╌>

IRS Timeline: President Obama spent months in 2010 warning Americans about the 'threat' to democracy posed by conservative groups, right at the time the IRS began targeting these groups.

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  len  •  13 years ago  •  37 comments

IRS Timeline: President Obama spent months in 2010 warning Americans about the 'threat' to democracy posed by conservative groups, right at the time the IRS began targeting these groups.

WSJ POTOMAC WATCH June 6, 2013

By KIMBERLEY A. STRASSEL

Perhaps the only useful part of the inspector general's audit of the IRS was its timeline. We know that it was August 2010 when the IRS issued its first "Be On the Lookout" list, flagging applications containing key conservative words and issues. The criteria would expand in the months to come.

What else was happening in the summer and fall of 2010? The Obama administration and its allies continue to suggest the IRS was working in some political vacuum. What they'd rather everyone forget is that the IRS's first BOLO list coincided with their own attack against "shadowy" or "front" conservative groups that they claimed were rigging the electoral system.

Below is a more relevant timeline, a political one, which seeks to remind readers of the context in which the IRS targeting happened.

Barack Obama warns the country about conservative groups, Aug. 9, 2010.

Aug. 9, 2010: In Texas, President Obama for the first time publicly names a group he is obsessed withAmericans for Prosperity (founded by the Koch Brothers)and warns about conservative groups. Taking up a cry that had until then largely been confined to left-wing media and activists, he says: "Right now all around this country there are groups with harmless-sounding names like Americans for Prosperity, who are running millions of dollars of ads . . . And they don't have to say who exactly the Americans for Prosperity are. You don't know if it's a foreign-controlled corporation."

Aug. 11: The Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee sends out a fundraising email warning about "Karl Rove-inspired shadow groups."

Aug. 21: Mr. Obama devotes his weekly radio address to the threat of "attack ads run by shadowy groups with harmless-sounding names. We don't know who's behind these ads and we don't know who's paying for them. . . . You don't know if it's a foreign-controlled corporation. . . . The only people who don't want to disclose the truth are people with something to hide."

Week of Aug. 23: The New Yorker's Jane Mayer authors a hit piece on the Koch brothers, entitled "Covert Operations," in which she accuses them of funding "political front groups." The piece repeats the White House theme, with Ms. Mayer claiming the Kochs have created "slippery organizations with generic-sounding names" that have "made it difficult to ascertain the extent of their influence in Washington."

Aug. 27: White House economist Austan Goolsbee, in a background briefing with reporters, accuses Koch industries of being a pass-through entity that does "not pay corporate income tax." The Treasury inspector general investigates how it is that Mr. Goolsbee might have confidential tax information. The report has never been released.

This same week, the Democratic Party files a complaint with the IRS claiming the Americans for Prosperity Foundation is violating its tax-exempt status.

Sept. 2: The Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee warns on its website that the Kochs have "funneled their money into right-wing shadow groups."

Sept. 16: Mr. Obama, in Connecticut, repeats that a "foreign-controlled entity" might be funding "millions of dollars of attack ads." Four days later, in Philadelphia, he again says the problem is that "nobody knows" who is behind conservative groups.

Sept. 21: Sam Stein, in his Huffington Post article "Obama, Dems Try to Make Shadowy Conservative Groups a Problem for Conservatives," writes that a "senior administration official" had "urged a small gathering of reporters to start writing on what he deemed 'the most insidious power grab that we have seen in a very long time.' "

Sept. 22: In New York City, Mr. Obama warns that conservative groups "pose as non-for-profit, social welfare and trade groups," even though they are "guided by seasoned Republican political operatives" who might be funded by a "foreign-controlled corporation."

Sept. 26: On ABC's "This Week," Obama senior adviser David Axelrod declares outright that the "benign-sounding Americans for Prosperity, the American Crossroads Fund" are "front groups for foreign-controlled companies."

Sept. 28: The president, in Wisconsin, again warns about conservative organizations "posing as nonprofit groups." Sen. Max Baucus, chairman of the Senate Finance Committee, writes to the IRS demanding it investigate nonprofits. The letter names conservative organizations.

On Oct. 14, Mr. Obama calls these groups "a problem for democracy." On Oct. 22, he slams those who "hide behind these front groups." On Oct. 25, he upgrades them to a "threat to our democracy." On Oct. 26, he decries groups engaged in "unsupervised spending."

These were not off-the-cuff remarks. They were repeated by the White House and echoed by its allies in campaign events, emails, social media and TV ads. The president of the United States spent months warning the country that "shadowy," conservative "front" groups"posing" as tax-exempt entities and illegally controlled by "foreign" playerswere engaged in "unsupervised" spending that posed a "threat" to democracy. Yet we are to believe that a few rogue IRS employees just happened during that time to begin systematically targeting conservative groups? A mere coincidence that among the things the IRS demanded of these groups were "copies of any contracts with and training materials provided by Americans for Prosperity"?

This newspaper reported Thursday that Cincinnati IRS employees are now telling investigators that they took their orders from Washington. For anyone with a memory of 2010 politics, that was obvious from the start.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
luther28
Sophomore Silent
link   luther28    13 years ago

Must be a different time zone than mine.

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

each and every time, after backing a tyrant, the liberal progressive is always shocked when finally they too, are ordered into the railcar.

each, and every single time.

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

rice is promoted, hicks gets demoted

walking in a liberal ignorantland

 
 
 
Blue Wolf2
Freshman Silent
link   Blue Wolf2    13 years ago

Is that what you learned from Haldeman? Liddy? North?

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

Among the many left-wing groups with tax-exempt status are:

-- ACORN (now renamed as other organizations, but all still tax-exempt), "community organizers" who engage in profanity-laced protests at private homes, dump garbage in front of public buildings and disrupt bankers' dinners in order to get more people on welfare in order to destroy the capitalist system and incite revolution;

-- Occupy Wall Street, which -- in its first month alone -- was responsible for more than a dozen sexual assaults; at least half a dozen deaths by overdose, suicide or murder; and millions of dollars in property damage;

-- Media Matters for America, a media "watchdog" group that has never noticed one iota of pro-Obama bias in the media;

-- Moveon.org, which ran ads comparing Bush to Hitler under its 501(c)(4) arm;

-- The Center for American Progress, an auxiliary of the Democratic National Committee funded by George Soros and staffed by former Clinton and Obama aides to promote the Democratic agenda;

-- The Tides Foundation, which funnels money to communist and terrorist-supporting organizations;

-- The Ford Foundation, which has never found a criminal law that isn't "racist."

These groups are regarded by the IRS as nonpartisan community groups, merely educational, while dozens of patriotic, constitutional, Christian or tea party groups are still waiting for their tax exemptions.

That's to say nothing of Planned Parenthood, PBS and innumerable other Democratic front-groups that not only have tax exemptions, but get direct funding from the government.

By contrast, the conservative groups being raked over the coals by the IRS actually were nonpartisan. The tea party forced sitting Republican senators off the ticket in Alaska and Indiana, and toppled "establishment" Republicans in Utah, Delaware, Nevada, Florida and Texas. Far from being a secretly pro-Republican group, the tea party has been a nightmare for Republicans.

Show me one instance where the Center for American Progress was more of a problem for Democrats than Republicans.

