HUFFINGTON POST: GEORGE W. OBAMA
NSA Prism Data Mining Is All Up In Ur Microsoft, Yahoo, Google, Facebook, PalTalk, AOL, Skype, YouTube, Apple [UPDATE]
America, here's hoping you've had enough time to be come to terms with the National Security Agency scooping up all of your metadata pertaining to all of the phone calls you've been making with Verizon , because here comes the next fun news about the government's far-reaching panopticon of total information surveillance, courtesy of Barton Gellman and Laura Poitras of The Washington Post :
A sign stands outside the campus of the National Security Administration, or NSA, in Fort Meade, Md. The Obama administration on Thursday defended the NSA's need to collect telephone records of U.S. citizens. (AP Photo/Patrick Semansky)
The National Security Agency and the FBI are tapping directly into the central servers of nine leading U.S. Internet companies, extracting audio, video, photographs, e-mails, documents and connection logs that enable analysts to track a persons movements and contacts over time .
The highly classified program, code-named PRISM, has not been disclosed publicly before. Its establishment in 2007 and six years of exponential growth took place beneath the surface of a roiling debate over the boundaries of surveillance and privacy. Even late last year, when critics of the foreign intelligence statute argued for changes, the only members of Congress who know about PRISM were bound by oaths of office to hold their tongues.
The Washington Post obtained "briefing slides" from an "internal presentation on the Silicon Valley operation, intended for senior analysts in the NSAs Signals Intelligence Directorate," from a "career intelligence officer" who cited "firsthand experience with these systems, and horror at their capabilities," as the reason for the disclosure. These materials described PRISM as "the most prolific contributor to the President's Daily Brief" and the NSA's "leading source of raw material, accounting for nearly 1 in 7 intelligence reports." The Post, goes on to report that while PRISM allows the NSA to collect "anything it likes" from the available data, it is in practice not utilized as a "dragnet" per se :
Analysts who use the system from a Web portal at Fort Meade key in selectors, or search terms, that are designed to produce at least 51 percent confidence in a targets foreignness. That is not a very stringent test. Training materials obtained by the Post instruct new analysts to submit accidentally collected U.S. content for a quarterly report, but its nothing to worry about.
Gellman and Poitras include a detailed history of the PRISM program, along with an explanation of how the system works and the extent to which the technology companies involved offer "resistance" to the data mining, so go read the whole thing

The man is in trouble.
He's only got about 18 months to get his act together or the GOP is going to take over Congress in 2014.
I have confidence in him, the man remains cool under fire, he'll pull out.
This story is BIG and will be around awhile.
1 - Obligatory image.
2. The right doesn't quite know how to react to this. a) Fox news in unusually tepid in its approach to this, with the exception of the always inane Hannity. b) Limbaugh's was uncharacteristically cautious as his listeners appear to be upset about their privacy being usurped. c) The WJS and CNN are offering very little in the line disparaging opinions.
3. The Democrats (as opposed the the ideological Liberals) are very quiet. I checked the site, "Democratic Underground" which is usually a good bellwether as to how the rank and file Democrats feel and even they are distancing themselves (at the moment) from this controversy. (see image at bottom)
4. ABC and CBS seem to be ignoring it, while NBC so far is poking around with it.
The facts are this;
My opinion - I don't think Obama going to pull out of this anytime soon.
He'll pull it out. The media gives the people what they want, right now the people smell blood, so the media gives them blood, it's all about ratings. Actually, the media loves Obama, he's rock star, and rock stars sell air time.
Obama is a master at manipulating the media, he just lays back until the smoke clears, then he emerges with that big smile of his, being all cool an' all, ... and they love him again.
(?!) After admitting;
You don't think Obama will pull out of this?! You have pretty much proved that there is actually very little to pull out of.
Let me put it this way, while this story was actually out in the UK on the 5th, it didn't break here til yesterday. a) I keep on mentioning that it was a UK story because the U.S. MSM was very reluctant to pick up on it. b) The US reactions to this so far is endemic to that of "shock." Both of these reasons explain the slow response by the US public.
This is only day two and we'll see how it goes but already there are rumblings that this is far from being played out yet.
And that was only after he was sworn into office.
(this posting editor is getting too damn twitchy)
Glenn Greenwald, who did the investigation and research on this for the Guardian, is hardly a RWNJ.
What I find fascinating, is you don't seem to care about what is happened? Just all politics, YOUR guy,
damn the Country.
LOL.
leave it to huffington puffington to find a new way to insult bush.
This is the thing that has always mystified me regarding Mr. Obama's treatment by the right. Circa the fifties, sixties and even the seventies he would have been considered a moderate Republican, now they consider him a socialist, go figure. Couple that and his continuation or expansion of some of Mr. Bush's policies and I consider him a left of center kind of guy.
I wanted him to succeed, but at this point I would say that is quite unlikely, some of it on himself the rest of it, most of know where that lies (if you don't lie to yourself).
Too bad for us.
