If the NSA Trusted Edward Snowden With Our Data, Why Should We Trust the NSA?
Edward Snowden sounds like a thoughtful, patriotic young man, and Im sure glad he blew the whistle on the NSAs surveillance programs . But the more I learned about him this afternoon, the angrier I became. Wait , him ? The NSA trusted its most sensitive documents to this guy ? And now, after it has just proven itself so inept at handling its own information, the agency still wants us to believe that it can securely hold on to all of our data? Oy vey!
According to the Guardian , Snowden is a 29-year-old high school dropout who trained for the Army Special Forces before an injury forced him to leave the military. His IT credentials are apparently limited to a few computer classes he took at a community college in order to get his high school equivalency degreecourses that he did not complete. His first job at the NSA was as a security guard. Then, amazingly, he moved up the ranks of the United States national security infrastructure: The CIA gave him a job in IT security. He was given diplomatic cover in Geneva. He was hired by Booz Allen Hamilton, the government contractor, which paid him $200,000 a year to work on the NSAs computer systems.
Because Snowden is now in Hong Kong, its unclear what the United States can do to him. But watch for officials to tar Snowdenhell be called unpatriotic, unprofessional, treasonous, a liar, grandiose, and worse. As in the Bradley Manning case, though, the more badly Snowden is depicted, the more rickety the governments case for surveillance becomes. After all, they hired him. They gave him unrestricted access to their systems, from court orders to PowerPoint presentations depicting the crown jewels of their surveillance infrastructure. (Also of note: They made a hideous PowerPoint presentation depicting the crown jewels of their surveillance infrastructurewho does that? Ive been reading a lot of Le Carr lately, and when I saw the PRISM presentation, I remembered how Le Carrs veteran spy George Smiley endeavored to never write down his big secrets. Now our spies arent just writing things downtheyre trying to make their secrets easily presentable to large audiences.)
Lets note what Snowden is not: He isnt a seasoned FBI or CIA investigator. He isnt a State Department analyst. Hes not an attorney with a specialty in national security or privacy law.
Instead, hes the IT guy, and not a very accomplished, experienced one at that. If Snowden had sent his rsum to any of the tech companies that are providing data to the NSAs PRISM program , I doubt hed have even gotten an interview. Yes, he could be a computing savant anywaymany well-known techies dropped out of school. But he was given access way beyond what even a supergeek should have gotten. As he tells the Guardian , the NSA let him see everything. He was accorded the NSAs top security clearance, which allowed him to see and to download the agencys most sensitive documents. But he didnt just know about the NSAs surveillance systemshe says he had the ability to use them. I, sitting at my desk, certainly had the authorities [sic] to wiretap anyone from you or your accountant to a federal judge to even the president if I had a personal email, he says in a video interview with the paper .
The worst part about the NSAs surveillance is not its massive reach. Its that it operates entirely in secret, so that we have no way of assessing the sophistication of its operation. All we have is the word of our politicians, who tell us that theyve vetted these systems and that we should blindly trust that the data are being competently safeguarded and arent vulnerable to abuse.
Snowdens leak is thus doubly damaging. The scandal isnt just that the government is spying on us. Its also that its giving guys like Snowden keys to the spying program. It suggests the worst combination of overreach and amateurishness, of power leveraged by incompetence. The Keystone Cops are listening to us all.

Imagine what he could have done with "actual data"!
Actually there was a snippit on the new that he worked for 3 months and was fired for violating ethics and something else. But I didnt get if this was his first job or the last one, where he gathered info. So obviously it didnt go un noticed by someone?
Secondly, all there is at this point in time is this guys word that this was done and that was done. When the truth comes out I bet we find out he didn't have as much authority or clearance as he thinks he did. For starters when someone goes getting into sensitive information that they are not privy to, it sets off an alert that this was invaded and by what computer. I think many of his claims are grandiose in nature but facts should start emerging soon. I will wait to see what else comes out.
I understand this work is contracted out? I would like to know more about that and if this was what happened with this guy which it seems like to me might be the case?
This has been my complaint about this situation all along. The NSA has secretly created a database so enormous that itintuitively defies credibility. It's one thing to have unconnected databases spread out all over the globe, but to secretly compile everything into one location, and then have it accessed by the enormous number of agents required to maintain and utilizesuch a system - there's no doubt in my mind that abuses will definitely follow. Snowden is the first example. Who knows, maybe there have already been hundreds of abuses of this system by those privileged enough to have access. How would anyone know? In fact, I personally know someone who most likely has access to this database, who I would not trust to not go snooping aroundinto his ex-wife'saffairsfor obviously personal reasons.
Well please listen to his whole interview as he mentions how the first step will be to discredit him and he outlines how this will be done. They have already pretty much followed his description of how this would be handled to a "T". OF COURSE they will discredit him. He just made them look bad. Take the discrediting information provided by the entities he damaged with a weary eye.
There ARE things we can agree on Hal!
Scary, right?
I am not sure that I trust myself any longer, does that make me paranoid?
Kidding aside, Hal makes a great point on the sheer scope of this project, too much information in too many folks hands.
US Intelligence has become an oxymoron. Its failures; many.
Theres a book worth reading: The CIA and the Culture of Failure.
And now this country is being asked by it's less than trustworthy elected officials to trust an organization that spends trillions of dollars but cant even seem to hire the right people?
Ill pass.
Well, the obvious defense to such abuses is to mislead the competition by deliberately creating false leads. We should never have geared the communications environment towards such a clusterfuck to begin with. Now that the cat is out of the bag, what good is any intelligence going to be anyways? Those who are involved in nefarious communications will now concentrate their agendaon flooding the system withenough false informationto makechasing down valid communications that much more difficult.
You are both right. Only problem is, we ALL know the Gubment gonna keep it going with our tax dollars anyhow!