It is obviously in the interest of the left to show us liberal groups also harassed by the IRS, so it's striking that they haven't been able to produce one yet.

Instead, they hearken back to the Bush years to claim that the IRS once audited the NAACP, which is treated as ipso facto political harassment.

First of all, the NAACP doesn't exactly have a sterling record of rectitude when it comes to organization funds. In the 1990s, the NAACP used tax-exempt contributions to pay hundreds of thousands of dollars of hush money to the mistress of then-executive director Benjamin F. Chavis Jr. -- as detailed in enraged columns by Carl Rowan at the time.

Find a tea party organization that's done that, and we'll understand the IRS conducting a three-year proctology exam on the group.

Second, the Bush-era audit of the NAACP was prompted by a blindingly partisan speech given by NAACP chairman Julian Bond at an organization meeting in Philadelphia in July 2004. Bond attacked a slew of elected Republicans by name, denouncing the entire party as one whose "idea of equal rights is the American flag and Confederate swastika flying side by side."

That's what we call "black-letter law" on improper activity for a tax-exempt organization. As a 501(c)(3) group, the NAACP is prohibited from supporting or opposing any candidate for elective office.

The NAACP responded to the IRS' letter by screaming from the rooftops that it was political payback. Consequently, Bush's IRS commissioner requested that Treasury's inspector general investigate the IRS' tax-exempt unit for political bias. The IG's report found no politics in the NAACP audit and -- to the contrary -- that more "pro-Republican" groups (18) than "pro-Democratic" groups (12) had been audited.

Nonetheless, the NAACP simply refused to cooperate with the IRS. There was nothing the Bush administration could do. No Republican was going to allow the NAACP's tax-exempt status to be revoked on its watch. Two years later, the IRS simply issued a letter clearing the group.

Today, the NAACP openly engages in partisan activity, such as a current weeks-long protest of Republican legislators in North Carolina.

...

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

Len here is some proof as to your accusations. I personally would like to get rid of them all, but some are so intertwine in corruption on both sides by passing money to other tax exempt organizations, the elite are taking us all for a ride. This will be long. I found many other sites but had to decide on just how much I wanted to put on here and believe me this is much more than enough.

Acorn

Many of ACORNs affiliates, allies, and old chapters remain active under different namesand at least two have received federal dollarsdespite the left-wing community-organizing groups official dissolution and ban on receiving federal funds, according to a new report.

Cause of Action, a nonprofit government watchdog group, recently identified 174 active or rebranded ACORN affiliates, as well as organizations that share former ACORN staff.

The groups shared the same physical location, leadership or staff, or tax ID number as old ACORN chapters, Cause of Action said.

At least two of the groups, Affordable Housing Centers of America (AHCOA) and Mutual Housing Association of New York (MHANY), have received federal dollars. According to MHANY, it receives funds from the Federal Home Loan Bank, the Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD), and Fannie Mae.

Its a serious concern because, as we stated in our letter to the IRS, it has been engaging in political activity, Cause of Action executive director Dan Epstein told the Free Beacon . We have concerns that these rebranded groups are using the same model that ACORN essentially trademarked: getting tax-exempt funds and using them for political purposes.

Matthew Vadum, an investigator for the Capital Research Center who has tracked ACORN, called the revolving door of staff among old ACORN affiliates and their political activities quite incestuous and corrupt.

Theyre really straddling the line with what nonprofits are allowed to do, Vadum said.

In some ways, Vadum said, the official collapse of ACORN was the best thing that could have happened to the organization. The former shell has now split into dozens of groups, making it much harder to track.

For some of these groups, all they did was legally change their name. Nothing else changed. The corporate structure, leadership and staff are the same, Karen Groen Olea, Cause of Actions chief counsel, told the Washington Examiner .

Cause of Action has sent several letters to the Internal Revenue Service requesting an investigation into the groups activities to determine if they have violated guidelines for tax-exempt organizations.

MHANY Management, Inc. shares the same IRS identification number as the erstwhile New York ACORN Housing Company, Inc. The name changed between the groups 2007 and 2008 tax filings.

MHANY partners with New York Communities for Change (NYCC), another renamed ACORN affiliate. HUD has approved it as a housing counselor.

The executive director of New York Communities for Change is former New York ACORN ofcial Jon Kest, brother of former ACORN national director Steve Kest. A 2011 Fox News report described NYCC employees shredding documents and removing any items related to ACORN after a previous report exposed the groups ties to both ACORN and the Occupy Wall Street protests.

New York Communities for Change received funds from the New York Foundation, Mertz Gilmore Foundation, Rockefeller Brothers Fund, Long Island Community Foundation, and the Edward W. Hazen Foundation.

The group has also received considerable funding from unions, including $500,000 from the United Federation of Teachers to campaign against charter schools.

According to its website , MHANYs mission is promoting, developing and managing affordable housing in New York. However, the group has partnered with certain large developers for projects that would seem at odds with its mission statement.

MHANY supported, and stood to profit, from the Atlantic Yards project in Brooklyn, which will replace a neighborhood of low-income brownstones with a $4.9 billion basketball stadium and residential complex.

Bruce Ratner, the former majority owner of the New Jersey Nets and one of the principal stakeholders in the project, provided $1.5 million in loans and grants to ACORN in 2008. The organization also positioned itself to make millions off of the new housing development.

Ismene Speliotis, then-executive director of ACORNs New York chapter, and now executive director of MHANY, told the New York Post that her organization expects to play a role in the marketing and lease-up.

This raises questions of cronyism, Cause of Actions Epstein said. Youve got a developing project launched through eminent domain and supported by groups that receive taxpayer funds. The taxpayers are suffering on multiple accounts here.

As previously reported, the ban on federal funding for ACORN has not stopped the flow of taxpayer dollars to many of the same organizers who previously led the scandal-ridden groups various chapters.

The Daily Caller reported in 2011 that AHCOA received more than $300,000 in federal funds. Shortly after, the Housing and Urban Development Department released a memo declaring AHCOA was not an ACORN affiliate, despite sharing the same Chicago address, phone number, and tax ID as a former ACORN entity, and was therefore eligible for federal funds.

Judicial Watch, another conservative government watchdog group, reported that an Illinois housing agency led by a former ACORN executive received almost $500 million in taxpayer funds.

Former ACORN president Bertha Lewis hinted ACORN was regrouping under different names in a 2011 interview .

We learned great lessons from our tribulations, and we decided that organizing by any other name is still organizing, Lewis said. The former chapters and their boards incorporated themselves, renamed themselves, and made sure that the reforms I had been putting in place around structure, financial management, and operations were carried on. Im happy to say that theyre very strong, and were in about 25 states. Glenn Beck and the conservative right actually helped us create 18 bulletproof community-organizing Frankensteins that theyre going to have a very hard time attacking.

ACORN spectacularly collapsed several years ago after its members engaged in electioneering, lobbying, and embezzlement, as well as allegations of voter fraud after a video sting by conservative agent provocateur James OKeefe. The group officially closed its doors in 2010 after Congress banned further federal funding in 2009.

MHANY did not return requests for comment.

New York Communities for Change did not return requests for comment.

