Too Many Teachers, Too Little Quality
The nations teacher-training programs do not adequately prepare would-be educators for the classroom, even as they produce almost triple the number of graduates needed, according to a survey of more than 1,000 programs released Tuesday.
The National Council on Teacher Quality review is a scathing assessment of colleges education programs and their admission standards, training and value. The report, which drew immediate criticism, was designed to be provocative and urges leaders at teacher-training programs to rethink what skills would-be educators need to be taught to thrive in the classrooms of today and tomorrow.
Through an exhaustive and unprecedented examination of how these schools operate, the review finds they have become an industry of mediocrity, churning out first-year teachers with classroom management skills and content knowledge inadequate to thrive in classrooms with an ever-increasing diversity of ethnic and socioeconomic students, the reports authors wrote.
A vast majority of teacher preparation programs do not give aspiring teachers adequate return on their investment of time and tuition dollars, the report said.
The report was likely to drive debate about which students are prepared to be teachers in the coming decades and how they are prepared. Once a teacher settles into a classroom, its tough to remove him or her involuntarily and opportunities for wholesale retraining are difficult if nearly impossible to find.
The answer, the council and its allies argue, is to make it more difficult for students to get into teacher preparation programs in the first place. And once there, they should be taught the most effective methods to help students.
Its an idea the council has applauded and suggests other states should consider to limit the number of candidates entering teacher training programs.
You just have to have a pulse and you can get into some of these education schools, said Michael Petrilli, a vice president at the conservative-leaning Fordham Institute and a former official in the Department of Educations Office of Innovation and Improvement. If policymakers took this report seriously, they'd be shutting down hundreds of programs.
Some 239,000 teachers are trained each year and 98,000 are hired meaning too many students are admitted and only a fraction find work.
Among the councils other findings:
Only a quarter of education programs limit admission to students in the top half of their high school class. The remaining three quarters of programs allow students who fared poorly in high school to train as teachers.
3-out-of-4 teacher training programs do not train potential educators how to teach reading based on the latest research. Instead, future teachers are left to develop their own methods.
Fewer than 1-in-9 programs for elementary educators are preparing students to teach Common Core State Standards, the achievement benchmarks for math and reading that have been adopted in 45 states and the District of Columbia. For programs preparing high school teachers, that rate is roughly a third of programs.
Only 7 percent of programs ensure student teachers are partnered with effective classroom teachers. Most often, a student teacher is placed into a classroom where a teacher is willing to have them, regardless of experience.
When asked how much experience they have, the most common answer from teachers is one year. First-year teachers reach around 1.5 million students.
http://www.boston.com/news/education/2013/06/17/report-too-many-teachers-too-little-quality/xQGCrPiYaN0igRA4kGnyeL/story.html
Tags
Who is online
68 visitors

A rather revealing report on the quality of the education that future teachers are receiving as they prepare to teach our children and grandchildren
Not surprising that the teachers union and some schools of education are discounting the results which do not reflect favorably on the results of those programs
Teachers are one of the most important professionals in our country and those entering that professional to teach the children and to shape the society of the future should only be those most qualified to do so.
A mediocre teacher is not desirable in any school in my view.
This is another of those subjects that just really get me fired up. Here where I live it seems the children are taught to pass the epcat test. They learn what is necessary to pass that damn test! Did you know they dont even teach cursive anymore? They said the kids dont need it because now a days its computers!
Another that gets me is that the teachers have a multitude of different students now. They have those with autism and add and adhd all mixed together and have a hand in making referrals and such for said children and then following an iep for those who qualify.
The one thing they are not allowed to do is take control of their class. If a child does something now days, its call the parents and little else. It seems the day of one on one when a child is having problems keeping up with the rest of the class is gone as well. And frankly, the future of our children are in the hands of these teachers and most are severely underpaid for the job they are expected to perform.
In this day and age you could not pay me to be a teacher. Just some of my gripes.
Just a couple short observations.
First, I think most schools have good quality education at the elementary school level. I notice most teachers are motivated to teach kids at that level and the motivator is they like kids.
We lose them big time at middle school and it doesn't stop in high school. I don't like painting a broad brush here because a few of the teachers at this level are awesome, but the average clearly drops precipitously.
