╌>

Supreme Court Unanimously Rules Human Genes Cannot Be Patented

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  z  •  13 years ago  •  30 comments

Supreme Court Unanimously Rules Human Genes Cannot Be Patented

67C1nbQ.jpg

In a unanimous decision, the Supreme Court justices ruled that a company cannot patent an isolated human gene. To look at the implications of the decision and its impact for patients and medical research, Judy Woodruff talks to Todd Dickinson of the American Intellectual Property Law Association and Sandra Park of the ACLU . - http://www.pbs.org/newshour/bb/law/jan-june13/scotus_06-13.htm l

The Courts decision threw out patents awarded to Myriad Genetics Inc., a Utah company that isolated the location and sequence of whats known as the BRCA gene, which can signal risk of developing breast and ovarian cancer.

Justice Clarence Thomas, writing for the court, said To be sure, it found an important and useful gene, but separating that gene from its surrounding genetic material is not an act of invention,

This is a big win for women high risk for breast or ovarian cancer. Myriad said patients could use only its test at a cost of more than $3,000.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    13 years ago

Those that don't have much knowledge of biology, or genetics need to understand that this is a huge victory for individuals!

I really couldn't care less about who has access to who I called, or even what I talk about on the internet or on a cell phone as I can choose not to make use of those things or not. This decision is a huge step towards guaranteeing what makes you unique and have no control over as an individual, remain yours.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Aeonpax    13 years ago

EI,

I think you best read up on how the biotech industry is reacting, they have been overwhelmingly receptive. I'll just bring up one quote;

"Penn State law professor Eileen Kane, who has a Ph.D. in molecular biology, said that companies who rely on cDNA should view this as a good decision. But of companies whose business is based on tests derived from isolating naturally-occurring DNA, Kane said: "Their business models are in question."

Kane said the high court decision would encourage research, which could lead to more options for tests." - ...

Also, thanks for your opinion on the test costs but as I'm reading it, experts in the field disagree with your synopsis.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    13 years ago

Biotech companies have all along known that their incentives towards profit would be along the lines of artificial genes and gene sequencing. Their wet dream would have been to be able to patent that which the court ruled is not patentable.

I don't think there is too much of a chance of profit loss in this area of business as this field of research is still very much in it's infancy.

(More importantly..... you got tickets for tomorrow night?)

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    13 years ago

This ruling is a good balance.

Processes can and should be patentable. It doesn't matter if you are working at the molecular level, or making a new kind of snow tire. Companies should be allowed to make a return on their investment. What this ruling does do is it makes it that the "natural" gene sequences that come "as is" from our DNA cannot be patented.

I would also venture to guess that this will extend into mutated genes that are a product of cDNA. The process is patented, but what you body does with it is not somebody elses property.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

From what I've read, the cost of the procedure was about $3,000. And some insurance companies didn't cover it.

The cost in perfecting the procedure must have some way to recoup their investment in accomplishing this or it will be left to the goodwill of the researchers. I haven't seen many people or companies anywhere who desire to make investments unless there is a potential payback.

Often we feel the recoup far exceeds the investment to such an extent the recipient is held hostage. There has to be an equitable medium in order to promote the research and also allow the beneficiaries of that research to be able to afford to take advantage of it.

If you take away the incentive, you'll take away the research.

An equitable solution for all parties could require some patent law changes in length of time a patent is enforced and/or the ability to purchase license to use the patent for a reasonable fee during that time.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Aeonpax    13 years ago

From the amoral corporate view which you more than adequately represent, everything must be done with the express reason for PROFIT, which I most adamantly disagree with.

It would appear, according to you, that the humanistic purpose behind research for the sole purpose of relieving pain, curing diseases and generally caring for the well being of humanity is strictly a capitalistic venture which should be fully protected by law, again, for the reasons of increased profitability.

While I do see the logic and prudence of reimbursing companies for their research along with a fair return on their investment, I do not believe that the supposed legal rights in regards to such research should be held hostage in perpetuity by patents or other legal manipulations that either prohibit other companies from developing different and less costly methods or put a cost on it that is unreachable by most citizen of the earth. Anything done to help humanity in the process of medicine, should be shared FREE.

To wit;

Edward R. Murrow: Who owns the patent on this vaccine?
Jonas Salk: Well, the people, I would say. There is no patent. Could you patent the sun?

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Aeonpax    13 years ago

I agree Fly.

I have no problem with a patent on a method that isolates a "naturally occurring" gene.

However, to patent that particular gene, denying others the opportunity (unless you pay someone) to develop alternative methods for isolating that same naturally occurring gene, is to me; immoral.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    13 years ago

In the grander scheme of things, this is a highly encouraging decision.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Aeonpax    13 years ago

Did you read the article? Or, perhaps if you did, may I explain to you something about the English language.....

