╌>

The Question Libertarians Just Can’t Answer

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  jerry-verlinger  •  13 years ago  •  144 comments

The Question Libertarians Just Can’t Answer

images?q=tbn:ANd9GcRXSMvWveHtC5L5OuLnnDZanIj2rq_NU2rj2yTC_S9FKlN0HhkQrQ&width=120

BY MICHAEL LIND

If your approach is so great, why hasn't any country anywhere in the world ever tried it?

Eug%25C3%25A8ne_Delacroix_-_La_libert%25C3%25A9_guidant_le_peuple.jpg?width=600

Eugne Delacroix - La libert guidant le peuple (1830)

Why are there no libertarian countries? If libertarians are correct in claiming that they understand how best to organize a modern society, how is it that not a single country in the world in the early twenty-first century is organized along libertarian lines?

Its not as though there were a shortage of countries to experiment with libertarianism. There are 193 sovereign state members of the United Nations195, if you count the Vatican and Palestine, which have been granted observer status by the world organization. If libertarianism was a good idea, wouldnt at least one country have tried it? Wouldnt there be at least one country, out of nearly two hundred, with minimal government, free trade, open borders, decriminalized drugs, no welfare state and no public education system?

When you ask libertarians if they can point to a libertarian country, you are likely to get a baffled look, followed, in a few moments, by something like this reply: While there is no purely libertarian country, there are countries which have pursued policies of which libertarians would approve: Chile, with its experiment in privatized Social Security, for example, and Sweden, a big-government nation which, however, gives a role to vouchers in schooling.

But this isnt an adequate response. Libertarian theorists have the luxury of mixing and matching policies to create an imaginary utopia. A real country must function simultaneously in different realmsdefense and the economy, law enforcement and some kind of system of support for the poor. Being able to point to one truly libertarian country would provide at least some evidence that libertarianism can work in the real world.

Some political philosophies pass this test. For much of the global center-left, the ideal for several generations has been Nordic social democracywhat the late liberal economist Robert Heilbroner described as a slightly idealized Sweden. Other political philosophies pass the test, even if their exemplars flunk other tests. Until a few decades ago, supporters of communism in the West could point to the Soviet Union and other Marxist-Leninist dictatorships as examples of really-existing socialism. They argued that, while communist regimes fell short in the areas of democracy and civil rights, they proved that socialism can succeed in a large-scale modern industrial society.

Read the whole article;


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago
 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    13 years ago

Jerry, I have always maintained that Libertarianism is impossible to implement simply because there are no checks and balances to counter the motivation of greed in their system.

The best chance it has to be a viable form of government is in a predominantly agrarian society. An industrialized society is out of it's ability to serve all components of that society.

 
 
 
Steve Ott
Professor Silent
link   Steve Ott    13 years ago

No state has ever been 100% democratic either. Does that negate the "philosophy" of democracy?

As I understand it, libertarianism at most would be a community, not a country.

Marxist-Leninist dictatorships as examples of really-existing socialism.

Perhaps, but certainly not communism.

Please point me in the direction of one country that is 100% any political philosophy. I crave learning.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

Please point me in the direction of one country that is 100% any political philosophy.

Here are a few ...to get you started.

I crave learning.

Big mistake, that!

That sort of attitude will only end up making you exceedingly depressed! Grin.gif

 
 
 
Steve Ott
Professor Silent
link   Steve Ott    13 years ago

Actually, learning is the main thing that keeps me happy. As for your list: well, I would say read the 100% thing again. A nice list as lists go, but still rather short of any country that has been 100% of any political philosophy, except perhaps Machiavelli. The Prince is a depressing read.

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    13 years ago

The link is to assholes who killed people, not the country being of one political philosophy.

 
 
 
luther28
Sophomore Silent
link   luther28    13 years ago

My point of view is essentially the same for all ologies, isms and ians.

As with all good thoughts they appear to work on paper, but when the human condition (greed, spite, envy you know them all) are added to the recipe the cake turns to manure. You have to take the notion of man (or woman) always doing what is right or noble out of the equation, what you are left with is reality.

With a viable third party our system would work that much better, remove money from the system and you just may have the perfect (as perfect as it can be) government in place.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

To understand why libertarianism is untenable, all one has to do is consider infrastructure - how much of it there is now, how it was created, and how much new infrastructure and maintenance of old infrastructure will be required in the future. No matter how you slice it, a libertarian paradigm shift relative to ownership of infrastructurewouldimmediately devolve into a quagmire one thousand times more complicated and ineffective than our current government already is, and the inevitable result would be an eventualmorphing back intoto the style of government that we see today - only the country would go bankrupt during the process of convincing themselves that libertarianism was a horrible idea to begin with.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    13 years ago

And what proof do you have that a libertarian approach would not continue the march towards plutocracy? What is it that libertarians have that will guarantee that the individual will protected from the negative aspects of capitalism?

 
 
 
StevieGee
Freshman Silent
link   StevieGee    13 years ago

Somalia has no central government, no taxes, no gun laws, no military bases overseas, no drug laws... Stop me when I get to one that's not a libertarian view. The tribal part comes about naturally because the libertarian anarchy doesn't work.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

Libertarians want to reduce government to something too small to deal with infrastructure, which requires massive capital to build and maintain. You all take for granted the fact that there are ample roads to get you from point A to point B, and when you take a shit you figure it just magically disappears once it leaves the toilet bowl. You see environmental regulations as a negative consequence of big government, because you haven't witnessed what a lack of these regs will do to a country of this magnitude.

Imagine living in the middle of a city block, attached to municipal utilities and accessed by public right-of-way. In an ill-thoughtlibertarian scenario, your income would increaseas a consequence ofsignificantly lesser taxation going to the entity that built those roads and utilities. In fact, the libertarian way would be to divvy up that existinginfrastructure and give a piece of it to everyone who helped pay for it through taxation, trusting that when it comes time to fix it, or replace it entirely, everyone will happily toss in some mutually agreed upon amount of money to make it happen - since they have so much more disposable income thanks to reduced taxes. And when it snows 30 inches, that everyone would grab a shovel and go out into the street to shovel that portion of the road that is "theirs", thereby achieving the same thing that the municipality was responsible for through your taxation.

Of course, that would never happen smoothly in the real world, which would necessitate the electing of officers to occupy positions in committees to force rules on everyone over how to address the obvious problem of infrastructure maintenance and expansion. Of course that would not go smoothly at all, as there would be as many opinions on how to achieve this objective as there are citizens, and the vast majority of people would expect that their new found wealth was there for them to spend on themselves. Citizens would coagulate into like-minded parties to endorse the electable candidates that best represent their opinions for these positions.

After the entire economy has been bled to death of money and energy from dealing with that mayhem, eventually people would realize that all theyare doing is recreating the wheel.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

Jerry, I have always maintained that Libertarianism is impossible to implement simply because there are no checks and balances to counter the motivation of greed in their system.

Greed isinherentin every political system. I've always maintained thatLibertarianismis impossible to implement because theyhavenever been able to define exactly who and what theyare allabout.Every timeI ask ask a Libertarian to define what they stand for, I get a different answer.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    13 years ago

If they don't like something, it's wrong, It's a very selfish belief.

