Wolf Blitzer Asks Tornado Survivor if She Thanked the Lord; Replies She's an Atheist + Glenn Beck Weighs in
Category: News & Politics
Via: the-irascible-harry-krishner • 13 years ago • 36 commentsTags
Who is online
79 visitors
╌>
Category: News & Politics
Via: the-irascible-harry-krishner • 13 years ago • 36 comments
79 visitors
LOL!
The irrepressible Glenn Beck weighs in, with his usual astute observations:
There are no Atheists in foxholes.
"That (question) was there for a reason"
And on a further note, have you ever listened to the tidy bowl man commercials backwards? It is God talking to you...
Hmmm... he seemed a bit pushy with that question, and I don't understand why. 1) why ask someone a personal question regarding their thoughts about a God on national television, and 2) why ask twice forcing a response. Can you explain to me what his objective was in asking the question?
and when was the last time there were "foxholes" ?
OH, not you too, CL. Did you watch the Beck piece?
Oklahoma City is the buckle of the bible belt. I am more surprised that they actually found someone who would correct another person while on tv. Oh, my!
To ask someone if they thanked the lord for saving them from a big tornado in OKC is about as no brainer as asking them if they ate dinner. Most of the time, you will get an affirmative. This one just happened not to be.
Brolly, Thank you!
I'll admit it, I ..shhhh.. watched it [said softly]...
Thank you for the education on OKC and "the bible belt" (to aid your understanding of my knowledge of such things---I didn't know of the Bible Belt until I joined Newsvine! lol.. If that term was in any of my History books, then I missed it!!). I've spent my entire adult life on the very liberal (much to my dismay-lol) west coast, so anything past about Wyoming - is a foreign country to me.
I didn't really know what states that term included...never researched it, so now that I know OKC is part of it---I totally understand now why an atheist would seem out of place. Thanx again..
(oh, but I still don't understand why the interviewer pushed the question, if it would be expected for her to say "yes." Why ask? What would be his point in asking? Am I making too big of a deal out of this? I just hate it when I don't get something! lol)
I wonder how many dipshits are concluding that her being an atheist was the reason god wrecked her house.
Google "Bible Belt" and look at the maps that are there, then Google "Tornado alley" and look at the maps there.
You will notice that the highestoccurrenceof tornadoes is smack dab over OK, as well as being among the highest in religious terms....
I think that the guy was like, "Hey yeah, I will bet she thanked the lord..." After he askedinitiallyand just followed up on that hunch.
But in the end, who really cares? In the worst case, following Beck's assertion, there were nefarious intentions of the producer talking in his ear, and in the most simple of explanations, he just hit the one out of a thousand chance that she didn't thank the lord, neither of which, to me, is a really big deal anyway.
I think the Pope has her back.
Thank you! I get why the interviewer was probably asking her if she thanked the Lord, now...thinking along the lines as you suggested in, "Hey yeah, I will bet she thanked the lord..." ..kind of like a joking mockery? ..Teasing more than insulting. There's a fine line between teasing and insulting, I think.
I don't mind that kind of humor, because I think poking fun at ourselves and sometimes silly ways, is a good thing. Some people don't like sarcasm and satire because they are sensitive to the issues being joked about, and will always take it as an insult.
I agree, who cares! So what! It's only one person's actions, opinion or whatever...and it really doesn't matter what they say, anyway--good or bad. The only opinions, actions or whatevers that should ever matter to us...are from those we care about personally in our own lives, and that can include our internet lives...imo.
Thanks again for explaining!
Oh, I don't know...
I wonder how many people crawled out of the wreckage of there homes and said,"Thank you Jesus for sparing my Life!" with no sense of irony what so ever... :-/
That said, there is a certain alignment of priorities among cultures who think similarly (e.g. pray to the same "god") which does lend itself to coping with greatcatastrophessuch as tornadoes. Cultural cohesiveness andhomogeneity do come in handy at least part of the time. More so even when the people are actually thinking of their culture as a part of a greater whole society, rather than the epitome of "right".
Point of clarification, I was not insinuating any teasing and or insulting was taking place, I think that he just said it because he thought it was the one question that he could ask and get "Hell, Yeah!" (irony intended) response.
Oh, Ok...that's an interesting interpretation.
In thinking more about why I see more of a "teasing mockery," is because we saw a video and could possibly read his facial expressions and body language, that help us communicate, usually...(one of the reasons why we often get misinterpreted on the internet).
Had his pushiness been stated with a serious, non-smiling expression---I would have thought the same as you, but the combination of his facial expressions and his voice intonations/inflections...told me he was asking out of a sort of sarcasm/ridicule, expecting her to admit his esotericism was 'right.'
But, since this happened in "The Bible Belt"-- the vast majority of peoples whose homes were wrecked were "believers"-- so I don't think many people there believed that.
