This Asshole Isn't Just a One-off. He is Today's GOP.
GOPer Who Got Millions in Farm Subsidies Thinks the Poor Should Starve Rather Than Get Food Stamps
He fulminates about people who are allegedly "unwilling to work" sucking off the government teat with impunity. This is a patently dishonest representation of the SNAP program. Most people who receive food stamps cannot be dismissed as losers who are "unwilling to work." Nearly half (47%) of all food stamp recipients are children. Another 8% are 60 years of age or older. The "working poor" - people who live in a household with income from work - represent another 41%. Between children, the elderly, the working poor, and people who want a job but cannot find one - someone should tell Fincher that there are still more than 3 unemployed job seekers for every 1 opening - that leaves very few people who can be accurately described as being "unwilling" to work. It's also worth noting that the average monthly SNAP benefit is a whopping $287. It takes a deeply disturbed person to crusade against providing this class of people with food to eat, when the economy is this battered, and when the broad economic benefits of the program have been so well established (at least in the reality-based community).
Now, this would not normally be worthy of mention. Hardly a day goes by without some Republican sadist expressing fury that poor people have it so good. Devising new ways to make the peasants suffer is what makes Republicans wake up in the morning. What's fascinating about this particular case, though, is Fincher's background.The reason this is even more egregious than the usual Republican class warfare is that Fincher himself is a poster boy for government dependency. It's not just that he's benefited here and there from some government help. That sort of low-level hypocrisy is almost to be expected from these types. But Fincher has received millions - $3.2 million as of June 2010 - in federal crop subsidies. The people who refer to themselves as Tea Partiers threatened to derail his candidacy over this, but then they realized that they have no principles, and supported him anyway. He's now a member of the "Tea Party Caucus," which, amazingly, is something that actually exists. Fincher's brother and father also snatched another $6.7 million in subsidies as Stephen geared up to run for Congress on a platform of eliminating "wasteful government spending." The "wasteful spending" that he had in mind, of course, was that which serves policy aims with which he disagrees, such as keeping poor people alive.

Thoughtful words, E.I. What irks me the most is the broad-brush accusation that all on government aid are shirkers, an accusation made by those who have received government aid. The hypocrisy is glaring, the heartlessness palpable. As stated in the article, almost half of SNAP recipients are children, the other half WORKING poor, and the remainder the elderly. Where does this "unwilling to work" shit come from????
It is not so much as to whether or not one believes in the program or not, it is the unmitigated hypocrisy that causes my blood to boil.
But I have always maintained that our politicians of this day and age are believers of convenience.
The same old double breasted corporate/congressman telling "We The People" that We cannot keep going on like this but all the while stuffing his and his family's pockets! This type of politician has been around for ages, the greedmongering, power hungry, sacks of shit! It is also fair to say that both sides of the aisle have these types!
Yup, no arguement from me, they both reek
.
This could be fixed - if corporate greed wasn't driving the bus. The corporations that are intentionally causing the lag shown above are consequently responsible for the increased demandin food stamp benefits.
Is your company outsourcing labor to save one ton of money, only to spend one half ton to import products of that labor, so that executives can split a cool half ton amongst themselves as a bonus for their efforts in increasing the bottom line at the expense of their country?
Btw - thesolid line represents the US aggregate.
I believe it was Schumpeter that said from time to time our economy requires a cold hard douch, the same may well apply to our political system.
why are liberals upset about anyone obtaining subsidies associated with the dept of ag?
are they not mostly the backbone of the progressives?
On a related topic:
Oklahoma senator wants to offset tornado aid with other cuts - Both Republican Oklahoma senators voted against federal relief for Hurricane Sandy victims and are for cutting FEMAs budget.
What hypocritical asshats.
is this like obama "firing" a guy at the irs who was supposed to retire anyway, pounding his fists outraged that conservative groups were discriminated against before he got re-elected, all the while demonizing them himself?
no?
Let's not forgetone huge reasonAmerican's aren't buying as many widgets - they can no longer afford them, because of the same outsourcing that is fueling the fire to begin with. One opening per three job seekers, and people being significantly underutilized if they are lucky enough to find a job at all. To make matters worse, for every factory that is shuttered here because of outsourcing of labor, there could be a dozen other industries that just lost them as an important customer - a landscaper, a gas station, a restaurant where the workers ate, a coffee supplier, an office cleaning service, a pest control service, etc. To extrapolate even more, the domestic expansion of that company serves the industries of architecture, engineering, contractors, suppliers, designers, etc.The current system of using cheap off-shore laborends up beinga vicious circle that serves only to further expand the divide between executive pay and labor pay, as well as decimate the Americanmiddle class in general. There are policy decisions that have to be made, but they are most unpopular with those who have the most income, for the reasons that got them that income. That's an unworkable situation in American politics.
BRAVO, E.I., BRAVO
I was so hoping that someone would pick up that ball and run it into the end zone, and you did.
I have a sister-in-law that really IS unable to work. It was the very devil to get her on food stamps and a monthly hassle to keep her on them. She can't drive, because she can't see very well, nor afford a car, and none of us are stupid enough to let her drive our car. It is worth it to just give her money for food because none of us have the time to go from one office to the next.