I find it very similar to having a discussion with a nine year old. They know what they want, they just want it, and rarely if ever think about what the ramifications to others or to their surroundings that would be impacted by acquiescing to their wants.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

This is what I mean when I say that libertarians fail to think their proposals through to their logical conclusions - what you have offered is strictly relegated to FHWA interests. When it comes to megaprojects, the planning and expense is an entirelydifferent animal than local infrastructure needs. All roads, not just interstates,need to bedesigned with the understanding that there is an agency that is devoted to finance, maintenance and design/construction oversight of those facilities. Libertarianism wants to eliminate that entity and trust thatJoe Schmo and his neighbors will put their heads together when need be to fix a problem. The problem is that Joe Schmo and his neighbors don't know dick about how to manage roadway infrastructure - and the same thing goes for any other facet of infrastructure.

Thinking that we can takeall the infrastructure related duties ofgovernment and give them to the people, is ignorant of the fact that thatsector of thegovernment is already made up of the best people and policiesfor managingthat job. It already is organized, and any attempt to remove that organization and replace it from the ground up with something new is an exercise in futility. It is laughable to think that doing so would somehow be more fiscally conservative and responsible. In the end all you have done is removed the instruments that have been developed to gear the system towards fairness and professionalism, and open up one million more opportunities for greed and corruption to fleece those who depend on infrastructure. It's entirely counter productive, and the inevitable conclusion is that we would end up having to go through helljust to get right back to where we started from.

Is actually the way it is done today.

Lol - no, it is not.

The libertarian way of paying as you go really works..... the dividing it up into the chunk everyone HAS to pay doesn't.

Well let's see .... how about we stop MANDATING that people contribute their fair share to infrastructure improvement, and just ask them politely to give what they can. We'll find out real quickly how libertarianism is programmed to fail. This is like when conservatives balk at public assistance and insist that the poor be served by private charity. It doesn't work that way, and it never will, because we are human.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

Somaliaseems to be giving it a whirl!

What makes you say that? Somalia has a bicameral parliamentary form of government with a democratically elected President who at this time isHassan Sheikh Mohamud. The President appoints a Prime Minister, who in turn appoints a cabinet. Their economy is pretty much runs on the capitalistic system.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    13 years ago

And why pray tell would we want substitute one form of greed and power hungry laden system for one that by design would welcome even more of the same?

To date Egilman, you have NEVER supplied even a remotely sufficient answer to how a libertarian system counterbalances greed.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

Somalia has no central government, no taxes, no gun laws, no military bases overseas, no drug laws...

Where did you get THAT information?! I would really like to see you find a link or some sort of credible reference to support that ridicules comment.

Capitafm Business Posted by AFP on April 13, 2013

IMF-BUILDING.jpg?width=500

The International Monetary Fundrecognizedthe government of Somalia on Friday, ending a 22-year break in relations that could lead to IMF technical and policy support to the country.

The International Monetary Fund today recognised the Federal Government of Somalia, headed by President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud, paving the way for the resumption of relations after a 22-year interval, the IMF said in a statement.

 
 
 
Polka-san
Freshman Silent
link   Polka-san    13 years ago

There are no libertarian states because the world is controlled by the wealthy elite and they need marriage of corporate power and the state to rule all of humanity. True libertarianism is not something they are prepared to tolerate.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    13 years ago

So what you are saying is that what you call "true libertarianism" can't get off the runway because it cannot or will not do anything about redistribution of wealth and power through law and regulation.

And here I thought libertarianism placed the right to self determination at the core of it's principles.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    13 years ago

If your form of government can't change, or is powerless against the very system or entity you rail against, what is the point of even attempting to promote that form of government?

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

They can't define it because more than likely, it's about THEM, and not about the system. If they don't like something, it's wrong, It's a very selfish belief.

I think you have pretty much explained it EI.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    13 years ago

I have a question that hopefully isn't too OT.

Why is it that when I seek a middle-of-the-road idealism, it is automatically interpreted as meaning Libertarian? I'm not a Libertarian but believe that both sides of the aisle have made both good and bad choices, and I would hope to see a middle ground that looks to resolve issues through legitimate comropmise and hard work....that does not mean Libertarian but it is assumed that that is the only possible third view-point. Is there really no such thing as a moderate anymore?

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

For guys that think they are the end all and be all of political knowledge, you know very little about libertarianism, since all you can do is insult it, you prove how little you know every time you open your mouths.

Back off there Egilman, the only one here spewing insults is you. There has beencriticism here of the Libertarian concept, but like a typical conservative, you take any criticism or disagreement to be an insult.

Furthermore, no one is saying they love the system we have today. The article and moreintelligentcomments here, are simply attesting to the fact that there is no country in the history of the entire world that has eversuccessfully practiced Libertarianism.

If you have any kind of argument to controvert what Michael Lind has to say in his article, lets here it.

So far all you have done iscriticizeinsult those that arecriticizingsomething you support.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    13 years ago

Thanks john for your response.

Do you believe that there is a chance for a third party beyond that of Libertarianism?

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

".....if they are actually taking steps to rectify their national governmental structural problems, then good on them."

They are.

As part of the official "Roadmap for the End of Transition", a political process which provides clear benchmarks leading toward the establishment of permanent democratic institutions in Somalia by late August 2012,Somali government officials met in the northeastern town of Garowe in February 2012 to discuss post-transition arrangements. [ Source ]

Note the 22 year interval in your 'clip'.

What 22 yr interval and what "clip"?

 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   Polly Cooper    13 years ago

American Libertarians don't believe in NO central government. They don't believe in NO taxes, No drug laws, etc. American Libertarians believe in limited Central government based on the Constitution of the United States. IF Somalia was based on the Constitution of the United States, they'd be fine until their politicians bastardized it the way ours have.

 
 
 
Blue Wolf2
Freshman Silent
link   Blue Wolf2    13 years ago

When Libertarianism evolves past the overwhelming emphasis on private property, it might stand a chance. That and when it evolves past "whatever I do only affects me".

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    13 years ago

I have voted both sides of the aisle for years John, Up until 2000, and I have voted straight Dem ticket since. I don't think it is any coincidence that it was around that time that compromise became a word that many elected officials couldn't or wouldn't utter.

At heart I am a moderate, but since there is little if any compromise going on in politics these days I have chosen to align myself with being a moderate left of center democrat.

 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   Polly Cooper    13 years ago

The first roads in this country were built by private enterprise. The first railroads in this country were private as well.

 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   Polly Cooper    13 years ago

What will guarantee that the individual will be protected from the negative aspects of capitalism? LIMITED GOVERNMENT.

Lets face it, Flynavy, the REASON we have so many corporate whores is because the government allowed - encouraged it.

 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   Polly Cooper    13 years ago

Actually, Larry, Libertarians are "classic liberals". If you really want to know what Libertarians believe, read this:

P rior to the 20th century, classical liberalism was the dominant political philosophy in the United States. It was the political philosophy of Thomas Jefferson and the signers of the Declaration of Independence and it permeates the Declaration of Independence, the Constitution, the Federalist Papers and many other documents produced by the people who created the American system of government. Many of the emancipationists who opposed slavery were essentially classical liberals, as were the suffragettes, who fought for equal rights for women.

Basically, classical liberalism is the belief in liberty. Even today, one of the clearest statements of this philosophy is found in Jefferson's Declaration of Independence. At that time, as is the case today, most people believed that rights came from government. People thought they only had such rights as government elected to give them. But following the British philosopher John Locke, Jefferson argued that it's the other way around. People have rights apart from government, as part of their nature. Further, people can form governments and dissolve them. The only legitimate purpose of government is to protect these rights.