"the rule of law, and transparency, will be the cornerstones of my administration"
obama lied, liberty died
I don't see that being said at all. No one is saying "damn the country", and it is all about politics, at least here, it's a political article,.... and it's an article about Obama.
What would you like us to discuss Egilman? People who troll discussion threads? We might not even be off topic if we went there.
Seems like what we have here is the "mirror" effect.
Yeah, even the NYT did that. Yeah, Obama has no credibility "on this issue" but the fault was really those nasty pubs (and dems) who passed the Patriot Act and placed the "temptation" before the poor Obama!
Unfortunately,thatmay be true.
Your right, and the Right Wingers don't seem to care about that, they just want to criticize Obama, no matter what the issue.
He's no Harry Truman, I'll admit that, but Obamas' administration has been weakened by Republican obstructionism more than by Obama leadership failures.
Sigh, leaders overcome, they don't fall by the wayside when obstacles arise.
You are contradicting yourself, merely to support Obama.
Ha, he has an exit strategy, I see
.
Did I say that?
When someone makes commentsaccusingpeople of saying or implying things they did not say (which seems to be a habit of yours), and when people make bizarre comments that have no impact on the thread other than to inflame the discussion (another habit of yours) .... those people are considered to be trolling (sometimes call "flamebaiting") If they show up on thread after thread, and constantlyexercise such practices, the are eventually labeled as a Troll.
I would start thinking about some of the comments your are making, I'm sure you don't want people to start thinking of you as a Troll.
I only said that as an offer of friendly advise, please don't go all bug-fuck on me like you did the last time I offered you some advise.
Yesterday was the 6th and London is is 5 hours ahead of New York, so they have a time advantage.
Anyway, I find it odd that the UK Guardian seems to be more interested in American politics than Americans. Must be that American politics sells well in Britain, I guess keeps their minds of their own problems.
MSM is a liberal publication, they don't like to push negative left wing issues.
We went through this before, when Bush was President, I think Americans are tired of the issue. Furthermore, they understand the necessity of this type of data mining and realized it is not as invasive as the media is trying to make it look.
The media will keep the thunder rolling until another story breaks.
Scandals sell air time, air time sells commercials ... do the math.
The media just want chaos and dissent no matter who is in office. They show about 2 days of support of anyone, politics, movie stars, sports stars, and then they start tearing them down and promoting drama. The saying holds true, the media doesn't report the news anymore they create it.
Nosurpriseto me, you guys are the ones that have been calling him a Liberal and aSocialist.
Did we now. I thought we elected a man that would do his job.
What is there to forgive? The NSA is data mining to help keep terrorist from being able to function. That makes Obama a Neocon?
All of a sudden you have disdain for Neocons? You have been one for at least as long as you have been on this site.
will liberals get upset if the nsa asks if they are praying to obama?
That's fairly outlandish statement. Obama has shown on many occasions that he is not the Flaming Liberal the Right tries to claim he is. Condoning the data mining practices of the NSA is a prime example.
Did he? Did it?
I suppose your happy, now that allclandestineterrorist in the US are now aware the US government is data mining all telephone calls and they need to only make calls onuntraceable track phones.
Understand, the NSA is not mining phone conversations, they are mining phone links, calls and connections, so they canpossiblyconnect the dots and preventanother9/11 or Boston Bombing.
Just how "transparent" do you want our anti-terrorism agencies to be?Shouldthey publish daily briefings in the New York Times to keep any terrorist planning an attack aware of what the NSA and DHS know?
We all need to tell the mediamoguls, out for no mare than better ratings, to find another story to use to sell their air time.
(I can't wait for the Zimmerman trial to start)
Thanks John. I saw that, and couldn't even think of a comment. Even lame is an understatement.
Please EI, let's not add to the lameness here, orthisthis thread is liable to becomecompletelyosteopathic.
Don't flatter yourself.
So have I.
THIS IS THE PART WHERE THIS ALL WENT WRONG (just when I was starting to have a good time)
My comment should not have been directed at you Egilman, it was meant to be directed at wmolaw (I could swear I just heard someones eyebrows hit the top of their forehead) You guys think so much alike it's sometimes hard to keep your comments separated.
Anyway, about trolling; the term has somewhat morphed from it's original usage. The term was originally used to describe hit-and-runcommentatorsthat trolled from Site to site and from thread to thread, making one or twoinflammatorycomments, then moving on. Today, legitimatesite members often constantly troll through threads making one outlandish comment after the other, sometimes not even realizing they're trolling.
We have at least one member on this site that fits that description to a tee. (not you, at least not here) So I apologize for calling you a troll Egilman, your comments on this thread have not been trollish or baiting .... they've only been incorrect, particularly the one about Obama not being able to pull out of these so called scandals.
I hope you will accept myapology so we can continue to disagree in good faith.
The newstheyreport, the drama is what they create..
Yeah, he keeps the oil for the wheels on that skateboard in the top drawer of his desk.
You got it Egilman.
Stay sharp, we'll be meeting again.