Google discloses how it transmits data to NSA, other U.S. agencies
http://http://www.latimes.com/business/technology/la-fi-tn-google-discloses-how-it-transmits-data-to-nsa-us-government-20130611,0,4862733.story
" SAN FRANCISCO -- Google and other technology companies are pushing back against media reports that they gave national intelligence agencies direct access to their servers to turn over emails and other online communication from users.
Google, Facebook and Microsoft each called on the U.S. government Tuesday to make public the number and scope of national security requests.
PHOTOS: Top music subscription services
When Google receives court orders to turn over information to the government, it uses FTP, a secure way of sending encrypted files over the Internet, according to Google spokesman Chris Gaither.
"The U.S. government does not have the ability to pull that data directly from our servers or network," Gaither said.
"We refuse to participate in any program for national security or other reasons that requires us to provide governments with access to our systems or to install their equipment on our networks. "

Well, the FTP might be a secure way of sending "encrypted files," to the Government, and it is also nice to know that random information can't be pulled directly from their servers. But I still have to ask, why does a business feel any pressure to hand out personal information to the Government...can they say no ? Is there something in it for a business in doing so ? ..Special favors of some kind in return ?
Good question CL..It would be interesting to know that answer.
Color me a spectic EI, but I don't believe one word that either the gov't or goggle says. CYA all the way.
Well, no, I wasn't suggesting that they should ignore the courts, I am wondering why they can't say "no." On what legal grounds can a government order they do it, without "probable cause." In the case of internet records, that wouldn't be the same in my mind because they can't be sure who was typing...yes? Therefore, I would think that would cancel out justification of probable cause. In the case of spying on a phone call, they have a voice to 'prove or disprove' legitimacy.
Do you see where I'm going with my logic ?
Kav, me either!
That's an interesting point. I hadn't thought of the court orders being the same as a warrant for someone's arrest, but I suppose this could be considered arresting someone's records. I see, justification for the act comes later. Ok.
If the Government's goal in doing so isn't so much trying to prove individual or group guilt, but just to obtain leads and other information, then I can see why they might want to do it, but if it's to censor a person or group's activity, then I go back to my point---they don't know who was actually typing.
I guess so. It just doesn't seem like they should be able to do it, imo. For example, and off-topic sort of, after the Boston race ordeal, the Swat teams were barging into people's homes, often forcing people out and restricting re-entrance for up to 15 hours... that didn't seem justified to me, and I think it should have fallen under the Fourth Amendment for them to not be able to do that.
Oh Chloe.......you're making too much sense. What law gives the government the right to order a company to turn over that information and for what reasons?
Oh I see......now it all makes sense.
LOL
Tell me.....do you trust this man or that woman?
Hey, our new National Security Adviser is on here too. Bet she doesn't do what Snowden did!
You see it's all the pixels that make up the whole picture, so here are some of the pixels to observe for yourself.
I don't have to watch CSPAN, even though I do, to see the big picture.
Why would Google have to abide by the government's demands because they had a product the government wanted?
Do I have to give my product to the government if they decide they want it as well?
Flame, I liked this statement of yours: " And the government is riding an excessively tight line, forced along by huge business interests and social interests and the simple need to maintain order when everyone is getting restive. " True, they are under pressure from all sides... each one expecting them to do something different, so they try to please everyone the best they can...yet, sometimes I get the feeling that they are trying to get used to "interpretation" of our laws and Executive Orders, moreso, than appeasement. I don't know.
It is to my ears, too, because I don't relate security and freedom in the same sentence. Freedom from intrusion without due cause is to me an injustice of privacy. I think "probable cause" should be related to some type of evidence, but, to think the Government can force their way into our homes without reasonable suspicion that they will find something...doesn't seem ethical to me..Just my thoughts. Now with data collection from internet files, they would seem to find a lot of useful information...reasonable suspicion, yet it still feels unethical to me.
What Is a Federal Warrant?
I can see if you're suspect of committing a crime, but just because the government wants your product, I don't understand that.
Egilman....That's good to know. I know Google has some privacy statements they make to customers, and there are opt-outs for the user, to protect their privacy. I wondering why Internet companies could claim some type of Fiduciary relationship with clients as reasoning for a Judge... unless the privacy agreement states that the Government can supersede the digital agreement.