The second point is early in Bill Clinton's administration there was a motivator to get older retirees into teaching as a second career which I thought was an awesome idea. Now I'm old enough where I'd like to consider it and I'm close to retirement but today there are too many roadblocks to make that transition easily. I'd be especially motivated to teach at the middle and high school level for either science or math - but there seems to be no interest or leadership on public policy to make this happen. I've asked my congressperson this question several times and essentially gotten blank stares or responses.
Well - one more point is I worry about how I'll gell with bureaucracy and how the school wants the kids to be taught. I have and continue to teach occasionally at the community college level and we have a lot of latitude there. If someone comes into my class and hands me a precise syllabus I have to follow, I know I won't last long like any other profession, there has to be some trust that the person in the class knows what they're doing and at the end of the course, the students are the best judge of how much they got out of it.
I taught for 4 years, about 31 years ago. My experience is, therefore, dated. Here are some thoughts:
About half of all teachers trained are trained for secondary education-- I guess the thinking is, the kids should already know how to read when they reach secondary education. At least in my state, they teach a new teacher how to teach reading in the primary grades. When you teach secondary education, you have at least one major and a minor to get. You're not going for a "teaching" degree, or weren't way back when, (and as far as I know, same thing now). You were going for a regular major and minor. These days, if you want to be a secondary teacher, you spend an extra year taking education classes and a full semester of student-teaching. Who has the money to pay for an extra year of college if your salary isn't going to compensate you for that time?
Then, once you are a new teacher, you have 10 years to get your masters in education. Believe me, having taken education courses, very few of them offer much in the way of classroom management, teaching students to learn to read, or understanding of adolescent and teenage emotional and physical development. It is all theoretical garbage, very little practical knowledge. Most of the classes are utterly worthless, and it is just a requirement to continue to teach. While I learned a great deal about early childhood development, a courserequired for all teachers, by the time the kids got to me in high school, they were already WAAAY past the 5 year old stage.
I taught high school physical and earth science. Why isn't science considered to be a core class?
It is a lot of trouble and additional paperwork to have a student teacher. It is done strictly on a voluntary basis, although the teacher does receive some, (not much), extra compensation for having to footle with a student teacher. Here in KY, the hosting teacher was required to have their masters in education, as well as be willing to take additional time and trouble for a student teacher.
Every school system in the world wants to hire a 1-3 year experience teacher because they are less expensive to hire. Beginning teaching salaries have drastically improved since I taught, but they are still a lot less expensive to hire. In these days of budget cuts, most school systems are hiring a little as possible of experienced teachers, and wanting to hire the newbies. Here is an example of average starting teachers salaries for the US. When I started, we made NOTHING like this! My starting salary was $10,000. I could barely pay my bills, much less pay for additional college classes!
Know thy source:
The National Council on Teacher Quality -- It's Driving Force
Oh, and one more thing
the NCTQ has continued to push for alternative routes to teacher certification and other corporate education reform policies such as a restriction on teacher seniority using a variety of methods:
CORPORATE!
Can you say "privatization" boys and girls?
Funneling teachers through cookie cutter programs of 'successful teaching methods' is not what I would call teaching. Any method or technique, whatever you want to call it, will always need tweaking when applied to students. After all, they are all different and should be approached as such. The minute you try to use such programs is the minute you become Charlie Brown's Teacher, "Wah wah wah wa wa waaa" To reach kids at any age, you have to look them in they eye and challenge them to succeed. Your success will be measured in how many of them remember you.
That's funny you say that, because the most valuable in-service program I had back then was on how to reach the "Peppermint Patties" of the world...
Why I left teaching:
Dowser
Thanks so much for sharing a real world look at your career in education
You sound like a caring educator whose efforts were frustrated by the system
Linda
I share your frustration
My wife sent a birthday card to our 12 year old grandson and wrote a beautiful note in the card, which he could hardly read not because he didn't know the words but had little experience with cursive writing.
Teaching to tests does not teach children to think or imagine and that shortchanges them greatly
Many of the teachers who inspired me the most were the hardest on the students, not because they were mean but because they had high expectations and wanted the best for us
Mark
Thanks for sharing your perspective
Excellent points
Teachers need broad guidelines and room to teach children to think, to use facts to figure things out and improve their social skills as well as their knowledge of subjects.
A good teacher is an asset, a great teacher is one of the best of us
Dowser
Excellent points and comprehensive perspective
Thanks for the feedback
A Mac
Thanks for the feedback and perspective
One
You are right about tweaking and on the job learning, but the point of the article is that many of these new teachers are not even being taught the basics, the framework from which to refine their skills into their own style on the job.
