increased population would make - is much greater if the cost of living is much greater than it is today, and the value of the dollar is much lower, say $ .30.
So, yes, to a statement you made in a different comment, that "they are still adding to the economy" even if they aren't working; they are spending those unemployment dollars. But the problem is still that a never-ending running faucet of increased need with a declining resource for employment that meets the consumer's needs - will only keep the inflation and devalued dollar perpetuated with the Government's need to keep pumping new money into the system to meet unemployment insurance demands. ..It would keep the majority dependent on the Government, and would keep Big Business in control of the Government.
__
You know how I not long ago agreed with you that pouring more money into the system, along with changes in rules and regulations, seems necessary to manage our increased needs for employment and having a 'life.' But, those views of mine were 'based' on a closed or tight border and having a larger tax base funded by more Business, not less....out of someone's earned or revenue generated income - not by a Gov/Banker's printing press.