Points:
1 - Th US government maintains that Google (among many others) have secretly allowed the NSA and FBI direct access to "all" of its data -
2 - From the very start, all the internet companies involved ( Microsoft, Yahoo, Google, Facebook, PalTalk, AOL, Skype, YouTube, and Apple ) have denied that. ...
The leaked information corroborates that #1 is a fact.
Something does not make sense here. It has already been established that the NSA and DOJ is using Section 215 of the PATRIOT Act to support what government attorneys call a sensitive collection program that may be targeting large numbers of Americans. Section 215 allows for secret court orders to collect tangible things that could be relevant to a government investigation.
Until the leaks occurred, Google was a secret participating member of this legal but highly questionable operation. Had this leak not occurred, I have no doubt that Google would have continued to secretly providing the government with its data.
Methinks the Google doth protest too much.
AeonPax, Thank you for this potential contradiction re Google's implied intentions. I had trouble accessing my link to the source in the article...I hope no one else did!
The rest of article that I didn't quote did state similar to part of what you said, also. Just so everyone can read the rest, I'll copy the brief second half of the article :
" Wired was the first to report how Google transfers the data. The Washington Post and the Guardian newspapers originally reported that the federal government has direct access to the Web servers of Google, Yahoo, Facebook, Microsoft, Apple and others, as part of a classified National Security Agency program called PRISM.
The companies have denied those reports. The government has acknowledged the program, which it says monitors foreign nationals who may pose a threat.
Google's legal chief, David Drummond, said in a public letter Tuesday that "assertions in the press that our compliance with these requests gives the U.S. government unfettered access to our users data are simply untrue." "
ALSO:
NSA program part of larger effort to target Internet
NSA contract analyst says he leaked surveillance documents
Google wants to tell you more about the info spy agencies are seeking
___
So, what looks like is happening here to me is deceptive implication - it's a form of diversion, a bit of sleight of mouth rhetoric to draw an intended conclusion (to overload and distract the conscious mind so that unconscious communication can be cultivated--from Wiki--Neuro linguistic Programming). I didn't see this before when I read the article.
But the deception is that they have me realizing that they actually didn't lie to us...they told us what they do and how they do it with the encrypted files...but they might have left out the little tidbit of information that they also, give the government the rest of their data in other ways, perhaps.
Look again, at this final statement:
" Google's legal chief, David Drummond, said in a public letter Tuesday that "assertions in the press that our compliance with these requests gives the U.S. government unfettered access to our users data are simply untrue." "
The surface implication is that they don't give the government unrestrained access to users' account information. How does our mind interpret that ? ..Most of us probably took that to mean (the unconscious communication)---Ok, so the government doesn't see everything because they don't have access to the servers. ..But, what Google might not be telling us that is more important is -- what is Google (and the others) doing with the information? Perhaps the government doesn't have "unfettered access to users' data" -- because they don't need it, if there is already an agreement that the media companies will forward all of the data to them. To keep the customers happy they might have devised part of the forwarding process to be in the FTP format saying that is what they send the government---but that doesn't have to mean that 'all' of what they send, is...so they might not be lying...they just might have left out some of the important stuff, like what else they send and in what format.
I agree, Six. I like your "product" points in that just because the Government wants our product, shouldn't mean that we 'have to' give it to them...despite their setting up their secret court that Egilman mentioned.
Is there a law that states that?!! ...I know there isn't, but I wish everyone, popular vote, could vote a "no" on that. That's too much power and control. Even though privacy isn't specifically stated in the Constitution, it's incorporated in specific ways to sensibly indicate the intention of Security with 'probable cause' and 'reasonable doubt' resulting from an event or action---not prevention of an event or action, which to me, is what they are actually doing.
I'm looking at this from a slightly different perspective. There was something about that Google letter I sensed didnt fit into the scheme of incidences here.
When I read the Google PR statement by its attorney, I was tempted to post my own exegesis of words and phrases I found in the letter to be ambiguous, prevaricating and obfuscated. However right I think I am, Im not an attorney and it would be only my opinion. The glaring thing to me was that his statement wholly contradicted what the government was saying. In plain words, Google is trying to cover its corporate ass.