People who call themselves classical liberals today tend to have the basic view of rights and role of government that Jefferson and his contemporaries had. Moreover, they do not tend to make any important distinction between economic liberties and civil liberties.

Actually, ALL OF YOU who think they "know" what Libertarianism entails should read this.

 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   Polly Cooper    13 years ago

Here's your answer, Jerry

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    13 years ago

"...what would be the philosophy of this party? Compromise? Compromise is the result of negotiation, not a political position."

- No lobbyists

- Result oriented

- Priorities to include a fairer and easier system of taxation,balancing thebudget, getting the economy in order, and jobs.

-A call for a very tight capon all forms of campaign benifits.

....for now.

 
 
 
Blue Wolf2
Freshman Silent
link   Blue Wolf2    13 years ago

Explain "the only legitimate purpose of government is to protect those rights"

Thats a platitude that I hear Libertarians say all the time, but there is nothing behind it except that they say it. Its a view, but its ONLY a view among many.

Our Constitution plainly says that one of the reasons our government is declared is to "promote the general welfare". Now either that statement is meaningless or its not, but it plainly goes beyond protection of rights.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

Your very nature is violent and dishonest.

In other words you would not welcome Republican and Democrats into your Party seeing how they're so violent and dishonest 'an all. Which means you want the minority Libertarian party to run the country. Is that what your saying?

Also, you seem to be implying that the Libertarian Party has the naive belief that if it ever could get control of the reins of government, it would absent of failures and corruption. Is that also what your saying?

Are you not aware that all governments, any government, is made up with people? People sometimes fail, people are sometimes corrupt. ( Often, when it come to politicians) To believe aLibertarianform of government would be anydifferentthan any other form regarding failures and corruption, is the pinnacle ofnaivety.

So far not one comment supporting the Libertarians has even attempted to answer Michael Linds' question;

If your approach is so great, why hasn't any country anywhere in the world ever tried it?

We're waiting45.gif

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    13 years ago

That and when it evolves past "whatever I do only affects me".

That's the one that I focus on for moderation and modification by so called libertarians.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    13 years ago

Interesting link and thanks Polly.

:~)

 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   Polly Cooper    13 years ago

Regarding EI:

Anyone who claims to know all the answers doesn't really know very much

New Living Translation of 1 Corinthians 8:2

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    13 years ago

Yup. Libertarianism is misunderstood. It is not a government structure, but a personal belief system that freedom is the highest and best for which individuals can strive.

Note, nowhere is there a "democratic party" government, or "republican party" government, or an "independent party" government.

The article is, frankly, dumb and merely attempting to trivialize those who believe in individual freedom. Take this statement:

They argued that, while communist regimes fell short in the areas of democracy and civil rights, they proved that socialism can succeed in a large-scale modern industrial society.

Ah, no, in fact no "communist" country has ever really existed. They all turn into dictatorships, either of personality or committee. So they can't be used to "prove" anything.

As I said, a dumb article.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    13 years ago

True but they don't seem to want to. They want to "win" so they can keep their positions and power. If we had a third party that truly made it there goal to serve rather than be served....ya know what I mean? Right now all that seems to matter is keeping "the other side" in check and hardly anything gets done.

 
 
 
Blue Wolf2
Freshman Silent
link   Blue Wolf2    13 years ago

The Nature of reality is dependence, not autonomy. The libertarian ideal of the individual as king/god/supreme level of importanceflies against what we really know about the interconnectedness of all things.It flies in the face of physics.

Freedom is NOT the natural state of man. Dependence is the natural state of all life.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

Well unfortunately for you liberals and smattering of establishment republicans, people are learning more and more of what libertarians stand for.

I haven't seen one iota of information from you or anyone else supporting the Libertarians, that is helping anyone learn anything here.

They aren't getting it from you people who claim they know it all and have all the answers because your history is one of those answers not working.

I also don't see any here claiming to "know it all", with exception of you, of course. But then that's the nature and earmark of a Libertarian, you guys have all the answers and everybody else is all fucked up.

Example;

"The people are looking for a change, just in case you haven't gotten it from the last few elections, the two parties that enjoy all the power haven't delivered, and the people are looking elsewhere."

'nother example;

"Finally, the two major parties egos have gotten the better of them, they have turned off so many they have figured there HAS to be a better way."

and this;

"Cause what we are currently doing and getting from either political party is not working."

I'd say the thought and energy of the people to learn the alternatives is time WELL SPENT!

IF ..... one of the Libertarians in the room had offered something new to learn. So far all you guys have done is fortify the title of the article;

The Question Libertarians Just Can't Answer

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

Squats When Peesspeaks with his cheeks.....very interesting!

What's that supposed to mean BadFish?

 
 
 
Blue Wolf2
Freshman Silent
link   Blue Wolf2    13 years ago

Do species other than humans have these "inherent" rights by nature? If not, why not? and if so, then how do you define private property?

The planet could do quite well without people, but it could not exist in any such state as it does now without the smallest of soil microbes which break down organic matter to a form useable by plants for food. This elevates soil microbes to a place higher in importance than manfrom a realistic/holistic point of view.

Why don't soil microbes have rights?

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    13 years ago

Actually, you're wrong. The NATURE of reality is competition, not dependence. It is true in EVERY corner of our world, in every aspect, and every species!

It is what drives evolution, life.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

Please point me in the direction of one country that is 100% any political philosophy.

Please point us to the place the author said anything about a country subscribing to 100% of any political philosophy.

He said (myemphasis), " .....how is it that not a single country in the world in the early twenty-first century is organized along libertarian lines?"

 
 
 
Blue Wolf2
Freshman Silent
link   Blue Wolf2    13 years ago

Thats drivel. You are dependent from before your first breath. You can only breathe oxygen because of the actions of ancient anaerobic bacteria whos by product (defecation) was oxygen, which over saturated the oceans and escaped to the atmosphere (which had no oxygen before that)

Flatly stated, you don't know what you're talking about.

ALL SPECIES ARE DEPENDENT UPON OTHERS.

EXCEPT libertarians...which seem to be a universe unto themselves (sarc)

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago
I'm confused - you want to go back to building roads meant to accommodate covered wagons? You clearly are not aware of what it takes to design modern infrastructure to serve high density population centers.
 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    13 years ago

I wonder, has anyone every actually read what the libertarian party's positions are?

Jerry, note, he also said:

When you ask libertarians if they can point to a libertarian country, you are likely to get a baffled look

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

Here are a few

Interesting observation.

The author is not advocating a 100% political philosophy. That's a Steve Ott brainchild.

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    13 years ago

So, you're saying Clinton was at fault as well EI?

Or is it just 8 years, or 4 years in the making?

How about we agree that the GOVERNMENT caused it?

That would certainly be a true statement, wouldn't it?

Which, then, points us all to the less government involvement/control, the less chance of events such as those occurring.

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    13 years ago

They're despots in training.

Yup, for they KNOW what's best for you! And they will use the police power to enforce their beliefs!