Occupy Wall Street

The Irony of It All: Occupy Wall St. Is Tax Exempt

Although the Occupy Wall Street movement has made tax the rich a central cause, the group is not shy about taking a tax break of its own. Donations to the group, now totaling more than half a million dollars, are tax exempt, the New York Post reported.

The group Alliance for Global Justice is sponsoring the protests, which allows the movement to share in its tax-exempt status. As a result, those donating to the Occupy Wall Street movement can deduct the amount from their federal taxes.

The Alliance is a Washington-based group that advocates a variety of causes including hunger strikes in California prisons and protesting the CIA and oil companies. In return for sponsoring Occupy Wall Street, the Alliance is taking a 7 percent cut of donations, according to the New York Post.

Media Matters for America

Media Matters for America ( MMfA ) is a politically progressive [1] media watchdog group that says it is "dedicated to comprehensively monitoring, analyzing, and correcting conservative misinformation in the U.S. media". [2] Set up as a tax-exempt , nonprofit organization , MMfA was founded in 2004 by journalist and author David Brock . [3] Eric E. Burns served as MMfA's president until 2011. [4]

Moveon.org

Tax-exempt status should be granted equally

May 30, 2013

The Maui News

Save |

With due respect to a May 22 letter writer who questioned why Tea Party Maui deserved tax-exempt status, I would submit for comparative analysis the following statement from the MoveOn.org website (a socialist/liberal organization): "MoveOn.org Civic Action is a 501(c)4 organization which primarily focuses on nonpartisan education and advocacy on important national issues. MoveOn.org Political Action is a federal political committee which primarily helps members elect candidates who reflect our values through a variety of activities aimed at influencing the outcome of the next election. MoveOn.org Political Action and MoveOn.org Civic Action are separate organizations."

Tea Party Maui is a 501(c)4 organization that primarily focuses on nonpartisan education regarding the founding of our nation and about the beliefs and sacrifices its founders made for this country. Our primary mission is to attract, educate, organize and mobilize our fellow citizens to secure public policy consistent with our three core values: fiscal responsibility, constitutionally limited government and free markets.

We believe that by educating the public as to the founding principles of our country we will enlighten and enable people to choose freedom and liberty over security and serfdom. As a secondary mission, we will continue to advocate, as permitted by the Internal Revenue Service's 501(c)4 rules, for legislation and candidates that support these values.

So, it's OK for a socialist/progressive group to have 501(c)4 tax-exempt status but not a Tea Party/liberty group? Define hypocrite for me then.

Lee Aldridge

Haiku

The Center for American Progress

What a fantastic talent liberals possess, the ability to talk out of both sides of their mouths. One side utters platitudes about campaign finance reform and the nefarious influence of money in politics, while the other whispers in the ears of oligarchs and plutocrats. One side slanders Republicans as the tools of corporate interests, while the other solicits donations from some of the largest corporations in the world. The next journalist to examine influence peddling on K Street need only walk two blocks south, to H Street. There hell find one heck of a story.

H Street is the home of the Center for American Progress (CAP), founded by former Clinton chief of staff John Podesta in the fall of 2003. Originally conceived as a think tank to match the conservative Heritage Foundation and American Enterprise Institute, CAP quickly dropped the thinking and became, simply, a tank. Its objective was to overpower conservatives and Republicans, to devastate them with a fusillade of government activism, to pulverize their fortifications with ammunition loaded into the progressive echo chamber.

Good weapons dont come cheap. CAP requires considerable stimulus to acquire, track, and destroy its targets. Podestas fundraising methods, as one might expect from a Clintonite, were ingenious. He incorporated two entities: The Center for American Progress as a tax-deductible nonprofit 501(c)(3), and the Center for American Progress Action Fund as a tax-exempt 501(c)(4). Donations would not be disclosed, allowing contributors the protection of anonymity even as CAP called for transparency in political giving and government regulation of political speech.

The Tides Foundation

This article is just too long to put on here but if you want to check out the link I think you will get the idea of what is going on with The Tides Foundation, because it is one of the biggest scandals in tax exemptions in the country.

the Tides Center offers a sort of blanket tax-exempt designation for its grantees and projects. The entire foundation (pun intended) on which the Tides Center is built depends on the notion that the law allows one tax-exempt group to lend its exemption to another organization.

The Ford Foundation

Headquartered in New York City , the Ford Foundation is a tax-exempt 501(C)(3) organization and one of the largest foundations in the world with over $10 billion in assets. [1] The foundation was founded by the ultra-conservative automobile tycoon Henry Ford in 1936. Today it donates to thousands of organizations worldwide but has donated largely to leftist groups. They are truly a money hub for far-left, radical liberal groups.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

8th Time!

The Tea Party and any/all POLITICAL organizations are NOT ENTITLED TO TAX-EXEMPT STATUS UNDER IRS 501 (c)(4) PROVISIONS

501(c)(4) organizations are generally civic leagues and other corporations operated exclusively for the promotion of "social welfare" , such as civics and civics issues, or local associations of employees with membership limited to a designated company or people in a particular municipality or neighborhood, and with net earnings devoted exclusively to charitable, educational, or recreational purposes. An organization is operated exclusively for the promotion of social welfare if it is primarily engaged in promoting the common good and general welfare of the people of the community.

501(c)(4) organizations may inform the public on controversial subjects and attempt to influence legislation relevant to its program and, unlike 501(c)(3) organizations, they may also participate in political campaigns and elections, as long as its primary activity is the promotion of social welfare.

The tax exemption for 501(c)(4) organizations applies to most of their operations, but contributions may be subject to gift tax, and income spent on political activities - generally the advocacy of a particular candidate in an election - is taxable.

Contributions to 501(c)(4) organizations are usually not deductible as charitable contributions for U.S. federal income tax, with a few exceptions. 501(c)(4) organizations are not required to disclose their donors publicly.

The lack of disclosure has led to extensive use of the 501(c)(4) provisions for organizations that are actively involved in lobbying, and has become controversial. Criticized as "dark money," spending from these organizations on political TV ads has exceeded spending from Super PACs .

The origins of 501(c)(4) organizations date back to the Revenue Act of 1913 , which created a new group of tax-exempt organizations dedicated to social welfare in a precursor to what is now Internal Revenue Code Section 501(c)(4).

No government agency should selectively, arbitrarily or capriciously exercise its authority by so-called "targeting" of individuals/entities for any reason whatsoever.

But let's not close our biased, political eyes to the Tea Party, etc. which lives on the individual citizen-taxpayer's dime via evading paying taxes by deception!

In more direct terminology --

DON'T BE A FUCKING HOLIER-THAN-THOU RIGHT-WING HYPOCRITE!

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

If the umpire is a hack with no principles, I might get six strikes or more, or I might strike out on the first pitch.

And if Big Money has rigged the game against the "little guy," those among the "little guys" who cheer for the riggers are more blind than the umpires (who are, by the way, the paid pimps for Big Money).

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

The list comes from Point of View Ministries - Defending Faith, Freedom and Family

HOW FUCKING HYPOCRITICAL AND IRONIC IS THAT?