In the legal arena, words mean a lot. Theres a big difference, when under oath, to telling the truth, the whole truth . as opposed to telling the facts, all the facts The same applies to pleading not guilty as opposed to claiming to be innocent . Good attorneys are especially attuned to the nuances, semantics and subtleties of the English language. Consider the cryptic phrase; Tangible things.
Take this news headline for example; Sen. Wyden: Clapper didnt give straight answer on NSA programs . ...
When asked by Wyden at an Intelligence Committee hearing, whether the National Security Agency collects any type of data at all on millions of Americans , Clapper responded, No, si r
He lied.but the Post merely stated he didnt give a straight answer . Again; big difference. To go further, he lied to Congress. People go to jail for that but but I have no doubt hell get off scot-free. If he was under oath that would also mean perjury.
This may be only the tip of the iceberg,I hope not.
There is another possibility..... it may not be totally about national security.
As all internet traffic is or will be in the future planned to go through the NSA servers, is it possible that this is a way for internet corporations to obtain "Pay for service", and the government to be able to tax internet purchases?
It's just a stretch of my imagination...
Not very far off, FLYNAVY, from what some of my other commenters said, if they are correct.
Great point on the semantics and legal implications with the way words are put together, and how the meanings can be different even tho they would seem to mean the same thing.
Well, if correct, this is what I was told by others...1) The media companies are already paid to provide the information to the government; 2) The FTP server is not secure! If that's Ok, I'll let you read what was said, I'll just copy their replies, I'm comfortable posting names:
___
"actually, 8.8.8.8 is Google's DNS server address, and FTP is a common (and NOT "secure") file transfer protocol that is built into almost every browser."
"Competent digital criminals running WireShark and some common network tools can capture the traffic.
The federal government has NEVER hired competent people to do this kind of work.
They don't even have proper job descriptions."
"they can get anything related to that "metadata" they want. something like 11,000 court orders were given last year (from what I heard).
true? I don't know, it sounds likely, but that doesn't make it true."
"When a warrant is signed by a judge then Google, Yahoo, Apple, and all other company must satisfy the request or face prosecution for obstruction of justice.
The standard consulting fee is about $150/hour for this kind of warrant.
Google, Yahoo, and Apple were paid to do this work."
"Companies like Google and Yahoo used to give the government anything they asked for without requiring a warrant.
That has stopped.
The trouble is that the warrants are 'secret' so FOIA cannot be used to investigate the extent of the abuse."
"Products like WireShark combined with other tools allow any criminal to intercept all data in transit across any public network, which includes anything covered by subpoena or search warrant.
Since we are talking about Google, check this out;
Ok, let me get this straight.
I strongly suspect corporate culpability here as well as both groups initially didn't get their lies stories straight and are now trying to dig their collective lying asses out.
How do you explain this statement then?
Google discloses how it transmits data to NSA, other U.S. agencies
lol, google head is a lib, and good buddy of barry's. hes probably been to the white house almost as many times as the head of the IRS has (which was 157 times).
I've never really trusted Google to begin with. I remember using various other search engines before Google came on the scene, and being perfectly happy with them. Then I noticed that the Google thing just started popping up everywhere, looking to be your first choice in search services. It got harder and harder toavoid Google and use my favorite search engines, until it was eventually impossible not to use Google. It always seemed strange to me thatGoogle wasforcefully occupying so much real estate on the internet, and then came the articles boasting how incredibly huge the Google facilities are, allowing for a crazy amount of storage. I would not be the least bit surprised to learn that Googlewas precisely a plannedcomponent ofa coordinated effort toherd all searches into the realm of the government surveillance program that is at the heart of today's privacy concerns.
Excellent point Hal.
I'm not too sure about that. The original "Wired" article says the same thing. - ...
It was written by Kim Zetter who is a senior reporter at Wired covering cybercrime, privacy, security and civil liberties....and generally known for vetting her information.
It wasn't just wiretapping, it was a conduit that transmitted the entire Internet.
641A
OK, the word "secure" should have been inserted in front of FTP. Glad you made that point crystal clear. I'll make a note of that.
However....
..the MAIN point is, you said "It has nothing to do with "PRISM" when the article made it abundantly clear that it did.
I'll take the word of Kim Zetters over yours and leave it at that.
It's all here...at one handy site.
Given the potential for abuse of power, including but not limited to political expediency, is it time to re-write and/or amend the Patriot Act to include the following provisions?