A good teacher indeed challenges you to succeed but more importantly picks you up when you fail and encourages your to keep trying and keep improving
Thanks for the feedback
No offense, but I would much much much rather my child be proficient with computer skills than cursive. When cursive was a priority, libraries were accessed by the dewey decimal system and computers were not even conceived of. Priorities change with the advancement of technology. Being upset that your grandkid can't read your cursive is no better thana kid being frustrated abouttheir grandparent's inability to effectively use a computer or smart phone.
Hal
No argument that computer knowledge is important to them, but why not both
Perhaps they will want to be able to read something written by their grandparents or great grandparents in the future
Why not both
My daughter-in-law found a program that lets my grandson practice his cursive writing right on the tablet, sort of like the old toy we had when I was small where you wrote on plastic over a wax pad and erased by lifting the plastic
The means are available to teach both
BadFish
Unless you want to read the original Declaration of Independence, or letters from the founders, or letters or notations on photographs from your great grand parents
It doesn't have to be either or
Ladies and gentleman, the posted news article here is what you call; Partisan Bullshit.
For starters, the National Council on Teacher Quality is an ideologically conservative and conservative funded think tank group. So you can pretty much throw out any objectivity here. They are analogous to the Heritage Foundationanother far right conservative group.
Just a reminder, these are the same people who call education elitist, are cutting teachers pay to barebones, use Sarah Palin as a spokesperson, promote non-science such as creationism, are against teaching Critical Thinking skills and are basically behind the War on Education.
The actual report, in .pdf format, can be downloaded here: - Warning about this report; this is academic based meaning it is about teacher preparation. Those who post things like this or comment on them , without having a deeper understanding of what teachers prep is, are just spewing partisan bullshit, as I suggested above.
The critiques on this report are not all out yet but already, some are quite damning, to wit;
Problems with new ratings of teachers colleges, point by point
National Council on Teacher Quality is Deeply Flawed
Kent State, Cleveland State dispute preparation study from National...
National Council on Teacher Quality claims uninformed
Mind you, I have major problems with the public school system in the US, especially with their dependance on so-called "experts" dictating curriculum, public school boards staffed with religious partisan nuts and the public schools authoritarian management style which crushes teachers spirits and innovations if they dare to teach children outside of "approved methods." " Teaching to the test " is another big problem and a by-product of Bush's failed " No Child Left Behind. " But this report is....in Lalaland.
Becauseit's all part ofa time budget. To add something new, something existing has to go. It's bad enough that art and phys ed have suffered so badly, but nobody is going to be in favor of diminishing the staples of traditional academia that have a useful purpose, in orderto accommodate an ability to read dated historical documents that have been reproduced countless times in type anyways. Cursive can be made an elective, or part of an extracurricular activity, but in no way should it crowd out computer literacy. Better yet, letthe grandparents teach it to their grandkids in their free time, and the grandkidscan in turn teach them how to use a computer. Cursive isn't exactly rocket science.
Hal
So they cannot be learning computer use while practicing cursive writing on a tablet computer
And it has a useful purpose as I have outlined above in a social and societal appreciation sense
This needs to be taught to young children, how electives did you have in the 2nd and 3rd grade?
Nothing taught in the elementary or secondary school process even remotely approaches being rocket science.
Mark,
"Quality Education" in this case primary but it applies to all levels, is extremely subjective. There is a wide difference in rural, suburban and urban teaching and the expectation of the parents. Urban schools are hit hardest with minority students whose parents do not value education and students with massive behavioral problems which distract classes if not entire schools from the learning process.
Also, urban school bureaucracy is so omnipresent and eats up so much of the cost-per-student budget, regardless of the level, those kids are getting short changed.
Why does it need to be taught to young children? Because it is so easy? It's not even close to being as difficult as a foreign language, and could therefore be a club activity, or taught at home. I want my grandkids to be able to compete with Chinese kids, and that meansspreadsheets,word processors, programming, internet skills, etc. - not cursive. The people that made that decision to eliminate it from the standard curriculum have a good handle on priorities. Cursive is a relativelymindless exercise. In my professional life, hand written information is rare, and when it does pop up, I see very little of it done in cursive.