Organization Name: Point Of View Ministries Inc

Function, Activity: Protestant

Assets: $77,123

Income: $1,458,011

Mission Statement

501(c)3 Religious Organization
A Religious organization running political articles.
Well, let's see

Exemption requirements: 501(c)(3) organizations

To be tax-exempt under section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code, an organization must be organized and operated exclusively for exempt purposes set forth in section 501(c)(3), and none of its earnings may inure to any private shareholder or individual. In addition, it may not be an action organization , i.e., it may not attempt to influence legislation as a substantial part of its activities and it may not participate in any campaign activity for or against political candidates.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

iaranuocon.... Len probably figures it's a waste of time to answer your question as the IRS admits to the corruption with whistle blowers from the IRS saying the orders came from Washington. Everything in his article is fact, whether you want to accept that is a different matter. As for you first question...

should organizations which only create a facade of charity work in order to cover for their main effort to campaign politically for a party or candidate be given tax exempt status?

I personally say no. Now in saying that, let us not believe it only happens on one side of the isle. And also many of these tax exempt organizations on both sides are supported by one side or the other by big money, so to speak. The web they weave is really quite complex and allows for the corruption to exist in the background beyond our sight. So I say scrutiny on what they are doing to a greater extent than ever before. Or you could just get rid of them altogether. All the ones Len put up are correct as far as I could find. I found many more than I put up, but I worked hard enough for nothing. If you don't believe he is telling the truth, then do some work on your own.

Your second question...

If no, by what criteria would you decide which groups deserve some scrutiny in terms of whether or not they're gaming the system?

If they did the intense scrutiny required on each organization to know the truth, which can be hidden as described above this question would already be answered in my response above. It is not an easy task. Giving charity a narrow definition would be a start.

IRS Ends 2-Year Probe Of NAACP's Tax Status

Now there is no way anyone can deny they are not a political organization, but they are tax exempt anyway. Nothing has changed since this article.

...

Heritage Foundation tax exempt as well

There's no way anyone could say they are not a political organization.

So there you have two, one from each side that in my opinion don't qualify for 501 (C) (3) but both are.

Now for you last question...

If yes, by what criteria do you decide to which groups the laws apply?

It's a difficult objective for any administration to accomplish, but you have to consider at this time the facts. The IRS according to whistle blowers within the IRS have indicated the scrutiny came from Washington and Obama's timeline of events are facts. With all these facts hitting us in the face it is obvious the conservative religious and other organizations were targeted by Washington. The administrators could definitely be blamed. I don't expect Obama will suffer from this at all. He has managed not to manage anything since he has been president. Last week with all of the things that should have been on his plate he was here in Mooresville NC just up from Charlotte talking to a bunch of school kids telling them how he was going to put broadband in every school and said it was already budgeted for. The guidelines for choosing who gets tax exempt seems to be determined by who allows government employees to remain employed and we know which group is for smaller government.

I mean we only have...

48.7 million on food stamps which are advertised.

Nancy Pelosi during her two terms spent more money than all the other House Speakers in the past combined.

Social Security for the most part is taking in less than they are spending.

The National Debt is already $17 trillion and is up for another hike now.

The GDP was 2.4 last month when it needs to be at least 3.4.

The DI is projected to become insolvent by 2016.

Unemployment is down to approximately 7.6% and one of the biggest reasons is people getting out of the workforce not more jobs. You understand that? If not I'll explain if requested. When the Democrats took over Congress in 2007 it was 4.6%.

Not one Republican (I don't care for them either) bill has been passed since the Democrats took over Congress and the Presidency.

In summation to your questions.....the organizations that get preferred treatment is determined by those in power and as in many cases loopholes in the law make it difficult to know who qualifies for these exemptions, but in this case those in power are the government employees with a president who stands on their side, not the private citizen and has let it be known the attitude toward the American public is to control them thru governmental means which has spread among the government employees in their attitudes.

Let me refer you to one of Obama's and Hilliary's mentors statement.

Ones concern with the ethics of means and ends varies inversely with ones personal interest in the issue. P.26

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

No offense but all the organizations Len has listed including the NAACP are 501 (C) (3) or 501 (C) (4).

And not a one of those aren't involved in politics.

  • 501(c)(3) Religious, Educational, Charitable, Scientific, Literary, Testing for Public Safety, to Foster National or International Amateur Sports Competition, or Prevention of Cruelty to Children or Animals Organizations
  • 501(c)(4) Civic Leagues, Social Welfare Organizations, and Local Associations of Employees

DON'T BE A FUCKING HOLIER-THAN-THOU RIGHT-WING HYPOCRITE!

Not when you use these sites to try and prove your political points. There's no way A Mac you can say that with a straight face, especially when the whistle blowers within the IRS are blowing the whistle.

My idea would be a much more stringent means of qualifying for these exemptions in a fair manner, but as a retired attorney, you are aware that justice is often obstructed by laws and loopholes. And this goes for either party. Add it up..... video, IRS, phone tapping, emails and more right before an election. It is the most transparent administration in my lifetime.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

Do I believe some shouldn't have tax exempt status. Yes, but none on that list should have tax exempt status either.

I looked up each and every one of them and all are politically involved in politics.

The point is, if you're going to give them tax exempt status, then the ones targeted should receive the same status, because they were no more politically involved than that list.

And it doesn't matter where the list came from. Look them up yourself and you will find the list is true.

Just because it didn't list a bunch of conservative organizations by Media Matters doesn't make it not so.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Not when you use these sites to try and prove your political points.

My point is that the list in this article came from a religious organization steeped in right-wing politics.

I'd revoke the tax exempt status of any religious/charitable/special interest organization that involved itself in political activity -- I'd also make all elections public, that is, paid for by tax money; no corporate, union, religious, etc. money! NONE!

The NAACP was targeted in 2004 and not one holier-than-thou right-winger said shit about it.

IRS targeted NAACP in 2004



And the right-wing hypocrites in Congress destroyed ACORN but

Two years later, ACORN cleared of voter-fraud charges

Brian Lockhart, Staff Writer Published 11:33pm, Wednesday, February 2, 2011

Read more:
 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

I'd revoke the tax exempt status of any religious/charitable/special interest organization that involved itself in political activity -- I'd also make all elections public, that is, paid for by tax money; no corporate, union, religious, etc. money! NONE!

You have my vote. Now all we have to do is see if we have the politician's votes.

We know the answer to that, don't we?

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

Tough one. I think I've put enough on this to point out too many have tax exemptions that are no different and even less eligible than the conservative groups targeted.

 
 
 
Leotie
Freshman Silent
link   Leotie    13 years ago

As a 501(c)(3) group, the NAACP is prohibited from supporting or opposing any candidate for elective office.

They are constantly rambling on about which candidates we should vote for here in NC. In fact, the state NAACP man is a "preacher" here in my town. When they do their "Moral Monday" demonstrations in Raleigh, they have to call an ambulance to haul him away, he's too fat to be taken by police car.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Exempting religions/churches from tax liabilities borders on being unconstitutional in my opinion. Government subsidizing religion is pretty close to maintaining, albeit not establishing, religion. An inherent conflict of interests exists when members of Congress, who, could address this, are ultimately beholden to religious institutions to which they pander for monetary and voter support.