1) No NSA (nor any other Federal, state or local government agency) act of surveillance shall occur without a writ of "probable cause" which shall be evaluated by the FISA court and, which shall continuously be subject to scrutiny by a neutral oversight body.
2) Where expediency/exigent circumstances necessarily delay the presentation of said writ, the writ shall be subsequently forthcoming within a reasonable period of time as determined by the oversight body.
3) Any/all NSA et al information gathered on individuals/entities that does not meet "probable cause" standards -- if/when so determined by the oversight body, shall be expunged from all NSA et al government data bases/records for all time, and, any/all references to such expunged information shall be inadmissible in any/all subsequent actions.
4) AT NO TIME SHALL THE NSA, et al government agencies, its employees, designees, etc., local, state or Federal, PLACE ANY INFORMATION, SOFTWARE, etc., on the hard drives or any/all other devices of any private citizen, business, etc., under penalty of commensurate breach-of-privacy laws.
5) Any/all NSA et al-obtained information previously gathered via acts of "domestic spying" on private citizens, businesses and other entities not meeting "probable cause" standards, shall be permanently expunged by systematic shredding/deletion CONDUCTED IN THE PRESENCE OF THE OVERSIGHT BODY WHICH SHALL VERIFY THE PROCESS DURING AND UPON COMPLETION OF THE PROCESS. All affected entities shall be apprised of the expunging and further apprised that the expunged information can never be admissible in conjunction with any/all adverse actions.
National Security is crucial and necessary but it must be implemented with protocols that do not violate or bypass American citizens Constitutional protections particularly with regard to "probable cause" standards.
____________________________________________
My two cents.
I think the NSA and the USA can "walk and chew gum" at the same time.
I'm talking about the possibility of PLANTING "EVIDENCE" on an unsuspecting user's hard drive, cell phone or other internet-connected device.
We actually DON'T KNOW WHAT RULES ARE IN EFFECT -- that's the problem. The logistics of information gathering is one thing -- obviously that must remain secret, but assuring deference/prioritization to "probable cause" and the Constitution, even retrospectively when probable cause turns out to be null and void -- that's my issue.
If terrorists have destroyed portions of the Constitution, we're no longer "America." It seems to me there's a middle ground.
Are you seriously asking why a government agency would plant evidence?
Remember Joe McCarthy/J. Edgar Hoover/Richard Nixon?
Once planted, "evidence" will be turned over to law enforcement. Are you doubting the existence of the setting up of "patsies" via collusion of agencies?
"Misusing the law?" Which government agency might be incapable of that?
Will you explain the significance of this?
By the way, there's some ass-covering to be explained; Organized Wealth has too much to say about who constitutes the biggest threats and to whom.
...
If the shoe fits
You know, I truly don't know who to believe, Gaither or the NYT:
...The Lockbox access that is suggested that it was created for Gov analysts to specifically access.
Yet, Google says they use the "secure FTP"...to send encrypted files.
So, which is it - Google sending or the Government accessing through a type of Lockbox access ?
One can access an FTP server, that is separate from other servers.
Either way, FTP servers are just places to store data, separate from other servers. Google may indeed send the info to a government FTP site from their own FTP location. FTP2FTP.
EI, I'm sorry but I did not get a tracking of your comment above and several others! This is happening a lot!
Anyway, I'm just wanting to clarify if there are two types of FTP--one secure and one not-- or if using FTP transfers means they are always SFTP.
Wired stated that SFTP involved some type of old-fashioned hand transfer system, leading me to think that there might be two types of transfers.
LOL.. You'll just get more spam for brands of pasta, now...and probably sauce. Gotta watch out for those spaghetti algorithms.
Yes, that makes sense, and I respect Google's attempt at honesty, while some of the other media cos that were asked about their policies...they refused to divulge. Hmmm...
However, the discrepancy appears to exist...with the PRISM reasoning saying giving the Gov their own access was the reason they created it, yet Google saying 'no' they didn't, they send files by hand.
Where my mind is going is that 'both' are probably happening. The italicized info I brought in commenting that the three were paid for their info release brings in another aspect that the media didn't mention. The commenter didn't say where he got his info, but he also said the same things as many of you here.
Chloe,
In my humble opinion, all this discussion about SFTP and lockbox is a Red Herring or a distraction to the greatest or only issue here which is governments spying on its citizens.
