╌>

Head cooking and its sad history in the Sunni / Shiite divide

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  kpr37  •  13 years ago  •  11 comments

Head cooking and its sad history in the Sunni / Shiite divide

Article Photo

What started as protest against an unjust totalitarian government, soon took on the flavor of sectarian conflict. Waged between the two main competing faction of Islam. This is not new, nor unexpected. Each view their form of "submission" as the one true and proper one. Meaning the other group are apostates, who no longer recognise or follow the "path" (sharia) allah has mandated.

It is a single moment of horrifying barbarism that provides a fleeting insight into the unimaginable hatred fuelling the war in Syria.

A young Syrian rebel fighter barbecues the severed and blood-spattered head of a government soldier, lifting it triumphantly by the forelock as he poses for a picture.

If this were not so stomach-churningly gruesome it would surely become one of the most enduring images of a conflict where the rules of war no longer apply and horror reigns... if it is indeed real.

Source

The New York times, yesterday, reported on heart eating, and there has been many be-heading videos posted over the course of the conflict. The simple goal of these acts is terror, it is not difficul to understand. The use of terror to get others to submit is the overwealming meme of Mohammad. It was by terror that Mohammad established his political power, and how the "rightly guided" Caliphs, extended the influence of the only excepted path (sharia) by means of conquest.

The first recorded Islamic head cooking comes from the "sword of allah" Khalid ibn al-Walid. It can be found in the Sunnah of the Prophet under Ra'y.

ijthad .... and ta'wil ...the search for sharia in the text, and traditions of the prophet, started just after Mohammad's passing. The prophet knew allah's law (he made it up as he went along) But not everybody could be divinely inspired and receive revelation on life's circumstance and happenings on demand. Some of the most vile human beings ever produced on this blue ball spinning in space, were going about codifying the only acceptable life guidance system for what in the future would be, over one point five billion humans, who "submit" to their theocratic rulings and regulations. Known as the sharia, or "path" of the prophet.

Here is one of the lesser known rulings on ta'wil (searching the "path" of Mohammad) exercising Ijthad. Was the case of the "Sword of allah" Khalid ibn al-Walid.

His be-heading of an apostate, cooking of the head, and raping of his wife was for some reason questioned in this instance, when it was in no way out of character. Raping of woman after killing their husbands was "sunnah" a previously established practice of Allah and codified in it's book the Quran

The term ta'wil was used by Khalid ibn alWalid, who killed Malik ibn Nuwayrah, and also by Abu Bakr. In order to examine this usage, we will have to go into the details of the episode involving Khalid. [2]

After the Prophet's demise, a group of people gathered in Saqifat Bani Sa'idah and chose Abu Bakr for the caliphate. Khalid ibn alWalid was one who had played an active role in the affair. After the event, he was dispatched with a force to collect zakat from the dissidents. During the course of his assignment, he went to a tribe inhabiting the region of Batch and demanded zakat. They declined to pay, stating that they did not acknowledge anybody except `Ali ibn Abi Talib as the Prophet's successor, as the Prophet (S) had nominated `Ali (A) to succeed him at Ghadir Khum while returning from the Last Pilgrimage. They stated that on this ground they would not pay zakat to anybody except someone appointed by `Ali (A).

He was a "shiite"

Khalid ibn alWalid responded to the position taken by the people of that tribe by committing a horrible crime. He ordered Dirar ibn Azwar al'Asadi to behead Malik ibn Nuwayrah, the chief of the tribe. Khalid did not stop at this; he slept with the wife of Malik the same night. To celebrate the occasion, he slaughtered a sheep and ordered Malik's head to be put in the fire under the cooking pot.

After his return, in order to justify his inhuman act and to make it appear something legitimate, he said: "Since this tribe had apostatized, I had to treat them in this manner." But within a short time, facts of the case came out. Abu Qatadah and `Abd Allah ibn `Umar gave witnesses in favour of Malik ibn Nuwayrah. Khalid had no alternative except to confess. While apologizing, he said to Abu Bakr: (I exercised ta'wil and made a mistake). `Umar ibn alKhattab and some of the Companions were of the view that Khalid should be stoned to death for zina (adultery). However, since Khalid had played a significant role in the episode of Saqifah, efforts were made to exonerate him and justify his deed Accordingly. Abu Bakr said: (I would not stone him, for he exercised ta'wil and committed an error). After this incident the term ta'wil was used in such cases by others.