When the Brewers destroyed the White Sox last year, 16 to 2, they didn't actually or literally DESTROY them. Destroy, in this case, is an allegory.

When a person chops a tree down, then chops it up, the tree doesn't actually go up to it's original position; that's called a colloquialism.

In this case, when someone says "owning a gene", that is known as a metaphor.

I hope this clears up things for you

 
 
 
Blue Wolf2
Freshman Silent
link   Blue Wolf2    13 years ago

The problem with the Capitalist system though is that you can't make it work for everybody. It requires poverty to function. It requires inexhaustable resources to function sustainably. You cant raise the living standards of everyone to what we would consider "acceptable" for us, because there isn't enough Earth to supply those resources.

It WILL fail the test...it IS failing the test, and quickly.

 
 
 
Blue Wolf2
Freshman Silent
link   Blue Wolf2    13 years ago

I didn't mention socialism...why don't you just take what I actually said and respond to that?

Besides that, if I HAD mentioned it, I would have used Norway as an example. You know, the happiest people on earth in a cradle to grave welfare state?

The truth is that it is a socialist government that has produced the best results for its whole population than any other system.

 
 
 
Blue Wolf2
Freshman Silent
link   Blue Wolf2    13 years ago

yup... so much for my idea of a workforce that works for free until they die...............

 
 
 
Blue Wolf2
Freshman Silent
link   Blue Wolf2    13 years ago

agreed, 100%

The way we've done things, thought about things, is wrong. Flawed at the core. We need a do-over from the perspective that the Earth is our Mother and that we are all related.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

I'm just glad that corporations couldn't copyright the amino acid sequence [ACGT ] . Patents are for only 17 years ... Still I'm glad that that this decision took place . Now how about extending it to non-human DNA ? Nature includes a lot more than human DNA .

One more thing . If one is to take patent law seriously the "innovation" must not be outside the laboratory for more than 1 year or it becomes unpatentable . Natural gene sequences have existed for many thousands of years . Where is the patentability ?

 
 
 
Blue Wolf2
Freshman Silent
link   Blue Wolf2    13 years ago
Every farmer knows and operates under the principle that you cannot overburden the land. Peopke have the ability to comprehend this and they will learn it one way or another. So, why are leaders so scared to tell the truth and whaft is to be gained by ignoring it? How can capitalism be the best system when it is based on a fallacy, flawed fatally at the conceptual level?
 
 
 
Blue Wolf2
Freshman Silent
link   Blue Wolf2    13 years ago
Agreed EI, but you know the concept and so do they....its a good microcosm of my point about profit too. You cannot take more than you return. This is the most fundamental rule of the life cycle. You know you're over the limit when you must take resources from elsewhere. That is the root of imperialism....because it means you have to take them from somebody else. Flame was onto it when he spoke of people in large concentrations.
 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Aeonpax    13 years ago

Here's the SCOTUS decision: and the oral arguments; f

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Aeonpax    13 years ago

The patent laws in the US are so out of date and so abused it has almost become criminal. It has spawned what is called Patent Trolls .

This is really one of those decisions that it pays to read.

However, at issue was two thinks [brackets are mine];

  • ...if valid, Myriads patents would give it the [1]exclusive right to isolate an individuals BRCA1 and BRCA2 genes, and [2] would give Myriad the exclusive right to synthetically create BRCA cDNA. Petitioners filed suit, seeking a declaration that Myriads patents are invalid under 35 U. S. C. 101.

Easy_Capture1.jpg The court allowed [1] which is the method of gene isolation but threw out [2] which means it cannot own a patent on a synthesized naturally occurring gene.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

Thanks for the clarification APax . That makes sense . Methodology [process] is patentable and to demand it to not be would be unwise . Now if they could just address the issue of the many naturally occurring non-human genes ....

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

And as we all know, the only known experiment in socialist organization wasn't exactly a success, with a basic point of it pretty much not really being optimal for anyone but an even smaller oligarchy, and nobody can say that the soviets were all that friendly to the environment either.

Believe it or not, the capitalist system is pretty much the best system out there, though I agree, externalities MUST be put into the system, but it must be done equitably.

Flame, I always respect your thoughts, but I have to go with EI on this one, in that I think Capitalism is still the best economic system in the long term....even for the benefit of those emerging countries that our businesses are accused of exploiting. While the businesses do profit, the workers are paid a higher wage (though still at poverty level) than they otherwise would have earned, which boosts their economy.

 
 
 
jack c hill
Freshman Silent
link   jack c hill    13 years ago

Is Myraid going to pay royalties to the genes inventor?Grin.gif

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    13 years ago

Nah.... more than likely, Myraid will issue convertible preferred stock.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

Flame, @ 8 hours ago:

Nice comment, and I too, don't expect others to take my viewpoint.