Some people here and other places online, are quibbling or prevaricating honest discussion on this issue to the De Minimis or Reductio ad absurdum level in regards to corporate involvement.
Theres a good article here; Heres everything we know about PRISM to date - While I don't agree with everything said, one point is clear: The method of transfer of data is absolutely and totally irrelevant .
For business reasons only, the corporations are desperate to distance themselves from the governments assertion that there was willful collusion involving PRISM because it will affect their profitability and that has a lot to do with something called Cloud Computing which the internet giants have invested heavily in.
In the simplest explanation possible, Cloud Computing is where companies and individuals upload/transfer all or most of their data (personal and sensitive) to the servers of corporations such as Google, which allows people, employees or agents online anywhere in the world, to access this data, depending on their security clearance.
If it is found that these companies (Google, Microsoft, Yahoo, etc) are surreptitiously giving the government wide or unfettered access to this data, (by passing security clearance) they stand to lose billions of dollars as those business who dont want anyone snooping through their data (much less the government) will pull out.
The real question here is Are the companies lying? Or using legalistic language to hide their participation? and that topic unfortunately, is being passed over in useless discussion on methods.
It fits perfectly.
Instead of monitoring and prioritizing a potential threat to the citizenry and national security, what was being monitored and prioritized was a perceived threat in the way of a well-deserved "black eye" to the thieving bastards on Wall Street -- the pricks that actually run the country by buying our legislators and other officials.
It was a deflection indeed -- but not from this thread nor by me; it was a deflection from national security to watch dog duty on behalf of Wall Street.
Get the fuck off the "cut-and-paste" attacks too -- if you and others don't care for back up information when I state my position, that's on you and them, not me!
All I copied and pasted was a link which you likely ignored; it explains my comment about organized wealth.
Here's the headline at the link
Unaware of Tsarnaev warnings, Boston counterterror unit tracked protesters
You should read it before accusing me of deflecting; you raised Boston in this thread -- I responded.
AeonPax,
Excellent reply and in pointing to the Red Herring fallacy that is being thrown into the issue by both these media companies and the Government !
I tried to implicate this diversion in my opening statement, but I too, was distracted. I should have been more forthright in stating as you did, that it simply isn't ethical for businesses to agree to it, nor for the Government to request it, imo. ..Very true, the method of transfer is irrelevant...it shouldn't be happening. Period.
As I see it as I implied in another comment, their (Gov) actions should be an after-the-fact, due process with evidence, "probable cause" that they physically obtained through the course of investigating an offender's actions -- not a preventative snooping beforehand that could be mis-attributed (not sure if that's a word) to an individual or group erroneously using "key words" detected by algorithms!
Also, I just love how you enlightened us with their (media cos) 'potential' reasoning for lying about not providing Gov direct access - protecting their heavy investments in cloud computing! Of course! That makes perfect sense, because that knowledge of the Govs nose in our business with easy access, would surely chase many away.
I remember when they all were trying to sell that technology to all of us...free up hard drive, et al. Funny how they leave things out, isn't it.
Exactly what we were talking about before. As I stated before, they really aren't lying, they're just leaving things out, and manipulating the use and structure of how words are put together, as you pointed out previously, to create a particular meaning...as I pointed out in their use of Neuro-linguistics Programming - used on us by both the Government and Business in order to sell us on ideas by the former, and on products by the latter.
Hmmm...not sure why my comment landed above yours, but really...I am just happy that it landed at all !
Also, here's a statement from Twitter that made me curious..
" Twitter, meanwhile, has said it did not respond to government requests to peer into its databases. Users "have a right to fight invalid government requests, and we stand with them in that fight," the company was quoted by the Times as saying."
I don't know, but I think they are lying, too. But, they are letting us know that we don't have to just 'take it as it comes,' either. ...A further point fromthat article..
NPR's Dina Temple-Raston, reporting on , says PRISM is part of a new effort to mine so-called 'Big Data' to handle very large volumes of information to winnow out some bits with significance that might otherwise be lost.
"Stores like Target have been using huge volumes of sales information to try to predict customer behavior ... now the intelligence community is trying to do that, too," Dina says.