The First Amendment ( Amendment I ) to the United States Constitution prohibits the making of any law respecting an establishment of religion ,

501 (c)(3) language, like 501 (c) (4) also includes the word "exclusively" and by the letter of the law, organizations engaging in political activity disqualifies applicants for tax-exempt status. It's time it was enforced as written.

501(c)(3) exemptions apply to corporations, and any community chest , fund, cooperating association or foundation, organized and operated exclusively for religious , charitable , scientific , testing for public safety, literary , or educational purposes, to foster national or international amateur sports competition, to promote the arts, or for the prevention of cruelty to children or animals . There are also supporting organizations which are often referred to in shorthand form as "Friends of" organizations

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

The Latest Lie: IRS Targeted Conservatives

by davej Follow

Remember the video of the guy in the "pimp costume" who got advice from ACORN employees on how to run his prostitution ring? Turns out the whole story was just a lie, a doctored-video smear job on an important organization. The guy never wore a "pimp costume" and the real, undoctored videos showed that ACORN employees did nothing wrong. But a lie travels around the world before the corporate media bothers to check the facts. The "news" media blasted the story everywhere, and Congress was so outraged they forced ACORN to close its doors. And here we are again.

The corporate media is blasting out the story that the IRS "targeted conservative groups." Some in the media say there was "IRS harassment of conservative groups." Some of the media are going so far as claiming that conservative groups were "audited."

This story that is being repeated and treated as "true" is just not what happened at all. It is one more right-wing victimization fable, repeated endlessly until the public has no choice except to believe it.

Conservative Groups Were Not "Targeted," "Singled Out" Or Anything Else

You are hearing that conservative groups were "targeted." What you are not hearing is that progressive groups were also "targeted." So were groups that are not progressive or conservative.

All that happened here is that groups applying to the IRS for special tax status were checked to see if they were engaged in political activity. They were checked, not targeted. Only one-third of the groups checked were conservative groups.

Once again: Only one-third of the groups checked were conservative groups.

Conservative groups were not "singled out," were not "targeted" and in the end none were denied special tax status even though many obviously should have been.

From last week's House hearings on this:

Rep. Peter Roskam, R-IL: "How come only conservative groups got snagged?"

Outgoing acting IRS commissioner Steve Miller: "They didn't sir. Organizations of all walks and all persuasions were pulled in. Thats shown by the fact that only 70 of the 300 organizations were tea party organizations, of the ones that were looked at by TIGTA [Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration]."

Bet you didn't see that blasted all over your TV news that night.

Click here to watch the video clip of this . It's worth it.

And from Bloomberg reporting: IRS Sent Same Letter to Democrats That Fed Tea Party Row , (emphasis added, for emphasis)

One of those groups, Emerge America, saw its tax-exempt status denied, forcing it to disclose its donors and pay some taxes. None of the Republican groups have said their applications were rejected. Progress Texas ... faced the same lines of questioning as the Tea Party groups from the same IRS office that issued letters to the Republican-friendly applicants. A third group, Clean Elections Texas, which supports public funding of campaigns, also received IRS inquiries.


In a statement late yesterday, the tax agency said it had pooled together the politically active nonpartisan applicants -- including a minority that were identified because of their names. It is also important to understand that the group of centralized cases included organizations of all political views, the IRS said in its statement.

Again, for emphasis: " It is also important to understand that the group of centralized cases included organizations of all political views, the IRS said in its statement. "

But no matter, its conventional wisdom now that "the IRS targeted conservative groups." And it's very useful to the right if people believe this. But it just is not true. (If you want to see conventional wisdom at work watch this clip from the most recent Saturday Night Live .)

What Did Happen?

Here's the story. After the "Citizen's United" decision allowed unlimited corporate money into elections there was a flood of applications to get special tax status that allowed an organization to hide its donors from the public, and in some cases even be tax-exempt. But the rules say that political groups can't get this special tax status. The IRS has to check out applications for tax status to see if it is really a political group trying to sneak in to a special tax status.

Because they were flooded and couldn't check out every applying organization, the IRS group looked for things in the applications that "flagged" an organization as possibly a political group. These flagged applications were then passed along to specialists to look deeper and determine if they were legit or not.

So What Was The "Wrongdoing"?

The Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration (TIGTA) has issued a full report: Inappropriate Criteria Were Used to Identify Tax-Exempt Applications for Review that looked into the accusation that the IRS "targeted" tea party groups that were applying for special tax status for extra scrutiny. The report is not all that long. You should read it. (Apparently most the people you are hearing from in the media haven't read it.)

According to the report, the swamped IRS group involved in this came up with ways "criteria" to identify groups that really needed to be checked further because it was possible they might be engaged in the kind of political activity that would exclude them from getting the special tax status. (The rules for what constitutes political activity that would keep a group for getting special tax status are, to say the least, not clear. See the P.S. below.) Some groups were chosen to receive the required scrutiny because they had "political-sounding" names. Some of the "political-sounding names" included the words "tea party." Others included "We the People" and "Take Back the Country." (The inspector general's report does not disclose if or which other "political sounding names" were also used as criteria.)

And the other problem was that the scrutiny these groups received involved some "unnecessary, burdensome questions."

That was the extent of the wrongdoing. At a time when they couldn't give all applying groups the necessary scrutiny they used criteria that included the names of an applying group to decide if it would get the required scrutiny. And they asked "unnecessary, burdensome questions." That's it. That's the whole thing.

Normally all groups applying for special tax status would and should all get looked at to see if they were really political groups. In this case no groups received any extra scrutiny as has been accused, instead many received less than usual. No group was "singled out" or "targeted" for extra scrutiny, instead they were not given the free pass others were getting because of the overload of applicants.

The IG report concluded that it was wrong to use a group's name as a criteria to help determine if an applicant would be checked out at a time when there were so many applications that every group was not being checked out. (However, the IG report did say that most of the groups forwarded with this criteria in fact should have been forwarded.)

Again, that's the wrongdoing that has triggered the absolute frenzy of outrage you are hearing from ... everyone. They said it was silly to use a group's name as criteria for deciding if they should be checked out thoroughly at a time when the IRS was too busy to thoroughly check all applications as they usually do. And they said groups filing for a special tax status but suspected of political activity were then asked "unnecessary, burdensome questions."

And again, that's it, That's the whole "scandal." That's the whole "IRS harassing conservative groups." That's the whole "Obama the dictatorial tyrant going after his enemies" hissy-fit. (Pleasee read Digby's The Art of the Hissy-Fit )

A Few Facts

Fact: The IRS is required to determine whether organizations applying for special tax status are "social welfare" groups or are instead engaged in political activity. Political groups cannot get the special tax status these groups were applying for.

Fact: Only one-third of the groups that were passed to specialists for a closer look were "conservative." Lots of other organizations were also checked, including progressive organizations.

Fact: No groups were audited or harassed or "targeted" or "singled out." This was about applications for special tax status being forwarded to specialists for a closer look to see if they were engaged in political activity that would disqualify them for the special tax status. This closer look is the kind of review all organization should get, but the IRS was swamped because of the flood of groups applying for a status that let them mask their donors, after Citizens United.

Fact: No groups were harmed. There were delays while the groups were checked to see if they should have special tax status. That's it. But the rules are that they are allowed to operate as if they had that status while they waited for official approval.