However, there was at least one preacher who thought that all of them were punished for the sin of "fornication":
I doubt that, too. There are many Scientists that claim they have faith as well. Some people are very capable of separating their areas of awareness that require deductive reasoning vs. those areas that require inductive reasoning (especially a religious scientist that might see there is a correlation between subjectivity and objectivity in space/time....what is up, is down).
I really don't see it. He is playing with the baby, everyone is smiling and the lady at east is very thankful that she made the proper decision.
I tend not to try and attribute motives to what someone says unless there is a repeated pattern. A one off comment like that, especially because he was smiling when he said it, leaves me flat as far as motives,nefariousor otherwise.
It was just a comment and someone raised it up as a question, probably because they wanted to make the CNN news personality look bad. Not because of any real or imagined slights on his part, but because they knew that by suggesting that something was there, they could make some people believe that there was something there, and thus damage hiscredibility in the eyes of some people. This is averifiablepattern that has been usedrepeatedlyto poison the well of, and make us not trust, the media at large.
The very fact that we are having this conversation lendscredenceto theinsidiousnature of the way that politicians and pundits keep the country arguingamong themselves, thereby splitting and driving a wedge between people who may not be aware of it, setting the one faction against another over some falselydichotomous bit of BS.
What about the people who didn't survive the tornado, I wonder?
Broliver,
I am generally like that, too, but depending on the topic/remark and the person, as well as body language. I honestly do think body language is often more accurate than words. I might appear like I am cynical of everyone, but that is not true; it just depends..and definitely 'patterns' are something I watch for.
Also, to me, it's the question itself that is so suggestive in motive..it was obvious, to me, that the woman reacted with hesitancy and a little embarrassment. If it was not a 'suggestive in motive' question, she would not have reacted with a leaned head and slightly flushed face, but would have confidently and proudly stated she's an atheist.
My point is that asking someone a question like that is personal, and can really put people on the spot, and it's done for a reason---that's not a question like, "Oh, and how are you today?" --which for the most part is synonymous with saying, "Hi." --not asked for a reason, but more of a salutation.
The motive in asking a question like that would be to expose emotional weaknesses or vulnerability in religious belief---and all believers in the media will be mocked or joked about by their atheist audiences...there is definitely a motive as I see it with a question like that.
I understand your last paragraph, too, and do agree that partisanship is used by the politicians, pundits and talk-show hosts to create division for their own gain.
So you are judging they reaction of the woman to the question to gauge the intent of the questioner? That is backwards by my estimation.
In Oklahoma, indeed in much of the south, it is assumed that you are Christian. It just is. So, if you are an atheist, it is kind of like being outed as a gay (Also frowned upon by the majority down here) when somebody puts you on the spot like that. It is kind of like being the only Jets fan at aPatriots'game. So, an ordinarily innocuous question for say a person from New York, is not so innocuous when the answer is no, and you are from Oklahoma.
Did he sense from her posture that she was going to say no? Hard saying, not knowing. It looked to me like after he had asked andreceivedthe negative response that he was starting to become aware that it might not have been such a grand idea to ask that particular question, if only because herealizedtoo late that it wasn't the politest of questions.
I give the woman kudos for stating that she was an atheist, if only because there are not that many who are open about non-belief down here. It is the norm to be asked to go to church, not to not believe. (I have been asked about 5 times since I have been down here this time, about 3 weeks.)
I lived in Upstate New York prior to 1991, on the West Coast (Washington and Idaho) from 91 to 98, and I lived down in the south (Arkansas and Missouri) from 98-2010. There is an amazingly different culture between the three places, the most different being between either coast and the center. There are similar threads woven in the fabric of them all, but there are different patterns to the weave.
Peace
Who are you saying is ignorant?
The believers-- or the atheists?
(Or-- TV reporters like Wolf Blitzer?
)
I thank the Lord I wasn't there during the tornado. To each his own. Do you think he was profiling? ooh...
And you wouldn't have to water board me either!
No, that is not what I said. This is what I said: " The motive in asking a question like that would be to expose emotional weaknesses or vulnerability in religious belief---and all believers in the media will be mocked or joked about by their atheist audiences...there is definitely a motive as I see it with a question like that. "
I sensed that too, but that doesn't negate my intuition that he was asking the question for a reason--to give his atheist audience fodder for ridicule and joking/teasing and insulting...it just backfired on him.
Boy, that would take some getting used to, only in that it is so presumptive...even if the norm is to be Christian; I would think there are different denominations.
I've been able to see some of that from being here and on NV. I was so shocked to see so much liberalism coming out of the New England states and some of the east coast, then the north eastern states. I sure wasn't expecting that---why do they seem so rebellious? I know the electoral maps show that too, but on this coast, they don't seem to be an accurate picture--R's often vote D for personal interest if they are wanting Grants and Subsidies, but they talk Conservative and are into their Faiths. (Political hypocrites--lol)
"Different pattern to the weave." Good way to say it!