In 1978, I published my first editorial piece in the old Philadelphia Bulletin newspaper (not the one under the current ownership).
The headline
When Graduation is a Fraud
The practice in Philly public schools at the time was called "Social Promotion," it enabled students to be promoted through elementary and (the then) junior high schools based NOT ON ACHIEVEMENT but RATHER ON AGE AND PHONY STANDARDS!
In the junior high schools for example, a student could advance to the next grade by passing TWO MAJORS and TWO MINORS. Translation; a student could pass Science and Social Studies, hygiene and physical education -- two majors and two minors -- and be promoted.
Further translation -- the remaining Majors -- English, Reading and Math -- a student could fail all three but, based on the "standard" I noted, would be promoted.
Students who moved through the system without reading and math skills obviously would fail again, but, because of age or the fraud of a promotion standard, continued to move through the grade levels, many of whom "graduated."
AND WHO GOT THE BLAME FROM POLITICIANS AND THE CONNED PUBLIC?
THE TEACHERS!
These fraudulent practices are in place because they (1) SAVE MONEY and (2) PROVIDE A CONVENIENT SCAPEGOAT thus ass-covering for irresponsible parents, fucked-up government spending priorities, quasi-privatization a.k.a. "Charter Schools" and vouchers for religious schools.
In spite of this, there are lots of good public schools in Philly and lots of good teaching (along with some bad -- as in every endeavor).
BELOW IS MY LATEST EDITORIAL RE: PHILLY PUBLIC SCHOOLS
You are more than welcome; I've added a comment that will illuminate this topic.
I loved those kids. They knew it, too. Back then, you could get away with a lot more than now. I had a class where every on of my students had some major, awful problem. I had girls whose fathers raped them, or step-fathers, or mother's boyfriends. Several of the boys had just lost their mothers to death or abandonment, and they were like lost souls. I had kids whose parents were in the midst of divorce, whose parents did drugs all the time, or drank all the time. Not one of them was "whole". I made it a rule that they were not allowed to leave the class until they got a hug from someone who loved them.
So, every day, they left my class with a hug. I put notes in their books that said I thought they were wonderful and special. I tried to report things to the authorities, but, back then, no one cared. I got some of my dyslexic students tested, but nothing happened to help them.
I WAS frustrated. I was absolutely at the end of my rope, when I quit. I went home each night and worried about what was happening to them... It was heart-breaking!
And, on top of that, I had to stick to a curriculum. These kids didn't need to know about the planets, they needed to know how to take care of themselves. I was allowed to do a unit on careers, so I desperately tried to find careers that they could pursue. We did budgets, we "bought" cars, we acted as if we were the head of the household and made decisions. They needed to know how to make a TV dinner, not whether or not Pluto was a planet. They needed to know how to read a bus schedule. I know I failed them in what they needed-- even though I received many accolades as a teacher... Rocks were just much easier on my heart.
Dowser
Well it doesn't mean a lot but on their behalf I say thank you very much for caring and sharing your big heart with all of those children
AeonPax
I think I mentioned above that the unions and some education schools had problems with the report and while there may be some structural errors there is little argument from anyone who has children or has anything to do with schools that there are big problems with the training teachers re being given and the quality of teachers entering the profession.
And by the way, I am gladthere is certainly nothing hyper-partisan about your comment or views on the topic.
Obviously a lot to respond to here - but I agree science should be core every bit as much as reading and math. It's critical in modern society to understand science.
You also have a general category "social studies" which is a combination of civics and politics - to me that rates high too.
I could go on about how important critical thinking, debate, and public speaking are as well and high school pays almost no attention to that at all but that's for another day I suppose.
Cursive is an art form in my opinion and should be taught. It is a thing of beauty and quite handy for communitcation when all your elctronic crap bites the dust.
Considering you chose an article containing supposed facts by a hyper partisan group, the "National Council on Teacher Quality" which wasn't really a study but the flawed analyzation of a survey they sent out to specific groups....I can't see where you have anything to complain about.
From my perspective as a mother who has always been active and involved with my children's education, I find that so-called report an insult to anyone with over a 5th grade education.
You said "some"? I only listed four from areas aside from unions and special interests. I have more. Since you haven't indicated that you even read those sources, I assume you haven't, you are in absolutely no position to offer your opinion or judgement on this issue, other than your own right-wing slant.