Fact: The only groups actually denied special tax status were progressive groups, not conservative groups. In 2011, during the period that "conservative groups were targeted" the New York Times carried the story, 3 Groups Denied Break by I.R.S. Are Named . The three groups? Drum roll ... "The I.R.S. denied tax exemption to the groups Emerge Nevada, Emerge Maine and Emerge Massachusetts because, the agency wrote in denial letters, they were set up specifically to cultivate Democratic candidates."

Fact: The IRS commissioner in charge at the IRS at the time this happened was appointed President George W. Bush.

Fact: According to the inspector general's report (p. 10) in the "majority of cases, we agreed that the applications submitted included indications of significant political campaign intervention."

Other scandals?

The stage for this story to take off at this time was set by other "scandals" in the news. The scandal frenzy began when ABC News' Jonathan Karl falsely reported that White House emails had "taken out" "all references to al Queda and all references to CIA warnings before the attack about the terror threat in Benghazi." He said that these emails "show that many of these changes were directed by Hillary Clinton's spokesperson ..."

Click here to see the video of this report.

But a couple of days later CNN broke the news that the emails Karl used for his ABC report were edited by Republicans to make it appear they said these things. Parts of the edited emails Karl used were "inaccurate" and "invented" to make the administration and State Department look bad. (The word "fabricated" comes to mind.)

Next came a story that the Justice Department had looked at records of AP reporters to see who in the administration had leaked a story. The story was that an informer high up in al Queda in Yemen had delivered a new kind of bomb to target airliners, while the government was still analyzing how to detect it and the informer was still in Yemen. The Justice Department looked at call records phone numbers only to see if they could spot who had called AP. This became a "scandal" with accusations that the government was "wiretapping" reporters and "secretly monitoring" or "listening in" on their calls with the "scandal" gaining traction with its conjunction with the "Benghazi scandal" story promoted by ABC.

Driving Right-Wing Themes Out To Wider Audiences

It is worth noting that Jonathan Karl is a graduate of a conservative-movement "media training" program, the Collegiate Network . The significance of this is explained by Fairness and Accuracy In Reporting (FAIR), in A Right-Wing Mole at ABC News: Jonathan Karl and the success of the conservative media movement ,

Conservatives dont just complain loudly, endlessly and inaccurately about liberal media bias. They also train right-leaning journalists to make their way into the supposedly hostile terrain of Beltway media. And one of the most famous alums of a conservative media training program is now a major star at a network news outlet: ABCs senior political correspondent Jonathan Karl.


Karl came to mainstream journalism via the Collegiate Network, an organization primarily devoted to promoting and supporting right-leaning newspapers on college campuses - such as the Rutgers paper launched by the infamous James OKeefe. The network, founded in 1979, is one of several projects of the Intercollegiate Studies Institute, which seeks to strengthen conservative ideology on college campuses. William F. Buckley was the ISIs first president, and the current board chair is American Spectator publisher Alfred Regnery. Several leading right-wing pundits came out of Collegiate-affiliated papers, including Ann Coulter, Dinesh D'Souza, Michelle Malkin, Rich Lowry and Laura Ingraham.

ABC's Jonathan Karl is also one of the reporters driving the "IRS scandal" story to a wider audience, with on-air reports like " Document Draft Shows IRS Targeted Conservative Groups ," " IRS IG Report: Targeting Conservatives Began In 2010 ," " IRS Scandal Spreads Wider Than Cincinnati Officers " and more such stories , usually with inflammatory headlines and sensationalist scandal-hyping story lines.

The Daou Triangle

In 2005 Peter Daou wrote a widely-discussed paper describing how the right's media machine works to drive false stories and smears out to wide audiences. In THE TRIANGLE: Limits of Blog Power Daou described how "a triangle of blogs, media, and the political establishment" worked together to "generate the critical mass necessary to alter or create conventional wisdom." "...it's still the Russerts and Broders and Gergens and Finemans, the WSJ, WaPo and NYT editorial pages, the cable nets, Stewart and Letterman and Leno, and senior elected officials, who play a pivotal role in shaping peoples political views."

Describing a triangle of "netroots + media + party establishment = CW," (netroots = "the base" and CW means "conventional wisdom"), Daou explained how they work together,

"...a well-developed echo chamber and superior top-down discipline, the right has a much easier time forming the triangle. Fox News, talk radio, Drudge, a well-trained and highly visible punditocracy, and a lily-livered press corps takes care of the media side of the triangle. Iron-clad party loyalty with rare exceptions and a willingness of Republican officials to jump on the Limbaugh-Hannity bandwagon du jour takes care of the party establishment side of the triangle. "

The Daou triangle described how Republican politicians work in concert with the echo chamber to turn false stories into "conventional wisdom." One the progressive-aligned side? Not so much. Daou again,

Whereas rightwing bloggers can rely on their leadership and the rightwing noise machine to build the triangle, left-leaning bloggers face the challenge of a mass media consumed by the shop-worn narrative of Bush the popular, plain-spoken leader, and a Democratic Party incapacitated (for the most part) by the focus-grouped fear of turning off "swing voters" by attacking Bush. For the progressive netroots, the past half-decade has been a Sisyphean loop of scandal after scandal melting away as the media and party establishment remain disengaged.

Six years later Doau wrote an update, How the Democratic establishment shunned the left, spawned the Tea Party and moved America right . From Daou's follow-up piece,

attribution: None Specified
At the root of the problem is this: the GOP benefits from a superior communications mechanism with which to shape and reshape conventional wisdom. Faced with a public that holds opposing views, politicians can either change their positions to match the publics views or change the publics views to match their positions Republicans almost always choose the latter, bolstered by a highly sophisticated framing and messaging infrastructure crafted and funded over decades.


... On the other side you have the Democratic establishment, political leaders, pollsters and strategists who, by and large, are poll addicts, chronically incapable of taking principled stands, obsessed with appealing to independent voters, hostile to progressive advocates, often just as captive to moneyed interests as their Republican counterparts. ...


[. . .] So the brashest, loudest, most confident-sounding voices end up filling the knowledge void, voices that sound authoritative and principled. Rush Limbaugh, for instance. Or Sarah Palin. Sean Hannity. Ann Coulter. Bill OReilly.


Echoing these blaring voices of authority are Republican politicians and the rights online denizens. Conservative pundits and columnists then lend it all an air of seriousness. And the media, desperately seeking to appear fair, give an uncritical national platform to those voices. Not to mention Fox News, which pipes a steady stream of propaganda into millions of American homes. The triangle of establishment, media, and Internet comes together on the right and conventional wisdom is created. Pollsters then dutifully register that shift in sentiment and the media regurgitate it. A virtuous loop for the right.


Theres simply nothing comparable on the Democratic side.


If anything, in the debt debate, President Obama and leading Democrats were part of the Republican triangle, reinforcing GOP talking points and running roughshod over a country that didnt even agree with the conservative position.

But The President "Admitted It"

Daou's last point is key. While Republican politicians work with the conservative movement's propaganda outlets, often Democratic politicians also echo Republican messages. In the case of the "IRS scandal" the President did just that, saying that what happened was "intolerable" and firing the acting IRS commissioner. This validated and propelled the false message that the IRS had "targeted" conservative outlets for "harassment" instead of refuting the accusations with facts. And this admission served to validate by proxy the other false right-wing scandal accusations about Benghazi and "wiretapping reporters."