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago
I'd respond, but EI has done a fine job addressing your argument. Libertarians think like stoners, and their extreme ideas amount to throwing out the baby with the bath water. Somewhere in our current system of governing lies the best fit to nurturing an efficient, progressive, protective and rewarding society. The focus should be on iteration towards removing what doesn't work, and strengthening what does work for the community as a whole, not obliterating the entire system and starting anew.
 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

I'll agree with you here Wmolaw. Historically, competition is an inherent human quality...dependance; beyond the child years, is an abnormality if not a human flaw. While tribes, clans and later, communities and civilizations formed an interdependence for things such as defense and trade, it's always been in pursuit of the greatest hunter, warrior and producer.

I do not know of a thriving civilization that has survived without competition.

 
 
 
Blue Wolf2
Freshman Silent
link   Blue Wolf2    13 years ago

Do you know of one which has thrived absent the microbes in the soil which break down organic matter to a form useable by plants?

You're thinking on a small level. There are levels upon levels below competition.

Humans falsely think they are much more important than they are.

I take it you don't think you are totally dependent upon things you can't even see? Things which never even cross your mind?

 
 
 
Blue Wolf2
Freshman Silent
link   Blue Wolf2    13 years ago

Also, they don't give heed to the essential non-human factors as being included in the "inherent rights" thingy.

When Nature herself is granted rights, then we will have something worth holding on to. But this homocentricity has got to go.

I don't see right and wrong as arbitrary either though John, I see them as TOOLS or formulas that either work or don't.

 
 
 
Steve Ott
Professor Silent
link   Steve Ott    13 years ago

And I said: AsIunderstand it, libertarianism at most would be a community, not a country.

My reading and understanding of Libertarian philosophy leads me to believe that there could NOT be a Libertarian country as we understand countries today. It would be organized more along the lines of a city-state at most; therefore, there could not be a Libertarian country.

You are correct in saying the 100% is my brainchild. I just wanted to see if anyone would try to answer the question. I don't believe I said the author of the article said it.

 
 
 
Steve Ott
Professor Silent
link   Steve Ott    13 years ago

Exactly.

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    13 years ago

The answer is simple. A complete change in the political and sociological ideology for a nation is almost never going to happen. It did with the Soviet Union, but that is the only example I can think of, and the system failed itself in that case. In Iraq, people cant even get used to the idea of "freedom". So, I dont really think your question is a good one at all. I mean, there are quite a few dictatorships left in the world. They exist, so they must be a good thing based on the presumption of Lind regarding libertarianism. The key aspect of almost all those who hold power is an unwillingness to relinquish that power. That pretty much puts a halt on almost any attempt to institute a new government where a coup/revolt has not taken place...and even then, there is no guarantee of change.

 
 
 
markpup
Freshman Silent
link   markpup    13 years ago

I think the best short definition of libertarian I ever heard was that in the general mix of moral and ethical values, things that promote freedom rate very high.

Sounds good at first, but then I think about what gets rated low to make up for it. If you're focused on duty, you're a sucker. Sinks it right there.

My immediate association with libertarian is the Ferengi on Star Trek - focused on accumulating capital but completely devoid of passion, beauty, duty, and caring for others. Not a world I'd want.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

I wonder, has anyone every actually read what the libertarian party's positions are?

I read it a while back when I got fed upwiththe GOP and explored enrolling in the LP. But I found that in many respects they are farther to the Right than the conservatives! There's a wholebunchof U.S. Constitutionredundancy in there, andin other places parts of the Constitution are completely rejected.

Overall it just adds up to being a platform for anunattainableUtopiandreamworld that provides no reasonable logic that would allow for it'simplantation and provides place for Republicans to hide that don't want admit they support the GOP.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

What was the crap? specificity please

How about the lack ofover-siteof the banking industry, allowing investors to back lenders that were selling every kind ofcockamamie loan they could think of. That failure was responsible for the primary reason the economy collapsed.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

but he certainly didn't do anything to get the country out (neither did FDR mind you),

FDR had a little problem called the 2nd world war to deal with.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

".... why do you always try to belittle me, like I'm some kind of lesser light compared to your infinite wisdom?"

Because he's right and your wrong? (Just a guess)

"I've been studying history seriously for 40 years,...."

It's of little importance how long you have been on the trail, what is important is what you have learned along the way.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

So, you're saying Clinton was at fault as well EI?

Clinton left GWB with a huge surplus.

Or is it just 8 years, or 4 years in the making?

It was 8 years. The same 8 years Bush spent blowing that surplus and leaving Obama with huge deficit and a collapsing economy.

How about we agree that the GOVERNMENT caused it?

I'll give you that one, as long as you agree it was because the GOVERNMENT did not it's job regulating the banking industry and properly overseeing other regulatory agencies.

Which, then, points us all to the less government involvement/control, the less chance of events such as those occurring

Which then points us all to the less government involvement/control, the MORE chance of events such as those occurring

Smaller government and fewer regulations sounds good an' all, until the government isn't there when you need it, and things get all fucked up because nobody is paying any attention the regulations.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

"..... so, they make-up nonsense, as a way to disparage the idea of freedom, as some form of anarchy.

Pure, unadulterated bullshit. (But then we have to consider the source)

Those that reject freedom, do so because they don't trust others, and demand government control instead.

More bullshit. Please explain the difference between "others" and "government control"

(I know Mike, that's a hard question for you, but your the one that made the comparison)

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

Nice find Sixpick, the guy makes some very interesting points.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

I'm going to answer the infrastructure thing, show you a libertarian approach that works a lot better than a tax and spend approach.....

Thank you for that, it was very informative and enlightening. However, you didn't provide the source oraccreditationfor the information. Although you did show the information in block quotes which indicates it was not your work, you also should have provided a link orreferenceto the source.

and there is one other problem;

The libertarian way of paying as you go really works.....

That is simply not true, as explained by Hal A. Lujah in his comment just below yours.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

The first roads in this country were built by private enterprise. The first railroads in this country were private as well.

It's 2013 Polly. Different times, different circumstances.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

Lets face it, Flynavy, the REASON we have so many corporate whores is because the government allowed - encouraged it.

And by limiting government we're going to increase it's ability to get better control over the corporate whores?

Anyway, I thought you guys wanted LESS government controls, It sounds to me like you want government to do MORE to control the big corporations.

How do we do more controlling with fewer controls?

You can't have it both ways Polly.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

I have a question that hopefully isn't too OT.

Is there really no such thing as a moderate anymore?

Not off topic at all Larry. Of course there are moderates. They are to the left of the conservatives and and to the right of the liberals, which make them the largest voting block and the most powerful group of voters in the country.

The conservatives think they represent the majority view of Americans, just as the liberals think they represent the majority view of Americans. The truth is both of those groups on the fringe of American politics, the majority view of Americans is actually held by the moderates.

The fringe left and the fringe right both have a certain amount of influence on the voters, but neither are strong enough in numbers to carry an election on their own. It is always the way the majority of moderates vote that decide which side will win.

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    13 years ago

The focus should be on iteration towards removing what doesn't work, and strengthening what does work for the community as a whole, not obliterating the entire system and starting anew.

They sing,

Kumbaya, my love, kumbaya! As they dance around a beach fire.

What fascinates me is how they just ignore the FACTS, how they ignore REALITY! The depredations of today, the march towards tyranny!

They see it as "tin foil", guess it's okay with them if they live as slaves to a government.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

I know what I need to know - that libertarianism is all confidence and no substance.Your ideology is only attractive to those types who want tohave partialcontrol of everything under the sun, regardless of how little they know about it. It is a recipe for disaster, and it is quite ignorant of the reasons centralizedgovernment exists in the first place.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    13 years ago

Thanks Jerry.