Just to note, I agree with your terrarium theory, but I also think the combination of earth's purging itself, and the layers of -sphere, with some movement of air going up, and another running perpendicular - causes renewal eventually, even with ozone depletion (it's depleted naturally also, by solar radiation- so how do we know the sun won't destroy other gas atoms, while others will reach the ionosphere and drift into space; plus temperature would then be a factor that would cause changes in weather patterns, and that ozone depletion won't lead to new earthly adaptations among its inhabitants?), and it all starts again. Just my thoughts.I tend to look at the bigger picture. :)

However, when it comes to increased population, I have been in those discussions, and I'm not sold either direction, but I do think that change brings change, and that new civilizations in new environments will open doors for newly discovered resources and ways of life. (Are Polar bears going to go extinct due to the melt, the ice they needed that helped them to fish? I personally don't believe so. They will adapt to their changing environment, and will have a different way of life and diet---and so will we with increasing populations, good or bad.:) And, Capitalism will facilitate that, as I see it. ...We don't have to agree, but ....

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

I see the importance of expediency in many areas of what we are doing, too, Flame. I think it's because we don't have any 'good' way of achieving balance in our lives, and not wanting to create laws that will oppress us preventing choice (although there are a lot of environmental regulations, but I'm referring to population issues) that we have trouble preventing destruction.

Like China--- look where that led - to selective gender abortions, that could throw things the other way for them in the distant future, leading to depopulation that can also destroy societies. It's such a necessary delicate balance that's needed, yet, again I don't see forcing everyone to live a particular life-style as the UNs Agenda 21 (and ICLEI), the answer either. The Rockefellers, Rothschilds, etc. take all of financial gain instead of leaving it with local communities.

There's both an upside and a downside to Capitalism, I know.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

Yes. And I hope it fixes itself.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Aeonpax    13 years ago

The opinion of Scalia's alleged "brilliance" is definitely not shared within the legal community nor the the public at large.

This Belief he refers to can also be an admission that religion trumps science and that in itself, is as ignorant as person can get. His use of the word belief can infer that at anytime and for some purely immaterial reason, a person can reject science simply because he/she does not believe in it.

Scalia mistakes belief for understanding.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Aeonpax    13 years ago

You make a major mistake here reducing this to an ideological struggle.

The Living Constitution is a philosophical concept involving constitutional interpretation which claims that the Constitution has a dynamic meaning that changes as our society changes. The idea is associated with views that contemporaneous society should be taken into account when interpreting key constitutional phrases.

The ideas of Strict Constructionism and Living Constitution are NOT inherently liberal or conservative but rather, are concepts which ideological sides align themselves to because of political expediency.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Aeonpax    13 years ago

Bad analogy if not completely irrelevant to this argument.

So you did NOT read the courts decisions nor the oral arguments, claiming doing so was "busy work." That speaks volumes about you but it's not the point here.

However, you should brush up on what the "Scientific Method" is and how it relates to this case, but that too, you might consider "busy work" and pass.

So, let me put this in a manner you might accept: Blessed are they who believe without seeing......

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Aeonpax    13 years ago

Thomas Jefferson on a "Living Constitution"; "No society can make a perpetual constitution, or even a perpetual law. The earth belongs always to the living." - Thomas Jefferson

Jefferson also wrote a letter to James Madison (6 Sept. 1789 - Papers 15:392--97) promoting the concept of a "Living Constitution" so please, lets dispense with this he said/she said argument. Quotes are a good way to drive home a point but are not proof of anything.

You haven't even addressed my main point that neither the "Strict Constructionaist" nor the "Living Constitution" is inherently a conservative or liberal perspective.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Aeonpax    13 years ago

So you can cut and paste his history, so what? Wouldn't a simple link done just as good?

You again, bypassed my arguments with your garrulous nonsense. No one is saying he's uneducated so why bring it up?

You are completely and deliberately missing the point here. The subject here is Scalia's jurisprudence .

Here are some headlines from newspapers and articles about Scalia's decision in this case:

Gene Patents: Justice Scalia Dissents On High School Science

Antonin Scalia Does Not Believe in Molecular Biology

Gene Ruling: Justice Scalia Reveals Ignorance in Gene Patent Decision

Supreme Court: Genes can't be patented, Scalia: What are genes?

Scalia isn't sure that genes play a part in sexual reproduction, thinks a stork might somehow be involved

Justice Antonin Scalia Does Not Believe in Genes or Genetics

Scalia on DNA Patents: I Dont Really Understand Science

Let's get back on topic.

 
 

Who is online




RU4Real


109 visitors