(The other shoe drops) - PRISM scandal: tech giants flatly deny allowing NSA direct access to servers
Two different versions of the PRISM scandal were emerging on Thursday with Silicon Valley executives denying all knowledge of the top secret program that gives the National Security Agency direct access to the internet giants' servers.
The eavesdropping program is detailed in the form of PowerPoint slides in a leaked NSA document, seen and authenticated by the Guardian, which states that it is based on "legally-compelled collection" but operates with the "assistance of communications providers in the US."
Each of the 41 slides in the document displays prominently the corporate logos of the tech companies claimed to be taking part in PRISM. - http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2013/jun/07/prism-tech-giants-shock-nsa-data-mining
Let's take this by the numbers shall we?
1 - Incident #1 involved the NSA in their supposed legally sanctioned attempt to spy on Americans through their phone calls.
2 - This incident, #2, involves PRISM and the internet .- " Reports based on leaked documents state that the PRISM program is described as enabling in-depth surveillance on live communications and stored information. It provides for the targeting of any customers of participating corporations who live outside the United States, or American citizens whose communications include people outside the USA. Data that the NSA is able to obtain under PRISM allegedly includes email, video and voice chat, videos, photos, voice over IP conversations, file transfers, login notifications and social networking details. "
To get this kind of information, the government needs to get direct access to the IP servers. By law, that requires " court order " which there was none.
The IP companies are now screaming they DID NOT give the government access nor did they allow it access through some secret back door.
These are things which start revolutions.

"These are things which start revolutions."
I am afraid you're right about that.
Saw this latest last night on the news, blew me away, I can't believe it.
This is one of those moments were the answer has to be, none of the above. Lying liars and the lies they tell.
They speak of the American Dream, I am beginning to believe that the dream has become truth.
Aeon, you're on top of this, great going.
Fact is that I suspect both the government and the companies are lying their ass off. They are in survival mode now, and we should all carefully watch the spin that is going to happen. It's all "for the children" (or some other such assertion, which Feinstein already began yesterday), it's not "what you think", go after the leakers, try to divert attention.
Even the NYT is realizing what this Country, what its voters, have put in place. Though, to the end, it tries, as much as it can with SOME semblance of moral authority, to shunt the blame away from Obama!
So, let me get this straight, it's really the CRAFTERS of the Patriot Act who are really at fault! Obama is just, well, he's not "Credible" but he's really not the guy that provided the means to do what he's doing!
Amazing, isn't it? Kind of like trying to blame the inventor of steel, for all the deaths caused by knives, or Nobel, for all the deaths caused in war, or by guns!
They STILL don't get it. No matter what tools are at hand, it's not the fault of the TOOLS when they are used improperly!It is not the fault of the TOOL MAKER. It is the fault of the person who elects to wield the tool in an improper/illegal way.
The rot has gone so deep, that even that portion of the main stream press that TRIES to cause itself to be the least bit honest, it just really can't do it.
One last note, proving the above. The NYT op/ed does NOT call for action against Obama, or, indeed, any governmental agency or person. Instead, it weakly calls for the Patriot Act to be "repealed."
The NYT, like so many others here, on this site, is merely shaking its shackles so it can pretend that it is still free.
Unfortunately, it just keeps coming. The EFF (Electronic Frontier Foundation) was working with The Guardian and have amassed so much evidence ( which they are posting now ) it has dramatically slowed down their servers. Among the items is a 57 page court document, which I downloaded, (just in case it disappears) naming names and companies involved.
Damn, this is is turning out to be a historic event.
Remember Erik Kain from NV (don't know if he's still there as I don't go there.) We remained friends on FB. Here is a great article he just wrote for Forbes. I posted it in a separate discussion as well.
Nice shackle shaking. We understand you are used to them, enjoy them, but that doesn't mean the rest of us have to.
Some people, a few, kind of like freedom.
wonder how the paid liar will be spinning this
liberal socialist solution: more laws, more taxes.
My money is on an intentional "leak" to gain political footing. It just doesn't make sense, that something everyone knew about, due to whistleblowers over years of Patriot Act implementation, is all of a sudden a scandal. Three NSA 'Staffers' and and a House Intelligence Committee 'staffer' have resigned due to what they perceived as questionable implementation of the Patriot Act/FISA legislation. One of which was charged under the Espionage Act of 1917, charges were dropped and the defendant pled to a misdemeanor. But the current administration was trying to crackdown on leakers. This all just seems part of a political offensive to be continued as needed.