I guess I am thinking about even just getting the work of running the government done. We have no budget really, unemployment is through the roof....the list goes on and on, of unfinished work, yet all we see in DC is finger-pointing as to why we are in such a mess, trying to one-up each other for political points. Our system is not working and it is evidenced by all the work not getting done.

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    13 years ago

Schizophrenic?

 
 
 
StevieGee
Freshman Silent
link   StevieGee    13 years ago

I stand corrected. It's good to see a government rising from the Libertarian ashes.

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    13 years ago

You should have stopped at Somalia. Do you guys have ANY clue what positions Libertarians even hold?

Go check out their site, learn.

 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   Polly Cooper    13 years ago

If you work on the assumption that the most important thing that the Constitution does is guarantee us our rights, then it follows that Promoting the General Welfare means that it is government's responsibility to protect those rights. I don't see anything "meaningless" about either statement. I see that they go hand in hand quite nicely.

 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   Polly Cooper    13 years ago

Actually wmolaw, there HAVE been true democracies (democratic governments). They failed. All of them.

 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   Polly Cooper    13 years ago

No Blue Wolf. The libertarian philosophy (and it IS a philosophy, not a type of government) has a basic tenant that whatever I do CANNOT HARM others. Big difference. Any moron knows that everything you do affects others in some way.

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    13 years ago

Agreed. Which is why ours is a representative democracy, which about 99% of the population of this Country does not know.

Not sure where I said that there had never been one?

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    13 years ago

Sorry, you are incorrect.

You are changing your position, though I don't expect you to be able to realize that.

Freedom is NOT the natural state of man. Dependence is the natural state of all life.

is completely different from this:

ALL SPECIES ARE DEPENDENT UPON OTHERS.

The first is incorrect. The second is correct.

Not unusual for posters to try to change what they write so as to be correct.

 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   Polly Cooper    13 years ago

You said:

Note, nowhere is there a "democratic party" government, or "republican party" government, or an "independent party" government.

I'm not trying to argue with you, as we are on the same page, I just wanted to kind of pound that reality home to the uninformed.

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    13 years ago

One need only look at every aspect of every species, fauna or flora.

Trees strive to be taller because?

Grasses?

Etc., etc., etc.

Natural state is competition.

Doesn't mean folks/animals can't get together. Doesn't mean that all species are interdependent.

 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   Polly Cooper    13 years ago

Libertarians have a duty not to harm others. They have a duty not to harm the property of others (environment). We believe we have a duty to take care of ourselves and our families. We have MORE passion for things like the Constitution than most of the rest of you. We believe WE have a duty to educate our children, not the government. We believe we have a duty to provide monetarily for our families and - through charities - to provide for those unable to provide for themselves.

So where in the hell do you get off making your comment?

 
 
 
Blue Wolf2
Freshman Silent
link   Blue Wolf2    13 years ago

What do they compete FOR?

Competition has no meaning outside of dependence/need.

Dependence underlies competition.

 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   Polly Cooper    13 years ago

Here's a "reality" for you. Take the government OUT of the entitlement equation and the money saved could lift literally MILLIONS out of poverty. There's my utopia.

 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   Polly Cooper    13 years ago

Yeah, really different. In fact, today what a private company can do for $10 Million a government contracted company can do for $100 million. We've come a long way, baby

 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   Polly Cooper    13 years ago

Hal, that's a ridiculous comment and you're really better than that. The first roads and railroads were by and large state of the art for their time. Ergo, in today's world, what a private company can do would also be state of the art.

Also, I DO believe that "modern" roads are still designed by private companies and then CONTRACTED to the government. (unless built by the Army Corp of Engineers) Do feel free to correct me if I am wrong.

FYI, I have seen "government" financed highways that look like roads meant to accommodate covered wagons in three to five short years.

 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   Polly Cooper    13 years ago

I wasn't talking to you. Go post another Code of Conduct violation insulting me.

 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   Polly Cooper    13 years ago

Oh for crissake, John Russell, just how many times do you have to be told that Libertarians do NOT believe in NO REGULATION OR OVERSIGHT! Jesus H Christ, you're like a fucking broken record!

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago
Calling everyone who disagrees with you 'weak' is a classic expression of overconfidence. The founders were not dealing with the demographics, population, technology, environment and global position that we have evolved to. The libertarian ideology fits within the modern framework of our culture like a square peg in a round hole. We are currently the highly evolved version of style of government that you are so eager to spread. Like so many others here have noted, you have failed to provide justification or even explanation for how libertarian philosophy could possibly be applied to the modern world, which is clearly the reason why there are no libertarian countries today. Why don't you go make a name for yourself and start one somewhere the hell away from this one and prove the world wrong.
 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   Polly Cooper    13 years ago

It's not that I can't take, it EI, it's that I'm so very tired of it. In fact, the more you rant, the more I'm amused by you. So, take your ball and go home. Bye bye.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago
Apparently, they just don't believe such regulations should be enforceable. The honor system in full effect. And y'all call us gullible?
 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

That we even have to discuss it from time to time wastes thought and energy that could be put to better use in other areas.

Libertarianism as a whole, obviously will not work in modern society, however certain libertarian ideals, of both sides of the spectrum, have value and are worth discussing from time to time.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

Insults that prove you now nothing about libertarianism, don't want to know, and are arrogant asses about it...

Cool down Egiman, we have a CoC on this site, and I hate to report abuse.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

I wasn't talking to you.

So, take your ball and go home. Bye bye.

(?!)

This is an open forum, anyone can comment on any comment. Let's try to keep this civil Polly.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

Thanks Jerry.

Your welcome.

I guess I am thinking about even just getting the work of running the government done.

I think what your trying to ask is, are there any moderates in Washington.

There are plenty moderates in America, actually most Americans are moderates. The problem is, the elected guys that we send to Washington, on both sides of the isle, are more worried about their respective fringe bases than they are about the majority.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

So what does that make me?

An intelligent voter.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

"A libertarian believe it or not,...."

Not.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

Egilman,

I mentioned before about posting accreditation, or citations with your quotes.

This is from the Carlton University (the first I could get my hands on)

Rule of Citation Review ;

#3 Ideas from sources need attribution, whether the ideas are quoted,
summarized, paraphrased or merely referred to.

#6 If you quote, you cite. It does not matter if the words precisely express your idea. Your own idea in your own words does not need to be cited. Your idea in anothers words does.

Charges of plagiarism or lack of attribution can be very serious, you should make sure you always CYA.

I don't know what the policy is here at NT, but I do know that people have been banned from Newsvine for lack ofattribution in comments and articles.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

Man! You have some temper Egilman.

What makes you think I want you gone?! I don't anyone gone from this site.

I see you posting what appears to be quotes from somewhere or another, so I post a comment warning you about posting quotes without attribution ...... and you lose your fucking mind!

What is wrong with you?! Calm the fuck down.

It makes no difference if you are at NV of here, copyright laws apply no matter where the content is posted. If copyright violations are picked up both the poster and the site are sanctioned and subject to copyrightinfringementconsequences. Which you can see at this site;

ithenticate.com

6 Consequences of Plagerism

Excerpt;

The legal repercussions of plagiarism can be quite serious. Copyright laws are absolute. One cannot use another persons material without citation and reference. An author has the right to sue a plagiarist. Some plagiarism may also be deemed a criminal offense, possibly leading to a prison sentence. Those who write for a living, such as journalists or authors, are particularly susceptible to plagiarism issues. Those who write frequently must be ever-vigilant not to err. Writers are well-aware of copyright laws and ways to avoid plagiarism. As a professional writer, to plagiarize is a serious ethical and perhaps legal issue.