"The intelligence community says that until they actually analyze the data which requires a judge's permission they are merely housing the information, not looking at it, so privacy isn't an issue," she says. "
Again, I don't believe that...they seem to be implicating that they have given themselves legal access, but they aren't able to do anything with the mass info until a court order comes down...I think that's part of the 'language' that we were talking about...maybe 'people' can't, but algorithms 'can' !
..Now my comment is below where it should be. Really...it was above before. No, I'm not crazy...it was... Oh well, life wasn't supposed to make sense anyway. lol
Good point! Intelligence should acquire phone numbers and data when they need it, and let proper entities store the info until that time.
Yes, very true. In that respect, I agree with the constant analysis. They might not be able to pinpoint if someone other than a billing name is doing the texting in an initial investigation, but with the phone's GPS's monitoring that's built-in, they would be able to locate the user in-progress, if that is correct. So, I can see how Intelligence's analyzing the original data could lead to a more invasive and necessary investigation using "probable cause", and should be considered legitimate.
EI,
I see what you mean, and I believe you are right. For example, if they interpret terrorist activity, they might not want to isolate individuals, but rather, wait for individual activity to lead them to the groups or leaders of groups, and suggestive data of future plans.
Is something like that what you had in mind?
No tracking. Good thing Egilman commented, otherwise I would not have known you commented.
Egilman...Thank you for that link !
These two paragraphs stand out for me:
" But this is more than just a data center, says one senior intelligence official who until recently was involved with the program. The mammoth Bluffdale center will have another important and far more secret role that until now has gone unrevealed. It is also critical, he says, for breaking codes. And code-breaking is crucial, because much of the data that the center will handlefinancial information, stock transactions, business deals, foreign military and diplomatic secrets, legal documents, confidential personal communicationswill be heavily encrypted. According to another top official also involved with the program, the NSA made an enormous breakthrough several years ago in its ability to cryptanalyze, or break, unfathomably complex encryption systems employed by not only governments around the world but also many average computer users in the US. The upshot, according to this official: Everybodys a target; everybody with communication is a target.
In the processand for the first time since Watergate and the other scandals of the Nixon administrationthe NSA has turned its surveillance apparatus on the US and its citizens. It has established listening posts throughout the nation to collect and sift through billions of email messages and phone calls, whether they originate within the country or overseas. It has created a supercomputer of almost unimaginable speed to look for patterns and unscramble codes. Finally, the agency has begun building a place to store all the trillions of words and thoughts and whispers captured in its electronic net. And, of course, its all being done in secret. To those on the inside, the old adage that NSA stands for Never Say Anything applies more than ever. "
___
But, we know they will still miss a lot, as they have in the past.
The manipulators and controllers of the world will have 'insiders' - plants to monitor what they are doing to circumvent the encrypted data's codes' message by aiding an alternate plans effectiveness that they aren't aware of - that trick I've read about on Newsvine - get them looking over there, while you're doing something else over here. Or, have I seen too many movies.
EI,
I'm sorry that I didn't communicate very well in my last comment. That was what I meant--after a pattern has been detected (that is caused by individuals' data)--then they go after who is involved.
That's what you meant, yes ?
EI,
What denotes a confidential, personal communication from everything else...the massive flow of data taken out of context ? How can they tell one set of words from another? I hope question makes sense. I guess I'm reading one set of thoughts that they are collecting and analyzing everything, but then another set of thoughts that they require a court order. I'm not seeing where that line is drawn when they are collecting 'everything' already.
Thank you for that reply. It was informative.
Lol, the Bourne movies were exactly what I was thinking about!
Yes, and I don't see how they could expect to pick up on everything, or even close, really. Those involved would be on the watch for not letting intentions known on communication devices, it would seem, and might use alternate systems or be in close enough contact to avoid satellites.
It's very disheartening, and I agree... we don't know who to trust.
EI,
Formal definition from Wiki:
The term metadata refers to " data about data". The term is ambiguous, as it is used for two fundamentally different concepts ( types ). Structural metadata is about the design and specification of data structures and is more properly called "data about the containers of data"; descriptive metadata , on the other hand, is about individual instances of application data, the data content.
___
No, I didn't gather from the conversations in these threads the formal definition of the term metadata...and from Wiki, it is stated that the term needs to be defined in context--not as a general term.
So, "Thank you" for commenting one of the uses of the word. Now that I understand which context you were putting the word in, I can now understand the need for a court order.
We are in complete agreement on this....who'd of thought....