I am also past president of the Cooperative Extension Service in my county. They have the EFNEP program-- a huge, (almost half of our staff), entity. EFNEP stands for Expanded Food and Nutrition Education Program. What a crock. I'm all for teaching people to cook with commodity products, and all for helping a family of four on food stamps to cook healthy meals for little $, etc. That's all to the good. But we were able to reach less than 1% of our population in poverty. The EFNEP staff went into day cares and offered programs for the poorer children about making healthy food choices. Great Idea! It helped the kids that it reached. But, out of 265 day cares in our community, we went to 17 of them.
HUGE WASTE OF MONEY AND RESOURCES.
I'm with EI-- all this needs to be in one place to help the people help themselves. We had community gardens, so that people could grow their own food. We even supplied the vegetable plants, free. They all sat there and rotted. The gardens were vandalized. We put up fences. They tore them down. We had sheds where we kept tools for the people to use. They were stolen. UNLESS the garden was in a church yard where people watched it every day, it was a HUGE WASTE OF MONEY AND RESOURCES.
I have no answers. But this guy needs to go and live in a homeless shelter for about a month.
Thoughtful words, E.I. What irks me the most is the broad-brush accusation that all on government aid are shirkers, an accusation made by those who have received government aid. The hypocrisy is glaring, the heartlessness palpable. As stated in the article, almost half of SNAP recipients are children, the other half WORKING poor, and the remainder the elderly. Where does this "unwilling to work" shit come from????
It is not so much as to whether or not one believes in the program or not, it is the unmitigated hypocrisy that causes my blood to boil.
But I have always maintained that our politicians of this day and age are believers of convenience.
The same old double breasted corporate/congressman telling "We The People" that We cannot keep going on like this but all the while stuffing his and his family's pockets! This type of politician has been around for ages, the greedmongering, power hungry, sacks of shit! It is also fair to say that both sides of the aisle have these types!
Yup, no arguement from me, they both reek
.
This could be fixed - if corporate greed wasn't driving the bus. The corporations that are intentionally causing the lag shown above are consequently responsible for the increased demandin food stamp benefits.
Is your company outsourcing labor to save one ton of money, only to spend one half ton to import products of that labor, so that executives can split a cool half ton amongst themselves as a bonus for their efforts in increasing the bottom line at the expense of their country?
Btw - thesolid line represents the US aggregate.
I believe it was Schumpeter that said from time to time our economy requires a cold hard douch, the same may well apply to our political system.
why are liberals upset about anyone obtaining subsidies associated with the dept of ag?
are they not mostly the backbone of the progressives?
On a related topic:
Oklahoma senator wants to offset tornado aid with other cuts - Both Republican Oklahoma senators voted against federal relief for Hurricane Sandy victims and are for cutting FEMAs budget.
What hypocritical asshats.
is this like obama "firing" a guy at the irs who was supposed to retire anyway, pounding his fists outraged that conservative groups were discriminated against before he got re-elected, all the while demonizing them himself?
no?
Let's not forgetone huge reasonAmerican's aren't buying as many widgets - they can no longer afford them, because of the same outsourcing that is fueling the fire to begin with. One opening per three job seekers, and people being significantly underutilized if they are lucky enough to find a job at all. To make matters worse, for every factory that is shuttered here because of outsourcing of labor, there could be a dozen other industries that just lost them as an important customer - a landscaper, a gas station, a restaurant where the workers ate, a coffee supplier, an office cleaning service, a pest control service, etc. To extrapolate even more, the domestic expansion of that company serves the industries of architecture, engineering, contractors, suppliers, designers, etc.The current system of using cheap off-shore laborends up beinga vicious circle that serves only to further expand the divide between executive pay and labor pay, as well as decimate the Americanmiddle class in general. There are policy decisions that have to be made, but they are most unpopular with those who have the most income, for the reasons that got them that income. That's an unworkable situation in American politics.
BRAVO, E.I., BRAVO
I was so hoping that someone would pick up that ball and run it into the end zone, and you did.
I have a sister-in-law that really IS unable to work. It was the very devil to get her on food stamps and a monthly hassle to keep her on them. She can't drive, because she can't see very well, nor afford a car, and none of us are stupid enough to let her drive our car. It is worth it to just give her money for food because none of us have the time to go from one office to the next.
I am also past president of the Cooperative Extension Service in my county. They have the EFNEP program-- a huge, (almost half of our staff), entity. EFNEP stands for Expanded Food and Nutrition Education Program. What a crock. I'm all for teaching people to cook with commodity products, and all for helping a family of four on food stamps to cook healthy meals for little $, etc. That's all to the good. But we were able to reach less than 1% of our population in poverty. The EFNEP staff went into day cares and offered programs for the poorer children about making healthy food choices. Great Idea! It helped the kids that it reached. But, out of 265 day cares in our community, we went to 17 of them.
HUGE WASTE OF MONEY AND RESOURCES.
I'm with EI-- all this needs to be in one place to help the people help themselves. We had community gardens, so that people could grow their own food. We even supplied the vegetable plants, free. They all sat there and rotted. The gardens were vandalized. We put up fences. They tore them down. We had sheds where we kept tools for the people to use. They were stolen. UNLESS the garden was in a church yard where people watched it every day, it was a HUGE WASTE OF MONEY AND RESOURCES.
I have no answers. But this guy needs to go and live in a homeless shelter for about a month.