That is why violators are immediately banned at Newsvine.

You said;

"I'll tell you something, I posted a quote from a Great American, without quotes, as a test to see just how many remember, how many actually think, and how many are actually paying attention."

It's not a fucking game Egilman, and now, after saying you did not steal anything, you admit you posted a quote without attribution.

Then you go on;

You tell me where, you do the work to find it, trust me the source is inarguable, and they would know.

I'll give ya a hint, it's a government source.

So yeah the government does know what works, they just choose not to do it that way.

You keep talking like that and you will be the cause of getting yourself removed from this site. They don't need the problem, as I said, it's not a fucking game.

What I said to you was;

Charges of plagiarism or lack of attribution can be very serious, you should make sure you always CYA.

Does that sound Like I'm trying to get you off the site? Or does it sound like I am trying to give you some friendly advise?

I think you owe me an apology.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

And still you have no explanations ... just a constant stream of criticisms and parroting "you need to use insults because you have nothing else", regardless of the fact that no insults are being offered. It's no mystery, since it's not possible to explain that which has no valid explanation.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

We have MORE passion for things like the Constitution than most of the rest of you.

That is a perfect example of the Libertarian "we're better than everybody else" attitude.

We believe WE have a duty to educate our children, not the government.

And a perfect example of Libertarians dreaming about aUtopianworld. They are correct when they say we have a duty to educate our children, but they fail to acknowledge that many people do not live up to their duty, causing many children to not be properly educated. When they say "our children", they mean their own children, because they only care about what is theirs.

When the rest of us say "our children", we mean all the children of our nation.Trulypatriotic Americans are concerned about what is best for America, not just what is best for only ourselves.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

Then call it equality and fairness.

Something Libertarians clearly oppose.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

Polly - I'm a civil engineer, so, not to gloat, but I know more than you about the logistics of building modern highways. I'm currently working on a multi-billion dollar transportation megaproject as we speak. You are correct, by the way, that such projects frequently get contracted out to the private sector, but those contractsare traditionally publicly funded.

There is a disturbing trend to privatize such infrastructure, which amounts to an increased amount of toll roads. Whyis it that wecontinue to be taxed from all directions, but insteadof those dollars funding newinfrastructure (like it used to),the rights to new infrastructureare being leased or soldoutright to investors (many times foreign) who want to park their money in roadways attached to US toll booths? I guess our dollars are now going to defense, and to programs that we aren't even allowed to know about. If this privatization trend is allowed to continue into other areas of infrastructure, you can plan on swiping your debit card just to get anywhere in your own vehicle, or toenter a restroom, or to get a drink from a drinking fountain, or to enter a park, etc. One thing you can also count on - no adjustments to your taxes to compensate you forthe servicesyou used to get in return for paying those taxes. In fact, since privatization is all about profit, expect those tolls to be higher, to change without notice, and for that infrastructure to be maintained irregularly. Tolls were originally intended to repay the costs associated with the construction, and then later be reduced to cover maintenance of those facilities. Now they are nothing but a cash cow. Privatization of infrastructure only allows the wealthiest corporations a path to lucrative investment opportunities that the rest of us not only can't benefit from, but we end up providing their profit because we are a captive audience that is dependent on that infrastructure.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

We have a new toll road here that not only changes based on what time of day it is, but changes without limit based on the actual volume of traffic, effectively pricing out those who can't afford it thereby guaranteeing a 40 mph min. speed limit.The toll lanesare adjacent to the general purpose (free) lanes (with some of the worst rush hour traffic in the country), soif the price gets too high youjustexit back into the poor people lanes and get to your destination late. It's all handled electronically throughyour E-Zpass. That shit is diabolical.

I'm glad there is a tiny space of common ground between us, btw.

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    13 years ago

Hal, we have that in Atlanta as well now, a pretty big brouhaha when it was first suggested. Racial allegations, "pissing on the poor" assertions, and they dubbed it the "Lexus Lane."

But, they needed the dough, so in it went. I refuse to use it, period, end of story.

Note also, when the got the 400 extension here granted, that was based on an absolute promise that once the construction of the road was paid for, the toll would be lifted.

Well, the road was paid for about 7 years ago, toll still on it and will be indefinitely! The old "this admin didn't promise that" bullshit.

But, things that go around, come around, they tried to raise additional funds for various "specific" projects, and because they lied about 400, those project funds were not approved.

Hoist on their own ....

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    13 years ago

EVERYBODY hates highway traffic!

It isn't a left or right thing unless your are trying to change lanes or get off the damned thing!

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago
Yep, our traffic (DC metropolitan area) has been dubbed the worst in the nation. Luckily I don't have to take that route anymore, but the route I do take to work takes me at least 90 minutes each way, sometimes up to 3 hrs depending on weather or accidents. It's fucking miserable.Toll roads everywhere are notorious for not living up to their promises when it comes to their construction debt being paid off. In fact, the project I'm currently working on is being partially financed by a toll road that is paid in full, and the project is a metro rail extension. Politicians used the excuse that the rail service will decrease traffic on the toll road, so therefore it should be able to dip into the toll revenue.
 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago
It's the Washington DC area (DC,VA,MD). I believe EZ Pass can be used all over the country now. Tolls introduce problems well beyond passing along the expense to citizens, like you pointed out. Funny how the solution to the traffic problem is to just toll any route that people use to get away from another toll. How convenient.In one of our counties here in MD, they tried to solve the problem of plastic bag litter by forcing all commercial entities to charge five cents per bag. I thought they were joking at Subway when my request for a bag for my leftovers came with a charge. Don't even get me started on the traffic cameras.
 
 
 
markpup
Freshman Silent
link   markpup    13 years ago

To me even though libertarianism and socialism are opposite ends of the spectrum, something they have in common is human beings are nothing like what they want them to be - so you have to impose unnatural constructs on them to get your political philosophy to work.

Socialism's way too optimistic and libertarianism is way too pessimistic.

Neither are remotely close to comfortable with religion even though it's ingrained deeply in the human psyche to search out what our purpose is and what we're about.

Both look at traditional expressions of duty as aberrant. Libertarians look at soldiers as suckers because they sacrificed for the state. Socialists look at them as tools for the ruling class. Wrong both times.

Libertarians would be right if every motivator in our lives was to enrich ourselves. But in families and what people give back to the community and their clan every day as naturally as breatheing, we see that not happening (thankfully) all the time. Duty defined as doing something for no monetary reward but only because it's the right thing to do has no place in the libertarian world but it's essential.

As an aside, nothing stops you today from educating your children. You don't have to be a libertarian to do that if you want. I applaud your stance on anti-collectiveness but libertarianism totally sucks everything passionate and beautiful and inquiring out of human endeavor and the adventure to get there. I want no part of it.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

And, with your interpretation, we can shutdown any and every site on the web discussing politics.

Not my interpretation. As a matter of fact, there is no valid reason for you to make that comment, other than to to create an argument. I gave you the link for the source, or was it too difficult for you to comprehend.

which is cool, I know the government would like to do that, it is in their DREAM LIST of desires

Pretty asinine comment. What makes you think the government wants to shut down any site on the web, your not reallythatparanoid,or are you?