This is not the first time the Obama administration was taken in by false stories originating at right-wing propaganda outlets before the real facts were known. Van Jones had to leave the Obama administration after Glenn Beck accused him of being a "communist" and other right-wing sites accused him of being a "9/11 Truther." Shirley Sherrod was fired from the Department of Agriculture after Breitbart (the same person who posted the doctored ACORN videos) posted doctored video that made it appear she had made racist remarks -- even though the full video later showed the opposite to be true.

The great Brad Blog tells these stories, in IRS 'Scandal' Appears Nearly as Phony as Shirley Sherrod, Van Jones, ACORN 'Scandals' ,

... if you listened only to the corporate media, you --- like the Obama Administration --- also probably thought that the phony, trumped-up "scandals" that led to the inappropriate firing of USDA official Shirley Sherrod, the cowardly firing of White House green jobs adviser Van Jones and the outrageous federal defunding of ACORN were also the unhappy result of an endemic culture of corruption by the Obama Administration, the Democratic Party and its insidious political apparatchiks.


Those fake scandals, however, all three of them, were shams. They were eventually identified as such, though only after a great deal of harm to Sherrod, Jones and ACORN had already been done by the Democrats who fell for them and acted out of knee-jerk and cowardly fear to try and contain the perception of "scandal" which was, naturally, helped along by the very loud misreporting of "the nightly news".

A Teachable Moment

This is a teachable moment -- to us -- to recognize how the right's machine operates, to see how the corporate media and Washington Democrats react, and to learn not to get taken in by it. This is what they do. We shouldn't fall for it -- again and again. Remember, it was Washington Democrats who were taken in by right-wing smear operations, responding by defunding ACORN and censuring MoveOn.

These "scandals" are intended to distract us from the important stories that are unfolding around us, and obstruct the Obama administration from being able to accomplish anything more. For example, one unfolding story is how Senate Republicans are obstructing all attempts to get the government functioning and the economy recovering. By obstructing the National Labor Relations Board and Labor Department nominations, they are preventing the government from being able to enforce laws and rules that enable people to organize and bargain for better wages and benefits. By filibustering laws like last year's Bring Jobs Home Act and The American Jobs Act, they are keeping us from growing the economy and rebuilding our infrastructure, and from preventing the offshoring of jobs. By using hostage-taking tactics with the debt ceiling they are forcing cuts in programs that help people and grow the economy.

This is where our attention should be focused.

PS - A Note About The Law vs. The Rules For Groups Applying For Special Tax Status

While researching this post I came across something interesting about the kind of special-tax-status organization that is allowed to do political work while masking its donors. This is called a 501(c)(4) organization, often just called a "C4." According to the IRS ,

The statute : IRC 501(c)(4) provides, in part, for the exemption from federal income taxation of civic leagues or organizations not organized for profit but operated exclusively for the promotion of social welfare.

The IRS regulation , or "interpretation" of the law: Section 1.501(c)(4)-1(a)(2)(i) of the Income Tax Regulations states that an organization will be considered to be operated exclusively for social welfare purposes if it is primarily engaged in promoting in some way the common good and general welfare of the people of the community, i.e. primarily for the purpose of bringing about civic betterments and social improvements.

Note the shift from "exclusively" to "primarily." These words have VERY different meanings. While the law says these "social welfare" organizations cannot engage in what is called political intervention, the IRS "interprets" this to mean that up to 49 percent of their activity can.

Recently the New York Times explained some of the ambiguity this difference creates, in Uneven I.R.S. Scrutiny Seen in Political Spending by Big Tax-Exempt Groups ,

The tax code states that 501(c)(4)s must operate exclusively to promote social welfare, a category that excludes political spending. Some court decisions have interpreted that language to mean that a minimal amount of political spending would be permissible. But the I.R.S. has for years maintained that groups meet that rule as long as they are not primarily engaged in election work, a substantially different threshold.


Nowhere do the rules specify what primarily engaged means, though there are indications that the agency has begun to re-examine the question. In March, the I.R.S. began sending out questionnaires to roughly 1,300 tax-exempt organizations, including some 501(c)(4)s, regarding their political lobbying and other activities. The agency has said it is merely seeking a clearer picture of how tax-exempt groups operate to ensure better compliance.

So all of those smear ads you see at election time, and no one knows who is paying for them? THAT is the difference between the law and this "interpretation" of the law. This "interpretation" of a law that requires groups with special tax status to operate "exclusively" for the social welfare is used to mask the corporate and billionaire donors and enable the smear ads that are destroying our civility and democracy.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

That's an awful lot of shit to not read.

It's actually pearls cast before swine (who think everything is shit).

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

I'm just pointing out that it is more convenient to not read a one line link to a multi-page article from Daily Kos than not reading what you post in entirety.

Actually, it's more convenient yet for me not post any information at all. In this particular posting, there are counter-points to a number of oft-made claims -- not the usual list of allegations that fall under scrutiny.

It's the readers choice to read, not read, consider that the article presents both sides of an argument, dismiss off-hand or completely ignore.

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

i understand china's leader was just congradulating obama on his control of the press, as well as his ability to direct federal officers to profile citizens and terrifying them into submission....all without actually giving a direct order!

yup, the reds in china could learn a bit from our dear leader.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Let me put it this way. Nobody reads those full page copy/pastes. It's not the first time that people have pointed that out to you. If it is not your own thoughts or ideas, then post a link as a supplement.

Nobody needs to read full page copy/pastes in the same way no one needs to go into a library, etc., and avail himself extensively on any given subject.

Anyone can skim what is posted or pass it by. My own thoughts on a subject invariably precede anything I copy and past to validate and/or explain why I express the thoughts I do.

Typically, those who have pointed out what you have, are invariably those who disagree with my positions -- and rather than disagree with them on a point-counter-point basis, they instead criticize the volume of supportive information I provide.

Debate the information if you wish but don't disingenuously criticize the amount of relevant information backing a position.

"Objection Your Honor! Counselor has presented a significant volume of exculpatory (or compelling) information and I can't necessarily refute any of it."

That's how I see the argument against copying/pasting and/or the personal/original presentations of germane information.

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

who cares, obama was re-elected.

just because he called the groups enemies, and a danger to democracy and attacked them consistently, its not like anyone could have taken that as an order to profile them.

even liberal senators, sending letters ordering treasury to profile them, should be completely ignored.

yup, the liberal is allowed to do whatever they want, cummings said the case is closed.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

people who post entire pages of c/p are in effect spamming and derailing.

I don't believe I've ever seen you object to seeded articles that are in effect, entire articles copied and pasted verbatim.

I could post The Dictionary because I THINK it is vitally important to the continuance of life on earth, and crucial to the discussion.

You could, but unlike when I post, no one would understand your rational or your rationality.

But if I just post a link, with a couple of definitions as an example, people who are interested could take advantage of my valuable information by proceeding to the link.

I agree -- or -- they could read what you copied and pasted from the link -- or they could just read what they wanted to read -- or, they could just pass it by.