But why now all of a sudden? If this was tied into the GOP wouldn't they be get more advantage out of serving this up come say August of 2014?
Tell me your thinking?
Nah, unless it is coming from the democrats themselves, which may be a possibility. They may want to be SURE this crap doesn't hit the fan in 14.
Fly is right, IF this was a pub action, it would have occurred in mid '14, not now.
I am of the belief, however, that people, right or left, are genuinely shocked at what they have discovered, especially given this president's prior statements, and wish for it to be stopped.
nothing to worry about, obama said moving further would require a judges signature.
whew, i sure feel better.
teaching moment: for the low information voter, the above is a reference to with-holders going judge shopping, until he found one liberal enough to approve a document accusing a journalist of being a possible violator of the espionage act.
Maybe their crack politicos didn't figure out how to do it till now, without getting burned themselves. Maybe the time is right. It's all about perception, slight of hand images. After all both admins/parties have used the shit out of this program to make us all "safer".
They most likely have a playbook. So what's the next play? After the faux constitutional outrage subsides. Because realization that the the man is up your ass, precedes the last two administrations. They have used the internet/phone secretly for as long as they have been around.
too bad there were no grass roots organizations who could have warned of an over-reaching out of control centralized govt.
wmolaw.
I'm sure people are shocked and want this thing stopped. Now that it is out of the bag, maybe it should be since its usefulness as an intelligence tool has greatly been compromised.
I know... at face value without knowing and absorbing all of the technical/legal details this sucker looks like a violation of privacy. But to be honest, if it were to help prevent something like what happened at the Boston Marathon from happening again, they can have all the electronic records from me that they want. A small price to pay to try and save lives in my opinion.
Well at least none that could find their ass with both hands and a bloodhound.
does this mean when the liberal socialists create another "movement" using union funds like ows, that we can expect to see homeland security vehicles parked near their demonstration areas too?
didnt think so
But still way too early for this stuff. The GOP doesn't even really have a lineup of who is going to be running where in the mid-terms at this point. And to make use a popular term.... The GOP doesn't take a dump without a plan. (good/bad or otherwise)
If that's the case, then maybe this is cover for something else. Something that is working well for NSA. What would be gained by making Prism a disinformation play?
I was four square against the Patriot Act when it was first introduced, and passed. Why? Because of its breadth COUPLED with the fact that it was not limited to foreign terrorists, or those working with foreign terrorists. Such a simple fix.
But it was "flexibility" that won the day, and the Patriot Act has, since then, been used for all sorts of bullshit!
To this day, all one would have to do is amend it so that it, and the evidence secured by it, could not be used for ANY purpose against ANY citizen, BUT FOR the charging and conviction of an act of terrorism (and I don't mean that bullshit definition, I mean four square terrorism.).
But the government, the politicians, the cops, will not do that because it would reduce their power!
For sure it could be the ole false flag, because of a history of coming down on leakers.
Unless they missed it or miscalculated.
Yes the issue is a concerning one, but when has that ever stopped politicking? The whole world looks at our politics as though it were the WWF/WWE.
Shock is not something I don't put much stock in, guess that makes me and optimist. However, if the American people are so dense, that they don't remember the discussion and exposure of it's potential abuses, well then shame on them. But that is false shock, IMO.I remember it and I've forgotten more shit than I care to divulge. Most likely due to brain cells being killed on a daily basis.
As far as your point about just what this is supposed to dofagetaboudit! By revealing the effectiveness they may tip their hand in the process. The truth won't be know till much later on that issue.
Counter intelligence. Pure and simple. After programs are implemented they become obsolete, due to leaks and spy stuff. It becomes important to use the exposure to misinform the other side. In this case, it will be the enemy and the other party.
Yep, I screamed my liver out the Patriot Act back in the day as well, for all the good it did me. I wrote email after email to a long cast of characters too.
The genie is out of the proverbial bottle now, and it is doubtful we will ever get it put back in.
You are correct. Google has been in the forefront, if not the only internet tech corporation, of being transparent in regards to government requests for data.