It's not a fucking game Egilman, and now, after saying you did not steal anything, you admit you posted a quote without attribution.

Who's the one getting upset?

Not getting upset in the least, actually I'm rather enjoying myself, guys like you are great entertainment.

Look, if it makes you feel better to post context and quotes with out giving attribution for the source, and let people, either think it's your own work, or know your a plagiarist, that's fine. It's your name and your conscience, I tried to give you a heads up, I'll give the NT admin a heads up, you do whatever you want.

 
 
 
Chucky Stuart
Freshman Silent
link   Chucky Stuart    13 years ago

Actually, for a couple of years in parts of Spain, it was quite successful until Franco's fascists and Soviet backed communists spoiled the fun. Read about it here.

And here:

 
 
 
Chucky Stuart
Freshman Silent
link   Chucky Stuart    13 years ago

Though perhaps more of an anarcho-communist movement, Ukraine under Nestor Makhno during the Russian revolution comes close as well. Read here:

 
 
 
Chucky Stuart
Freshman Silent
link   Chucky Stuart    13 years ago

And then there's this well-documented case that occurred during the time of King Arthur:

 
 
 
markpup
Freshman Silent
link   markpup    13 years ago

So far what you say to me makes you a poor Libertarian but a very good conservative - which I'd applaud.

Conservatism is based on recognizing what human beings really are and accepting that we won't be able to social engineer ourselves to something else - and proceeding based on what our ancestors discovered worked. It was how the Constitution was written and it was a resounding success.

You say if the country went solidly Libertarian I could choose to be otherwise. Human nature being what it is, I seriously doubt that. I know you don't envision mandatory indoctrination about the wonders of capitalism and evils of socialism, but that's as inevitable as rain in springtime. And those that got ahead either in the private sector or in the military or government would be the ones that pay the Libertarian creed lip service.

I'd still assert duty whether you define it the way you did or the way I did is a very conservative concept, but not a very Libertarian one. Duty in either case is a voluntary surrender of freedom to be selfish for the common good. Libertarian ideology - and it most certainly is ideology - looks down on that. Conservatives revel in it and I'm more of a conservative.

I'd also assert the Founders were not Libertarians and would have found the concept alien. They fell in different places across the political spectrum from liberal to conservative but had a common idea. I think even today if there was a revolution, it wouldn't be a conservative, libertarian, socialist, populist, or liberal one you'd get some people from all viewpoints and all walks of life that would make the sacrifice to make our future better. That's what the revolution was in 1776.

I'm also every bit as anti-socialist as I am anti-libertarian. I don't want any ideology that tries to social engineer us into something we're not. Socialism does the same thing where they present themselves as bastions of personal freedom and defeating oppression and it's just as big a lie.

 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   Polly Cooper    13 years ago

That's not the case at all. It's about reasonable regulations which have a purpose OTHER than to eliminate competition. While we allow government to let large corporations write the regulations, they will be largely frivolous and expensive. Many regulations include overlapping of several governmental entities and jurisdictions, bureaucratic inefficiencies and costly permits. Small businesses often cannot afford the legal costs to wade through the bureaucracy in order to comply with all of the regulations. THAT is what large corporations have accomplished by purchasing our elected officials. That is why some companies are "too big to fail". They have gotten that way by urging costly regulations and buying up the small companies which cannot afford the multitude of ridiculous laws passed for no USEFUL reason.

 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   Polly Cooper    13 years ago

No, Jerry, when government doesn't have jurisdiction over so many aspects of "business", the corporate whores won't have any reason to buy politicians to pass laws that suit their particular needs.

Businesses should be allowed to succeed or fail WITHOUT intervention of unfair regulations which favor one or two "government owned" companies (like Monsanto) to the detriment of small businesses. (And NO, I do NOT mean that companies should be allowed to pollute our water, etc)

 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   Polly Cooper    13 years ago

When you look at what Libertarians really stand for, you will find that most of them ARE centrist. Take a step back from what you have perceived to be libertarian idealism and look at where most of us stand. We don't believe in international interventionalism. That certainly doesn't mean we don't believe in a strong military, but it does mean that we are tired of sending our military to foreign countries to fight other countries' battles. I think many Americans are with us on that now. Fight to protect Americans and America. That's it.

Look at corporations. We don't like "too big to fail" bailouts. Companies of ANY size should make it or break it based on their own management practices. Most of Americans are sickened and disgusted by the big bank bailouts, etc.

Look at drugs. We do NOT think all drugs should be available to the kids on the streets. We DO think that the billions being spent on the "war on drugs" is a waste of money - certainly now in the face of Fast & Furious we've had a pretty big wake up call.

The Environment - Libertarians believe that every single person has a RESPONSIBILITY not to adversely affect property of others. If I pollute my water supply it's going to pollute yours eventually, so protecting the environment is INHERENT in our philosophy.

The economy - libertarians believe in the American Dream. It's what MADE this country what it is today. Don't most Americans still want to believe in the American dream?

Entitlements - libertarians believe that charity starts at home. I'll take care of my family, my friends, and even that homeless man on the corner who wants a dollar for a cup of coffee. If that homeless man doesn't want to be on the street, it's up to me to help him find a better place, but it's not up to the government to FORCE it on me. The billions of dollars spend by the government running the entitlement programs are wasted billions. Better to let us keep our tax dollars and give help where we WANT to give help. I think a lot of Americans now understand that we've crossed the line with entitlements and we've gone too far.

So you see, when you really look at our positions and NOT what extremist Libertarian Haters keep falsely posting, you'll see that your own centrist point of view might just be closer to the Libertarians philosophy than you might have guessed.

 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   Polly Cooper    13 years ago

Tell me, Jerry, is there ANY politician philosophy which exists that doesn't include a "we're better than everybody else" basis? The Democrats don't think they are better than the Republicans? The Republicans don't think they are better than the Democrats?

So some parents fail to live up to their duties. Ok fine. That's a given. Do you think the government can change that? I am a Disability paralegal. Every day I talk to dozens of people who want to file for SSI. A good 70% of them (under the age of 40) HAVE NOT FINISHED HIGH SCHOOL. So basically, has the government been SUCCESSFUL in changing the parents failures? Not in the least.

Government cannot change parents, no matter how many laws you pass.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

You have to move into civilization Hal, ...... where there no people!

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

when government doesn't have jurisdiction over so many aspects of "business", the corporate whores won't have any reason to buy politicians to pass laws that suit their particular needs.

Myth.

If government had no jurisdiction over corporations, the greedy bastards would run wild and the cost we would pay in increased priceswouldbe triple the taxes we spend to regulate them.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

Whatever Polly,

I read the Libertarian platform, even considered registering in the LP at one time, but I came to the same conclusion as most others, ..... it just doesn't work.

The really good things in the LP philosophy are outweighed by the really bad things.

Your trying to sell a flawed product.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

Tell me, Jerry, is there ANY politician philosophy which exists that doesn't include a "we're better than everybody else" basis?

You make a good point, I guess it'sjustthe "Holier than Thou" attitude you guys portray.

So some parents fail to live up to their duties. Ok fine. That's a given.

Agreed.

Do you think the government can change that?

No. But with some effort they can likely improve it.