Most of the North-east (New England & the Middle Atlantic States) is predominantly very liberal. (The exception being some of the more rural areas). The Southeast mainly fairly conservative. (Except for some cities).
The Left Coast mainly liberal (with exceptions)-- qnd the Rocky Mtn states pretty conservative.
So much so that in any presidential election, for example, regardless of the candidate-- there's never really any question as to how Massachusetts or Hawaii `will vote (Democratic-- and by a wide margin), or how Wyoming or Utah `will vote (Republican-- by a wide margin).
Although in any state, rural areas generally tend to be more conservative, big cities more liberal. And most "racial"/ethnic groups tend to be predominantly Democratic or Republican, depending upon the group. Most African-Americans, for example, regardless of where they live, are overwhelmingly Democratic. Most first generation Cuban-Americans in Florida are overwhelmingly Republican (but not their kids).
Various cultural attitudes-- conservative or liberal-- are usually fairly highly correlated with party affiliation and ofte with area of residence. (For example, most rural white Southerners would probably have cultural values, attitudes, accents/dialects and even habits that are pretty different than most members of minority groups living in San Francisco or Boston).
And, finally: although for the most part it happening slowly, regional differences are becoming less and less. `
I'm only ignorant of who "you people (yeah, you)" actually are. Truly.
guess they were "truly ignorant".
Well, that's good to know.
If there's one thing I can't stand-- its a faux ignoramus!
I just don't see that. How about his Christian audience? HisBuddhistaudience? His audience of whatever that are not atheist? You seem to be willing to want to believe that he plays to an atheist audience, yet seeks to demean an atheist? How exactly does that work?
I think that you are taking the entirely wrong read from this. And if he had expected a positive affirmation (yes, I thanked the lord), what good would that have done for the atheists, proved that one more person who lives in the bible belt wasChristian? Now there is a shocker.
And what makes you pre-suppose that his supposed atheist audience would even want to ridicule, tease or insult this woman who has, by sheer luck, just survived a horrible, deadly tornado with her infant son? That would be the height ofinsensitivity and just plain mean. I really do not see how you can ascribe these motives to either the interviewer or any of his audience, be they atheist or not.
As it is anywhere and everywhere you go. You cannot get an accurate conception of the peoples lives unless you live with them. People have a myriad of experiences, some unique, others not, that inform them and make them the individuals they are. It is the sum of these experiences and the lessons and insights gained from them that cause the people to vote in the ways that they do. That is why they believe what they believe. It doesn't have to be right or wrong, it just is.
Ever are we cursed to do the same bidding as our fathers, to learn the same lessons, not from them, but from the lives that we lead taking the same paths, making the same mistakes, seeking the same glories, all because we "know" better.
Krishna,
Thank you for your thoughts on the regional areas and demographic attitudes and values.
Interesting that we appear to have two things happening: some seem to establish affiliation not so much of their own attitudes, but adopt the 'regional attitude,' pressuring their state economics to vote their way, and others appear to arrive in the country with a previous value or attitude, and join an area that might be predominantly an opposing view. It's hard to know if having a state with a lot of diversity is healthier, or if having a state that is majority like-minded is better with less conflict in their state legislature, maybe..
The context of our point, I thought, was "motive." The motive would only makes sense in the context of pointing to the polarity of Christianity and the Christian God of the "Bible Belt."
" I think that you are taking the entirely wrong read from this. And if he had expected a positive affirmation (yes, I thanked the lord), what good would that have done for the atheists, proved that one more person who lives in the bible belt wasChristian? Now there is a shocker. "
I agree that he 'might' have just been asking the question to make conversation for an interview.
It was the combination of his body language, his pushiness in asking the question twice, essentially demanding an answer, and the fact that it isn't a seemingly 'average question' to ask--religious thought seems personal to me...like politics. So, I concluded it was a motivational question.
"What good would it have done?"....Given the religious opposition a good laugh. As it was, the laugh was on the interviewer in that he picked the wrong one to interview to make his point! lol
Why? Because my experience on these two social sites has revealed that atheists have fun poking at anyone that believes in "Sky Fairies" as it appears, for one; and CNN is considered a leftist site. I've noticed some of their Journalists specifically look for reports that aren't just reporting the News, but are looking for irony and oppression. This report would seem to be looking for irony in that a large body of believers would have this catastrophe happen to them...so I see it that 'he' picked the wrong person to interview.
But, I admitted that, as you say, I might have added up everything all wrong (We do the best we can with the amount of grey matter we were given. I was given an IOU...still waiting.
)
" People have a myriad of experiences, some unique, others not, that inform them and make them the individuals they are. It is the sum of these experiences and the lessons and insights gained from them that cause the people to vote in the ways that they do. "
I agree with that, because I think everything we say and do is 'caused.' I don't think action is random.
They always say we continue to repeat History. I guess nothing is new.
Thank God I'm an Atheist.
FYI: I am an agnostic atheist.