Agreed! I taught Biology/General Science/Space Science and Art at one time and in 1999, was a technical consultant to Philly school teachers, teaching desktop publishing.
Every subject has value and to "play" certain subjects against others so as to manipulate reality because politicians foist their priorities -- is unconscionable. And the political game is to demagogue teachers and teachers unions.
Robert, thank you-- that means everything! I loved them. If I did nothing else, at least there was one place where they were safe and loved.
Dowser
I has a couple of teachers like you and I have never forgotten them
Add the funny thing is when I went to my 30th reunion a few of our teachers were there - one a lady a lot like you who taught me Latin for three years and English Lit when I was a senior and while I always remember her, she called me by name as well.
I was shocked - she taught for nearly 40 years and yet she still remembered some of the stuff (good and bad) we did in her class
It was the highlight of the reunion for me.
Rest assured you made a difference
AeonPAx
I browsed through the links you gave and there are good points made in them as there are good points made in the study the article talks about. None of the sources or the report tell the whole story of what is wrong and right with education in the U.S. And my middle of the road attitude is in response to your left wing attitude
I never sang the praises of the study other than to say that it was correct that the quality of teachers being produced is a lot lower than in years passed.
I did not post the article looking for a fight, which appearsto be why you commented but rather to spark discussion which it has. Not every issue is a partisan fight for everyone though it seems to be for you.
How VERY wonderful! I'm so glad you were able to see her!
I'm going to my 40th reunion this summer-- but many of my teachers were the teachers that my parents had... (We all went to the same high school, just 25 years apart.) So, I'll never get to see them again, until heaven, maybe. I know they're there...
Thanks, Robert, you've made my day!
Discussion on what? A walk down memory lane? I've read the replies here and only a very few were directly related to the article itself, which has to do with teaching students (undergraduate college level) to be teachers.
While teacher education as a whole needs to be overhauled and a new paradigm constructed, the political and sociological problems in the real world are the problem, not teacher prep. None of this will change the outcome of a nation in which close to half of its graduating seniors are functionally illiterate.
You belong to an ideological group that has denigrated teachers for over a decade now, call education elitist and whine about teachers being paid too much. You have no say in this, as I have said.
There is no discussion here about the problems with education other than anecdotal, which is interesting but far from the issue of why America is failing its children in education.
AeonPax
Thanks for sharing that politicalideology rant
Very nice word there "paradigm" and perhaps you are right that it needs to be changed, but what really needs to be changed is thatonly qualified people with high potential should be admitted to education programs, stricter standards need to be applied to their curriculum and more need to be weeded out and eliminated from the profession in the preparatory phase and during the student teaching evaluation.
Additionally a real performance evaluation process needs to be put in place, continuing education needs to be more than just getting a masters.
I have never once denigrated a teacher; I have the highest respect and admiration for teachers and think that only the most qualified, most dedicated individuals should be in the profession.
Your attack dog mode suits you as you are more interested in ideology and stack than anything else.
Wow, you are just full of rhetoric this morning. I don't think I know of any business that doesn't want " qualified people with high potential" but if you say that's a problem only endemic with teaching, you are way off the mark.
Speaking of education, I re-read what I wrote; "You belong to an ideological group" which does not accuse nor even infer that YOU personally have those opinions. It would seem a guilty conscience is its own accuser.
Since you have not offered proof that anything I stated was false or erroneous, then you must tacitly agree with it. The Republican - Conservatives have been in the forefront in the War on Education for over a decade now. Unless you are willing to admit you are neither Republican or conservative, then perhaps I can cut you some slack. Until then, you remain unqualified to comment on this issue.
AeonPax
I did not say it was a problem "only" endemic to education, if you are unable to comprehend you should read slower and go overthe commentstwice before replying.
You have no idea if I belong to an ideological group ir if so what that group might be, you merely assume
Everything is a war with you liberal zealots, on education, on women, on voting rights, on minorities everything is a war
And you have the audacity to accuse anyone else of using rhetoric
90% of every comment you make is rhetoric
There is no war on education - there are opposing views on what is best for the improvement of the American education process and the best outcome would be a merger of the two opposing views into some action to make things better
AS my qualifications you are woefully inadequate to assess mine or anyone else's lacking any qualities other than those of an attack dog rather than a debater.
Screaming "I am right and your are wrong" may be what you think debate is but no reasonably intelligent person will agree