Every day I talk to dozens of people who want to file for SSI. A good 70% of them (under the age of 40) HAVE NOT FINISHED HIGH SCHOOL. So basically, has the government been SUCCESSFUL in changing the parents failures?

70% of the people that apply for SSI is a small minority of Americans.

And yes, the government has been successful in changing parents failures,, by making illegal to not provide a proper education for their children.

Government cannot change parents, no matter how many laws you pass.

And the Libertarians have figured out a way to fix that?

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

Actually, for a couple of years in parts of Spain, it was quite successful until Franco's fascists and Soviet backed communists spoiled the fun. Read about it here.

And here:

Your 1st link didn't work and the 2nd one requires an awful lot of reading. Why don't you just C&P some excerpts that address the Libertarian issue, and make it a little easier for all of us?

Thanks

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

And then there's this well-documented case that occurred during the time of King Arthur:

Cute, but I'veneverbeen a Monty Python fan.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

We're in the middle of a 1 Billion dollar expansion to add an HOV lane to the 405

What's a HOV lane?

 
 
 
Steve Ott
Professor Silent
link   Steve Ott    13 years ago

Every time I ask a Democrat or Republican to define what they stand for, I get a different answer. Why? Because both systems of encompass a broad spectrum of people and thought. Surely this is not your litmus test for a political philosophy?

 
 
 
Steve Ott
Professor Silent
link   Steve Ott    13 years ago

24.gif

So libertarians aren't allowed to have a big tent? What is wrong with a three tent circus?

 
 
 
markpup
Freshman Silent
link   markpup    13 years ago

OK we're coming together somewhat more - but I have to admit that I don't agree at all that all Conservatives are Libertarians. They are quite different. I would say for myself I tend toward conservative, but find any thought of being a Libertarian totally distasteful and ultimately for the same reasons I'd find being Socialist distasteful - because they depend on molding humanity into something it's not. And in my view that will never happen and should not.

Hayek and von Mises to me are the founders of the Libertarian ideology - the ones that codified it at least in the same way Marx/Engels codified socialism. Hayek's essay "Why I am Not a Conservative" - while I think Hayek got it utterly wrong on what a conservative is, immediately tells me it's not the same view.

I could write long on this - but one difference I'd point out right away are the existence of traditional social obligations that the well to do owe to society. Conservatives would say there are some including spending time in public service, charity, building nonprofits and the like. Libertarians reject this idea saying that if you earned your money, you have no further obligations to society at large and it's up to you. Conservatives and Libertarians would agree that inequality based on merit and ability are rational and expected. But after that there are major differences.

Another disagreement to me is role of government. Conservatives if they're honest want a sizable government but the orientation would be traditional - spend lots of money on a first class military, justice system, police, and whatever else it takes to assure national security and maintain a safe environment for its citizens. Libertarians would cut back on these things and even attempt to make some of it privately run. Conservatives and Libertarians would agree that large-scale Federal social programs are counterproductive and best left to whatever states want to run them - but again the differences follow.

On both of these issues I'd suggest I'm much more conservative than Libertarian.

And - I think Libertarianism is much more ideological than it appears on the surface. I'm more inclined to see conservatism as a political philosophy where its goal is to advance public policy based on what we as humans really are rather than have to change us into something we're not.

Oh - one more point. I don't think the GOP represents conservatives at all the way Reagan and Goldwater did. I think also they just pay lip service to Libertarians because it's aligned with the one goal they've been reduced to which is to lower taxes for their rich patrons. Otherwise they don't care. I realize some GOPers care about social issues but today it's just a smoke screen for what they really care about.

 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   Polly Cooper    13 years ago

Nope. The difference is that WE aren't going to try to fix it. Parents have every right to be whatever they want to be. And God knows, you just can't "fix" stupid.

 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   Polly Cooper    13 years ago

It is much less flawed than the Republican or Democratic pplatforms.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

Right no I'm not sure of who I would support, Rand Paul hasn't shown me enough to go solid in his direction yet.

If it were not for the high profile his father spent decades building, Rand Paul couldn't get a janitorial job in Congress. He lacks the charisma and dynamics to ever be the standard bearer for the Libertarians.

But other than him, there is no one even worthy of support that would have sufficient backing.

There's always Jesse Ventura.

All Libertarians are not Conservatives, but, all Conservatives ARE Libertarians.

I think the public perception of Libertarians would indicate you have that exactly backwards.

 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   Polly Cooper    13 years ago

The public perception of Libertarians is so skewed by ignorance that they don't even know what we are. Again, we are CLASSIC LIBERALS. Generally liberal on all things social and generally conservative on all things economic. Again, though, the Libertarian party is mostly free-thinkers, so generalities can get you in trouble sometimes.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

Parents have every right to be whatever they want to be.

And allow their children to go without a proper education? Actually, they are not just "their" children, they are our children. Every American child is a child of this country and is a part of Americas' future.

It is the responsibility of American society to make every effort to give our children the best education possible.

You can fix stupid.... one generation at a time.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

It is much less flawed than the Republican or Democratic pplatforms.

Then why have the American people not embraced that platform?

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    13 years ago

This thread has been up for ten days now, and here are four observations.

1) Not one of our libertarian members has done more than give excuses as to why their movement/form of government hasn't become more popular. (the other parties won't allow it, it's the MSM fault, people are sheep... Etc. Etc. Etc.)

2) None have yet to give compelling evidence as to why their theoretical movement/form of government will be more successful than what is currently in place.

3) Inadvertently, and continuously reminded us that libertarianism, with few exceptions, is nothing more than the current GOP platform on steroids.

4) Continuously point out to that those that are not libertarians, that it is their fault for not understanding what libertarianism is all about.

 
 
 
Cady Stanton
Freshman Silent
link   Cady Stanton    13 years ago

Conservatism is based on recognizing what human beings really are and accepting that we won't be able to social engineer ourselves to something else.

It seems most people who call them conservatives today want to social engineer all of us by using the force of government to impose the religious ideals of a sub-set of the dominant religion.

It also seems to me that self-identified libertarians such as the Paul's want to be 100% libertarian until it comes to telling women that we need to live by their ideas about what's a fetus and what's a baby.

 
 
 
markpup
Freshman Silent
link   markpup    13 years ago

I don't think today's GOP represents conservatism.

Let's be careful though - the rule of law is very different than social engineering. I wouldn't consider laws against murder as social engineering. And one of government's roles is to enforce the law. We also have centuries of human experience showing countries that live by a rule of law do a lot better than countries that don't.

We know that those who like to enforce their views on others like to use the law to do it - we just have to be vigilant about that.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

The public perception of Libertarians is so skewed by ignorance that they don't even know what we are.

The public perception of Libertarians is a result of observing of the way Libertarians present themselves. IMO, that perception is that Libertarians do not have a consensus of what they are, or what they represent.

Btw Polly, all Americans will tell you they're "free thinkers", regardless of their party affiliation.

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    13 years ago

This is what they are and what they represent.

 
 
 
markpup
Freshman Silent
link   markpup    13 years ago

Einsteinian Insanity - I agree and to me this is something that is very analogous to socialism. When I have a discussion with someone about socialism a lot of times the response is they tried this or that type of socialism and that's why it didn't work. I hear exactly the same thing from libertarians - both are very strong ideologies with all kinds of rationalization built in when things don't work and both require turning humanity into something they're clearly not and need extensive social engineering which inevitably fails.

 
 

Who is online







92 visitors