No punishment was delivered, all was well in the submitted world. The sword of allah went back to what he did best, call non-believers to submit to allah's new sharia, by the use of jihad. He raped many more women, be-headed uncounted infidels, but as far as I know, he never cooked another head. Even though no punishment or repramand was deemed nessessary by the first "righty guided" Caliph.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
kpr37
Professor Silent
link   seeder  kpr37    13 years ago

Since America is taking a side in Syria, I think we should all know the history behind it.

It is history, sad and fucked up as it is. America now supports a group with a head cooking tradition(LOL)

I'm against supplying air cover to head cookers, how about you?

Hezbollah, a close ally of Iran and the Syrian regime, is openly engaged in the fight against the rebels in Syria. It has also fought for years against Israel, arch rival of Iran and Syria.

" The leader of the party of the Satan comes to fight the Sunnis... Now we know what the Iranians want... They want continued massacres to kill Sunnis," Qaradawi said.

"How could 100 million Shiites [worldwide] defeat 1.7 billion [Sunnis]?" he exclaimed, "only because [Sunni] Muslims are weak".


And the other side.

The video being circulated online reportedly dates back to 1988 and shows a younger Nasrallah saying: Our plan, to which we, as faithful believers, have no alternative, is to establish an Islamic state under the rule of Islam.

Lebanon should not be an Islamic republic on its own, but rather, part of the Greater Islamic Republic, governed by the Master of Time [the Mahdi], and his rightful deputy, the Jurisprudent Ruler, Imam Khomeini, he said.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    13 years ago

We go into Syria and we will reap the whirlwind.

Not good.

 
 
 
kpr37
Professor Silent
link   seeder  kpr37    13 years ago

BEIRUT A Syrian rebel group's April pledge of allegiance to al-Qaeda's replacement for Osama bin Laden suggests that the terrorist group's influence is not waning and that it may take a greater role in the Western-backed fight to topple Syrian President Bashar Assad.

The pledge of allegiance by Syrian Jabhat al Nusra Front chief Abou Mohamad al-Joulani to al-Qaeda leader Sheik Ayman al-Zawahri was coupled with an announcement by the al-Qaeda affiliate in Iraq, the Islamic State of Iraq, that it would work with al Nusra as well.

Lebanese Sheik Omar Bakri, a Salafist who says states must be governed by Muslim religious law, says al-Qaeda has assisted al Nusra for some time.

"They provided them early on with technical, military and financial support , especially when it came to setting up networks of foreign jihadis who were brought into Syria," Bakri says. "There will certainly be greater coordination between the two groups."

I just don't know what to say.
 
 
 
kpr37
Professor Silent
link   seeder  kpr37    13 years ago

The legal ruling on Khalid ibn al-Walid, according to sharia, or "path" of the prophet.

Charge...... head cooking

Ahmad ibn Ali alShafii, famous as Ibn Hajar al`Asqalani, while describing the Sahabah, says that they exercised ta'wil and that in cases that the mujtahid errs he is not only not liable to any censure and punishment but deserves one reward.

What is more interesting is that some who claim to be Muslims consider even such a vicious character like Yazid with his irremediable crime, which has no parallel in history, as a khalifah of the Prophet (S). Moreover, they justify his heinous crime and say that he exercised ijtihadand erred in his ta'wil; therefore, he cannot be blamed!

In Ibn Kathir's history (vo1.13,p.9), Abu alKhayr Ahmad ibn Isma'il ibn Yusuf alShafi`i al'Ash'ari is reported as having made this statement about Yazid: (He was an imam and mujtahid). Ibn Kathir himself writes (Vol .8, p.223) that some people justify the evil and heinous deeds of Yazid and state the he erred in exercising ta'wil and ijtihad. In another place (vo1.6, p.323) he says: "Khalid continued to hold his office with the approval of Abu Bakr ( and therefore his assignment was legitimate), though he took part in the killing of Malik ibn Nuwayrah. But since he exercised ijtihad and erred, he cannot be blamed."

