Supremes Say You Can't Ask for Proof of Residency for Voting
So, my question is once you remove all the posturing, why not? If you have to prove your old enough to buy beer by showing an ID (which can be gratifying to many of us that have long past that particular Goal Line), why should you not have to prove that you are a legal voter in the state and municipality you are voting in?
I truly don't understand the commotion. Make it simple to get ID and prove you are who you say you are.
Tags
Who is online
107 visitors

I look forward to a real discussion. Leave your attitude and political posturing at the door, act like an ass, be prepared to be called out.
Sorry, correction noted. So, how do you get proof of residency? generally by getting a license-if you're an illegal alien, how do you get the license?
The argument was based on the Native Americans - specifically the Tohono Odohm, whose reservation splits the two borders. The Tohono have declared for years that they don't need "U. S. Birth Certificates" because they are a Sovereign Nation - true statement 'bout the Sovereignty - and those tribal members born on the "Mexican" side of the res, other than their Tribal Card, have no verification they are U. S. Citizens (1924 American Indian Citizenship Act).
Unfortunately, that opened the door for the ILLEGAL ALIENS not needing documentation either.
residency requirements vary from state to state , and depends on what one wishes to do . most states give a person 30 days to get a state drivers lic , some give as long as a year . for voting purposes some states only require one to have a piece of mail usually a utility bill with physical residence on it , some states require some to wait an entire year to be able to buy a resident fishing or hunting lic , and some its simply having established residency to vote .
a simple way around this USSC decision , since it deals with federal elections is simply take it down a notch to state and local elections which are not classified elections for federal office ( IE , such as a presidential or house of Rep or senate seat) . Once one is certified as a citizen on the local or state level , there would be no need to ask for the verification on the federal level. as for DL's currently most if not all states now are required to verify by BC as well as other governmental forms the person is whom they say they are, this is part of the real ID implemented so that its harder to make fake dl's so the way to verify is already there. as for those that never get a picture id , a simple way to combat voter fraud , that purple ink on a finger that takes days to wash off just as in other parts of the world . since the decision relates to the federal elections , let them have that .state and local well I think you see what im saying . and constitutionally a state can require such proof of citizenship as well as residency in those lesser non federal elections , the constitution allows for the states to make their own rules ( within certain boundries ) for their own elections .
Didn't they also validate the SC or NC law as well??
I thought this Arizona based case raised the issue of state/local requirements/limitations, as it relates to constitutionality. In that venue, don't most state/local venues work from a list of "residents"? One proves who they are and not proof of that residency. On the list you vote.
jwc2blue
I have always accepted the point you make as the starting point for this debate -
I think that is true in every state.
I do not think there needs to be a voter ID card, but I do think that when you arrive at the poll and state that "I am Joe Q Citizen" and your name is on the roll that you should have to produce ID (drivers license, library card, Medicare card whatever) that proves you are who you say you are not that you are eligible to vote as the voting register already shows that Joe Q Citizen is eligible to vote. Otherwise
I could walk in and say that I was Joe Q Citizen and vote in your place.
E I
In Ohio you must show a photo ID
I do it every time I vote
jwc2blue
So long as the ID has a picture on it, I too think there should be great flexibility in what can be used
But I support confirming that the person is who hey say they are when they come into vote
As to your last point, that is true unless they are coming for someone who passed away or moved between elections and remained on the register
Wisconsin passed a law which requited a State ID to vote. The law which has not yet been implemented, has been challenged in court. Recently , the 4th District Court of Appeals in Madison unanimously ruled the voter ID law did not violate a provision of the state constitution that limits what restrictions the Legislature can impose on who can vote. At issue is not what is required to get a vote or state ID.
Part of the requirements to get an ID is " Proof of U.S. citizenship , legal permanent resident status, legal conditional resident status or legal temporary visitor status." This is not being challenged.
I oppose this state voter ID mainly on the grounds that the Republicans claim it will stop voter fraud. However, that can't prove that any widespread voter fraud exists. I see this this as a way to keep blacks and Latino's from voting.
Personally though, I have no problem with it.
all U.S. citizens have the right to register to vote using the national postcard. Key word being ALL, federal law trumps state law. Arizona didnt know that? No they were trying to trump the federal law and lost is all. The excuse of voter fraud fell thru the floor as a result of no statistics to back up their claim. Duh?
The correct decision was made under the law....
Election-law expert Rick Hasen, a law professor at the University of California, Irvine, wrote recently that a ruling by the court to uphold Arizonas law would have alter[ed] the state-federal balance over federal elections and give[n] states a greater ability to manipulate election rules for partisan reason.
In other words, it would make it easier for other states to attach their own requirements to voter registrations formsfor instance age, mental capacity, and criminal records could theoretically become criteria for states to use if the law is upheld.
AeionPax
You seem to be on both sides of the issue
So do you oppose, support or have no real feelings one way or another on the issue?
Robert good point, but out here there are local and state referendum votes annually though this decision makes it illegal to ask so on the federal election level , it does leave the door open on local and state levels , then of course there would be a question of if voting for a rep or senator is actually a state or federal election since it deals with electing a states representation on a federal level but is a state matter on whom they send to DC. im sure there will be work arounds discussed and explored to both remain within existing federal law and state laws , I simply pointed out some things that could be considered. personally I like the purple finger one shows no party affiliation nor lets anyone know whom was voted for , simply that they voted.