EI,
Well...here is what I have to say about that in regards to "Nobody wants to discuss":
We do, but we all need to be on the same page with terms, and to make sure we can prove our statements like this one:
Yes ?
While you claim nobody is reading your articles, it is blatantly obvious you are not reading anyone else's.
As I see it:
...the act of mass spying on innocent citizens is }}}} Wrong {{{{
One way or another, this issue is going to the Supreme Court and for better or worse, they'll be the final arbitrators of this.
Who, pray tell, has been saying it isn't legal? There's a BIG difference between people arguing about rhetorical aspects of the legality of this scandal and someone who is point blank saying this is illegal. I've seen no evidence of the latter. It is you whom are making an issue where none exists.
The fact that you are consistently are bringing up the issue of legality where no question exists, either proves you are an apologist for the president and congress or, are shilling for them.
We'll see.
(Smith vs. Maryland)
I think with " reasonable cause " for suspicion, I can agree with tapping a customer's line for #s dialed.
But what Google and other companies are doing is giving access and handing over data without "reasonable cause" (Because we don't get to see those secret court orders, then we don't know if "reasonable cause" is used or if they are just snooping), and you nor I know which metadata is actually viewed by them, and yes, they would have phone # info as well as tower networks info as part of the phone companies digital recordings for billing - and - I don't see how tapping phone lines due to 'reasonable cause' has anything to do with accessing mass transit data for general analysis, so, whether it's "structural metadata or descriptive metadata" or didlysquatdata -- how it gets precedence status with Smith vs. Maryland is not apparent to me, as they are unrelated! And remember, metadata is not a general term---we need to specify which one we are talking about so that we all know what is being referred to, by our government and media cos.
The point remains as AeonPax pointed out---what they are doing might be legal with precedence in the case of phone record monitoring---but it is not ethical to collect data on everything and anything, especially in the case of the new Data center---they do not need to know how we use a credit card observing every purchase and bank transaction, every internet and phone transaction without "reasonable cause" -- no matter which form of metadata is used. I agree with Twitter, if they truly made the statement I quoted --- we can and should fight government intrusion into our lives---despite secret courts and case law with unethical interpretation, with internet data collection !
Ok...fine, quit, but if any of us don't understand what you are trying to communicate, please consider that maybe you have communicated ineffectively, and that it 'might not' be our lack of comprehension.
___
The only *dual concepts* that I recall encountering in these threads (and please know that I might not be aware of previous articles you have written, as I'm not always here -- so I might not have read what you stated in your articles) are:
1) There has been data collection (of some kinds/types) from phone lines & there has been data collection (of some kinds/types) from internet records;
2) There are two forms of metadata.
3)...Google claims they only send encrypted files from court orders, but the Gov is saying they have lockbox access resulting from PRISM.
Yes, it does matter if there is morality/ethics involved---legal status might be established by the Congress and SC...but if they are 'harming' the citizenry in their decisions, as many of us see, then we should 'right' the 'wrong' - Period. ...And, no, I do not believe they are not accessing Descriptive Metadata, as well as Structural, without a court order.
So, in your attempt to make me look stupid---you have not made it clear what it is you don't think I'm getting. I've said many times that I understand they created laws that benefit themselves...and I have been repeatedly letting you know why we, as a body of citizens, should not let it stand. So, you can ignore my request to tell me what part of that you don't think I understand, but I will be very disappointed if don't.
EI,
I don't see anything to misinterpret or misunderstand, so that's why I'm trying to get from you what it is you think I don't understand.
Do you mind simply and clearly stating what the two programs are, enumerating them -
AND - pointing to what I saw as the point of this article - Google saying they only send encrypted files to the government due to court order - but, conversely, the Gov says they have access to Google's special account set up for them resulting from PRISM - how this article fits contextually with your two programs... in other words, do your two programs help us with who is telling the truth...Google or the Gov?
That was the point of the article.
___
AeonPax and I support a separate point than the article's point, of ethics, saying that whether case law is being used or not---in the event of internet data collection using FISA secret court orders---it should not be happening *without reasonable cause*. There should be no 'secret' that they are accessing massive data. They don't have to tell us 'why' they are if there is sensitivity, but they should tell us if they do have direct access to a cos files so that we are aware we are being spied on or recorded en masse, and can make our own decisions accordingly.