In the abovementioned cases, the exercise of ray is referred to with the name of ta'wil, and this usage continued until the Sunni community gave it the name of ijtihad, developing special rules and terms for it and opening new chapters in the realm of ilm al'usul. Consequently, the act of deriving a hukm by this means was called "ijtihad", and it practitioner "mujtahid".

As stated, the practice of ray emerged after the demise of the Prophet (S) and the term continued to be in use for ijtihad in the writings of the Sunni fuqaha' until the early years of the 6th/12th century. Abu Hanifah alNu'man ibn Thabit (80150/699767) and his followers used the term ijtihad in the same sense. Their approach met with the outright rejection of the Shi'i Imams (A) and fuqaha; who denounced it in the strongest terms (details will come in the discussion about the sources of ijtihad). The use of this term however continued through centuries, till the time when it underwent a change.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

We need to go into there, like we need a whole in the head.

And I am not an isolationist. It's just that this is a lose/lose proposition and so why waste the money and then still be hated later?

BTW, Kpr, thanks for making me puke this morn, LOL!

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    13 years ago

I just don't know what to say.

That getting into bed with Islamists leads to a very nasty case of the Crabs?

 
 
 
kpr37
Professor Silent
link   seeder  kpr37    13 years ago

Sorry (LOL)

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    13 years ago

" Hizbullah Supporters Threaten To Harm UNIFIL Forces If EU Decides T... "

Aw, Jeesh ...lol,...it just doesn't get any more real or darkly comical...

"On June 12, 2013, the Lebanese daily Al-Akhbar reported that during a visit to Marjayoun by European Union (EU) Ambassador to Lebanon Angelina Eichhorst the previous day, village heads and mayors belonging to Hizbullah warned of the implications should the EU decide to include Hizbullah in its list of terrorist organizations."

In other words, "Don't call us terrorists, or we'll terrorize you!"

 
 
 
kpr37
Professor Silent
link   seeder  kpr37    13 years ago

AS THE civil war in Syria has dragged on, the rebels have become more Islamist and extreme. For Western governments pondering whether to arm them, Jabhat al-Nusra (Victory Front) is the biggest worry. Its global jihadist ideology justifies violence to bring about a nation where all Muslims unite. It enjoys murky sources of private funding, including regular payments from al-Qaeda in Iraq. Ahrar al-Sham has more local aims, but its comrades are also vehemently Islamist. Other umbrella groups, such as Liwa al-Tawhid in Aleppo, Syrias embattled second city, are harder to classify, in part because they serve as franchises or bring together smaller groups with a range of ideas. The Farouq Battalions, whose territorial reach goes from Homs to Hasaka in the north-east, is another mixed bag, ranging from Islamists to people with no particular ideology. The Supreme Military Command, led by General Salim Idriss, a Sunni defector from President Assads army, includes some able commanders but still lacks the cash and arms to match either the regimes forces or Jabhat al-Nusra, which ignores the military command. Ominously, rebels from more secular-minded or more moderately Islamist groups speak openly of a second war to comeagainst Jabhat al-Nusra

 
 
 
kpr37
Professor Silent
link   seeder  kpr37    13 years ago

Hezbollah leader Hassan Nasrallah on Friday said his militias intervention in Syria was late and came in response to a global project led by the United States and Israel to control not only Syria but the Middle East as a whole.

Nasrallah dismissed accusations that his militia is leading a sectarian war in Syria. The conflict in Syria is not between doctrines, not between Shiites and Sunnis; it is between two different projects.

He attacked pan-Arab television stations Al Arabiya and Al Jazeera and accused them of broadcasting not only inaccurate, but false information on the conflict.

The Hezbollah chief said for the first time that his forces will remain involved in the conflict after helping the forces of President Bashar al-Assad control the town of Qusayr. We are going ahead with our project and we bear all the consequences of it, Nasrallah

The ShiaCaliphate, the other side is fighting for a sunni Caliphate.

Al-Arabiya

Lebanon should not be an Islamic republic on its own, but rather, part of the Greater Islamic Republic, governed by the Master of Time [the Mahdi],

 
 

Who is online




RU4Real


109 visitors