"The Complete Works of Leo Tolstoy" i.e. would undoubtedly contain a multitude of issues -- when I post an extensive piece of information, it is limited to where the thread has taken (usually) just a single issue.

Big difference,

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

War and Peace (like everyone else), some short stories, Anna Karenina.

Going forward, I will consider posting just links or, links with just a sentence or three.

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

brilliantly executed

the left must be so very proud

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

the left must be so very proud

We are

You're on the right.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Hey,

How come you didn't update us, Len?

(CNN) A conservative Republican manager of Cincinnati-based IRS screeners told congressional investigators there was no evidence the White House was involved in the agencys targeting of conservative groups, according to the Democratic leader of a committee probing the scandal.

This refutes claims by some Republicans that the groups were targeted at the direction of political operatives working to get President Barack Obama re-elected, said Rep. Elijah Cummings, D-Maryland, on CNN's "State of the Union" on Sunday.

He is a conservative Republican working for the IRS. I think this interview and these statements go a long way to showing that the White House was not involved in this, he said.

And

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago
 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

It isn't only about what Obama knew, or about his direct involvement. None of these issues is only about what Obama knew or about his direct involvement. It is first about the fact that they are taking place.

Not any more it's not; that's the bullshit Issa tried to make it but it has been debunked.

Further, the IRS wasn't "targeting the Tea Party" -- Tea Party entities were applying for 501 (c)(4) status by identifying itself as "TP Patriots" which generated the usual IRS investigation in terms of verifying legitimate qualifications.

Further, Issa so far has refused to release all of the transcripts from his "investigation" likely because they'll show he cherry picked comments that appeared to incriminate the White House.

Out of respect for your request that I do not copy and paste extensive amounts of text, Robert, I offer

...

And

Darrell Issa Wont Release IRS Transcripts Because They Prove Him Wrong

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

So, why did the admit it and apologize?

A fair question; being contrite for fear of being the victim of a political with hunt?

Transcripts of what? He was accused of cherry picking Benghazi information, but it was the White House who refused to release the information, only letting some members of Congress look at and take notes.

Transcript of his investigation of an alleged IRS/White House scandal. Benghazi information was clarified subsequently by CIA e-mails

May 15th, 2013
08:45 PM ET

First on CNN: White House releases 100 pages of Benghazi e-mails

Regarding

What if you were a tasked with oversight, as a member of Congress? Would your primary concern be that nothing touches the White House?

Issa has a long history of abusing such power

Darrell Issa and House Republicans' Permanent Witch Hunt

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

An adversarial position.

But not adversarial for the sake of being adversarial with a political, rather than a "what's-good-for-the-coutry" objective.

It's one thing to investigate or take a contrary position if it's objective, but to proceed with a "gotcha" agenda and apply it to virtually every "investigation," -- no!

Obama seems to be led. He does not lead. His minions push him around. That needs to be shown.

I am much in agreement; never liked Emanuel and other of Obama's advisors/strategists and from early on, I have felt Obama is too much interested in compromise, that is, compromise to promote an ideal and, at the expense of pushing for legislation that is utilitarian.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

adversarial - involving or characterized by conflict or opposition

I have no problem with opposition if it's honest and a matter of objective principal, but conflict (an incompatibility between two or more opinions, principles, or interests) -- particularly a contrived, perennial, incompatibility for the sake of power-brokering, is not in the interest of Americans in general.

And politicians, lying, self-serving fucks that they are, campaign on representing "what's good for America" and pander to a significant number of dumb ass electorate-shits who vote their one-issue-cut-off-their-nose-to-spite-their-faces agendas!

I'm not naive, neither am I willing to just accept that stupidity shall forever rule-the-day.

So I rant like you do, Robert, but from the other side of the street.

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

remember obama's false outrage? when he demanded an investigation! and fired that employee?

well, he made a big show over nothing, cummings said: case closed.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

So Republicans bitched for expressions of outrage, Boehner asks, "who's going to jail," and all before any proof of wrong-doing was established; now it turns out that there was no wrong-doing so, Republicans bitch about unwarranted outrage.

Did I get that about right?

 
 
 
Jimster
Freshman Silent
link   Jimster    13 years ago
If money is free speech, then explain the illegality of prostitution.The only thing in that case that makes it illegal, in the eyes of the law, is the money. Otherwise it's just two people screwing.Lemme know when a hooker wins a soliciting charge on First Amendment grounds.
 
 
 
ce smith
Freshman Silent
link   ce smith    13 years ago

To answer your question, the IRS allows tax exemption forMANY political non-profits. One-liners frompundits aren't going to makeanyone lookpoliticallysavvy, so verify it yourself. This isONE of the IRS links below ifbloggerswant to know the truth andbe less invested inpride and party allegiance.

The operative term here is faade, and this requires a presumption of guilt if you adopt this language. My America doesn't snoop on ideological opponents, unless they care to join the likes of Nixon. (To my horror, I discovered our president and administration actually used the scare tactic of foreign interests when depicting the Tea Party, like America isn't comprised of foreigners?) That was the last tacky divisional straw for me. Gray Davis let me down, and the rest of the party is swirling behind him. I trust nobody in politics at this point, particularlythose who attempt to raise legal doubt over what bloggers feel isIRS permissible, versus what isexempted. Poor and blank...reminds me of Martin Niemller's poem. Victims in waiting. No thanks, I prefer, Now you know, and knowing is half the battle.

Last time I checked, this wasn't Mao's China.(Anyone read Chen Village?)

When I heard testimony that the overwhelming applicants delayed or harassed by the IRS (andcompletely unconnected agencies like ATF) were associates of this TP political group, the stink had a link. American citizens (including paranoid, manipulative, deceptive creeps)are entitled to enumerated freedoms thanks to our founding fathers. No public policy should engage in acommie-come-lately mentality that feels it can label, delay, or otherwise thwart a group of contrary ideologists unless they are convicted and/or pose an eminent danger to the larger populous. Tea Party hardly constitutes al Qaeda in my book. Give me a break - I researched these people and saw numerous videos and news reports depicting angry, not violent, protests byTP advocates.

While I may not subscribe to any over-arching party platforms of the Tea Party, people screened by a "neutral, independent, non-governmentagency" such as the IRS in this manner have every right to be outraged. If Bobby Kennedy couldn't reach beyond reasonable to get the mob, why is our leadership so hell-bent on this group? If they can't draw clear connections to improper activities within a framework that respects our constitutional rights, tough. You don't get to go rouge on your hunches; that's tyranny.

You are beyond ill-informed and blatantly in denial if you think that withholding status from these groups for 3 years plus "per Washington's directive" was a reasonable way to "scrutinize suspect applicants" who were never convicted of criminal activity but criminalized publicly nonetheless by political opponents who illegally used their power to coerce others and oppress so many of their due process. Theattorney generalreported gross abuses. Abuse was already admitted by some officials , but the directive, they said, came from Washington and wasn't thebrainchild of the accused IRS branches in Cincinnati.

Informed people don't need to resort to infantile demeaning because the content of atimeline might framepast political choices unfavorably. Follow a logical path to sources that will (in)validate the information one way or the other independently. Find out whowas involved, so we can give them their day in court.

 
 

Who is online





RU4Real


86 visitors